EP150 Transcript

You're listening to the Fierce Fatty Podcast episode 150. When people in your life are anti-fat and pro-diet. I'm Vinny Welsby, your host. Let's do it.

Hey, how are ya? I realized I almost never introduced myself. I'm Vinny My pronouns are they them? I am a smelly British person, British Irish person living in Canada in Vancouver, which is the traditional ancestral and unceded territory of the Coast Salish peoples, Squamish, slaver tooth and Musqueam nation forms. Welcome to the show if you're new here, and if you're not new here, welcome back. So good to see ya. How you doing what's going on. This week, Spotify had released its you know, the rap thing. And if you are a podcaster, they will give you your podcast stats, I can see my stats anyway on a different program, which releases it to all the platforms. But then Spotify put it in pretty graphics means more because it's in pretty, pretty graphics. Well, I just wanted to shout out the top 10 countries that people listen to the show from so we're top 10 We've got the United States. Yes, United Kingdom. Thank you, Canada. Yeah, Australia, Germany, Netherlands, Sweden, New Zealand, Finland and Norway. We're trying to so interesting. I'm like, Who is listening in Sweden or the Netherlands? Or Norway or Finland? How do they know about me? How do you know about me like US, UK and Canada. I feel like you know, I've that's my general region. Right? And then other folks. Hi, how did you find me? Hey, hey. And first of all, your podcast is in the top 10% shared globally, and you're not in the top 2% global rank for popular podcasts. I'm in the top 2%. Wow, and I just I checked also checked out recent reviews and I do want to read out a few one of them is a one star review. Okay, so five stars informative. This is a review of the show. If you want informative well research information on how to be a fat ally or on how to set boundaries as a fat person Vinnie is a perfect choice. They are entertaining, empathetic and sensitive, funny, and they do their homework. I also love the regularity of new episodes. Thank you very much. And that is from someone in Ireland. Oh, Ireland is not in the top 10 Come on Ireland on five stars fat positive podcast at its best. empathetic, knowledgeable, hilarious. You get all this and more when you listen to Vinny Welsby. I am in love. On that's from that's from Germany. Five stars. This pod is awesome in capital letters. Videos podcast is a must for anyone who needs some fatty love and also for tons of well researched education around fatness and all the issues that intersect with it. Their style is so fun, but also sensitive and compassionate. Listen, listen, listen with four exclamation points. And that's Great Britain. Thank you so much. Honestly, it makes me feel so good reading those and you know what, what makes me feel really, really good, is the empathetic and compassionate stuff. I'm like, Yes, I really appreciate that. And then like the ego mean, when you say that I'm funny. I'm like not everyone agrees though one star tried really hard, they say tried really hard to enjoy this and learn but just completely completely misses the mark on a lot of things including contradictions within the same episode to support the point of the moment. Also, all of the constant singing and shouting makes it hard to listen with headphones be warned. And that was from Great Britain boo boo it is. And you know, that review I was like, you know, had I like a moment a moment of I'm too loud and sing too much. And you know what, you know with a singing thing. I don't know if I probably have mentioned this before. So I go to choir but also, I started going to like singing groups because I was so all my life. I felt like I had to be quiet because growing up. My dad couldn't tolerate any type of noise in the house. And so things like singing prohibited obviously, and I wasn't He's very, very shy, which people are very surprised with. But I was I was really, really shy. And so even if I wanted to sing, there was no way I was going to and I did want to sing but so using my voice and singing and being loud is a very hard one battle for me. And I'm not always loud. You know, sometimes I might laugh and shout or whatever, but I think that's just a normal human thing, right? And the singing thing, listen, that's just me. Some people won't like it. Some people will like it. Some people will be indifferent. Some people believe it. Yeah, they're having fun, who cares? Other people might be like, I wish they didn't sing, but whatever. And also this week, because this is quite kind of timely this week at my choir every week, one person gets to stand up in the in the break and and sing a song if they want. And so the choir is about maybe 100 100 250 people? I don't know, actually. Anyway, and it was my turn this week. And yeah, and I sang Oompah power from Oliver the musical and got people to join in and we had a good old knees up. And so had a little bit of kind of like a vulnerability thing from that. And then I saw the the pay singing is harder lesson because I sang and I was like, oh, but then I remembered that I'm, I'm first phase. So yeah. Anyway, thank you very much. All those reviews. Thank you for listening in for this year. Apparently, we I've got like 87% of the listeners this year on new listeners. So hello, if you started watching the show, or listening to the show this year, you can always find a video of the show on YouTube, if you ever want to watch it because I record the video, just for the I don't know, for the couple of 100 people that watch it on YouTube. And also, there's transcripts for every single episode. I think we've done it now we've gone we went back and we did it for every single episode. And so that's complete. Now that project. So if you ever want to go to the transcript, just go to the show notes. And then you can find the specific show notes for whatever episode it is by going to face fatty.com forward slash 150 For this episode, or forget that first fatty.com forward slash pod cast quick update on the vacation to Dominican Republic. We have six earlybird tickets left. And so if you want to get on the early bird train and get $100 discount, go to the show notes and click on the details about Dominican Republic vacation. If you forget where they are, you can always go to my Instagram. And there's a link in my bio. Basically, we're going for five days to the Dr. It's a fat positive vacation. accessible for those with limited mobility and disabilities. is going to be fucking amazing. So anyway, thought I'd give you some fierce fatty news or not first fatty news, but fatty news or just scandal news. A listener or a follower? sent me an article they're in Germany. Hey, Germany, they're in Germany. Just tell you that I dated a German guy. Recently this year. He was cool. He was like really forward thinking. And he says yeah, Germany is Germany is pretty forward thinking when it comes to a lot of things. Not so much on the fat stuff. Anyway, so here's a new story out of Germany, Tinder ad with Paul Ripka. Think that's how you say his name. weightwatchers responds to criticism. So this is what happened. There's this famous guy called Paul Ripka. And what Weight Watchers did is they partnered with this guy, Paul. And apparently Paul didn't realize what they were actually doing, allegedly. But what they were doing is they were advertising on Tinder. And so Paul, Paul, Paul's profile will come up. And the profile would say, quote, I'm in the mood for a change. And I like to try new recipes. Are you also in the mood for healthy habits, then let's cook together. And so you know, it's like a, he says that he introduces himself as a budding Master Chef, photographer and podcaster All right, and then he says, I like eating food. Do you want to Let's cook together. Okay. And then those who swipe Yes, on him, would then get the message. I've been around for a long time and have finally found myself and my center. Are you also longing for inspiration and support on your journey to more to more balance and a healthy lifestyle? So Sign up for Weight Watchers now and get a taste for new habits. Apparently this only went to fat people

rip key apologized last Sunday after several social media accounts drew attention to the advert. He says of course, the advertising was was declared as such a not only fat women were addressed, he explained. Nevertheless, all the advertising that Weight Watchers did was a stupid idea. He said, The only relevant thing is how users felt about it. This is translate, okay, I'm on a German website, by the way. And this is translated with Google Translate. And so I think some of the words might be a little bit off. So. So it was not making sense. And apparently, he immediately was like, take this down. And so they did. But imagine that you're like, Oh, hey, Paul. You know, he's like, this foot you're on. We're all guy looks pretty cute. It's got a little bit of chub on him is cute. Like, I mean, I, you know, I don't know about who he is. His personality might be raging, right wing weirdo. And if that's the case, then he's not cute. But you know? And you're like, Oh, I'm gonna do some cocaine with calm. And then it's like, Hey, Fatty, go to weightwatchers Oh, Lord, that's fucked up. So anyway, I thought that was interesting. Let you know about that. So let's talk about what we're talking about today. And what we're talking about today is other human beings. Oh, it's so hard to communicate. Oh, communication, I feel like you know, if I could have a superpower, I've got this diary. It's a five year diary. And then they ask you a question a day, one of the questions is, if you could have, or if you could be an expert at something or have a superpower or whatever. And I almost always answer that question. I've done it for three years, I wish I could be the best communicator. Because communication is so hard. And when you are, and being a good communicator is such a skill, right? That's such a skill. Skill as in, it takes time to master. And yeah, and I think you know, what, with the podcast thing with the people saying that I'm compassionate, is that that's, that's a really big compliment for me, because my communication skills used to be when I was younger, or very angry, and not compassionate, because I was not compassionate towards myself. Yeah, so communication skills, I think is, is a really awesome thing to keep, keep trying apps. And yeah, I'm always I'm always thinking about this and thinking about folks who are newer in their anti diet or fat positive journey, and what that looks like for people. And what that looks like for a lot of people is because most of their lives if you are new to this, and if you are, in in the world of now, you know, Health at Every Size, or intuitive eating or fat positivity or body, body, whatever. Most of your life, theoretically, you have been pro diet, anti fat, and those around you have known you as this personality. And so when we make the change to a different ideology, which is liberatory, which is sometimes against the grain for a lot of people, those in your life can have problems with it. And the other thing is, you'll start to realize how anti fatness and diet culture is everywhere. Oh my goodness, it's everywhere. It's everywhere, right? And a lot of people say that to me, and I'm like, oh my god, Vinny. Like what the hell? I'd rather let's put these glasses back on where I call it see all this shit, because it's fucking everywhere, and it can be really exhausting. And and it's kind of like, well, where do we pick our battles? Are we going to be you know, 20 times a day being like, Hey, by the way, don't say that. That's anti fat or, you know, not watching any TV not consuming any any content any going online, you know, just walking around the world, just, you know, fingers in our ears type of thing is that's impossible, right? But there are times that we do need to deal with other people who are in diet, diet land, or who are, you know, anti fat because we've realized it really is an issue for us. And when I talk to people in coaching and and I we talk about the kind of barriers to their success of loving themselves or you know, getting on with intuitive eating or whatever it is, very often will have. Oh my mum, or my mother in law, or my sister or my friend or people at work or on diets talk shit about fatness that a lot of times they don't talk about shit about the person's fatness. So that you know, the person I'm talking to the talk shit about fatness in general and their own body. And often, the people are not fat, right. And so it's kind of more difficult. Because if someone is like, hey, you know, you're fat, and I don't like you, because you're fat. It's just, that's a lot easier to say. Okay, that's not gonna be so good for my mental health. And it's more clear on what to do, right? And what to do is be like, set a boundary, you remove them from your life, whatever it is, it feels good for you. But when there's more nuance it can be like, What do I do here? And I've asked followers on Instagram to give me your situations, your questions on what to do with certain situations, right? You know, what you're dealing with right now. So I can give specific examples of what to do. But I want to go over first a couple of strategies that I that I teach, and talk about boundaries and don't general right. And so with this, we've got two strategies, boundaries, or remove, reduce protect, which is what I talk about all the time how to protect yourself from fat phobia is removed, reduced protect. So the gold standard is, can you remove fat phobia from your life? So can you get rid of the most triggering aspects of fat phobia? Examples? unfollowing, fat phobic folks on social media and harmful relationships, stop watching that really fat phobic show with only normative bodies, etc. And so remove is like, can we remove that phobia? Great, then, you know, perfect is it's removed from your life. That's not always possible, right. And with boundaries, what we're doing with boundaries is trying to remove or reduce, right, reduce the exposure, remove their exposure, have a boundary, don't talk to me about that being terrible. And if they do, then there's a consequence, and the consequence could be reducing time with them. It could be removing them from your life temporarily or full time. Okay, so reduce is if you're not able to remove for whatever reason, say, for example, it's your parents and your and you are your carers of your parents. And so you can't, you know, you have decided that it's not appropriate for you to remove them from your life because you're the carers. And that's not something you want to do, that's absolutely fine. Or for whatever reason, it doesn't need to be as dramatic as your their carers, but for whatever reason, there's a power imbalance, whatever you can reduce, if possible, can you reduce the amount of time that you're exposed to fat phobia. So an example of this could be spending less time with fat phobic people only watching one hour of that fat per phobic show instead of three. And finally protect so if you can't reduce or remove, then you can potentially protect yourself. And what that looks like is after spending time with fat phobic fat folks engage in self care, spend time reviewing fat positive resources to feel good put headphones in, say if you're at work, and people are talking about diet stuff, or leave the room during during diet talk. So they are three ways we can tackle protecting ourselves from fat phobia. And those things can mean that you're going to have to, you know, communicate with people about this topic. And some of them, maybe not, right, you know, if you're protecting yourself, if people are talking about fatphobia at work, or you know how they love going on diets or whatever. You're removing yourself from the situation or putting headphones in, you know, that's protecting yourself and I want to kind of note here is that whatever you is accessible to you. Is a Okay, right. I don't want folks feeling like oh, you know, I could have I wish I knew what I was what to say or I wish

I had the perfect Zinger to stop people in their tracks, tracks. You know, that's cool. kind of expecting maybe at this stage, you know, it's unrealistic. And it's, it's probably not helpful for you to expect that you're able to go into battle when you're kind of just kind of finding your feet in this area. So if you're, if you're newer to this, you're maybe you're finding your feet. And even if you've been doing this stuff longer, you might also not be used to communicating your feelings and thoughts. And also, even if you if you are used to, this is like, potentially high stakes business, right? You know, you're sitting around the lunch table with your colleagues, and they're like, Oh, my God, I love cucumbers up the bum. And if you say, Hey, by the way, that's not cool. You know, what are the consequences, you could lose relationships, you could lose your job, you could be ostracized, you could, you know. And so, there's many reasons why this stuff is difficult. And if you choose you want to do something or say something, then that's great. And if you want to and stumble in the moment, that's normal, you know, because when we are confronted with this stuff, our bodies are probably having a reaction. And the reaction could be that your heart is beating faster, perhaps you're breathing quicker, because your heart is beating faster, and your body is like we are in danger. And your brain is not thinking, right? Okay, let's go into the back catalogue of all the research, I know about fatness and Health at Every Size and intuitive in eating and let's come up with a real perfectly well formed sentence, your brain is like, we're in danger, get out of here, just, you know. So you're not in the best stead, is what I'm saying. But saying all that it's a practice, right to practice, practice. And I want to give you some ideas. So with boundaries, not everyone can set boundaries, nor is it always appropriate, you know, I'm talking about the power imbalance, if you're not safe, for whatever reason, it might not be appropriate for you, there could be you know, that power imbalance as your boss. So if you're in a relationship where that person has more power, say, they are the one who earns money, and by disagreeing with them, you know, that they're volatile. And so it's not maybe appropriate in that circumstance. And there's lots of others too. And the other thing is, people have known you potentially, for years, as someone who loves a little bit of diet or, and so it's gonna take time for people to get used to you having new rules and guidelines in your life. Because hopefully, this is going to be a lifelong journey, right? And maybe in the past, you've gone on diets, and it's been a kind of, you do it and you're excited, and then the diet fails, and then you're less excited. And then maybe there's a new diet, and you're excited, and it fails. And so so maybe people are used to you having kind of new things that you're excited about, and maybe they're not taking it seriously that this new thing that you're excited about is something that's going to be for the rest of your life. And so then maybe they're not taking your boundaries as seriously because of that, but we need to help folks understand that no, we are serious about this and it's forever and the way that we do that is with our words and our actions. So my favorite way to get people to stop talking about things that I you know, diets or anti fatness in front of me that my favorite piece of advice is, Hey, friend, family member person, I love person I care about. I don't know if you notice, but I've actually started learning about intuitive eating, anti fatness, whatever. And I've recognized that when people talk about diets, anti fatness, whatever, that it's, it can be a trigger for me. And so I'm wondering if I can have your help with something. Sometimes, you know, starting with, I'm wondering if I can have your help with something. You know, people who love us are like, yes, I'd love to help you with something. Can you avoid talking about XYZ? Or can you not talk about XYZ while I'm around? Now that's one way that we can do it making it about ourselves. And the way the way the reason why I like this is because when we're asking someone to change behavior, Avior it can be very difficult for them because they might hear, you're a bad person, you've hurt me, You've ruined my life, your fault, you're responsible for the way that I feel about myself, right? And, and then that can be difficult for them to listen and hear and understand what's going on. Which is, you know, them problem. But for me, when I'm framing it about me and the fact that I want to achieve this goal, and I'm wondering if they can help me achieve this goal, it's not about how they have fucked up. It's about what I've noticed me, and what makes it difficult for me to love and accept myself. Now, people might might be like, you know, fuck you, blah, blah, blah, oh, you might find that, that that's disempowering for you to say, you know, hey, I've got, I'd like you to help me with something. And that's okay, too. You can say something else, right? And so whatever words used to describe to say to that person, can you stop talking about this thing? And they say, yes, they say, Oh, I'll try. They'll say, no. That is great information for you, whatever they say, is information on what you are going to do next. If they say no, okay, well, we know where we stand. And, you know, for me, it would be unfortunately, I can't continue this relationship with you, or unfortunately, I can't see you as much or, unfortunately, I'm going to have to cut you off if you do start talking about it, or whatever. Depending on what type of relationship you have. If they say, I'll try, but it'll be so hard, then you can have a conversation of, okay, well, what would be helpful for when you do slip up for me to say, and so you've already got that kind of pre pre agreed of, you know, that you're gonna say, Oh, don't forget, we talked about this or whatever? And if they say, yes, great, I might also have that conversation too. Because if they say, yes, they're probably good, you know, they're a human being, they're probably gonna forget, right? And then when they do then forget and say something, which is unlikely, unlikely thing to happen, you can decide kind of like, what amount of tolerance Do you want to give? We don't want to be the thing is here, we we need to have a level of, of standing our ground, right. And that is where boundaries fall apart, is that there is no standing of ground when someone says that it will. So this is what happens if someone says, Yeah, I've set boundaries. I've told my my mum not to talk about my body, but she keeps doing it. And then I say, okay, so what do you do when she does keep doing it? Nothing. And then I'm like, Ah, okay, and it's inappropriate that your mom still talks about your body. But also, this is kind of like a new education thing for for your mom, you know, your mom's known you as this person and known how to talk to you for X amount of years. And so we need to then be reinforcing our new boundary by saying, Hey, you remember I said about this or by doing whatever could be that you're going to leave the room, it could be that you're going to end the conversation, it could be that you're going to decide not to talk to them for an X X amount of weeks. It could be that you end the relationship, whatever it is, that feels good for you, you know, but if we're not following it up with something, then that is where we're going to fail. Right? Because you're serious about this right you are serious about this. This is not acceptable. And we have to keep helping people understand that it is not acceptable by how we react when they mess up which they probably will because they are a human being so in my life I've set boundaries and it was very difficult for me because I was slash am probably still a massive people pleaser and terrified terrified to to say anything to state my needs because I thought people would just you know, flip a table and be like, Fuck you, you're dead to me. You know, even if it was like, Hey, can you take your shoes off at the door? Never like what? take my shoes off. That would just be way too high stakes. And so you know, I couldn't go in with a Um, hey, here's these big huge boundaries with big important people in my life, I had to go in with, you know, the easier things like, Hey, do you think that you could take your shoes off?

You know, whatever it is. And you know what, it made me a better better friend, because instead of being, you know, seething, that my friend is in my house wearing shoes and being like, so mad about a, you know, it could just be nipped in the bud. And you know, and it gives them access to having a better relationship with me, because I'm not secretly, you know, mad at them for something that could be corrected so easily. But it was still hard, right, because of what I've learned about, you know, about that this stuff growing up, we didn't have boundaries. So in my life, I, almost everyone has had a good reaction when I set boundaries. One of my siblings refused to honor a boundary, a very kind of simple boundary. And unfortunately, I had to end a relationship with her. And because we're at the same state, it's been, I guess, a number of years now would be like, three years or something, that I haven't had a relationship with her. And that feels really good for me, right? That's like a long time coming of like many years of therapy to get to that point, right? And set boundaries with her. And then when she just was like, no, no, I'm not going to do that. And I know, but you basically I was like, oh, okay, well, that's a great information for me about the type of person she is and what type of relationship she wants, she wants a relationship, which doesn't have boundaries, or, or, you know, not being able to respect or try and understand me. And so, you know, that means that I can't have a relationship with her. And my life, because of that has improved, not having a relationship, and I'm able to offer her in my brain more compassion, for understanding where she might be at, versus before, I was just constantly angry with her. So, yeah, so let's move to so what the reason why I'm telling you those stories is probably most people are going to have either a neutral or good reaction, right? Depending how the way you say, if you're like, listen up here, motherfuckers you're all pieces of shit and ruined my life, and I hate you, and you better not say this, or I'm gonna punch you in the face or whatever, then maybe they might have a good reaction. And it's fine. If you feel like that, you know, that's absolutely to be, you know, understandable, because sometimes these people have really fucked with our lives, and are the cause of these issues that we're dealing with. And you don't have to do anything. You know, be kind to people who have been unkind to you. But, you know, normally speaking, if we're having conversations, which are, are nuanced, and, you know, trying to be big, be kind and respectful to each other, then these types of conversations tend to tend to go okay, or good, and sometimes they might not, and that's okay, too. That doesn't mean what you're asking, Is this awful, terrible thing and that you're unreasonable? You know, that, you know, we can't we can't draw that conclusion from someone not respecting our boundaries. So here's a question from a follower on Instagram, who says my partner's mum always mocks his weight and blames me for making him fat with my cooking. He has a history of restricting and fainting due to malnutrition. And I encourage intuitive eating, his mother is fat herself, but says it's only acceptable to be fat when you're 50 Plus, I have told her several times I don't accept her speaking about her son in a demeaning way, but she keeps telling him to lose weight because, quote, he looks so much better. I wonder what to say to someone that clearly does not respect my wishes, not to fat shame and I find it odd why it's common for older fat people to shame on younger fat people. Okay, so you know, when I read that I just felt really like this is straight up bullying and is cruel and is deeply harmful. If from the first sentence blames me for making him fat with my cooking, I mean, that's so sexist, right? So you're making him fat with your cooking like he is this helpless, baby boy and you're his mother Mother responsible for his care. And so you're to blame for him having a body you know, so weird. It's so so it's just the patriarchy right there and As the other thing is, is that he's fainted due to malnutrition. Could your partner be anorexic? The last episode we did on atypical anorexia, Anorexia and fat folks? And that, you know, someone is not eating enough that they faint. That is, I mean, it's could be a sign, right? So you're, you're, I'm saying Mother in law, you didn't say mother in law, I'm just gonna say mother in law to shorten it. Your mother in law could be encouraging an eating disorder. And I'm curious to what does your partner do? Or say, when the mother in law says these things like? Because it sounds like you're standing up for him, but we don't we don't have the information of what he's seeing. Whether he's saying, Yeah, mom cut it out. Or if he's saying nothing, and then when when you get home, he's like, I can't believe my mom said that. Or if he's saying, Yeah, well, you know, how my mom's like, just leave a B. And, you know, you're the one kind of taking on this, this burden. So I'm curious about that. Because, you know, it's, he plays a he, you know, he, it's about him, right? And so, would it be appropriate for you both to come up with consequences? Because I wonder, you know, like, she, you said, we've taught, I've taught her several times, and but she keeps doing it. And so she keeps doing it, because there's no consequence, right? Like, if she wasn't in your life, she couldn't not do it. And I was saying, that's it and the relationship. And, you know, and it's, and again, we need to have a bit of, of nuance, when we're thinking about this. You could be living with them with the with, you know, the mum, you could be dependent on her for for cheaper rent or something, or, or we're not we, you know, we don't know the situation, exactly. And so, would it be appropriate to have consequences, where it's like, we're not going to see you, we're not going to talk to you or whatever. Maybe it is, maybe it's not. But I think every time that she's doing it, I think there has to be, this is not acceptable.

This is not acceptable. Coming up with some type of word track that you just keep saying. And it could be that you're saying, you know, this is not acceptable. Do not comment on his weight. You are engaging in, in, in bullying and in bigotry right now. Whatever it is, it could be that you literally get up from the table and say, I'm sorry, we're not able to be here, while you're talking about why you're shaming Sutton. And walking away. It could be that you, I saw this post where someone says that whenever someone talks about something, why they're done, or if it was wait, but they just come up with a random fact about otters, and they said, Did you know that otters hold hand with hands when they sleep? You know, and so that she learns that is not it not is not going to gain her anything by keep to keep talking about his weight? Because it could be that right now, what she's thinking is, well, if I keep going, they're going to really understand that this is something that's important for me if I keep shaming him, he might become thin you know, there's that that's that you know that she's doing it for a reason some benefit to her. And that benefit could be that the sun she perceives the sun and having a better life, if he is thinner, you know, and I you know, your question of like, why is it that older, fat people shame, younger fat people and I feel like sometimes older fat people can be really deep and fatphobia they've been alive longer they have been around during the peak of, of diet culture and you know, all sorts of stuff, depending on their age, they might have been around where, you know, things like Fen Fen diet pills and all sorts of stuff. Now, we're lucky enough to, you know, in the last 10 years be more exposed to that and sometimes not all older people, but sometimes, some older people are not exposed to those messages and it just seems so you know, quote, everyone knows that being fat is bad. They're not exposed to the other idea of, you know, That's all true. And so because sometimes older folks can be do even fatphobia, they know, they've seen the they've experienced the world that is so deeply anti fat. And the conclusion in their mind is not, Let's rally against fat phobia, it's, let's not be fat. And so in their mind, it might be okay to fat shame and not even might be in this example, it is okay for her in her mind to fat shame, because it might get her the result that she's hoping for, which is the chance that her son will become thin, and therefore in her mind happier, and therefore, safe from fat phobia. And so there's kind of something you know, you know, a plus b equals 25, you know, so it's kind of like, a plus b, that makes sense, you know, but we're targeting the wrong thing. So she's targeting the wrong thing, which is, instead, we should be tackling bigotry and anti fat bias. She's saying we should target fatness and fat people, and probably feels like she's doing a really good thing. Because being fat in this world is difficult, you know, but I mean, shit. It's, there's plenty of fat, older people and thin older people who would recoil at this story and say, well, that's obviously really fucked up. And that's obviously going to drive a wedge in the relationship between you and the sun, and obviously is not going to be successful. So I really don't like this kind of letting people who are older off the hook. Because I mean, it really feels like we're infantilizing older people we're being like, well, they don't know any better. Why not? They have a brain. They are able to be compassionate, you know? Hello. And just because it was, you know, different when they were young, doesn't matter. Other older folks have been able to get it. You know, my my mom, my mom was deep in that stuff, right? She's 71. Now. And she is I mean, if you talk to her, she's so radical. She's got things that she needs to work on. Yeah, like as we all do, but there's no way I would have thought that she would say the things that she does now, you know, it's really beautiful to see. And so even if someone is currently being a beggar, there is hope. But we cannot accept that. And we cannot accept any bigotry, and that is fat phobia. That is racism, that is sexism, that is all of those things, it is not appropriate to just kind of be like, wow, you know, they're older. And you know, this person is not saying that I'm just saying in general. It's just not acceptable and fat phobia is bigotry. It is anti black racism. It is not acceptable. Yeah, so for this one, I really want to know what consequences we have in place. What is happening? And what is the what is your partner doing? Like? Is he involved in this process, because that could be difficult if he's not because you're, you know, one person standing up when the relationship dynamic is between, you know, the Son and the mum. And, and that could cause that there to be barriers, right. And it could mean that your, your boyfriend, your, your partner, sorry, says I don't mind and I'm not going to say anything to mum. And it could mean that you decide, well, I'm not going to go and I'm not going to hang out with with your mom anymore, because it is not appropriate for me to be hearing those things. And I really wish that, you know, you could stand up to her or whatever. The you know, there's so many different scenarios that could be going on here. But really, we need to be laying down those those consequences, whatever they are, whether it's you're saying something, you're changing the subject, you're getting up and walking away, you're spending less time with her, you know, just starts closed there's a real that me and some have made where it's like how to respond to fat folks. And it's a funny thing, like and one of them was I bent over and started you know, making my bum, my bum cheeks move and bid and being like, man, you know, just stupid like you're not going to do that but you could do that. Or just say stop or whatever. You can come up with many different things that you can say and and also Oh, understanding there might be some situation here where doing those things might not be appropriate because there might be some power imbalance. So, yeah, yeah. Yeah. Okay. Now, let's move on to our next one, which is my best friend is st sized. And in the past, she and I have engaged in very disordered conversations around food and weight loss. I have recently been trying to reframe my thoughts around my plus size body, and focus on my health, physical and mental rather than my Wait. My friend, however, continues to make comments like, I feel so fat and disgusting today. I finally told her how these comments make me a person who is objectively much larger than her feel terrible. And she has accused me of gaslighting her and making it so she can't say anything about her own feelings, for fear of upsetting me. I want her to be able to express herself to me, and I'm trying to find a middle ground help.

Yeah, so first off, this is this is, you know, kind of like what we've been talking about. We in the past, you have engaged in disordered conversations. Right. And so, so this is kind of like growing pains. And you say you've recently been trying to. And so this is, you know, it's a recent thing. And so this is kind of growing pains. And so we're going to have to help her and you know, understand for you as well, what is okay and what is not okay, and I would love to pick your friend's brain about you know, shoot her saying that the you are gaslighting her. And when I read that I was like, Okay, what I suspect is happening for her. Obviously, I don't know, I'm not talking to her. What I suspect is she's hearing something that you're not saying, I suspect she's hearing something like, Hey, friend, you can never feel bad about your body because my body is bigger. Which invalidates her feelings. And I'm sure that's not what you set. But you know, us humans are so good at making it about ourselves, right, making us to blame because if we are the fall, and we are bad than we can fix it, right? And so, you know, especially if you're bringing in say, hey, when you say this, this makes me feel bad. She's wondering, she's probably gonna get defensive and kind of maybe misunderstand what you're saying. And what we're trying to say here is that talking about fat as a negative, is difficult to hear, especially from people who are smaller, as it contributes to the idea that your body is particularly bad, because it's bigger. Even though your friend isn't saying that she's saying about her, she still is framing fatness as a negative, it might be appropriate for your friend to say, I'm really struggling with my body image today. And I'm sure that that sounds a lot better, right? If your friend said, Hey, I'm really struggling with my body image today. But she's not she's saying I feel fat, and disgusting. Therefore, fat is disgusting. And saying that as someone who is living in a privilege privilege body. And the reason why that's inappropriate, aside from aligning fat with disgusting, is that it raises your experience of living in a bigger body and the very real stigmatization and marginalization that you experience, because of your body size, right? Everyone can have the potential for having terrible body image for hating themselves, no matter their size. But the difference is, it's only people who have marginalized bodies and in this example, a fat body that experiences systemic oppression when they go out into the world, so a straight size person is not going to have to also deal with feeling shit so because anyone can feel shamed about their body, but also then not be able to buy clothes. You know, but also then have the doctor say yeah, you are too fat, you need to lose weight, but also then not be able to find a date because only 25% of sis hat men would date a fat sis hat woman. So it's like this added layer and and we're not talking about like, oh, straight sides. People don't have their bad side. Straight size people can struggle so much with body image, it could be deadly for them. And I think maybe when your friend said, I feel like you're gaslighting me, that could be maybe what she's feeling of you don't understand how hard this is for me. And we want to understand that it is body image stuff is devastating. And we can be less black and white with our thinking about it. We can think okay, well then how does it affect others if I am talking negatively about their marginalized identity? You know, because I feel like your friend would be able to understand that that difference between you saying that her saying that fat is bad and you saying hey, don't say that fat is bad. So I think if we were to have the conversation with her about power and privilege, and fat politics, that could be helpful. And acknowledging that struggling with body image issues is a very real battle for many, many people and can be very painful. But the difference is that fat people also have to deal with the very real lived reality being in a bigger body in a society that villainize is fatness. So, again, you can make it about you and not about her not that she's, you know, we can say, hey, I want your help. And the thing is, she needs to get used to this new language that you're speaking. She needs to get used to the idea that anti fatness is never acceptable. I mean, if I if I was friends with her, and she said, I feel so fat, and disgusting. And I was friends with her and say, I didn't do this job. Immediately. I be like, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa. What's going on? What do you mean, you feel so fat and disgusting? Hello, I'm a fat person. And what does that mean? What you think about my body? And then she's, I don't know, I think you look weird. But, you know, you know, that, that, you know, if they suddenly got my body, they'd be like, Oh, I'm so fat, you know? So and it is about them, right? It is about them, you know, and then how they feel but really, they're less throwing you under the bus in the process of trying to express themselves. So I would if that happened to me, I'd say hey, you know what, when you say you feel fat, using fat as a feeling word is not appropriate because you are in sin you insinuating that fatness is bad. And that fatness is disgusting. And then it's not appropriate, because we were out here trying to be you know, when we don't do anti fat anymore, that's like really 2013. So, I'd love to hear about how you're struggling with body image issues. But or you can say you know what, I don't want to hear about your stroke you struggling with body image issues because I'm not in that place right now where I can hear it because you live in a bit in a smaller body. It can be very difficult for a fat person to hear a straight size person say that they think that an attractive when society says that they are attractive, when you are experiencing so much shit because of the body that you're living in. And so some fat people do say to their straight size friends, I love you. But unfortunately, because of where I am at with my body image journey, and because I don't have the spoons, okay, the mental energy, I cannot talk to you about body image. I support you, I really wish that you the very best on your journey. But that's just one thing that I find very difficult to talk about because of the privilege imbalance in this relationship. The privilege the body size privilege, and that is okay, too. I mean, it's pretty it's I mean, it is obnoxious to be in a thin body complaining about how fat you are to it to a fat person. I mean, it's pretty cringy right. But it's so normal. We mean, we've probably all done it. We probably still do it today, you know, like it's so normal, but it shouldn't be and by the way, you know, I was saying hey, well we're whoa you know someone's But that to me, obviously, I'm a fat activist. Like, I'm so used to talking about this stuff. And I have it on the tip of my tongue. Right? I don't expect anyone else to be doing that. But knowing that, from my perspective, my perspective, it's not okay. At all. Not even close to Okay.

Yeah, so so so we're just respond to that one summarizing that is, I think maybe clarifying what you mean. clarifying that, you know, about anti fatness and why saying your she feels fat is not appropriate. And also saying that you deeply empathize with her in regards to her body image issues, and her body image issues are very real, no matter what her size is. And it's very important that she is able to overcome that stuff, if you want to, you know, and that she's important, her feelings are important. But also, her feelings are important, but she can't throw you under the bus in trying to express them. Okay, so I had a little question box for the kind of like, short little questions here. Someone just sent in mother in law that was it. Just a mother in law. I was like, huh, yeah, yeah. And I think as well with mother in law, it's it's difficult because it's not your mom, right? Your mom, it's kind of like there is theoretically unconditional love. But with your mother in law, the relationship is difficult, right? She can tell you to fuck off. I mean, your mom could it anyway. But their relationship is difficult. And you kind of have to be polite. And depending on your your culture, or where you're from there could be that really kind of, you know, respecting your elders to the point where the elders can be deeply disrespectful for you to you and abusive to you, but you can't say anything because it's a culture. Yeah, so if you are dealing with a mother in law that is happy to be displaying body bigotry, then I am so sorry that you have to deal with that. Okay, someone else says here whenever I eat something, quote, healthy people accuse me of dieting. I'm anti diet and hated. Yeah, so that's fucked up. Ira roll. I mean, people can't get away with eating anything now without someone having some type of opinion that they want to express right? If that person eats a salad, Oh, really. But you don't eat salads often or but you're doing that just for a performance? Or? Oh, are you trying to lose weight good for you ever eating a salad like you've never eaten a salad before? Or if you eat something that is quote unquote, unhealthy, then oh, surprise, surprise, and no matter you're fat, or if you even if you're straight size, and you're eating something, quote unquote, unhealthy, then, oh, you've been naughty, you know? Just keep your opinions about what someone is eating to yourself. Unless you want to be like, Oh, that looks delicious. Can I try? So I'm you know, you would be doing that to a random stranger. Maybe you would. But for me if someone said to me, Oh, are you dieting? I didn't like No. No. And I explained why I'm anti diet. I'm anti diet. And actually, it's really inappropriate that you would ask me that and talk about food. Depending on your like your relationship with that person. I mean, Fuck if I was a being a salad and someone says, oh, you dieting I might, you know, grab a fistful of salad and just be like that. Now, I'm not dieting. Yeah. So there that might be. That might be a an opportunity, depending on your relationship with that person for a little bit of education, about how it's inappropriate to talk about anyone's food, and presuming that they're dieting. Why you're presuming that that person is dieting? Yeah. Okay. Someone says coworkers, mine are brutal. They never say anything about me. But constant diet talk. It's rough. Yeah. So that's the thing is, is it's a lot harder when they're not saying something about you directly. But that kind of art, right? So with co workers, that's another thing is because you can't just go in there and just do some roundhouse kicks and just be like, shut up, Sharon. You might get fired. And so you could approach this in a few different ways. It could be that you send an email to HR and say, Hey, can we institute a no diet talk policy because blah, blah, blah. HR might be like, Oh, why would you do that being fat is bad. You know, you're you might not have HR? It could be that you just have a conversation with your work colleagues and say, Hey, can we not with a diet talk? You could do any of the things that we spoke about earlier about changing the subject, you could, you know, question them you know, if people were talking about diet So I might be curious about like, why do you want to be thin? Like, why do you want to lose weight? Why, but why? We want to be thin and we want to be, it's not healthy to be fat. Is it? Like, where did you get the idea from? Did you know? And so eventually, they'd know that. Why would we talk about that in front of Vinny? She's such a party pooper. They're just, they're such a party pooper. And it could be that you explain to them hey, you know, I've had a history with history of disordered eating. And so when people hear talk about diets, it's really bad for my mental health. It could be that you just get up from the table. Anytime someone talks about dieting, it could be that you put in your headphones and just press the play button when they start talking about dieting. But another thing could be that you ask a manager or HR to bring in a professional like me to teach about anti diet pro fatness, and that's something that I do, right, this part of my businesses is going into organizations and teaching about fat phobia. And I talk about diet talk at the lunchtime, and it feels so fucking satisfying. To be saying, Hey, this is not okay. And for, you know, people would have been like, oh, shit, when I do that all the time. You know, it feels so good to be protecting folks, by talking about that stuff. Someone else here I said, I asked a question. Does anyone have any tips, someone said that they made their own presentation on fat phobia and presented it to the organization. And now they are the lead mental health now they're their mental health team lead organized in my organization is what they said. So it could be that they you know, there's no budget to bring someone like me and but you are going to do it yourself. And then you explain like, why is this harmful? You know, what, what, what is all this about? My father in law comments on my four year olds, body and food choices every time were there. Yeah. So that is boundaries, boundaries, boundaries, boundaries. And also, you know, with a remove reduced protect, it could be that, you know, father in law said that you're never gonna see them again. You know, we've decided that but also you want to talk to your child about what happened, okay? So you might, you will not be able to protect children from being exposed to anti fat bias. But what you can do is help them understand how it's not okay? By talking to them about that, how that made them feel, and all that type of stuff. Someone asks, mum thinks fat is ugly and doesn't want to be fat. She says it's because she always liked beauty. How do I respect her body autonomy without passively supporting her fat phobia? Yeah. So your mom has an opinion, which is based on a belief and beliefs are not facts. It's not a fact that fat is ugly. It's an opinion. Okay. So I might say to mom, hey, did you know that there are many people who think that being fat is absolutely beautiful, and I happen to be one of them. Sometimes when you talk about how you don't want to be fat, it hurts me in these ways. It makes me worried that you're not going to love me if I'm fat. It makes me anxious that you're judging my body. I mean, if you I don't know if your mom's fat or not. But you know, I, I would probably have that conversation about how it affects you. And if she wants to continue to dye it or be thin or hate being fat. I don't know what her body size is. You know, that's fine. She can do that. But what she can't do is harm you in the process. Even if you have a small body. This stuff is harmful, right? It's this indoctrination of anti fatness, this slow drip. That is, you know, we might say hi. Is it a big deal? Sometimes it's not. Sometimes you might be like, Ah, whatever. But sometimes it is and for those who are struggling with body image stuff. Almost always they have a parent or a sibling or friends who are big into anti fatness that that really influences them. And I'm like, Okay, well, that is a great opportunity to, to sort that out. Because it's probably going to really help you. Yeah, so I would in that situation, talk to mom and say, hey, you know, I understand that you think that that's the fact it's not actually a fact. And this is how it's negatively affecting me. Is there anything I can do to support you in it? accepting your body the way it is. And if she wants to continue to do whatever, in regards to her body, that's her choice, right? Okay, finally one mother in law justifies herself as whenever she eats something she thinks she should be eat, she shouldn't be eating. Well, I never eat junk food like this usually. So I guess one time is okay. When literally no one commented.

Yeah, so I might go with the Hey, mother in law, I'm wondering if you can help me with something. I'm I'm trying to unlearn harmful beliefs around food. And so talking about junk food, quote, unquote, I've noticed is not great for my mental health. I'm wondering if you can avoid talking about that. It could be that when you when Mother Nora says junk food. And talking about like, it sounds like you struggle with allowing yourself to have have certain foods, you know, are you okay? Can we help you with that? Or, you know, or you could come back with some type of sassy thing of like, you know, when she's like, Oh, I'm, I'm, I'm being so bad. You were like, you know, you didn't just, you know, murder again, guinea pig, you know, you're not actually doing anything bad. You're just eating food like a human. Yeah. So when that stuff happens around me, I genuinely ask questions. And, you know, who knows how it goes. But you know, if I ask questions, I know that I'm going to ask questions again, next time that they talk about it. And so then they're less likely to do it. And you know, with other people in my life, I've already set boundaries. And so it's not often I get these experiences. It's only when I'm meeting new people.

So, so yeah. What do you think? What do you think? How are you feeling? I hope you feel like you can. I know. Set boundaries, if it's if it's appropriate. And also, I want you to forgive yourself, if you if you don't say something in the moment, and then afterwards, you're like, Shit, I could have really like, said this thing. And that would have changed everything. And you know, they would never do it again. And I didn't I just sat there and smiled and nodded. You know, I mean, this stuff is fucking hard. I've been doing this for years. All right. So I want you to, you know, know that this is a process. This is a lifelong, right. And also, it's not appropriate that you're exposed to this stuff, especially from people who you see a lot who you're close to. Who that who you love and who love you, is really, really upsetting and can be very impactful to your mental health. You deserve to have safety in your relationships with with whoever. And it sucks that we're the one having to do this fucking work. It is not fair. It is not fair that we are the ones having to to fucking work so hard to be treated fairly. Get some my fucking tits, huh? All right, well, I'm gonna leave it there for you today. Again, if you want to go to Dominican Republic with me go check out the link in the show notes or go to the link in my bio on Instagram first dot fatti. And we'll see you I guess actually, I'll probably see you in the new year now because I'm me and me and my team are taken off two weeks, the end of the year. And let's see, we're going to take off the week of the 19th and the week of the 26th. So yeah, so probably there's not going to be another podcast until beginning of January. So So actually, so this is good timing because then if we were doing stuff with the holidays, then you know, be prepared. And remember that remove reduced protect. There's a link in in the show notes where you can find a an image for that. So you can refer to that. And yeah, just give yourself a lot of a lot of love and hugs around this stuff. And have a wonderful rest of your day or night or afternoon or whatever.

EP149 Transcript

You're listening to the Fierce Fatty podcast episode 149. Atypical anorexia, let's do it.

Hello, welcome to this episode Fierce Fatties. Nice to see ya. Hey, I just got some details back on the first fatty vacation, and I want to tell them to you and tell them to you. So for those who don't know, our first fatty vacation is to the Dominican Republic. And it is also a fats, Joy themed vacation. So it's for fat folks. What does fat mean? Who is fat? To answer that question is kind of difficult, because a lot of times it's measured against women's clothing. And not everyone wears women's clothing. And also women's clothing sizes are different in every country, and also different brands, they're different. So a very, very rough guide of what is fat, or what is plus size is someone who is size 1618 as a minimum, and so that might be someone who is like a two XL in of a gendered clothing. But more importantly, a definition of who is fat is if you've experienced systemic marginalization due to the size of your body, so that is, you know, not fitting in chairs, not having blood pressure cuffs that, that fit, being denied opportunities, whatever types of opportunities because of your body size. And it's not your perceived body size, it's the kind of systemic things that have happened versus someone saying, You're too big when you're actually a straight size person. So I'll leave it up to the people who are coming on the trip to work out if they feel like they are a fat person. And in the past, whenever I've said something is a space for fat folks, people have been good in selecting if that hits, if that fits them. And the reason why we're making a fat, fat joy and fat only trip is because to make it a safe space, right? So that everyone is kind of in the same boat in a kind of roundabout right way, right? Because everyone's going to be different sizes, but as long as everyone is a small vat or higher then beautiful. All right, so dates for the trip June 14 to June 18. When the podcast comes out, the trip would have been live for a few days. So go to the show notes and look at the link and it will give you all of the details and you'll have the chance to get early bird tickets, the first eight spots out of thing it's twin, D It's just I'm just looking at my my doobly doo here 18 Okay, so the first eight out of 18 Get earlybird pricing. So go check that out if that interests you the types of things that we are doing. Okay, so, here's here's a snapshot of the things that we're doing when you're low Beach, relax on a palm lined white sand beach and enjoy the clear turquoise waters. I've seen pictures of this place fucking gorgeous. It's so it's like out of a I don't know when you imagine exotic places or you know, a hot places. You know, it's this is this is what it's like it's beautiful. Next Pearl Beach Club. Have a delicious lunch at a private pool, and beautiful with beautiful beachfront views. Cap Karna harbor visit, visit shops and take pictures and afterwards take a dip in a marina port and sip a complimentary cocktail. Oh whoa indigenous ecological park and reserve visit. The reserve consists of a network of trails including 12 freshwater lagoon swim in one of the lagoons with its clear water glittery water and enjoy the sights and sounds of the surrounding tropical forest. Off Road adventure driving your own ATV across a diverse landscape of the Dominican countryside, stock photos and sample locations. receives delicacies like chocolate and organic coffee, cooking class difference delivered by a professional chef who will explain the cooking styles of the region and teach you about traditional Dominican cuisine. And group dining, spend time with your new travel buddies and your host me Vinny at local restaurants. And at the hotel, something delicious local cuisine. And we're gonna be talking about fat joy and kind of setting intentions and laughing having fun splashing in the water, eating food, all that type of stuff. I really would love it to happen. And the only way to happen is if you come along, if we don't have enough interest, then it won't happen. So it's all down to you. Who knows? I have no, I have no idea. What is going to happen with this? I you know, I did a survey to see if you were interested. And you are a lot of people said that they were in theory, I guess. And so it's down now to if in reality that extends to actually making it happen. Pricing wise, you're able to break up the payments, they've have a financing option type of thing. I don't know if it's financing. I don't think there's any interest on it. It's you know, like, you know, have you seen like, now when you buy clothes as the option to spread the payments over X amount or something? I want to find out more about that. And, yeah, so I, I know for sure. But anyway, there's that option, I think you have to put 25% of the price down. early bird pricing is 2695 2695. Yeah, so that's that if you'd love to come then come if you would love to come but can't afford it, I totally get it. The price is a little bit higher for us because we have included things that are accessible. So for example, the transport from the airport, instead of being in, you know, small, a small bus we have, we have a bus with bigger seats. So that we are in a hotel that has bigger showers, we had to pick a hotel that was a little bit more expensive. So just kind of just some transparency there. Again, this is absolutely accessible in regards to if you need to rent a scooter or a wheelchair, we have that option. We have options for buses that have ramps, the activities that we're doing, they are all well, it's it's activity level one. So the activities we're doing, as you can see from the things that I was telling you, like quani low beach, so that's accessible Pearl Beach Club, and so again, that's accessible in regards to wheelchairs, and also folks who have limited mobility. And then there's other things like you know, like the ecological park and and that's, you know, as much as you want to explore, you can do that. And if others want to explore more than they can do that too. No one is going to be left behind. I absolutely promise you. And you know, rather than the ATV, if that's not something that you want to do, you don't have to write. But again, we're going to be driven right to the adventurer place so the ATV So yeah, if you've got questions, if you're unsure about anything, then please do send me an email fattie at fierce fatty.com or go on to the link in the show notes to get all of the details because I'm just kind of giving you a little overview right of the things that we're doing. But then you've got more details on what that looks like every single day and all that jazz. So who knows that is going to happen. You tell me if you want to come? I would love to see you there. Okay, so let's talk about what we're talking about today, which is atypical anorexia, and I've never done an episode that is dedicated to atypical anorexia. And actually researching for this episode, I was like, Yeah, I know. I know, you know, atypical anorexia, I know about that. But I've learnt some, you know, more facts around it. And I thought that it was really interesting, and I thought that you would find it interesting to her. And a big trigger warning here we're going to be talking about the effects of atypical anorexia.

What it's like and the differences that people in bigger bodies experience and so if that's not feeling good for you today, then maybe skip this episode because we We'll be talking about that I'm not gonna be talking about anything like calories or, or weights, specific weights. So you don't need to worry about that. Alright, so a typical anorexia let me just read out a little bit here. Atypical anorexia, basically, I'm not reading by the way, I'm just talking Exia is anorexia in someone who is in a body that is not very small or underweight. Okay. So if you think about anorexia, a lot of the times what we think about is someone in a very small body. That actually should be called atypical anorexia. Because the most typical form of anorexia is anorexia in people with bigger bodies. And just to look a heads up oh, look at Quick what Mayo Clinic say about anorexia nervosa. Anorexia is an eating disorder characterized by an N Abloh, abnormally low body weight, intense fear of gaining weight and a distorted perception of weight. People with anorexia place a high value on controlling their weight and shape using extreme efforts that tend to significantly interfere with their lives. So notice that with this just standard definition, characterized by having a small body and that's the first thing that they lead with at Mayo Clinic. But really, that's it's kind of like where, where you're starting out if you already have a smaller body, then it's more likely that if you if you have anorexia, that you'll get a smaller body. If you have a bigger body, chances are that you'll still have a bigger body even if you have anorexia because there's only a certain amount of weight that your body can lose before it just says no, that's enough. And a lot of times for people who are in bigger bodies, it's not low enough to be classed as having anorexia but they will be classed as having a typical anorexia which is problematic and we'll talk about that now. Okay, so here's a quote. Atypical anorexia is dangerous because it did it's often not recognized family and family it's an even doctors might be praising a young woman. I don't know why they say women here because everyone can have an IDI but it is more common in women praising a human for impressive weight loss when she is actually critically unwell. A typical anorexia patients have all the same symptoms and behaviors as typical patients typical anorexia patients except the most visible one low weight. A 2016 study found that there were they were just as physically compromised and distressed emotionally as their typical typical counterparts. Both are driven by an obsessive fear of weight gain and being fat but atypical anorexia patients had what they what they study called significantly higher levels of distress related to eating and body image and a fear of fatness, but their weight history might exacerbate. Let me read that again. So people who are in bigger bodies who have anorexia have significantly higher levels of distress related to eating and body image and a fear of fatness that their weight history might exacerbate. So, you know, people in bigger bodies have got that evidence that lived experience of what it's like to be in a bigger body and what would happen if they got back to that bigger body that maybe they had before? Or if they have lost weight, and what that experience is like and what if then they get a even bigger body than what they had previously. So there's a New York Times Magazine article, which is the which came out in a month a month, like six weeks ago, and I had pinned it to read is really good. And I have linked it in the show notes, but it's behind a paywall, depending on how many times you've looked at New York, New York Times, as I've also linked a link so that you can read it from behind the paywall. So if you if you there's it's an archive.ph link and so if you're like what the fuck is this, this dodgy link that Vinnie has given me, that's just what that is. And so you can go and read it. It's about a I'm 45 minute read. So it's quite in depth. And so I'm going to pick out some of the things in here that I thought were was really, really interesting and I'm going to read a few paragraphs from the very beginning. And the title of it is you don't look anorexic. Okay, so are you sitting comfortably, then I shall begin for centuries, the eating disorder that would become known as anorexia nervosa, mystified the medical community, which struggled to understand or even define an illness that causes people to deliberately deprive themselves of food. As cases rose, over the course of a 19th and 20th centuries, anorexia was considered a purely psychological disorder akin to hysteria. So William with the girl, an English physician who coined the term anorexia, Nova Llosa, in the late 1800s, called it a perversion of the ego. There's a link there to the perversion of the ego. And there's a there's a kind of article in this 1800s I don't know what it was a magazine for doctors, and him describing a patient and he has a I think it was woodblock illustration of the patient, and her symptoms and all that type of stuff. And it's quite interesting. There's mention of weight in there. So if you don't want to see that, yeah, so and yeah, and saying it's a perversion of the ego kind of sounds like he was quite perplexed about what was happening. Okay, continuing in 19, after an autopsy revealed an atrophied pituitary gland. Anorexia was thought to be an endocrinologic injure and DRO Coronado logical disease and chronological disease oh my god, I've worked so hard. That theory was later debunked, and in the mid 20th century, psychoanalytic explanations arose pointing to sexual and developmental dysfunction and later, unhealthy family dynamics. More recently, the medical field has come to believe that anorexia can be the product of a constellation of psychological, social, genetic, neurological and biological factors. Since anorexia nervosa became the first eating related disorders listed in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders. That's called the DSM in 1952. So anorexia was put in the DSM in 1952, its criteria have shifted as well. Initially, anorexia had no weight criteria, and was classified as a psycho sociological, psycho physiological disorder. In 19, in a 1972 paper, a team led by the prominent psychiatrist John finer, suggested using a weight loss of at least 25% as a standard for research purposes. And in 1980, the DSM introduced that figure in its definition, along with a criterion that patients weigh well below, quote, unquote, normal for their age and height, although normal was not defined. Doctors who relied on that number soon found that that patients who had lost at least 25% of their body weight were already severely sick. So in 1987, the diagnosis were revised to include those who weighed less than 85% of their, quote, normal body weight, well qualified as normal was left for physicians to decide. In the 2013 DSM, the criteria shifted, again, characterizing those who suffer from anorexia as having a significantly low weight, a description that would also appear in the 2022 edition. So this is interesting. So the first time that anorexia was mentioned, it was in 1952. In the DSM, as in, you know, in that in that context, in the DSM, and there was no way attached to it. And I wonder, I wonder, the discussions around that at that time, if you listened to the episode last week of the biggest scammers in the weight loss industry.

And we know by the 1950s, weight loss and diets and all that bullshit was in in full full force, right full swing, people were absolutely trying to become smaller and absolutely presumed to know that fat bodies were bad. My wonder One how much that influenced folks with anorexia because we've had cases since the 1800s have been identified and even before you know, we started last last episode on talking about stuff hate happening in the early 19th century, but anti fatness has been around for hundreds of years. So yes, one, how much anti fatness influenced folks with anorexia, and also how much anti fatness influenced the idea that there should be a weight categorization. Because if you lose 24.9% of your body weight, that's just a diet. But if you lose 20, lose 25% of your body weight, then that is our Axia. You know, according to the DSM in 1980. And, and so, I wonder previously to that when they didn't have that weight limit or weight criteria, which is absolutely bizarre, it's the only mental illness and has a weight criteria. Can you imagine if you were like, Oh, you don't have depression, because you're too fat to have depression, only thin people have depression. You're just imagining it. Yeah, and I wonder if diet companies or those invested in anti fatness, push, push back to get a definition. And even if it is people in the mental health world, pushing back and they they are living in a world that is anti fat. The idea that whatever fat person loses weight, well, then that's good no matter how much you know. And people who are, who are the higher weight people are regularly encouraged to lose 25% plus of their weight, right? And so at least in the 1980s, if you had a 400 pound person, and they lost weight and they became a 250 pound person, then folks might start to say, Okay, well, what's going on here? Are they engaging in disordered eating? Do they have an eating disorder? Whereas more recently in the 22,020 13 DSM, we've got that has to have significantly low weight and I wonder what was going on there? of why is it that we have positioned fat folks who have an eating disorder if they are still currently fat as that's okay. Or that is not a typical anorexia. And a lot of people haven't even heard of a typical anorexia. Right. I mean, a lot of a lot of doctors GPS don't know don't know that term. And if they do, they probably think it's, it's, you know, not that common when actually it's the most common, you know, straight up anorexia is way less common than atypical anorexia. Yeah, so I find that interesting to think about of why is it then we got to the 23rd. Why is it we've got to 2013 and then we've got the significantly low weight isn't a mental illness, the same mental illness depending on your size? Is it the fact that a fat person could quote, still stand to lose weight? And then so then, okay, well, it's not a bad thing in that circumstance, but you know, we do have the atypical diagnosis in the DSM. So let me continue. In that 2013 addition, then a new diagnosis appeared a typical anorexia nervosa nervosa after healthcare providers noticed more patients showing up for treatment with all the symptoms of anorexia nervosa except one, a significantly low weight. So isn't that interesting, right. So physicians saw fat people coming in with anorexia, and instead of expanding the definition of what anorexia is they reduced it further to be so it's only for people who have a significantly low weight. Okay, continuing. Those with atypical anorexia, doctors observed suffer the same mental and physical symptoms as people with anorexia nervosa, even life threatening heart issues and electrolyte balances. They restrict calories intensively obsess about food eating and body image and view their weight as inextricably linked to their value. They often skip meals eaten secret adhere to intricate rules about what foods they allow themselves to consume and create unusual habits like chewing and spitting out food. Other exercise to the point of exhaustion abused laxatives and purge their meals. But unlike those diagnosed with anorexia, people with atypical anorexia can lose significant amounts of weight, but still have a medium or large body size. others because of their body's metabolism, hardly lose any weight at all. To the outside world. They appear quote unquote, oh word. Yeah, so that's the introduction of the history of a typical anorexia. And so starting in the mid 2000s, a number of people seeking treatment for the disorder rose sharply whether more people are developing atypical anorexia or or seeking treatment, or more doctors are recognizing it is unknown, but this group now comprises up to half of all patients hospitalized in eating disorder programs. So half of all patients hospitalized in eating disorder programs, have those with atypical anorexia. And so just a reminder here, atypical anorexia wasn't in the DSM, until 2013. Okay, so if you were kind of similar age to me, I'm, I'm 38. You might be thinking, holy shit, I never knew about this, I think that I have lived with a typical anorexia myself. And we, you know, we didn't, we didn't know these things, we didn't know that. As a fat person, you could be not eating enough. I always thought, when I was not in, in fat positivity, I always thought, if you were fat, you had eaten enough, full stop. And until you became very thin, then that was evidence that you had not eaten enough. But that's not how the body works, right? How fat on your, on your body, having adipose tissue is not this unlimited fuel source, right? Someone could die of starvation and be a very fat person. Because the body needs so much to run just to just run basic organs right? need so much just to keep you alive, nevermind. Other things like going out in the world and walking around and, and using your brain and keeping you warm, and all that type of stuff. So every day, we need so much energy to be able to do that. And, you know, when we stop eating enough food, a lot of people think well, you know, your body just kind of keep burning and burning and burning fat to make energy until you become thin. And that's not what happens, right? That's not what happens. Our fat cells don't contain all of the things that we need to live and thrive. And also, our body stops that process from happening because our body goes into a starvation state. A lot of hormones are whizzing around telling us to to conserve our energy, making us extra hungry. And our metabolism can go out of whack. Right? And, and so you can have a fat person who, whose body is desperately desperately unwell from being under nourished, you know, the same reasons that someone with a smaller body would die from anorexia are the same reasons that someone with a bigger body would die from anorexia, right?

The body is eating away at muscles and your heart being a muscle and it becoming weaker and weaker and all of the other processes that are happening right. Which to me, when I understood this about atypical anorexia, I was like, what you know, isn't what I just really it I found it very hard to wrap my head around the idea that you could starve and be fat, because, you know, I just saw fatness as this just unending fuel source. but it's it's not right Okay, continuing with some some quotes. So studies suggest that the same number of people even as many as three times as many will develop a typical anorexia as traditional anorexia in their lifetime. So let me read it again, study suggests that the same number of people, even as many as three times as many will develop a typical anorexia as opposed to traditional anorexia in their lifetimes. One estimate suggests that as much as 4.9% of the female population will have the disorder for boys the number is lower when estimate was 1.2. For men, it's likely even lower, though little research exists for non binary people, the number jumps to as high as 7.5% That's a big difference, isn't it? For non binary people? 7.5% for for women 4.9%. And when we think like, oh, that's not that many people. It's, it's a lot of people to have a life threatening mental health condition. Yeah. So despite its prevalence, atypical anorexia is still considered widely under diagnosed and under researched. And many primary care doctors have never even heard of it. Patients too are unaware of it and see themselves having a weight issue. Yeah, that's the thing. It's like, it doesn't matter what you do to get thin, just get thin, is the is the message that we hear, right? It doesn't matter if you have to cut cut off healthy organ, putting yourself into into your digestive system into a disease state. It doesn't matter if you use that device, a spire assist which pumps your stomach after you eat. It doesn't matter. If you never eat food or you eat so so much food, you're in a forced starvation state which is the same, which is the same amount of calories that many diets Noom prescribe, that doesn't matter, because you're getting thinner. And of course, thinner is healthier. Oh, yeah, it's caused you to have an eating disorder. Oh, who cares? You're fat? Is what society says. So, and it's hard. Yeah, it's hard. I mean, how many of us fat people have had that experience of losing weight and going to the doctor, for example, and the doctor saying you've lost weight? Amazing. Right? That's so good, good for you. How did you lose? It doesn't matter. It doesn't matter. You're thinner. That's all that matters. And even if you did say to the doctor, well, you know, I'm, I'm eating this and that and it's clearly not enough for a human to live on what the doctor say. That sounds like you're not eating enough. Very unlikely. Very unlikely. Okay, continuing in 2020. Aaron Harrop, an Assistant Professor of Social Work at the University of Denver completed a survey of 39 people with atypical anorexia, most of whom were fat. They used to work and found that participants endured the disorder for an average of 11.6 years before seeking help. They lost an average of 64 pounds, and a quarter of the group had yet to receive treatment. By comparison, the treatment delays for anorexia are on average 2.5 years for bulimia 4.4 for binge eating disorder on average are 2.5 for bulimia 4.4 for binge eating disorder 5.6 According to a 2021 review, okay, so people with atypical anorexia have to wait 11.6 years. And that's even if they get help. Where as on average, a straight size person will have to wait 2.5 years. That is a huge difference. Imagine what living with anorexia does if you were doing that for 11.6 years, with no support with people encouraging you with you being convinced that your body is wrong. And so presumably from that, then Um, fat folks must have poor outcomes. I don't know this is I'm speculating, but I you know, in regards to even if they are able to go to treatment, and are they are they then more likely to have longer term effects? Are they likely more more likely to die versus straight size people don't know. Continuing to make it easier for people with atypical anorexia to be screened, treated and insured, there's a growing movement in the field to collapse the categories of anorexia and atypical anorexia into one to no longer see them as separate illnesses due to decouple anorexia from his virtually synonymous Association within us. Many, however, are fiercely resistant to letting go of the metric of weight, it would require altering the organizing principle by which the public and the greater medical field conceive of the condition. It would also require recognizing that anyone in any body can starve themselves into poor health. And you'd never know it by looking at them. That is, that's a really powerful sentence, I think. And that's it. And that, and then fat people have to deal with the stigma of there's no way that you are anorexic because you're fat. We all know, anorexic people have discipline and are thin because of that discipline. But look at you fat person, you're so undisciplined that you could never have anorexia. And these are the types of thoughts that I would have. When I was severely restricting what I ate, of, there's no way that I'm hurting. There's no way that I'm not getting enough food, because we all know that fat people. That's not their story, right? That if we're if I really was starving myself, I'd be thin. But I really was starving myself. Continuing the line between the two diagnosis is not particularly scientific, and has harmful effects on patient's ability to secure care. So this is what happens. When a human body is stabbed for long enough. It undergoes a complex series of biological, metabolic and hormonal changes to ensure its own survival. Every system moves to conserve energy, and the body begins to mind muscle and fat for glucose to keep the heart running and the brain functioning. The metabolism slows, which is why some people can eat very little and hardly lose any weight. If malnutrition worsens, their hair becomes fragile and falls out and muscle mass dwindles, including within the heart. People with severe anorexia of any kind can have orthostatic hypotension, heart rates lower than 60 beats per minute and electrolyte imbalances that may cause arrhythmias or even lead to cardiac arrest. From what little research on atypical anorexia exists, the medical complications appear to be the same as anorexia, and occur in similar rates across body sizes. So you don't have to be someone who is living in a very small body to experiences those things, is just when the body is forced into starvation.

Recent research has found that body size is a less relevant indicator of the severity of both eating disorders. And other factors, including the percentage of body mass lost the speed of that loss and the duration of the malnourished nourish state. So it having a small body doesn't tell you that your anorexia is more severe than someone in a bigger body. There are other indicators to show you how severe it is. And I'm going back to and I've mentioned it many times before, I mentioned in the last episode, Minnesota, the Minnesota starvation experiment, to see reminding us of what starvation does to us mentally, as well as physically and those those people who went through the experiments were given calories, which are actually more generous than than modern diets, many modern diets and they really, really struggled with their mental health left with eating disorders, left, you know, being hospitalized, left with less fingers than what they started with because one gentleman chopped off three of his fingers and Um, yeah, more recent research suggests that losing just 5% of one's body weight can be associated with a clinically significant eating disorder. Wow, this is huge, right? Losing just 5% body weight can be associated with a clinically significant eating disorder. And what is it that we are told to lose it is going to help us and our health so much five to 10% of your body weight. I had that Weight Watchers key ring, which was in the shape of a 10 for years for the 10%. But But weight loss when I got the 10% weight loss. And I was like 10%, I can do more than that. And I did. But they make it a thing. And it's, it's it's made up right. There's no scientific data to show that losing five to 10% of your body weight, it will improve your health. It's a marketing ploy. And here we've got this information losing just 5% of your body weight can be associated with clinically significant eating disorder. Yes, yeah. Recovery is different. When atypical anorexia patients were given the same high calorie foods in the same portions as anorexia patients, they did not recover as well. It might sound like a no brainer. GABA says Scarborough's, someone in the thing, they have a larger body size, and so we believe they need more nutrition to recover. Hmm, it's like having a, you know, maybe someone in a smaller body there like a fee at 500. And then someone in a bigger body, it's like they're a jeep, right? And then you put the same amount of fuel in both and expect them both to have the same results. And it's probably like, you know, we need we need, you know, what they're saying here is we need more fuel to recover when you're in a bigger body need more nutrition to recover? Some psychologists report that atypical anorexia is hard. It's harder to treat than anorexia because the fear of weight gain is even greater in people who have been bullied and shamed for their size. Yes. And so we have, we have stories that inter woven in this piece, I'm not done with this piece, but inter woven in this piece is stories of different people and their experiences with a typical anorexia. And basically, their experiences are, it's took a long time to be diagnosed, even if when they were diagnosed, either they weren't believed by other people, or they didn't believe it themselves, because they were so kind of entrenched in the idea that their body was bad, and they need to become thin. And then when they went to treatment, so people were sent to what do you call, I remember the name of them, but you know, treatment facilities, treatment facilities, and they were treated really badly. So they even though their their charts would say that they had a typical anorexia. They were treated as if they had binge eating disorder. Because folks associate binge eating disorder with with people with bigger bodies, and were denied foods were given less food because of their body size. And also, care was denied by insurance companies who would pull funding after a couple of weeks or not give any type of funding to go to treatment, because they have higher body weights than what you see with people with typical anorexia, which is not typical, should be called the atypical. Yeah, so anyway, so continuing on in recognition of the inconsistent care that people with atypical anorexia sometimes receive a small vanguard of professionals in the field are experimenting with ways to improve treatment for people with larger bodies. But there's only so much can they can do before butting up against systemic challenges. And the biggest one is discriminatory insurance coverage. The issue stems not only from the lack of knowledge about a relatively new diagnosis, it's also a product of how the diagnosis is named and coded, because it's labeled a typical and filed under the murky, other specified feeding or eating disorder category, it is often seen as less dangerous. It is an absurd diagnosis, says Jennifer L. Qadiani. an internist who specializes in eating disorders in Denver, and the author of sick enough a guide to the medical complications of eating disorders. There's nothing atypical about it. If there's anything atypical it's the people who get underweight. Mm hmm. Yes, Jennifer To make it easier for people to secure care, some therapists, social workers and researchers have been advocating combining atypical anorexia and anorexia by removing the requirement to have a significantly low weight from the standard anorexia diagnosis. So how a typical anorexia is treated is apparently the most effective treatment. Treatments also often involve cognitive behavioral therapy, dialectical behavior therapy and family based treatment. And psychotherapy, medication nutrition counseling. You know, the nutrition counseling, I wonder if, if when they're in a fat body, it's like, Hey, don't eat too much. You don't want to get me I'm gonna put on weight group and our family therapy and hospital hospitalization. Mm hmm. Yeah, so we hear a lot of fat folks going to treatment for needy. And being told don't, don't put on weight, recover, but don't Don't, don't, but don't go away, don't want it to be bigger than you are or, or even if they're straight size, we don't want you to get fat, like if someone is is has a low body weight. Even the staff who are trained in in eating disorders and how to treat them will put the heebie jeebies up them and say, you know, but we don't we don't want you to get above a certain way, you know. And there's not any, there's not any resources on anti fat bias, which is a huge part of fear of fatness, the real experience of living in a fat phobic world and how that is real, and really painful for folks. And so how that is a genuine fear. And also the perceptions of fatness being unhealthy and lovable and attractive, all that type of stuff. And those those being, you know, false for a lot of a lot of folks, right? Yeah. So I asked people to tell me their experiences with atypical anorexia, and I got an incredible message from a health care provider. So this is an experience from the inside. All right, so this person says in the US, I worked in an inpatient unit. And a typical anorexia wasn't a billable Insurance Code for inpatient level of care. Already, you know, that first sentence, you were not you were denied care if you had a bigger body when you had a mental health condition.

That is the most fatal mental health condition of all of them. Now, if that isn't raging fatphobia, then I don't know what is the only thing that's different body size. Okay, continuing. So providers often had to diagnose them with something else on paper to get them care. Despite that being insurance fraud. I mean, cheat the system. I don't care, but it quickly developed into fat phobia when recurring diagnosis given to fat folks with anorexia was binge eating disorder. So much stigma, and then others providers from then on would see that dx diagnosis and make all kinds of harmful assumptions. The worst is when a fat patient came in intake form said, Edie eating disorder. And the attending psychiatrist, didn't bother to do the questionnaire, and just diagnosed the person with BPD binge eating disorder, despite having blatant anorexia. And I said, Wow, thank you so much for this. I really appreciate your insight. How do you think this affected patients? And this person says one time, I remember one time a patient saw her chart and asked that it be changed. And she had to go through patients support services, which informally brands a person as, quote, non compliant, or even litigious? The attending would say, Why is she wasting so much time on this? She's just avoiding doing the real work of getting care. I'm ashamed to say that I used to think that that was some that think that was some keen psychological insight into a patient when now looking back is just a human being asked that they have some agency and lay evils that will define the quality of care they receive for the rest of their life. It's so nice to hear from someone on the inside, right to see to show that it's not kind of the perceptions of folks in there. It's, this is real, right? And people in eating disorder recovery, how often they are deeply, deeply, deeply entrenched in in anti fat bias. So I'm going to end this episode with the story from the main person in this this article. And that person is called Sharon Maxwell. So I thought I'd leave it till the end, because it's, it's kind of in pieces in that that big article, and I've kind of pieced it together into like, one code, one coherent story without kind of going back with on statistics. And also, I'm just going to be talking for like 10 minutes, I guess, you know, with her story. So if you don't want to hear Sharon story, then I mean, you can go, you're dismissed. Anytime anyway, like, I'm done with you Vinny pause. But I thought we'd end with this. And before I share, Sharon's story, which was written by the New York Times Magazine, just kind of, if you've, if you have kind of recognized, oh, maybe I have atypical anorexia, or maybe I used to, or, or I'm struggling with any type of eating disorder, I just want to say that you are important, your care is important, your mental well being is important, and you deserve to be supported in recovering from an eating disorder. And there are resources out there, there is an increasing drive to have good quality, weight neutral care. However, that is not the standard. And so sending you all the love and fatty hugs, and I encourage you to Google, you know, in your local area, what could be helpful, helpful for you. And, you know, go check out the links in the bio for the New York Times story, because, you know, that might be there's more stuff in there than what we've talked about today. So that that might be helpful for you. And there are other people there, who also have experienced atypical anorexia, and it might be helpful for you to go follow them on social media. And I know at least one of them has a podcast where they talk about this stuff. So that could be helpful too. So I hope you're able to reach out and even if it's just someone you're in your life and tell them that you need help, because I bet they would love to be able to help in any way that's possible. Alright, so let's talk this to Sharon Maxwell story, so I'm just going to be talking and sharing her story. Sharon Maxwell spent much of her life trying to make herself small. A family put her on her first diet when she was 10. Early on Saturday mornings, she and her mother would drive through the empty suburban streets of Hammond ind. In Indianapolis, Indiana. In an effort to attend Weight Watchers meetings. Maxwell did her best at that stage to track her meals and lock her points, but the scale wasn't going down fast enough. So she decided to barely eat anything on Fridays and take laxatives that she found in the medicine cabinet. Food had long been a fraught subject in the Maxwell household. Her parents are also bigger bodied, and dieted frequently. They belonged to a fundamentalist Baptist mega church where gluttony was seen as a sin to eat at home was to navigate a labyrinth of rules and restrictions. Maxwell watched one time as her mother lost 74 pounds in six months by consuming little more than carrot juice. Her skin temporarily turned orange. Sometimes her father sees by a new diet idea abruptly ransacked shelves on in the kitchen sweeping newly forbidden foods into the trash. Maxwell was constantly worried about eating too much. She started to eat alone and in secret, she took two chewing morsels and spitting them out. She hid food behind books in her pockets under mattresses and in between clothes folded neatly in drawers. Through Maxwell's eating it through Mac through Maxwell's teenage years and early 20s Eating became even more stressful. Her thoughts constantly orbited around food, what she was eating or not eating the calories she was burning or not burning the size of her body and especially what people thought of it. her prayer appearance was often a topic of public interest. When she went grocery shopping for her family other customers commented on the items in her cart. Honey, are you sure you want to eat that? One person said other shoppers offered unsolicited advice about diets. Strangers congratulated her when her cart was filled with vegetables. As she grew older, people at the gym clapped and cheered for her while she worked out. People would say go you you can lose her weight. She says. While eating and public other diners offered feedback and they still do to this day on her choices. A few even asking if she wanted to join their gym. Some would call her name's pig fatty. Sometimes people told her she was brave for wearing shorts, while others said she should cover up. She was always aware whether she wanted to be or not of how others viewed her body. Maxwell tried just about every day she could find juice cleanses Atkins Slim Fast South Beach Mediterranean whole 30 zekiel, a regimen regimen based on biblical references. She tried being vegetarian and Vigo at vegan and paleo. She tried consuming less than 500 calories a day and taking HCG fertility hormone rumored to suppress appetite but flagged by the FDA as risky and unproven for weight loss. During periods of religious fasting at her church, she would take the practice to an extreme consuming nothing but water for days. And on one occasion, two weeks. I passed out a few times, but I did it she says sometimes she exercise more than three hours a day in high intensity interval training sessions and kickboxing classes. Eventually she started vomiting up her food. Every day Maxwell stepped on the scale and internalize a number as a reflection of her self worth. Often the number on the scale went down. But if she let up on her rigid food, food rules, even briefly the numbers shot back up like a coiled spring. I just cycled through that she says but it became harder and harder each time to get the weight off.

During the many years of dieting and deprivation Maxwell experienced mysterious health problems for a decade starting when she was 16. She almost never had her period. She was always cold, and she often had dizzy spells and occasionally passed out in class. When she was in college, she fainted three times in one day and was taken to the emergency room. For an appointment with an endocrinologist one year, Maxwell took a purse full of small plastic bags. Each one contained a day's worth of hair clumps that accumulate accumulated in her brush or had fallen in the shower drain. Her head was popped with board spots. The doctor was pleased with her weight loss and to her memory didn't seem too concerned about her other symptoms. Anything that makes the scale don't go down. Maxwell says I was given a pat on the back. Four years ago at the age of 25, Maxwell walked into her primary care doctor's office near Scottsdale, Arizona, where she lived and worked as a middle school teacher. She was there for an annual physical and she was prepared to be told to lose weight. And she had almost always been instructed. But this time the doctor an osteopath started asking unusual questions. Maxwell's blood work showed abnormally low iron and electrolyte levels. The doctor asked Maxwell what was she eating and what was she doing in relationship to food? Was she starving herself or she vomiting on purpose? Maxwell was surprised by this line of questioning. These are things I had heard in my whole life from my family, my friends, doctors. She says the Osteopath pa told her. She thought Maxwell had an eating disorder and suggested arranging treatment right away. Maxwell would later be diagnosed with atypical anorexia nervosa, and increasingly common yet little known eating disorder that shares all the same symptoms as anorexia nervosa, except for extreme thinness just as many people and possibly many more suffer from atypical anorexia. At the physical Maxwell Maxwell stared at her daughter in disbelief. She always thought that eating disorders were for skinny people. I laughed. She says, I don't use language like this any longer. But I told her she was crazy. I told her. No, I have a self control problem. It took Maxwell a long time to process that she had an eating disorder she had seen so she had been so steeped in the Gospel of dieting, that it was hard to accept that risk stretching her food was not unequivocally healthy. But her doctor instructed. She began making visits to the hospital for intravenous fluids and started taking iron supplements. At night she began attending outpatient sessions at the liberation center, and now shuttered facility in Phoenix where she ate dinner with other clients and attended group therapy. The staff at liberation told her she needed more intensive treatment and recommended attending a residential program. In the summer of 2018, after teaching through the rest of the school year, Maxwell agreed to go to a center in Monterey, Monterey, California, California, that was covered by her insurance. A day after she arrived However, her insurance rescinded approval. Because of her weight, the company didn't believe she was sick enough to meet the criteria for residential care for eating disorders. She was at once ashamed and incensed her art drove her five hours to pick her up, and she spent much of the next 10 days on the phone with the insurance company. Her assure insurance eventually authorized her to go to another facility, the Center for discovery Rancho Palos Palos Verdes, which sits on the Southern California coast. Maxwell's three month stay would consist of group meals, outings to restaurants, to practice dining and public settings, yoga and therapy. I went with the expectation that as soon as I walked in the door, they would be the people who would help me finally become thin once and for all she says. Instead, on her first day, a dietitian at the center explained that she would need to eat three balanced meals and three snacks a day to recover. Her treatment plan also required that she abstained from almost all forms of exercise, so her system could recalibrate. Maxwell panicked, she had never consistently eaten that much in her entire adult life. And she still felt that her body was a problem to be fixed. Maxwell already harbored a deep mistrust of the mental health profession. When she was growing up. She remembers a pastor at her church preaching that psychiatry was the work of the devil. The message seemed to be that anxiety was sinful, a sign of faithlessness Maxwell had left the church two years earlier, but its lessons were still large deeply in her mind. She couldn't abandon her long held belief, one that her doctors reinforced for much of her life. That thinness was the primary measure of health. Maxwell forced herself to go along with each step of the treatment program. She tried to eat three meals and three snacks a day, even though it caused her excruciating fear. For years, her thinking have revolved tightly around food and exercise and during twice weekly individual therapy sessions, and daily group therapy, she tried to learn how to redirect those thoughts. She started to talk about the self judgment, shame and childhood trauma that led to rigid behaviors, and an over reliance on control both central features of restricted eating disorders. After about five or six weeks into treatment, it dawned on her just how much damage she had done to herself. Her esophagus burned from years of purging. She experienced heart palpitations and was often dizzy from or foot orthostatic hypotension, a type of lower blood pressure that leads to dizziness and fainting. And her hair and nails were thin and brittle from malnutrition. I started to realize Holy shit, this is real. She says, I started to see what it had done to my body the magnitude of it. Over the ensuing ensuing weeks, Maxol began eating enough food that the staff allowed her to go on walks and swim, not around calories, but as a part of learning how to live a balanced life. Her physical symptoms started to ease her vital signs and bloodwork improved. She felt less Dizzy a heartbeat more regular. She got her period back for the first time in a decade and perhaps more surprisingly, she was not gaining weight despite eating more food. I think that's a bit of a fat phobic line. To help her overcome her self judgment, a nurse suggested that she look in the mirror and express what she liked about her body. At first, Maxwell couldn't think of what to say. She could hardly make eye contact with her own reflection. But eventually she thought of something. I'm grateful for my curly hair, she said, looking in looking at the nurse in the mirror.

After she left the Center for discovery, and moved to South Carolina Maxwell started a partial hospitalization program at the eating discovery eating recovery descent center in Greenville. She immediately began noticing how her size was affecting the quality of her treatment. When she arrived a staff member member put her in her room and told her to wait. While the people with quote normal eating disorders gathered next door. Her words felt like a gut punch. At lunch she was told to sit by herself at the back of the dining room, while the other clients sat together with their backs to her. I was like, I can't sit with them. She says the center had mistaken her diagnosis for binge eating disorder, and had a policy of separating those clients from the others. Sometimes staff members singled her out and had her eat less than small bodied patients. At a group therapy session in which she was the only large person in the room. Another patient shared that she would rather die than be fat, her literally expressing spirit expressing that while I'm in the room, that to be me to live in this body that I have to recover in would be worse than anything. It's just ostracising Maxwell says the eating Recovery Center does not comment on individual patients experiences but since 2021, it says it has made efforts to counteract weight stigma in its treatment centers in late 2018. Maxwell decided to be more open about her eating disorder with friends and family and started posting about it on Instagram. Over the years she's included photographs of her younger self and shared memories of her decades long journey. Sometimes it felt brazen and edgy, but also good. I am fat and I have anorexia. She wrote in a 2020 post, and I don't have to explain my body to you these days. Maxwell's inner landscape is very different than it once was on a Sunday sun on a sat on a sunny Saturday afternoon in may not far from where she lives in San Diego. She did something that would have brought her waves of anxiety in the past. She went to the beach. Amid the tiny jangle of an ice cream truck she truck she unfurled her towel and sat down. Before she started her recovery. She would have spent her time at the beach worried about what she was wearing or not wearing, what she had eaten or would eat later and what other people were thinking or not thinking about her body, followed by this tangle of thoughts she would miss the experience. Now she doesn't give those things much thought. on that Saturday, she watched her dogs zoom around the sand and laugh with a couple of friends. Her mind was not floating above her body disassociated. Maxwell is choosing to recover as fully as she can, but it's not easy. After 19 years of going undiagnosed. She still suffers from some of the physical, mental and social costs of anorexia. Doctors are monitoring her recovery from Long QT syndrome and electrical issue with the heart that can turn into potential fatal arrhythmia. Long QT syndrome is a rare side effect of anorexia. She also has an annual endoscopy endoscopy to assess the slow healing from her damaged esophagus from years of vomiting. She has incurred mountains of debt from months of treatment. She checks in with a doctor and a therapist regularly and takes photos of her meals to a dietitian. As proof that she's eating three meals a day a standard in recovery. She attends an eating disorder support group even though she has rarely seen another larger bodied person there. She also has started to cook for herself. But to be a larger person in this world is to be constantly reminded her are reminded of how other people view your body. When she posts about recovery and fat positivity on Instagram or Tiktok whether it's theatrically smashing her scale with a baseball bat, or performing slam poetry in her car, a flurry of trolls rise from the backwaters of the Internet to riddle her feed with insults and death threats. You need a sign that says beware of pig one commenter wrote, moo moo goes a cow route another who created a handle at Sharon Maxwell Hayter expressly to bully her. Society pities you because you're eating yourself to into an early grave, and other wrote. But Maxwell has also received direct messages from people who have struggled in similar ways they have never admitted to themselves, let alone to their family or friends how much they are suffering. I just wanted to say that I am a fat person with an eating disorder who isn't yet in recovery but trying one route. Every day I have these crazy disordered thoughts and get into a spiral of how I'm not valid valid enough for recovery. The content has been absolutely pivotal for me, and I'm so happy that you exist. Many people with anorexia describe the illness as a battle between two selves. One is a maniacal super ego hell burned on control at all costs, in a misguided attempt to find safety in imposes preferred prefer perfectionistic rules and restrictions in Sisyphean pursuit of unreachable ideal. Some fear it is intent on self destruction. This self which much Well Matt So of course a conceptualized self enforces all the expectations of one's upbringing in the culture at large and sees the world in lifeless tones of black and white like an OLED TV. The second is what Maxwell calls the authentic self. For her. It's a self that spontaneously breaks into impromptu dance moves and wears T shirts that read, don't be a butthole to yourself and therapy is cool. This self has a passion for gold glitter and animal print and signs up for rec basketball team on a whim, something that she would never have never have allowed herself to do before. She can eat strawberries or a sandwich or an ice cream cone in public. This self is no longer concerned with being quiet and obedient or apologizing for her existence. And perhaps most important, she has no interest in making herself small. He and so you can go follow Sharon Maxwell, on Instagram on Tik Tok. There'll be links in the bio of the show. A reminder of where you can find that is first party.com forward slash 149. If you ever forget what episode you want to find, you can always go first viking.com forward slash podcast and then all of the episodes will be there the most recent at the top. Yeah, so that's atypical anorexia. Thanks for hanging out with me today. And a reminder if you're interested in going on vacation with me, go check out the information on that in the show notes and I will see you for the next episode at face value podcast. Stay fierce, fatty.

EP148 Transcript

Y'all listen to the Fierce Fatty Podcast, episode 148. The biggest scammers in the weight loss industry. Let's do it.

Hey, fatties, welcome to this episode. So glad you're here. I think this episode is probably the one that has taken me the longest ever to research. Frustrated, frustrated without like, it took me.

Like, many, many hours. I was like, Oh, this would be a nice quick thing to do. Maybe not.

I was going to record the podcast early today it is now 10 to five I was like, well, I'll just quickly get it out at like 10am New had more research to do. So there are a number of links for for this that you'll find in the show notes for everything that I'm talking about, which is facebook.com forward slash 148. If you want to donate to the podcast, because there's no adverts, there's never been adverts. So my goodness. And if you'd like it without adverts then feel free to go over to PayPal, PayPal, and it's just first fatty if you want to send a donation over and if you don't, that's fine as well.

There's actually a four part documentary series, which was the thing that inspired me and the documentary series. I'd watched it years ago, and I was just reminded of it it's called the men who made us thin. It's a British production. And it goes through, it's kind of it's almost it's half there being fat positive, but not, not really. There's a lot of mentions of the Oh words. And the presenter is kind of focusing on how it's bad to it's bad to say that everyone is fat, because people like him, who were only ever so slightly fat aren't unhealthy. But it's kind of like the way that he talks about fat fat people is like, well, of course they deserve all this barbaric treatment. But it's the ones that are like me, that's the kind of gist of of this person, the reporter so I mean, and then there's lots of good, there's lots of good, good kind of like, you're like, yes, you're talking about this amazing. And then they go and talk about like McDonald's, I was like for fuck sake, don't direct. So watch that with caution. There's links to watch all four parts. It's on daily motion. So you can watch them for free. If you are so inspired. It's four hours.

And yeah, so but from that, and from other research, I was like, You know what, there's some really key kind of the biggest scammers and I thought it'd be nice, nice, lol, enraging to put the list together of maybe who's benefited the most from diet culture, weight loss, all that type of stuff. And like, I think, you know, it would be great if this is all in recent recent recent ish history in the last 200 years. I would love if I have more time and another episode to do maybe older history.

Because here we're going back to I mean, the earliest is we're talking about 1830. But really the biggest scammers in the weight loss industry is white, white colonizers. Right? And I'm wondering if there are more kind of solid. This person was the one that did this in regards to and I know what we've spoken about it before on the show in regards to perpetuating the ideas of of thinness and whiteness and fatness and blackness being linked and you know, to be attractive, you need to be thin, aka white.

And I think that's basically the biggest scam is in the weight loss industry is is what whiteness, basically whiteness, right?

But this is more kind of recent history and what some rolls abroad is everyone on this list is white.

Yeah. So but I think all of this that we're talking about today we cannot get away from the systems that are at play here of, of anti black racism of ableism of colonization, sexism, etc, etc etc right and the the big thing being anti black racism that mean that this type of stuff perpetuates and has for hundreds of years now. But anyway, saying all that, but keep that in mind I want you to actually like pick out individuals versus versus systems of oppression, right and so like the people who have really benefited the most from this bullshit, and we're going to start off with we spoken about him before a Dolphy quitter let in 1832. So he was the fella. He was a fella who invented the BMI, although it wasn't called the BMI at that time. So he was an astronomer, mathematician, statistician, and sociologist, who created the idea of the ideal man. So he used the words long Moya, which is actually

average man, but when he was talking about average, he didn't mean average as in mediocre, he was more like average as in the best, right. And so he was prolific in doing a lot of research, and was really interested in finding out about what the average man was. And he said, If the this is a quote from Quizlet, if the average man were completely determined, we might consider him as a type of perfection, and everything differing from his proportion or condition would constitute deformity or disease, or monstrosity.

Unknown Speaker 7:15

So he's saying that those who are outside what is the ideal are diseased and monstrous or deformed. So he created the quitter let in quite ALEKS index, later renamed the BMI by measuring white European men their height and their weight and coming up with an arbitrary equation to calculate averages. And the reason people people like the BMI is because it's so simple, right? And that's the reason why it's so fucked up, you know, apart, aside from the fact that it's is bullshit is, you know, it's the, the idea that we're, you know, it's very simple. It's very simple, and it's very easy to say, it's people who fall outside of this are not ideal. And lo and behold, he did an all of his studies on on white men, European white men, and he actually his work actually constitute contributed to the creation of phrenology, which is a racist pseudoscience, which uses the human skull to falsely determine cultural and intellectual superior superiority of white people. So you know, like, you might see those, if you're not familiar with that, see those skulls and it'll have like, little, you know, oh, look, let's measure the length between the nose and the eyes. And let's look at this bony part here. And our turns out that white people are superior Surprise, surprise.

Unknown Speaker 8:50

Yeah, so his work really influenced a lot of eugenicist pseudoscience

Unknown Speaker 8:59

because it's the measuring of humans, right. And also grouping humans and races and, and so he benefited greatly because he was seen as an expert in the field. He had many different positions.

Unknown Speaker 9:18

Yeah, and basically, that, you know, that he did say, we don't want to use the quick lead index to measure health, we want to measure the ideal person, and he talked about beauty and things like that as well. Right. So that was 1832. So let's fast forward

Unknown Speaker 9:40

to 1972. So do you remember the name Ancel Keys, so add some keys in we've spoken about on the podcast before. He was famous for running the Minnesota starvation experience experiment, if you want to go into that and one

Unknown Speaker 10:00

Learn more about the Minnesota starvation experiment. Go to Episode Oh, I think it's 92. It's called the psychology of hunger.

Unknown Speaker 10:09

And in this study, he had a bunch of consequences a conscientiously objectors. This was in 1944.

Unknown Speaker 10:19

He had a bunch of them. And there was a lot of kind of shame around being a not being at war. And he wanted to see how to refeed people

Unknown Speaker 10:32

in war torn places. And so he did this study where he quote, starved, it was starvation experiment, and, and then referred the volunteers Guess how many calories they were on

Unknown Speaker 10:46

1800 calories a day.

Unknown Speaker 10:49

And in the study, which is unreasonable, I'm pointing that out is because that would be seen as a generous diet, you know, calorie amount on a diet, right, but, but the men in this study had terrible side effects, even when so they, when they were, they had a control time where they were fed, I think, 3600 calories for a few months. And then they did this for, I think,

Unknown Speaker 11:18

three, six months and go to the episode, it tells you more, episode nine to three to six months where they were doing the 1800 calories, and then they had another three months where they would refeeding back at the 3000 Plus calories.

Unknown Speaker 11:32

And during the time that they were in the starvation period, they just they basically had a really tough time. And then it didn't end when it was the refeeding time.

Unknown Speaker 11:46

The the effects were were really, really long term on these men. One man chopped off three of his fingers.

Unknown Speaker 11:56

One man had to be hostile but hospitalized well after the study because he couldn't stop eating, because he was he had developed but but develop developed BDD binge eating disorder. So later on, and so he had that knowledge from 1944. Five years later, he published a study, he used that information earlier to help with the war efforts to help people when they were coming across people who were who were starved.

Unknown Speaker 12:22

So that was 1944. And then, in 1972, he did a study where he popularized the use of Quickflix original index and renamed it the body mass index, again, made the same mistakes, steak is quite a lot using data from predominantly white men. And that study that he did, the National Institutes of Health then popularized the use of the body mass index as a way of establishing health.

Unknown Speaker 13:00

So what what really gets on my flaps about Ancel Keys is he saw the, the damage that starving people did to them, and, you know, starving them on still, you know, what would be now considered, you know, a sensible diet, right? And he saw what happened, and instead of championing work in regards to not prescribing diets, he went on to create the Mediterranean diets. So it's like, he was so close, he was so close.

Unknown Speaker 13:42

You know, his work was, you know, obviously, there was there was good work there. And he did, you know, very, very helpful things for for many people, but

Unknown Speaker 13:52

it's like he could have, it feels like he didn't put two and two together. You know, and and he just couldn't get out of that fatness was something bad.

Unknown Speaker 14:05

Yeah, and so him and his wife released a number of diet books later in the years. So that was Ancel Keys.

Unknown Speaker 14:13

Okay, so I don't know why I went straight to now selkies in 1974, because actually, we're gonna go to 1940 So let's go back in time, let's get back in time. So Louis, Dublin was the chief statistician for maternity Metropolitan Life Insurance Company and now was the biggest insurance company in the world at the time. So this fella Louie Dublin arbitrarily drew up a chart of the weight. Height

Unknown Speaker 14:46

of, of people who bought his insurance their insurance Met Life Insurance, and included frame size.

Unknown Speaker 14:55

small medium large, what Burfoot frame size

Unknown Speaker 15:00

means what what

Unknown Speaker 15:02

friends is like a human beings a tense leg. So he got people's heights weights and frame size, and concluded that the people of a certain size lived longer. But using only data from people who were 25 to 30 years old.

Unknown Speaker 15:22

And data which was self reported.

Unknown Speaker 15:28

Data from people who were rich enough to afford

Unknown Speaker 15:32

life insurance, that's going to be a lot of white people seeing a theme here, the theme here, female, a perfect white body.

Unknown Speaker 15:41

And so this this, you know, the chart that he drew up was not based on on evidence or any scientific study.

Unknown Speaker 15:49

He made the weight, which someone is considered too heavy, much lower than what it was originally. So previously, just a small percentage of the population, it'd be like, you know, how, you know, the doctor might say, Oh, your kids in the 95th percentile for height, and you know, that most of the kids are shorter than your kid, right? So that before, you know, the people who were the highest weight people, but like those were the people who had the biggest bodies, right? Were or were considered too big. So he changed it so that suddenly overnight, and you'll see this is happened a lot of times before when I say a lot of times, or two more times, this has happened big overnight changes to BMI, and what is classed as too big, suddenly, going from a small percentage of people who were considered too fat to half of the American population was reclassified as too fat. So with the stroke of a pen, he was Angel able to change people, people's premiums and charge people's premiums, increase the premiums due to their body size and establish that their bodies were wrong. I mean, I gotta give it to them, you know, for capitalists, you did it right. And his ideas were adopted by the medical establishment and then by the US government, and Louis Dublin's ideas contributed to the toward the creation of the modern diet industry and has had a massive cultural impact.

Unknown Speaker 17:26

Him doing this as lead doctors telling people in droves to lose weight. And people at the time in the 40s and 50s, rushed to pharmacies in panic, a huge market of consumers, consumers were convinced that they were too fat. And corporate America realized to sell the impossible dream of fineness, they could make an imaginable profits. So corporate America was like licking its lips. And I guess he you know, Louis W. Mills from corporate America, right, you know, was one of their folks was like, Hey, everybody. Yeah, you're too fat. You're too ugly. You're too this. You're too you know, you know, taking on the fat thing. Oh, don't worry, we've got the cure. Right, we've got the cure.

Unknown Speaker 18:18

So that was in the 1940s.

Unknown Speaker 18:21

Let's move to 1950.

Unknown Speaker 18:25

John Mayer.

Unknown Speaker 18:28

So John Mayer.

Unknown Speaker 18:33

So this guy is the person to come up with the idea that physical activity will help you lose weight.

Unknown Speaker 18:46

He was a French American scientist. And he established the popular notion that

Unknown Speaker 18:54

physical activity would help you lose weight. With this really incredibly poor quality observational study he completed on a handful of children.

Unknown Speaker 19:07

So he went to a summer camp, he looked at a group of girls, some of them were fat, some of them weren't fat. He noticed in that group of girls, one was a cheerleader. One was a ballet dancer. And on the whole, the smaller girls did more physical activity than the bigger girls. They didn't just look go into some camp and just have another look around. Right? And from that, he was like, ah, ha, I know why I know the mechanisms. Clearly. The people who are bigger or bigger because they don't do physical activity, and there was

Unknown Speaker 19:41

nothing popped up into his head to say,

Unknown Speaker 19:45

Could anything else be going on here? Could it be that the fat kids are shamed when they do when they do physical activity, and so they'd rather do other things? Could it be that

Unknown Speaker 19:57

having a bigger body

Unknown Speaker 20:00

Who came first and not wanting to engage in physical activity came second, could it be that the physical activities that were on offer at the camp that weekend didn't tickle their fancy? And they were more into rugby and archery? And that was all next weekend? You know? Could it be that they came from poor families who couldn't afford to send them to ballet classes, and buy them cheerleading outfits? And could they even fit into the cheerleading outfits? Because they only came in small sizes, you know, like,

Unknown Speaker 20:31

investigation here, John Mayer, but no, he was like, ah, ha, you're Rica, I've got it. And, you know, weight loss.

Unknown Speaker 20:44

Weight loss is easy to achieve temporarily through reducing your, what you eat, right? Weight loss from moving your body, really, really hard to achieve. It's just not doable. You know, weight loss from from physical exercise exercise, even though exercise can be something that's really health promoting for some people, not for everyone.

Unknown Speaker 21:12

It can be helpful, but it's not helpful to for people to lose weight. It's just not there's no, there's no

Unknown Speaker 21:20

evidence. And I mean, John, here was the first one to say it with his really shit study.

Unknown Speaker 21:29

You know, no matter how much you exercise, the calorie burning effects are limited by your metabolism. So Maya was incredibly ambitious and was zealous in spreading his faulty science to the US. He became an advisor to three presidents. And his ideas were published in numerous newspaper columns. His influence was such that it became public policy, and so did the deep flaws in his logic.

Unknown Speaker 21:56

And like to us now, it's like, well, of course, if you exercise you'll lose weight, right? Like it seems so logical, but you know, these ideas are not backed by science.

Unknown Speaker 22:08

So in 1954, we have a je Cremin. AJ Cremin was the first weight loss surgery doctor, and he was the first one to perform a gastric bypass Cremin and his team connected a patient's upper and lower intestines. It caused numerous medical problems such as uncontrollable diarrhea in patients, as well as other things. And we can you imagine, I mean, no weight loss surgery now is fucking horrendous. Never mind in 1954, the first weight loss patients and why did

Unknown Speaker 22:51

Ajay Cremin? Like, what?

Unknown Speaker 22:54

Where did this come from? Right? Like, where did this come from? Why did he why was he doing this? Right. And obviously 1954 this was happening because of diet culture of fat phobia. And because clearly, diets weren't working, we didn't have the we wouldn't have the need for weight loss surgery if diets worked. And so in 1954 people were resorting to which was then a very, very, you know, new and dangerous with no no understanding of long term effects surgery in order to become smaller, which leads me to believe you know, that's a that's a difficult decision. Right? And so it leads me to believe that they had done lots of things to try and lose weight before doing this right.

Unknown Speaker 23:48

So then, we had in 1959, metric cow, which was a brand of

Unknown Speaker 23:57

this milkshake, which was said to look like baby formula for weight control. And it was the first mass market diet product launch. So MetroCard and it came in like a can that you opened with a tin can opener and I watched a, an advert from them, and their ad weren't and the advert went, one out of two adults is overweight.

Unknown Speaker 24:21

One or two adults is overweight. Hmm, where is that from? Oh, remember, Mr. Dublin, Louis Dublin of MetLife, who classified 50% of the US population as to fat. And here we go. 1959 We've got adverts foot for it. One out of two adults is overweight. And because overweight not only detracts from appearance, it also impairs health and shortens life, you should lose weight. I mean, where is this information coming from impairs health and shortens life is coming from that insurance company.

Unknown Speaker 24:56

So you were to drink the product instead of meals?

Unknown Speaker 25:00

So it's the first meal replacement thing and they use that Dublin's fought flawed districts to persuade people to buy their product that convince more people that they had a problem through TV and magazine adverts, so that they can sell them the solution. Right? So Louis had said, we've got a problem. And advertisers would like more yawns. Thank you licking their lips, we've got the solution. So advertisers positioned it as something fun to drink a way of life. And so they've got an advert where it's like, having a cocktail party, they want a cocktail party, and you're there with your friends who were all thin and you're thin as the star of the advert. And you were like laughing drinking this fucking rank metric cow. Because especially like the shakes in early days were really bad tasting.

Unknown Speaker 25:54

And yeah, and so they make made it into the scene, this like really cool and social thing.

Unknown Speaker 26:01

And they made it. It was presented as a really aspirational way of life, and the matric how ads were huge successes, and they ran for years.

Unknown Speaker 26:12

And soon metric, hell had hundreds of imitators because consumers failures that getting thin was a recipe for business success. And by the early 1970s, diet, companies were turning over millions of dollars. And as the market became more competitive,

Unknown Speaker 26:34

it also became more extreme.

Unknown Speaker 26:38

So

Unknown Speaker 26:41

with the idea that weight loss came from also working out, we had the rise of in the 1970s. People like Richard Simmons, and he was the first person to make serious money by talking about exercise and weight loss. And so the Richard Simmons show was seen in 200 markets by over 5 million people five days a week. He had a best selling book saying Never say diets and his own gym and ran weight loss cruises where people shouted farewell to fat. He claims to have helped humanity lose 3 million pounds of fat with no evidence to support this claim. And he made his success by exploiting fat people exploiting

Unknown Speaker 27:35

people who are vulnerable. And a lot of people are like, Oh, Richard Simmons is so nice. He was He always wants to help people. And he could have like, you know, absolutely, he could have genuinely wanted to help people. But I mean, he had made his success over

Unknown Speaker 27:53

a method that doesn't work, which isn't science based.

Unknown Speaker 27:57

And

Unknown Speaker 28:00

and he was a raging fat phobe.

Unknown Speaker 28:04

And he used fat people in order to continue to be successful.

Unknown Speaker 28:11

So I mean, it leaves a bad taste in my mouth.

Unknown Speaker 28:17

All right, so in 1977, we had the last chance diet by Robert Lin, a revolutionary new approach to weight loss, oh my goodness, in 1977 they cracked it.

Unknown Speaker 28:37

So the claim was people will lose up to 100 pounds by using it instead of food.

Unknown Speaker 28:45

And it was a high protein drink. So kind of like Metro cow, but they they're going balls to the walls now with you know, making it

Unknown Speaker 28:58

as nothingness in it as possible. So it was high protein and lacking essential nutrients and vitamins.

Unknown Speaker 29:06

So it began to be linked to serious health problems and death. This frickin drink.

Unknown Speaker 29:14

So the inventor of the diet, Dr. Robert Lin denied any wrongdoing, and the FDA eventually banned it. The industry responded by adding vitamins to meal replacement drinks and people just carried on buying them. The most popular of this tweaked version was SlimFast. So Dr. Robert Lin, he was like hey, I'm just gonna here's a drink with protein and I'm a doctor. I'm a doctor. I know what I'm talking about it so it was just protein. people died because they would they they they they couldn't humans can't survive just on this drink. Right there was no there was no nutrients and there's no vitamins, and it was seriously lacking nutrients. And the guy was just like

Unknown Speaker 30:00

When when FDA banned it, he was like Lola Lola fingers in is nothing wrong with it. I'm a doctor.

Unknown Speaker 30:07

Yeah, so slim fast. The natural way to lose weight was invented in 1977. That's when the FDA banned this drink. So he actually started the drink a little bit earlier than 1977. And so it was invented in 1977 by New York businessman Daniel Abraham. And so his strategy was to sell SlimFast cheaper and make it tastier than his medicinal tasting rivals, the SlimFast plan was sold as a natural and healthy way to lose weight. And so it's the same thing, meal replacement shakes, and then they also created fourth food products. And Daniel Abraham.

Unknown Speaker 30:52

At that time, I think individually, still is the most successful diet billionaire that has ever lived. He sold the company to Unilever in 2000 for $2.3 billion.

Unknown Speaker 31:09

He also created DEXA trim, which was a diet supplement, which increased the risk of hemorrhagic stroke alongside other nasty side effects. So he was in it for you know, getting getting the money out of the fatties. And when you hear him talking about, you know, watching an interview with him, he, you know, really has contempt for for fat folks.

Unknown Speaker 31:40

Yeah, so he has made some some money, a lot of money 2.3 billion off the backs of fatties.

Unknown Speaker 31:50

Okay, so

Unknown Speaker 31:53

going back in time again to 1963 I thought I had these in these in time order. Apparently I didn't.

Unknown Speaker 32:00

The Atkins diet. So the so the Atkins Atkins

Unknown Speaker 32:07

as in a keto diet, so it's a Keto ketogenic keto

Unknown Speaker 32:13

that was invented, like in the 1950s 10, something around there. And actually, it wasn't a diet for weight loss. It was a diet for for children with epilepsy, right. And so for a long time, it was just a used as a diet for children with epilepsy. And it still is today, because it's effective as something

Unknown Speaker 32:39

for pay for children with epilepsy, epilepsy, right. And so in 1963, Robert Atkins came along. And he didn't like diets that met drinking real meal replacements or counting calories. And so he decided he could lose weight just by cutting out carbs, and using this keto diet.

Unknown Speaker 33:01

And this was based on a false idea that certain food types are responsible for weight gain. So his book a diet revolution, so hundreds and 1000s of copies a week, and he was the first international diet guru. And despite the criticisms over the next 40 years, he built an empire with a range of low carb foods. So there's no evidence to show that the use of the Atkins diet or his products results in long term weight loss or improved health. Unless you're a child with epilepsy, then you could just do any type of keto diet if that was you don't need to do Atkins. So you know, there was a big hoo ha about oh, X, Atkins died because he had a heart attack or something. I was looking into this. And actually he he died. So this is what happened. This, this is what I've seen.

Unknown Speaker 33:57

There's an icy sidewalk in New York, he's fell slipped his head, I think he went into a coma then died. But then

Unknown Speaker 34:06

there there was leaked medical records, his wife refused to let them do an autopsy. Apparently, this is all apparently leaked autopsy records to say that he had problems with his heart. But then other people came and said, Actually, it was just some type of minor thing. And he was I think he was in his 70s. So it was not that scandalous. But some people are like, Aha, here's proof that the Atkins diet didn't work because the Atkins founder died of coronary heart coronary heart disease.

Unknown Speaker 34:42

And he was so fat when he died. He like they mentioned that how many pounds he was he wasn't he wasn't he wasn't so bad when he died. I think he was just like an average weight of a man you know?

Unknown Speaker 34:55

But they were like, Haha, this shows that this diet doesn't work well. I mean,

Unknown Speaker 35:04

It isn't one man. Right? You can't say our diet doesn't work because he might have died from a heart condition. Who knows? Right, but, I mean, that's what really, is this diet gonna make people thin? Because that is what are people going on diets for is thin increased health improved health for whatever. And there is no, there is no evidence right. And you know he was going to die it eventually he lived to 70 Plus, I mean, which is I think slightly less than the average but I mean,

Unknown Speaker 35:43

is this black and white thinking that I'm like, I don't like this black and white thinking of haha, see, you know, we don't know what else is going on in his life. And I mean, he's fell and slipped and we might have fell because he had a heart attack. Who knows? We don't know. Right? And even if he did

Unknown Speaker 35:58

us fat positive people are not judging people.

Unknown Speaker 36:03

In that way anyway, so.

Unknown Speaker 36:06

So that's the scandal. Yeah. I don't know what to make about it.

Unknown Speaker 36:12

Either way, Atkins doesn't make you thin.

Unknown Speaker 36:15

And he got very rich and became a international diet group guru on the back that it will make you them.

Unknown Speaker 36:24

So Jean NIDA rich, the founder of Weight Watchers.

Unknown Speaker 36:31

So she is frog.

Unknown Speaker 36:35

She was this is in the 1960s Right. So Jean began giving talks to housewives who wanted to slim after she had lost weight herself. She then decided to franchise a business by having copycat genes all over the world giving speeches to groups of people and charging for the privilege. In 1967, during the time of Twiggy thinness being in Weight Watchers came to the UK, the head of the UK operations Bernice Weston.

Unknown Speaker 37:09

She is a giant bellend said you can go and watch it Episode One

Unknown Speaker 37:16

quote when it comes to eating fat people are basically very stupid.

Unknown Speaker 37:23

Thanks, bunnies.

Unknown Speaker 37:25

You can submit it's

Unknown Speaker 37:28

so Weight Watchers owns to statistics and quote, evidence of success has shown that their lifestyle change is not effective. It's not effective, and only a tiny percentage of people maintaining weight loss past five years. So Weight Watchers trance was transformed into a small domestic business into a global super brand under the financial direction of Richard Sambre, who worked there for 25 years. And he said

Unknown Speaker 37:59

okay, so this is the finance

Unknown Speaker 38:02

director of Weight Watchers for 25 years, he said Weight Watchers is successful because those who fail have to come back and do it again. That's where your business comes from.

Unknown Speaker 38:15

So he was quite happily talking to the to the journalist saying yeah, I mean, that's our business is repeat customers.

Unknown Speaker 38:25

weightwatchers chief scientific officer said she was really mad that he said that she was like, well, he doesn't know anything. He's not here anymore. So I think he I don't like it. Basically, she was mad. But then she said there's a reason that we've been here for 60 years is because people come back to us time and time again.

Unknown Speaker 38:50

Oh,

Unknown Speaker 38:53

really? Like why are you bragging about that? Ah, Weight Watchers is a revenue of $1 billion a year. Today, Weight Watchers is based in the very building where Louis Dublin from MetLife insurance company paved the way for the diet industry all those years ago.

Unknown Speaker 39:14

Okay, so let's move to the 1990s. And

Unknown Speaker 39:25

you've got an honorable mention here for a

Unknown Speaker 39:28

normal person but a pill.

Unknown Speaker 39:32

I guess I could try and find out who created it. It was probably a team of people anyway. Fen Fen so fenfluramine slimming pills, so methamphetamines previous to this methamphetamines were prescribed in the 50s and 60s to lose weight.

Unknown Speaker 39:47

And then they were banned

Unknown Speaker 39:55

because they realized that they weren't giving housewives meth

Unknown Speaker 39:59

but then

Unknown Speaker 40:00

And it paved the way for fenfluramine. phentolamine which was called Fen Fen. And then that was released for sale after meth was was banned. And it was lauded as a dream drug and a miracle cure. It was an appetite suppressant. It was addictive and it killed many people and it has long term effects on the people who took it. The manufacturers Wyeth pharmaceuticals so we're going to hold a pharmaceutical company whole

Unknown Speaker 40:34

responsible for this one. Why is pharmaceuticals knew of the harm that their product what the harm of their products and withheld this evidence even when they were under investigation, in order to cash in on the moral panic made up around the made up a word epidemic.

Unknown Speaker 40:56

So

Unknown Speaker 40:59

Fen Phen Fen Fen by the way, it's built pH en dash f en.

Unknown Speaker 41:08

And the thing is with these

Unknown Speaker 41:10

these diet, diet drugs, we did an episode on diet drugs.

Unknown Speaker 41:15

It's always the same story. This is a miracle drug that is gonna make people thin. And so how does that work? How does it work? It's basically speeding up your heart. Well, and the FDA approves it because being found is the worst thing ever. And it doesn't matter if fat people die because you know, at least at least they'll be fat and dead huh lol

Unknown Speaker 41:38

you know, being sarcastic there with that lol.

Unknown Speaker 41:42

And, you know, even in recent years of these, you know, drugs that are coming out, it's the same shit. There's no we don't have the evidence. You know, they'll have a short term study. People lost weight. Yeah, but then they died. You know? So we got to, you know, when when we have these new drugs coming to market looking at what, what they do, and what long term evidence that we have for it?

Unknown Speaker 42:10

Yeah, because it's probably not good. Okay, now my personal

Unknown Speaker 42:17

I hate this guy. He is, I feel like he is really a villain.

Unknown Speaker 42:25

Professor Philip James, British guy 9095. He set up the international Oh, word task force by OTF.

Unknown Speaker 42:36

He looked at the recommended BMI is created by Louis Dublin in the 1940s. So it's 1995 by now, I looked at the recommended BMI created by an insurance company and arbitrarily dropped the recommended BMI due to that faulty evidence.

Unknown Speaker 43:00

This was then adopted by the World Health Organization.

Unknown Speaker 43:04

Millions more people became classed as fat again, overnight.

Unknown Speaker 43:13

The IoT f the international obesity task force was funded. Who were they funded by? What do we think? What do we think? Tell me your answer. Who were they funded by?

Unknown Speaker 43:26

Weight loss companies? Yes.

Unknown Speaker 43:28

Weight loss drug companies who gave a number of payments to Philip James totaling 1 million pound or 1.2 million US dollars.

Unknown Speaker 43:43

And he's like, Yeah, who cares that they they're the ones who funded this research.

Unknown Speaker 43:48

If even if it's even if it's false, at least we're going to get people to be less fat.

Unknown Speaker 43:55

That says his attitude.

Unknown Speaker 43:57

Like it doesn't matter if it's if it's if it's wrong, if it's arbitrary because if we tell more people that they're fat, then less people will be fat. Like what?

Unknown Speaker 44:10

You know more people can be treated for the disease of fatness.

Unknown Speaker 44:16

Okay 2006 John Franco dicta Capello invented the key diet Ke Ke Ke diet which is Ke Ke tau

Unknown Speaker 44:28

but it was with a twist because we need to get more extreme because you know that doesn't work doesn't work doesn't work. We need new branding. This is what we do. We need new branding. We knew we need a new twist. Okay, and so this diet the KE diet, also known as the feeding tube diet.

Unknown Speaker 44:46

A doctor will put a feeding tube into the patient and is fed a proprietary mixture which is 270 calories or

Unknown Speaker 45:00

De through the feeding tube for a specific number of days,

Unknown Speaker 45:06

they then come back to the office have the feeding tube out, and then presumably go away

Unknown Speaker 45:13

with a temporarily smaller body, probably disordered eating, and then we'll then way more than when they started. I'm absolutely fucking wild.

Unknown Speaker 45:30

And so it was, it was the mixture was

Unknown Speaker 45:35

keto based, right. So the, you know,

Unknown Speaker 45:40

protein

Unknown Speaker 45:44

270 calories a day. Can you imagine?

Unknown Speaker 45:49

Okay, so 2007 We have Kevin Trudeau,

Unknown Speaker 45:54

a marketing man with no medical training, has a diet book called The Weight Loss Cure, they don't want you to know about reported $5 million in sales and is based on a discredited 1960s diet, where you eat a tiny amount of calories a day and ingest hormones that can be extracted from the urine of pregnant women.

Unknown Speaker 46:21

I love the fact that this one's been descript discredited, but although the rest of fucking every other diet hasn't been discredited yet.

Unknown Speaker 46:29

So that was a New York Times number one bestseller, The Weight Loss Cure, they don't want you to know.

Unknown Speaker 46:36

Yeah.

Unknown Speaker 46:38

So in 2008, Syed Yu Jiang and Artem Petkov, created new, I was surprised that NUMA is actually that old because new and feels like it's about five years old, right?

Unknown Speaker 46:54

And you're thinking, Who are these creators? Are they nutritionists? Are they therapists, because NUMA is all about, you know, psychology? No, they are to computer scientists. And they trick people into thinking they're getting cognitive behavioral therapy. Their website says neum is grounded in science. It's at the heart of everything we do, is it?

Unknown Speaker 47:25

Because

Unknown Speaker 47:28

they have a so I went into the like this, or they have a research bank. Oh, oh, love it. No, I'm gonna look at all the studies. And they will they've got the links to the studies. And then they tells you what the study says in a sentence.

Unknown Speaker 47:46

That that laughable, they really are laughable. I scroll all the way down to the one study that says,

Unknown Speaker 47:55

from the 40 Plus studies that they've got, because they're like, We love science. And this is how this is how these diet companies are tricky. Motherfuckers because if you said, Okay, so we're backed by science. Okay, I believe you want to do it in a more digging? We use cognitive behavioral therapy, we use psychology. Oh, that sounds fancy. must be true. But it's if you still don't believe us, check out our 40 Plus scientific studies. You've got 40 Plus scientific studies, they must be great. All right, I believe you now, but even if you still don't let's look at the studies. And that's what I did. So I had a look at the study days.

Unknown Speaker 48:44

So one of them has got mention of amount of people who have

Unknown Speaker 48:51

like 30 something 1000 people I was like, amazing. Love it. Lots of people. That's good, right when we had that, that that's the episode I did a few weeks ago on how to how to decipher studies, right? And so one of the things that studies do is they'll say, we love to three people. Turns out blah, blah, blah, and it's like really three people or you know, 10 people, but this had 30 plus 1000 people great after a great start.

Unknown Speaker 49:24

They said okay, so they said the summary of this study is 77.9%

Unknown Speaker 49:29

reported a decrease in body weight while they were using the app.

Unknown Speaker 49:35

Okay, that doesn't sound that good. If someone is using the app, shouldn't they shouldn't be 100% of people losing weight. Okay, well, let's go set this round up to 80% 80%. I'll pay ya percent. All right. How much why did they lose?

Unknown Speaker 49:56

Well, looking at it most lost less

Unknown Speaker 50:00

Some 5% of

Unknown Speaker 50:04

their weight. Okay, so 5% We're looking at a 200 pound person, that means that person lost 10 pounds.

Unknown Speaker 50:14

And what's the other thing that we said about studies, specifically weight loss? Weight Loss studies, do you remember about the time timing? With all diets, weight loss is very easy to achieve. Normally, depending on how many diets you've done, the more diet you've done, it's harder, but

Unknown Speaker 50:36

you will lose weight initially, and then three to five years, that's when the weight comes back on and more. They looked at users over 18 months. Of course, of course. So they're there fantabulous data to show that 80% of people lost around 5% of their body weight in 18 months, doesn't sound that amazing, does it?

Unknown Speaker 51:06

And that's about the you know, that's less like the top line of reading that's reading the study, if we go in deeper,

Unknown Speaker 51:14

will get more information, but I was like, shit, you know, it's not gonna get any better than that is it? I mean, this is what this is what they're bragging about, you know?

Unknown Speaker 51:22

And, and so I'm gonna give him the benefit of the doubt and say that it is 77.9% of people who lost way bigger in life and give him the benefit of doubt that that's a good thing and give him the you know, it's a tiny amount of weight, a tiny amount of weight

Unknown Speaker 51:39

and he's people who are self reporting.

Unknown Speaker 51:43

Alright, so, I love this, this post by Reagan chest and I'm going to give you a quote from it.

Unknown Speaker 51:50

About noon their commercials are chock full of diet advice that is old as the hills and has no research to back it as actually creating sustained weight loss. Brackets eat grapes instead of raisins. Drink wine isn't a beer, drink a glass of water if you're hungry, blah, blah, blah. And one of the programs seems to be based on the old eat watery, fiery bulky foods so you'll feel fuller advice that doesn't work because your body is a sophisticated piece of machinery and not a lawn mower in 1987 1987 called it called and wants its shitty diet advice back. Moreover, how can they claim to be brand new while also claiming that they you helped to keep the weight off for life? That claim would have had to be backed by some serious long term research. In order to be credible. I asked them for research I asked in an email through their website contact and on social media, including one memorable thread that's had 758 comments to which they replied directly to 757 who Guess whose comment did not receive a response

Unknown Speaker 53:00

Reagan's common

Unknown Speaker 53:02

Yeah, so it is hilarious. Hilarious.

Unknown Speaker 53:07

They're like we're a brand new Daya lifelong weight loss. How do you know that you're offering what lifelong weight loss when you haven't been around for the for the lot for life for me with lives? You know?

Unknown Speaker 53:25

The reason why neum is so big is because they got a shit ton of investor back backing.

Unknown Speaker 53:32

They were anticipated to go to IPO initial public offering. And that would value neum in excess of $6 billion.

Unknown Speaker 53:44

So neum

Unknown Speaker 53:46

right, these companies right, what they're what they are a lot of these companies what they are, is they're just sophisticated marketing companies, right? Because they have this product which is is

Unknown Speaker 53:57

shit, big pile of shit. And they do some very good wizardry to trick us. People are very passionate about neum whenever people mentioned no more online there's gonna be people who will say no, they're different they talk about psychology, but

Unknown Speaker 54:20

it's

Unknown Speaker 54:22

no they don't they

Unknown Speaker 54:26

give you a very very low calorie diet no matter what your goals are. If you say you want to be healthy if you want to say you want to lose weight, they'll give you the same fucking thing and

Unknown Speaker 54:37

they will give you they do the coding that you know red foods, green foods yellow foods, right the same shit that Weight Watchers was doing right points and what's the other one in the UK? There's a big one Slimming World in the UK. And they've been around what since the 60s.

Unknown Speaker 54:55

It's the same fucking advice has been going around for you for forever. There

Unknown Speaker 55:00

his food is bad. And if you eat it, you're gonna get fat. So don't eat it. Ah, you've lost weight.

Unknown Speaker 55:07

Don't talk to us in a year or two because we don't want to know when you're fat again.

Unknown Speaker 55:11

But they've got they've got millions and meat they've got they have

Unknown Speaker 55:16

had so much funding. That's why every single fucking podcast has a known advert is because of the gargantuan amount of funding that they have. Because they are smart marketers, because they've said, Okay, there's a gap in the market for a good app. And they've won awards for their styling of the app for the for the user experience, right? They've done a good job at that. But they are charlatans they are scammers because that diet doesn't work and their own evidence shows it but they hope people are

Unknown Speaker 56:00

a trustworthy trusting of them enough to not look about evidence.

Unknown Speaker 56:05

You know?

Unknown Speaker 56:08

This motherfucker did so sorry. That's my dog. That's my dog. Coughing

Unknown Speaker 56:14

All right, so 2009 We've got Dr. Oz. That giant human turd.

Unknown Speaker 56:22

Lawmakers called out OLS for describing certain supplements on his show as quote, magic Weight Loss Cure and, quote The number one miracle in a bottle. Lawmakers had a hearing and specifically took aim at Oz's promotion of pure green coffee beans, which claims to help users lose 20 pounds in four weeks and 16% body fat in three months. The FTC the Federal Trade Commission sued the products Florida based marketers

Unknown Speaker 56:55

and won a $9 million settlement. And with Dr. Oz, it's kind of like well, if he wasn't scamming people, then he would lose his license. It's actually really difficult to lose your medical license. You have to basically be killing people.

Unknown Speaker 57:11

You have to really, really fuck up. Really fuck up. Telling people about scammy fake miracle cures on a TV show isn't going to cut it. Unfortunately, he has to kill some people and I mean,

Unknown Speaker 57:30

I mean, these this shit that he's showing, you know, has it killed people probably, you know, this is caffeine shit and shit your pants stuff and who the hell knows. But that says that's Dr. Oz is that this show since 2009. He was on Oprah. Oprah gave him a show.

Unknown Speaker 57:53

And that's, he says, basically I lie because it's more entertaining. I need to give flowery, flowery language.

Unknown Speaker 58:03

And when someone is on his show when a product is on a show, it's called the OLS effect. They they make they make a shit ton of money. Millions. Because he says hey, here's a miracle cure. Here's what here's what's gonna make you fucking green coffee beans. I mean, you can't make this shit up.

Unknown Speaker 58:26

The Dukane diet in 2010 his book became the best selling diet book in the UK. The Dukan diet is high protein low carb, Atkins do can expanded massively beyond selling diets creating a business built on books, foods and health supplements. He became fitness and became famous because it said that

Unknown Speaker 58:46

what's her face the princess that's married to William

Unknown Speaker 58:52

Kate Middleton, that Kate Middleton and her friends and family did the dukan diet to become thinner for her wedding. His business is worth a reported 96 million. He makes claims that his products are quote miracle calorie burners. But no evidence of such He also claims that 25% of people who do his diet, keep the weight off for for four years. And that seems to be picked out of his asshole. Because there's no evidence. All right, so 2013 Dean Kaman Dean is the person who invented the

Unknown Speaker 59:35

wheel sad thing on wheels segway.

Unknown Speaker 59:40

He created the Segway. He didn't stop there. He was like I'm not done with creating stuff. He also created a machine, a machine assisted bulimia device. He created a machine assisted bulimia device called Aspire assist to pump the stomach's contents through

Unknown Speaker 1:00:00

retube which has been served surgically implanted into the abdomen.

Unknown Speaker 1:00:07

It's horrifying. It's horrifying. Basically, it's surgery to give someone bulimia, they eat food. Then they have a

Unknown Speaker 1:00:19

wire, a tube that's going directly into their stomach coming out of their tummy

Unknown Speaker 1:00:25

in an open wound, and there's a port there, they connect it to this pump, and then they stand over the toilet, and they empty the contents of their stomach into the toilet.

Unknown Speaker 1:00:40

Here's a quote. This is the first time that I look at a device that was approved by the FDA and I am absolutely utterly and totally appalled that it was approved, says Joseph Guttman, an endocrinologist and diabetic diabetic technologist under a shoe that's diabetes. in Pembroke Pines, Florida who has treated patients with Oh word for 30 years, Guttman says, oh my goodness, that's his name Guttman, and he treats fat people. So as he put together a group of 750 physicians who want to sue the FDA to take the device off the market, his ultimate goal is to get 4000 doctors to join him. It is the most pathetic exhibition of ignorance on the part of our agency, the FDA, it is nothing but a bad trick. It's like a bad joke.

Unknown Speaker 1:01:30

And so, surprise, surprise, the FDA approved it after a very small trial.

Unknown Speaker 1:01:39

Side effects the port valve can cause infections the tube can leak. Some experts fear that the device might trigger eating disorders and no shit Sherlock.

Unknown Speaker 1:01:54

nuv final one, our final one we're getting to 2021 and we're giving a shout out to Paul Brunton and Richard Hall.

Unknown Speaker 1:02:08

Paul Brunton was the lead researcher who released the jaw wiring device called dental slim.

Unknown Speaker 1:02:16

You know what I had a I had an epiphany about dental slim. I've been reading it reading it as dental ism.

Unknown Speaker 1:02:26

Ever since it came out in 2021, I've been reading that and I did a podcast about it and have read the word dental slim, because it's all one word as dental ism.

Unknown Speaker 1:02:38

And I was like, how are they changed the name of it? No, I just my brain had just was like, No, it's called dental dental slim.

Unknown Speaker 1:02:49

And so we've got the lead researcher. We've also got you know, authors of the study the study into this dental swim. The split study is garbage, by the way.

Unknown Speaker 1:02:59

We've got Richard Hall

Unknown Speaker 1:03:04

and

Unknown Speaker 1:03:07

Paul Brunton

Unknown Speaker 1:03:10

we've got front and then we've got people who created the device

Unknown Speaker 1:03:18

who were on the

Unknown Speaker 1:03:21

author's they were the researchers and authors into this device. Right and so turns out that Dr. Hall, Richard Hall,

Unknown Speaker 1:03:31

and the University of Otago, which is where Paul Brunton is from and then another fella called doctor, but don't ski. They are all owners of the device. So Dr. Hall 40%, but Dansby 30 and University of Otago. 30.

Unknown Speaker 1:03:51

And then they kept it secret, right? They kept it secret.

Unknown Speaker 1:03:54

They basically I haven't even told you what this fucking thing is, is I did an episode on it. But in case you didn't listen to it, it's a jewel wiring device where you have like these brackets on your teeth and then magnetically locked shut.

Unknown Speaker 1:04:08

And basically, you can only have a liquid diet and that is why they think that it's in that's the weight loss mechanism.

Unknown Speaker 1:04:16

Doesn't work and has terrible side effects.

Unknown Speaker 1:04:21

But yeah, they did this study, and the study was done by the people who own the fucking device.

Unknown Speaker 1:04:34

So that is something that the ethics committee should have known or spotted before given the study the green light, and there were no conflicts of interest stated in the paper. So they are fucking scam scam scam a ruse. And not only that, even if the study was legit, they are still people who have made a jaw wiring device.

Unknown Speaker 1:05:00

In 2021, we're not in this fucking 40s anymore. It's 2021

Unknown Speaker 1:05:08

Yeah, other shoutouts to the other big diet companies. Herbalife HMR Boston Jenny Craig lindora Medifast Nutri system

Unknown Speaker 1:05:23

profile by Sanford simply good foods which is actually Atkins Weight Watchers.

Unknown Speaker 1:05:29

Yeah and you notice how a few of these Herbalife

Unknown Speaker 1:05:34

I think Nutrisystem, Medifast. They are all

Unknown Speaker 1:05:41

M. L. M. 's multi level marketing companies which add on, add on another layer of scam because they're scamming people with the diets. And then they're scamming people who are working for them by getting them to pay to work for them, to then scam people to work underneath them. It's just scam a rific. They're the most scam tastic of the diet companies. So so there you go, there's an overview of the biggest scammers in the weight loss industry. Who is your, I don't wanna say favorite.

Unknown Speaker 1:06:19

Who's your like, I hate them. I think Louis Dublin, like Louis Dublin, from the MetLife has a lot to answer for but

Unknown Speaker 1:06:30

that British guy who's

Unknown Speaker 1:06:34

a giant bellend what's his name? Professor, Philip James, he also

Unknown Speaker 1:06:43

is Pooh poohing. So, study came out, Katherine Fleagle, did this lead the study into looking at all the data, they did a

Unknown Speaker 1:06:55

roundup of all the data about

Unknown Speaker 1:06:59

mortality risk of, of different PMIs. And

Unknown Speaker 1:07:06

I think it was 40 studies with many, many, many people. And the study showed that people who were

Unknown Speaker 1:07:13

Oh word had

Unknown Speaker 1:07:17

decreased mortality than people who are, quote, normal weight.

Unknown Speaker 1:07:23

And he's just talking shit about her. I mean, like, she's not doing she's not doing the research. She isn't. She was what what they did was they did a meta analysis of other people's research. You she she was just like, here's, here's what the information says mother hugger. And he's like, I don't like it. I think fat people are awful.

Unknown Speaker 1:07:46

Yeah, he, he gets all my tips and most

Unknown Speaker 1:07:53

I, you know, like some of these people.

Unknown Speaker 1:07:57

They I think they genuinely

Unknown Speaker 1:08:04

do they, I think some people do care about like some people who are in the world of,

Unknown Speaker 1:08:10

oh, research, care about fat people and health.

Unknown Speaker 1:08:16

I'm saying this with really, like,

Unknown Speaker 1:08:18

dare lie.

Unknown Speaker 1:08:21

But a lot of these people are just like, dollar signs in their eyeballs.

Unknown Speaker 1:08:28

You know, if I was deeply unethical, and I had a time machine, you mean going back and like starting a diet company?

Unknown Speaker 1:08:36

I mean, you know, probably got better things to do. But

Unknown Speaker 1:08:40

no,

Unknown Speaker 1:08:43

that's it, you know, if you're unethical then talking about,

Unknown Speaker 1:08:49

you know, get helping people to temporarily lose weight will make you money, you know.

Unknown Speaker 1:08:58

But you got to be a sophisticated marketer to stand out from the crowd. And that's the what the difference is with the these folks, right, because there's probably been lots of diets that have come and go. But

Unknown Speaker 1:09:13

these are either the most outrageous, or

Unknown Speaker 1:09:17

the ones that have stuck around the longest. And they had something new, like think about Weight Watchers, they had something new because they had the group meetings that was never done before. New had something new because they they were, you know, out in 2013 on the app game, that was new and they're like, oh, psychology, right? Soon enough new is going to be the old deal might take 20 years before and people are like oh yeah numerous for like middle aged ladies or whatever. But

Unknown Speaker 1:09:49

then there's going to be something new right? And it's going to have to be even smarter. I mean, there's gonna be something new every single fucking day but

Unknown Speaker 1:09:58

because

Unknown Speaker 1:10:00

I think that we, as consumers have become

Unknown Speaker 1:10:07

more attuned to knowing that weight loss advice doesn't work. And so they're having to take a new approach and make it about what is in fashion, or coming into fashion. And that would be

Unknown Speaker 1:10:27

body positivity at the moment, right?

Unknown Speaker 1:10:30

And mental health and all that type of stuff. And so they are absolutely going to do that. And when that is out of fashion, or there's a new thing that is more more sexy, then they're going to do that.

Unknown Speaker 1:10:45

And I really think that, you know, these folks, they might not have meant to be, but a lot of these folks are deeply unethical. And I've caused a lot of harm, some more than others, and some maybe didn't mean to,

Unknown Speaker 1:11:02

but they have ideas in their mind and have run with it, you know,

Unknown Speaker 1:11:09

to the detriment of a lot of people are not just fat people.

Unknown Speaker 1:11:16

So they can Oh, fuck off is what I think. All right, well, thank you for hanging out with me today. I'm gonna go take duty for a little walk. It's dark now. Oh, my goodness. My be video is failed again. I don't know why.

Unknown Speaker 1:11:29

You know, you know, once a year, I have to have things go wrong. And two weeks in a row. My video has failed. So who the fuck knows why

Unknown Speaker 1:11:38

I think my phone just from time to time, so it's just like, fuck yeah, I'm done. I've had enough of your bullshit, Vinny.

Unknown Speaker 1:11:46

But I've got

Unknown Speaker 1:11:48

rollerskating tonight. And then tomorrow, some Internen friend of the show is coming around my house and we're recording some

Unknown Speaker 1:12:01

videos she is playing in the video. She's playing a wellness influencer, who says, you know,

Unknown Speaker 1:12:10

shit to me. Like I guy. Have you had some color hair up your bomb. And you know, I'm playing the fat person who's like, well,

Unknown Speaker 1:12:20

so we'll see how that goes with other games. And then before we get some lunch, and then oh, I've got a day on Friday with the same guy.

Unknown Speaker 1:12:29

This will be date number five, with the same guy that I mentioned a couple of episodes ago. So

Unknown Speaker 1:12:38

this is the most updated someone in like

Unknown Speaker 1:12:44

a number of years.

Unknown Speaker 1:12:47

I was like, I think I've been single for three years. You know what, I was looking at something the other day and I was like, oh shit, man, I've been sick for five fucking years. What?

Unknown Speaker 1:12:56

I think you know, the pandemic is like, messed up with timelines. Right? You know, it's kind of like because those years didn't exist. And so, in my mind, I'm like, Yeah, but real human years. It's three years because two years we were like, inside and the shit. And now we're hot. You know? What now we're kind of half coming out. And so these are half years. Anyway, so So yeah, so yeah, the most updated someone so who knows how it's gonna go so far. So far, so good. So

Unknown Speaker 1:13:25

I'll keep you updated with whatever happens even if it goes tits up.

Unknown Speaker 1:13:29

And then I can spill the gas because I know that he he's not listening, or I won't get

Unknown Speaker 1:13:38

all right. Well, thanks for hanging out today. We'll see you in the next episode of ie.

EP147 Transcript

You're listening to the Fierce Fatty Podcast episode 147. One of you want to support a fat person to lose weight? Let's do it.

Hello, and welcome to this episode. Nice to see you. Thanks for being here. So this episode is for is for everyone. But specifically this episode is for people who are fat or who are pursuing intuitive eating or Health at Every Size or adjust, you know, living living life as a fat person. And they have someone who is in their life who is worried about the fact that they are fat, is worried about the fact that they have are not losing weight. And this is to play for them. Okay, so this episode is for the person who is concerned about a loved one concern because they are fat, and are concerned about their health, and has hopes that their loved one will lose weight. Everyone can listen to it. I mean, you probably want to the fat people probably want to listen to it just to make sure I don't you know, don't know what I might say, but I know what I'm gonna say. But feel free to listen to it. Even if you're not someone who's telling someone to lose weight is probably going to be quite cathartic, right, it's probably going to hear hear the things that you wish that you would have heard or someone would say to someone that loves you or who is who was concerned about you. So, I've been I've been thinking about this episode for a long time for a really long time. And I keep putting it off because I'm worried that it's going to be imperfect. And the thing is, it is going to be imperfect you know, I'm so I'm so concerned about this might be the only chance that I have with folks who are not currently fat positive. And I want to make it so impactful and so informative and make it understandable so that something good comes out of this right and I realized that this can't be perfect. This is not going to be the perfect response to all of the questions that you might have as someone who loves a fat person and he's concerned about it. And there's going to be this like what if situations but I thought about all of the common things that I hear from people who I'm working with who say but what about this, but what about that, but what about blah blah blah and answer those things for you. Okay, and as well as thinking about this like why do I want to be to be perfect? Well, because I was thinking it's because what if someone is listening in bad faith? What if someone is listening to say like fuck you Vinnie. You're a piece of shit. And kind of picking apart every single word that I use type of thing. And you know what, that the episode is not for those people but not for people who are not listening in in good faith and open to hearing a different perspective. And so really, I'm I'm talking to people who genuinely care about fat folks and love them and want what's best for them right? Not for people who are like I hate fat people and nothing that is nothing that you say is going to change that if that's you then I mean then I don't know Yeah, this is well yeah, maybe maybe you might have your mind change probably not but this is for people who are listening in good faith. All right, so I started thinking about this episode because I came across a Am I an asshole on post on Reddit? If you're not familiar with it, it will normally start a i t a Am I the asshole right and so the am I an asshole so that person will ask them read it. What do you think? What does everyone think? And then people will say I think you are an asshole. I think nobody everyone sucks here or nobody is an asshole or something else. And this is a post stuff that I read, I'm gonna read out to you. And by the way for those who are listening who are fat, I'm going to be using the old words during this and I might be mentioning some some weight, or you know, pounds and things like that. I will just a heads up if that's I'm going to be taking out as much as I can but I want to some people might not understand our fat, you know, our in fat language type of thing. Okay, so this is a post, which has since been deleted, but I'll leave I'll leave a link on for the there's a there's a what is it called Wayback Machine Time Machine Wayback Machine, you can go back to old Reddit posts that have been deleted in case you ever wanted to know that you can do that. So I'm 26. I'm 27 years old, and I have a girlfriend of six years who I live with. When we first got together. She had an athletic body and all that changed the past couple of years when she got promoted, and started working longer hours. She started smoking weed every night claiming that his it helped her relax after a hard day's work. She also started eating like shit. She's about 19 pounds heavier than when we first met on on her five to frame it definitely shows. After ignoring or ignoring my subtle hints for the last year, I finally sat her down last month, and said enough is enough. She needs to make an effort to get healthy. She agreed that and she agreed and asked me to help since I'm in great shape shape myself. I did everything to support her in losing weight I paid for an expensive supplement program. I woke up early in the morning and repaired her healthy lunches so she could take to work. And when she got home from work, I had a healthy dinner prepared on the table. I added her to my gym plan and even bought her a road bicycle. Today I borrowed her car and found fast food wrappers everywhere, along with receipts of recent purchases. This led me to check our joint bank account and I saw she's been picking up fast food every day since we've had that discussion about her getting healthy. Not only that she that she also was buying fast food during work suggesting that she has been thrown away the meals I have prepared. This really pissed me off, I confronted her. And she started crying and took accountability for her lack of discipline, discipline. I was telling my girlfriend's sister about this ordeal, and she said I was being controlling and an asshole. But from my perspective, I think we just want her to be healthy. I think I went above and beyond in my approach and how I dealt with this being five two and gaining 19 pounds of fat rapidly. And she's only getting heavier. She's she's setting herself up for heart disease, diabetes, and could cause issues to her knees. Also, we don't even have kids yet. So to be gaining this type of weight so rapidly is definitely concerning to me for her health. Okay, so I read that and I was like, I really wish that I could have a one on one conversation with this person. And now this might sound like this might sound like you, this might be your situation. Or you could say oh, I'd never be so mean as to do what this person has done. I am just worried about my loved ones health. And I just say I'm worried about your health. And I think you should lose weight, or I'm not quite on board with this whole, whatever they're doing. And so this might be very similar to you or B can might be completely different. But I thought this was a good starting point for talking about what has gone wrong here. And what maybe could happen in this situation, what should have happened in this situation. Okay, so the first thing to know, it's very well established that intentional weight loss diets. So any type of intentional weight loss, whether that be through a fad diet, or through something that's quote, kind of sensible or reasonable, something that structured something that's well established or something that's like, you know, drink this tea to shut your pants. That's all called intentional weight loss. All forms of intentional weight loss don't work in the long term. So you might have seen in, in life, depending on how long you've been alive, that people go on diets, and they lose weight, and then eventually the weight comes back on. Now, the reason why people will view that people who are maybe not not up to date on weight science and will say, Well, it's because the person did something bad is the person's fault for not following the diet. That's what I thought. When I started dieting, I was like I'm gonna be the best motherfucking Dieter ever because all these other people who don't lose weight is because they're lazy and they're greedy and they can't control themselves. They don't have self discipline.

That's actually not the case. The failure rate of diet is incredible. It's 95 to 98%. Now I have a document with the research about why and how diets fail. And we have data dating back to, you know, 100 years, 100 years worth of data basically showing that dieting doesn't work. And so a lot of people will say, there's that one study in 19, in the 1950s, that has a 95% failure rate. And that's all we've got. But that's actually not true. We've got many, many, many studies to show that weight loss, intentional weight loss is not sustainable, and that there is a risk in the act of losing weight. And I'm gonna do, I'm just gonna go through a few, I'm not gonna go through everything. Because we'd be here for for for a long time, just to kind of pick it out. And also, I'm gonna give you access to this spreadsheet that I've got with, with the evidence here that we're talking about all the studies, and so you can go and have a look and be like, was Vinny talking shit? Or was this study good and valid and all that type of stuff? Okay, so the first study we're talking about this is from 1959. And this is the one that is typically credited with a 95% failure rate on diets. And what it does is it looks at the previous 30 years of data. So 30 years before 1959, they were looking at this data, they will look at all that data from 30 years previously. And what they say in this is hundreds quote, hundreds of papers on treatment for so the word obesity, I'm going to censor out because it's it's not a good word. I mean, it's like I can go on tangents and about lots of things. So I'm just going to say the O word okay for obesity. So literature, hundreds of papers for treatment on on Oh word have been, let's just change it to fatness. Okay, so for fatness have been published in the past 30 years. Most however, do not give fingers on the outcome of treatment. And of those that do most report them in such a way as to obscure the outcome of treatment of individual patients. Okay, and so this is, this is what happens with diets and weight loss science. So, using our critical thinking skills, a lot of what weight weight loss science does is it will say it works on these people. But then if you look at how many people it's worked on, and how much weight they've lost, and how long that weight has been kept off, the numbers are always unimpressive. Very, very, very unimpressive. And so they kind of do a lot of, you know, smoke and mirrors type of thing to say, to make us who, who who don't look into the actual study, to say, oh, okay, well, you know, it worked, you know, from Pam from Ipswich lost 40 pounds. So, you know, and then I'll have that little asterix that says, results not typical. And, and, you know, we get into that kind of, well, I'd be the one that would be typical for because I'm really, I really don't want to lose weight. Okay, so then we go to 1992, we've got the national institute Institute of Health, who says that in controlled settings, participants who remain in weight loss programs usually lose approximately 10% of their weight. However, one to two thirds of the weight is regained within one year, and almost all of it is regained, regained within five years. And so here, this is a pretty common thing is people will lose a certain a certain amount of weight. And it's, you know, a saying here, it's around 10%. As I say, if someone is 200 pounds, they would be losing 20 pounds, which I mean, is not this significant life changing amount. But then within a year to five years, almost all of it is regained, and more. And what is happening is the body is doing some awesome stuff to make sure that we go back to the way that our bodies are is used to. So chemical processes are happening. Our setpoint weight every time that we intentionally try to lose weight, our setpoint weight goes up and up and up. And so that is called weight cycling, also known as yo yo dieting, and it's just a natural reaction from the body. When it is put into perceived famine is to say Holy shit what is happening we need to maintain the the, the fuel that is coming in and not burn off too much because we're in a period of uncertainty, which is an amazing thing that our bodies do. But for those who do want to lose weight long term, it can make it literally impossible. Alright, so if we move to 1999, how effective are traditional dietary and exercise interventions for weight loss, quote, a low long term follow up data on Miga. So that's a thing, again, is that we don't have that long term data. The data the data that do exist suggests that complete relapse after three to five years. A brief survey of the most popular dieting techniques used over the past 40 years shows that most techniques cycle in and out of popularity, and that many of these techniques may be hazardous to health. The paucity of the data of data provided of the weight loss industry. So the paucity is scarcity. Industry has been inadequate at inconclusive, those who challenge the use of diet and exercise solely for weight control purposes based their position on the absence of waste weight loss effectiveness data and on the presence of harmful effects of restrictive dieting. So when we say restrictive dieting, that means dieting, weight, calories, fat, whatever is restrictive. So that's any amount of dieting. All right, so we have studies from 2007 2010 2013. From 2013, the Australian National Medical Health and Research Council on obesity said that weight gain is very common after weight loss, and that is achieved that is achieved with lifestyle interventions. Weight loss is maximal at six to 12 months, regardless of the degree of initial weight loss. Most weight is regained within two year period, and by five years, majority of people are at their pre intervention, body weight. And that is great a evidence so grade eight evidence in Australia means that it is so well researched, it is you know, great evidence in Australia is smoking can cause cancer. That's great evidence. So you know, it's like not disputed, it is so well understood that that is something that happens. It's great evidence that dieting doesn't work as grave evidence in Australia. A study here from 2015 The probability of a fat person to gaining normal weight. The annual probability of achieving normal body weight was one in 210 for men, and 121. In 124. For women, the probability declined with increasing BMI category category, in morbidly obese patients as quotations around that because that word is made up I guess, like all words, but it's really fucked up. And the in morbidly obese patients, the annual probability of achieving normal weight was one in 1290 for men, and one in 677. For women in women, the probability of achieving normal weight among super obese participants, one in one in 608, which is similar to the two that observed among morbidly obese patients. In the smaller number of super obese men, the probability was higher at one in 362. So it's very unlikely that we can become thin long term. The most recent study that came out in 2021, I'm going to talk about this one, this is called obesity treatment, weight loss versus increasing fitness and physical activity for reducing health risks. Again, all of these are going to be linked in I've got it in a spreadsheet, you're gonna have a link to the threat spreadsheet, but I'm just quick from that. So the paper cites 225 other papers, okay. So it analyzes and it does a meta analysis. So it's not just one study, it's looking at 225 other papers, quote, we propose a weight neutral strategy for obesity treatment on the following grounds. One, the mortality risk associated with fatness is largely attenuated or eliminated by moderate to high levels of cardio respiratory fitness. So that's called CRF.

The acronym CRF, cardio respiratory fitness, so you know, moving your body or physical activity so pa so CRF, cardio respiratory fitness or PA physical activity to most cardio metabolic risk markers associated with obesity can be improved with exercise training, independent of weight loss, and by a magnitude similar to that observed with weight loss programs, three weight loss even if intentional is not considered associated with lower mortality risk. Okay, so, losing weight is not associated with lower mortality risk for increases in CRF or PA so that's exercise are consistently associated with greater reductions in mortality risk than is intentional weight loss and five weight cycling. That's the yo yo dieting that's just dieting right doing a diet and then the diet failing and doing another diet. weight cycling is associated with numerous adverse health outcomes including increased mortality. Importantly, fat people in conjunct us fat people and importantly, overweight and obesity in conjunction with moderate to high CRF were associated were associated with a lower death rate than adults in the unfit to normal weight category. Okay, so if you are a fat person who exercises a lot, your your death rate is lower than someone who is a straight sized person. So someone who's not fat, who doesn't exercise CRF does not eliminate the CVD mortality risk associated with high BMI. Nonetheless, the data illustrate that low CRF is more hazardous, hazardous than a high BMI, okay, so it is more hazardous to not exercise than it is to have a high BMI. In fact, the data in figure two clearly shows that risks associated with higher BMI within both the fit and unfit groups are much lower than the risks associated with low CRF regardless of BMI data on 21,925 men in the aerobic center longitudinal study demonstrated that lower all calls and cancer mortality risks associated with higher levels of muscular fitness were independent of BMI, waist circumference, and percent body fat. And that the lower risk was observed even after after associated with reduced mortality risk. Even in those studies that demonstrated a benefit of weight loss, it is not clear whether the weight loss itself was the primary factor that reduced mortality risk. This is because the RCTs included in the weight loss meta analysis invariably incorporated changes in diet and or exercise, either as a program that participants could attend or is or as advice, as discussed in subsequent sections increases in physical activity are consistently associated with reductions in mortality risk independently of changes in changes in weight. Okay, so what that is all saying in a lot of a lot of language, is that that it's not weight that causes you losing weight doesn't doesn't cause reduce mortality risk. Okay? What does is physical activity, okay. And they're saying is, you know, when someone goes on a diet, and they see improvements in health, it is not because of losing weight, it is because they have engaged in health promoting activities, like physical activity. So a big disclaimer here is that physical activity is just one of many, many, many, many different ways that that we can change health or what promotes health, okay, so I don't want you to take from that like, right, I'm going to tell my fat person, they need to go for a run, because it will make them healthier. I please do not take that from it. We're going to talk about what is health and what makes up health in another section here, but this is just showing that if you are a fat person and you engage in activity, physical activity, your mortality risk is lower than someone who is a straight size bodied person or you know someone who's not fat and who doesn't work out. All right. Again, that doesn't mean that okay, so that means that one fat people have to work out or to even that it's suitable for all fat people to work out although even all fat people can work out. Right. And also, physical activity for some fat people is actually really harmful for many different reasons mentally and physically. Okay, and so we, what we're what we're trying to do is take a holistic approach to this is to take a You know, send a black and white thinking of oh, here's the answer. This is what we need to do. Okay, what what does this mean, for each individual? Is this helpful for each individual? And, you know, it might be that someone loves working out, and that's great. And if someone doesn't like working out, that's fine too, because there's other ways that we can engage in health if we want to. But also, health is not an obligation that other people owe us. All right. Okay, so one thing intentional weight loss doesn't work. All right. Number two here is that being fat doesn't equate to being unhealthy. Okay, so you cannot look at someone's body and presume that they are unhealthy or that they will become unhealthy. We do not know individual people's health status is fatness is linked with an increased risk of offset and conditions, as we have been told a million times over. The thing is, is we don't know why. Okay, we don't know that having more fat tissue, adipose tissue on your body? Is the causal the causation of the increased risk. Okay? We don't have that science yet. We don't know. There are certain identity factors that people can have like, say, being a man, we know that generally speaking, men live Long live, not as long as women. We know that if you live in France, for example, you'll live longer than if you live in the United States. Is that because that person happens to live on this certain piece of land? Is that because someone has a certain gender? Or are there really complicated issues that go along with it? So for example, you know, you're you live longer if you live in France? Is it because of of the healthcare that's accessible? Is it because of working hours? Is it because of XYZ? Right? And there's lots of different factors that can go in and we can think of that very easily. Oh, yeah. Well, you know, it's not that they physically live in France, you know, they stand on that ground, but it's called France. It is because of all these different things that are going on. And it's the same with fatness, right. What we do know about fat people and health is that something that is really, really damaging towards fat, people's health, and everyone's health is marginalization and stigmatization is oppression. And so fat people experience a shit ton of, hey, you should lose weight. And that actively damages our health. Right? stigmatization marginalization doesn't feel good. And also, what happens is, it leads a lot of fat people to not seek out health care, to not go to the doctors, and then not get diagnosed as quickly. Or even if they do go to the doctors, having their concerns ignored and told to lose weight. And that contributes towards discrepancies. In fact, people are more likely to, you know, experience this or that.

And i Because, you know, because why would you want to go to the doctor, if you go in, and every time you're just told to lose weight is pretty difficult, you know? Okay, so in these studies here, too, we've got a study here that goes over all of the different common things that you would think is associated with fatness, you know, like diabetes, or heart disease or whatever, and looks at whether dieting helps improve it outside of weight loss. And spoiler, it doesn't. It doesn't. Right. So we don't know, someone's health status by looking at them. And also being fat doesn't equate to, to being unhealthy. And also, what if someone is fat and unhealthy? Does that mean that they are an unworthy human being that they should just go away? You know? No. And so then what's the what's the solution? Say if we knew 100%? Absolutely. Every single fat person on the planet is deeply unhealthy. It's they're just ticking time bombs and they're, they're going to take everyone down with them. What's solution, we know that we can't lose weight, there's a very, very, very, very, very small chance that we can. And even the act of trying to lose weight is harmful to health. So what's the solution? You know, even if he can't get behind the fact that, you know, weight and health is a lot more complicated than what we have normally known. So you can you can say, I don't know, can't get behind that Vinnie. Vinnie, like fat people are obviously unhealthy. That's fine. Well, what can we do? Weight loss doesn't work. And that's great evidence that weight loss doesn't work. There's no, there's no kind of like, oh, hang on, we don't have a lot of evidence. We have so much evidence, so much evidence, you know, it's like vaccines, the amount of evidence of supporting, you know, vaccines don't cause autism, because people are like, Oh, it does. And it's like, we don't need any more studies to show that vaccines don't cause autism. I mean, we do always need more studies about this fat thing, because it's so well entrenched, right? But it's kind of like that. And that's the way I view it is like, there's so many studies. Okay, so number three, you can support your health in weight neutral ways. Okay. So we touched on that earlier of those studies, showing that if you engage in physical activity, you have a lower mortality risk than someone who who, who doesn't who is smaller, and you're fat. So there's lots of different ways that you can support health without tying weight loss to it. Okay. So there's a study, which is linked in the spreadsheet, under weight neutral care does work. Okay, so it's called weight science, evaluating the evidence for a paradigm shift came out in January 2011. And what this does is it looks at four folks who are dieting, and engaging in health promoting behaviors, and folks who are just engaging in health promoting behaviors and not dieting, what they found was the people who were dieting and also engaging in health promoting behaviors, they were unsuccessful, because diets don't work and unsuccessful in losing weight long term. And also, they stopped engaging in health promoting activities, because they preach they presumed that they weren't working because they weren't losing weight. And so the people in the group who were just engaging in health promoting activities, just for the fun of it, they did continue with those health promoting activities, when they were outside of that marker of weight loss, being at success, they weren't even looking at weight, they were just doing those things. And so when we have health promoting activities outside of weight loss, people tend to do them longer. Because they don't feel like they've they're failing, because, you know, weight loss doesn't work. And they say, I don't want to do this anymore, because it's not working. Because it's not, it's not getting to me to where I want to go, which is lower weight. But if we really looked at is it getting me to a place where I might be healthier, then that is potentially happening. We have another couple of studies here showing that healthy habits are associated with significant decrease in mortality, regardless of BMI. Also, we have an interesting paper here that is called I think, therefore I am perceived ideal weight is a determinant of health. And so this found that the difference between actual and desired body weight was a stronger predictor of physical and mental health than body mass index. And so if we continue to shame fat people, and they internalize that shame and say, Yeah, I am a terrible person because I'm fat, that will have a negative impact on their physical and mental health versus if we support fat people in just living being humans. And, and they are able to internalize those ideas of ideal body weight, and what that looks like for them, you know, and then they're able to accept that fatness is not their fault and, you know, engage in behaviors that improve their mental and physical health. And also, you know, the other mechanism mechanisms that might make that happen. And so, you know, you can support your health in weight neutral ways, but health is really Eat a really complicated topic. And shaming fat people is very, very unhelpful. And so, you know, we spoke about exercise as being something that could influence someone's health, the World Health Organization, and many, many countries came together to look at the data of the determinants of health, what makes up health for an individual. And the determinants of health is really, really complicated. And it was very, very surprising to me that what you eat, and how much you exercise are not the number one things that make up someone's health status. They're not even number two, or three or four. We're going to talk about it and you can go and have a look at the images. So if you Google go in vo g o i n VO and determinants of health, you can go and have a look at a huge diagram or I have one which is simplified as well on my on my Instagram, but 89% of health occurs outside of the clinical space through our genetics, behavior, environment and social circumstances. These factors are known as the social determinants of health. Despite their importance, attempts to integrate the determinants into a single visualization has been limited. And so then they've got the the in the illustration, okay, so most of what makes up our health is not our individual behavior. Okay? individual behavior makes up 36%. Of of health, okay. Inside that 6% you like, you might think, well, I thought, Okay, well that means are you eating broccoli? And are you going for a run? Actually, inside that individual behavior? What we see is if you smoke, if you have safer sex, if you get enough sleep, your mood levels and your exercise patterns. So we've got, you know, your optimism level your life satisfaction level, your cognitive cognitive function in late life, your risk related behavior like gun behavior, motor vehicle behavior, do you wear a seatbelt? Are you living with anxiety, depression, stress and hopelessness. And then the final two in here, physical activity and diet patterns. Okay. Let's just pretend individual behavior is 100% just physical activity and diet patterns. It still only makes up 36% of what makes up health. Okay. The others social circumstances. That is your social connectedness, your social status, so your income, your language and literacy level, education, your occupation, your culture and tradition, your race, ethnicity, your citizenship, your sexual orientation, if you've served in the military, your gender identity, history of income, incarnation, incarceration, incarnation, incarceration, discrimination, and work conditions.

22% is genetics and biology. And that under genetics and biology, we have body structure, and that is weight, height, weight, hip ratio, and age. So the World Health Organization is recognizing that weight is down to genetics and biology. Okay, so underneath that here too, we have like bone density, density, blood pressure, intuitional status, biochemical function, your DNA, your gender, chromosomes, things like that. Okay. 11% is medical care. So access to health care, quality of health care, patient engagement and health literacy. And we think about that with patient engagement, how fat people might engage with formal medical care setting settings and what happens when they're there. And finally, 7% is the environment and so that's pollution, exposure to tobacco, air quality, water quality, the location, crime level, job opportunities, public space quality, access to vocational training, residents quality exposure to firearms and allergens. Okay, so there are mind that 36% of what makes up someone's health status is individual behavior. And only one of the things underneath that. And there's many different things here is diet, and only one is physical activity. So we're not saying that those things don't matter. But say if you can't engage in physical activity or don't want to, you can decide to do things like improve your sleep patterns, you can decide to ask for a raise at work, you can maybe not expose yourself to firearms or wear a seatbelt, you know. And so when we think about health, you know, are we thinking about, Okay, what's, where do I live? What color is my skin? How much am I making, we don't think about that, which is unfortunate, because that is, you know, the complex picture of what makes up health. And it's a lot easier just to say, you know, don't eat this and move your body because you know, that's very simplified. And it makes us feel like we have more control over our health than we maybe do. So the next thing here that I want to talk about is what are you trying to achieve by telling a fat person to lose weight, I'm going to presume that it's because you care about their health, right? That's wonderful. If you care about someone and you care about their health, that's a wonderful thing that shows what type of person you are, you're a caring and loving individual. Something we also want to care about is not just physical health, it's mental health. And what happens if you say to a person that they need to change for whatever reason, and how that affects their mental health. So if you care about their, their physical health, you should also care about their mental health and know that this is probably having a negative outcome to the mental health. And telling someone in a, quote, nice way, or encouraging them to do certain things is still just as harmful, right? Like, we're not we get it, you know, if you're dropping subtle hints that someone should lose weight, or if you just say, Listen, you're fat, and you shouldn't be, you know, the, your fat and you shouldn't be as harmful but, you know, being quote, nice about it is still is still harmful, you know, and it might be that, you know, the being nice about it and the kitten light gently dropping hints is kind of like a, you know, drop of water or like a paper cut. And it's like a death by 1000 cuts or, you know, it's it's like, a ton of feathers. Each each little thing is like a feather. But then, you know, eventually a ton is a ton, right? Yeah. And also, if you're worried about health, like, no one owes you health. Even though it would be great if everyone was like, 100% healthy, they just did what we wanted them to do, right? I wish I I would say there's almost I wish I could control people and just make them think like me or do things like me, unfortunately, I can't and unfortunately, you can't write. And no one owes you to do anything with their body, even if it means that they have negative health outcomes. And, and focusing so much on health, there's a name for that. And that's called Healthy ism. And that is valuing people, because they are healthy. And valuing unhealthy people less. That is a form of ableism, which is saying that to be non disabled, is superior to being disabled, disabled, folks, we don't need to think about them. People with disabilities are, you know, negative in some way, right? People are going to be unhealthy. And as we continue to be alive in this world, as we get older, we're going going to going to become more and more unhealthy, we're going to become disabled. And so our current health status, if you are a person who was someone who's currently very healthy, that's not necessarily something that is going to stay the same forever. You know, because you're gonna die. Sorry. So, I mean, if if you know self worth is being derived from health, then it's something that is going to be slipping away from you eventually. And so, you know, if someone worthy outside of their health status, you know, you can say, Yeah, but Vinnie, you know, you said that fat people can be healthy, whatever. I know, my loved one is so unhealthy. I see what they do. I know. It doesn't matter. If you if you see them doing things that you don't agree with, and you perceive them to be unhealthy or you quote, know that they're unhealthy, whatever unhealthy means. You, you know, you can't force them to do what you want them to do. Right? Which I know is annoying. I wish we could. And there's one more thing about health. It's really interesting. Like, I remember going to the doctor's one time. And it was like a annual checkup or whatever. And the doctor said, You are very healthy. And as she was handing me a prescription for all the medicines that I need to take to be healthy, and I just thought I was then I talked to the pharmacist, I said, Isn't that really funny? Like she said, You are healthy, as she is given me things, because I'm not healthy. What is healthy? What does that mean? You know, given me prescriptions for like, my asthma, or my, my fibroid, or you know, mental health stuff, and, you know, IBS and blah, blah, blah, so am I healthy? Or am I not healthy? What is it? You know? It's complicated, right? And so, like, Would I class myself as a healthy person? The doctor said I was healthy. But I have things where my health is not good. It's complicated. So you know, kind of think of it like that it's a more nuanced thing. And also, why is it that we think about certain conditions more favorite favorably than others? So say, if someone broke their leg, you blocked here, you know, they broke their leg climbing a mountain? Oh, wow, you know, who they were doing something really good. And they broke the leg? What if a someone who was fat fell out of their wheelchair and broke their leg? Then how would you think about it? Or what if a fat person has diabetes? What would you think about that versus a thin person who has diabetes, or even, you know, diabetes versus having an issue with your thyroid? You know, what, why is one seniors maybe better than the other. And by the way, diabetes is a largely genetic condition. You can't eat your way into diabetes, just a heads up, you know, and everybody gonna be saying that, but hang on, they're eating bad, quote, bad food. And here's the thing, here's the thing, right with food, because you could say, Okay, well, I'm not going to tell them to lose weight, but I'm going to tell them that they should not be eating that food. That really, really, really contributes towards poor mental health. Almost every single one of my clients who I help unlearn fatphobia has many, many stories from a very young age of well meaning loved one saying don't eat that you should eat this, and how that destroys destroyed their self esteem, their relationship with food, their well being their mental health, like it, it can be just one comment. We, the world is well, very well educated on how many calories this has the fat content of that the nutritional value of you know, like, we are smart. You know, we know that people say that you should eat a cucumber and not eat something that is perceived as unhealthy. Like, it's not like we've gone through our lives and not pick that message up.

We have picked that message up. And so we don't need someone else to say, Hey, did you know, like, we've heard that message a bajillion times. And hearing it again, is just another paper cut, you know, or even a huge sword, you know, is really, really painful. And it's not helpful. Shaming fat people, actually makes them fatter. Not that being fat is bad, but it's the opposite of what theoretically you want to achieve. So restricting people's food intake, say if you have here have children, saying you're not allowed to eat that eat this, it really really is setting children up young people and adults with with a high chances of, of disordered eating, or even a full blown eating disorder, we have to be very, very careful with the way that we talk about food, because it is deeply personal and powerful. So again, if you have an adult person that you're concerned about the way what food they're eating, they're an adult person. You telling them that you have seen what they're doing and you're judging them and that you think it's wrong, isn't going to enhance your relationship and isn't probably going to make them change what they're doing long term. And you know, who that's even saying that the what they're doing is bad. You know? So an example We'll hear a thesis is that I used to have an eating disorder, right? I used to have an eating disorder, I had a shit ton of trauma growing up. Lots of trauma, I ended up in when I was 17, I was homeless living in a shelter for young people, I ended up meeting a 30 year old guy who was a massive creep. And I ended up living with him, he was deeply abusive. My life was shipped, shipped, shipped, shipped, shipped, like close to death. Terrible because my mental health was that bad. The only thing that I had in my life that gave me a little bit of joy was food. And I'm not saying that that is every fat person's experience. But that was my experience was that once a week, I was able to go to the shop and have some food. Because this guy was also denying me food. I viewed that as deeply pathological that there was something really, really wrong with me. It was a natural response to being denied food and being told that what I wanted to eat was wrong. And from there, I developed an eating disorder. So food saved me in food was the only joy I had during the two years I was with that guy. So if someone had come along and said, Oh, you shouldn't be in that. And they all they saw was someone who was, who was fat, eating foods that they perceived was unhealthy. What would that have done to me? You know, what, what would that? How would that have helped me it wouldn't have. And you know, you might say, well, that's not my fat person situation. And it might not be but you know, who says that eating food is, you know, is a morally corrupt thing to do? And I know that you don't think that you know, you're just worried about your person, but I think letting them be them is probably the best you can you can do for them. Now moving to that, that that idea that first you know, the question that while that I read out about this guy didn't find his girlfriend attractive. I want to read out an experience that I had. So this is a blog post that I did five years ago. Okay, it's called Why I was happy when my boyfriend told me he wasn't attracted to me. Okay, I'm gonna read this out. There's gonna be a link in the bio tech in the in the show notes. Okay, I always got the impression one of my partners just wasn't that into me. Let me rephrase. Just Not That Into my looks. My suspicion was confirmed four years in when he told me he didn't find me as attractive because I had put on a little weight walking in the park at winter. When he Seamus shamefully told me his secret. I assured him I would, quote become better, I would lose weight. The next week, I went on what would be my last diet, I vowed I would lose the weight, the, quote, healthy way. And my partner would finally see me see how wonderful I was and think I was the most beautiful person in the world. Of course, as all diets do, it failed. I put on more weight. I became resentful. Why couldn't he just love me the way that I was? Why did he have to tell me something that was so devastating to me? I was filled with shame, anger, and confusion. Why I am now happy that he gave me this information is it that it led me on a path to self discovery around beauty. Six months after we split I asked him would you have liked me better if I was sinner? The yes. He said this time his words didn't hurt. It didn't hurt because since I gave up on that last i i have learned all about fat positivity and feminism. I have learned about our patriarchal society and beauty ideals, how they hurt all of us. Why would a thin girlfriend be important to you? I continued. He explained that having a thin partner improves his status that having a small girlfriend makes him fulfill more masculine. Like a lot of people he's never explored our society's beauty ideals.

We are constantly told that the most desirable are white, young and thin. This belief will hurt him as he searches for a new partner. It will hurt him when he finds a new partner and she ages it will hurt him if she ever puts on weight. It will hurt her to as it hurt me knowing that the man I adored would prefer a different version of me Now I know it's not about me. It's a byproduct of living in a society that objectifies women, men seeing their partners as status symbols and women believing their worth is determined by the number on the scale amongst other things. If I could travel back to that time in that icy cold Park, I would have such a different reaction, I wouldn't have seen my body as a problem. But the fact that my partner believed my worth was decreased. As my weight increased, I would have, I would encourage my partner to explore his idea of what is desirable. And if he couldn't see the beauty of my waves and honey, that I would remove myself from the relationship. So if you're in the same situation as I was, No, it's not your fault. It's this fucked up beauty ideal. You deserve to be with someone who accepts you for who you are. And if they don't leave them. By the way, my now ex is a wonderful kind person, he didn't tell me about his feelings to be cruel, but to try and strengthen our relationship, it just didn't work out the way he planned. If you are worried about your loved one, and and it's someone that you're in a relationship with a romantic or sexual relationship, and you say it's about health, I want to I want to challenge you to dig a little deeper of is it about health? Or is it about your definition of what is attractive? And is that because our society decided that women need to be or people need to be young, thin, nondisabled, white, etc, etc. And think about why is it that we're told we need to be these things? What systems have told us that whiteness, thinness, youth being non disabled, are the most desirable. Those systems are racism, the patriarchy colonization, sexism, etc, etc, etc, right? And it's so hard to unlearn this stuff, especially when it comes down to it's my preference. This is my preference. Fineness is my preference. Our preferences like that are not made in a bubble, right? You weren't born and in your brain was, the idea that fineness is superior, you were told that we were all told that we are all bombarded with images of what is attractive, day in, day out. And that means that we've been influenced by them, right. And it's, I feel like it's a very narrow world, when we can only see beauty in a limited number of bodies, like I feel, I do feel for people who, who don't have the experience of being able to deeply appreciate all different body types, because it just makes the world a little bit more magical, you know. And so there is a way out of that. And the way out of that isn't telling your spouse that they're, they need to change their body. Because one, weight loss doesn't work. It is not sustainable. And too, it is going to damage your relationship. And even if you do it in a nice way, it will still damage your relationship. And three, it means that you're you're never going to be truly satisfied. Because if your partner goes on a diet, their weight will increase in the long term. So your partner will have a bigger body than they have currently. And if you're not satisfied with their body right now, then, you know, it's probably not going to change for the smaller and they are going to age, they their body is going to change in other ways. And so if you're not satisfied with their body right now, it's probably not going to change for the better. Therefore, what you can change is the way that you perceive your partner's body that is changeable. The way that you perceive all bodies and your internalized racism and sexism and Lala and by the way, we all have internalized bigotry right I'm in turn, I have internalized fat phobia and racism, sexism, colonization, all that type of stuff, right? Because I because I've been born into this world. This it impossible for me to have not picked it up. But it's my job to try and unlearn that stuff. It's my job if I want to be a better person than I do, right? I think we all do want to be a better person. And and if you're listening to this podcast, it means that you, you you care, right? You care and you care deeply if you've taken the time to listen to this podcast, and if you can take that deep caring and love and and use that to help you work on the way that you perceive fatness, I think that'd be really, really helpful for the person that you love. And for yourself, it will make the world more colorful, it will make you satisfied with different things that you previously thought that thought that you weren't satisfied, not just fatness, you know. So I'm going to read a couple of other you know, questions that people have put onto the internets. And if we think about what we've just, we've just gone through what we might answer to these questions. Okay. So this one is, quote, I'm not physically attracted to my wife, her physical appearance has always been an issue and it only gets worse. She has put on a considerable amount of weight. And this is very unattractive to me. I've tried to hint to her tactfully. I'm not insensitive, that it bothers me but she only gets offended. Okay, so let's just pause here. So I'm not a physically attracted to him to my wife. It's always been an issue and only gets worse. Okay, so, you know, first off what why did this person marry the wife, the person that they are not attracted to? And I mean, fucked up to begin with. She's bought on a considerable amount of weight. This is really unattractive to me. Okay, so that's a that's a him problem, right? That's a him problem. It's not a it's not a her problem. And I'm presuming that this person is a him we don't know. I've tried to hint to her tactfully. I'm not insensitive. And so they say he's saying, I'm not insensitive, but she gets offended. And so he says he's doing it tactfully. But it's not tactfully, because she's offended because it's an offensive thing to do. It seems like it's not my place to say so anymore. Instead, there's a gnawing silence and growing indifference to sex. I'd like to say that it's so that she is so beautiful inside that the outside doesn't matter. But that's not true. In many ways, children, finances practical, practical things, we we communicate well, I respect her and she's a good mum. But this war between us is an increasing source of emotional distress, anguish, loss of intimacy and hormonal hell, what do you suggest, okay, so what we suggest here is for this person, to probably go to therapy, and to learn about fat politics, to read some books, listen to some podcasts, and stop continuing to hurt his wife. It might be an idea for them not to be together, if if the wife knew that he was talking about her like this, I it's always been an issue. And it only gets worse our physical appearance, I mean, that's really very, very unkind and shows really a deep lack of respect for their person. Okay, so this other person says, When my husband and I first started dating, I was extremely attracted to his physical appearance. But throughout the years of our marriage, he's put on a considerable amount of weight, when I tell him, he needs to lose weight, he gets angry and really hurt. Is it unfair of me to want him to lose weight. I mean, it's not unfair for you to want him to lose weight, because you this person is programmed to think that weight loss is good, right? Being thinner is good. And looking at their, their husband from these, you know, when they when they were younger, when you first meet your your spouse, that you know that they're going to, they're going to be great, you know, if you're attracted to them are going to be great that you're going to age that kind of put on weight, their body is going to change, okay? And that's just the way that it is, you know, some people to some degree and some people to more degree, right? And so the more that we detangle these, these ideas of our spouse needing to look a certain way or object, objectifying our spouse, the more comfort we're going to find in the world. Right.

So should this person you know, it would be like, yeah, it is unfair. To tell him constantly that he needs to lose weight. This person needs to go and learn about that positivity and go to therapy and all that type of stuff. So I asked my followers, what would you like me to say to well meaning people who are concerned for your health, or want you to lose weight, what message would you want me to pass on? What impact does it have when a loved one comments on your weight and tells you to be thinner? And this is what people said. So this is from my followers. I know I am fat I knew at last time you told me and the time before, just stop, that they're treating me like a problem, not a person. That despite all the good that I bring to the world, I'm still not enough. It makes me feel like you wouldn't love or take care of me if I got ill. If I did get ill, I'd probably keep it from you because of your judgment, I'd be alone. health and weight aren't correlated and if they are concerned are eHealth vote for health issues. Gaining weight is often a sign of healing. But body comments are never welcome. Yeah, so that's another thing is, a lot of times when people are held healing a an from an eating disorder or disordered, disordered eating, that means that they will gain weight and so that's just a normal part of healing. And so we see a lot of people who are in treatment who are setback a huge amount because family members say oh, no, you're putting on weight, and it really fucks them up. Body comments are detrimental and triggering to mental health and eating disorders reevaluate if they are actually well meaning that health risks of weight cycling are higher than being fat. Please trust that I know my body better than you do. I know what I need. My size is of no surprise to me. It is not helpful to mention it as I know myself. It affects my mental health negatively impacts my self esteem I want to cut contact no one should be commenting on someone's body period. Then people have health issues too. It's not exclusive to fat people. The impact of it is it feels like I failed them failed the family that I am a failure that their love is conditional fat people already know that they are fat you're dumb fucks bloody I know I'm fat I live in my body they act like I'm not aware of my weight I am other people's concerns just add fresh it and makes me want to eat more show that they care in other ways. Think about their how their comment may trigger a trauma response as a result to be more understanding of my trauma history when with food and weight when commenting. Mainly that the science says dieting does not work. I am not a failure. I am the norm. I was heavy as a kid. I'm sitting in therapy because I was treated as less because of my weight by my peers and my loved ones. I would like to have a proper answer to the health concerns which is never really their true concern. So this person is like health concerns is masking something else and it often is it often is masking fatphobia you know that that the things that we've learned about fatness and also desirability. It is harmful when they body shame. More concerned with looks than my well being. Weight does not equal healthiness mental health impacts of feeling like your body is wrong and you are too weak to change it. There is so much more to me than my size. No comment about weight. Our comments about weight are helpful, fat or thin. It fuels the idea that our weight is our worth. I've spent 45 years hating my body because you have always told me it needed changing. When people bring up my weight. It feels like my physical body is all they see or care about. You're worried about my health but you're happy to drink lots of alcohol with me regularly. I used to think like you but now I know better. It's okay to admit you're wrong. Learn then teach. Be more concerned with our mental and emotional well being. Please stop telling me about your new diet. I didn't ask and I don't care. I grew up to have an eating disorder because of adults saying this to me as a child. We know about our way we know the quote concerns and complications. I know you think that this is helpful but all I hear is that I am not enough as I am that they are asking me to sacrifice my mental health to do Diet, everything that they think they know about the health of fat people is untrue. Your comments make it clear to me that you can't or won't see beyond my size. This dismissal of who I am is hurtful. For me, I had to choose between trying to be thin, or health promoting behaviors. We have a longer a longer response hear from someone. I'd like them to know that when commenting on my weight, however well intentioned, it doesn't come off that way. For me, it brings me such shame and really knocks my self worth because what I'm hearing is that they see me as bad or wrong or something to be fixed. It also feels like they only see me as one thing fat. And to them that is bad. And that is that I'm not living to my full potential. As someone who grew up with a mother who was so hyper aware of my weight, mainly due to her own body hangups, I think, I've always felt not good enough that my body is the common denominator in how I am perceived in everything I say, or do. I often wonder how I would have turned out if I have just been left alone and allowed to live my life without feeling like I was never good enough. Unless I was thin. The issues around self worth are filtered into everything. It affects how I advocate for myself, and how I am often afraid to take up space. I think I would want people to just stop and look inward before they speak about another person's body. Ask themselves where it's coming from. And really, at the end of the day, will it change anything or affect their lives anyway, just leave that people alone. Let them live. We don't need a commentary. And the last comment here is thank you for your concern. But please know that bodies exist and function best in many different shapes and sizes. Personally, I know I'm healthier, both mentally and physically than with a disordered relationship with food that would be required to achieve a lower weight. I would say that it's important for me for for more people to understand the health warnings about being fat are overblown. For many, many people gaining weight after restricting over exercising and weight cycling, particularly if you gain weight, and then have a pretty stable weight is actually healthier, not just for your mental health and confidence but for your body. Your health markers will actually improve when you focus on them, not trying to just lose weight. I wish my family knew that when they praise my siblings extreme weight loss and praise diets, it feels like they are telling me to lose weight. It feels like they don't have the guts just to just tell me, I should be like my siblings. So they pile on the prey so I can connect the dots is never subtle, like they think it is and we see right through that through it to their message that they are disappointed in our body and think it's not okay. It feels like they think my body is their personal failure. And they must remedy it. Not necessarily something to say to them directly. But I wonder how many others feel this way with their families pressures and expectations. It hurts when I'm healthiest I've ever hurts when I'm the healthiest I've ever been. I have figured out how to enjoy exercise again. And I get out and move pretty much every day, walking the dog running with a dog going to the gym hiking sports, I'm much stronger, I'm getting more nutrients, I have more energy, I'm happier and overall better. And it sucks knowing if your family could pick they don't want you to go back to disordered eating and restriction and harmful pathways. Because weight is more important to them. They can't see past the weight. Yeah, those are really I think powerful responses directly from from fat people. I a lot of fat people can't say this to their, their loved ones who tell them to lose weight because, you know, they wouldn't get the response they wanted you know, they their loved one wouldn't say shit, I fucked up I'm so sorry. You know, and so it's not safe for them to do that. And that's really really sad. And I just I just want to end with just really getting home this idea of there's going to be a lot of people who are like, Well, what but what about their knees or what?

But what about the they're you're about to have a heart attack or what about their joints? Or what about this or what about bla bla bla there is no way to lose weight and keep it off long term. That goes for fat diets, lifestyle changes, and even bariatric surgery. We just don't have any information and data to show that there are ways to manipulate human body size in a way that It is something that's going to be lasting long term, we don't have that data. So even if we knew that every fat person is deeply unhealthy, and you know, their knees are about to buckle under the weight of them, by the way, it's not true, then we can't, there's nothing we can do to not be not be fat, right. So what we can do if we want to support a health, or many of the different health promoting behaviors, which include dismantling fatphobia, and all the other things that we didn't think that were related to health. And what we need from you is love, and acceptance and support. And to know that you are that person and place we can go to who is not going to tell us that we are bad, that we need to do this or do that. If you do that, it just continues to erode the relationship. And I really got to tell you, so many I mentioned it before, so many people have had devastating consequences because of loved ones telling things saying things to them. And they end up cutting off those people from their life, or reducing the amount of time they spend with them. Because they refuse to do anything else. And I don't think that if you no care sort of get you care about someone, if you had the choice to you know, just not say anything and have them in your life, I think you'd would prefer that right? And then some people might say, well, if I don't say something, they might die, and then I won't have them in my life. But you know, we just don't know that. We don't know that. Do we want to lead with kindness and compassion? Or do we want to make people feel awful, which in turn negatively impacts their health? So let me round up everything that I just said. One, what if you want to support a fat person to lose weight, or you're concerned about their health. So the first thing here is intentional weight loss doesn't work, we've got over 100 years worth of studies to prove that. And we'll have the link of all of the different resources for you as well to so you can look into all the data that intentional weight loss doesn't work. And that means any type of of weight loss with with any method. Being fat does not equate to being unhealthy. You can support your health in weight neutral ways, and so you can engage in many different activities. And things outside of focusing on weight and a study show that they will stick more if you are not focusing on weight. Health is a really complicated topic. And shaming fat people is really really hard, unhealthy, unhelpful. What are you trying to achieve by telling a fat person to lose weight if you care about their health, and you also need to care about their mental health, telling someone in a quote nice way or encouraging them to do certain things is still just as harmful. No one owes you health and focusing on it so much is health ism. And ableism in practice is your definition of what is attractive based on infantilization racism, patriarchy, and other harmful oppressive systems. The fact that you love someone and care enough about them to want them to be healthy is a beautiful thing. And the best way that you can support your loved one is loving them unconditionally, no matter what their weight is, and celebrate them for exactly who they are right now. Okay, so I'm going to leave you with one last thing which is Hayes health sheet. So Hayes is Health at Every Size. So ha ha E S stands for Health at Every Size, health sheets.com is an a resource if you want to look more into the common conditions that are associated with fatness and learn more about how to how to live with them, how they how they are created, what's going on. So you can understand like say if you do have a loved one who has type two diabetes and you're like, oh my god, they need to be doing this and that and they need to be becoming thin to help themselves. That Hayes health sheets is going to help you understand why is helpful outside of weight loss and how how this condition came to be and in the mechanisms and and what to do Yeah, so in case you're interested in that type of stuff and again like this is imperfect there's gonna be things where you know, there's there's different areas I've not, you know covered. But yeah I hopefully this has been helpful. Maybe you've picked up something maybe not, you know, I know that you're coming from a place of love and I hope that with that love you can maybe make a tweak to the way that you're approaching fat folks and and just love them and accept them. You know, the same way that you want to be loved and accepted, right? Yeah. And if fat folks are listening Hey, you're rad and amazing and big fat he hugs to you big fat he hugs to everyone. And thank you for hanging out with me today. And I guess we'll see you on the next episode goodbye you.

EP146 Transcript

You're listening to the Fierce Fatty Podcast episode 146: Actions to take today to stop hating your fat body. Let's do it.

Hey, hello, welcome to this episode How you doing? How's life you get home? Good here good. Yeah, welcome to this episode we're gonna be talking about some things you can do to help with if you're struggling right now with accepting yourself and your body, things that you can be doing. And even if you are feeling pretty good, just some checklists here to make sure that you're safe if there's any areas of opportunity to improve. So, yeah, and hey, I've got a I've got a date tomorrow with a human being Yeah, it's exciting. It's going to be a second day we had a video date as the first day, you know, I find that I'm doing more and more video dates as a first date. I mean, it's such a good idea to kind of see you don't have to leave your job. You know, you don't have to dress from the waist up, you know, to make sure that you've got some type of chemistry and that they are who they say they are or whatever. Yeah, so we had a phone date yesterday, and then tomorrow, we're gonna go to a bar or place to eat food or whatever. Yeah. Should we get pretty good. I had a date a couple of weeks ago, a video date with someone and it went really well. We were like chatting for like, three hours, I think. And, and then we would do to me a couple of days later or whatever. And then 10 minutes before he was going to leave his house. He text me that to say he was counseling because he was feeling sick. And so I was like, fuck, Psych, because he was coming like near my area had cleaned my house just in case he came around. So I spent like an hour cleaning up. So I was like, fuck, like, cleaning for nothing. But he said, Oh, I feel sick. And so I'm like, It's 10 minutes relieves. I'm like, it's a bit Sass, but whatever, you know. And so as I Oh, okay. He says, Yeah, I feel sick. And I was like, Oh, dear, well, I hope we're happy, okay. And he says, Well, I'm sick, because I left my window open last night. And this was, you know, in a few weeks ago, when it wasn't really cold. And I was thinking, oh, you know, maybe he's got, like, some underlying health condition where you can't be cold or something. And I don't know. And he says, oh, no, because I'm just, you know, warm blooded, and I don't like to be cold. So it's made me sick. And I was like, you know, whatever. It's not my, it's not my place to pry into the mechanics of him being sick from a window being open. So I was like, whatever, you know, it's a bit such as it being 10 minutes before, but you got to give people the benefit of the doubt, while also kind of sticking a little pin there in your brain of and I was like, oh, okay, well, I hope you feel better. And he says, are you mad at me? I said, No, I'm not mad at you. I just kind of, you know, just something to know. You know, just man or something, like similar to what I just said to you, but nicer. And so then he didn't, he didn't reply. And then like, three of them three in the morning, he's just sent a picture of the hospital of inside the hospital, nothing else. Three in the morning, federal hospital. And so I saw it in the morning, and I was just like, What is this? This is a bit what is what is he doing here? And so I text him saying, Oh, my goodness, are you okay? Why are you at the hospital? And he says, I just felt so bad yesterday, I called the hospital. And I was like, Oh, wow, like, you know, are you okay? Like, what's going on? You know, all this from from the window being open thinking, what's going like this is what is what is happening, that the window being open would cause him to go to the hospital or like, and he was like, This isn't funny. Oh, not trying to be funny. Um, he's like, You don't believe me? And I was like, Oh, yeah. Yeah, but believe Yeah. And so I was like, Oh, my, his the way he's the way he's acting is just a bit strange. And so I was like, Yeah, you know? It just saying, Yeah, I believe you. But maybe I've said something to make you feel like, I don't believe that you're at the hospital. So if that's the case, and I apologize, and, and then and then. So the next day, he texted me, like, I think about eight times, I hadn't responded quick enough for him. And then the last text was him saying, Oh, why are you ignoring me, then? What's his, you know, basically shouted at me because I hadn't responded in a quick enough manner for him. And I was like, may know, this is not good. Like, that's it. That's the unknown. This is the this is the end of that, you know, we've had one, one video chat, and you're acting like, you know, we're a couple or something and the IOU I don't know. I don't know. It was very strange. And he kind of got stroppy when I said, I don't want to, I don't want to do anything. He's like, What could I have possibly done wrong? In the few days that we've known each other? And I was like, well, here you go. Here are the inappropriate kind of things that kind of raising a little bit of a flag here and there and altogether, just, you know, it's just too much. So. But anyway, I've got a date with someone else tomorrow. And so far, so good. So I'll, you know, I'll let you know how it goes next week. See if I'm, you know, I seems like I can't get past like date one or two, because they do something fucking where I'm like, really? What? Really? Can you not just just behave you know? Anyway, let's talk about actions to take to stop hating your fat body. Adi Adi. Alright, so we've been influenced to believe that fatness is bad, right? I'd say most of people who are listening to the podcast, we're socialized to believe that fatness is bad. And certainly you have had messages from the media and all sorts of different places to say fatness is bad. And so if you're struggling, liking your fat body, or even, you know, you feel like you hate it. That's absolutely valid and absolutely to be expected. I've said it before, but I think other people who come out of childhood and into adulthood who who don't have struggles with body image issue are like they're the unicorns, right? I think it's a lot more common than, than we know. And, and so it's just a natural reaction, your your brain is behaving in a way that is to be expected. And so I think about beliefs, like suitcases, if we have a suitcase and on the front of the suitcase is the belief like fat is bad. If we open the suitcase, the suitcase is the belief will find different things inside your suitcase or my suitcase.

And so my suitcase, the belief of fat is bad. I had, you know, my parents telling me that as a kid, you know, watching 1990s British TV teachers saying this and that have a boyfriend saying this or whatever. And so that was my experience, which is, you know, probably similar to a lot of people's experience, but not exactly the same. And so if you open your suitcase, which is your, your belief, there'll be different items in there, you know, t shirt or hat or whatever, and each of those representing different things that lead up to that belief of fatness is bad. And so we want to be taking out all of those items. If we can, it might take a very long time and maybe it's not even possible and examining those beliefs and also having a another suitcase that says fatness is okay or even fatness is great, or even my body is worthy, or my fat body is spectacular, whatever it is that we're wanting to, to believe instead, and putting things in that suitcase and supporting ourselves to put things in that suitcase and removing things from the other suitcases that are not helpful. And unpacking them examining them. holding them up saying is this smelly, old sock? Something that I really want to carry around anymore? No, it's not. Let's empty that suitcase. And so that So kind of using an analogy, or a metaphor, one of the to who the fuck knows one of the when we think about beliefs, but what are some practical ways that we can actually do this. So I have a formula, which is remove, reduce and protect. And this is what we can do if we're living in a fat phobic society to help us with our beliefs, to unpack unpack those unhelpful beliefs, and to support us in creating beliefs that are more helpful for us. Now, you might have the belief saying fat is bad. And some people might say, that's a good belief to have, because fat people are bad and fat people are unhealthy. And if that works for you, that works for you, you know, I mean, obviously, the things that are inside that believers that will hold on to bigotry and misinformation and things like that. But I mean, if that's working for you, and for some people, it is, you know, some people who are maybe professional weight loss coaches or whatever, if it's working for you, that's great, whatever. But if it's not working for you to believe that your fat body or your body, if you if you're not fat is a piece of shit, then we can try to unpack them. So. So remove, reduce protect is the formula. And so let's talk about what that means. So the first step, the gold star in this process, the you know, the thing, which is really amazing if you can do is to remove sources of weight bias from your life. And that's a big Asterix, if possible. And so what that looks like is looking at your, your life, and seeing where the greatest sources of fat phobia are coming from. So really, just think about this for everything that we're doing. Thinking about your friends, your family, your clothes, the media that you're consuming, the TV shows, you're watching the people that you're following on social media, where you live, like even your location. So sometimes I talk to clients and they're like, I live in LA, and it's so beauty centric, they're where you work, perhaps you work in a place that is really focused on looks, your activities outside of work if you work, how you move your body. And so if we thinking about our life, we think about everything in your home, like do you have pictures on your wall of straight size bodies, for example, which is, you know, it's not necessarily a bad thing, but examining if they are helpful or harmful or neutral in our quest to find a more peace in our body. So remove and so if we're thinking about removing things from our life, if possible, if possible. Okay, and so a great place to start is to get out your phone right now. Get out Get a phone, you're like Vinnie, I'm already on my phone listening to your your ding dong. But see if you can go on to the social media network that you might use the most. If you do, you might say I don't, that's fine. But if you're using Instagram, bringing open Instagram or Facebook, and seeing the first 10 or 20 posts, that you see that you're exposed to, what are they? How many of them are fat, positive, intuitive, eating, joyful movement talking about you know, social activism, you know, juicy, juicy things? Or how many of them are kind of maybe neutral one Oh, no, this is neutral, but dog videos, that would be definitely positive. But that's kind of like not influenced you either. Either way, right? So might be like dog videos, or I mean, like, what else could there be in the world apart from videos, pimple popping videos, I'm thinking of all the things that I like watching toenail clipping videos. I'm sorry if I just disgusted you. So how many of those are kind of like more neutral that have not necessarily positive positively or negatively influencing the way that you think about your body? And how many of those are things that you're seeing of normative bodies, white bodies, thin bodies, recipes, diety type stuff, and and so do this if you If you're not getting enough data from 10, then do maybe 20 or more and just see what's coming up. What I like to see is people who are maybe more along in their journey is they will say more things like, yeah, I got a lot of dog videos, and I got some, like politics. And I've got a couple of, you know, body positive people not fat positive, though. And people who are newer on their journeys are like, oh, yeah, there's this diet account. And yeah, there is this like, thin person who's, you know, telling me that I'm an ugly piece of shit. And so that, that gives us some clues of what we can do to what things we can do to remove and social media. I mean, a lot of these images were scrolling past really quickly. And we're thinking, Oh, how much is it affecting me? It's affecting it is affecting? What about the when you go to the page on Instagram of the I think it's for you page? What things are you seeing there, I noticed when I first started Instagram, for the first year or so, there were a lot of diety kind of body things on there. Until I taught Instagram that I wasn't interested in that content, it will store from time to time, try and show it to me. And so I had to be really every time I saw anything that was not aligning with supporting me, I would be unfollowing, I would be blocking, I will be reporting diet ads to teach the algorithm what works for you and what doesn't and what content you engage in. It's very, it's very tempting on the for you page, if you see something like a person person's body, it's very hard not to click on that and see what is this that they're saying, right. And so if we can just help ourselves with with that, so we don't have to try and avoid it. And so you can say, you can click on Instagram, you can click on the three dots and say do not recommend, do not recommend this this account if you see anything like that. And if you are following people who are a lot of if there's any diet things, or fat phobic things like how Yeah, you need to get rid of that stuff. If it's someone on Facebook, you can mute them, you can snooze them for 30 days, you can mute them forever, but you'll still stay friends. And then fill up your social media with good stuff. And people who don't look like you, and all different types of varieties, because then you're training your brain to understand what human bodies look like, versus a very curated and edited version of what human bodies look like, which is not really what human bodies look like. And so that is removing right? Now, when we think about removing when it comes to friends and family. That is absolutely possible. And I have removed people from my life who are dickheads. Or that was mean, but you know, who were not great for me for whatever reason. And but that was like a very long process. There might be someone who you liked, you know, what I've just had enough of poly Poly is a is a decade so you know what I'm gonna I'm gonna end the relationship that I have with poly.

More often than not, you want to have relationships, who, you with people you have relationships with already, or it's not possible for you to end relationships. So for example, if your boss is a raging fatphobia, you probably don't want to send them an email saying, I've decided I ain't talking to you anymore, because you're a bellend because then your boss is gonna be like, Okay, well see you later, you don't have a job anymore. But in that example, perhaps you can work towards finding a new job if that is an option for you. Or as we have the Remove, reduce protect, in the reduced perhaps we can reduce the amount of time we're exposed to that person. But when we're thinking about remove, we can also think about it in this way. Can we remove the things that are coming out of their mouth from hitting our brain? So if your mum is particularly fat phobic, normally what I see is a mum and a sister together. And so someone's mum and sister are going on diets and stuff. And then there's that one person who will like who's like, Oh, my tidings not working anymore. And the mom and the sister were like, oh, cucumbers up the bomb or whatever. And that's very difficult because it's kind of two against one. And so in those instances Is it possible, I really encourage people to set boundaries. Now, boundaries around this stuff might be more of an advanced level thing. But I really feel that it's very difficult to continue this journey of trying to love and accept your body if the people closest to you are engaged in in bigotry, which is fat phobia, and diet culture, right? It's very, very hard if the ones that are closest to you. And we're not saying that those people have to change their beliefs and and, and their politics, but there are certain things that we should be able to or should have the power to, again, big Asterix, if possible, there's different power dynamics out there. And some things aren't possible. But we, we should know that there are topics that people cannot talk to us about without consequences. And so I know a lot of people will be really good at doing things like shutting down racism when it happens. And of course, if you are a white person, that should be what you're doing anyway. But say, if you were talking to someone, and they started saying those are racist, racist shit, you would be like, Okay, well, that's not acceptable. And you would, it would be very clear, in your mind that you would see that as unacceptable. And of course, absolutely any type of bigotry is unacceptable. But when it comes to bodies, is a lot harder, because it's just such a common way for people to talk. And people don't realize that it is based in anti black racism. And so if we know that, and we've got that this is this is something political.

And no, it's not acceptable. I feel like in like, 1020 years, we'll be like, Oh, God, remember when we were talking, like, people just bang on about diets and shit. But now, it's all isn't that a bit like, inappropriate, hopefully, but of course, there's lots of corners of the world where people will openly speak, talk about racism, and, and transphobia and sexism and all that type of stuff. And, and it is normal. You know, I'm talking from a very kind of left leaning mindset of, of, of my experience and community. And as we know, that is not everyone's experience. So really, we really long term, we can't have this in a big way in our lives, right? It's because it's, I don't feel like it's congruent with us feeling the best about our bodies, if those who we are closest to disagree with basic parts of our humanity. So but that might be a longer term project, right? You know, telling your mum to please don't talk about diets in front of you might be like, Absolutely, that's nowhere near what I can do right now. Because you might be a little, you know, newer at this stuff and not as comfortable and not know what to say if your mum says, but don't fat people die early or but don't isn't fatness bad, you might not know what to say in those instances. And so you're not yet kind of tooled up to have that conversation. But just know that that is something that I think is really important. And maybe you are getting close. And this might be the push that you need to, to say, Hey, I can't I'm this is what I tell people to say. I tell people to say, if this sounds good for you, it might not sound good for you. But hey, I'm wondering if you can help me with something. Hey, Mom, I'm wondering if you can help with something. Yes, child, I would love to help you. What is it? I love being your parent, and I want to help you? Well, I don't know if you know, but you know, with my history of eating disorder, or you know, you know how I've always hated myself. Yes, I know you've really struggled for years dear child, that's really sad. And I'm sad that you struggled with this stuff. Yeah, so I am I've actually started learning about you know, diet culture and an accepting my body and something that I've noticed is that when people talk about diets, or then being on a diet or their own body even, it kind of triggers me into thinking making it about me, and I know it's not about me, they're talking about themselves. But I my brain is really good at making it about me. And so I'm wondering if you can help me by not talking about diets when I'm around and then see what see what you Mm says or whoever it is that you're talking about. One with framing it as I'm, I need your help people, I think more and more likely to listen versus listened up here, MOTHER FUCKA you've been fucking ruining my life for the last 30 years, go suck my swinging tits, you know, then people are on the defensive or like what I didn't mean to say I'm talking about myself and what's wrong with it, you know, and you make it about you, then that might be easier. That approach might sound like awful, and no, do it. But that's, that's what I do. And then also, the big thing is, you need to continue with that journey, because guaranteed not guaranteed but pretty likely that you your person is going to next time you see them be like, Oh my God, did I tell you about the cucumber at the bottom? And you'd like Yes, Mum, you did? And then that's where people fall for fall short is that they're just like, what I told her once. And I tried and she's not done it. Well, if someone knows you and they've known you to be a dieter in the past, or Hating Your Body or, or that talking shit about fatness is normal for you, it's going to take more than one time telling them probably, I mean, hopefully, they hear you once, and they never make a mistake again. But I think it's very normal for people to make mistakes. And that's when you are doing the really, really difficult work of bringing it up again and say, Hey, you remember when you said you remember when I said last time about the diet thing? And you know, not making that big of a deal about it. And then the person person might be like, oh, yeah, sorry about that. Or they might be like, Oh, for fuck sake, I thought we forgotten about this, or, you know, they're going to react however you want, however they want. And then you are going to react in a way that aligns with you. And that could be you know, leaving, not talking to them, continuing to commit to tell them to stop, or, you know, or not, right, whatever is working for you. But I think we need to help people know, learn how to treat us, especially if they've been treating us a certain way or talking in a certain way for a long time. We need to help them understand. And that I think when you decide that you need to remove the person, it's when for me, it's when they are egregious in their dismissal of you, and they just refuse to, you know, meet you a common ground. And so that's happened with me, specifically with one of my sisters who was just like, No, I'm not going to I am not going to say that. I'm not going to call you that. Because I told her I don't use the Oh words. She says no, I'm gonna keep doing it. I don't care. I don't care about how you feel. Okay, that's fine. Unfortunately, we can't, you know, move forward in a relationship anymore. So we're not we never know how someone's gonna react. By the way, setting boundaries. Nine times out of 10 For me, people are just like, oh, yeah, cool. And previously because I was terrible, terrible at setting boundaries, boundaries. I thought people would say, Fuck you. I hate you flip a table. How dare you? Oh my god, you're such a troublemaker. Why are you so difficult? You're so touchy. You're so you're so emotional, whatever. And the reality people were just like, oh, you know? And I was like, what would you mean? Okay. Well, and still they might have had feelings, you know, that they dealt with afterwards. But you know, it was very anticlimactic. But there is that one at a time where it was climactic. climaxing climactic. It was it went tits up. Yeah. So remove that's one thing we can do. And there's lots of different things we can remove. Right and and so going back to the categories, friends, family clothes, do you have clothes in your closet that kind of goal outfits that every time you open your closet? Oh, hi, I'm a pair of jeans that used to fit you like 17 years ago, your piece of shit? Then maybe get rid of them. You know, if you're watching loads of TV shows that you know have tons of normative bodies and don't make you feel good, then maybe can't you can remove that or you can do reduce. Yeah. And so reduces the next next one. So say for example, you spend all of your Sunday with your fat phobic family. How about instead of spending six hours with them, you spend three hours because for whatever reason, you can't set boundaries. You don't want to and a relationship with them. And so you say I'm going to reduce the amount of time or that that TV show that you really like, you're going to instead of watching six hours, you're going to watch three hours and then you're going to watch three hours of a TV show that you know makes you feel good about yourself or neutral about yourself. Or you're going to do three hours of you know, looking at fat is on the internet, whatever it is. And maybe it's that you're going to still watch six hours of that TV show that doesn't make you feel good. But then you're also going to you know, next week not watch any of it so you know, whatever it could be something that you're you're doing temporarily and it could be something where you're you're adding in extra good stuff to counteract the stuff that you know influences you So yeah, if you've noticed I'm having a particularly bad body day to day body image day to day thinking like what has influenced me am I stressed out at work am I tired of have I been watching you know, the last did I binge bikini babes on the beach dating show thing you know, like what is let's look at the evidence to see what's been put into that suitcase the belief suitcase that fat is bad what has been being thrown in there recently. And what have I been doing to put stuff into the other suitcase which is fat is good fat is okay fat is spectacular, whatever it is, or my body is good bla bla bla bla but reducing is not always possible right?

Sometimes you can't reduce the amount of exposure you have to something because it's just not in your it's not in your influence right so if you go back to the work example you know your your you have a colleague who who's who you sit next to in the office, Susan and Susan is always like, oh, diet culture fat phobia, she has a fat phobia vortex and you can't be like Suzanne you know what I'm going to spend like less time near you because you can't move your desk Susan's gonna Susan whatever. And so what you can do there is protect yourself so for example Susan's like Allah Allah Allah Allah Allah diet culture, you can put your earphones in maybe, maybe you can't, you can go browsing the internet for for fat positive stuff, you can listen to an episode or first for a podcast. You can go and see your therapist and be like, Susan is have a fucking piece of work. You know? So what can you do to protect yourself? What can you do to protect yourself to before you're even hitting your brain with Susan isms? You know, what can you do beforehand, so say, if you're going for a weekend away with your family, and you know that they're going to be like, Oh, you're so fat or whatever? Can you have things set up in place already to help you, you know, going in there being like, Okay, this is what I'm going to say if they say this, I'm going to write it down on my notepad, this is what I'm going to do. If they keep talking, I'm going to excuse myself and go to the bathroom and hide in my room or go around for a stroll or a roll around the block or whatever. And then, you know, be on the toilet, going onto the internet onto the first fatty friend's Facebook group and being like, oh, oh, relief from relief from the fat phobia. And so again, thinking about this remove reduced protect friends, family, clothes, media, where you live, where you work, your activities, your your movement, any anything like that. And so for everyone is different, right? Your experience and the things that you have going on your life a totally different from mine, maybe. So there's no kind of one thing of I'm like, okay, so you know, your uncle Barry, you need to say to him this and do that and blah, blah, blah. But if we're thinking about all of these different areas, and and as well, the thing is, I am very eager allied or very perceptive to these things, because I do this work, right? And so I'm very like, ah, that person said that and that was based in the belief that fatness is bad. Whereas, if you're newer to this stuff, it might be a lot harder to spot, cuz it's just a common language that we all talk. And so right now, you might say, Well, I think everyone everything's fine. Okay, I think you know, my friends and family are pretty supportive. I think and, and everything seems okay. And then if that's the case, great. And also, it might be the case that you're unable to spot it right now, because we're all talking a common language and it seems acceptable. And the more that you learn, you might be like, Oh, actually, yeah. Yeah, I did notice that, that they said this or that, or, you know, there was this kind of comment that that alluded to that and you might become more aware of how things are a little bit more harmful that you can't see right now. And I think that's everything to do with our journeys, right? Unlearning all types of different systems of oppression is that some things that we think are fine now, you know, and you're like, years later, you're like, oh, no, I thought I was totally, you know, or I thought I was, like, 10 years ago, I would have been like, I'm not racist. And now I can be like, oh, yeah, I'm racist. Massively. Obviously, I'm, I'm working to be an anti racist person. But I have so much bigotry and bias up on this, this gorgeous noggin of mine, just because I was socialized inside white supremacy, you know, the default of whiteness being superior. So, I think that's the kind of awareness stage of oh, there's so many things I don't know, right? So many things. I do not know. And that goes for, you know, so many different areas of we just don't know when the more that we, we learn about this stuff, and even me, right, you know, I do this as a job. But still, there'll be things that come up and I'm like, Holy shit, yeah. I hadn't thought about that. And I hadn't thought about this, you know, intersection with fatness and I hadn't thought about how that person's experience might be different from mine. And, and we just don't know what we don't know. Isn't that a line from Pocahontas? You'll never knew the things you never knew. What is it? What is that? How does that line go? Something like that. Anyway, poke on it as fans are gonna be like me. No, it's this. You never knew. You never know the things you don't. You get the sentiment. It's really really annoying to hear me go. You never knew the things you never knew. You never know the things you don't never know. Ashley is in front of the fat studies reader. Let's see. Maryland one quoted it. Good night. I'm getting out. Okay, okay. You'll learn things as it you'll learn things. You'll learn things you never knew who you never knew. lyrics from Pocahontas and anti cult colleagues. I always struggle with when people do different versions of Colin, that colonialist, anti colonialist movie that contains unexamined colonialism. Haha, yes, it does. Yeah. Anyway, you'll learn things you never knew you never knew. And that is to do with all different types of learning. And also don't don't don't don't make that fit, make you feel like a giving up or whatever the fact that actually how much do we know? Probably not that much. Because you probably still also do more know more than you did yesterday. And same with me, you know? No, no, yesterday, last week, last year, last month, whatever. And it's a process, right? So all of this stuff. Here's some you know, from all of this stuff, I said, I've given you a lot of different examples, right. And so I would go and make a list of the things that seem easy. And so the things that aren't easier are probably looking at your phone, probably adding in some more people that are good influences on your body image journey on your social media. If you ever want to know who you should follow, go to anyone that you're following who is fat positive, who's anti diet, and go and see who they're following? If you see me, if you go and look at who I'm following, you'll also see disgusting pimple popping stuff. So keep that in mind. Actually, I wonder who who would come up. Let's see. I'm following 2300 people. Okay, okay. Yeah, good. Good. Good, good. Good. I'm just seeing who I'm following on like, Yeah, okay. That's their or good, good. Good, good. Good. Yeah. Good. Good. Get good. You Yeah, you know, I've got maybe like 20 people that I'm friends and, you know, friends or family with. But I think the most of everyone that I follow is people that is going to be helpful for for other people to follow. Yeah, yeah. It's also good things on who I'm following. Yeah, so that could be one. So you're going to do that, you're then going to say, have you noticed that your wardrobe is filled with things that make you feel like blur, you might not even have goal outfits, that's great. And if you do have gall outfits, you don't need to feel panicked and be like, Okay, well, I have to throw them in the bin. And I don't want to, I'm still holding on to the idea that I could be thin, and that's fine, you can just maybe put them at the back of your closet, you can maybe put them under your bed, you can maybe you know, store them away somewhere, and then just you know, see how that feels. And then maybe one day, you happen to become thin, and you can get them out. Or maybe one day, you're like, actually, I'm ready to give them away to someone or not whatever. And so it could be that your closet is, is filled with things that fit you now, and that feels good. But there's nothing in there that makes you feel, whoo, or makes you feel really good. When you pull it out. Is that possible for you to get something that feels really good? And again, that might not be possible for many different reasons. Maybe you don't have the money? Maybe? Maybe you're a supersize fat person, and it's very difficult to get clothes. And it's very difficult to get clothes that make you feel, you know.

But is if we're moving on from that, are there any relationships where you think, okay, maybe I need to reduce the amount of time I spend with that person, or perhaps long term, I can think about setting a boundary with them, or actually, right now I'm ready to set a boundary with them. Do you? What do you what media do you consume? What's coming up there for you? What what shows you're watching? Everything that's going into your brain? And think about those kind of key things are key things that are going into your brain on a day to day basis? Are they supporting the idea that it's okay to be fat? Are they supporting the idea that it's not okay to be fat? Or are they neutral? You know, neither? Neither? Neither? Neither? Or can we get more of the supporting and less of the fat is bad stuff. And so come up with some ideas of what you could do. And I'm sure there's probably a few things that have come up and see what you can turn into kind of like a short term, short term goals, and longer term goals. And, and even with, with family and friends, if you're not ready to set boundaries. I know a lot of people don't even talk about this stuff yet, because it's so new, right? They don't talk about the fact that they're unlearning fat phobia. So that might be another goal that you could set off, I'm actually just going to tell people that I'm on this journey. I've decided that dieting is not working for me right now that I've decided that that I don't want to heat my body anymore. And even just talking to other people about it, because if this is going to be something that you're committed to long term, then that will eventually happen. Right? And, you know, the reason why I don't have to set boundaries around this stuff a lot anymore is because everyone just not it's my job. It's, it's like a huge part of who I am. And so because of that, people who know me know not to talk shit about fatness because they know that Arbalet are that's kind of gross. And so I've got a great deal of privilege there. Because I don't have to set boundaries because I've I've made it my personality, you know, I don't have a personality. My personality is fat. That's it. Yeah. So has this been helpful? Have you got some ideas I hope you are able to create some some tweaks and changes in your life to make yourself feel better. And if nothing, just go and have a big nap, have a cup of tea, whatever it is you'd like to do go and get one of those you know remember those things that you there were like little wires that you put on your head and it was like you'd scratch your head and put it feel really good you know one of those like head massager things. Yeah. Oh, I'd like one of those. I had one of those ones, but it's just seemed like a waste of space. Not that it's big. But yeah, go and go and do like a little head massage thing or you know, just go and have a nice poo. Whatever you whatever is accessible to you. I'd be far better. And thanks for hanging out with me today on the podcast. And we'll see you in the next episode.

EP145 Transcript

You're listening to the Fierce Fatty podcast episode 145: Legends that fatphobia stole. Let's do it.

Hello, welcome to the Episode Hello. Welcome to the podcast nice to see to see you nice if you're British get that reference. How's life? Are you doing? What's going on with you? What's going on with me as I have moved apartments and there is apartments facing my apartment. And I've witnessed a person in the apartment opposite me. I'm having a beautiful friendship with the seagull. Yes, this person opens their window and the seagull come and lands on the windowsill like seven floors up eight floors up. And they feed the Seagull and then another seagulls hanging up the top. So I think maybe multiple seagulls are being fed. And I feel like I'm in a David Attenborough documentary. Because also there's a tree outside my new apartment that an owl lives in. And so the crows of the neighborhood are like this motherfucker. An owl is in my motherfucking tree and go bananas when they see the owl. They're not going wild today. No coring, but I'm like I love the you know everyone's like, there's a fucking owl chat everybody in the house like, dude, I'm trying to sleep like I'm not turn or chill. So yeah, totally in nature right now. I'm not in. I'm in. I'm in downtown Vancouver so I'm not in nature. But I see you can see a tree so it's pretty amazing. Yeah, so if you're watching the video, you might recognize that it looks different I don't have any of my paintings up there anything yet so yeah, I got someone from TaskRabbit I don't know if you've ever heard of TaskRabbit before but it's a website where you can hire people to do any type of thing that you want. Think within reason like so I got a couple of people to come and help me move. And then also I got someone to do some handiwork around the place unfortunately this guy that did the handiwork right feels like he fucked up everything in my wardrobe right I asked him to put a pole in the pole is wonky.

I asked him to put so there was a shelf only in the wardrobe and and so I said can you just move that up a little bit? So you know, we put the pole in and the guy was like really tall and so he's put the shelf like four inches from the ceiling so I can't reach it or put anything in there and most of the space and he's done that with the whole room close it too. And then like I asked him to hang my my vacuum my Dyson it's wonky and hang a curtain pole and he did half of it and there was like no context this is this is a can't do this. He was saying that the curtain pole it was curtain poles fault and I was like oh okay, but no, I don't think so. Because then like a couple days later the whole thing just fell down Oh, yeah, so I've got another one another another person coming out in a week to finish the jobs and stuff and yeah, so fix the jobs I actually rehang the pole myself and also put the in my closet put the the shelf where it should be but I did an imperfect job the shelf is wonky so so now that now the poll is still looks longer because the shelf above it is like slightly on an angle so yeah, so I'm going to wait for someone else to do it because it's just too much for my brain. I can do it like I bought a bought some drill bits and shit so but it's just not worth my worth my brainpower and I think it's about it's about 40 to 60 bucks an hour ish, depending on the skill of the handy person or that you're someone's like a professional but it's it's more, but I mean, it's good to know. Anyway, so today's episode it's pretty heavy. And so if let me change that word because the word heavy implies bad thing. are heavy or hurt are bad or are are difficult. So let's let's change that phrasing. It's pretty difficult to hear maybe for some people, for a lot of people, maybe there is talk about eating disorders. There's talk about deaths because this is we're talking about here in this episode, famous people who died, potentially at the hands of fat phobia. So almost everyone in this episode are people who have died, who have died, potentially tragically died from died too young. died because of maybe because of fat phobia. And also talking about fat phobic stuff people say about fat celebrities when they die. Talking about diet pills, we're talking about stomach amputation and squeezing surgery. We're talking about facelift. We're talking about there might be mentioned of calories. Maybe there might be mentioned of weight. I don't think I'll probably take the weight out depending on this, talking about mental health stuff. So if any of that is not feeling good, then skip the episode. And come see me next week. Just a quick update on last week's episode talking about the vacation. And the vacation Shawn. We had lots of people complete the survey. If you haven't completed the survey, please do so. Because then also you'll get to let us know where you want to go. When I say us I mean me and and also it it means that your email will be in the system so we can let you know when it's announced. So far people's top three favorite destinations top for Ireland. You choose Ireland is because Irish mommy, and you want to go see the Irish mommy, Ireland, Italy. And no New Orleans. Yeah, New Orleans and coastal Maine. Also on there was lower down on the list was Dominican Republic. and Mexico. The reason why I bring those up is remember last week, I said you know my ideas about this vacation. It's really important for me that it's accessible. And the fat fat folks who've who've hosted vacations, who are fat, fat influences have tended to pick locations that were the top requested, which were also happened to be deeply inaccessible. So for example, somewhere like Italy, because we have in Canada, and also the US we have ATA is called something else in in, in Canada, American Disabilities Act. And so we've got like this set of standards that we that we know that certain places will adhere to and what they actually mean. Other countries don't necessarily have that. And also say somewhere like Italy, if we're going to be going to Italy and Rome and a lot of places a cobbled streets, a lot of places. It's walking tours, all of the things is walking tours. And so I asked folks, what are your excess? What your What are your accessibility needs a few folks said one person said that they would need a mobility device and someone else a couple of other people said we don't want long walking tours. And so because of an as well, because of what I'm looking to do is more chill I want you know, beach time relaxing go and maybe doing an activity that doesn't involve climbing a mountain and things like that, right? It's really important for me to be accessible so and so I really want to know if we did choose between Mexico and the Dominican Republic and there's a reason why I'm using those two specifically is because both of those locations, the locations that have been previously scattered out have been a body positive seal of approval of fat positive seal of approval. Now I'm working with the tour operators to absolutely nail down what that means but so far no activities where there is a weight limit under 500 pounds. rooms that can be on the first floor with showers that you can walk or wheel into large towels in the in the hotel. I said What does large mean? Let's clarify what large means because you know thing people like that towel is huge. And then we put you know if that person uses and it's like, oh, it's a smaller base, it's more Wasserman. cloth. Yeah, so also, people who are running the tours have also had sensitivity training. So that sounds good, right? That sounds good. Versus if we went to somewhere like Italy, that there would not be any of that stuff, right. And here's another thing, Italy, or anywhere in Europe is a lot more expensive than Dr. or Mexico, or Costa Rica makeup, maybe. So, but I'm wondering, you know, I'm gonna do what you want to do. And so if you're like, Vinny, I don't care about all that fat shit, you know, I'm fat, but I just want to go and, you know, eat some pizza, and whatever, in Italy, you know, go and ride on some Italian decks or whatever, you know, that's what you're interested in. And the whole accessibility thing isn't even, or even the sensitivity training and the fact positivity angle is not of interest to you, then let me know. But if that is important, please, please let me know. And so that means go into the the survey, I'll put it in the show notes. And letting me know that Mexico, or Dominican Republic is where you want to go. If we see that moving up, the it's in the top 10. Right now, if we see that moving up, for where you want to go, then we'll know that that is important for folks. And if you have accessibility requirements or needs, please email me and let me know fattie at first fatty.com It's really important. So I can understand what is needed. And also the thing is, you know, folks could say, Absolutely, we have accessibility needs, but we don't know if those those folks are gonna come on the trip, right? Because this is all very preliminary. So the more information that we have, the better. All right, so, I mean, I'm biased. I'm like, I wanted to make it fat positive. And relaxing on the beach, you know, swimmin sand, Paul, love it. And, you know, the Italy thing is very kind of walking every day, walking, walking, walking, walking, some more walking, walking, walking, eating a pizza, does Morcombe so it's a totally different type of vibe. And a lot of people you know, like that. And I'm not saying that that's a bad thing. Like, I probably want to do that too. But it's not aligning with my vision. So let me know you might be like, Fuck your vision Vinny. We want Italian we don't Italy we want somewhere else as well.

So let me know go to the server knows anyway, so So know if you're not gonna listen to this episode, because you think it might trigger you can go now, leave. Enjoy your day. But let's get into Legends at fatphobia style. So just a kind of this is something that I've been thinking about because I watched the new bathroom and Elvis movie. I really enjoyed it, even though it felt I feel like it goes against my better judgment because it was very there was a nod to black culture which really Elvis just stole black culture. And you know, there wasn't a whole lot of there wasn't a lot of it, but I was like I'm only you know, there's a nod and Tom Hanks is wearing a fat suit. So I guess my better judgment I watched it and I enjoyed it a lot. Which is I don't know whatever my brain enjoyed it. But it made me think about is about Elvis obviously. How the how we talk about Elvis, you know, fat Elvis. Elvis died. Either the stories that we hear about why Elvis died, and the fact that he was he was so fat is what people say he was so fat, and he was just eating so much food and because he was so fat, and he he died on the toilet basically. And basically, and I think as well as well. There's another urban legend around someone else. But basically being fat and taking drugs is is what folks a lot of times talk about. And it's very what I was reading stuff about Elvis the words that people were using, gorging, you know, out of control, locked himself in the way in his room just so heavy and things like that. And I was just like, shit, like, That's fucked up. And in the film, you know, his an in real life is his mum. She died young and she was fat. Let's say she wasn't fat, fat. She was more kind of like a small fat person. But that was kind of I really liked seeing that seeing that that Elvis had that as a part of his life is a fat person. in his life, and then all that shit that he got anyway, so it made me think about all of the other celebrities that have died, potentially at the hands of fat phobia or maybe in very much more likely at the hands of fat phobia. And the they don't necessarily need to be fat because we know fat phobia affects everyone. Of course it affects fat folks. Much more and more, you know, if you have other marginalized identities, even more fat phobia does affect everyone. So I want to start off with Amy Winehouse. So Amy Winehouse, I love a bit of when Amy Winehouse music, I really wish that she didn't die, so that she could have made more music for me to listen to so very selfishly. But I remember when Amy Winehouse was first coming around, and I remember seeing her image in a, you know, women's magazine. And this is when she before she was actually famous. It was kind of like, Oh, look at this new up and coming up and coming singer. And she was described described as like plus size or curvy. And she ABS she wasn't she was just kind of she was straight size with it with a tiny little bit of kind of a no, not even a roll like she had big breasts. And that's a lot of times is people equate that to being curvy, anyway. And then obviously her body changed. And then people had opinions to say when she had a bigger body. And people had opinions to say when she had a smaller body. So let me quote from this article, which I'm going to buy from pitchfork. And it's we need to talk about Amy Winehouse is eating disorder and its role in her death. So let me quote from this. I'll link to that in the show notes. There is a tacitly accepted set of rules that our culture follows when it comes to women in the spotlight. They're required to be thin, they do not eat a normal diet and that in itself is seen as normal, not even dangerous. disordered eating is so normalized in our culture, especially in celebrity culture, that a few people even acknowledge that it is not healthy. And few people even acknowledged that it's not healthy and very potentially fatal. Eating Disorders fall in line with what society expects of a celebrity. We love thinner, so much yet we know we're supposed to be repulsed by the means of achieving that fit thinness. It's easier to scrutinize their lifestyle or their partying than ever examined the toll of staying under a certain weight. Amy Winehouse learned those ugly rules of womanhood early as footage from a safe Cambodia's devastating much praise documentary, Amy reveals a teenaged Winehouse snacking with her friends laments between mouthfuls that she's a pig and cannot help herself. In a voiceover during the sequence. The singers mother Janice Janis Winehouse recounts the moment of a young Amy tells her mother about discovering a great new diet, eating and then vomiting that allows her to eat without gaining weight. That section goes on to say that her mom and her dad kind of weren't alarmed by this and the way that Amy was talking about her body because they just thought it was normal teenager stuff, which, you know, that makes sense. But also, it sounds alarming to me. But you know, I've got many years of hindsight, maybe at the time, I would have been like, oh, anyway, continuing this casual dismissal from her parents. The first mention of Amy Winehouse is eating disorder is wrenching, and comes almost halfway into the film. For many viewers. This may be the first time they've ever heard about it. Winehouse is eating disorder, as well documented as her struggles with alcohol and drug addiction were the tiny little fact of her severe, untreated decade long eating disorder was rarely mentioned. When her fineness was mocked in the media, it was almost always with the implication that Hey, Alex are always skinny little wrecks, if a puffy face was ever evaluated, and it was because every aspect of her physical appearance was eviscerated during the height of the media's obsession with her. It was through the lens of someone looking for signs of alcohol addiction, which commonly causes bloating in the face, and not signs of self induced vomiting. So what they're talking about there is you can have someone with someone who might be vomiting, a lot might have in gorged or enlarged or puffy salivary glands, and they are kind of on your face underneath your ear. Kind of kind of like yeah, where you were, you'd know that no, yes. salivary glands if you think about it in your, in your mouth at the back. Actually, we know we've got we've got two foot. We've got some at the front and then some at the back, right? Anyway and so it's kind of like a bit on your jaw. And so what they're saying here is that people were like, Oh, look, her face is puffy even though she's thin because it's alcohol, but not realizing that it might be her Ed. Continuing yet, Amy Winehouse is eating disorder wasn't simply yet another bad decision. Because here they're saying that, you know, oh, look, look at Amy Winehouse, that she just making bad decisions left, right and center. The environmental and genetic factors at play in wine houses childhood and adolescence, adolescence put her at extremely high risk for developing an eating disorder and the lack of early intervention education and stable guidance meant the disease was able to firmly take root and flourish as she was put in higher and higher stress situations. Yeah, and not only higher and higher stress situate situations like say if she had a an average career she was you know, working in an office and she had high stress situations. She was in the public eye and exactly that word that they used eviscerated, eviscerated her appearance. And yeah, according to the National Association for anorexia nervosa and associated disorders, quote, there isn't one conclusive cause of eating disorders, multiple factors are involved. This is genetics, metabolism for psychological issues such as control coping skills, trauma, personality factors, family issues, and social issues, such as a culture that promotes sickness, and media that transmits this message. So this is important to note is that it's complicated, right? Eds are complicated. But here's one thing to think about. I think it's very rare that someone who has an eating disorder happens to be fat positive. No, not for others for themselves. I think what the one thing is when you know, can they be fat positive towards others? And that's, I'd say that much more likely, because they can probably say, Absolutely, this person looks great. But what if we looked at that internalized fat phobia in themselves? And how much are they struggling with that? Everyone has weight bias everyone?

Even me? So it goes goes without saying that also those with with EDS have weight bias because we've been raised in a society and been given messages that says fatness is not good, right. And you would have to be pretty spectacular to not absorb any of that information. Not even spectacular, like, I'm sure it's happened, you know, that's probably most of the places that it could have happened. But, you know, on the whole, generally speaking, we are, you know, we all have that bias. Same way that we're all racist and ableist. And, you know, just goes with having a human brain. Okay, continuing when one house has many visits to treatment centers and her many attempts to go clean, all center and recovering from drug and alcohol abuse, but they seemingly never address a CO CO morbid eating disorder, despite the fact that it was ruinous to her her health. And was the disease that she had been suffering from the longest amount of time. Yeah, absolutely. And, in the in the s some other things here, it seems like with with a lot of folks is if someone that happens to be curvy, or chubby, or is I don't even need to be is people saying you need to lose weight and a lot of celebrities are told they need to lose weight for for whatever reason, because of fat phobia. And the framing of that initial you need to lose weight almost always seems to be unless a person who's already very small, seems to be a positive thing. You know, like, especially in fatter bodied people. Oh, well, we were doing something good to become thinner and then it got out of control. And it's like, Well, why is it that you have to have a smaller body for it to be quote out of control. And why was it good when they had a bigger body and why is it now bad? Now they have a smaller body and it's because of fat phobia. Right. Okay, Amy. Amy Winehouse is official cause of death was alcohol poisoning, but this can be understood as the equivalent of someone with AIDS who have who has died from complications from pneumonia. Similar to the way HIV compromises the quality of body's ability to fight infection. Bulimia damages the body to the point where it is no longer able to keep up basic functions. He's more susceptible to external threats. A doctor interviewed in the film describes the White House's death as a combination of alcohol poisoning, poisoning and the weakened state of her body due to an eating disorder. But that acid assertion never made it into the official cause of death statement released to the public, after Whitehouse is passing. So that the article goes on to like, what if it was, what if we were more aware of the fact that it wasn't just alcohol or drugs that Amy was struggling with? It was also an ED. And where did that come from? How did that start? Why was Amy calling herself a pig when she was eating? And telling her parents that she's got this new great diet? Why was that not seen as alarming? At the time? You know, because she was, you know, ever so slightly? A little bit curvy, you know, again, I might not really, but you know, maybe was it because it was like, Well, you know, she could stand to be thinner, so why not? You know, and then, in that moment, perhaps, if her parents weren't invested in diet culture, or fat phobia, maybe her parents would have and it's not a parent's fault, but maybe her parents would have said, Darling, why is it that you want to be thinner? What's going on? Why is it you're calling yourself a pig? Why do you think that you need to be a pig to eat, you know, and have that support there? Amy died 23rd of July 2011, age 27.

Okay, next, Carrie Fisher. So, I wasn't aware of this. I got a message from a follower who said I could write a sonnet sonnet about this, but Carrie Fisher, her mental illnesses were well managed with meds but she gained weight. They quote needed her to be thinner to play general layer. So it's assumed she went off her meds to lose weight and use other less safe drugs to even out and it is very well may be what killed her. Because we couldn't have a fat general layer. It breaks my heart. Every time I think about it. So Carrie Fisher spoke about this spoke about the what she had to do to play. Princess Leia, General Leia, I don't I don't watch Star Wars, whatever it is, is it Star Wars? Some people are like, Oh, really. So she talked about she spoke about this more recently. So there's a good housekeeping article, titled, I'm in a business where the only thing that matter are weight and appearance. So Carrie reveals she was pressured to lose more than 35 pounds for the new film. And the new film being the second film that she was in in like the 80s. So they don't want to hire all of me. Only about three quarters, nothing changes. It's an appearance driven thing. I'm in a business where the only thing that matters is weight and appearance. That is so messed up. They might as well say get younger because that's how easy it is. Carrie Brown, Carrie Fisher was on say Carrie Broderick, Carrie Fisher, the things I've read about her since doing this research. I'm like, she was fucking badass, because she was talking how all this stuff is bullshit. And I'm loving it. So Stephen Colbert asked her about about that article that she did. And she added the first movie I had, I guess you'd still call it baby fat. The first movie I had, I guess you'd call it still baby fat. I'd like to call it that. But it was probably just fat. So I went to a fat farm where they harvest fat. She said a couple of other celebrities were there as well having their fat harvest. By the way, she didn't appear to be fat at all. From when I'm looking at the images, I think at the time she was seen as a sex symbol. Continuing meanwhile, Carrie previously revealed she had to lose two and a half stone to reprise the world in Star Wars The Force Awakens. She said nothing changes. It's an appearance driven thing. Oh yeah, I've read that quote already. And then she says when I do lose the weight, I don't like that. It makes me feel good about myself. It's not who I am. My problem is that they talk to me like an actress, but I hear them like a writer because she was also a writer. And so she was So she had to diet and stuff and so she also at the same time was dealing with mental health issues and coming off those drugs helped her become thinner temporarily. Then she was in another Star Wars movie in 2015. The Force Awakens, and people were talking shit about her body when she has co stars who are the same age as her Mark Hamill and Harrison Ford. Everyone was like, Oh, Mark Hamill is so nice. He's such a great guy and Harrison Ford is so hunky and Carrie Fisher Fisher. She hasn't aged well, when she looked exactly what she you know, she should look like as a human being at the age that she was. And so quote, Carrie Fisher has had it up to here with body shaming discussions about how she no longer looks like she did in the 1980s When Princess Leia squirmed around in a gold bikini while in prison prisons by Jabba the Hutt. In a series of tweets the former Star Wars Star, now Best Selling Author took to social media to address some of the body shaming comments being made unfavorably comparing Leia in The Force Awakens to her smelter appearance 30 plus years ago, in The Return of the Jedi, she these are the tweets she said, please stop debating about whether or not I aged well. Ultimately, it hurt through all three of my feelings. My body hasn't aged well as I have, as it hasn't aged as well as I have. So Carrie Fisher died of a heart attack. Her daughter stated that Fisher battled drug addiction and mental illness her entire life. She ultimately died of it, she was purposefully open in all of her work about the social stigmas around this these diseases. And oh my mum, she'd want her death to encourage people to be open about their struggles. And as well. I wonder, you know, how much of data to know 2015 When she was in this in this in this movie? She died in 20 16/27 of December age 60. did how did that that affect her? You know she's she's got these these tweets. And she's she's quite sassy, like fuck off sort of thing. But she's also saying I haven't aged well, I mean, I don't know about that statement, because what is what is aging? Well, what does that mean? And so did that then spur her to come off? Her medications for that helped her with her mental health? Did that also help with her? Maybe taking some diet pills or something? I don't know. I don't know. What happened when she did take diet pills. And I did an episode on diet pills. And they really really are very, very dangerous as well alongside yo yo dieting weight cycling, which is basically just dieting is really not good for your heart. Yeah, so just something to think about there. All right, so Cass Elliot, Cass Elliot, if you don't know was a singer, or the lead singer. Maybe the Mamas and Papas? Which was a band from the 70s 19 1970s I think I sang all the all the trees. Let me do it properly. Let me find out exactly what they sang. California dream and I think that's what they did like Google Google and Googling, Googling, Googling songs. California Dreaming Yeah. Dream a Little Dream of me seeing that one, as well. See the lyrics of California Jim. All the leaves. Leaves a brown and the sky is gray and the sky is gray. I've been for I've been for a walk on Awareness Day on a winter's day, right? Because a lot. Now you're like, Oh, I guess I know who you're talking about. In case you don't know. Or maybe you don't even recognize that song.

Right. So quoting from an article from voc. Mama Cass Elliot died almost 50 years ago, but her memory is still obscured by fat phobia. It was a death heard about round the world or at least around California. On July 29 1974, Mama Cass Cass Elliot, one of the most memorable and charismatic members of the Los Angeles based folk rock group, the Mamas and Papas died in her sleep in a London apartment at the age of 32. There are too many similar stories to count about musical legends passing away before they time Jimmy Janice, Kurt, and all the other members of the morbidly named 27 Club come to mind but Elliott's death stands out in part because of the baseless rumor that has persisted for nearly half a century specifically that she died by choking on a ham sandwich. I first heard that story sometime in my late teens shortly after discovering the song California Dreaming in the way that young people love to discover retro music, which is to say, insufferably, at the time it occurred to me as a mere historical oddity. What a weird way to go. But now having learning more learn more about Eliot's short and pain field life, I'm struck by the fact that one of the few fat women in pre ops music history is forever tethered to an ugly urban legend, implying that her death was brought about by food. appetite, was what killed Elliot, the now debunked legend seem to say an appetite so big and out of control that she couldn't tame it to even fit the punishing norms for women's bodies in the 1970s. America. For most fat people, this fear of Gluttony is nothing new. We're constantly told that our bodies are too big, that we're too lazy that we're driving up healthcare premiums simply by existing in our skin. I'll never know Eliot or understand what it felt like to be one of the few highly visible fat women in a society marred by unchecked fat phobia. But I think I can guess what it might have been like to stand on stage every night before an audience who saw you as either a threat or a joke. Of course, Eliot was adored by legions of fans juggler just like other folk rock, Sean toussis all her time, but things were different for her. Even her own band poked fun at her weight, including the line. No one's getting fat except Mama Cass in the lyrics to the 1967 song Creek alley. Hiding behind the hand sandwich legend, which has now been thoroughly disproven is a much grimmer backstory to Mama Cass is life and death, one which is far too which far too many people will be able to identify. In February 2020 episode of The Hollywood law podcast you must remember this, the Oakland based writer Lexi pandal, explained that the actual cause of Eliot's death was heart failure brought on at least in part by a history of crafted crash dieting, in an effort to lose the weight that all defined all but to find her image. Elia had experimented with drugs, but none were present in her system at the time of her death, nor was there any food in her windpipe. According to coroner Keith Simpson, and its official cause of death was labeled as fatty myocardial degeneration due to Oh word, but that would still be a shocking cause of death for such a young woman and has largely been refuted. pandal tells me from the research I've done and the doctors I've spoken, I spoke to it seems the most likely cause of death was extreme dieting, in combination with long term substance abuse. Pan Dell believes that present day fat phobia contributes to a continued lack of understanding about how how Eliot actually died, in part because confronting the possibility that cast may have died due to extreme dieting. Challenges are idealization of diet culture. There is a wealth of evidence out there about how unhealthy extreme dieting can be. I'm going to come in here and say, not even extreme dieting, not to mention ineffective in the long term with a 97% of dieters gaining back every pound they lost and then some within three years. Unfortunately, though, during the span of Eliot's all too short life, to be thin, was widely considered empirically good and healthy, while fatness was seen as health, compromising, and morally suspect regardless of the specific of an individual's health status, or medical history. Despite all the body positive gains that have been made in the last half century, far too many of us are still stuck in that binary blinkered mindset. We also have a quote from an article that Mama Cass was quoted in, she says, I've invented a fabulous new diet, it costs only 2000 dollars for each pound you lose. It also weakens your natural resistance to disease. I can't guarantee it but the mammoth cast diet can give you acute tonsillitis, hemorrhaging vocal cords, mono Lukey, mono, and a dangerous case of hepatitis. At least that's what it did for me. I lost my house and more than a quarter of a million dollars in earnings as a singer. Yeah. And I watched her. Her last her last appearance on TV, I watched her the beginning segment of it, her mom was in the audience. And I just saw in a few days, that mom is going to be heartbroken. And even Cass Elliot was saying, Oh, she passed out. She said she passed out because she hadn't eaten all day. And I was alarmed by that. But the host was just like, oh, change the subject about rings that she was wearing. And then then she went back onto it. And she was like, Yeah. And it was kind of embarrassing, because, you know, I passed out with curlers in my hair when there was lots of people around. And again, the host doesn't say anything about it. And then there was a kid on the stage, and the kid was had this big jar of candy and was eating the candy. And the kid said, Oh, you can have some and she said, Oh, it's okay. I've already had some. And she said she again, she said, I haven't eaten all day. So I needed to quickly grab something to keep me going, is what she said. And to me that was if a straight size person was sat on that stage and said, I passed out because I didn't eat anything all day long. And I had to just grab some candy there because I haven't eaten I need to keep going. Would that host be like, oh my goodness, it sounds like you're not eating enough. That sounds kind of like you need to eat. But he was totally ignored. And I doubt that anyone else really picked up on that. And if they did, they will probably like, well, good for her. She's trying to lose weight. When she was saying that it was you know, it caused her to pass out. And then, you know, shortly after, from what this doctor is saying, you know, chronic dieting took a life and then very Crawley because I think she was staying in actually another famous person's house. And in the house, I think there was a ham sandwich around. And so the the medical examiner who was there the rumor got started because their medical examiner was there. It was like, Oh, look, there's a ham sandwich. Perhaps she choked eating it. And I mean, how fucked up is that? Would a straight sized person who was lying dead? Who happened to there was happened to be food around in the apartment? Have a medical examiner say oh, it's probably because they were eating and then that that's how the rumor got started. Because that was then shared with the press. And they're just like, well, of course it could this fat person who died eating and it wasn't true. And he did say that the medical examiner an autopsy needs to be done to find out exactly, but here's an idea. Because she was 32. Right? And she shouldn't be dying. There's there's no reason for her to be dying. And so it's not like it's you know, maybe an older person. It's like, oh, well, you know, they died of old age. And so there needs to be a reason there. What's going on. So she died July 29 1974, age 32. I really wish that she had she'd stuck around looking at pictures of her oh my gosh, she was fucking cool. And she was fat by the way in case there's any confusion that she was one of the people here that we're talking about the was actually fat and had spent so much time and effort to try and become thin. Alright, so let's go to another from the 70s Karen Carpenter. Karen was a singer in the pop duo the carpenters. They did the song. Why do birds suddenly up he every time you are.

So that was Karen Karen Carpenter. So this is a quote from the independent ie the real reason Karen Carpenter was driven to anorexia she died from anorexia. Kara's disorder is described as having started out innocently Enough, innocently enough when she wanted to lose a few pounds after leaving high school, she had been a chubby teenager and in 1973 she saw a photo of herself that prompted her to take action. She had put on weight and didn't look good and didn't look good in her stage outfit. So the independent says doesn't look who says. So she hired a personal trainer who put her on a carbohydrate based diet. She also had friends who told her that she was too big. Naturally, she began to bulk up she fired her trainer and took her own extreme measures. She lost 20 pounds and quote looked fabulous, said a sister of an old boyfriend. But unfortunately, she didn't stop there. At restaurants, Karen pushed her food around a plate and urged friends at the table to try her meal stealthily getting rid of her food was given the impression she was enjoying her meal so much she wanted others to try to. In 1975, Karen was admitted to hospital physically and emotionally exhausted from two years on the road and years of extreme dieting. This particular occasion got that her mother's attention, and she nursed Karen, she even regained some weight. Finally, she died from eye peak ipecac poisoning that which is a drug used to induce vomiting in overdose cases. And Karen had been using it as another way of controlling her weight. She was not aware of its side effects of slowly dissolving the hearts muscle muscles and had been taking it every day. She died February 4 1983, age 32. Yeah, and so I'm thinking, you know, Ed is a complicated, right. But what is the starting thing here? She saw a photo of herself. And she didn't like the fact that she'd put on weight. Which is, which is fatphobia her friends and family told her to lose weight. Why did they tell her to lose weight when she she clearly wasn't not ever fat? Right? Why did they believe that that was the best course of action. Perhaps they were trying to prepare her for a success in a fat phobic world. Perhaps she was trying to prepare herself for success in a fat phobic world by being as soon as possible. Because that was what we're told, is needed. So let's talk about Elvis. And Elvis is kind of like well, I just want to talk about him. So quote, Presley was one of the biggest musical sensations ever, but he was human and had feelings. His former girlfriend Linda Thompson shared that the weight gain really bothered him. So he had gained weight in the later part of his life. According to elvis.com, she said it was living life out of the public eye. He was living life and eating out of the public eye and eating at all hours. It just feels so unkind to be talking about him like this press, he loved food and cycles of weight gain began. Thompson added that he always battled with his weight, and the two of them structured their social life around eating. She also said that the weight game really did bother him. The formal model elaborated the criticism bothered him. He was a very sensitive, acutely sensitive person to other people's perceptions of him. And you know, he just, it did hurt his feelings a lot. So I'm thinking about that, you know that. We don't know that he took diet pills, but I was there something in that Elvis movie that made me think that he had anyway he was taking other other drugs? And so how did fat phobia contribute towards Elvis's experiences? In life? What was going on there? What? Why? Why is it you know, what he's saying his life revolved around food and, and all of these other really awful articles. I'm not going to read out this was like, the kindest that I could find. being like, Oh, he ate X amount of calories a day. And, you know, he was just all he ever did was eat and you know, and it's just to me, I'm like, is that true? Is that a good story to tell? If it is true? What is going on? What is? is L? Was he Okay, mentally? Was he? What was going on with him? You know, like, I'm just was he just trying to survive in this really, you know, difficult situation that he might have been in and watching the film was about how his manager financially abused him. And he was kind of stuck. kept the the comment what the name of the hotel is in Vegas with his residency forever and ever. And ever, he had a little freedom. And his manager made it so he couldn't leave because if he did, then he would be bankrupt and lose all his money money. So, I mean, is it a case of him trying to like with me with me when I was in an abusive relationship. One of the only sources of comfort that I had was food, it because I wasn't accessing, you know, drugs or alcohol or anything like that. But it was the only joy and it really did help me survive. At the time, I would say I was actually pretty straight seitan in a small fat person, but my boyfriend at the time had told me that I was too big. And so he put me on a diet and controlled everything that I ate. So I didn't have control when he was around for what I ate. And so I did when he wasn't around, and I think it saved me. Because that's what I had higher had access to. And I think about that with you know, obviously that's not everyone's story. And it's not it's probably not even a lot of people story, but that might that's what came up when I thought about Elvis. And, I mean, it could have been anything else as well. But the way that we talk about Elvis Elvis, as if he was like, just let himself go and who was this? Just, you know, the thing. I don't even want to repeat them like the words they were saying about him. Okay, so Anna Nicole Smith. Recently, she lost a reported 69 pounds and became a spokeswoman for trim spa, and weight loss supplements. She always had problems with her weight going up and down. And there's no question she used alcohol. It was no secret that she quote had a very troubled life and had so many problems. She wanted to be like Marilyn Monroe her whole life and ironically died in a similar manner. Monroe died of a drug overdose at age 66 in 1962. And Anna Nicole Smith died of an overdose of diet pills. Correction, it wasn't diet pills. I was looking at us looking at a different link here. It was combinations of lots of different drugs. But I mean, she was a spokesperson for this trim spa. And I wonder how much of you know she says struggling with her weight. So I wonder how much of what was going on with Anna Nicole Smith was linked to her desire for thinness. Okay, so this is the thing that I was looking at the star who did die from diet pills. Police Academy star Bubba Smith died from diet pill overdose. Police Academy star and NFL legend Bubba Smith died from taking too many diet pills. According to the LA coroner, county coroner. They released the actor's cause of death the first which of which was acute. I wouldn't want to say the name of the diet pill intoxication. This This name is a generic name for a weight loss medication. He was six foot seven and died at age 66. Okay, Shane Walker knows Shane Warne, a famous cricketer. I don't know about cricketing, but Shane Warren was on extreme 14 day diet as new details of tragic death emerged. Age 52 His manager James Erskine revealed that he resorted to radical measures to lose weight and had just finished an extreme and quote ridiculous cleanse in which he had only fluids for about 14 days. We don't know that's if that was what killed him but it happened to they happen to mention that

Joan Rivers she didn't die from fatphobia but I she died from having a facelift and so why are people haven't faced this because beauty culture because of ageism. Her daughter Melissa Rivers has filed a maltron Petrus practice suit against Yorkville endoscopy, the New York City clinic that treated her mother Joan for a minor through surgery last August and she had a facelift. The procedure had complications and Joan Rivers went into cardiac arrest. She died a week later To Takashi six nine. Still alive. Young a young person was hospitalized after ingesting a combo of diet pills and caffeine. According to multiple sources and as covered by people, the rapper was admitted to a Florida Hospital after admittedly taking more than the suggested dosage. He told the Shade Room that instead of taking one pill, he took two and mixed it with a cup of coffee. After that his heart rate sped up and he began to sweat excessively the celebrity gossip account added that Takeshi to Kashi is recovering at home and is doing fine. The company that sells pills that he took asserts that it can help customers lose weight fast, without any unwanted side effects. However, history has provoked proven difficult. In fact, the pill that to Kashi took was linked to severe organ damage and multiple deaths, and has reportedly been removed from the market by the FDA multiple times. And another thing about diet pills. This is this article from CBS, Hollywood's dangerous weight loss secret. And it's talking about the kind of open secret about diet pill usage within Hollywood. Inherit quick quotes, they're reporting on the pressure on actresses and models to be thin causes some to find dangerous ways to find to speed up their weight loss along more people seem to be turning to drugs like bla bla bla, which is approved by in the United States to treat asthma in horses. The side effect of this drug is that it builds muscle and results in temporary weight loss. I hear it a lot in my gym and it's a dangerous drug. Hollywood fitness trainer said there isn't a magic pill if there was I'm a business person I'd be selling it I'd be taking it. But in Hollywood, some people are willing to trade their health to be thin celebrities and models are dissected on the red carpet and runways and face a lot of pressure to look perfect. If you're thin your success as successful said Ken Baker, a West Coast executive editor at US wiki Us Weekly, US Weekly, US Weekly I think that's it has become this epidemic that you have to be thin and too thin is never thin enough. Scarlett Palmer's who starred on The CW sitcom Reba is recovering from an eating disorder and says many young actresses feel they have got to get got to get skinny if they want to work. I definitely have heard horror stories from other actresses and actors too, that have been told, well lose 15 pounds, you can get that part. She said, It really just puts you in this place where you kind of don't know what's normal or not. A lot of these women in Hollywood are under such extreme pressure that they'll go to extreme mothers measures to get the look that they want. Some say this diet pill has become Hollywood's dirty little secret Hollywood hair stylists Ricardo Reyes have used the drug to drop weight. Why get there in three months? We can get there in a month? Well, the answer to that is because it is going to hurt you. Also, I'm just thinking about any celebrity who, who's died whilst being fat. Like what's his name? Chris Farley? That guy that was in Uncle Buck. John, John, what's his name? Uncle Buck. That was a good film, wasn't it? Do you remember that one? John Candy? Yeah, anyone who dies whilst being fat. It doesn't matter what their what they died from. People report it as they die from being fat. You know? Like Chris Farley, he took a speedball like, I can't remember it's a combination of two different drugs. And he died. And I'm reading articles about about him and it's like, well, he was so fat. What he dried what? And as well, like the way that when they were alive, they were portrayed. You know, like Chris Farley, he was famous. So he was on SNL Saturday Night Live. He was famous for this Chippendales sketch where him and Patrick Swayze audition for the Chippendales. That was the sketch right? And it was the joke was that Chris Farley was fat. And look at this this guy, Patrick Swayze, who was muscley and toned and tanned and tall and oh, look at this Chris Farley. He was shorter than him fat, visibly fat. And then they both take the shirts off and they're both just dancing. And then the joke is the joke is all they can't decide which one to pick. And it's like, it's an the joke is it's so ridiculous because clearly, Patrick Swayze is the perfect person to be a Chippendales model because Chris Farley is fat As I mentioned, they go with Patrick Swayze. And how much of a fat person who is in the media spotlight is their fat nurse is just a core part of their, quote, personality, you know. And as well, we think about diet pills. Also, celebrities will undergo stomach amputation or stomach squeezing surgery. And so I'm just going to not that folks have died from it. But there's a list of people who've had bariatric surgery. And so Rosie O'Donnell, who was told that she needed to lose weight and so she had surgery after trying a diet. I don't know, I don't know, this is a before and after picture, and I can't really see that much difference. Lisa Lampanelli. Don't know who she is, but apparently she's famous. And her before pictures, she seems pretty dry size or small or small fat. And she says For 32 years from the age of 18 to 50. I tried everything on the planet to become thin. And anyway, I what I've done a few episodes, episodes on gastric surgery, and it's really, really fucked up and the results. I mean, the studies that we have around it, absolutely lacking shocking. The information is not showing that this surgery is, is good. It'll help people temporarily lose weight, surprise, surprise, has terrible side effects, really high death rate from surgery, increased risk of tons of different things. But for some folks, it does make them smaller. And so they're like, Oh my God, my life is amazing now, which is fine. If that's if that's what's worked for them, then I'm happy that they haven't had negative outcomes because the you know, that's a really difficult thing to go through. But, you know, why are these people going through these surgeries? They're famous people wonder why, let's continue. Randy Jackson Jackson, the former American Idol judge because he was diagnosed with with type two diabetes. He tried lots of different things to get thin. Get this. He says liquid fasts, bee stings, urine of pregnant women. You name it. I've tried it. And then he says that he has a disease which is the O word. In 2003. Randy got gastric bypass surgery and lost x pounds when he began to gain some of the weight back Carnie Wilson of the pop group Wilson Phillips a few months afterwards she says it was the right decision for her. I will Roker everyone's favorite weatherman. He has a memoir never going back winning the weight loss battle for good. He promised His dad on his deathbed that he would lose weight. He wasn't even that be Sharon Osbourne she had lap band surgery in 1999. She says the procedure procedure made her very sick so she had the band removed in 2006. I've struggled with weight weight my entire life. I've been fat and I've been thin she told Us Weekly as you know I got the lap band and I lost a ton of weight but it made me so sick that's why I had to remove it. But when I removed it I gained 45 pounds. Cabaret said of a Roseanne Barr Mama June Shannon so that was from what was her name Honey BooBoo. Yeah So Mama June from Honey BooBoo had a gastric sleeve surgery in 2006. She says doing all the surgeries really took a toll on me not just physically but emotionally. Graham Elliot, the start a master Master Chef judge, Lauren Manzo. The real high foot housewives who lives of New Jersey.

Got a lap band when she was 24. And they share her weight. She was small. She says getting the lap band was the best thing I've ever done in my life. Star Jones Co hosts of the view, NFL coach and current ESPN analyst Rex Ryan Abby Lee Miller from Dance Moms, Austin chumlee Russell from porn stars. And the list goes on. Etta James No. Etta James, you know, last mile love has come along. Yeah, so the list goes on and on. As you know, probably a lot of folks who've had surgery and I mean if someone wants to have surgery Go Go for it. But I wonder why, you know, the pressures of that. Being in the public eye is probably a lot, a lot harder. I can't even imagine I've said this before, if, if a celebrity does anything to try and become thin, I totally understand it. And that's why I titled it. Legends of fatphobia stole because I really feel folks that they are victims to systems of oppression, that hurt, hurts many, many peoples and they've got the added layer of being in the public eye. And I mean, you know, who started I started out with Amy Winehouse and the way that the press spoke about Amy's body. I don't know how anyone could survive that. I mean, even if someone was was really, you know, had a therapist I could talk to every day and their mental health was in tip top condition. And then they had papers by paparazzi falling, following them everywhere and at their front doorstep. And then writing absolutely awful shit about even when she was not theoretically using drugs, or alcohol. was still talking shit about her body. And it doesn't matter. You know what, what people do? Celebrities, people are always going to criticize our bodies are too big to bat too thin. But obviously, the driving force behind a lot of this is weight bias is the idea that thinness is superior to fatness, which is not true. Yeah. So what do you think? Is there? Is there anyone else that you can think of? There's probably many right that I've totally missed. And, you know, there's many that we maybe don't even know about, I know that death was was ruled as there so that without the Elvis prevalent Presley, his autopsy has been sealed. And it's sealed until 50 years after his death, which is 2027. And so in five years time, we're gonna be able to see the autopsy results to know what really was going on. And, you know, there's lots of different theories about what happened to him. But I think the the cause of death that they announced was heart attack, maybe I think that's what it was. Yeah. But if we think about fat phobia, anti fat bias, as in understanding the harm that it causes to our physical and mental health, it absolutely has contributed to many, many deaths, and many of the deaths that I've spoken about today. And it's hard to be absolutely sure, right, because it's a very complicated issue. But I think that for a lot of these folks, especially the ones with EDS, there was that underlying anti fat bias that definitely contributed to a lot of those experiences that they had in their lives, which was was not okay, you know, that, that I really do have compassion for people who were in the public eye. Because I mean, I don't know if I could do that, to have people write about me constantly and pick up pick apart every single part of me, in a, in a world that supports fatphobia. Sounds really difficult. So I wish that these folks were able to live without that. And obviously, that wasn't the case. And hopefully, celebrities of today, we're going to be able to treat them with a little bit more kindness when it comes to bodies. And I think, you know, yes, there will be but there's always going to be this idealization of fineness, at any cost. And if you think about it, like in that one, where it was like, the hidden secret, which is diet pills in Hollywood, what would you do? If you were told you needed to lose X amount of weight to get into this film, and potentially become rich and famous? And you knew you had to do it in two weeks or something? I mean, I wouldn't be sure that I would say no, you know, like, I you know, we're sitting here right now I but I will, no, I would, that wouldn't happen, because I wouldn't be in that situation or that. But what if I was trying to be an actor? What if I was told that I am sis close to achieving my dreams, and all I need to do is become thinner? Would I say no? And go back to you know, and let my dreams die, theoretically, or would I just do it? I think a lot of us would just do it, you know, and I'm saying, who knows what I would do because you'd think, Oh, it's just so close. We're so close. If I just lose this amount of weight, I'll be thin enough, you know, trying to get to this place that doesn't exist and even And then if you do happen to become famous it doesn't stop it doesn't stop it just gets worse because you have more eyes on you dissecting your body anyway let me know if you've got anyone else that you think should have been in this episode. I'd love to hear about it and obviously not everyone is episode died just in case you're like hang on did Takashi six nine die? No all the other people who had gastric surgery none of that none of them died. Yeah, and you know, we've talked about a lot of darker kind of stuff today and fucked up stuff today. So if you need to go and do a little bit of self care I would encourage it go and go and watch something amazing on Netflix or go and look at some fat positive accounts or watch like some funny cat fail videos. Have a good I was doing that last night when it was like two in the morning. I was like go to fucking bed. Stop watching these and then it goes into like funny fail videos and it goes into watching idiot drivers. I was watching like for an hour so silly that I was like, Okay, enough. Enough go to bed. And I did. Anyway, thanks for hanging out with me today. I hope you are having a wonderful day and have a wonderful rest of your week and life if I never if I never hear from you again. Okay, goodbye. See you in a while alligator. Perfect.

EP144 Transcript

You're listening to the Fierce Fatty Podcast. Do you want to go on vacation with me? Let's do it.

Hey, hey, hey, face fan ease. How you doing? We got a special episode today where it's just chatting about chatting about going on a vacation with you. With you. Yes, I've spoken about it before. This has been like long time planning long time coming. But I'm officially starting the process of organizing a vacation for fatties. And I want to get your input before we start the planning process. Well, this is the planning process before we start the confirmation of where we're going. So I mean, it's really timely because it started raining in Vancouver this week, and I cracked out my jumpers. And so yeah, I'm ready. I'm ready to go to somewhere hot. Yeah, so there's a link in my in the show notes, which will take you to a questionnaire to see where you want to go, what do you want to do? What's, what's your budget, or that type of stuff. So the company that so this is, this is a this is a deal, this is a deal. So there's different companies out there, you might have seen other people doing something similar, but there's companies out here, which is such a great idea that help people organize trips for their community, and they take care of everything. I will just see who wants to go and then they just book everything do everything. Look after everything, look after us. And the the company that I'm I'm working with is called trover trip. And I've been talking to them for probably about six months now. And I'm just really impressed with their knowledge on fat activism, and accessibility, disability rights, all that type of stuff. So because I was like, listen, I know these types of trips, it's just you know, trips made for thin. You know, active, hyperactive, high, not hyperactive, but super active people who were. And we don't think about fat folks. But this is not the case with this company, they've really made efforts to make sure certain trips are are inclusive, which is really cool. So that's why I decided to go with them. And they have really helped me craft this vision that I have for a vacation with with the first community which is a vacation where fat folks are obviously right at the center. And accessibility is incredibly important. The theme I've decided not that vacations need to have themes, but it was like our theme and the theme is fat joy. That joy. So this is this is these are the things that are important for me, my goals, it would be to a location that you can fly to with an airline that has a customer of size policy. And it would be accessible to those with limited mobility or folks who have disabilities, as well as non disabled fatties. There will be COVID Private protocols in place. And we will be doing activities together that have been vetted in advance to make sure that there are they are safe and fun for fatties. And we can all do together. So what they do is they have tour guides on on site in on location, and they will vet the activities to make sure is good, you know, because sometimes when you go on vacation, you're like, I'm gonna go on this thing and who knows, who knows, like one time when I was in Greece, I went to Greece like 20 years ago. There was it was it was this tiny little tiny little, I don't want to say village, maybe town. It was a really small community.

Anyway, and so we went on this horse tour this horse tour so it feels very like we were we were driven to this out into the country and it was a blister During a hot day, and this is me and my then boyfriend, we couldn't speak the language. And so we went these, like, we went around around the area on these two horses and I was like, the horses, they looked like they were like, fuck, you know, we don't want to do this, we're hot. We just want to go and have a nap and you know, eat some hay. Anyway, so we went around, it was fun. I remember, they gave me a helmet. The helmet was a child's helmet. And I was like, Oh, it doesn't fit. And the guy came along and just hit the top of my helmet on my head. And it was like, We got stuck under my head, and you go, and he's like, there it fits now. I was like, Okay, anyway, and then at the end of the tour, I thought that the horse was straining under my way. I don't know if that was true, or if that was just my insecurity. And then of it, they were like, Okay, thanks. And they left us at this farm. And I said, someone will be here to pick you up. Take you back to the community. And we waited for ages, so much so that I got what is it when you're in out in the sun and you get to sit, you get sick from it. heatstroke then there was no shade. It was a field, right? There was no shade. It was awful. It's terrible. And in the car back and eventually did come pick us up in the car back. I was not like him, I had my head out the window because I was I was throwing up anyway, all that to say that there will be things like that where it's like, if this is this going to be good or not, it's going to be good. So there's lots of different things that we can do. So one of the things on one of the tours I saw that was really fun, like a sunset boat tour with optional snorkeling, and I thought, oh, that's gonna be really nice. And, and I don't want there to be a million activities every single day. I want it to be kind of like, one day, we have nothing planned. So you can just chill by the pool. Go and explore on your own. You know, spend more time with your new friends, your new fat community. nap, drink, drink, liquid eat food, sleep, you know, well nap and sleep are the same things. But are they no sleep is longer term napping shorter term. Yes, I can sleep and now. And then maybe the next day, then we'll go off and do some activity which is inclusive, which is not like let's go and hike. Kilimanjaro. Good luck, you know, so things where we're, everyone's included, right? I think that's a big thing with with fat folks, is that a lot of times when you want to go and do things like this, you're thinking about the fact that there's going to be loads of straight size people who were like, going really fast and running up the hills and, and you're left behind, or you're you feel like a burden or, or you know, perhaps you you're, you know, an athlete fatty and, and you do like those things, and that's great. But then you know, you go and do something like you want to go snorkeling and Oh, surprise, surprise, they only have life vests in size small or, or, you know, things that are not accessible because no one saw that fat people exist. And this is this is my my dream of, of that not being the case, you know, and because of activities are vetted. And, and we can think about accessibility needs on site. So if if we have folks who need access to mobility aids or devices, and we can look to organize that on site, in case you don't want to fly with them. Yeah. So right now, this is a dream for me, but it can become a reality. And I need your help to make it happen. And, and your help is to fill out that survey, which is in the show notes. And it's going to take two minutes to complete. So the survey asks you where do you want to go? What is your budget? I think it asks you what type of activities you want to do want to go on. It doesn't ask and I asked them to change this, but they weren't they were unable to in time. It doesn't ask you what your accessibility needs are, which is really important for me. And so if you fill out the survey, and you want to let me know, what is important for you and your accessibility needs, and absolutely please email me and let me know.

And you can email me fatty at face fatty.com And so then, so then once we get enough people doing the survey and saying yes I want to go then we can Han see what location people have decided that they would like to go to? And then make it official. And then that's when we would open the doors for people to actually go ahead and purchase. And I think they offer payment plans correct me if I'm wrong person who is not even here by you you put like a down payment and then you then you've got, you know, the final payments. Yeah, so yeah, I'm excited. What do you think? Do you want to go on go on vacation with me? Can you imagine going on vacation with so minimum 10 people, maximum 20 people, a group of RAD fatties who are there to have fun and be supportive and love and go out for dinner with each other and sunbathe and hype each other up, and I'm thinking of doing, you know, we're like fat joy. I'm thinking of how we can include fat joy. And so I'm wondering, if because, you know, with an investment Academy, a big part of it by the Academy is what is your What are you doing right now that you you know, that you don't want to be doing in regards to loving and accepting your body? And what what are you doing? And what are you not doing? So are there things that you want to achieve. So, for example, a lot of folks might have things around wearing certain clothes, or doing certain things and I mean, like something like this even just going on, not even just but going on vacation with folks, that could be an incredible thing to achieve in regards to the things that you are or aren't doing because of the way that you view your body or because of societal realities in regards to how fat people are treated. And, you know, if there's ways that we can help folks achieve any goals that they might want to achieve during the vacation, for example, wearing a bikini, or, you know, eating a certain food that makes them feel anxious, or having a dance or you know, whatever it is, whatever it is, you know, wearing shorts or whatever, you know, being surrounded by by folks that will help you and also with me that you know, would be really really amazing. And yeah, so that's, that's something else I'm thinking about of of you know, can we overcome together so and relax and chill and and lounge and just having a wonderful time with with the first party community. So to make this reality you need to fill out the survey if you're interested. If you're like No, I would never do this and I hate you have any that you don't need to fill out the survey and you can just carry on with your life. And someone messaged me and said, Well, what do I can what do i Is this just for fat? What is fat? This is just for fat folks. So this is it. This is a community for fat folks. What is fat? Well, if we look at the fat lip ash from the fat lip, she popularized the fat spectrum. And let me tell you what the lowest is on the fat spectrum fat spectrum. I think it's 16 or 18. But that's not helpful if you are not wearing women's clothes zoomable look I come up with the fat spectrum. Okay, so small fat size 18 a 1x or 2x Yeah, so I think about fatness Are you fat? If you are sis you are systemically excluded because of your body size so so that's not you know, have people talk shit about your body because everyone in every size has probably experienced that but is the world less accessible to you because of your body size? And have you experienced oppression and discrimination because of your body size? Because it is not seen as a straight size body? So that's for me is that but if you're if you're unsure feel free to message me fatty at fears fatty.

Yeah, ya CRC is yours. Okay, so link is in the show notes. Go find it. If you can't find it for any reason you can go to my Instagram and on the In my bio, the link is the first link on there. And if you've got any questions, email me, but I would love to go on vacation with you. It's probably going to be March, April ish time. But again, that's in the survey of when, when when you want to do this? Yeah. And let's see, well, I mean, if people people not interested, then we won't. We won't go. If people are interested, then we will. So it's up to you if you want to go. I would love for it to happen. So we shall see. We shall see. All right. Well, thank you for hanging out with me today for the shortest episode of the face for any podcast that's ever been recorded. Yeah, like normally, I'm always like, Oh, I'm gonna make a short episode. I'm gonna ramble on forever. But this time, I am actually making a short episode. So yeah, and for those who are watching on video, you might notice that I'm in a different apartment. That's because I moved last week. Well, yeah, a few days ago. I'm still unpacking boxes and stuff and getting things sorted. So. But I had a couple of people that I got from TaskRabbit to come and do all the heavy lifting for me, while I sat back sipping a martini and smoking a cigarette from one of those long pipes. I didn't do that. But just imagine and I was wearing a fur coat, and I was dressed like Corona DeVille. I said, Hurry up and work. No, they did the heavy lifting. And I was doing no like the fixing stuff. And, and they were both both the task robots were like, Oh my God, you were so handy. You managed to dismantle your bed and put it back up in half an hour for each of the tasks. And I was like, Yes, that was super gender affirming. And then one of the TAs Roberts, people came back and he was doing stuff around the house, like, you know, drilling, because drilling into walls and stuff because I haven't got a drill or a stud finder. And I was helping, like put things together. And he was like, Oh my God, what you're working way faster than me. And you're so good at this and, like kept going on about how how how handy I was and it just felt very gender affirming. I was just like, yeah, because I'm non binary. didn't say that. But that's what I was thinking. I was like, yeah, a magical, a magical, but I mean, it is gender stereotypes, really, isn't it? That's yeah. Okay, well, thanks for hanging out with me. And we'll see you on the next episode on the face value podcast where we're actually gonna be talking about other fat stuff, but this is important stuff too. So very crash on. Alright, see ya soon. Bye.

EP143 Transcript

You're listening to the Fierce Fatty Podcast episode 143. Beachbody announced they are body positive. But are they really? Let's do it.

Hello, fatties and fat allies. Welcome to this episode. I'm so excited to talk to you today about this juicy, little bit of gossip. And we have a guest. Oh my goodness. I know you're not used to ever having guests on the show. But I know someone who is a giant. I don't know if they're gonna be okay with me saying this nerd when it comes to this topic. And I was like, I will not do this topic, justice, justice. So I want to introduce you to our guest, Jen say Hi, Jen. Hello, everybody. How are you today, Vinny? Oh, well, I thought you're talking to the audience and say how are you already? Everybody? Everyone's Yeah. How's the audience doing today? I hope well, yes. Well, fingers. Obviously they're doing well then listen to the face value podcast that makes?

Yeah, no kidding. So I met Jen on the Instagrams. We were connected like probably before when I was probably messaging messaging about stuff and and then recently, you had either shared or commented on on a post that I had reshard of mine, which was about the intersection of LM, L, M. R, for fuck sake. I always struggle with this. I want to call them m&ms. But there's M L M's, if I refer to them as m&ms From now on, we'll know what that is. And we will talk about what that isn't.

And so lmm m&ms, diet culture, and cults and the intersections there and so that, you know, got restarted talking about that. And you were telling me all about Beachbody, and I was like, Oh, this guy started talking. But anyway, before we get into all of that, Jen, tell us who you are, what you do.

Everything just tell us your life story basically. Nice and simple. That's too much. Um, so my name is Jen Brousseau, I am a certified personal trainer, and nutrition coach, former Beachbody, quote unquote, coach that is what they call their M M and M reps with an m&m company be so much better. So MLM is multi level marketing. So we'll throw that out there. I was, in Beachbody for many years as a rep, and let's just say the experience was not good. In the end, I still wanted to help people with health and fitness. And come from a place that is complete opposite of what they do there. And so I consider myself size inclusive, I do I have a certification in that I try and make fitness accessible to everybody.

Everybody, and every body is really important to me. I want to say I create a safe space. But I don't know if I can actually say that quite yet. But I work hard to.

And I just I meet people where they're at. That's the biggest thing for me. meeting people where they're at in their health and fitness journey, because not everybody is going to be the same because every body is different. Mm hmm. And so how long were you with Beachbody? Um, I started with Beachbody in 2012. But they burned set of insanity DVDs.

Because I was watching late at night after work drinking bottles of wine and the infomercials would pop up and I didn't have the money just to buy even the DVDs. So I had a cousin said I've burned copies, you can have them. So that's how I started and I started posting my workouts on Facebook. And somehow I ended up in some sort of Beachbody group on Facebook and I got sucked into the coaching world. Mm hmm. Which is like you'd be amazing coach. You can make a side income, have a side hustle and make a career out of it just by sharing your journey. no training, no qualifications, no education and health, fitness. Anything needed. You just had to buy a challenge pack and that is still the case today. Wow. Beachbody was started in 1998.

So that's ata, 190 90 894 years. Oh, really, I thought it was a little bit older than that. Like I can imagine, like, you know, people in the 90s develop 1998 was when Beachbody was founded. So it's been around for 24 years. Yeah. And so so for those who are not familiar with what Beachbody is, my knowledge of Beachbody is just you know from watching the scam shows, you know the MLM shows and also that outrageous ad that they did a number of years ago, years ago, which was a yellow adverts which had a picture of a thin white woman and it says said, Are you Beachbody ready? Or was that is that what I said? Are you Beachbody? Ready? Are you Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah. So tell us what what is Beachbody? We're saying lmm m&ms and all that type of stuff. So is it a fitness company, a nutritional company. It is a fitness and media company that also has nutrition plans as well. They sell supplement lines, ridiculously overpriced, unnecessary supplements. And we'll get into one of them a little bit later when we talk about how they're trying to shift and CO opt some things.

But it started out just as like home workout DVDs. And then they shifted in 2017 into the online platform with Beachbody on demand. And now they're going interactive with their shifting from Beachbody on demand. Now they have body which is what they're going to be calling themselves now. But it's an acronym. It's Beachbody on demand interactive so Beachbody is still in the name. Beachbody is not going away it's still there. It's the be in body but they're putting it all on one platform now they're really trying to compete with peloton are in the garbage as well? So, yeah, it is all up. They went up during the panorama, which is what I like to call it because people were at home. But now it's the world is opening up people are going back out to gyms and at the same time, especially with Beachbody. People are waking up to realizing that we don't want that type of messaging, our marketing, the before and afters the transformations eating minimal amount of food. Like it's people don't want it anymore. We're waking we're waking up. It's finally let me this movement started way before I came along, you know, and

Unknown Speaker 7:41

it took me hitting my rock bottom in my IDI

Unknown Speaker 7:48

and discovering intuitive eating. And then just immersing myself in that type of content on Instagram. Like I did a detox of my feed. And just reading and listening to podcasts. I've listened to your you know, listening to yours. And

Unknown Speaker 8:06

realizing that

Unknown Speaker 8:09

we need to we don't want to shrink ourselves anymore.

Unknown Speaker 8:14

You're not sure we shouldn't have to to be valued a valued member of society. Do you valued as a person? Yeah, absolutely. So so people are waking up and we've been Beachbody has been confronted about this. Karl has been confronted about it. There's the CEO, Carl is the CEO. And Autumn Calabrese is the face she's this quote unquote Super Trainer who does not have any current certified current certifications. Yeah. I was gonna ask you that because I was in the chat profile today. And she says fit training trainer expert and nutrition expert and I was like, hold on to shift does she like a registered personal trainer?

Unknown Speaker 9:00

She She is no longer certified as a personal trainer. She let that lapse. She is certified as a holistic health coach through i n which is the certification that Dr. Mark

Unknown Speaker 9:16

Heyman Hyman ever use I don't like him. Name. That is his school, which is so that is her? That is what she considers herself as a nutrition expert. Yeah. Because she's has that certification. Yeah. Okay. So let's let's go back to Beachbody and the the structure of what what happens and so you mentioned before originally, they were selling DVDs.

Unknown Speaker 9:41

What What was the shift into being a I'm just gonna say primitive pyramid scheme from now on, they deny that they're a pyramid scheme, but what how are they a you know, M L M. M? What does that mean exactly. And when did that happen? Roughly, it started shifting around so they started in 98. They were just selling TV.

Unknown Speaker 10:00

He's, the CEO of the company was actually using his before and afters as marketing.

Unknown Speaker 10:08

Um, and then as more people were joining and doing this, they came up, they saw what other MLM multi level marketing companies are doing, how can we not pay for marketing, and get other people to do it for us, since that's what multilevel marketing is like, they don't want to pay for the advertising. Let's just get the people doing to sell for us. So in 20 2014, around 2014, is when the coach network started, maybe a Team Beachbody coach. And there were seven founding coaches, and they are still to this day part of the company. And they do not actively work the business, but they are making millions of dollars every year. And how do they make that millions of dollars? Jen, let Jim enlighten us. So you start here, you bring on people here, those people bring on more people, and it just keeps going. So every time somebody buys something, it goes all the way up to the top. And so for those who are just listening to the audio, Jen is drawing a pyramid shape.

Unknown Speaker 11:18

So they're at the top of the pyramid. And what they do is they will recruit people underneath them to become coaches, and then those coaches then recruit coaches to be coaches underneath them. And so their income is not from selling products, their main income is from their downline. The main income, and the bulk of the money comes from what's called Team cycle bonuses. So it's based on the volume of sales your downline makes, hmm. And they actually they're changing up the compensation plan a little bit, I haven't had a chance to look at look yet, but somebody sent me all the information. So to look at that again, but it's still the same scheme. And so the person on the top their income mostly comes from the person underneath them and their team underneath them and verb a bubbler from the person recruiting people. And the more people that they recruit to sell the sell more recruitment, that's how they're making their money. So say, you know,

Unknown Speaker 12:27

and, and then do you have to pay fees to get started 6095 a month, you have to pay for the monthly business fee. And you can either sign up as a coach by just paying the coach signup fee, I think it was it's either $39 or $49. But they usually get people to join as a coach by saying by this total solutions pack, then you don't have to pay the coaching fee. And what's in we actually hack there's a variety of them. They usually include the membership for the Beachbody on demand or body and then it includes supplements. And usually Shakeology Yeah, okay. And so then your your upline your boss, would you call it your what? How would you call them that your mentor? They're, they're your upline, they say upline, yeah, so they would be pressuring you to do what to get you to sell what? To get you to sign up more people as a coach.

Unknown Speaker 13:28

You don't want you don't want customers you want coaches. Yeah. Yeah. And I actually my upline didn't like me, because I refuse to sign people up as a coach if they weren't going to actively work the business or buy shakeology or supplements every month because when you're coach, you get a 25% off discount.

Unknown Speaker 13:54

So instead of paying $150 a month for 30 servings a bag of Shakeology, you were only paying 100. But then at the same time, you were still paying 6095 a month. So still $120 a month to stay active as a coach to make money. And you can go to any store and buy those things for like a fraction of the price anyway. Yeah, and it's better. Yeah.

Unknown Speaker 14:22

tastes better. Yeah. Which I guess is not the goal of Beachbody is to have people they're getting the discount to buy the overpriced stuff. Anyway, their goal is to get more coaches selling more coaches to be have this lifestyle of being an entrepreneur. The coaches are the customers. Yes, yes. And I think that's the difference between like watching what in the states defines a pyramid scheme. And the idea is, where is your income coming from? Is it coming from selling products? Or is it coming from recruiting other people and if the majority of the income is from it

Unknown Speaker 15:00

Selling coaching, you know, getting more people under you, then it's a pyramid scheme. Yeah, like, and obviously Beachbody has a lot of money and a lot of power to lobby different governments to influence outcomes of, you know, investigation. So, unfortunately, at this point, they are still allowed to get away with it, which boils my pass.

Unknown Speaker 15:25

Yeah, because I think about all older people like Eugen who,

Unknown Speaker 15:30

who works so hard to try and you know, you say, work the business. And, and I don't know about you, but I know when I started in the online business world, I was like, I am gonna get shit done. I'm not like one of these other people who don't take it seriously, I'm gonna be really successful, because I am committed. And yeah, I watched an interview that you sent me with the CEO, Carl had Danica Is that his name? Daikeler Byculla. That's it.

Unknown Speaker 16:08

And he says, the level of what your level of your work determines your income. And I was just like, that is absolute bullshit. It's not your level of work, because people could be working really, really hard. But then have ethical standards, like you mentioned, of refusing to recruit people. Because, you know, it's, you know, maybe at that time, you didn't know that it was a scam. But you were you were doing right by people. And so it's almost like your, the level of your income or your success in these businesses is

Unknown Speaker 16:45

in some ways, like your level of your, your, I don't want to say morality, but you're

Unknown Speaker 16:52

desperate. This ethics. Yeah, like your level of your ethics. And, and I don't want to blame the people who were in it unless they're in like, you know, the top positions, because I think people are totally

Unknown Speaker 17:06

not giving you the information, right, like I

Unknown Speaker 17:09

was sent for, like, fulfill something like this. If it happened to me at a certain time. Like what? There's no doubt, you know, because yeah, you know, it seems simple. You be your own boss, and work hard. And you'll be successful, like, Fuck, yeah, I can do that. Because they tell you, they tell you, you can work in pockets of your time. And you only need to work an hour a day to be successful. I remember that. There really, there have been recently cook top coaches that are working from a hospital bed after they've given birth to their babies.

Unknown Speaker 17:47

It's absolutely horrifying. And that's not and they talk about time freedom. You don't have time freedom, you have location freedom.

Unknown Speaker 17:58

It's not, they're always on their phones, like my business is 95% online. And I have business hours.

Unknown Speaker 18:08

I have boundaries. I don't work before a certain time. I don't work after a certain time. Because after being in Beachbody and working a full time I was working

Unknown Speaker 18:19

in a restaurant, I was managing a restaurant and working 7080 hours a week. And then I would get my uplines and people like Why aren't you working? Or why aren't you on all our team calls? Why are you missing our calls you need? This should be our priority. I'm like, I'm sorry. I'm working a full time job that is actually paying me and paying my bills in the so I was a coach for a while and then I quit. And then I came back. I got sucked back in.

Unknown Speaker 18:51

When my

Unknown Speaker 18:53

at the time sister in law

Unknown Speaker 18:56

saw I'd had elbow surgery and I

Unknown Speaker 19:00

I stopped exercising. I was eating like I was drinking way too much. And I just was not happy. And she saw it. And she said Why don't you join and be a coach on my team. You'd be a great coach and start doing this again. And I said no for a long time because at that I had left the management job and I took like a 75% pay cut. So I did not have I knew I didn't have the money for Shakeology every month and she's like, well, I'll buy the challenge pack for you until you get three people under you and that'll pay for your Shakeology every month

Unknown Speaker 19:37

so if they got me in that way, but throughout the time that I was in it,

Unknown Speaker 19:42

I sat down and I looked at my profit and loss like we finally did the numbers in like three and a half total years I worked the business I made $200 Wow. Oh my god. I wonder what that would come out to per hour probably like a penny per hour or something.

Unknown Speaker 20:00

Less, less amount of money I worked. So when when coaches or anybody is like I'm thinking about doing this, ask your upline for their profit and loss statement, keep track of what you're spending on all of your supplements, and what you're bringing in. Because if you're not in the in the US, if you're a 1099 contract employee, the business that you're contracted with, if you make $600, they need to send you a tax form.

Unknown Speaker 20:30

If you're not getting that tax form at the end of every year, they're losing money. If you're, if you're making $550 in income from Beachbody, you're losing money within six months, because Shakeology costs in six months over $500 Yeah, yeah. And the great thing about this is great in quotation marks is these companies will have the statements available of what percentage of their coaches are profitable, and it's, it's something like, less than 1% that make a profit. And the profit can be like you say, it can be five bucks, you know, and the amount of work that you're doing and so, so, Beachbody is shady as fuck exploits their people is a pyramid scheme is a piece of shit company, because of all of that stuff. But also,

Unknown Speaker 21:27

let's before before we get to this part, I was gonna say we, um, I have I do YouTube lives with some girls, women who were in Beachbody with me, we call it sipping snark. And we listened into the quarter to earnings call with Carl Daikeler. And ups of where they're, you know, the investors are asking, he called the Beachbody coaches and unsophisticated Salesforce. Oh,

Unknown Speaker 21:59

why Ontake? Like the audio is there.

Unknown Speaker 22:03

Like he's calling them this? And at the same time, they're like, oh, my gosh, she's amazing. Like, do you understand how we actually feels about you? There's so much cognitive dissonance within not just Beachbody, but within all MLMs.

Unknown Speaker 22:20

Oh, my goodness. And that's, that's, that's Yeah, absolutely. I I speed listened to that hour long interview with him and a coach on to speed because I was like, I can't, I can't have this in my brain. And I was horrified at the way that he was talking to that coach, and also about everyone the presumption that everyone is lazy. And if only they worked and worked harder, then they would be successful. And if they just did what, what he said or, or, and the way that he was harassing

Unknown Speaker 22:59

that coach, I would just felt like second round trauma for what she was experiencing. And and you pointed out that he was like, why are you not making more money? Why haven't you reached this level? And she said that she was working 18 hours a day. And so he's like, so you're hustling for 18 in her previous business? And so if you're hustling, hustling for 18 hours a day, why are you not making whatever it is gold star spangled whatever. And I was like, What do you want her to sell a fucking kidney?

Unknown Speaker 23:32

Yeah,

Unknown Speaker 23:33

she's probably close to death from exhaustion and stress. And this fucking CEO is a rich white man is saying why you're not making more money for me. I just wanted to kick him in the face. Yeah, was that is that the one I sent you where he shamed her for being the modifier not having a bigger transformation? Yeah, that when you say what do you say modifier what is that? So when they do the workout programs, they'll have the trainer doing the moves. And they'll have a modifier who's doing a different variation like an easier variation.

Unknown Speaker 24:12

So this, this coach that you saw, is the perpetual modifier in because autumn is her best friend. So she's in a lot of her training programs,

Unknown Speaker 24:24

which is a whole nother level of hot mess when it comes to the coach business. If you're friends and close with the Super trainers, I'm using air quotes here, people super Yeah.

Unknown Speaker 24:38

That gives them a leg up. Like she's she's in the top of the company. And you see anybody any coach who is has a close relationship with one of the trainers, they do well, they try and say that's not true, but the numbers don't lie. And so modifier is seen as not as good as a trainer, right? And it's usually a

Unknown Speaker 25:00

Have someone in a fat body? Oh shit. Really? Yeah. Oh, because the fat people can't do the apparently they can't do the original stuff. And so they need to be like, here's what you can do. And so it always has to be a fat person basically to show you have to do it because clearly all fat people have a fatter person a larger person. Somebody's not as small as autumn because she is tiny. Yeah, yeah. Interesting. Yeah.

Unknown Speaker 25:31

So So what is, so Beachbody is selling? Is it selling weight loss? Is that the goal? Or what is the goal like weight loss slash health?

Unknown Speaker 25:42

They're saying they sell people on improving and have living a healthy fulfilling life. Mm hmm. But it's about weight loss. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Big. Yeah, it's about weight loss. And

Unknown Speaker 25:59

they, in the beginning of this year, they launched a program called gut protocol.

Unknown Speaker 26:07

This goes into

Unknown Speaker 26:09

Ms. Calabrese is qualifications. It's an elimination diet. So my two eyes like oh, she's like, a doctor as well, like a gastroenterologist. It's, it's, it's even stricter than 30. Whole 30. Which is problematic in and of itself. But it's the point of it is to identify your food triggers. Because every because they throw it, they've thrown out a stat, that 95% was it 95% is 75% of Americans, of Americans have undiagnosed food sensitivities.

Unknown Speaker 26:49

Um, food sensitivities, isn't a ret isn't a medical term. It's not a thing.

Unknown Speaker 26:57

Food intolerances and allergies are, but how can you it was a 75% of the population is diagnosed that meat and 25% Is that means 100% of our population has food sensitivities.

Unknown Speaker 27:10

Well, I mean, like, I'm sure, like, if you ate something to extremes, you know, like apple seeds that have arsenic then maybe you'd be sensitive to arsenic. You know, like, you'd have to eat like 5000 pounds of apple seeds. So maybe then, you know, maybe an extreme or something. But yeah, that's interesting. Okay, so they're diagnosing Everyone is sick, so but they've got a solution for it with that.

Unknown Speaker 27:36

And but this program is supposed to make you is supposed to be about feeling better, and feeling good. But then as soon as they started putting out the marketing material to promote it, at the very top is weight loss and inches lost. Hmm. But it's not about weight loss. So if it's not take that out, and stop showing the transformation pictures. Mm hmm. Because they have lots of before and afters, right. Oh, they're not calling them before and afters. Now. This is part of their they're trying to flip the script. Yeah, we'll talk about that in a in a moment. Yeah, absolutely. So.

Unknown Speaker 28:11

So what are they doing? Sneaky? Yeah, they are sneaky. Motherfuckers you have to be really eagle eyed to spot this stuff.

Unknown Speaker 28:18

So what do they think about fat bodies? In their, you know, what's their messaging around fatness?

Unknown Speaker 28:26

That that bodies are not healthy.

Unknown Speaker 28:30

They can't be healthy. And as much as they try and deny that.

Unknown Speaker 28:38

It's on tape. There's words, they've said it

Unknown Speaker 28:43

in groups.

Unknown Speaker 28:45

And there are people who have been in Beachbody as a coach in fat bodies, who felt ostracized

Unknown Speaker 28:53

and not part of the community. And they leave and they speak out. And whenever,

Unknown Speaker 28:59

whenever they do, we're called haters and trolls. And we just didn't work hard enough. It wasn't it wasn't the program's fault, or the diet's fault that it didn't work. It's your fault. Yes. Yeah. And it's blatantly false. Yes. Ah 100%. And exactly that correlation with with diet companies. So you know, diets diets in general, if only you were really committed if only you really wanted this, then you would have been successful. It's your fault has nothing to do with our garbage product or garbage company. And I was I was immensely successful with the program's

Unknown Speaker 29:44

not that good. Yeah. And so by that, um, I, I was diagnosed with

Unknown Speaker 29:54

orthorexia, and binge eating disorder and pause

Unknown Speaker 30:00

Look, I wasn't diagnosed with anorexia though because I wasn't small enough. So you you had quote a typical anorexia which is anorexia in people who are not very very thin now, I was still according to that stupid scale. Yeah normal Yeah, we just fucked up and actually so funny that you mentioned that my next week's episode is going to be on atypical anorexia and how fucked up it is. It really is you know, because if someone who was not eating enough

Unknown Speaker 30:32

has any struggling with that no matter their size if they're struggling they're struggling you know but in a in a someone who's not very thin then it's gone like good for you keep going you're like yeah, but I have a mental illness doesn't matter. And if somebody is fat there say don't keep doing what you're doing keep doing what you need to lose the weight keep doing it, you're fine. Yeah. They don't like that bodies.

Unknown Speaker 31:01

In

Unknown Speaker 31:03

was it was it 2021 When Cosmo UK came out with the I am this is healthy. Yes. Right with Jessamine Stanley and

Unknown Speaker 31:13

who else was in there was test test holiday in there. I don't think it wasn't test holiday. It was athletes, right? It was other athletes? Yes. Um, well, this is how Beachbody feels about that. You can you can call them strong. But you can't call them healthy because they're in a larger body. They may be strong athletic, but their blood markers are off they're not healthy as what how do they know that? She doesn't this Autumn Calabrese.

Unknown Speaker 31:45

But hang on. Probably she does because she's she's an expert. Right? So maybe she's got like X ray vision or something said in this there is again, anything I'm saying that she said I have video of it. There's there's audio there's like this is

Unknown Speaker 32:02

it. It's out there.

Unknown Speaker 32:05

She I'm not an expert. I'm not a medical expert. I'm not a doctor. But they can't be healthy in that size body.

Unknown Speaker 32:14

Like yes, they can like she's tiny my mind. Like

Unknown Speaker 32:21

yeah, so this goes back years

Unknown Speaker 32:25

of her saying things like that. And the mindset and the mentality she has and the field she has people in fat bodies. It's deeply rooted. And once you once you think for me, once I got out, and I started learning, and listening and shutting up

Unknown Speaker 32:47

and feeling uncomfortable, it's a lot easier to see now. And so can I it's been four years. So when I first started, I was very, very resistant to listening to any of it because I was in Beachbody for so long. But now, once you get out, it's like red flag red. You see it? Yeah. Like it's it's not hard to miss anymore. Yeah. And I just want to I want to say just for the listeners, were mentioning Autumn Calabrese because like you mentioned, she's a quote, Super Trainer. And she's got like a million followers. And she's the, basically the coach of all coaches. And then above her would be the CEO and the management team and all that type of stuff. But then she technically probably still isn't even an employee of Beachbody. She's probably a consultant. Yeah, they're under Yeah, they're under. They do contracts. Yeah, yeah.

Unknown Speaker 33:43

So what about their prescription for like movement? So do they talk about movement in a holistic way in regards to say, movement can be a small part of healthful behaviors and obviously, not everyone can move and sometimes movement can be unhealthy for people and so so I'm guessing that they absolutely definitely talk about movement like that. It's no excuses. Oh, it's everyone has 20 minutes a day. No pain, no gain. It's sweat as fat crying.

Unknown Speaker 34:19

Wow. And so they want you to work out every day.

Unknown Speaker 34:23

Um, pretty much so the programs

Unknown Speaker 34:28

there's no program that is actually designed for seven days a week thinks it's like five days, five or six days a week. Some are for like going to like the newest one that came out was four because it really people don't want well one. She was putting them on a severe restrictive diet. Eliminate, you know, with the exercise program went along with it, and they still weren't eating enough it did.

Unknown Speaker 34:53

This is a disaster waiting to happen.

Unknown Speaker 34:58

But when

Unknown Speaker 35:00

You're doing the programs in this group of like in a Facebook group, because all of you always had a Facebook group, you're running challenges, they call them their boot camps, and you're all doing the program together.

Unknown Speaker 35:13

But in order to be a product of the product, you have to have a before and after transformation.

Unknown Speaker 35:20

Because you need to sell you need to show that you're changing.

Unknown Speaker 35:23

So

Unknown Speaker 35:26

this is my experience now. And I'm not the only one that did this, I would do the program that we were doing. And I would do two other workouts.

Unknown Speaker 35:36

There were some days where I was doing three hours of workouts

Unknown Speaker 35:40

and eating less than what the portion fix lowest bracket was showing publicly.

Unknown Speaker 35:49

Then not showing was the binge eating.

Unknown Speaker 35:52

And I was still dropping.

Unknown Speaker 35:55

Because it was really, really intense. And just basically what they're doing is teaching people how to

Unknown Speaker 36:05

eat in a disordered way, and move their body in a disordered way. And eventually moving into having eating disorder, symptoms and behaviors. And, you know, like you mentioned orthorexia,

Unknown Speaker 36:21

etc, etc. Like it totally fucking up your relationship with food and your body. And your actual overall health. Yeah, my, my hair was falling out. My nails were always breaking, I was always cold, my blood pressure was low. My thyroid is where my thyroid was messed up. And I was actually going through a health issue the entire year of 2016. I ended up having a hysterectomy and 2017 as an ER every month still doing these all these workouts still follow its plan, not sharing any of that on social media because that would be like that would blow up the illusion that Beachbody is perfect.

Unknown Speaker 37:03

It was I don't I am. So

Unknown Speaker 37:07

like when they they're shifting, they're trying to say their body positive now and they're there with the body positivity movement. They have no idea what it is because I am so I don't love my body all the time. I never will. But I am so thankful, grateful and accepting of. I'm still here.

Unknown Speaker 37:26

I'm still here, which is like to I'm amazed, to be honest, sometimes. Yeah, I'm thinking about this to thinking about the state that they put you in that state of starvation, over exercise. And on top of it, you've got your upline saying why haven't you done this? You need to do more of that. Why aren't you on the call? Have you made sales? Have you recruited people have you? And then you're thinking, Can I pay the rent? Can I feed my kids? Can I?

Unknown Speaker 37:55

Like that's just a recipe for disaster burnout. Major stress just be a no, not good stuff. Yeah, so that an issue in these groups is that you actually don't have access to the trainers.

Unknown Speaker 38:14

It's you because you're a coach now and your uplines still, there's people in there asking questions about nutrition, about fitness, about injuries about health about, and there's unqualified people

Unknown Speaker 38:28

telling people what to do. Yeah. It's like going into, you know, the mom groups and asking, Hey, my kid has a fever, what do I do and then all these randoms instead of going to the actual professional,

Unknown Speaker 38:41

you need an oil change in your car, you aren't going to go to your beautician

Unknown Speaker 38:46

gonna go to an oil change.

Unknown Speaker 38:48

So that's one of the things when I decided to leave because I still want to I'm like, I need to educate myself. I actually want to help people. And I want to know what the heck I'm talking about. Huh? Yeah, absolutely. And at the same time, I'm gonna be like, if someone asked me something, I don't know. I have a network of people that I will hear go talk to them. Yeah, absolutely. Or I can ask. But you have people assuming because now their title as coach, that they're, they know what they're doing. And they're qualified to be giving advice, and they're not.

Unknown Speaker 39:19

And I guess a lot of people are under such immense pressure pressure to be this knowledgeable person when they don't have the resources and they're tired and fucking hungry. So that they will do things which are maybe not aligned with their values because they're in a, in a difficult state, trying to survive this company. Yeah. So what's been beach bodies?

Unknown Speaker 39:47

stance on body positivity in the past?

Unknown Speaker 39:54

They don't like it.

Unknown Speaker 39:56

They believe well, one, they don't actually

Unknown Speaker 40:00

They understand what the body positivity movement is.

Unknown Speaker 40:05

They do you think that they think it means

Unknown Speaker 40:09

that thin white women sitting on their chair folded over to picture showing the rolls?

Unknown Speaker 40:17

That's what it is. Yes. Yeah. So sketch showing skin skin natural skin folds on a on a straight size person. Yeah. Yep. And that's one of the previous top coach, she got to top top at the company for like building underneath her. Because a post went viral, beautiful woman stood up, this is my body, then sat down showed her natural photo. This is all about body body positivity. Like that's not what it is.

Unknown Speaker 40:48

And at the time when that went viral, I believe that's what it was. Yeah, but when you know better you do better. Yeah. Yeah. Like love that quote. Yeah, like, hashtag, embrace your flaws. And it's like,

Unknown Speaker 41:02

you're a thin white person. Like, wherever you're close. I can't see them with my eyeballs. What are you talking about? Yeah, they, if you go into the groups, they think it's just no, just celebrate everybody's body. It's like, well, that's not what it is.

Unknown Speaker 41:20

Yeah. And for they don't want to and they don't want to hear it. Yeah. No. Because then if it is just that, then they can use that as a tool to sell more shit.

Unknown Speaker 41:30

Yeah. And but in the past, they weren't they were anti body positivity. Right. Tell us about that one. That one person who was went on a rant about it. Oh, it was autumn again. I was also again, oh, autumn, who was on? And it was this summer? Yeah.

Unknown Speaker 41:51

People have been pushing back. Like I said earlier against what Beachbody has stood for last year and a half. Really? It's picked up a lot, especially against her. Because a lot. Most of the other super trainers don't. Don't put themselves out there like she does. And actually, like someone, a few of them I've met and I'm like, Okay, you're really cool. But she had she promotes her idea of health is her.

Unknown Speaker 42:19

You're only healthy. If you look like her. You eat like me, you work out like me. This is healthy. And people were like, Oh, this program isn't good. This isn't healthy. This is hurting me like people like I had that experience. And she blocks and cultural. Like, there's no conversation, even though she says I'm willing to have a conversation. No, because I've been blocked for like eight months now. And I was very kind when I messaged her. I was like, Hey, can we actually talk about what body positivity movement is and what diet culture is because diet culture is not been on a diet.

Unknown Speaker 42:55

It's more than that. And I got blocked.

Unknown Speaker 42:59

Don't want to hear it. Um, but she basically said she is so sick and tired of this body positivity bullshit movement. Mm hmm.

Unknown Speaker 43:11

Because people aren't positive about her body. Yeah. Which is not about her. Yeah, yeah. And when I watched that, that video, and I'll share it on the podcast.

Unknown Speaker 43:24

That video just wreaked of privilege of not understanding the fact that as a thin white woman, she is able to move through the world. And yes, sometimes people will say, I don't like the look of your body, and that's not okay. It never, never is. That's not what body positivity is, you know, saying that thin people don't look good. But not understanding the systemic issues that people in bigger bodies face daily, the interpersonal and intrapersonal stigma that they are facing, and it is nothing

Unknown Speaker 44:04

short of someone saying your body is too small autumn is nothing compared to what fat people are saying the people in bigger fat bodies and also people who have other marginalized identities experience. And so because some people have said, I don't like your body, she thinks that it is like a lot of the a lot of the comments

Unknown Speaker 44:27

about her body. Were actually concerned. Yeah. For her health because people are watching and they're seeing a shift. And people are actually showing concern. She's not liking the concern. And there yes, there are some people being very rude, very disrespectful and totally unnecessary. But many of the people reaching out to her. Were sharing concern.

Unknown Speaker 44:55

Yeah, and she didn't want to hear it. Still doesn't want to hear it. Because she went on to

Unknown Speaker 45:00

A

Unknown Speaker 45:01

This was great timing. She did a live this morning. I sent that to you. Yeah, she's doubling down. She's She tried to backtrack. No, no, I don't hate the I don't think the body positivity movement is bullshit. I think everybody should be body positive.

Unknown Speaker 45:17

But she centered herself again, muted about her being attacked again. It's like you're being attacked. For how you look, you're being questioned and challenged in your attitudes and your belief and how you are presenting information. Yeah, and how the fact that she's what she's telling people to do is harming them. You know, like, literally teaching people to, well, you know, taking their money for what and with the pyramid bullshit, but then also telling people that they need to be thinner, or they need to work out a certain amount or eat a certain amount of food. It's just no, no, even a dietitian, even a registered dietitian won't tell you what to eat. Like no work with a dietitian, he does not tell me what to eat. No, no, unless I unless I asked him for specific ideas for food. If I'm like I need I'm like, I really want it. I need something quick or easy. Mike help. I'm blanking. Yeah, you know, I have a nutrition certification. But I don't take on nutrition clients. I use it to help the people I've worked with now, if they want help with that, and I give very general information. And it's more about dieting them to be confident and making their own choices. Mm hmm. Yeah. If they need more help than what I can give them, then I refer them to a registered dietician. Yeah, absolutely. And if you if anyone's listening, and they have a dietician telling them what to eat, and less, it's because they are definitely allergic to it allergic to it.

Unknown Speaker 46:51

They might die from eating it or whatever, then that dietician is probably teaching you some diet, culture disordered eating and know what type of Yeah, so. So the reason for us talking today is because there has been

Unknown Speaker 47:07

what was it like a yearly meeting or something? Yeah. So they have, every summer they have a big summit with all my I always say all the coaches with a lot of the, you know, coaches, it's just a big show. And I watched them over this year, and I went to one and 2017. And they said the same exact things like it's theirs. It's the same stuff every year, same thing, and it's just like, it's just a way to get people more into buying in

Unknown Speaker 47:38

to the cult mentality of and when you say the same, the same things, is it more like you need to hustle you need to be better because you're all pieces of shit. Yes, yeah. This year was this year was funny, though, because

Unknown Speaker 47:50

we I know that the company has been listening. And Carl has been listening because he got on stage in front of 10,000 coaches and called out the haters and the trolls who are speaking out against each other. Oh, is opening speech? What did he say? Like? Hi?

Unknown Speaker 48:09

MySpace? Yeah, no, I'm, we're, we need to ignore them. Oh.

Unknown Speaker 48:15

He was like, Oh, he's changing. We're gonna listen to your concern. No, no, no, we're gonna ignore them. Ignore them. They're just unhappy, miserable people? Yes.

Unknown Speaker 48:27

I'm sure. And he also tried is he's

Unknown Speaker 48:33

he said they're not a multi level marketing anymore. It's not multilevel marketing. Oh, it's it's participation marketing. Oh. And so what's the difference? There isn't one. Oh, it's just a different name. A different name to trick people eyes, as I say, yeah. So they do the big thing in the summer. And then in the fall, they have what's called the leadership retreat, which air the top, you have to earn enough points to get there, which essentially means you have to build a team and get get people under you to a certain rank, so they build teams to get there. So it's about recruiting, who's recruited the best and who is taught people to recruit the best? Because like, I think there maybe was, like 100 people there. It's small. And they take this time to tell that they're the leaders of the company.

Unknown Speaker 49:30

They say this is what's coming up next year. So that was what is what happened last weekend. 35 minutes from my house. And so they announced what's coming up next year, and you mentioned it before,

Unknown Speaker 49:45

is that they are now going to be a body positive company. Yes, they're embracing body positivity. Okay, actually, no, I'm going to back back in that up. They brought on a new vibe.

Unknown Speaker 50:00

He's president of personal development. And she got up on stage and spoke and said, Carl, is the only person in the fitness industry putting a stake in the ground and make these changes. Oh, for fucks sake. Ah, god.

Unknown Speaker 50:18

Yeah. And for anyone who's like, why, why, why, why is why is when you haven't that reaction is because that is utter bullshit. People have been working at this stuff for years for decades. And of course, it's a rich white man who is putting a stake in the ground and saying no longer we're gonna do it the right way. Thank God for CEO Carl he's saving the day. Oh, amazing. It was an it was a rich than white woman who made that statement. Yeah, of course. Of course. There's no There's no diversity in the in the executives at all.

Unknown Speaker 50:57

There are white and thin.

Unknown Speaker 51:00

Yeah, yeah. Men.

Unknown Speaker 51:03

And they're all men when I'm guessing. Most men, you know, the coaches are probably women, aren't they? Yes. Yeah. Yeah. Yep. Tracks, tracks, but they're all men. And so then bolster men. And so, Carl, the CEO was putting a stake in the ground. And he's saying that the Beachbody is now going to be a body positive company. Yes. And okay. So when I hear that this is what I think of a body positive company. They're no longer going to prescribe any type of diets, any type of restrictive eating, they are not going to be teaching eating at all. In fact, they are going to be teaching intuitive eating and healing the harm that they have done through their restrictive diet. So that's the first thing a body positive company will be doing. They are overhauling their leadership team to make sure that we have lots of fat people, Infini fat people, a lot of people with other marginalized identities, queer people, trans people, etc. They are going to

Unknown Speaker 52:15

only have workouts that are presented by people in marginalized bodies, and they're never going to tell anyone to work out. Also, they are no longer going to be making money from selling shakes and stuff like that. And they're also not going to have a pyramid scheme model.

Unknown Speaker 52:39

And they're also going to make a huge donation for all of the harm that they've caused to eating disorder charities, to fat positive

Unknown Speaker 52:49

movement. Leaders. Yeah, so that's that's probably what they announced right, Jen? No, oh, none of that. Well, what is it that they announced that they're going to be doing to make themselves body positive?

Unknown Speaker 53:04

body positivity? This is their new definition, and a healthy active lifestyle can coexist.

Unknown Speaker 53:12

They're two separate things.

Unknown Speaker 53:16

And shifting from beach body to body which again is an acronym body on demand, interact, Beachbody on demand interactive the ODI VOD i It's a lowercase i This is where it is always feels good to be you.

Unknown Speaker 53:34

Huh?

Unknown Speaker 53:38

This so fucking tricky. Because if I was a layperson to this topic, I would read that this is where it would say again.

Unknown Speaker 53:49

This is where it feels good to be you. Oh, that is so fucking tricky. I would hear that and say, okay, they they support that I'm fat. They support that I am trans non binary. They think it's cool that I'm queer. Hola. Hola. Hola. Hola. There's not going to be any of that bullshit. But I was a bait and switch. Yeah, just the same old bullshit but with a pro bowl on top. So now their new platform is based on health, esteem.

Unknown Speaker 54:27

Self esteem, health esteem. You have to love yourself enough to make these changes.

Unknown Speaker 54:38

Which is they haven't been

Unknown Speaker 54:42

happiness and long term results coexist.

Unknown Speaker 54:46

Ah,

Unknown Speaker 54:48

not if your happiness does not coexist with disordered eating over exercising eating disorders. Fucking not making any money not being able to pay the rent like

Unknown Speaker 55:00

factor is not going

Unknown Speaker 55:03

oh my goodness. So build this. Here's the health routine. Yeah, yes. I mean my though there's more truly feel amazing and truly enjoy your life and the picture they have up there is all thin white

Unknown Speaker 55:20

Well, I can't say all because there's there's one woman that's not white she's a couple of people are Hispanic but they're white women and

Unknown Speaker 55:30

social the acceptable bodies.

Unknown Speaker 55:34

It none of these pictures is there anyone in a marginalized body Oh,

Unknown Speaker 55:41

my God, Mike and the whole health esteem thing.

Unknown Speaker 55:47

Not everyone can be healthy.

Unknown Speaker 55:50

Health is a deeply complicated topic. And a lot of what makes up health is social justice stuff. It's like where you live, it's the color of your skin. It's if you can access health care. It's not did you have this Shakeology shake.

Unknown Speaker 56:09

But like

Unknown Speaker 56:11

that,

Unknown Speaker 56:13

you know, the their idea of health esteem and how to build health is to exercise to eat sustainable nutrition, which their plans are not

Unknown Speaker 56:27

mindset, they're bringing that in now. So now they're bringing in mental health. So now they're going to be mental health experts.

Unknown Speaker 56:34

Which is I found interesting, because when I was in there and since the beginning one they have five pillars of what it takes to be a successful coach and one of them is read personal development every day.

Unknown Speaker 56:47

You're always reading personal development. Well, I can't say I was because I hated all the personal development books that they told me to read. I tossed

Unknown Speaker 56:56

like this is crap. Good for you.

Unknown Speaker 57:00

Like no this I saw so I was I had one foot out the door when I started.

Unknown Speaker 57:06

But that's their thing. And now they're so they're co opting body positivity and trying to turn it into something that's not and at the same time they're saying they are anti diet because you can eat more dessert hang on hang on. They're saying that anti diet

Unknown Speaker 57:25

they are anti diet. Yeah, because they're nothing is to eat more dessert. That's harder their health esteem thing he

Unknown Speaker 57:36

was about was about bats, bats bats Tiki bats, but the desert that they're saying that you're allowed to eat is like fucking and a date dipped in like unsweetened chocolate that once was a whisper of a baby's breath or something like what?

Unknown Speaker 57:52

What is Shakeology?

Unknown Speaker 57:59

Shakeology.

Unknown Speaker 58:01

Hmm,

Unknown Speaker 58:03

because

Unknown Speaker 58:06

they're going to encourage people to eat dessert every day but only but it Shakeology desserts. They got rested.

Unknown Speaker 58:16

Oh, Jen, you

Unknown Speaker 58:18

were anti diet because we want you to buy more of all fucking shit.

Unknown Speaker 58:24

And make recipes with them. Which I again, like I said earlier, none of none of this. None of this language. None of the stuff they're putting out there is new. This is the same stuff they were telling back in 2014 1516 when I was in it. Yeah. We were using Shakeology for dessert mug cakes back then, we were talking about Shakeology as being I went I scrolled through my social I scrolled through my Instagram the other night just to see how how bad I actually was. Because I was at some point. And there's posts of me with my Shakeology, and I didn't eat a cupcake at my mom's birthday, I came home and made myself this instead. This is my dessert.

Unknown Speaker 59:08

This is how like how much this this? Eating a disordered eating has taken hold in my life. I won't celebrate my mom's birthday because I'm gonna make some shitty Shakeology bullshit that's not going to satisfy my hunger. Like shakes. Like recipes for puddings and cakes and Shakeology. Like

Unknown Speaker 59:30

that's not new. It's been around but now they've gone from Shakeology was your healthiest meal of the day. It was seven salads in the glass. Why now? Yeah, that was that was what they used to call it.

Unknown Speaker 59:45

Yeah, seven salads in a glass your healthiest meal of the day. And now it's dessert. I find it's so funny because I bet you there are so many people in the company who say like, we want natural food and we don't like

Unknown Speaker 1:00:00

Do you know any man made crap or motorcycle? Shit? Tell them oh my god.

Unknown Speaker 1:00:07

So eat dessert every day and be fun and consume clean energy. Ah. But of course, Shakeology is clean even though it's like, you know, a powder process.

Unknown Speaker 1:00:21

But other process stuff that ain't clean that shit.

Unknown Speaker 1:00:25

Clean Eating and clean supplements, and the energy they're talking about is their energize supplement. Oh, because that is clean and all the other energies all the other pre workout supplements out there dirty is dirty. Oh, but they're anti diet, and they're anti diet culture. But they're there's a hierarchy of food there. Yeah, that's so clean, dirty. Yeah, can have this dirt not that desert. Yeah, they've really working hard to polish a turd with that. Really? Working hard with that. Wow. And so they so when they announced that they're definitely anti diet, they have had said that they're not going to be telling people what to eat, and they're not going to be prescribing wrong. Oh, of course, they still, with every program that comes out, you have access to their nutrition plans. And Autumn was on her Instagram today live telling people yes, you can do that protocol with my new workout program coming out. You can do time nutrition, but you have to use your containers or you can just choose ultimate portion. It's all based on containers and portions. They limit the number of fruits and vegetables you can eat.

Unknown Speaker 1:01:38

Of course, because it's not about health, it's about weight. Yeah, they're not. Not that eating just fruit vegetable is gonna make you healthy, but you know, but they limit the number. So it's like,

Unknown Speaker 1:01:52

you eat four servings of vegetables, and you're still hungry, you want to eat more bulk, no berries, all my green containers, I can't have those carrots.

Unknown Speaker 1:02:00

But maybe you can have a straight Shakeology. So when I say I wasn't eating what, what was on the plan, I rarely ever ate my fruit.

Unknown Speaker 1:02:10

And I was also afraid of carbs. So I would only eat like one of my yellow containers, which yellow was the carbs? And they're saying they're anti diet when they're literally like saying this is this. This is what you're going to eat and presumably, then you're going to have that before and after. Because you're going to be transformed. But they're not before and afters anymore. Oh tell us you tell us well, because their body positive before they're they're concentrating on you now and loving you now. So it's a then and now. Oh, so they went to the thesaurus and looked at what before and after before what's a different word for before then what's a different word for after now that's it will trick them will trick him now they know that we love that people because we say then and now. And then at the same time.

Unknown Speaker 1:03:04

They're the new the structure of their workouts programs are releasing or changing and it's called body blocks. So it'll be three weeks of a workout program one week of rest. But if you go to the frequently asked questions about the body blocks the first paragraph talks about submitting your transformation pictures after the three weeks to enter the Beachbody challenge for your chance to earn part of the $100,000 price.

Unknown Speaker 1:03:34

But they're not about before and afters. No no no, no, no but submit your before and afters because we want to see how how thin or ish Oh, you get a shirt. Oh, yeah. You got a shirt if you're fit enough. If you submit a before and after.

Unknown Speaker 1:03:49

They will use it for marketing. Yeah. Does the shirt come in five sizes? No.

Unknown Speaker 1:03:58

No, I actually one of the one of the person I've connected with is left. She shared a picture today in her stories. She wanted a shirt and it was a double XL and it didn't fit her

Unknown Speaker 1:04:13

and she called them out for being size inclusive because this was the double XL is the biggest size that they do and it's probably not a double XL either. It's probably you know it's a medium

Unknown Speaker 1:04:25

to medium like

Unknown Speaker 1:04:28

the other thing was

Unknown Speaker 1:04:30

that interview that I watched at double speed with Cava CEO and then this other this other coach that was not a coach and what she wanted to say were modifier modifier. She She is a coach, but she is a modifier in workout program. Okay, okay. So something that he said to her at the end of the session. He was like, Oh, it's so great to talk to you because, quote, oh, so he says you're not in the shape a coach should look like but you're on a journey.

Unknown Speaker 1:05:00

Knee. So that's what he said. And this person is

Unknown Speaker 1:05:06

a 50 year old woman who is very, very slightly chubby. Like you. She's straight size, right? And yeah. And so he was holding her up, have you look at this, this disgusting person, she's on this journey to try and become fit because she's not in the shape that a coach should be. After he spent an hour saying why you're not making more money and needling her and saying, but what are you going to do to get your coaches to make more money? But what are you going to do? What are you going to do? Why aren't you rich error? Why aren't you and and asking her inappropriate questions about her income and all this type of stuff, like

Unknown Speaker 1:05:50

so, so the CEO is quite happy to comment on and shame people's bodies on a public call, a live call, that people can go and watch. And it just be kind of like a tough love type thing. Because he kept saying, I know you can take it I know you can take it you can think of in your head when and I was just like, she's doing it because she's she was structured, she's got a job. What is she gonna say to you like, fuck off? You know, you're a decade. And also he said

Unknown Speaker 1:06:24

you need desperation and pressure to make it work. Like that's it. That's how he wants his people desperate, under pressure, starving, overworked, working 18 hours a day, and then he's gonna talk shit about your body and tell you you're not making enough money for him. Right and then put on the show a week ago about being body positive and wanting to erase the stigma of the of the name Beachbody so they're shifting to body so they can reach all of the people that may not have felt welcomed before. Yeah. And and their marketing team will experts, right look the same with new new is a diet is a diet is a diet numerous 100% A diet but because yes, they said we are backed by psychology. They are not this is just one guy who, who started new and was like, Okay, well, we want to make as much money as possible. Diets are great, we're going to do that. And let's stick on the label of psychology and get people in like, we have some magic formula. There is no magic formula. There's it's not backed by science, it's not evidence based. But it caught people it would have caught me if I was not I would 100% have done Noom. And when I was in diet land myself, phobia, and I think this body thing, I would have said, Ah, they've got their shit together. Now, I'm going to do it because they it's about you know, mental health, and it's about how often it's about. It's about loving yourself and self esteem and health esteem. And I'm like,

Unknown Speaker 1:08:14

oh, it's, it's, it's gonna be a bait and switch outside. So I'm like, it's all smoke and mirrors, it is all see because

Unknown Speaker 1:08:22

we're watching like,

Unknown Speaker 1:08:25

the coaches now they're not changing their messaging they did for three days.

Unknown Speaker 1:08:30

And now they're back to showing before and after pictures of programs. They're showing the pictures, they'll go, but it's not about the weight loss, even though they talk about the weight loss. Like why are you showing that you don't need to show those pictures, and you can just talk about it.

Unknown Speaker 1:08:45

Yeah, like I've been, because I don't use I don't have anybody take pictures.

Unknown Speaker 1:08:52

I don't share my own like, because it's not part of it. There's no way in and I'm like, there's no reason to because that's such a very small, insignificant part of who you are. And what your fitness is, how your health is how well being who you are as a person. It doesn't matter.

Unknown Speaker 1:09:14

We tried some shifting away from that. And but there it doesn't, it's not going to work with them there too. It won't work. Because they just don't know. They don't know that. Like they don't understand what

Unknown Speaker 1:09:27

the social jet the fact that this is a social justice movement. They don't know the history behind it. And they don't care. Because if they did it would mean that they would they would have to close the business down or make humongous changes as they actually want you to align with body positivity. That positivity. Yeah, liberation. They're just using it as a marketing tool. And I think you know, it's a very smart move, but hopefully, folks, if they listen to content like this, and a lot of people won't

Unknown Speaker 1:10:00

because they were like they're just trolls or whatever

Unknown Speaker 1:10:07

also kind of extending like big love to people who do get trapped in it and who are sucked into this stuff because it is so tricky and it's they're gaslighting, this so gaslighting you and they manipulate men. Yeah, yeah, it's literally there was there was someone the other day in her stories?

Unknown Speaker 1:10:30

It was like I had to call my therapist to schedule a session after watching them because like I still, you know, like it never goes away still deal with it.

Unknown Speaker 1:10:39

But first, she started by calling haters and trolls and basically saying those of us that have spoken out and said we have had issues with disordered eating orthorexia eating disorders, is that exacerbated by these programs, she called us liars.

Unknown Speaker 1:10:56

And then she went on to start crying talking about her own issues with an eating disorder and said that Beachbody saved her not therapy, Beachbody.

Unknown Speaker 1:11:07

And then she goes, my heart goes out to those people for what they're saying. It wasn't for what we experienced this because we're wrong and what we're speaking about. Yeah. And I'm like,

Unknown Speaker 1:11:18

Oh, my therapist, I need an appointment. Oh, my God. Yeah, I would have been like, it was hard to watch, because you could see in her face, she isn't healed, and that she's saying this saved her. But she just went from this to this and shifted or disordered behavior to something that is socially acceptable. Instead of and then she said she helped save other women. I was like, Oh, God, no, you're not a therapist. You're not an eating disorder specialists. You're not an MD? No, like I don't I, I have people that come to me and be like, I want to work with you. But I'm working through the disorder. I'm like, Okay, you need to work with that first and sit and talk to your therapist. And if your therapist says you're ready, let's work together as a team, because I'm not messing with that. Even though I had that experience at No, that's not my expertise. My expertise is movement, and training.

Unknown Speaker 1:12:14

And so they're taking on, just because they experienced it, I'm an expert in it. So I'm helping save women from the same thing I went through. And that's like, that's not how it works. It's dangerous. And also, I'm saving them by giving them more of the stuff that they're trying to be saved from. Yeah, given them more diet, culture, body checking, etc, etc.

Unknown Speaker 1:12:37

I just want to like clarify for anyone who's listening who, who don't, who doesn't already know me or isn't familiar with,

Unknown Speaker 1:12:46

what fat liberation is, what health every size is, what Intuitive Eating is just, I've done a whole podcast episode on this. Because Beachbody thinks that it's something else. So body positivity is a social justice movement movement. First records records of people talking about it is in the 1960s. But it was people have been talking about it long before that it just wasn't documented. Started by fat folks, fat women, fat trans people.

Unknown Speaker 1:13:21

Infini fat people fat, black, indigenous people of color.

Unknown Speaker 1:13:26

And the it's a social justice movement to say fat people deserve the same rights as everyone else is the same access to the world, the same opportunities, and we don't deserve discrimination. In the 1990s, the body positive

Unknown Speaker 1:13:47

language came about which was stemmed from the origins of fat liberation, and focused a little bit more on accepting your body.

Unknown Speaker 1:14:00

No matter what size it was, but also still focusing on folks in larger bodies and those who have most marginalized bodies. It's not about

Unknown Speaker 1:14:10

fineness, thinness, not should not be centered, whiteness should not be centered. Body Body, body positivity or fat liberation is not anti health. It's got nothing to do with health, apart from let's make sure that fat people have access to health care.

Unknown Speaker 1:14:27

It's not saying you shouldn't work out. Moving your body can be wonderful for many people, but also many people can't do that because they might be living with a disability, because they just don't want to because they have other priorities in their life. And those who do move their body knows or don't, there's no morality difference in them.

Unknown Speaker 1:14:49

There's nothing like you should eat, quote, unhealthy food and if you eat, quote, healthy food that you're bad, there's no you shouldn't be thin

Unknown Speaker 1:15:00

Fat people are better. All of these ideas about what body positivity or fat liberation is that are not. Let's look for liberation for the most marginalized bodies in our society, specifically fat folks, is just

Unknown Speaker 1:15:17

false. It's just false. Like, I did this, on this, and

Unknown Speaker 1:15:23

they said, there was this video that I watched called body positivity gone too far. And I watched it being like, Oh, let's see what the criticism is. And the guy said, here's a new story. A, some parents says that they sleep in a bed with their children. And the children are not wearing clothes, body positivity gone too far. And I was like, What?

Unknown Speaker 1:15:50

What?

Unknown Speaker 1:15:52

What the Wow. He's saying that Oh, because they were European. Because, you know, a lot of Europeans have a lot more open minded. On on nudity. So So he's saying he was thinking nudity, okay, that means that they have a body, and we shouldn't feel ashamed of our body. Therefore, we should sleep with children naked. Therefore, people who are people who speak with children,

Unknown Speaker 1:16:21

their parents, they are body positive, and they are predators. Like it was like, wow, how are you? But that's just what people do. They are willfully, willfully, willfully misunderstanding and saying, because really, how can you criticize the idea that fat folks should have equal access to to the world? I mean, like,

Unknown Speaker 1:16:49

because there's nothing to criticize, you know, like, instead of, like, make it up, if to make it up. And like with,

Unknown Speaker 1:16:58

with autumn, specifically, and today, you need she talks about people body shaming her. And it's like, no, we're not talking about your body. We're talking about your behavior and your attitude. And the messaging that you put out there, it's not about that, but she makes herself the victim

Unknown Speaker 1:17:20

and centers herself 100% of the time. And I know for me, when I wasn't blocked, noticing I was in the comments. I'm like, This is what diet culture is. Here's some, here's the facts. Here's education. Here are some resources, if anybody wants to go, see I never talked about her. I was just sharing information. I got blocked for that. Yeah, of course, because they want this echo chamber. They don't want people to hear something other than what will keep them rolling in the money. Yeah, exactly. And, and one thing we didn't mention, we'll just say this, this thing before wrap up is what do you think was the reason for them to shift to body positivity?

Unknown Speaker 1:18:07

Money.

Unknown Speaker 1:18:09

They're not they're their money is it's

Unknown Speaker 1:18:13

their stock is doing horrible. They went public last last summer. And I think it was it was around $12 a share. As of this morning, it was down to $1.06.

Unknown Speaker 1:18:28

And Carl is the major shareholder.

Unknown Speaker 1:18:32

He holds the majority. Yeah, this year alone, it has not gone over $2.70 and their stocks have gone down 53% year to date. So he had to do something pretty radical. And stepping closer to the fatties is probably incredibly radical for him but in a way that is very dishonest and I I think it's gonna backfire. Do you think time yeah, oh, well, there's so much more and

Unknown Speaker 1:19:06

people should go on and follow you because you talk about this stuff. Where can people find you?

Unknown Speaker 1:19:13

Best place to find me is Jen be Jen with one end dot coaching on Instagram. Awesome. And so what do you do in your business? And what's the name of your business? Anchor Fit Club? And so an anchor Fit Club. How can people work with you?

Unknown Speaker 1:19:30

Find me through Instagram. I do a group. It's a group coaching program. So it's it's our the program is already written out. But it's I like to say it's a combination of one on one coaching and group coaching. Because there's a lot of access to me one on one calls. I bring in guest speakers every month which Vinny will be coming to speak with my group in February.

Unknown Speaker 1:19:56

But I created it to introduce

Unknown Speaker 1:20:00

swimmin to strength training in a way that is actually building them up and not saying you need to make yourself smaller. Yeah, I'm open to conversations. So the best way just to chat Yeah, if you've got some Beachbody gasps I'm sure that I'm sure that you would like love, love to talk about it. Yes, and I do have a YouTube channel. I can't remember the I think it's just Jen baru so. Um, but I do live videos on there. We do sipping Starks on Beachbody so

Unknown Speaker 1:20:32

yeah.

Unknown Speaker 1:20:34

Good stuff. I've had so much fun talking to you about this bullshit, even though my radiometer is through the roof.

Unknown Speaker 1:20:42

This is why I need a therapy. I'm

Unknown Speaker 1:20:46

gonna go to a snack. I'm gonna go to a smash room this weekend. Oh my goodness. And just like have a picture of Carl's face while you're smashing some vases or something? Yes. It just needed in my head. Yeah, yeah. Yeah. So if you're if you're, if anyone's thinking about falling for body, don't do it. Don't do what you're what you want. But you know, like, message me first? Yeah.

Unknown Speaker 1:21:11

And she'll tell you all the shit. So thank you, Jen for being here. You would thank you for having me. Yeah, it was so fun talking to you. And thank you everyone for being here on this episode of the face value podcast. Okay, bye. Bye. Okay.

Unknown Speaker 1:21:31

Thank you, Jen. Oh my goodness, this could be a Swiss way it can be like a 30 partner.

Unknown Speaker 1:21:38

I'm telling you, you've got so much.

Unknown Speaker 1:21:41

There's so much stuff. Yeah, I bet people would be really really interested in there. Maybe you should have like, what are you what are you doing your videos? So? Yeah, I think the more that we have.

Unknown Speaker 1:21:53

It's interesting. We had somebody I had somebody send me a call from one of the top coaches.

Unknown Speaker 1:22:02

She's like, I'm still am on her tee. I think I'm on our team. But I don't know, but I haven't cancelled yet. But I'm canceling before I get charged again. This month. She's like, here's all this stuff. So we have people sending this stuff constantly.

Unknown Speaker 1:22:18

So that's where we like we don't I don't follow any Beachbody people. I people send me there in this screenshot, send me the videos, hey, you need to go watch this. I'm blocked by a lot of them. But I do have an extra backup account. So if I really need to go watch.

Unknown Speaker 1:22:37

But it works. Having a team of people that are like, okay, we're all on the same page. Let's shed light and put out the information out there that the Beachbody Coaches won't. Yeah, like you need to be an informant. That's our big thing. Like just be informed if you hear all what we have to say. You listen to it, and you still want to join that church choice.

Unknown Speaker 1:22:58

Right, but just being formed. Yeah, yeah. They don't want people informed. Yeah. And that's it. You know, it was only when I especially this, this moves into also the like online business. Well, the online business world is filled with all of this type of shit to like, have, you know, manipulating people like by my really expensive program, and you'll become a millionaire in 10 minutes and all that type of stuff. And a lot of a lot of Beachbody coaches, the older ones that have been around forever. Well, they're starting to recruit more now, because they changed how you can make money. So they need to recruit, they actually need to recruit people now.

Unknown Speaker 1:23:33

But they've started their own offshoot businesses, teaching people how to work the Beachbody business, ah, creating their own planner. So they're doing that and they're running their beachbody business, which isn't their business. Their employees hate it when they call themselves CEOs. But everybody on their team, they say you need to sign up for my course too. So they're making money off these people with commissions and volume money and they're the downline is paying them $600 For a two month course. Yeah, yeah, so just raking that money in from people and it's just not gonna and that's like another lost lost money for people because no matter how hard they work, there's only a small percentage of people there's going to work for and it's probably people who already got connections. Yep. People who've already sell businesses, people who've got you know, money already, that can pay for the the low earnings last year for a beachbody coach of all ranks was $10.

Unknown Speaker 1:24:38

The high earnings and this person doesn't even work the business was 2,864,000. Wow. But the average earning the average is only $3,000.

Unknown Speaker 1:24:56

That's the average and that's over a year. Yeah.

Unknown Speaker 1:25:00

It

Unknown Speaker 1:25:03

is horrifying, isn't it? It's, I just I hate it so much. I hate it so much. Take it back. I don't want it.

Unknown Speaker 1:25:11

I don't like it. And I'm glad you got out. I'm glad you got out. I am too. Yeah. And I think this is a really interesting and important topic. I think you should talk even more about it all the time. I am I'm trying. I'm trying to find the balance between talking about this and at the same time sharing fitness. Yeah, it's, it's a hard it's, it's, it's a balance. It's definitely like, am I talking about too much? I do need to promote my business too. So it's, it's interesting. Yeah, but I have it I'm working on.

Unknown Speaker 1:25:45

Because I didn't say the price because people can just message me and I tell them, it's I put it out there. It's once 157 a month for my for the group program.

Unknown Speaker 1:25:56

It first three months or commitment and then it's month to month after if they want so.

Unknown Speaker 1:26:01

But that's the price of the Shakeology back, oh, when I talk about it, just so you know, the price of my group coaching, which is a full on training program, one on one coaching calls with an actual expert group calls with experts, a community where we're not focused on shrinking ourselves, this 157 per month, but I have people that are leaving each body are like I can't afford that. But I want to work with you. I was like, Okay, well I can do I'm working on doing like just a group, like a membership without the training. Where it's just like 10 bucks a month for like a founders thing and then increase it and then they'll they'll get the calls but there won't be like a training program. And they won't have messaging access to me, it would just be me in the group chatting. Yeah, no direct messaging or anything like that. But it would be in there sharing so that's a thought process I'm coming up with right now is like I was on a call this morning with my business group mentorship thing, and we're actually talking about social justice and anti racism work. And things like that this morning and the whole time I'm like, oh, beachbody coaches with hate this call. What do you think they would? They would hate it we you know, we talked about the four levels of power internal transactional, organizational, cultural, institutional, like all over that stuff. And like, yeah, they would hate this. Who's your business coach? Um, right now I'm working with Allison Tony. And I don't know. I look him up how Alison Tani elephant ne te n n e. Y.

Unknown Speaker 1:27:35

And I've worked with Christina Montalvo to know

Unknown Speaker 1:27:41

Alison tennety. I'm looking at Instagram. She's probably not on Instagram or under pitch. Nope. She's under Allison.

Unknown Speaker 1:27:49

Allison 20 Fitness. Yep.

Unknown Speaker 1:27:56

Yeah, and I just I did the size inclusive trainer certification with the Leeds green at the beginning of the year. Yeah, she's my friend. And then I've done I did Coach's Corner with tamale Fraser this year, too.

Unknown Speaker 1:28:16

And then fitness for all bodies. Oh, just as I've done though, I've done his his courses. They have a

Unknown Speaker 1:28:25

message to him. Like you're in panic, like didn't answer me. You're in Paris.

Unknown Speaker 1:28:30

They're doing another calling all white women. They're doing a what? Sorry.

Unknown Speaker 1:28:35

They do a talk or workshop every once awhile called calling all white women. Oh, that's happening. December 5 again. And like I mentioned like, I want to come to one you always should to share it too late. The next one, like December 5, I said I've marked up my calendar. Oh, I never was is teaching about racism and stuff. Yeah, very good. Yeah. So done that one. And then next year, I'm looking into doing more social justice stuff, because the the training

Unknown Speaker 1:29:10

I have I have a certification. I have my personal trainer, but it's the same thing. Like once you have programming and training down and you know, people move. That's fine. It's the other stuff. Like yeah, the hard stuff. Yeah, there's so much to learn. Like, yeah, lifelong process of learning all of that bullshit that we internalized.

Unknown Speaker 1:29:34

But yeah,

Unknown Speaker 1:29:36

well, thank you. Thank you for being here. And I really appreciate it and I was fun. Yeah, really interested in this topic. And so the podcast will be out next week and I'll tag you.

Unknown Speaker 1:29:49

Hmm. I'm wondering because I normally do a an audiogram which is a snippet from the podcast and because I do it at the end and I say dead edited a

Unknown Speaker 1:30:00

All

Unknown Speaker 1:30:01

right now if you've got time, which is like spend two to three minutes just

Unknown Speaker 1:30:05

talking about this year, okay, so let me what do I, what do we want to say in it?

Unknown Speaker 1:30:11

Okay, so watch out

Unknown Speaker 1:30:15

for Beachbody is

Unknown Speaker 1:30:18

new.

Unknown Speaker 1:30:21

Okay, so what I'm gonna do is I'm gonna say, watch out for beach bodies, new body positive

Unknown Speaker 1:30:27

grift. And then I'm gonna say, Jen, tell us about it. And so in like two minutes,

Unknown Speaker 1:30:35

or one minute, 30 seconds, the shorter the better. Say, last week,

Unknown Speaker 1:30:42

they had a meeting and they announced that Beachbody is now body positive, and they're changing their name to body.

Unknown Speaker 1:30:49

And

Unknown Speaker 1:30:53

and,

Unknown Speaker 1:30:56

and then maybe then I'll say,

Unknown Speaker 1:30:59

oh, so Jen, are they?

Unknown Speaker 1:31:02

Are they no longer teaching diets? Are they no longer teaching disordered exercise routines?

Unknown Speaker 1:31:09

And then you'll say no. And then I'll say, Oh, it's just us. It's just a big old gap.

Unknown Speaker 1:31:17

And I'll go yes, yeah.

Unknown Speaker 1:31:21

Okay, lab a lab. labeler. Well, all right. Okay. I gotta, I gotta, I gotta get a wiggle on. I gotta get on with the locker chat all day to your gym.

Unknown Speaker 1:31:32

Again, we'll do it again soon. Yeah. Yeah, yeah. Yes. I have to start getting ready for

Unknown Speaker 1:31:38

I have to get the kids to karate. That's what do you have to get them to cry? Karate. Oh,

Unknown Speaker 1:31:45

karate. Oh, how to get them to cry. Oh, oh.

Unknown Speaker 1:31:50

I have a My oldest is almost 16 And my youngest just turned 12.

Unknown Speaker 1:31:55

Yeah, lots of stuff. Lots of stuff. Well enjoy the karate. You're getting them there. Yeah, I'll tag you and I'll let you know when it's coming out next Tuesday. Oh, okay. Yeah. So hey,

Unknown Speaker 1:32:09

buy I'll talk to you later.

Unknown Speaker 1:32:21

Perfect.

EP142 Transcript

You're listening to the Fierce Fatty Podcast episode 142: Why have I been diagnosed with the O word and when dieting is the only option? Let's start.

Hello, Fierce fatties and fatty allies. Welcome to the show today. We have a couple of extra guests. Guests you save it I know who would have thunk it. Well, it's Jackson and Bella the puppy is from the people down the hall My name was so if you're on video, you might have seen Jackson will come by he's a boarder he's really fucking cute. And barely Bella is a ginger little thing. wearing a diaper because she likes to we in my apartment little Bella he's wearing a diaper diaper of shame when I bring it out she said I look after these pups whenever I walk by there my name is apartments and there are on their own they do a little walkie I am a Bucky Papa Rena woof, woof. When they do in a bulky when their own I'll text my neighbors and say do you want me to hang out with them? Stop around and get them bring them to mind. So anyway, I normally don't do it when it's a podcast day because they do like a lot. They do like to do a book. So let's just hope they don't do a book today. Or they're gonna they're gonna be going home for the podcast. Anyway, welcome to today's podcast is going to be a listener question part two. Hey, thanks to everyone who's emailed me saying that they liked the podcast. I really appreciate it. A lot of you were saying that you liked the body dysmorphia episode. Why? Why? Why did you like it so much? What did I do differently that you liked it so much? Maybe it's not that it was different or better, but maybe it just was really resonated for some reason. Wow. So anyway, thanks for that. Okay, so we've got a we've got a couple of themes today. And the first one is going to the doctors and finding out the doctor has written on your chart that you have quote, oh word which is own Should we show up? I don't even want to say it had so much. And so and then the next one is about being so frustrated with everything that maybe you choose to die it and you know whether that's the answer or whether it's not who the frick nerves, well, well, I've got opinions, and we're gonna be talking about that. Okay, so this is from Amy, who says, oh, what could be the reason behind doctors diagnosing me with a word in my chart when one we haven't discussed my weight at all, too. All of my health markers are within normal range and I have no symptoms of anything and all three the appointment in question was about something unrelated to body size. I know you've discussed doctors lecturing their fat patients about weight when they come in with a sore throat but this is slightly different. These doctors three so far in my case have never said a word to me about my size. They just congratulated me on how healthy I am and then right I word in my chart as soon as I've left the office is it some how an insurance thing a cover your ass move? So if I dropped dead then from fatness tomorrow they can say that they documented that it might happen. It feels like such a beat Trejo Yes, I so feel this when when Amy says it feels like such a betrayal.

I had to get my doctor's notes. I'm been in the process for like five years of getting victims of crime compensation from when I was our word by an ex partner talked about that abusive partner in the past like many many episodes ago if you want to, if you want to know the gos on that, anyway, and so one of the things that they need is was my medical records notes Lelli that led you to do back then. And so I got them from my doctors from the whole time I've been in Canada which is 13 years and I was obviously having it or no I was am nah, I was really surprised by the doctors writing stuff about what I looked like. I was just like, what? And not just fatness like I'm presented well in a in a in a business suit. personality was like this eyeballs were teary. I don't think that ever happened because I'd never have gone to a doctor and cried apart from one time when I was like 17. Anyway. Yeah, so and then one of them was Constand to you lose a little weight. What am I was like, rude and too I was like really? Just a little thing no way ungenerous. Obviously I don't think I could stand to lose anyway. But yeah, so I was like, rude, rude. What the heck are they? Why? So there could be a few things going on here, right? Depending on the country where you are in the world, your health care system. A lot of don't a lot of doctors are compensated if they quote counseled people on weight loss, or mentioned they are fat. But we know doctors actually often don't like talking about weight loss. Don't feel like that some doctors are very happy to do it, but some doctors aren't. And so they will just put it in the chart so they don't have to talk about it. And also, they could be doing it just as a to see where you're at and compare. So I'm going to quote here from this core question. So the question on core, core core cork your core core? why do doctors make notes on patients hygiene, grooming nourishment and disposition at each appointment, no matter the nature of the visit, and so a few doctors chimed in here and said, This is what's happening. This one post I'll put the link in the show notes. That is part of the examination it gives clues into mental health and social determinants of health believe me we see many patients with significant deviations from the norm on the standards of observation sometimes we will see someone skeletal sometimes you will see someone with bizarre makeup or clothing that indicates disorganized thinking. Oh

I mean, who gets to decide what is bizarre clothing that deviate that indicates disorganized? I mean? Anyway, carry on. Sometimes the nurses are spraying the hallway outside the exam room with Lysol got rude. Sometimes people's mood is suspicious or angry in a way that indicates mental illness. Sometimes a person is wearing muddy slippers because they have no car and no shoes. Did you notice the most basic of observations will show a great deal immediately upon entering the room. Is your patient Well, or is something else going on? That they're not mentioning? Is it a headache? Or do they have carbon monoxide poisoning because they are trying to heat their home in some in an unorthodox way? Is a patient going to walk to the pharmacy in their slippers and be unable to afford the medication is the page patient's mental health spiraling out of control, we can get a lot of things, the few observations, then we can ask the right questions. Some of the person says from the same person who is a former GP from the HSA, as I've written written in 10s of 1000s of medical records, I can assure you that doctors don't do this. So someone else says it's certainly often appropriate in frail elderly people or in people with serious mental illnesses. So I mean, some people are saying, you know, we do standard and some people and not like with my doctor's notes, 90% of the notes were not had any mention about my parents. And so who knows, like, you know, this doctor, why they're doing it, one thing we do know is that that doctor is probably experiencing bias towards body size. Because as we know, body size is not an indicator of health. And they've got your health markers there, right. They, you know, the doctors, like you're so healthy, but then writes down the O word. And, and so I would I would suggest or or guess that it's probably because they think that the O word being fat is a negative thing, right? Something that, that that doctor wants to probably keep an eye on. Or it could be as well that they want to make a little bit extra money for counseling someone on how to lose weight or you know, weight loss counseling they. So there was this other article in it's called Who are you calling? Oh Word doc. The you they use your a word from the Canadian Medical Association Journal, and it's talking about how it makes me search a little a little a little a little mad. You know what makes me really mad, Pip. So people who are openly fat hating people who are just clearly don't like fat folks and think fat people are unhealthy and want fat people to go away and die. I feel like I have more. I don't want to say the word respect, but I'm not as angry at those people because I'm just like, clearly something is going on right? Clearly. This really steeped in in bigotry. And I it obviously it's annoying, but also I kind of feel a little bit more relaxed about it. People who are self designated Oh word s experts who say they advocate for fat people. They are not fat themselves, and they ignore fat activists. Those people really, really fucking annoying me. I can just feel right now my heartbeat is Oh, my chest is getting tight from thinking about how loud I am them. Because they're just so they're just so off the mark. They're so off the mark that it's like, you know what? It's not I know, I'm gonna conquer it to this. Ignore, ignore that ignore. And then it's like they've got their fingers in their ears and they're just like, I'm gonna save the fatties from their fatness by eradicating fatness. So anyway, this this, this article is Who you calling? Oh, word Doctor doc. And they're saying you should you know, listen, we've got to be careful with our words. We gotta be saying person with a word. And not that someone has a word we what we need to make sure that we say clinically obese? Because? Because it sounds nicer. Where they get that information from the fact that it sounds nicer. It doesn't. It sounds nicer. And, and also, we still need to definitely record the fact that people are fat. And also, you need to tell people that they're fat.

This is this is coming from someone who is from the Canadian Oh, word network? Who says who thinks that they are an advocate for fat people who says basically, if we put the fact that that someone has this disease of obesity in their records? They might see it and it will it means that they might lose weight, because then we don't have to talk about it. But she says Just tell him to lose weight because she says quote, these are concrete health health risks. It's not just not it's not just about being kind to people. I literally want to stab my computer screen. I'm so mad about it. Yeah, so if you want to look at that, oh my god and then isms fucked up image on there. Don't don't look at it. Don't look at it. Don't look at it. I'll do the looking so you don't have to what it really really stinks off what it really really stinks off is Do you know Autism Speaks. So Autism Speaks is a nonprofit nonprofits in the US? And it's basically a lot of people have said that it's basically a hate organization. So I'm looking at a PDF about what you know, before you donate to Autism Speaks, consider the facts. And so they say very little money donated to Olson as Autism Speaks goes towards helping autistic people and families. So most of it, oh, 1% Family Services. Oh, yeah. So and then 48%, quote, awareness and lobbying. Autism Speaks talks about us without us. So that is a phrase in the disability rights community. Nothing about us without us. And this is what the O word quote experts are doing. They're like, Oh, happy what I need to have a say. Of course not to be silly. So Autism Speaks has only one autistic person out of a total of 28 individuals on its board of directors. 23 of the 28 board members are from major corporations, like CEOs from PayPal or Goldman Sachs, blah, blah, blah. So Autism Speaks is fundraising strategies promote fear, stigma and prejudice against autistic people Autism Speaks uses its plant formed an advertising budget to portray autism and autistic people as mysterious and frightening their fundraising tactics, increase stigma and create barriers to the inclusion of autistic people in our communities. So, so it's the the blue puzzle piece, the puzzle piece, that's the ones that you want to avoid. And so this is really, really similar to what obesity networks or obesity researchers are doing is they're like, Oh, we are. And so Autism Speaks advocates for his person first language. So people with autism, and what the O word researchers and experts also say is, we have to be kind to fat people, we have to say, people with O word and not just oh word, because we have to have inclusive language. Have I asked fat people what they want? No. Are they are they fat? No. Majority not. And, and in turn, creates extra stigma and harms fat people. And the idea behind Oh, word research and the quote experts is the goal is eradication of fatness and with Autism Speaks to it's about managing autism as this awful scary thing. And let's have less autistic people in the world. But we're going to be nice about it and call them people with autism. Right. And so there's this, this push, there is this push for medical professionals to be quote, kinder. In ways they've been told by people who were experts in quotation marks on the subject who have never talked to fat activists, or people who are maybe actually knowledgeable about this topic, or the community in general. And they don't have the lived experience themselves. And they're just like, we've decided that this is what what is best, we want to eradicate fatness and so we're gonna put we're gonna do it with a smile on our face.

So when the doctor's note says, oh, word, that's what I think of is the smiling Doctor Who is like, you walk out the door and they're like, oh, they were disgusting. They were really fat. You know? And then like, exactly the Amy says, it feels like a betrayal because you're like, oh, actually, is this person? Like, are they? Are they on my side? Are they a good doctor? Oh my god, I have I arrived at a doctor who is fat positive. Oh my god. And there's another article here that I was I was looking at and saying how doctors describe patients matters even in their notes. And it's saying how I mean this just this isn't start and stop at fatness quote from here. A recent study in medical records of 18,459 Americans published in Health Affairs found that black patients were 2.54 times more likely than white patients to have at least one negative descriptor such as resistant or non compliant in their files, records for patients receiving social assistance. Those who who are unmarried and those who are ranked higher on a comorbidity index are also more likely to contain negative descriptors. And then and so I'm like, Great, this article is great. Amazing. And then then they talk to Oh word experts. So oh word Canada, which co authored the guidelines the guidelines on clinical practice guidelines on Oh word has seen a shift in terminology and awareness of weight bias. See how they're co opting our language weight bias in Oh word research presented at conferences since the organization started requiring authors to use person first language in abstract submissions in 2017. So they're like with overthinking talk shit about the fatties but make sure that you say person with a word because then then then it shows that we read it really, really respect them. And so quote, we want to describe what a person has, because they have decided that oh, oh word fatness is a disease rather than a certain setting. waterpolo the person is Dawn happened that happened NACA don't have to have the NACA of Oh word Canada told the CMHA the language physicians using the notes matters to even if patients don't see it because of the influence in the healthcare hierarchy. Okay, bets everyone but sketchy. Betson dawn, the executive director or the leader of Oh word Canada, that's please. Is Dawn fat or is Dawn St. sighs that sin bets in what our record is door. I'm a fat person when they are leading an organization organization for fat people that splits could you bet in? No, no, Dawn is thin, and all the pictures of people on the O word, website 90% of them have been people and I'm thinking like, did they throw out some fat? He's just to be like, here's here's one of the poor awful fatties that we're trying to help by. By erasing them from from society. Yeah, anyway, so this is kind of like you know, a side side rant on on this fucked up shit. Fucking so anyway, just you know, just to be aware of of that, that that's happening. And yeah I'm gonna breathe out all of that. And that's what I mean as well. You know, sometimes I get people who are like bariatric surgeons or Oh word experts can shoot quotation marks. messaging me saying are we agree on so much and it's just like, Okay, so are you going to stop telling people to lose weight? Are you going to stop using inappropriate language to? Are you going to stop calling fat people disease? No. No, because we need to get rid of fatness silay well, then fuck off. Go away. Yeah, it's I feel like I would almost be more comfortable like having dinner with a raging fat for over than I would someone who is a self claimed Oh, word expert. Like that's how that's how I feel. That's how I feel. Unless I thought that I might change their mind and maybe I would have a dinner with them. I'm not gonna have a dinner with a fat foe in his imaginary world of who would you lose like at least want to have dinner with none of those people. But anyway. Okay, so let's get into a question from Madeline and oh my good they both called Madeline to Madeline's. But it's about different.

So Madeline says I've been chewing on some thoughts about autonomy, and the body recently I'm a therapist and spend a lot of time reflecting on fatphobia I've been thinking about the choice to acknowledge harmful systems and quote, go back into the matrix or engage in disordered eating behaviors in attempt to control one's shape. I see the potential for harm of course, but I can also sympathize with and feel compassion for this experience. What are your thoughts and then Madeline? Number two says I've been really struggling with feelings of bitterness towards people in my life who are not plus size I feel so angry about the things I have to deal with with being in a fat body that they will never have to worry about or deal with just because they are thin. I'm so tired and so frustrated of having to try so hard to survive nevermind being treated like an actual human being simply because of the size of my body. I work in a healthcare setting and I see how patients treat my thin co workers versus how I am treated. Some people are nicer than others barely acknowledged me and a lot of people seem to pity me I'm just so tired and struggling with the strong urge pushing me towards diet culture surgery literally the most desperate measures measures to achieve fitness so I can stop dealing with the difficult parts of being fat. So I really with Madalyn to Madeline to the person who's experiencing the things that Madeline was talking about. Like this is a prime example of why telling people that you you mustn't diet often is not helpful. Because say you know with Madeline we can really feel I don't know about you but I can really feel how frustrated how difficult things are how what a struggle it is I'm letting you know these are literally Madeline's words. I'm so tired and frustrated of having to so hard to survive. And so much pushing them towards diet, culture surgery, any desperate measure to achieve fitness. And so Madeline's Madeline two's safety is in question here. Madeline's mental well being her survival. Sorry, I just said to her I don't know what Madeline's pronouns are. Madeline survival. And so, for Madeline to survive I, if they decided, I'm going to go on a diet to temporarily ease that deep, deep discomfort, life threatening discomfort. And I know, I know that it's, it's going to be temporary. I know that it is also probably going to be harmful to my mental health and my my physical health. I know that it will probably make me bigger in the meantime. But right now I feel so desperate, that it's what I need to do to survive. Should we be saying to Marilyn, to Wow, you've really fucked up? Like, how could you do that? You know, I thought you understood about that dieting doesn't work. I thought that you were you know, like my mom says, out of the matrix, you know, I thought you wouldn't, I thought you'd taken the pill and you understood? Well, you know, life's a little bit more complicated than, you know, kind of, we've seen the light and then that's it, we turn our back and we move forward because they relate the realities of living in a in a body that is big, and also in a body that maybe has some other marginalization means it's difficult, right? And that's why some people do decide to have surgery. You know, especially when you've got so many people potentially in your life and with Madeline to go into work and people being like that. I mean, and maybe Madeline as well at home, and then maybe Madeline Madeline too with a doctor. Then maybe Madeline twos got a therapist who was like, Yeah, you should be thin. I mean, how many therapists are actually fat positive? Not all of them, you know. And so, I think recognizing that difficult experience that absolutely overbearing pneus of the overbearing pain of fat misery or fat hate and the fact that is it is institutional, it is interpersonal, it is intrapersonal. And it is ideological, it is weaved into every single part of our society.

So if you need to do whatever you need to do to live and survive, then I get it. I mean, we can hear Bell bells now. Oh, bells thank you is adorable on a balcony outside barking. And so with Madeline one, who was a therapist, and you know, talking about a Maryland and ask this but kind of like seeing the harm in engaging in disordered eating in attempt to control one shape? Is that what Madeleine one said? Like? Do we encourage that like, as healthy as a healthcare provider, as a therapist, as a friend? Do we encourage that if someone said to me, You know what, I'm really struggling and I feel like I want to go on a diet. If say, if I was coaching them, I would say Yeah, absolutely. I get that like and what is it that you're hoping to achieve from from going on a diet and they could say, you know, event, my mum would get off my back, my doctor would allow me to access gender confirmation surgery, I might be able to experience a little bit less shame in the world. I might be able to fit clothes because right now I am sized out of even plus size clothing stores. And so I'm, I'm going to do that just to kind of access certain things certain access certain privileges. And also, I know that, you know, maybe if I do get close that it's probably going to be a temporary thing. But right now, I just need to feel like I'm a human being, you know, just for a short amount of time. And I would say that sounds violent to me. And also it's really fucking awful that you have to do that. It's awful that you have to play this game where no matter what you're not going to be a winner right? You know, there's no way to win. Because we need to we were playing this game where there's there's no winning we need to destroy the game. You know? So I would I would, you know, validate those those feelings and And, you know, talk about, you know, like weighing weighing up the pros and cons of, you know, I might have to engage in things that are disordered to access these, these privileges and benefits temporarily. And knowing that, that long term, probably not going to work, but sometimes you need to take a moment to catch your breath, right? Catch your breath. And when I say Catch your breath, I mean, so if this person decides to engage in dieting, that might be the catching the breath moment where you can then be on better footing to then deal with the fatphobia that we see every day. Right? Ultimately, the thing that we would love to get to is to be able to know how to, or you know, know how to and also have access to resources that help you survive this world. Whether that be you know, therapy, or fat community, or, you know, whatever it is like that, that is the goal because obviously, we want to be alive, right? We want to be able to survive in this world. And unfortunately, we're not going to wake up tomorrow and everyone but like, fat people are cool. Like, that's not that's not the reality. So we're gonna have to be in this world, this fat hating world, but we can do things to make it a lot easier. I was talking to so I got my hair cut yesterday and I went to this new hairdressers, a gender inclusive hairdressers. Amazing one of the posters that I had said, heterosexuality is as is a second boring life. So that was amazing. And I was talking to the hairdresser, and their pronouns were she, she, they. And she was saying about working previously in a straight salon is what she was calling it. And, and they were saying that they could never go back to a non queer salon. Because she's seen the light, right? Like now she's seen how you could be treated. And the alternative is just absolutely not sustainable for them.

And so she was saying that if she ever left that solid salon, she just wouldn't go anywhere else, that that would be the end of, of of their hair career, right. And I thought that that was really interesting, because I feel like that's what it's like when you come out of being in diet culture and believing it and believing it. And, and the current is like, you're at this. It's like you're working at a straight salon. And it's currently absolutely unbearable. But there is the existence of that one queer salon, but we don't know where it is yet, like so with Madeline to saying, I'm feeling awful. It's almost like Madeline to is in that, you know, currently in that that straight salon, where, you know, my hairdresser was saying that they they were telling where they were telling them to wear makeup and be more presentable as a woman. And she was like, Oh, gross. Whereas this other salon, it's just, it's just great, you know, everyone was just being themselves. And so I think about that, that that having to survive in that, you know, straight salon and Madeline to hear having to survive in a world where presumably everywhere that they turn is is fat phobic. And then I compare it to like so you know, when I first started this journey everywhere, everywhere I turned it was fat phobia because I had so you know, surrounded myself by that because I loved it. You know, I loved it quotation marks that was like, I was playing the game. All my colleagues were fat phobic. My friends were not all of them. My family, mostly, and you know, everything that like watched everything that every everything that went into my brain was like, fat people or shit. And that was overwhelming when, as Madeline one says, I came out of the matrix or went into the matrix. I don't know what the I can't remember what the analogy is. I know what to do with a film matrix. But I don't know. You know, if we're saying go into the matrix, go out of the matrix going in the matrix and we work this out. Okay, so we're going into the matrix and matrix is the fake world, right? And you're out of the matrix. Is that right? You're out of the matrix. And you're in reality, and now you can't see the make believe world. Yeah, okay. So going into the matrix, we'll be going into dark culture. I bet you there's some people listening being like, Eva Fox, like this is really simple. I'm sorry, I'm sorry. And so with Madeline too, there's a A technique that I like to use which is remove reduced protect, and remove reduce. redact is kind of like survival 101 and to reduce fat phobia in your life and so the first thing is can you remove the sources of fat phobia? Can you remove the sources of fat hate? So if it's Madeline's job to be surrounded by fat haters, is it realistic for Matt Madeline to get a new job? Probably not. But maybe maybe it is Madeline might be like, Oh, I'm thinking about leaving. And so actually, you know what, fuck it. I'm definitely gonna leave because I realized that this sucks. And then also Madeline might go to a new job and it might be just as bad because Madeline's in healthcare, right. Okay, so remove, but then again, Madeline might have some friends who were like, hate fat ease or whatever. And so Madeline could decide that they are going to remove those friends? Well, maybe not. Right? All of these are kind of like, maybe we can do that. And maybe not for various different reasons. Remove reduce. So if you can't remove something for various reasons, power imbalances, accessibility reasons, you just don't feel like it. Can you reduce the amount of time spent with them? So if it's a, you know, awful family member, Aunt Karen, who is like, Oh, we're fat people, you know, they're awful. Then maybe, you know, instead of spending every single Friday with with our Karen spend every other Friday, Friday with Aunt Karen, I said, just waiting for hours without Karen spent two hours with John Curran. And finally, if you can't do that, for whatever reason, like you know, your workplace, you can't just be like, You know what I've decided I'm working part time now. So I don't have to deal with you. Motherfuckers. That might not be something you can do, obviously. And so what you want to do then is protect protect your mental health. And so this could be doing things like listening to this podcast, it could be watching, affirming shows and movies, it could be reading books about this, it could be educating yourself, it could be looking, looking at pictures of fat people doing cool things. It could be talking to your therapist, etc, etc. Remove, reduce protect.

So when I see someone who was really, really struggling, and they're feeling kind of maybe similar to what Madeline is feeling, that tells me that they really are getting hammered, you know, like they're on the battlefield. They've got, you know, arrows and swords and people on horseback coming at them, and they cannot get a breath. There's no respite. And what is the solution for them? Sometimes it is to die it sometimes it's to try and get off the battlefield in some way. Maybe it's to hold up a shield so that the arrows don't hit you. Sometimes it's to hide in a trench, you know, what all of those things are valid. Sometimes it's to wave a white flag and say I give up, I'm going to go on a diet. And none, though none of those are choices and make you a bad person. It's what is accessible for you. And, you know, diets don't work. To make people thinner, you know, long term. But they might work at reducing the amount of stigma someone is experiencing temporarily. Because I mean, how many of us have experienced being thinner and people saying, Oh, my God, look at you, and feeling like a good person. And also how many of us has experienced that and then knowing that that person is judging us. And that when we do put weight back on, because that's what happens with diets that they're in their head, probably thinking. They used to be so thin and now look at them. They're fat. And what does that mean? Oh, they're this and they're that or whatever? If the person is not that positive. So yeah, it's complicated. It's complicated. So for Madeline and Madeline, I hope I answered those questions for you. And for Amy. Yeah, so I'm actually going to make this episode a little bit shorter today, because I've got laundry in the dryer downstairs with shared laundry, so I'll have to go get it. And as well, because I thought you know, I'm going to do a little shorter episode today because I'm always rambling on for about an hour. And you know, sometimes people might like a little shorter episode, even though this is at 40 minutes, so is it Sure it is. Okay, well, thank you for hanging out with me today. I really appreciate it. And if you've got questions for the show, email me fatty at first fatty.com And that's, that's my assistant and she will collect them. And I'll yeah, I'll have a look at them with my eyeballs. Yeah. All right. See ya on the next episode. Okay, bye.

EP141 Transcript

You're listening to the Fierce Fatty Podcast episode 141 listener questions. I'm your host Vinny Welsby. Let's do it.

Hello, welcome to this episode fatty and fatty allies. So great to see ya. Just want to do a land acknowledgement. In case you don't know where I am, I am in Vancouver, Canada, which is the traditional ancestral and unceded territory of the Coast Salish people, slaver tooth Musqueam nations and Squamish peoples love it. And hello.

I always talk I always just get into the episodes and just start talking like we're best friends. But you know what, sometimes people don't know who I am, where I live, what's it all about? And because you don't Hey, I, Vinny, my pronouns are they them. I am a trans non binary person, I, British Irish, I've been living in Canada for 13 use.

I'm a fat activist. And before doing this work, I was an adjunct professor at University of British Columbia in the business school. I was in corporate recruitment for nine years.

And what else I also do diversity consulting alongside my activism stuff, and I have a dog called Google. And that's it. That's everything about me. And I am currently have blonde, whitish hair, I'm a white person. I'm fat, like a medium fat got red lipstick on with a blue denim type shirt buttoned up all the way and some round tortoise shell glasses. I've got green eyes, big issues, and teeth.

So you can see if you're watching the video, but you're not watching the video. There you go. That's who I am. Okay, so today, I want you to do listener questions. And actually, we've got so many questions that I'm going to do a two parter. I love it. When you send me questions, send me questions, do it. My email is fatty@fiercefatty.com.

And my admin, my admin superstar person is going to pick them up and then put them into a document for me to look at and answer if I think that people would like to hear the answer. So we've got a few questions here. Today, I'm going to give you an overview we've got we're talking about pregnancy, we're talking about how to call people in and out. We're talking about trans stuff. And we're talking about a badly behaved mother. I haven't read all of the, the the email bits I got like the jest, and was like yeah, okay. So all right. Now, the first question we have here is, do you have any scripts for calling in? Slash out? Anti fatness in the moment just from regular people or people not necessarily from a doctor or anything? Excellent question that is from me yell and someone else has asked a similar question, which is, how should I respond to fat phobic statements from people? There can be subtle or really blunt fat phobic statements, I would just like to be equipped with comebacks when I feel like responding.

Excellent, excellent, excellent stuff. So first, I just want to explain calling and calling out. So calling in is something that is potentially a little bit more gentle. And something if you are wanting to maybe continue relationship, establish a relationship where the common is not necessarily as egregious, maybe you're ready to do a little bit of educating. So calling in would look like maybe taking someone aside and saying, Oh, hey, you know, when we were in that meeting, you said that thing and actually, what I learned about that thing is it's we don't really say that word anymore, or whatever. I'll give you some scripts in a minute. But it's kind of more of a Oh, hey, you know, what did you mean by that? Or what was your intent, that type of thing more kind of like, if your friend kind of said something and you're like, oh,

I know that you're totally cool. But sometimes we say something. So a friend would probably be like calling you out. And you'd be like, thanks. Calling in sorry. Calling out is more urgent calling out. So calling in is private more often than not calling out is public calling out could happen if calling in hasn't worked. So as an example, you know, the the incident with Linda Bacon, maybe you don't, but Linda Bacon, member of the health every size community wrote the book health every size was called out. Because they for for bad behavior. Linda Bacon uses a them pronouns by the way.

And the calling out happened with people making public statements, and the calling out happened after the calling in didn't work. Now you don't have to call in someone first. It depends on the situation, you could just go straight for the calling out.

It totally depends on on a million different factors. So calling out might be, say if you're in a meeting, and someone was like, oh, fat people are ugly. And you're like, Whoa, that was egregious. And you could like hey, actually, that's not cool. Don't talk about fat people like that. You giant Ding, dong.

Ding along dangling, dangling, dangling you ding dong, ding a ling, or ding along ding along we might have a new word. And so it's more urgent. It's more about safety. And it's all more about disrupting power. Okay. Or car. All right, so so so so, as you wrote about this in my book, my book, I've just picked it up. I was like, where is it copied? Why is the copy of my book not around? And I think it's because I feel I feel good about my book at the moment. Well, I haven't felt good about my book in the last couple of years, because there's a couple of things in there that I don't like, I think I used a word in there that I don't like, I think I use the word tribe, which is not appropriate. I am not a I'm a white person. I'm not from any First Nations indigenous communities, or I should not be using that word. And 2018. When I wrote the book, I obviously didn't know that. So there's a couple of other things. I just, I don't know, I'm beating myself up a little bit anyway. So I found it on my laptop, that the copy that went to print. So in my book, what to say. And so we've got a few different scenarios. So if someone says you're fat, if someone says you should do this, don't do that, as you should eat something or don't eat something. A person says, Oh, my God, have you lost weight. And so what to say in those types of situations, and we'll talk about more kind of day to day what this could look like. So some of these things, you'll be like, I would never say that. Some of the things you be like, yeah, that's, I could say something like that. And I could tweak it to make it sound like me. The idea with this stuff is to get a few word tracks in your brain, or even like put it on your phone or whatever. That sound like you that you would say. So you know if someone says something fucked up, and your normal response is maybe to be a bit of a plea people, please pleaser. Hello, that's me.

And I'm like, Hey, you should flip a table and then like, do a roundhouse click kick in someone's face and then clothesline them.

You might be like, well, that's great. And all I'd love to clothesline, someone but that's not my style. And so we have to make it sure make sure that it aligns with your style and what is accessible to you and what feels good. Okay, so quoting from my book, I'm quoting with the obligor. Who, apart from online criticism, you may find that those in your real life see I don't like that. See, pass veneer don't like that. Real online life is also real life and possibly, thank you future Vinny. You're welcome. You may find those in your day to day life or in person life are quote concerned about you loving yourself. So I have created a list of sassy, badass, easy ways to respond when people are throwing shade. About your appearance, your food choices, your lifestyle decisions, I shouldn't say throwing shade either.

Unknown Speaker 9:27

Of course you have. You have to say anything. Of course you don't have to say anything to anyone. But if you want to take a little sass from here, so this is kind of like you know, if you want to be a little bit, you know it kind of like fuck you.

Unknown Speaker 9:39

Okay, so if someone says you're fat, you can say, I know. Thanks for noticing. Don't I look gorgeous? Oh, wow. I'm so glad to meet my own personal dietician. Please tell me more about the nutritional value of kale.

Unknown Speaker 9:57

I'm so sorry. You have to degrade people to feel better.

Unknown Speaker 10:00

After about yourself.

Unknown Speaker 10:02

It's interesting how you think it's appropriate to comment on my body. I like that one.

Unknown Speaker 10:09

Do other people know that you're this rude?

Unknown Speaker 10:13

With the are you pregnant? Question? Yes, I had Mexican for lunch. So I'm expecting the arrival of a healthy 10 pound burrito sometime this afternoon. I have kept that a one in the back of my brain for so long now, and no one has asked me if I'm pregnant in like,

Unknown Speaker 10:32

maybe three or four years like before this way, maybe four or five? Yeah. What are we 2020 So for us, so like, in four years, none was asking me if I'm pregnant.

Unknown Speaker 10:42

So rude because I'm I'm so excited to come up with that one being like, the baby's due tomorrow, my giant shit is going to be arriving episodes soon.

Unknown Speaker 10:54

The last time someone the last time someone asked if I was pregnant, I was in a mall with my then boyfriend. And

Unknown Speaker 11:02

they were like, You know what, there's like little stores that are selling shit. And they were like, oh, here have some like herbs and stuff. And definitely you want it for the pregnancy. When's the baby? And I just walked away. I was like, No. And then. And then after that, I was I went to

Unknown Speaker 11:21

a haunted house amusement park thing for Halloween. And I went through and the I was given them my ticket and they said, you only have one ticket here. And I was like, Oh, yes. You know, everyone else has their own ticket. And he then he started putting it in my belly. He's like, don't you need a ticket for two? And I was like, Oh, no. And just went through it. But I mean, like shit.

Unknown Speaker 11:48

wides what? why would why would people do that? Why? Anyway, so yeah, burrito for the for the pregnancy.

Unknown Speaker 12:01

So if someone says you're fat Did you really just say that like a really or I am so proud to be fat and fierce a baby. So someone says you should do this or don't do that. Raise hands to your eyebrow pretending to look for something in the distance and say, I'm sorry, I was just looking for who actually asked for your opinion

Unknown Speaker 12:24

is cool how you think you know more about my life than I do? Please do continue.

Unknown Speaker 12:31

Remember when I asked for your opinion? No, me either.

Unknown Speaker 12:36

If I wanted to hear from an ass I'd fart

Unknown Speaker 12:40

I'm not interested in listening to people's opinions right now.

Unknown Speaker 12:46

I only listen to advice from people who pay my bills. You don't pay me you don't get you don't get a say that's like a report. If though if a report quote quote which is a what is it off the top of my head if those bitches don't. If they don't pay your bills, pay them bitches no mind.

Unknown Speaker 13:08

Why do you think it's appropriate to tell me what to do?

Unknown Speaker 13:12

If someone says I'm concerned about your health, then say if you were really concerned about my health, you'd be concerned about my mental health too. That's another one. I go. That's another one. I go back to a lot.

Unknown Speaker 13:23

I appreciate that. You're concerned about my health. My health also includes my mental health. So

Unknown Speaker 13:33

if someone says oh my god, have you lost the way

Unknown Speaker 13:37

you look so

Unknown Speaker 13:39

when people compliment weight loss, you don't know what you're complimenting. You could be complimenting an eating disorder. You could be complimenting an illness. You could be complimenting cancer, you could be complimenting grief. You could be complimenting

Unknown Speaker 13:52

you talking about someone's body. Start doing it. Okay, so am I gonna have you lost some way? Change the subject? Totally. Nice weather today.

Unknown Speaker 14:03

Oh, Sweet baby Jesus. I hope not. That's my go to is I hope really? Do you think so? Oh my God, I hope no hope not. I love being fat.

Unknown Speaker 14:12

No, but I look good, don't I? You know, it's probably all this happiness from not dieting.

Unknown Speaker 14:19

You could just say no.

Unknown Speaker 14:21

Well, do you monitor my body weight a lot. It must get tiring keeping tabs on me like that.

Unknown Speaker 14:28

I'm too busy being fabulous to notice my weight.

Unknown Speaker 14:32

Do you think it's appropriate to comment on someone's body?

Unknown Speaker 14:35

Not if I can help it

Unknown Speaker 14:38

is weight loss, something that's important to you? Because it's not to me, or the one you can use in any situation. Go fuck yourself. So they're some kind of sassy ones. But what I tend to do is a

Unknown Speaker 15:00

If you do want to call people out and I've spoken about this before have, you do not need to it is not your job, you are not being paid to educate people unless you are.

Unknown Speaker 15:12

You don't have to do that. If you are live in a big in a big body, I mean shit, this, there's so many things going on already that you have to deal with that having to deal with

Unknown Speaker 15:23

idiots who were like, Oh, you're fat, or I love diets and whatever, is it's exhausting enough. And if you choose to just be like,

Unknown Speaker 15:33

see you later and not deal with it, and then afterwards be like, Oh, I'm so mad about it. And that's absolutely fine. Or even in this situation, you could feel like I'm gonna say something and you could just be like, Oh, I don't know what to say, you know, sometimes, sometimes, situations like this. I don't know if you've ever experienced this, but you're just so riled up that you just want to cry, and then you start talking, then you just start crying. And you're just like, Oh,

Unknown Speaker 15:59

that was me. And

Unknown Speaker 16:03

I'm sad. And you're just and then afterwards, you're like, Well, why couldn't I communicate coherently then. And it's because so much is going on in your body. At that moment of when when when someone says something that's really awful. Our brains are in Fight, fight, flight freeze for and chances are that your heart is beating faster, when your heart is beating faster, your breathing becomes shallower, your breathing becomes shallower, and your brain is like oh my god, we're about to be eaten by a tiger, what are we going to do? And your brain is not as well equipped to be able to be like, Okay, let's assess the situation. Let's go back to that episode. 141, I think it was from, from fears fattie. And remember all the things that they said that I could say and I'm going to very eloquently and in a balanced way, say them to this person who is causing me harm. Like, if you, if you get to that point, it means that you have practiced this stuff a lot. And even I will get flustered from time to time if someone is saying stuff that maybe, you know, it makes me really mad or, or I've not heard before, or subjects that I'm not as familiar with.

Unknown Speaker 17:24

But with stuff like with fatness, most of the time, I'm just like, so used to the talking points that it becomes second nature and I don't need my body doesn't react in that way. But that's only because of the the the fact that I do this for my job, right.

Unknown Speaker 17:45

So normally, what I do is I try to understand where the other person is coming from in regards to like, why are they saying that? Are they saying that? Because they want to say a joke. They wanted to connect with me? Are they saying that to directly hurt me? Are they saying that? Because they're talking about themselves?

Unknown Speaker 18:08

How much? How much capacity do I have right now to engage them in a conversation? Like, for example, my neighbor, she's a 70 year old woman. She's really cool this like feminist, great choice in movies.

Unknown Speaker 18:26

Anyway, I love talking to her. And then I bumped into her and she's like, I'm just gonna go have my breakfast for breakfast. And I don't know why the fuck I said this. I said what you haven't for breakfast? Why did I do that? I should not be asking people what they're having for breakfast for a mean different reasons. But I was just like, Oh, I'm gonna go and have breakfast to you know, what are you? How are they? And then she said, Well, I used to eat this. And I said, That's what I eat for breakfast. And she says, but then I know I don't eat that anymore because it's got too much sugar. And I was like

Unknown Speaker 19:02

well, I just done a sugar episode on the podcast. And, and so I said, What do you mean? I know what she meant. But I said, What do you mean? And I said, Oh, is it that you fear that? Do you fear that sugar is bad for you? She says yeah, oh, yeah, here it is my said, actually, you know what? So this is this is the work that I do. And I literally just recorded an episode on sugar. And actually,

Unknown Speaker 19:26

we don't need to fish sugar and you're not addicted to sugar because she's like, she's like, I can't have sugar in it in my house. I will just eat all the sugar. I'm out of control around sugar. She said all that type of stuff, right?

Unknown Speaker 19:40

And,

Unknown Speaker 19:42

and then I said, Do you know what's not true? And she was like, really? I was like, yeah, and then I just left it left it at that because I could kind of see that she was kind of like bullsh.

Unknown Speaker 19:54

I'm gonna continue to get engaged in a conversation.

Unknown Speaker 19:58

But I might also in that section

Unknown Speaker 20:00

ration if she was like, sugar is bad, I might just be like, yeah, totally see like a baby.

Unknown Speaker 20:05

And she because she wasn't saying, Vinny, you're a piece of shit because you eat sugar she was, you know, it's about her, it was about her. And maybe in the future, I might talk about things with her. And she's actually said a couple of things that I was like,

Unknown Speaker 20:21

when she she talked about being afraid about getting fat

Unknown Speaker 20:24

twice.

Unknown Speaker 20:27

And it didn't, it didn't. When she said that it wasn't followed by, which is fucked up. Because, you know, I know that's, that's my own weight bias and Lola, and I was gonna bring it up with her later, but then I was like, Ah, fuck, I can't be bothered. Anyway, so she's the only person in my life currently who like kind of believes these types of things. And, and because she's so cool, I really like her.

Unknown Speaker 20:52

I will persevere up until that point. So, so come up with a few different ways, whether it's like, questioning them trying to understand their intent, or straight kind of shutting it down.

Unknown Speaker 21:09

Another thing kind of the I will go to is, the one that I go to is, I just want to be nice and kind to people, even if I don't understand them. And so

Unknown Speaker 21:23

when people are like, wow, in immigrants, or these people, or that people or whatever,

Unknown Speaker 21:31

I just think it's best in our world to try and be kind.

Unknown Speaker 21:37

And it's hard for people to say, No, we shouldn't be kind.

Unknown Speaker 21:44

I mean, it's hard. It's not impossible, it's certainly more like fuck them fatties.

Unknown Speaker 21:50

And, and that's when, you know, if I'm flustered, and I'm just like, I don't know what to say, I just say, I just want to be kind to people. And if people, you know,

Unknown Speaker 22:00

do this or do that I, you know, I just want to respect them and be kind, because that's important to me, that's one of my values.

Unknown Speaker 22:09

That's when you know, I want to have a conversation with someone, sometimes you just have to shut that shit down. So an example of me shutting something down recently was, there's this guy that is in my neighborhood. And he hangs out and he barks at people who he perceives to be women with who have dogs.

Unknown Speaker 22:30

And he's done it to me a number of times. And then he's like, laughing with his mates.

Unknown Speaker 22:40

I think he's probably got, you know, mental health issues and, and whatnot, but it, it makes me feel really uncomfortable. So anyway, I was like, Oh, my, this motherfucker. And I was talking to my therapist about it. And I was like, Well, I don't want to say anything, because I don't want him to be sad, because he's probably got mental health issues. And I don't want to be like, you know, you're a bad person. Because what if he then means that he's like, going to be sad, and then die. You know, my words are so powerful that I just got killed people on the street.

Unknown Speaker 23:10

So eventually, I saw him, he was like, harassing this woman that was at a coffee shop this this older woman at a coffee shop. And I walked by and he turned around him, he started barking at me and I said, Stop harassing women in the street.

Unknown Speaker 23:24

So that was me calling him out. That was loud enough for people to hear.

Unknown Speaker 23:29

And I mean, it wasn't like public in the, you know, I wasn't going on the news being like, man, but you know, barks at women.

Unknown Speaker 23:36

But

Unknown Speaker 23:38

I was firm, and I wasn't calling him in calling him him in would be me saying, Excuse me, can I have a conversation with you? Why is it that you're barking at people in the street? Why? Why is it that you're, you know, standing waving at a woman who is trying to ignore you and drink a cup of coffee? Like why? Why is it that you're doing that? I chose not to do that. I just went straight to call out, he shouted back at me and says, I'm not barking at women, women, your your dog is not a woman is it? I'm barking at your dog. And I was just carried on walking because I wasn't interested in engaging with him, but I just wanted to stand up to him. Afterwards, I felt terribly guilty, which I shouldn't have because I mean, he was badly behaved.

Unknown Speaker 24:18

Yeah, but I had had that line in my brain ready to go for when I saw him next because I had I knew I'd be mentioned within him next.

Unknown Speaker 24:29

And it was ready.

Unknown Speaker 24:32

And and basically, in other situations, I'm leading with curiosity of trying to understand the person

Unknown Speaker 24:39

for me, I find that I find it really interesting like with my my dad who died in in 2018. He was like, Oh, I don't like immigrants and I don't like this and that and, and Britain was better when I was younger and and over like, but why like, why don't you like in Britain, so because they're coming here and doing this and that and I'm like, Well, I'm an immigrant.

Unknown Speaker 25:00

and Canada. Oh, but you're a good immigrant. Why? Well, because is it because I'm white? Well, yeah. What is going on? Like, what's underneath that? What's what what was what was happening anyway and got to the bottom of it, my dad was like, I was just happier as a younger person. And there happened to be less diversity within our culture when I was a younger person. Therefore, I'm correlating it with the increased visible diversity that I'm seeing on the streets. I'm less happy now. Therefore, it's because of these people being present in our community. And I was just like, well slam dunk, and I was like, Well, this is it. This is he's like, Yeah, I still don't like him.

Unknown Speaker 25:46

Never got to him got him to change. And he he died. So there we go. Anyway, so next question, let's move on to I'm struggling with my fertility treatment being denied on the NHS. And the question of do I try to lose weight or not? Not that I want to lose weight. I'm happy as I am. And healthy to boot. So that's from Rebecca. Oh, my goodness. That's just so

Unknown Speaker 26:15

one of the first episodes of the podcast I think the only guests I ever had on the show was Nicolas Salman. Because I don't know why. I don't know. I don't know. Not that. I don't know why I had it. But I don't know why I started having guests because I was always like, I don't want to have guests because

Unknown Speaker 26:32

I can't be bothered to like book people or whatever.

Unknown Speaker 26:35

Anyway, I had Nicola salmon. She's great Nicola salmon, salmon on the Instagrams is called fat positive fertility. She's got a book, she's got tons of resources. In her Instagram link, she's got fat persons guide to getting pregnant for free. You can work with her in many different ways. You've got one on one coaching, one off consultation sessions. They've got a community fat and fertile Alliance and, and free workshops. Nicola is amazing. She's British, so she'll know about the NHS and all that type of jazz. In short, this is a really tricky question, because

Unknown Speaker 27:16

it means it's just so fucked up. There isn't the evidence to show that?

Unknown Speaker 27:26

Why why are we denying people with a certain BMI IVF treatment, just because it might be ever so slightly less effective.

Unknown Speaker 27:39

Like, and the stats are Nicola will be able to talk about this more, but it's like,

Unknown Speaker 27:46

tiny change tiny

Unknown Speaker 27:49

changes with between BMI categories. And so they're just like, Fuck it, if your BMI is this go by. It's just so awful. And it's eugenics.

Unknown Speaker 28:00

But what can we do if we are living in that system? And what can we do if we don't have the money to go private? And so with Rebecca, I don't know, Rebecca situation, Rebecca might have the ability to go privately for IVF. And privately, there might be clinics, I'm not sure of Rebecca's BMI that will take on that There are clinics that will take on higher weight patients, there might be areas within the NHS that take on higher weight patients. Now, I'm not an expert in this area. But I know certain places are more kind of cut and cut and dry. And some places might have some more flexibility. And so it might be a case of asking, Are there places in the UK that do take higher weight patients for IVF treatment? Which is not fair? I mean, it's not fair because that means that you might have to travel outside of where you are, which is causing an extra stress for you. And it's work that a straight sized person is not having to do and it What if they say no? And then you have to go private? What if he can't go private? So then the question is, do I lose weight,

Unknown Speaker 29:12

and some people may decide because of all of those barriers, that they are going to temporarily lose weight. Put that body into a disease state potentially if they go and get stomach amputation or squeezing surgery,

Unknown Speaker 29:35

set their body up to be in not the best condition to get pregnant in the first place. Because if you are losing weight, your body is in starvation mode.

Unknown Speaker 29:44

With all the trauma that's happening and all the worst out health outcomes that can happen from intentional weight loss, so that you can go to the doctor and be like, I lost the amount of weight that you told me to get the treatment and then let your body do what it is.

Unknown Speaker 30:00

Gonna do which is put the weight back on and more probably some people do that because they have no other choice literally being held hostage to do this awful thing that you don't want to do and you are healthy that you spent the Rebecca saying I'm healthy to do it

Unknown Speaker 30:21

is absolutely outrageous and a manifestation of eugenics policy, stopping fat people from having children when it's not evidence based

Unknown Speaker 30:37

makes me so mad.

Unknown Speaker 30:40

Gonna have a deep breath. Okay, so go check out Nicola salmon and I bet you she is going to be like okay a Bish bash Bosh this is what you want to do

Unknown Speaker 30:51

and especially in the UK and

Unknown Speaker 30:54

she also did a workshop with Regan Chastain which was fat healthcare summer workshop series report reproductive care for that patients with options for weight inclusive reproductive care. And I bet you can get a replay of that and Reagan's in the in the US so for the for those who are in the US, maybe Canada, and I'm not sure about other countries.

Unknown Speaker 31:18

But I mean, Jesus is fucked up. I feel for you I really do. I can't even imagine I cannot even imagine and also having to make that decision to to maybe engage in disordered eating to become thin temporarily to please this doctor

Unknown Speaker 31:41

makes me want to it makes me want to do a clothesline on someone.

Unknown Speaker 31:47

Yes, okay, so

Unknown Speaker 31:52

I need to

Unknown Speaker 31:55

so bad I'm so mad. Alright, so Melissa has emailed have any love your podcast like yay.

Unknown Speaker 32:07

What are the Melissa's questions is? How can I reframe my thoughts? When I think that everyone is staring at me because I'm fat, and judging me for being fat? So we did a whole episode about this.

Unknown Speaker 32:23

Let me find out what it was what number Hang on.

Unknown Speaker 32:27

Okay, so it was episode one to one seeing people have to go after gaining weight. And I talk about

Unknown Speaker 32:36

fearing judgments, right? judgments. Thing is also if you think about last episode, is it body dysmorphia? Or is it weight bias?

Unknown Speaker 32:48

Here I'm gonna kind of raise that of

Unknown Speaker 32:52

if you are actually someone living in a smaller body, I've no idea, then could that actually be body dysmorphia? And if you are a fat person, I mean, it could be as well if you're a fat person, but if you are a fat person, that that fear that fear, depending on your size, especially if you were a larger fat person could be legitimate, that people are staring at you because you're fat and are judging you, right. And we know as fat people that happens. And so

Unknown Speaker 33:25

I have a thought i People are staring at me because I'm fat. Maybe people are but also maybe people aren't. But what can we do? What can we do? And maybe like is it to the extreme where you're like, every single person is like, oh my god, there's a fat person or call the police. There's a fat person walking around the streets. And you think that every single person walking by you is just horrified and thinking, Oh, God, they're fat. And they're unattractive because they're fat. That's probably unless you're walking, I don't know, on Miami Beach, or I don't know, walking in a fashion show for thin people and all of the thin audience hates fat people. I don't know. Like, it's probably not realistic that every single person is

Unknown Speaker 34:17

awful. You know? And, you know, you don't have to be awful to have fat phobic thoughts about fat people. I mean, it's just a case of

Unknown Speaker 34:27

living in a society but

Unknown Speaker 34:30

it's natural for humans to notice other humans, right? And if, if another human is slightly more visually interesting, depending on whatever, they're a wheelchair user, they have a new visible text or something or, or they have a different hair color or they've got a big beautiful Afro or they're fat. You would probably notice them, right?

Unknown Speaker 34:58

But I I want you to

Unknown Speaker 35:00

Think about what you're thinking when you see someone who is a supersize fat person, or a fat person, or a smaller fat person, or any other person who might have a marginalized identity. What are you thinking? There might be a moment of, oh yeah. And if you are struggling with a lot of, you know, judgments about yourself, then you might be thinking negative things. But even if you were, if you did see a fat person and you thought negative things,

Unknown Speaker 35:30

you're not probably going to go home. You know, call up your mum or your mates and be like, guess what?

Unknown Speaker 35:38

I just saw a fat person walking down the street. Can you believe it? You're not gonna go, you know, to diarrhea at the night, Dear Diary, fat people exist, and I'm mad about it is a fleeting thought, unless there's something bigger and deeper going on.

Unknown Speaker 35:57

And so can we survive that? Can you survive knowing? Some people might look at you and say, I don't like that.

Unknown Speaker 36:10

And also, can you come to terms or realize that most people

Unknown Speaker 36:20

are probably going to be on the spectrum of just noticing you not noticing you not caring? Or being in their own head thinking? That person just looked at me? What was he thinking? Do they think that my my nose is too big? Do they think that this could do I have a camel toe today? Oh my god, does it? Do I stink? You know?

Unknown Speaker 36:46

The truth is, it's probably kind of like Shades of Grey, right? And there gonna be people being like, this person looks good. You know, you're walking by and they looked at you. And you might be in our heads being like, Oh, God, what are they thinking? And they're like, No, I wish I could look like them. Or, oh, they look happy. Or, or look at their shoes. You know, that could be thinking something positive. And the thing is, we can't do anything to change that. Right? Even if you know, I walked out on the street right now in a split crotch bikini with a peephole bra. People are gonna be like, Oh my God, you look awful. People are gonna be like, yes, you go for it. Oh my god, I love it. I love that you're showing off your nips, and your flaps. Some people are just gonna like someone walking around a bikini, whatever. Some people are gonna be like, you know, I wish I could do that. Some people are gonna be like, Oh, thank God, I'm not that fat, you know, and that's got really nothing to do with me, but their own self perception.

Unknown Speaker 37:51

Now, don't think that you're probably walking around in Split crotch panties. And a peephole bra. You probably walking around and you know, just average clothes. And so there's probably not going to be like shock and horror, when you're walking around.

Unknown Speaker 38:08

So we have to decide, are we going to let the potential negative thoughts of people stop us from living?

Unknown Speaker 38:17

Hopefully, the answer is, nah.

Unknown Speaker 38:23

Nah, for some people, some people it's not now it's Yeah, unfortunately. And that's when I think that then if we can get into accessing mental health help, that would be helpful. Because that seems like it's, it's, it's just disrupting your life. Right.

Unknown Speaker 38:43

So yeah, so there's some thoughts of, of what's going on what I would think you know, what I'm thinking what I've done to convince myself and reframe my thoughts of, you know,

Unknown Speaker 38:55

what are you gonna do?

Unknown Speaker 38:57

People are gonna judge you, what are you gonna do? You know, and the people who are judging you?

Unknown Speaker 39:03

If someone is judging you negatively, do you really care about their opinion? Like, would you want to be friends with that person? Mo, you're gonna fuck that person? No. So why would they, you know, why would their opinion matter? And I mean, I'm saying that as a rhetorical question, their opinion matters because we want to be loved by everyone and admired and because of safety.

Unknown Speaker 39:31

But we still also want to

Unknown Speaker 39:36

do shit, right?

Unknown Speaker 39:38

Okay, so Melissa is the question I became really fat in the pandemic and I've been avoiding going back to dancing because I feel people will judge me for how my body is now dancing is very thin, focused, how can I go slowly and dip my toe back into it? So yes, I've heard a lot about you know, traditional tap dancing settings. It was really fat phobic and

Unknown Speaker 40:00

A lot of stories I've heard from people who were in dance as younger people, that is horrifying. So I would try and do it in ways that is safe. And so for example, guess what I'm going to this weekend fat dance party.

Unknown Speaker 40:21

I've never been to a fat dance party, but I just saw it advertised on Instagram. And I was like, Is everyone

Unknown Speaker 40:26

Oh, shit. And

Unknown Speaker 40:28

actually, the creator messaged me and said, Do you want to come? And he's like, Yeah, I want to come.

Unknown Speaker 40:35

So

Unknown Speaker 40:37

I'm going to that. I've been to that dance studio before. And they've never, I've never seen a fat fat dancing. But anyway, I would look for a studio that seems to be a little bit more

Unknown Speaker 40:51

into diversity. Or there are many places that you can find dance videos that you could do at home. So you could be like, I like dancing, but I'm just gonna do it in the safety of my home for right now. Or I like dancing. And I'm gonna go to the studio that I think is a little bit more diverse. And I'm gonna bring my friend who happens to also be fat with me or someone who was supportive with me. And doing little things, see how it how it feels if it feels too much taking a step back.

Unknown Speaker 41:22

But I really hope that if you love dancing, that we don't let

Unknown Speaker 41:31

we don't we wouldn't. We don't stop doing that the things that bring us joy because of our body. And also, so many so many people I'd say like, you know, science 200% of people are like, my body has changed during the pandemic and I'm worried what people are gonna think.

Unknown Speaker 41:49

So, yes, all right.

Unknown Speaker 41:54

Okay, so let's go to our last question, which is from

Unknown Speaker 42:02

second last question, sorry.

Unknown Speaker 42:05

So second last question. Hi, Vinny. Love your show. Thank you always look forward to you. Your show. Your humor makes me crap crack up out loud. Thank you. It always helps me feel better about myself. While on this fat phobic world. Hora. I'm pleased about that. Thank you, Dina. I am dealing with my elderly mother. I want to enjoy the last years I have with her. I moved away when I was in my 20s and hadn't lived near her until now. I had a lot of time to heal from her very intense and sometimes downright mean personality. There were control issues and with weight and food. We live in the same city. Now. One of the first things she said to me when she first got off the plane was how she didn't like my body.

Unknown Speaker 42:57

Before she moved here, she agreed no weight, diet and body talk. But it didn't stick. At first I firmly held her to it, but she just keeps bringing it up. My mum is a bit of a manipulator. Instead of letting her think she's got my she's got my goat. I've decided just to not engage anymore, and change the subject in order to keep the peace. She isn't a person that takes into consideration someone else's feelings before speaking. I've noticed that after I visit with her I usually have urges to eat sweet, sugary and sometimes large volumes of food. And so I eat more than my body wants and my mind starts pondering desperately to how can I lose the weight? I've made much progress with intuitive eating and rarely binge. But after seeing my mom who is also starting to get senile, it is hard. Sorry this is so long big hoax Dina

Unknown Speaker 43:54

Love it. Love it. I mean, I love that I love that you've shared all of that I don't miss I don't think it's too long. This is so

Unknown Speaker 44:04

this is hard right?

Unknown Speaker 44:06

So

Unknown Speaker 44:08

I want to enjoy the last years I have with her.

Unknown Speaker 44:12

It sounds like your mom is trying to do

Unknown Speaker 44:18

many things so that you can't enjoy

Unknown Speaker 44:21

the last years with her

Unknown Speaker 44:26

right doesn't it? She's what she's saying is

Unknown Speaker 44:35

triggering you into disordered eating behaviors maybe.

Unknown Speaker 44:43

And by the way, it's absolutely okay to

Unknown Speaker 44:46

soothe your soul with with food. Right?

Unknown Speaker 44:52

If that is what you have available for you to in order to manage certain emotions and that's what's what's there.

Unknown Speaker 45:00

then that's okay. Right.

Unknown Speaker 45:03

But also it sounds like that that's doesn't feel good for you. So it sounds like we want to work to a different solution in this scenario.

Unknown Speaker 45:13

So I wonder, does your mum want you to be there? Like, does she,

Unknown Speaker 45:20

she interested in having a relationship with you?

Unknown Speaker 45:24

Because I'm like, I'm like reading this. And I'm like, wow, this is this doesn't sound like, I mean, we've got, we don't have a lot of, you know, all the information here, right? I'd love to, you know, if you were on here right now and having a conversation, or there'd be many questions I'd want to ask you have, you know, what does she do that, that makes you feel good? Like?

Unknown Speaker 45:46

Do you have happy times with her? Does she tell you nice things? Or is it just this, this abusive stuff, and, you know, there's this big thing of kind of, what if someone's going to die soon, and we're gonna have to, you know, be nice to them, who knows when they're gonna die. And,

Unknown Speaker 46:05

you know, they're old. And so they get a pass, because they're old. And I hate all of that. I'll hate all of that. And their families. So we have to have

Unknown Speaker 46:15

no, we don't have to, like, if you don't you, you don't have to see your mum, talk to your mum, spend time with your mum, if you don't want to just put it out there, it sounds like you do.

Unknown Speaker 46:28

And it sounds like also you want to say your mum, but you want to enjoy your time with your mum. So

Unknown Speaker 46:37

it sounds like you did some incredible work with saying, you know, setting boundaries.

Unknown Speaker 46:44

And she also did some incredible work to push you and push you and push you until that boundary broke down. So I wonder

Unknown Speaker 46:55

how we can reestablish that boundary and

Unknown Speaker 47:01

actually stick to a bottom line.

Unknown Speaker 47:05

And, you know, sometimes you might decide, okay, well, I'm just going to let it slide today. But if it's really affecting you, I think it would be fantastic. If you know, you're going to be like, right? I'm going to leave, I'm going to get up and leave.

Unknown Speaker 47:22

And so your mum would probably get the question the get the message pretty quickly, if you know, she started talking about your fat or your this or whatever, I don't like your body. And you say you say I love you, Mom, I hope you have a wonderful rest of your day.

Unknown Speaker 47:37

But I I'm unfortunately I'm not allowed to I'm not, I'm not able to be around diet, talk, and just leave and be consistent. And, you know, you might decide that you're not going to be around her.

Unknown Speaker 47:53

Or you might decide

Unknown Speaker 47:56

I'm just going to suck it up

Unknown Speaker 47:59

and take all of her abuse. Because I don't see that there's any way that she could possibly attack change. And I want to be around her, even though she's being abusive, and take that risk to see what that does to my mental health. Because I don't want to feel guilty for not being there.

Unknown Speaker 48:21

I don't know what the answer is right, you know,

Unknown Speaker 48:25

especially you saying, you know, maybe her dementia might be coming in to.

Unknown Speaker 48:32

I'm worried about like, you don't want her to think that she's upset you.

Unknown Speaker 48:42

But it is upsetting. Right?

Unknown Speaker 48:45

And so if you don't want her to know that you're upset, I think you know, just leaving.

Unknown Speaker 48:52

I mean, you say you change the subject. I mean, does that work? Does that feel okay? It says you say afterwards, you don't feel good.

Unknown Speaker 49:00

But it's hard, right?

Unknown Speaker 49:02

I think what I would do in this situation. And what I would do is based on that little bit of information and also not being actually in that situation. So it's probably a lot easier for me to say is I would probably try again with the boundaries.

Unknown Speaker 49:17

See what she does

Unknown Speaker 49:19

and have to stick to some really clear bottom lines. And if she kept making me feel the way that you're saying, I'd have to either reduce the amount of time that I spent with her significantly or stop seeing her.

Unknown Speaker 49:36

So I mentioned my dad before and my dad dying in 2018.

Unknown Speaker 49:41

My dad

Unknown Speaker 49:43

he almost died when I was

Unknown Speaker 49:48

about six or seven due to alcohol and his consumption of alcohol. He had cirrhosis of the liver, all of his drinking buddies all day

Unknown Speaker 50:00

died, he was the only one who didn't. And it was probably because he had a young family had four kids, right?

Unknown Speaker 50:07

And so

Unknown Speaker 50:09

the idea Daddy's gonna die. He's the end of his life was there right at the top from when I was six. My mom would always be like, your father is probably going to die soon. He's not going to live long.

Unknown Speaker 50:22

So that message of his he's going to die.

Unknown Speaker 50:26

Anytime made me have a relationship with Him out of guilt.

Unknown Speaker 50:34

Because he's going to die any minute. Right?

Unknown Speaker 50:37

He died when he was 6968.

Unknown Speaker 50:45

And he didn't die from from alcohol. He died because he had a blood clot in his leg.

Unknown Speaker 50:54

So

Unknown Speaker 50:56

that kind of like, Oh, he's gonna die soon. He's gonna die soon. So yeah, so I have to have relationship with Him. The more that I went to therapy, the more that I was like.

Unknown Speaker 51:06

But,

Unknown Speaker 51:08

you know, he's lived this long. Do I want to continue having a relationship with Him? When, when I would talk to him? He would never ask me anything about me. He would just go on about whatever his things. I mean, if I had went up to him and said, you know, a stranger went up to him and said, Tell me about your child. What job do they have? He he'd be like, oh,

Unknown Speaker 51:35

did not he wouldn't even know what job I had. He knew that I lived in Canada,

Unknown Speaker 51:40

because he likes to talk about Canada because he lived in Canada when he was baby.

Unknown Speaker 51:45

But I didn't feel good after spending time with him.

Unknown Speaker 51:51

So I just stopped. I didn't I didn't make an announcement. I just, I would see him like the last time I saw him was my sister's wedding.

Unknown Speaker 52:02

We had a little bit of a conversation. And that was it. And when I knew that I couldn't continue having a relationship with him. I was like, Okay, well, how can I handle this guilt? Like if he was to die tomorrow? And I don't have a relationship with him? What will I regret? And I said, Okay, well, I'll regret not asking him certain things. Because he did some fucked up stuff. To me, my mum, the family

Unknown Speaker 52:28

to ask him, Why did he do that?

Unknown Speaker 52:31

What's behind him drinking? What's his what's his, you know, ask him questions about his background and all that type of stuff. And so that's what I did. I said, Hey, can we can we do a, we, we did a at the time, it was a new thing, like video calls were a new thing. So we did a video call. And I recorded it. I wrote down the answers to all of his questions. And it was kind of like all the questions you'd ever want to ask a parent, like, have you ever been arrested?

Unknown Speaker 52:57

What was it like as a child? Why did you do that fucked up abusive thing.

Unknown Speaker 53:04

And I was able to get then get closure.

Unknown Speaker 53:08

And then kind of end the relationship. And I didn't do what kind of like this, this is the end of the relationship, it was kind of like, Oh, I'm just going to, you know, not be there as much.

Unknown Speaker 53:20

And when he died, I had that kind of, I'm so pleased that I did that thing. And also, I'm pleased that I didn't force myself to have a relationship with Him out of guilt.

Unknown Speaker 53:32

So I don't know if that that in that that story is going to be helpful to your tool. Of course, everyone's situation is different. You might be the sole carer of your mum.

Unknown Speaker 53:42

There might be other things going on.

Unknown Speaker 53:46

You know, like, for example, sometimes parents are like, Oh, if you don't hang around with me, then you're not going to get any heritance. With my dad, I was like, well, there's no, there's no inheritance. So I don't have to worry about him cutting him out, cut me out of his will. He cut my brother out of his well, just because he was a dickhead. Yeah. So

Unknown Speaker 54:06

good luck to you. And really, I would, you know, you said you started with the boundaries. You did so much work there, I think continue with the boundaries and hold firm to that bottom line. And see how that makes you feel? You know, does it make you feel better when you do go home? And do you engage in disordered eating behaviors? Or is that happening less?

Unknown Speaker 54:29

So kind of you could and there's no kind of, if you do this and you're a bad person if you don't do this and you're a good person and bla bla bla, whatever. See how it goes for you? And

Unknown Speaker 54:41

yeah, good luck. Okay, so our last question is from BK.

Unknown Speaker 54:47

BK says, Hey, Vinnie, thanks for sharing this and I've been having some thoughts lately.

Unknown Speaker 54:54

Sharing this as saying, Hey, do you have any questions? Well, for the past past few few years, I've kept

Unknown Speaker 55:00

I came out as non binary trans mask.

Unknown Speaker 55:05

Just an FYI for people who are not familiar with the language non binary is saying that you don't adhere to the binary

Unknown Speaker 55:14

designations of man or woman.

Unknown Speaker 55:18

That's like either or, I'm knew the man or woman. Some people, some non binary people all have their own version of what binary non binary feels like to them. For me, it feels like gender, is if we think about gender as all the Scots stars in the sky, one of those stars is man, one of those stars is woman. Another star is non binary. No, the other stars represent all different genders that maybe we don't have words for yet. And we also have lots of words for different genders anyway. But yeah, that's the kind of like simplified trans mask trans means the prefix trans means going from one place to another. Trans means not trans, when it comes to gender, transgender means that

Unknown Speaker 56:04

you don't align with the sex that was assigned at birth. So for me, the sex I was assigned at birth is female, I don't align with that, because I'm non binary, therefore, I would be a trans person, not all non binary people identify as trans you can identify any way you want. But it would be under the trans umbrella, a non binary would be under the trans umbrella. Trans mask is so masculine is short for mask is short for masculine. And so this person would align a lot with a lot with me, although I'm kind of like,

Unknown Speaker 56:43

feminine, androgynous in my brain, more masculine. It's also complicated. So it's someone who is their gender is non binary. They are trans because they were not assigned non binary at birth, they were assigned, you know, male, female, or intersex

Unknown Speaker 57:04

is a trans and then masculine is that gender presentation, or could be how they're feeling in the room.

Unknown Speaker 57:12

So let me read that again, without this whole big long explanation.

Unknown Speaker 57:19

I've been having some thoughts lately. Well, for the past few years, since I came out as non binary trans mask, about how my body size about my body size and shape. I know that you did a trans focus episode, but I can't remember the details, by the way that that episode is episode 1123123. Let's see if I can find out what the name of it is. I think it was like trans and trans and fat identities. Yeah, fans that fat and trans identities intersecting. So if you want if you want to go in depth from that, then have a read of what.

Unknown Speaker 57:55

So BK continues, I know that gender is a social construct, yet. I have trouble detangling gender from body shape. I don't feel like I necessarily want to have surgery. For example, when I see a thin mask a body in a nice fitting suit, like Rico Ortiz with some heart eyes. I'm so overcome with jealousy, I will never have that shape, though. I got close in the throes of my eating disorders. So even if I were to say chop off my tits, I would still have a very femme presenting body. The only benefit would be the ability to fit into the shirts I like IE men's button ups. So then how much of that is wanting to be perceived as a masculine person? How much of that is my actual desire for the body? How much of that is internalized fat phobia and transphobia? How much of that is me thinking thin mask people in suits that good? Because that's what I've been conditioned, conditioned to believe. It feels like such a struggle with no answer. I know I don't need to look a certain way to be non binary slash trans but I'm definitely uncomfortable with femininity, but my body and the way it collects, collects fat reads femme. So anyways, your reflections on that intersection I think would be helpful and interesting. Which does lead me to Okay, and then something else probably.

Unknown Speaker 59:22

This is such a great question. Because this is something that I've been thinking about a lot too. I'm not an expert on on trans

Unknown Speaker 59:34

trans stuff in the way that I you know, my experience with fatness I've been talking about fatness for many years and that it's been my own personal journey right. And my own personal journey to with trans nurse and being non binary and also having the exact same thoughts as you BK of looking at thin trans men or not

Unknown Speaker 1:00:00

binary trans mask men, or non binary people, sorry.

Unknown Speaker 1:00:06

And thinking,

Unknown Speaker 1:00:08

my body will not look like that. Because I was literally just thinking this morning, my belly, if I think about men's bellies, they'll have a beer belly, right? And it'd be like a round kind of nice round, like barrel, or is the way that my belly holds fat is more,

Unknown Speaker 1:00:31

quote, feminine.

Unknown Speaker 1:00:34

And I was thinking is that same thing? Like, what if I did chop off my tits. And you know, that's something that I was like, Oh, well, maybe I'll start binding. So we you can bind, bind your chest to make it look flatter. But then because I'm fat, it will never necessarily look like

Unknown Speaker 1:00:57

a thin person who binds or has

Unknown Speaker 1:01:02

the chest tissue removed. Chest tissue is the is the

Unknown Speaker 1:01:09

gender neutral way of saying

Unknown Speaker 1:01:12

tats or breasts or whatever. Because some, some people that

Unknown Speaker 1:01:19

call referring to chest tissue as breasts is,

Unknown Speaker 1:01:25

doesn't feel good, right? Because if they're a man, and they have these things that people are calling breasts, that can be recalled a lot of dysphoria.

Unknown Speaker 1:01:41

But you can, there are these vests that you can wear that that kind of compress your torso. And so then you'd get more of that kind of,

Unknown Speaker 1:01:52

quote, masculine Barili type distribution of your fat.

Unknown Speaker 1:02:00

And so the question here from BK is, is that transphobia? Is that fat phobia? Is that me just wanting to be perceived as a masculine person? Is that a desire for how my body looks? The answer is, I don't know. I don't know. But I have a suspicion that because

Unknown Speaker 1:02:27

we've been raised to be transphobic, fat phobic.

Unknown Speaker 1:02:33

And because we are trans people,

Unknown Speaker 1:02:37

that is probably a combination of a lot of things, right? of wanting to feel at home in your body.

Unknown Speaker 1:02:45

And there being some incongruency is there have you know,

Unknown Speaker 1:02:51

and thinking about you know, as well

Unknown Speaker 1:02:56

if the criticism if fat people really did love their themselves, why why are they wearing makeup? Why are they brushing their hair? And it's like, well, because it's the separate because it makes me feel nice to like, as I'm wearing lipstick today. I like it. It makes me feel good. It makes me feel like me. It doesn't mean that because I wear lipstick. I hate fatness

Unknown Speaker 1:03:21

because it works. Right. But that simplification? I wonder if that's like a white supremacist?

Unknown Speaker 1:03:30

I bet it is. Yeah, that's white supremacy, culture, black and white thinking. That's white supremacy culture. So then we've got that added layer of is my own internalized white supremacy at play here to now says, Yeah, I'm white. So probably, and in what form? It's complicated and exactly what BK says, there's an ending struggle with no answer.

Unknown Speaker 1:03:54

And I think,

Unknown Speaker 1:03:56

I mean,

Unknown Speaker 1:03:57

are we ever gonna get an answer of like, what percent of the way we're thinking about this certain topic is bigotry. We're never gonna get their answer, because the answer is who the fuck knows. We can't measure it like that. But I think there is an answer in regards to the way that we can work towards feeling better in our bodies, and feeling that our bodies are aligned with our gender identity. And also knowing that if we are aware of transphobia and fat phobia and white supremacy and all the other different oppressive systems out there, that we are probably going to be asking ourselves questions exactly like what we're doing here now with BK of what is going on, and we can begin to explore of

Unknown Speaker 1:04:54

is it that and the thing is here, BK is 1,000,000,000% right now

Unknown Speaker 1:05:00

What we see in the media of of trans mask people is Elliott page. And his body type six pack, ripped, thin.

Unknown Speaker 1:05:17

And when we like, because I'm there on Instagram this weekend looking for all of the trans mask, non binary people.

Unknown Speaker 1:05:26

They look great. I'm like, they're they're rocking a suit, they're rocking the shirt, and they're thin.

Unknown Speaker 1:05:35

Am I thinking that they look great? Because they're thin?

Unknown Speaker 1:05:42

am I teaching my brain what a trans mask person looks like? Because all of the people who come up on the trans mask hashtag are followed the most are thin and muscular.

Unknown Speaker 1:06:01

Or is something else going on? And these are the questions that I'm asking myself. I you know, I don't know.

Unknown Speaker 1:06:11

And it's probably yes. And probably also something else too. And, and, you know, how can I find more

Unknown Speaker 1:06:19

fat trans mask people?

Unknown Speaker 1:06:25

Because I think

Unknown Speaker 1:06:28

I know, you know, like, if I saw a fat trans mass of people wearing a suit, wearing suits, you know, Looking dapper, you know, cool hair cut stub or whatever. I be like, yeah, that looks great.

Unknown Speaker 1:06:43

But then, what if?

Unknown Speaker 1:06:47

What if

Unknown Speaker 1:06:50

the distribution of the body fat

Unknown Speaker 1:06:58

makes me think that distribution is quote, feminine? Would I think that they look less good? I'm just like, thinking out loud here is so complicated, right? It's just so kind of

Unknown Speaker 1:07:13

how much of this is

Unknown Speaker 1:07:17

this ridiculous idea of how

Unknown Speaker 1:07:22

gender looks?

Unknown Speaker 1:07:25

Anyway, again, I'm not an expert on this. This is just me. This is me going through the process right now of, of

Unknown Speaker 1:07:35

being like I was triggered in the last few weeks being

Unknown Speaker 1:07:42

at this new choir that I went to.

Unknown Speaker 1:07:48

I shared on Instagram, but there's so this new choir that I went to, right, so I stopped going to my last choir because it was like women, women, women, women, women, were all women here and we love we're men with women, women were men. And I was like, Hey, I'm non binary, and they're like women.

Unknown Speaker 1:08:03

Anyway, so I went to the new choir and messaged them beforehand. I was like, Hey, I'm trans non binary. You're cool with that. They're like, we're cool with that. And then

Unknown Speaker 1:08:13

I went and they were like, Hey, there's a woman. Literally, I walked in and they said, you're a female.

Unknown Speaker 1:08:22

That's going to happen, because my voice is tenor tenor is lower.

Unknown Speaker 1:08:29

It's more common that men would be tenors, right?

Unknown Speaker 1:08:34

And it'd be less common not although not uncommon for for women to be pretenders. But anyway, I'm not a woman, right? And so I've messaged them about this. I'm not a woman. They said to me, you're Oh, hey, you're a female tenor. I said, I'm not a female tenor. I am a non binary tenor. So what does that mean? There's no actually that means you're a tenor one and then low voices will be tended to oh, great, great. I thought we had that COVID. So I walked in and they said, Oh, you're a female tena. We've got another female tena. And I said, Actually, no, no, I'm not. I'm not a female tenor. I'm non binary. And then they started talking. The conductor was like, female tennis and then I

Unknown Speaker 1:09:14

showed him a name tag with the them on there to reminder just in case you forgot, and she was kind of like, Oh, what are you talking about? She kept saying, female Tanner's and I was literally had to sit there and convinced myself not to cry, and was just like,

Unknown Speaker 1:09:30

having a conversation in my mind of like, just leave, just walk up and get your stuff and you've got a friend there and tell them to pick up your stuff. No, stay, you're missing out on joy because of this law. Anyway, I stayed. And then in the intermission, I said, Hey, can you not call me female Tana? And she was like, Oh, my God, I'll get it. And it's like me. I've already had 50 million emails with you about this Jesus Christ, like how many times I have to say, I'm not a woman.

Unknown Speaker 1:09:58

And then she said,

Unknown Speaker 1:10:00

A conductor said well, actually, we Why don't you just go into the

Unknown Speaker 1:10:07

Alto section? Alto is, is higher voice. Why don't you just go into the Alto section because then I won't have to remember to not call you a female. And I was like

Unknown Speaker 1:10:19

I think I said at work alright then But then then then I went back and said, actually, you know what, I don't want to go into the alter section. I want to stay in the tenor because if it's gender affirming to be with the men and she just burst out laughing What does God What

Unknown Speaker 1:10:34

are you doing?

Unknown Speaker 1:10:36

Why can you be so? Oh, anyway, it uses mopping and I was just like yeah,

Unknown Speaker 1:10:42

she's I'll let you know. I'll let you know if you can be you can stay as a timer.

Unknown Speaker 1:10:47

So she emailed me the next night. Vinnie is going to stay in the tenor. She is this Lola because she CC Don's admin person. Let's you back.

Unknown Speaker 1:10:58

By the way,

Unknown Speaker 1:11:00

my 50,000,000th time of saying My pronouns are they them and so you won't use a word she hers. So you would say they are in this section, that person message rack and said, Oh, actually, Vinnie is in that section. And they were always in that section. And I was like, Oh, they

Unknown Speaker 1:11:17

got it, right. So anyway, I was having a lot of like,

Unknown Speaker 1:11:22

dysphoria, dysphoria, and looking at pictures of, you know, like, what can I do I

Unknown Speaker 1:11:30

and wanting to just be, be

Unknown Speaker 1:11:34

have the body of a man so that

Unknown Speaker 1:11:38

I'm just perceived as a man

Unknown Speaker 1:11:42

and thinking about that a lot of

Unknown Speaker 1:11:46

what that what that what would that looked like for me as a fat person, and also wanting to hold on to certain aspects of femininity, you know?

Unknown Speaker 1:12:01

Like things like, you know, wearing lipstick and all that type of stuff. And absolutely, I could do that as a trans man, if that's what I wanted to do. I'm just exploring it Alright, so I'm not saying that I'm a trans man. I'm just you know, you know, maybe I was triggered and I you know, we're searching for comfort in that maybe actually, you know, I am a trans man and who knows.

Unknown Speaker 1:12:23

talking aloud blubbery bloop bloop

Unknown Speaker 1:12:27

so

Unknown Speaker 1:12:29

the the resolution to this was I had dinner with some ended and my friend friend of the show, and we were joking about this thing after me being you know, annoyed and upset or being like, Okay, well, she's gonna actually said she was gonna stand outside the place that we we do rehearsals. And

Unknown Speaker 1:12:48

I had seen as mean that said,

Unknown Speaker 1:12:52

I managed to train my parents not to miss gender, my sibling. By bringing a

Unknown Speaker 1:12:59

is not Foghorn. What's it called? You know, it's an air horn, air horn. I brought an air horn to Christmas dinner every time they misgendered my sibling, I blew the air horn. They were trained really quickly not to do that again. Maybe that's what Melissa and Melissa

Unknown Speaker 1:13:17

have lost the thing. The last question should do with

Unknown Speaker 1:13:23

anyway, I was talking about love and about that. And then someone's like, well, I'll come with a fuckin Foghorn and air horn and sat outside the venue. And every time she was like, female tanners. And so then

Unknown Speaker 1:13:36

I decided I was going to write a sine. So I wrote a sine, because it's an 80 person choir, right? And so people are having side conversations while she's conducting or whatever. And so she kind of, she doesn't listen to them. And so when you're talking, you say, Hey, she doesn't listen. So she misgendered me I couldn't say hey, because she, you know, tune it out type of thing. So made a sign saying 1001, not female tenor, and was prepared to hold it up. But then last week, which is our second week,

Unknown Speaker 1:14:07

she towards the end, said, Oh, by the way, I've had a request from a non binary.

Unknown Speaker 1:14:14

Kinda can't get with the words there. It should be a non binary person.

Unknown Speaker 1:14:19

And I'm going to call all the female tenors, tenor one, I was like,

Unknown Speaker 1:14:24

loops applies again, not female. And then she said, Oh, a female and a non binary. And

Unknown Speaker 1:14:33

the male tennis 10 A two. And someone said, Well, why don't you just say, people with high voices 1001 and people low voices tend to she's like, Is this too complicated? too complex?

Unknown Speaker 1:14:46

It's like, well, A for effort, which is great. So theoretically, I'm never gonna have to use a sign. But I've got to kept it in my folder in my music folder. So that if that has I mean, she's probably

Unknown Speaker 1:15:00

Got a slip up? I can I can hold it up.

Unknown Speaker 1:15:04

Yeah, so anyway, I'm blabbing on.

Unknown Speaker 1:15:10

Okay, so I'm gonna leave it there. I'm gonna answer some more questions next time. I like this. I like answering questions. It's like we have this log cabin, we suddenly have a relationship. It's like you're my friend. And I'm just saying friends stuff. So

Unknown Speaker 1:15:24

I like it. I like it. All right, well, um, hey, if you want to send a question and then Vin fatty at first fatty.com and my assistant will put them into a file for me to have a look at if I could do part three of this.

Unknown Speaker 1:15:46

And I hope you are staying feels a fatty and we'll see you in a while. Like Gator at a

Unknown Speaker 1:16:06

perfect.

EP140 Transcript

You're listening to the Fierce Fatty Podcast episode 140. Do you have body dysmorphia? Or is it weight bias? I'm your host, Vinny Welsby. Let's do it.

Welcome to this episode, so pleased to see ya. How you doing? It's life. Okay. My life's good. I just bought a bday. Oh, it was amazing with a BJ. Or as some folks call it a budu. Day, I think that's more of an American thing. Say, buddy, I got it from tushy you might have seen the adverts around around the place. And I got it on sale for 96 American doll hairs. And it's normally like, I don't know, 150 It's the one with hot water as well as cold water spray up your bum hole. And just like an FYI, if anyone wants to buy a one I was worried about the. So if you look at the thing to tyshee, buddy, now that I'm saying it, your device is probably hearing me say it, and it's gonna advertise it to you. I don't know if that's true. But anyway, anyway, there's like, you stick it in your toilet. And it there's like a box that comes to the side. And I was like, well that I'm I'm gonna sit on the box, I know because my bum is bigger than the toilet seat. And it's gonna hit this thing. But on the tishie thing, when you put it onto the seat, it goes underneath the seat underneath the bottom of seat, it actually has like a snake I type slots where you can slide it across. And so I slid it across. So it's not center on my toilet. But it's not didn't it didn't actually look center, but so that the box was slightly to the right even more. And so my almost almost doesn't, I guess it can touch it a little bit, but almost doesn't touch it. And so if you are bigger than me, so I must size US size. 20 ish. And obviously, everyone's leg and bum wits is different. And it's a control panel. That's what I'm talking about. It's a control panel. So if you're worried about that, then you have a little bit of adjustability on that. And I mean, I've had it for a day I installed it yesterday, I felt like a plumber extraordinaire. extort, installing it like yeah, pretty. It was you know, relatively easy. And my water pressure in this apartment is so strong. So when I first use it, I was like, oh, lash X. The it's like, you know, when you watch those videos on YouTube of people doing power washing, and their power or power washing, like the pavement or whatever. And my water pressure is so high.

That's like, what what my, what my day might be day is it's not that hard isn't obviously not that extreme. But yeah. So I'm sorry if I need to power wash my asshole. Then there you go. And you can like wiggle around and do other areas too. So I was like finally because I have IBS. And I was like I don't want to be like wiping my bumhole all the time. And so this is an alternative. So yeah, anyway, a little bit of be day by day news for you. Yes. And so today, and by the way, hey, hey, if I told you this already, I have told you this already. But if you don't remember telling me this. And if you don't have it. There's a browser extension extension called Honey, listen, I'm not I'm not sponsored by Toshi or honey, you can probably get a if you can't get the sushi in your area for a good price and just get something of Amazon is cheaper, right? Whatever. But this is browser extension called Honey, it's free. And it will pop up. You install it and then it pops up when you're at a checkout. So often, I'll get a discount. So my the tissue was actually cheaper, because then like the honey popped up and it was like some random discount code that I wouldn't have known about if it wasn't for honey. They probably like selling my data to someone else. I got the cheaper bday am I going to get cheaper? clothes shopping and cheaper or most everything the only thinking just work on is DoorDash. So food delivery, because they're probably like, we're onto your ship, honey. You can't use it doesn't work here. Yeah, anyway, so get honey if you haven't already not sponsored. Yeah, so why don't you talk about body dysmorphia disorder today? Because I've never actually spoken about it, which is, I'm surprised I haven't. What it is how is it related to weight bias? Is it caused by weight bias? Is it totally unrelated? And as well because, you know, we, we are in the world of, of body positivity, and a lot of folks say, just love yourself, I did it, so can you and then you look at them and they're thin and conduct conventionally attractive and neurotypical and white and non disabled and rich. And just like, wow, yeah, I wonder why you led to be able to love your body. Yeah. And so like, Is it as simple as choosing to stop hating yourself? Or could that could there be actually something else going on. And if I think sometimes, if you're really struggling with really, really disliking your body, then there could be something else going on. So, body dysmorphia, I am going to go to the DSM five, the DSM is the diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders. And so it's in there. It was in the in the number four and I don't know when it was in there before but it is a obsessive compulsive, the class of it is obsessive compulsive disorder. And so this is from the DSM five A preoccupied preoccupation with one or more perceived defects or flaws in physical appearance that are not observable or appear slight to others. At some point, during the course of the disorder, the individual has performed repetitive behaviors. Example mirror checking, excessive grooming, skin picking, reassurance seeking or mental X example comparing DSM why you're not gender inclusive comparing his or her or they're comparing their appearance with that of others. In response to the Appearance concerns. Their preoccupation causes clinically significant distress or impairment in social, occupational, or other areas of function. Their parents preoccupation is not better explained by concerns with body fat or weight in an individual whose symptoms meet diagnostic criteria for an eating disorder.

So this is not an eating disorder, because of worrying about being fat, or worrying about weight. It's a it's related to an obsessive compulsive type of disorder. So and there's we've also got muscle dysmorphia, and that's the they say the individual is preoccupied with the idea that their body build is too small or insufficiently muscular this specifier is used, even if the individual is preoccupied with other body areas, which is often the case. Also here we've got indicate degree of insight regarding Body Dysmorphic Disorder belief. So some people might have fair insight, poor insight or delusional beliefs in regards to their bodies. And so with good or fair insight, the individual recognizes that the body dysmorphic disorder beliefs are definitely or probably not true, and that they may or may not be true. With poor insight, the individual thinks that the body dysmorphic beliefs are probably true. And with absent insight or delusional beliefs, the individual is completely convinced that their body dysmorphic beliefs are true. So that's a lot of kind of that's from the DSM right. And so his kind of the layman, the layman what it is, and so it's a mental health condition, where someone spends a lot of time worrying about their quote flaws or their perceived flaws. And anyone can have BDD, but it's mostly it's more common in younger people. So teenagers and young adults, affects all genders. And it's not about being vain or self obsessed. It can be something that has a really big impact on your life and can even lead to suicide. So it makes people feel embarrassed and shit ashamed and anxious. And may they may avoid social situations. And so there's a lot of that repeated checking the mirror or grooming or seeking assurance for many hours a day. Yeah, so the symptoms and so how I'm going to list out the symptoms here on include links to everything that I'm quoting from. This is the symptoms here, being extremely preoccupied with a perceived flaw in appearance that others can't see, or appears minor, strong belief that you have a defect in your appearance that makes you ugly or deformed. Believe that others take special notice of your apparent parents in a negative way, or mock you engaging in behaviors aimed at fixing or hiding the perceived flaw that are difficult to resist or control such as frequently checking the mirror grooming or skin picking, attempting to hide perceived flaws with styling makeup or clothes. constantly comparing your appearance to others frequently seeking reassurance about your parents from others, having perfectionist tendencies, seeking cosmetic procedures with little satisfaction, and avoiding social situations. And so with BDD, it seems to be that you focus on maybe one body part more than others. And the most common areas are face nose, complexion, wrinkles, acne or blemishes.

Then it's hair. Its parents thinning and baldness, skin and Vayner parents breast size, muscle size and tone and genitalia. So I am here thinking about this from a I'm I'm thinking about this from like a social justice issue. So this is a mental health condition. Right. And I'm thinking about the the other the other thing, the the definition of atypical anorexia in the DSM and anorexia, and there's a typical anorexia, a typical anorexia is the exact same as anorexia, but there's a weight there's, like anorexia, Anorexia, and a typical or atypical is for fat people. Because we have to have create a whole separate thing, because is the only thing in the in the DSM, which has a weight limit to it, which is hopefully going to change because I mean, it doesn't matter what your weight is, if you have an eating disorder, you have an eating disorder, right. And so with this, talking about the symptoms, and it's, it's all kind of like, perceived flaw, and not noticeable to others. And I wonder about who decides, you know, body image standards, right? Who decides that, that that nose is too big? Who decides that that that skin is not good, that that that someone weighs too much, etc, etc, right? Like, they're these these things are influenced by, by outside forces? And what if, what if the person who has BDD is fat? And they are extremely preoccupied with the floor, quote, floor of their fatness? Would that be encouraged? And I mean, the answer is, for some folks, it has been, I know when I was in it and just disorder world. When I went into the doctor's and had lost a lot of weight. Of course, he was like, Oh, my God, keep doing what you're doing. What am I doing? Not Eating Enough food. Having an eating disorder. So. So with with when we're thinking about weight stuff, when we're thinking about body image standards, this kind of gets a little bit more cloudy, not in regards to, you know, the person feeling this way, but maybe the way that we treat folks who have BDD as if they're conventionally attractive perhaps Perhaps folks would say you're just being so vain. There's nothing wrong with you get over it. And so not being sympathetic or understanding that it's a mental health condition. And with with folks who have quote, be quote here, real flaws. Whether that be being slightly chubby, or having parts of themselves, which is not the white, European standard of beauty, so maybe having a bigger nose or, or darker skin, for example, would that obsession with those areas be more encouraged? If someone was very, very fat, someone was a supersized fat person. And their whole life was about them thinking about their fatness would a a therapist, psychologist, whoever say, oh my goodness, they really preoccupied with this thing, because if the therapist sees that as a real flaw, then would they see that as then a negative behavior? It's just interesting, right? Yeah, so the prognosis, BDD. Body Dysmorphic Disorder usually doesn't get better on its own. If left untreated, it may get worse over time, leading to anxiety, anxiety, extensive medical bills, severe depression, and suicidal thoughts and behavior. With most of everything, we don't really know what causes it knows there's different things that are risk factors like having family history of it and having having a mental health conditions like depression or OCD. Yeah, but no one's really sure. Treatment Treatment for BDD is going to therapy CBT, cognitive behavioral therapy, and sometimes also medication like SSRIs, sometimes people will need to go into inpatient treatment. So with CBT, it's it says it's the only psychological treatment that's been proven and support supported by research, but it can be hit and miss. And it focuses on changing the thought and behavior patterns triggered by the condition. Your therapist will help you identify situations that cause anxiety, and develop healthier coping mechanisms. Through CBT, you can learn to step outside of yourself and view your body through a more objective and forgiving LAN.

So what about the intersection of BDD and anti fat bias? So is BDD informed by anti fat bias? Are they completely separate? So let's hear from some people who have BDD. So I don't have BDD never had BDD. No experience with that, myself. But I, I suspect a lot of people who are struggling with body image stuff, a lot of people might have undiagnosed BDD. And with most mental health conditions, people are like, Okay, so what's the difference between disordered eating and an eating disorder? What's the difference between not liking myself and having BDD or something else? And what therapists say is that it's how much it is affecting you and disrupting your life. So if you were like, I don't like my body. And I, because of that, I think that if I walk into a restaurant, everyone's going to be staring at my nose and thinking it's too big, and they're gonna be laughing about my nose. And in fact, I don't want to go out or do it all day long, I spent thinking about my nose, like, I look at my nose in the mirror all the time, I got plastic surgery, and that still is still I don't think my nose is is right. Um, so I'm gonna get another procedure and I constantly need validation from people telling me that my nose is okay. So see how that is. That is, you know, that's a lot that's kind of like taking over someone's life. Where is it? Where it's like, the difference would be like, Yeah, I don't like my nose and I don't feel comfortable, you know, seeing it in pictures. And if I could fold it, I guess I'd have surgery but you know, it's one of those things. means I don't love it, but I'm going to get on with my life. I'm not going to stop living, but I might be known to be a little bit conscious of it. And so that probably wouldn't be to the extent of having full blown BDD. But that doesn't mean that that's not also you know, not a great feeling and sucks, right? And, and also, therapists you know, a lot of a lot of folks don't like having to, to label people. But in case you're curious about that, and it same with things like I've I don't know, I have an eating disorder or disordered eating, and it's kind of like, how much does it affect your life? What's going on? Yeah, so let's go to Reddit, the body dysmorphia community on Reddit. So that was a discussion that that I enjoyed looking at and so the discussion was the the title of it. Body Dysmorphia is a form of fat phobia. So the person says, So I saw this similar topic in a suburb for eating disorders, which I also follow and I'm wanting to know your thoughts. I saw a popular tweet recently, they said that body dysmorphia was actually fat phobia. So I'm just going to pause here and say what we've got is two separate things. The first statement is body dysmorphia is a form of fat phobia. And then the second line here is body dysmorphia was usually fat phobia. I tried to find the original tweet thing this is from a year ago. I couldn't find it. So I'd love to know what it actually said. So we've got kind of two definitions of what it said, Body Dysmorphia is a form of fat phobia, and body dysmorphia was fat phobia. Okay, so the person can continues this is wrong on so many levels, and it has loads of likes. How I perceive my body is no way affects how I see other's bodies because mainly, it's not just my body is every inch of detail I perceive to be wrong no matter what my weight is. I've never once projected my body issues on to another person only perceive myself as disgusting. Do you agree? So one of the first comments is, I'm not sure if the term fat phobia is used as a term for irrational fear of body fat in oneself or others, or the social stigma or fatness? Regardless, it isn't a diagnosable disorder. This is correct. So fat phobia isn't in the DSM because and so this is interesting, because you know, so that even the word fat phobia, so fat phobia is kind of falling, falling away a little bit.

Some folks in the community and also some folks in the disability rights community say that we shouldn't be using the word phobia, because phobia is actually a mental health condition. And really, what we're talking about is hate from a social justice standpoint in regards to hate of a group. And so some folks will say, Okay, we need to use the word, you know, fat Hey, anti fat bias. Other say it will for some folks, it definitely is. It definitely is to that level where they are obsessed and they really are afraid and anxious and it ruins their lives thinking about being fat and getting too fat. And so I think, you know, using different words for different situations of when I think about the troll on the internet, who says fuck fat people, that person is obviously hates fat people, and they are steeped in anti fat bias. And, you know, anti fat bias can be used for individuals to absolutely but I also because I've seen it right, I've seen it with clients, that palpable kind of so powerful, deep fear of fatness meaning something about them as a person, you know, I chat to people I'm like, what does it mean to be fat? Like, what does it mean about you? And never have I heard that it means Oh, you know, just it just means I have a bigger body. And these are from people who are struggling, right? This is not from you know, people who are Who are recovered from fat phobia? Or anti fat bias? It is. I'm a bad person, I'm a failure. I'm lazy, I don't have my shit together, I am unattractive. I'm unhealthy. I am an, I'm embarrassing, and you know, like, the list goes on. And so but then also is it kind of like when you think of a phobia, like a lot of times we think of people, you know, be, you know, screaming and running a run away and avoiding certain parts of life to avoid that, that phobia. And, and so I don't think folks are not having that reaction of like, you know, being terrified and running away, but in other ways, they are terrified. So I it's, I just find it really interesting to think about. So anyway, continuing. So this person says regardless, it isn't a diagnosable disorder. That is correct. I think it would fall under different things. So BDD, on the other hand, is a recognized mental disorder. With diagnostic criteria and treatment recommendations. There is literature and studies is also a key feature in BDD is its connection to Oh, C, D. And the fact that people seem to have issues with reading faces properly. I don't know what someone would be hoping to achieve by trying to muddy the waters on what BDD is, but know that it's that it's true recognize and diagnosable disorder a no stranger on the internet has the authority or capacity to define it as something that hasn't been accepted and replicated by the scientific community. So I guess what this person is hearing is the person who'd made the original tweets who I you know, I can't find the source, but they were saying, BDD isn't real, that you just need to learn to love fatness, and you would not, you would not have BDD. I don't think that like there. This is there. The first persons the first person to comment, that's what they're reading from that post. I'm reading something different. Because I've got obviously, a different perspective. I didn't read it as BDD isn't real. I read it as BDD is, has a big fat phony fat phobia component, something like that. That fat phobia is a part of BDD is what I've read is from that thing. So I don't know. Someone commented, someone commented commented, they're not seeing BDD as a compulsive thinking disorder that it is, like, I'm sorry, my brain got brainwashed by Instagram models and my boyfriend's porn watching history. And now I have a compulsive tic in my brain that tells me, I should hate myself for not being an Amazonian Goddess from the islands. So so this person is saying that they got brainwashed by Instagram models and their boyfriends, porn watching history. And so that goes back to Okay, so why is the boyfriend watching certain porn with probably very unrealistic depictions of humans, right? And Instagram models? Like, why are I'm presuming that this person doesn't say it, that they're thin Instagram models, right? And so why is it that we are holding thinness up? And so would this be the same if this person happened to have grown up in a fat positive household? I don't know. Like, you know, this is a mental health condition. Right? And that can as we know, from before, we don't really know what causes it, but, uh, you know, if we lived in a fat positive society, would it have would it? Would it have shifted into perhaps, I'm not fat enough, or some other perceived flaw because if we lived in a fat positive society, you bet, you bet. Capitalism is going to create something else for us to hate ourselves. Right? You know, it'd be like your ear lobes are too long to grow. So have you seen your ear and I was looking at these Instagram models and their perfect ear lobes, you know, it'd be something of, you know, something else that we'd be

we'd be focusing on and no doubt a lot of the other comments are like people saying that their body dysmorphia is centered around their face and so it's got nothing to do with fatness. So someone else said, I think I saw the same tweet and it annoyed me a lot. They say the same about eating disorders and how you can quote cure your To disorder by confronting and dealing with your internalized fat phobia was, which is absolute bullshit. It also simplifies BDD to be just about thinking you're bigger than you are forgetting that people have different types of BDD, facial, muscle, muscle, etc. Some people are very insecure about how thin they are, too. It really annoys me when people make someone else's mental illness about themselves. So with this, this that response, I'm, I mean, they say the same things about eating disorders, how you can cure your eating disorder by confronting and dealing with your internalized fat phobia. So with eating disorders, and with any with BDD, disorders that focus on body and food, we they are not created in a bubble, right? They are informed exactly what we're just talking about. Even if we live in a fat positive society, there'll be something else, right, there'll be some other focus, that society says we need this, and some folks will struggle with that because of mental illness. Mental health conditions can be informed by the society we live in. Right? And I'm not saying created or anything, but but we are complex individuals. And, and so understanding like with an eating disorder, that it's not made in a vacuum. Where is this coming from? Why do we think that eating certain foods or not eating certain foods or having a smaller body or etc, etc, etc? is better or worse? And, and also, what else is going on? Right, what else is going on? And so I think personally, that there, they're, they're, they're intertwined, right? I don't think that BDD is like a manifestation of fat phobia. I don't think so. But I think what we are focused on is informed by a society that says, thinness is better that says whiteness is better, that says, being non disabled is better, that says, European beauty stare, ideals is better, etc, etc, etc, right? It can't not be because we've got these beautiful brains that are like hi, I want to fit in. And there's a mental health condition going on to

this one person says I agree that it doesn't have to do with fat phobia, and this is total misunderstanding of the disorder. My own body dysmorphia is triggered intensified by lots of different things, many of them having nothing to do with body fat. If I feel that a certain haircut alters the way that I look in a way that is out of alignment with how I feel about myself, this causes the same level of distress and ways of thinking that have more body fat than I want does. Same with having less body fat than I want or less muscle or more muscle or clothing that doesn't suit me or makeup that doesn't look the way I want it to etc. It's not about one specific aspect of the body like fat, and I don't dislike body fat on other people or even on myself it's way the way I want it to be. I'm attracted to a lot of people who would be probably considered Oh word. If I felt that having more body fat wasn't in line with how I feel about myself then I would want more body dysmorphia to me it has to do with something about the body not being in alignment with this spirit, and obsessive compulsive desire to make it come into alignment and fear that you won't be able to which causes excessive worrying, fixation on and magnification on all things that are quote wrong. I think there's definitely a component of lack of body acceptance and body positivity, and being exposed to fat phobia can exacerbate it. But most people I know with Body Dysmorphia are not fat phobic, and are generally body positive towards everyone but themselves. For me, I often feel like I'm the only one with a fucked up body. I see everyone else skinny, fat, muscular etc as having quote normal body's Body Dysmorphia tells me that mine is not and everyone will notice that is not normal. I know it's I know that it's distorted thinking, but your mind makes it real. Someone else's comment says I know there's an immense amount of shame around this this disorder. But I think it can be a positive thing to really look critically at the way BDD affects not only our perception of ourselves, but others. And I think the truth for most of us is that we do value appearance more highly than others. And we do notice and make judgments based on that. Those judgments are much much more centered on self and others and I can't speak for everyone but I think most people with BDD are noticing flaws in others. However, I think that we are much more forgiving of these flaws in our loved ones than ourselves. I don't know about y'all. But a big part of BDD for me is that I feel inherently unworthy in a way that I don't feel about anyone else. So I hold myself to an appearance standard that is higher than my loved ones, because I believe if I could reach that, I would be worthy. Like them something I think here as well is it, it sounds like a lot of folks with BDD is focusing their focus on themselves, right. And these perceive thought flaws in themselves. And weight bias, as we've discussed in the podcast before, is there's there's the different levels of bias, and it can be in interpersonal, intrapersonal, institutional and ideological right. And so you can have a ton of weight bias, and that could be something that you're just throwing on to yourself. And that's a lie, I see that a lot is, is fat folks saying, I think other fat people are good, and great and wonderful, but not me. And so I can see, then they're, they're further along in their journey of unlearning fatphobia. And then the next step is to, is to understand it and accepting it themselves, themselves as a fat person, and their body and all that type of jazz. And so the step before that is thinking other fat folks unattractive as well as themselves. Right? And so it's so easier to extend grace and compassion or humanity to other people to when it goes to ourselves. Were pieces of shit, right. And so I think that some of these comments are kind of missing that, that, that we can still think of that we can think fat people are great. And also, we can still hold weight bias towards ourselves and still hold internalized privilege. If they have small bodies. No wonder like in the future, if the DSM is going to have some type of thing about fear of fatness? I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. Yeah, so I mean, I wonder like how you're feeling how you're How are you feeling? How are you feeling? Are you kind of seeing that? Oh, yeah,

actually, you know, I thought that I just needed to kind of unlearn fatphobia and I could learn to love myself, but turns out from what you're saying, Vinny that there might be something else going on, alongside or separate from struggling with with anti fat bias? And, or maybe you might be like, You know what, I think I think I should just, you know, see how it goes on learning, fat hate and see if that helps. And that might be valid for you. Yeah, so I think that our society helps inform what an imperfection quote is, and fat phobia is part of our society. Also, here's another thing to think about is that there could be something else at play. So for example, that there was that one comment or saying about the haircut not feeling right. One time a trans person asked me, Do I have gender dysphoria? Or do I have fat phobia? And I was like, I don't know. It's complicated. Do we live in an anti trans society? Do we live in a fat phobic society does not being able to be your true self and look the way that you want? As a trans person also caused dysphoria? Yes, yes, like yes to all of that. But what I do know is that we all hold anti fat bias. Everyone, you know, even me, it might be, you know, layers and layers and layers deep that I've, I've excavated, but there'll be stuff that pops up and I'm like, Oh, hello, anti fat bias. There you are. So we can't ignore unlearning that shit. And if that helps with how you feel about your body, wonderful, that's great. That's perfect. And if that's what you needed, perfect, great, perfect, perfect, great, great, great, but also, it could be that you have something else going on that you would benefit from going to therapy for if that is available for you. And I also think that with the CBD CBT that folks do in therapy and the treatment that people who have EDS go through that there should be a lot of support in normalizing a variety of, of bodies. And we know that in a lot of eating disorder treatment places, there is the, you should put on weight, but not too much. You don't want to get fat. And I think that's deeply unhelpful for people who are afraid of, of being fat and getting fat and being out of control. Right. So I think unlearning systems of oppression is always going to be helpful in many places in our lives. And I think here, particularly so, you know, and as well, you know, like, we're gonna say systems of oppression, too. It's like, you know, you're focused on on, you know, your nose not being the right shape, or your, your, your skin doing this or whatever. And it's like, where does that idea come from? Is it just something that your brain has just picked out of nowhere? Or has it been informed by other things? If it has been informed by other things? Can we help our brains support them in getting new beliefs about big noses being absolutely boss, and fatness being cold and fineness being cool and not having muscles or having having a big belly or whatever it is? That that's just a normal part of having a body and it's all great, you know. And my story was, you know, like I mentioned, I don't have BDD I never did. My, my story was that a lot of my body hate was fat hate, like, I didn't like myself, and it fucked with my life in a big way. But it wasn't to that in as we mentioned, with BDD, that kind of obsessive and the checking and all that type of stuff. And I personally just needed to be educated on weight science and detangle, my fat phobic phobic thoughts, and that was really, really helpful for me. And it made it so that I just was like, Yeah, I've got a body, whatever.

But that's because I didn't have a mental health condition. Related to this, I mean, had other stuff going on, but not particularly, you know, related to my body, and the way that I viewed it. So I mean, it's complicated. And I want folks to be able to get support, if they need it, and if they can, and I know a lot of people probably can't afford to go to therapy. And, and I was looking at this one, one article, it was saying kind of like things outside of therapy, even though they're saying therapy is the most helpful. And the only thing that's evidence based for BDD, there were there was another article on that was on a eating disorder website. Was it centers for change? Yeah, a sense of change. And they were saying things like unlearning, unlearning, what what word did they use? And I was like, oh, that's different. Fat. ism. fattism. I've never I've never heard someone call it fat ism before. And learning fattism and learning diet culture and and I was like, Oh, shit, okay, Centers for change. Because normally eating disorder places and maybe not as recognizing that type of thing. Yeah, let me see what the other things I said. Actually, the other things I say is except genetics, the most most of what you look like is determined by your genes. Understand that emotions are skin deep. So if you're saying, I feel fat, it's not really about fat, even if you are fat. Question messages portrayed in the media? Yeah. Recognize the influence of body misperceptions. In here, they say women are prone to more negative feelings about their bodies and men. In general, women are more psychologically invested in their physical appearance, your body image is central to how you feel about yourself. Because women are objectified to the max. Research reveals as much as a quarter of your self esteem is a result of how positive or negative your body image is. And they say that there's this distortion in the way that a lot of people can view themselves. And they say, befriend your body. So do like body image work. So I mean, you know, I'll link to that in the in the show notes. First party.com forward slash, Oh, 140. So go check that out. And I mean, even if you do have BDD, I think there's no harm and also, I mean, I think when I say no harm, I think it's a good idea to also try and unlearn any fat hate that you've got simmering there. If that's something that you can, you can identify and sometimes it takes time, right to to recognize how we are fat phobic. It can take, you know, doing some of this work first maybe with a therapist and then being like, Ah, shit. Yeah, that's why I think that and it can take time to an earth those those biases that come up. So yeah, what do you reckon? Do you? Do you feel like you kind of recognize any of those those symptoms or signs? Or do you think that? Are you feeling good? Even good about your body? Are you just here for fat politics? Or like, what is what's going on here? Are you, hey, is something that I've been thinking about? For like, six months ish, is I don't know if you've seen a few few people going on holiday, going on holiday with their followers, their community. And a vacation by the way, if you're like, what are what are you talking about? And so this company approached me and called trover trip, like, six months ago, and was like, Oh, do you want to go on vacation with your, with your community? And I was like, Yes, question, Mark. I don't know how I can make it work. I don't, I don't. I have a lot of hesitation. So my hesitations were that I wanted to be fat positive experience, right? I don't want to be you know, because what they do is they will create the holiday, they handle everything they book, the itinerary they pick where you stay, they get the they book, The the van, if you go in somewhere, the bus or whatever it's called. And, like, Is it is it gonna be inclusive, and actually, they're really social, social justice, focus. And so they've got a few places that are 100%, inclusive, they've also got places inclusive for

folks with disabilities. And also they've got places which they call body positive. And and then you can, I mean, I can say, Okay, so we're thinking about going and doing a pottery class or scuba diving or whatever, go and ask your people on the ground? Are there going to be seats that fat people can use? Are their wetsuits that come in this size? Are their life jackets, that what sizes do they come in, etc, etc. And they were like, yeah, that's, that's literally what we do. I was like, Oh, shit, okay, so I've been waiting for my PR car to come back from the Canadian government. It should have been back like, five months ago, I was gonna go surprise my sister in the summer because she had a better human come out of her and I was gonna go and surprise her and, you know, terrify her and rip her stitches and all that type of stuff. But my thing didn't my thing hasn't arrived. And so I'm gonna go for Christmas anyway, blah. bluh bluh bluh is what I'm saying is, I am going to send out a survey to see where people want to go. If you want to go where in the world you would like to vacation? What types of things would you like to do? Do you ever want to go with me? I'm like, no one would want to go with me and some people are like yeah, they would and I'm like, I don't know I don't know. And I think he'd like the the theme could be fat joy. And, you know, us just just being fat and being fucking amazing. And in and not necessarily people who are not necessarily like you have to go out there and wear two Doritos to cover your nipples and you know, flush everyone your fanny. Just say like, Hey, we're fat people and we're just living life even though we might be scared even though you might be anxious about going to the beach even though it's scary to meet new people. We're going to do it anyway. And we're not going to let the way that society views fatness stop us or the way that we're viewing our own fatness stop us. And I think that that would be really amazing. Factually, just when we like fuck it with fat with fuck, society says that fat folks can't be a martyr and just hang out with each other and just have some fun and I also was thinking, I was talking to Lauren feelgood dietician. We work together on stuff. I do coaching in a program. She's great, by the way. And she went to Italy she took her people to Italy, and she said that she did like almost an activity every single day and sometimes some days they had activities in the morning. They were driving on a bus somewhere, and then an activity in the evening were little Like, I was like, I just want to be a bit more chill, more kind of like beach time. You know, maybe like a day at the beach and then the next day, a pottery class or the next day a there's all in the one that I'm looking at is Sunset scuba diving boat tour, how cool would that be? And then, you know, relax at the beach, and then it evening dinner out. And I think you know, make it more more relaxed. And so we can not not having to run around everywhere. And also, wanting to see what folks is mobility is and what people want to do so that we are able to accommodate everyone. So I was on this call with, with other people who were doing it and one of the people because they work with lots of different people. One of the people was a crossfit coach, and she was like explaining her vacation, and I was like, that sounds fucking awful. She's like, we started vacation by waking up at 5am to do some CrossFit. And I was like, Oh, no. And then she said at the end, which I mean, fine, whatever. Look, some people love that. Right? Even, you know, even I'm not saying that people don't know if CrossFit family wouldn't like CrossFit. For everyone there might work what walking, waking up at 5am, whatever, you know, blah, blah, blah, but yeah, and then she says, Oh, by the end, I thought we'd be working out every single day, maybe a couple of times a day. By the end, people were saying that they didn't want to work out anymore. I was like, because then the her activity she says we had some really intense activity to like hiking up mountains and stuff. And I was like, Oh God, like I love a nice hike. I like you know, doing these things.

But I don't want to go on holiday to wake up and do a CrossFit session at like 5am like, No, not for me, it might be for some people, but that's the type of holiday that I don't want. So just FYI, if you are the kind of Let's wake up at 5am to do a mountain hike, Andy did it at a you know, maybe like, you know, a nice walk in the afternoon or something like something like that, you know, sipping margaritas by the pool, whatever. That's the type of thing. That's the type of thing and you know, going on some scuba dive scuba, some snorkeling or whatever is a skier or snorkeling home, they probably have to train us for scuba anyway. So just an FYI. You If even still listening to the episode, I don't know I'm just rambling on about shit. So let me get on and let you go into the world and have a great rest of your day. Wherever you are. I hope you're okay and that you're feeling happy and good. And honey, is that name of the extension? Toshi is the name of the spray the the water hose spray that's connected to my asshole now forever. Yeah, I mean, people can come up to me and they can just, they can just inspect my asshole and be like, Wow, did they have a bad day? You're saying? Look at that last haul. I'm gonna eat my dinner off. That's my life now. So look at you. But sometimes I think about like, if I was to be run over by a car today, and people had to cut my clothes off. I'm always like, I'm like, so good. Like, underneath my clothes today like this underwear. So cute. They're gonna be like, well, or sometimes I might like oh, you know? I don't tend to have not nice underwear. I kind of like having nice underwear. Or you know, like, I was like, oh my my pubes are all over the place today. But you know, it's just like, who they don't no one would no one would even though is maybe they do I don't know. If I have this accident I know if nurses are going to be measuring the length of my pubes who the fuck knows? Because they definitely don't have better things to do than measure register random versus POS. Oh look at there are so on but like Oh, definitely be de owner. Yeah, is it just me that thinks about that? Yeah. Okay. All right. Okay, so well thanks for hanging out with me today. I want to see you in a why y'all alligator say face hottie be. Perfect.

EP139 Transcript

You're listening to the Fierce Fatty Podcast episode 139. Kourtney Kardashian, Britney Spears, thin celebs being anti-fat and pro-diet fun. Let's do it.

Hello and welcome. I'm your host Vinnie worlds. Pronouns they them. And I'm a civil Santa that your hand today to talk about subtle Loughborough Tsar's. I mean, I do like a little bit of celebrity gossip from from now now and again from time to time. And I thought that you might as well and actually this week, there seems to be a couple of instances of celebrities being giant dabblings beg donuts. girthy sausages. That's what these celebrities have been. And we're talking about Kourtney Kardashian and Britney Spears. Today, they have been doing some eye ball rolling stuff I tried. I tried to take a picture. So before the show before I start recording, I take some pictures for the marketing materials for the podcast. And I was like, Okay, I'm gonna do a rolling rolling my eyes picture it's impossible to do your own rolling my eyes, but I don't know everything but it mustn't be impossible, but it's impossible for me to do it for to translate on the screen. It just looks like I'm just looking at something that's above me. Or that I don't know if I'm doing my head in the wrong way. I don't know. But that's not the picture that we're gonna use it we're gonna do something else. Anyway, so I had a few people tagged me in things saying oh, look at this. And the first one is we're going to talk about Kourtney Kardashian. But you know, I was thinking about this this whole goop push which is Courtney Kardashians wellness company, which is kind of like goop and goop is like goop is what Gwyneth Paltrow knows company. And Kourtney Kardashian is in the press because she's promoting lemme, which is a gummy company. And I mean, all of these names. And all of these companies really are based on fat, disgust, fear of fat, health ism, orthorexia promotion. Woowoo anti science bullshit. I just did a quick Google before we just started here. I was like, wonder if Gwyneth Paltrow has ever done anything fat phobic, and I just just googled Gwyneth Paltrow, fat phobia. And, of course she has recently, if you watch RuPaul drag race, you might have not noticed Ross Matthews, which is one of the people on the panels was kind of a chubby guy. I wouldn't say he was like, I don't know. I guess he would probably say that he was fat. But you know, you weren't, he wasn't. Anyway. He's kind of like a small, a smaller fat guy. That's what I'm trying to say. He's a smaller fat guy. And Gwyneth Paltrow recently shamed him. But he doesn't tell the story like that. She She intervened on his disgusting body, pointed at his belly and said, What's going on here? I love you get it together. And so then he was like, Well, that was it. That was that was my final motivation. So he's finally been shamed by Gwyneth Paltrow. And he is now the spokesperson for Jenny Craig, or as North Americans call it, Craig. And he's temporarily lost some weight.

And he says the weight was such a shameful issue for me. I'm so happy to be rid of it. And it makes me so sad for Ross Matthews because he is probably going to be a higher way in the following years, right as we know. So we're all average. I see a celebrity or anyone being like, Oh, I'm so happy to be free of this thing that was so shameful for me like Ross. Matthew says, I'm just like, My heart aches for them because I know that they're gonna probably look back on this time and be like, Oh, look at me. I was so proud. And now look at me now I'm so I'm such a failure, I put weight back on and it doesn't need to be like that. Because when you didn't have to lose weight in the first place, and to gaining weight is not your fault, because we know diets don't work. Anyway, so all of this, you know, the wellness, the whole wellness thing is just red flag, red flag after red flag. And anyone talking about wellness? I'm really like, What do you mean by wellness? Do you mean? Well, like we spoke about on the podcast a couple of podcasts ago, putting herbs, herbs up your edge? Yeah, herbs. evag. Don't be fat. Don't eat anything. And then you'll be cool. Yeah, so Kourtney Kardashian, which is the oldest sister of the Kardashian family. I've never watched a Kardashian show or anything. So I'm only familiar with them in regards to just seeing media about them. And so I don't I've never watched any episodes of but I bet you people who were who are avid fans have probably got lots of instances to share where the family have been fat phobic. But Kourtney Kardashian has really stepped up the nonsense and has been restricting her kids food intake. And it's horrifying. So there's a Wall Street Journal article, and it's behind a paywall. I've got a link in the show notes so you can read it behind the paywall.

If you don't want to subscribe to Wall Street Street Journal, so here's a little tip for you if you ever want to read something that's behind a paywall, often if it's a you know, somewhere for like the Wall Street Journal or something like that, you can Google the title and a lot of times, totally separate websites will just copy and paste the article into the onto their website to see if they can get clicks from that and you can read it there for free. Not always also another method is the Wayback Machine. the Wayback Machine is a website that makes you be able to see what a website was doing on a certain day and what what a webpage was doing. And so if someone edited something, you can go back and look at the Wayback Machine and see what was there before it was edited. And this, it doesn't always work. It didn't work for this or had to get it somewhere else. Anyway, I've done that work for you go to the show notes facebook.com forward slash 139. And it will it links to that article. But let's go to this first article, which is Kourtney Kardashian has been accused of projecting an quote obsessive and quote unhealthy relationship with food onto her kids ever after revealing what she restricts them from having in a controversial interview. And so this is a this is a roundup from BuzzFeed on the interview in Wall Street Journal and it's so let's do some quotes from it. If there's one thing that sets Kourtney Kardashian Barker, apart from her famous sisters, it's her preoccupation with health, wellness and nutrition. So she married blink 182 drummer Travis Barker and so that's where the Barker comes from. While all the car Jenner's are suddenly dedicated to healthy eating, the others haven't gone quite as far as the elders of the group in their quest for an organic lifestyle. Courtney is meat free and follows a mostly vegan diet and she has tried everything from keto to intermittent fasting over the years. She has also been public about her decision to cut out gluten and dairy and sugar from her and her children's lives. I went and read the article as well. I'm going to share bits from that about her decision to begin fostering eating disorders disordered eating with our guests. The star is mum to 12 year old Mason 10 year old Penelope and seven year old rain, all of whom she shares with her ex Scott Dezik Disick die sick Disick back Back in 2019 Courtney's aversion to sugar became a central storyline in her family's reality show after she and her sister Kim Kardashian wanted to throw a joint birthday party for their daughters. Kim's oldest child north and her cousin Penelope wanted a Candyland themed party and Kim was left stunned when Courtney didn't want there to be any, quote, junk food at the event, and I've got a picture of his kids and they're all dressed up in like beautiful rainbow colors and Penelope which is Courtney's child is dressed with like lollipops on her dress and candies in wrappers. And nos has got like jelly bean prints. And it's just sucks. So fun. I mean, imagine if you had that party as a kid. But way Courtney didn't want them to have that party even though their own party. Kim said at the time, Courtney has this vision of no sugar or no disgusting chemicals in candy. It's like a completely sugar free gluten free party free fun free. So because Courtney has decided that it just doesn't make sense. And it really wasn't the theme of what North and Penelope wanted for their birthday. Yeah, I mean, hello, Thanks for ruining the party. But Courtney did not back down and argued I can't believe that Kim isn't willing to compromise at all, and that she doesn't feel guilty about giving not only her kids and my kids, but all of these kids that are coming out to party so much junk, and candy. It's such a dated fight vibe to be like that. And when I when I read heard that, like it's such a dated vibe to be like that. I thought that was really interesting. Because a lot of people are like, Oh, well, we're so we're so good with nutritional science. Now. Now we know like, that.

We're eating these things that are terrible for us. And when we're when, you know, previously, we just didn't know. And she says, I'm going to read it out and a little bit. She says, you know, my, my my parents felt as terrible food. And I think that's a theme of a lot of these wellness communities is that now we have the science we can do better and feed our kids air and dust so that they are their healthiest selves. But the reality is this rhetoric goes back hundreds of years. And these ideas about sugar and chemicals and palatable foods being bad is really really well established in our culture. And it's not anything new. Like the dated vibe is not allowing your kids to have a fucking birthday party with candy. Can you imagine that? Imagine if you were invited to a birthday party now. And the theme was Candyland and you're like folk you're probably going to be some coke candy then I'm gonna just you know eat some nice candy and you turn up and Kourtney Kardashian is running it and and she's all about she finds candy that is not candy and has nothing in it. She talks about these candies that she finds which is like you know not candy. You know, unhealthy versions of candy be so devastating, right and imagine if you were a kid and you've got your friends from the neighborhood covered around you like a fucking candy by a blimp and that they turn up and it's like, oh, here's some frozen grapes. Grapes like candy of the fruit wild. The kids are gonna be like, What the fuck? Give us some give us a good stuff. We're not here for your frozen grapes. Thank you. Yeah, okay, so continuing. She ended at a time there's just better solutions to things instead of your dated candy that's literally food coloring that gives people diseases. Food coloring does not give people diseases. In the in the wellness communities, we've seen people say that it gives you cancer, that it causes blood clots that it causes ad haich D

I don't just an FYI. It doesn't we don't have any evidence to support that stuff. If you're really interested in unlearning that type of stuff around like chemical halls and food coloring and preferences for, quote, natural food coloring and all that type of stuff go to food science babe on Instagram or Tiktok. And she is a food scientist, and she debunks all of this stuff. And it's all just fear mongering. So just people not understanding food and being frightened by things like GMO, or you know, preferences for organic and thinking that sugar is basically what we heard in another episode, basically, a very harmful drug. And it's not. So continuing. And this has been a common theme ever since in one viral moment from keeping up, Courtney sniffs a doughnut that she refuses to eat and says, I can't eat this, but how exciting it is to smell it. Like that Rudy hops back to all of those days of joy that I missed out on when I was in my dieting stuff, where it was like this huge temptation of this thing, but I was so like, disgusted at the thing that I was having a temptation around, which is when I say temptation, it's like a natural thing. Of course, I was denying myself it just ruins it just ruins so many different things. Like she could have just had that donor and just been like, oh, yeah, that's nice. Whatever. No big deal, you know. Continuing the mindset has also carried over to the family's new reality show The Kardashians. When Season One launched earlier this year, a major storyline followed Courtney and her husband Travis on an extreme fast the IRA or your verdict cleanse saw the couple abstain from sex, caffeine, alcohol, and sugar.

Yeah, no, we don't. By the way, we don't need to do cleanses. We have a liver and kidneys are beautiful bodies. Detox for us, right? We don't need to do these cleanses. I mean, what why why why? Why did? Why? Sex, caffeine, alcohol and sugar. What? Okay, well, what's the point of being alive you know, can I make as a result, Kardashian fans are understandably well aware of Courtney's extreme dietary choices, but a new interview has sparked backlash after her comments left readers concerned that she is projecting an unhealthy relationship with food on to her three children. I mean, shit. Why hasn't this come up already? Of course she is. Even before this interview came out where she's, you know, she talks about what what she says. If you're doing those things, your kids are seeing it right. It's like, oh, you know, why are you You know, why are you drinking that? Why you're not eating that? Why you? Why are you exercising every single day? Or why are you You know, all of this type of stuff. You kids are gonna say yeah, there's no way that her kids have never been exposed to this shit already. Yeah, so So in this Wall Street Journal article. She's She's selling her new vitamins. And so she says that she shared her pride her oldest son saying that people who let him eat junk food are bad. So it starts off as she's saying I'm really proud of my my son because he he kind of confessed to me that he was being tempted with these smoothies devil foods. So it quote from Wall Street Journal article when I had my son is when I really started my wellness journey. He's very smart. He'll tell me a person was bad because they let me have and then she says something that is food which is a normal food that people eat. How bad they're so terrible. So concerning let me let me pull from the Wall Street Journal article in recent years. She says that she's taken up to 30 supplements a day. And she says, quote, I know who Oh, I mean, we don't often. We don't need to take supplements like people like the supplement industry is just like fuck yeah, we're just gonna get people to take the supplements that like don't need and supplements at a way higher rate that we need. And some sometimes you do like I take vitamin D, because my doctor said I was low in the past I've taken iron because my doctor said I was low. If my doctor said, Hey, take her around whatever vitamin or supplement or whatever, I'd go do it. Or if someone's just like, you know, I just take one of those, you know, one day multivitamin thing. You know, whatever is it's probably not going to hurt you. I don't know, maybe it maybe.

Anyway, it's not gonna hurt. Yeah. But I mean, 30 supplements a day that's really beginning to show something that's quite excessive. And the more I read this and more that I look into his I'm like, okay, so it sounds like there's probably orthorexia going on there. And orthorexia being, I think, is like one of the newest eating disorders, it's been added to it even in the DSM. Let me see. Let me see. DSM five orthorexia. Okay, it's not there we go. It's not included in the DSM five. It is still recognized by many mental health professionals, and eating disorder experts. Basically, it's an obsession with being healthy eating healthy. orthorexia is an eating disorder characterized by having an unsafe obsession with healthy food and obsession with healthy dieting and consuming only pure foods. Or clean eating becomes deeply rooted in the individual's way of thinking to the point that it interferes with their daily life. So yeah. And we've already seen that there's some things here that's showing that it interferes with her daily life. Okay, so continuing when she was developing her own brand, she made it a priority to use non GMO. There is nothing wrong with genetically modified food there is nothing wrong with GMOs, okay. There's no evidence to show that they're harmful. There's no evidence to show that non GMO foods are better. Yeah, vegan as a continuing so she made it a priority to use non GMO, vegan, gluten free gelatin free ingredients that don't include corn syrup, artificial colors, flavors, or sweeteners. And she had the formulas, muscle tested, muscle tested, you say? I've not heard of that No. and alternative medicine practice, okay, or red flags that aims to locate weaknesses in the body and to diagnose food allergies and other deficiencies on herself. muscle testing is a controversial is controversial in the medical community, which cites a lack of evidence of its efficacy. bloodwork is generally the best way to assess nutrients assess nutrient status, says Katie Kasane, a Colorado based registered dietitian and nutritionist. So what they do this muscle testing they put the food item in your hand and this person will be like, No, this one isn't the This one's not working for you because it's got an artificial ingredient into it. And then Kourtney Kardashian says, oh my goodness, no one no one in my family can can eat this thing anymore because I held it in my hand and someone who is making lots of money from me is telling me that I it doesn't work. It's there's no good on my muscles. It's just Oh my goodness, it's so silly.

Okay, so lemme is Courtney second brand in the lifestyle category. In 2019. She launched a website called push that publishes advice on fitness and nutrition as well as product recommendations. I do not want to be getting any product recommendations or nutrition fitness advice from push or goop or any type of wellness place that I know is anti fat and pro diet. Yes, so the interviewer asked her was wellness part of your life when you're growing up? She says it was the 80s we had really unhealthy food in our house in our house. And then she lives just list out these unhealthy, quote unhealthy foods. And I'm like, um, that just, that is just food, you know, that's just food that the kids and families eat. You know, she's just really she's positioning these very normal things as unhealthy, like, oh my god, basically, it was the A's and we were wild in the A's, we just ate anything, you know. The interviewer asks, What's the most extreme thing you've done on your wellness journey, and she said, It's the, that cleanse that we mentioned again, which is what she said she's going to do again. And also, we mentioned that no caffeine, no sex, all that type of stuff. And also you've got to eat, really clean this really clean, strict diet and do it for five days. And so you know, all of this clean eating is so manifestation of white supremacy culture, really, the Clean Eating foods are just really white, or foods that have been co opted and stolen from other cultures, whitewashed and then served up these these mystical foods that will cure all illnesses, stripping them away from the ways that they've been used within cultures where they're from. And there's nothing cleaner or dirty or about any food. And you know, like the, the, I don't know, if you you've you've seen the Dirty Dozen, there's this this thing, which is people coming up with 12 fruits and vegetables that are called the Dirty Dozen, the worst that we we have to have as organic because the pesticides are so awful, that you shouldn't eat them. It's all made up. It's all bullshit, by the way organic food uses pesticides. Like anyway, want to know more about that go to food science, babe. She'll talk to you about that. Okay, so the interviewer will ask also anyone who influenced you? And she says, Yes, when I had my kids, I started taking it more seriously that I find that interesting because I'm often having children being pregnant.

Being postpartum is a big trigger for body image issues. Right? And so we see that a lot of post pregnancy really wanting to be the person that they were before. And so Nicole, Richie steps in your car. I happened to mention her last week on the podcast, sidekick to Paris Hilton, Paris Hilton, who famously wore the t shirt that says said stop being poor. And ironically, I mean, it's kind of funny if you were poor or something and you're wearing it like ironically or something I still it's fucked up. But a Paris Hilton, who is rich from being born into a into a rich family. Anyway, Nicole Richie parasitism sidekick really helped. She was one of my only friends who had kids before I did. She was like, you have to buy this bug, super baby third, and it was all about making your own baby food. It taught me about organic products. And honestly, it changed my life on how I started eating and eating. And then it was a snowball effect. You can't unlearn inflammation, right. By the time I was pregnant with Penelope, I was fully in it and doing different kinds of cleanses. I did a blah, blah, blah cleanse and all these different things I was getting into really changed my life. Something that i i I see often and you'll probably see this a lot is when people are talking about how they have an eating disorder or they engage in disordered eating, but they just want to pass it off as a normal lifestyle choice. A normal like I am just trying to be healthy. They will sprinkle in times when they have been, quote, bad to illustrate that. It's all about balance. And that line. It's all about everything in moderation. It's all about balance. Sometimes, you know, I look at pictures of sugar, so you know, sometimes I'm really bad. Yeah, so she says it's definitely about moderation and being kind to yourself. If I'm going to Cabo I'm definitely drinking margaritas and having chips and chips and guac guacamole is all about the back Allen's as, I'm Mike Ranney. Really, what are the chances those margaritas are zero sugar. So again, no carb, no gluten, no GMO, no lalalalalala, etc, etc. Same with the chips and guacamole. How many chips? Is she in? Probably like, you know, I don't know. Not a lot and she's probably doing that only in Cabo. Like, why is it that we need to say, the only time I'm allowed to have a margarita and have chips and guacamole, which is just a normal part of a diet? Is when I'm on vacation? I'm so balanced. So balanced. Yeah, no, no. Yes, so, so the most egregious thing is the most egregious thing is what she is doing with her children. Okay. So this is like the last questions is the interviewer, so thinking of a childhood of these foods that she says are unhealthy? Do you think your kids are deprived of something by not letting them have it? The answer is, yes. Absolutely. My kids are deprived when I tell them that they are not allowed to eat foods ever. She responds that was my response. She responds today. I was having my one on one time with my son, Mason, and he said, Mum, I need McDonald's french fries. Today, please. That I'm putting I'm putting. I don't know if he said it like that. Ma'am. I need please, mum. I need McDonald's french fries today. poorly.

It's been a year since I've had it. He says her response was was I was like, today's not the day. Sorry. The kid hasn't had French fries in a year. He says please, I need french fries today. Today's not the day sorry. And she wasn't doing it in an intuitive eating type of way. Because you know, if you are if you are teaching your kids intuitive eating, you control what and when and where. And, and so you might be saying today's not the day and saying french fries. Sounds delicious. I've already made dinner for tonight. But how about on Tuesday, we stopped by McDonald's. And we did it. You know? And be like, Oh, what's your favorite thing at McDonald's? She wasn't saying it like that. She was saying, you've gone a year without french french fries, motherfucker. You ain't you ain't gonna break that today. Because she sees McDonald's chips as something bad. What is that going to do to that poor sweet boy? What did that type of stuff do to you? Because I know a lot of people listened to the show a lot of people who struggle with with this love their stuff had parents who did some type of version of this. Now this is extreme. She's not letting her kids eat. Sugar, gluten, dairy, french fries, candy, the list goes on. What is that going to do? And we know that there's so many different things that could happen from that. He's been taught disordered eating. He's been primed to develop an eating disorder if he already hasn't. He's learning what's good and bad. He's told his mum, he's confessing to his mom. Who is deciding what is good and bad. Someone tried to give me something bad today mummy. And then the next you know, the next thing she talks about him he's asking for some fries, not today. And if he's, you know, if he is asking for some fries, I want to know, you know, how much shame is he currently feeling around food? If he knows that this food is bad? And he's saying to his mum, oh, I'm telling you what happened because I want to be, you know, I want you to love me and be proud of me. And then he's then confessing that he needs some fries. How much did it take for him to get there? How much shame is he already feeling by asking that question when he knows his mom is gonna say no. And she says know, what is that they're going to do? What happens when he's with other people with other families? Does he then be able to access fries? Or is his mum monitoring him? And she says as well that they don't eat out very often, because she wants to control what the family's diet is. And so what she says about the other article about how she stopped her kids from eating gluten and dairy, and so she says, it wasn't a necessity, the way it is for many people. So she's she's saying it's not because we had some type of allergy or something. And she says, I kept battling with myself back and forth. Like, why am I doing this diet, I've always felt fine before when eating dairy and gluten, but I do believe that we only have one life to live and I would like to live it feeling my best. And so she says, I've always felt fine eating dairy and gluten. And so it's, it sounds like, you know, maybe like an ED voice or, or the rational side of her brain is like, why would we need to do that? Everyone's fine having dairy and gluten. But then that, that shaming that, that diet culture, that fat phobia that that pressure took over? And she says no, that fear, what she, what she's feeling of what could happen to her kids, if, if they eat dairy and gluten. And she says, I've noticed a great positive change in behavior with my children when we stick to a gluten free and dairy free diet. Yeah. And you know what I think a lot of people do see, when they when they are changing diets, because they believe that one thing is better than other, the other versus like, say if you the doctor said, Oh, it sounds like your kids are allergic to milk and you believe Okay, well, let's see how it goes. Versus Oh, I think milk is, you know, the juice of the devil. Then if they stopped drinking milk, and you're like, Oh, my God, it's a miracle. You know, little Timmy is no longer speaking in tongues, and now he's a normal boy. You know? So, it's often that people see that, you know, same with with sugar. Studies have shown that parents who think that, that sugar, they who observe that should that sugar God, the children, the children on sugar, we'll just call them triggers. When their triggers, the children have had sugar.

They observe them being more hyperactive, but they aren't actually more hyperactive. Or they say they've been told that they've been given sugar. And though parents were like, Yeah, I know, they've been given sugar. Look at them, they've gone wild. And they hadn't been given sugar at all. So it's, I think a lot of it to do with our perception. And as well, the way that we talk about sugar like you're getting this thing that's so fucking special, and it's gonna make you mad and, and it's gonna, you're going to just be off the walls, if you have sugar. And then the kid is going to be like, I'm having this thing. That's just and then do we think that they're going to be you know, bouncing off the walls? Probably if they're getting this secret drug, you know? Yeah, so she says it's been an adjustment for her kids. But some meals are easier than others. She talks about what they eat and what she eats. It's nothing was not not and it's not nothing, they eat food, but it's clearly disordered. And she says we will eat this especially if I'm trying to get bikini ready. When is she not trying to get bikini ready Yeah, and again, she ends it with of course, we pick our battles, and I do let the kids have popcorn at the movies and at Sureau Disneyland there's that thing like his moderation. And what does that look like of you know, oh, you can have one kids popcorn thing between all of you but but no, no, no butter on it. And and make sure that this and you're in but you're not allowed anything else and and a cero at Disneyland like surely Disneyland is meant to be like a place where you have loads of fun and joy like are they having an eight hour Disneyland? Are they having food? They're probably not they've been allowed to cero you know, maybe that was one time and, you know, in 2001 they're allowed to Chiro and 2001 was like, well More than 20 years ago, so it didn't make sense. But time and time is weird, right? You're like, well, you know, 2002 2020, you know, which was, you know, 22,000, which was 10 years ago, but it's not, it's 22 years ago. Anyway, so that's fun. That's Kourtney Kardashian. What do we think is gonna happen with the kids? I think okay, so if we think about everyone, you know, that's been raised by a parent like this, and I think this is kind of extreme. I don't, I mean, and you've got the other complication of them being in the public eye. And the oldest kid there he was born on telly, right? I know this because of the research I've been doing. I care much about like Kardashians now. And that is hard. Can you imagine? Can you imagine if you grew up on telly to like the most famous family in the world? Ah, that would be mortar fire Yang. If I had to look back at me. You know, oh, you'd be like, Oh, God. Anyway, so this complicated? And so what do I reckon that's going to happen to the kids? disordered eating? Well, they've been taught disordered eating, can it go into a full blown eating disorder or multiple eating disorders? Sure. They're going to be living in a ton of shame and guilt.

They could really deeply believe this stuff, internalize this stuff, and continue on the legacy. They could have kids and do the same. They could discover anti diet and fat positivity and be like, Mum, you really fucked up and in 20 years time courtly being like Courtney's kids, being on Oprah Winfrey bring saying, you know, my mum fucked me up because of the way that she made me. Maybe it doesn't affect them. Maybe they have other influences in their lives where they're able to, you know, like Kim Kim standing up saying that that's weird. Let the kids have a fucking birthday party. Maybe they have influences that are like this is here come around aunties and have some food. But then maybe. Maybe it was Kim that gave the son quote, bad food and he was dubbing on Kim. Mm hmm. Yeah. Cuz she says she says as well in any articles, she's anti social. She doesn't see a lot of people. People should just see his family. So it's probably one of the family members who tried to give them food. That would be me, wandering me. I'm like, come round my house. She would go to McDonald's. And let's go to the movies and let's do this and, you know, then they're probably like pebbling Vinnie gave me McDonald's and then I'll be banned from seeing the kids. Yeah, fun. So, all right.

So Britney Spears, Britney Spears has done something. She made a post. This is what it says. This is on Instagram. I found this so she's it's a quote, quote image. I found there was only one way to look thin. Hang out with fat people. Have Britney, I like Britney. I've always kind of I've always just thought, you know, she says, you know, cheesy, cheesy, cheesy queen, you know? She seems kind of funny. And she's got some good tunes, you know? And she's gone through this terrible experience. She's obviously got a lot of mental health struggles. So I have a soft spot in my heart for Britney. And the caption that goes with it. I wish I could have chosen the nannies for my children, my dancers. I mean, if I had Christina Aguilera as dancers, I would have looked extremely small. I mean, why not talk about it? Don't you think my confidence would have been a bit better if I could choose where I lived eight, whom I was on the phone dated and who was on stage with me. It's hard sometimes. Now I see how much of my womanhood was stripped away at that time and every person sat back and didn't say a thing. Anyways, I will be here talking about things people never talk about. I wrote I wrote I wrote in the comments. I was tagged in this post. In the comments everyone is one person who's doing claps Gretchen Rossi, whoever that is, um, but then the rest of them. Damn Whoa, Queen. No. Yeah, no. Whoop. This is far from cool Britt. Someone says Christine is backup dancers sing this like and that's got the eyes emoji emoji. Someone's I'm pleased delete this. Someone else says love when my skinnier friends only hang out with me to feel skinny. So fun. Super cool. Yes, that is so true, right? That when you're fat, and you have thin friends, you know, they are using you, you know, when we're younger, hopefully you don't have these friends now. I don't have these friends now. But when you're younger, when you've got shitty friends, you know, they are using you and looking at your body being like they make me look good. I'm not as fat as them. At least I'm not as ugly as them. I used to always be hanging out with I always would always have like a thin sidekick. And that thin sidekick would always get the boys. And I'd be like the funny one who would, you know, be like, Oh, my friend fancies you knowing there was no chance in hell any of the boys will talk to you would be interested in me because I have the thin friend next to me. And that really boosted their confidence, my thin friends, right? I recognize this and I was like, Well, fuck if I can't get them by that stuff.

I'm just gonna have to start sucking some decks, you know. And I'm just gonna have to have to start being super sloppy. Because my friend Jenny Rogowski, she didn't want to kiss boys. She wasn't interested. She just wanted to be boyfriends. And I was like, well, I'll fucking kiss. Yeah. And so be with me. And so I would, I would be who's so sad so sad. But anyway, blobby Bloop, bloop. Is we know, fat people know that thin people are looking at us saying, well, thank Fuck, I don't look like her. Thank fuck, I don't like them. At least I'm not as fat as him. So that was two days ago. And then Brittany made another post talking about why she spoke about it. And it's kind of like, I think she views it as a, an apology post, but it's not really. So she talks about the post, by no means Was I being critical of Christina's beautiful body. It is what it is. Well, I don't think she was being critical of Christina's body. She was talking shit about her dancers. She's saying that her dancers were, if I hadn't had Christina's backup dancers, then I wouldn't look very, I would have looked very, very thin, is what she said. Right, saying that her Christina's dancers were fat, and made Christina look thin. Ah, maybe when she wasn't thin. So maybe she was kind of in a way? Well, I mean, she's saying that she wasn't but you know, Christina unfollowed. Britney. So Christina, obviously, it was like, I don't think so. Brittany says, I flew to see her show once. And the main thing I noticed was a difference of people on stage by no means that I even mentioned Christina, look at my post. I was inspired by her show. And she's a beautiful woman of power. Thank you, Christina, for inspiring me to be honest.

I'm not trying to be critical of anybody. What I posted is a projection of the insecurities I deal with all the time as a result of how many of how my parents and the media have treated me. I would never intentionally body shame anybody because I know what it feels like. I struggle with this because of how I feel about myself, not because of how I hate how anybody looks. I feel like my family knew I was insecure. And people were trying to purposefully feed into this insecurity by not not letting me have a choice in the people who were on stage with me. I appreciate you all for being understanding with me as I figure out this new life I'm living yeah, so I don't think like I don't think Britney is intentionally being like, hung on to fuck with the face day. But also Britney is one struggling with mental health, too is had a hard time of it. And also the same as a lot of people living in a society that hates fatness is pro diet. And she's a public figure. Right. But also that doesn't mean that it's okay for her to be fat shaming. I mean, actually, there's no there's no there's no if ands or buts of this she she was saying, if I want to look thin, I need to hang out the phase because they met me better because they are less attractive. Right? Well then she wasn't saying they're less attractive. They are just they're fat. better, right? Like, I don't think it's okay. But I think this is, this is, I think just the undercurrent of a lot of celebrity culture, a lot of the I'm selling shit your tea pills and then getting performance reading which means that they need to lose weight and you know, like, like Beyonce, love Beyonce. And I was so disappointed in what I saw, I watched a documentary on Coachella. And she was saying about everything that she did for Coachella. And it was basically like, eat no food and work out loads and I was like, No, Brittany, you need to be able to you need to eat food, you will you were doing this athletic performance, which is hours long. You need to you need food you need for your food anyway. And I think that that is just so normal. And also it's not okay, and I think celebrities have somewhat of a duty to try and unlearn this stuff. And I think most of them, a lot of them, not a lot not all of them but a lot of them keep that stuff to themselves of up the ante fatness, but a lot are working on it like like, you know, in the same breath. Beyonce was saying that about her Coachella performance, but then she also had fat dancers.

When I was watching, because I watched the performance first and then watch the documentary I watched him perform was when I was like, there was like, I think about three or four fat black dancers. Now that was small fat, but still there was that representation there. And it was like an amazing for them and Brittany's talking about having to be having to lose weight by not eating anything before her her shows. And she was she didn't say I'm not eating anything. She was like, I'm eating like, you know exactly what Kourtney Kardashian was saying like, you know, chemical free, which is I'm just like, ah, if you really want to be chemical free, you're gonna have to stop breathing because oxygen. Oxygen is a chemical. Everything is a camera. Oh, lordy, lordy, lordy. Yeah, so that's fun. Um, I tell you who celebrity is gray. Matt McGorry Matt McGorry. John Bennett in Orange is the New Black Asha in How to Get Away with Murder. And most recently, he was in archive at one. And he recently shared my what he followed me a couple of years back and I was just like Karima pence. And then he has shared my stuff a few times. And yeah, he's fat positive. He is He, he's just he's just, he's, he's great. I want I'm gonna love him. And he has gone through his own journey of being a personal trainer, being a bodybuilder, being a Hollywood actor, where he talks about he wrote a medium Medium post where he talks about the length of his disordered eating to get ready for being shirtless in Orange is the New Black. And basically doing the same things that a bodybuilder would do not drinking water to become dehydrated. So his muscles popped more and things like that. And then he stopped doing that stuff. And now he is I think it would describe himself either himself as fat now. And his Medium post is like, you might have noticed that I've put on weight and it's it's really changed my health. And then I was like, oh, no, and he says, my health is much better now. And I'm like, Yeah, this mat and it goes on is great. So if you want to know, you know, get more male body positivity, fat positive, do all that type of stuff. And he's he's, he's radical, right? He's not the soft and fluffy stuff. He's, you know, abolitionist and all that type of stuff. So yeah, there's there's a Hollywood celebrity that is still in it. Right? And if we think about what's his name, Brendan Fraser, and his comeback and it's just so exciting that and it's so heartwarming to see he's back in action. And he's he's Brendan Fraser, star of the mummy. You know, he was a Hollywood hunk. Now 20 years ago. He is a fatter person. And and people already got behind him. And I think that we're we're hungry to see that type of stuff. But unfortunately, he is starring in this movie that I mentioned last week, the whale and and that's not okay. It's fucked up. It's fucked up. I mean, I've read some bits about so the whale start is added as a play. I've read I've read snippets about, like, what was in the play? It's it's not okay. The movies not out yet. But yeah. You know, it's kind of like one step forward and 10 steps back with. We have all aware we're being we're being we're including a fat celebrity, you know, which was so inclusive and kind of, but we're casting him at him in a role where we dehumanize him, and more importantly, he's wearing a fat suit because he plays someone who is 600 pounds a super fat person. We are dehumanizing super fat people. And I want to read a little excerpt from so comfy fat.

Wrote comfy fat on the Instagrams, J A pillow. They are trans non binary use they them pronouns. I'm just going to read this a bit from this piece that they wrote on their website. I'll link to it in the show notes so you can read the whole thing. So Jay writes a stockpile of points against the fat phobic film the well. I'm just gonna read some snippets here about the film. It is in a wildly unwelcome yet unsurprising turn of events. Another one of those fat phobic inspiration porn films is headed our way. If I think of this as me talking now, if I think about you know those inspiration porn films about fat people, I have loved them in the past example of one What's Eating Gilbert Grape? Or who's in Gilbert Gilbert great, whatever is Gilbert Grape, and the story is about the mama's so fat that the house is collapsing underneath her. I loved that film. And the reason I loved that film because I was a raging fat phobe, and I was like a lace I'm not as fat as anyway. The whale starring Brendan Fraser is about a, quote 600 pound recluse who hides away in his apartment eating himself to death. And, quote, the film has been adapted by Darren Aronofsky from a play written over a decade a decade ago that follows a depressed superfat gay man who was estranged from his daughter. The synopsis alludes to a transformational ending, you guessed it, life changing weight loss, the play states that the main character has one last chance at redemption, because him just being alive means he doesn't have redemption. Articles both of the film ends with a trans and transcendent epiphany, and a feeling of hope. This movie will create emotional discussions within within the fat community, inevitably triggering some of us but will also undoubtedly perpetuate the dehumanization of fat and especially super fat people. I'm writing this piece in preparation for the film debut because we as fat people cannot just avoid watching the movie and dodge the film, dodge the harm it will cause there'll be images and video disseminated through the internet with the intention of discussing disgusting the viewer. Scenes of fat bodies doing simple things like eating or moving will provide plenty of shock and gawk content, as I call it, we will be the subject to these triggering images and the insults that will soon be hauled our way in defense of this entertainment. Should we challenge it? Almost every fat person has a story about the time they were called Shamu. So shampoo, I think that's an that's an American thing reference, right? It's an American whale. I was called Mrs blobby. So that's a British reference of what I was called. Continuing fat bodies aren't here to be respectable fat bodies aren't here to be gawked at, we do not exist solely to inspire others of of what not to be. We don't exist to show you that our bodies can be overcome fat people are all each individual complex and dynamic human beings. And so then j goes on to this this great less talking about the reminders and challenges in critiquing the narratives in this movie. So go to the post to read all of them and so, you know, things like nothing is as simple as eating themselves to death. It is not a lack of discipline that would lead to someone to use food as a coping mechanism. To the point they make themselves sick. Their associate to economic, societal, systemic and chemical reasons this could happen eating disorders are real and yes, fat people can have them. Also have them and yes, fat people can have other forms of eating disorder that involve restriction and starvation. Yeah, so basically this film is about someone who has an eating disorder and mental health, mental health and mental health issues and, and it's kind of like, hey, look, look at this loser. It's so fucking ablest as well as fat phobic. So go check that out there just just ending with the the ending paragraph here.

Does the thin majority thing that the root of our fatness is that we're not evolved enough to know how to be thin? They believe we lacked understanding and discipline how convenient deflect responsibility for the fat phobic ideals they themselves perpetuate what better way to inspire them to set the precedent that fat people are beyond repair. And then to tell a story of the miraculous epiphany that brought us super fat to the super thin light it's inspiring because it is a lie. Nothing is that simple and you can't help paint yourself thin thin people applaud themselves for believing this big fat lie about big fat people when they do it it only subjects them to being further duped by capitalism diet culture and up ultimately upholding white supremacy that doesn't serve anyone now does it remember my fat reader you are valued you are complex You are more beautiful writing from J I don't think I've ever read any J's any of Jays blog posts before just just the Instagrams. I saw that and I was like yes this is great. I want to I want to share it with you. And so good to read the whole thing and all of the juicy content in the middle there in the show notes but if you just want to go right now to go and see it without looking in the shownotes just go to comfy fat on Instagram, as you might be comfy comfy fat is their website. I think the I think it's comfy fat travels let me let me double check. Yeah, comfy fat travels. And they are dating Carissa and a king fat girl flow. I have one or caresses fanny packs. That says fat bitch. And it's my favorite. I'm so proud when I wear it. I don't have as much fat merch as possible. Because it is I've never been able to find a as we call it in England or bumbag because they're too small. But fat girl Flo has great shit and it's those if you've ever seen those fat bitch T shirts, that's Karissa. So power couple Am I right. Okay, well, I think that's everything for today. Yeah, so I hope Brittany feels better and unloads her fat phobia and I hope I hope Courtney does too. And and both of them stop. Stop their sharing of their bullshit. So specifically, I hope that Courtney's kids have some type of respite from what they're seeing. And you know, who knows I might be there might be there might be doing great, you know? Yeah, now. All right. Well, thanks for hanging out or Mitsui. Links for everything we talked about today. facebook.com forward slash 139. If you forget the episode number just go to for first party.com forward slash podcast and I'll see you in the next episode. Goodbye vis Valley and allies. See you in the next episode goodbye. Perfect.

EP138 Transcript

You're listening to the Fierce Fatty Podcast episode 138. 20 ways to tell if your own learning anti-fat bias and diet culture and trend 20 signs that you're not. I'm your host, Vinny Welsby. Let's do it.

Hello, hello. Welcome to this episode how're you doing? I'm I'm doing well, little bit of ginger gender dysphoria today I'm feeling too feminine. I had put on some lipstick. And I had to take it off because I was like, yeah, and now I'm like, Oh, the shape of these glasses are a little bit too feminine, then, I mean, quote, feminine. feminine, what is feminine? I'm gonna take them off. Anyway. Okay, there we go. A little bit more gender neutral now. So sometimes with my gender stuff, sometimes I really enjoy doing more feminine things and you know, makeup and accessories or whatever. And being high femme. And other times I'm just, my brain is just like, No, I don't want it. I don't like it. There's something wrong with something. It's like, you know, when you're looking at a painting, you're like, There's something we need to add? Is it a bit of glitter? Or is it a bit of more? gray paint? Is it what is it and that's how I kind of feel of, but not like, more like, ooh, it's so hard to explain. But I'm lucky because I feel like I can normally quite kind of do something to make myself feel better, like I others, the things that might make them feel better, might be more difficult to achieve, right? So I feel that I'm I'm lucky in that regard of I feel like I can put on a baseball hat or something and, and just feel more, less feminine. And I'm all learning this stuff. So I might be just talking shit. But anyway, that's it, I'm finished today. And I've got some juicy stuff here for you today of ways to tell if you're unlearning anti fat bias and diet culture and signs that you're not. And by the way, I'm going to be reading out these ideas and these listicles that I've created. And if you hear stuff on one side or the other side, I don't want you to be like, Oh my God, I am a giant human turd. Because you're not even if you're doing all other things or thinking or other ways on the you're not unlearning anti fat bias and diet culture. That's okay. Yeah. Because it's to be expected in this world that tells us that dieting and being thin are the best things ever. Often, it's strange when people have a different belief system. I mean, like if they if they naturally came out of life without having to discover this stuff and learn this stuff. I mean, those people that Widow's the giant where are they? Where are they coming from? Some in Arca, you know, in in, you know, global North culture anyway, so, so don't feel bad. Don't feel like oh my god, I thought I was doing really well, really well. But I'm not doing really well. This is all shades of gray. Right? And so some of these things, you might be like, Ah, well, I don't really do that. But I can't do that. And we've got to take the little wins, right? And so if you're like, well, sometimes I think this good thing, but most of the time, I'm thinking you know that my body is a piece of shit. And so we've got to take the you know, what were you? What were you thinking before? Well, you're constantly thinking that your body is a piece of shit. And then now you're thinking like 1% of the time that it might be okay, well, that 1% is better than the 100% that it was before of the opposite, right? So yeah, if you're doing any of the things, I'm not doing these things, it doesn't mean that you're superior, inferior or whatever. It's just stuff that I've noticed common themes when talking to folks. And I had a little insight this morning I made a new friend. I love the West End community here in Vancouver because everyone's out walking their dogs and we have a lot of people who are retired or people who work from home. So I get to talk to a lot of people walking dog at the dog. And so I made a new friend. And this morning, she said, What am I going to have for breakfast? She says, I don't want to have any sugar. And I said, why? What's wrong with sugar? And she says, Well, I don't know. But you know that they say, they say it's bad for you. And I said, What do you mean? And she said, Well, you know, it causes. What is it that it causes? And I was like, do you mean do it? She's like, inflammation, inflammation? And I said it.

It actually doesn't. And she was like, oh, and I said, No, just go ahead and eat some sugar. Go wild was sugar. And she says, Well, before, when I when I let myself eat sugar, I just ate all the sugar. And I said, but were you really allowing yourself to eat the sugar? Or were you mentally restrict restricting yourself and saying to yourself that you were bad free in the shitter? She said, Yes. I said I was being bad right in the sugar. And so anyway, it's not often that I come. I come into contact with dieters, or people who have in a non professional sense, like, obviously, talking to clients, that happens a lot, but in my day to day life, because people when they get to know me, they know that it's not a comment that I'm not going to not question. You know, I won't just be like someone says, Oh, sugar. I won't just be like, yeah, totally, Sugar was so naughty for eating sugar, I'll, I'll talk about it. Or I'll tell them, you know, to shut up in a nice way. Unless it's something someone like I don't want, you want to have a relationship with another day. See you later. Any way blubbery blue, blue. But let's talk about the signs that you're unlearning anti fat bias and diet culture. So number one, we're going to do a little listicle. So signs that you're in learning, anti fat bias and diet culture. Number one, if you have a bad body image day, you don't make it about your body, rather, systemic issues. So if you are doing the unlearning of this stuff, it doesn't mean that you are never gonna have a bad body image day because guess what, you have a human brain in that noggin of yours. And so you're going to be affected by things. From time to time. It's not going to be a you know, everyday thing. Oh, my God, I feel terrible. But it will happen. You know, like today with me having this this gender dysphoria, I'm kind of don't feel as you know, fabulous or fierce or whatever, as normal. And so I am not this moment being like, there's something wrong with me. I. And if I was thinking, Oh, I feel too big today. It would be more like, Okay, well, there's something that's triggered me and this is not about me, this is systemic issues, right? This is all of this and all this bigotry that I've I've soaked into my brain, and I'm making it about me, when really, it's nothing to do with me, what can I do to find comfort? What can I do to self soothe that type of thing. So one, number one, if you have a bad body image day, you don't make it about your body, rather systemic issues. Number two, you're off the diet land swing of restrict and binge. And so that diet land swing, which is pulling back into restrict, which is I mustn't eat that I shouldn't eat that and being bad, and I'm not going to eat that. And then the, you can't hold the swing up forever. And the higher you do pull the swing up into the restricting, then the bigger it's going to go into the binging. And there's nothing wrong with binging it's a natural, natural response to restriction, but you managed to get off that or if you are on it still, it's like a little, you know, a small swing, it's a little of a swinging here a little bit, you know, maybe something bad's happen in the you pull back into restrict a little bit. But generally you're not being like whoa, so hang in high and swinging low on the diamond and swing. Number three, if you engage in movement, you do so for reasons outside of manipulating your body size or because you feel shame for eating. So you if you decide to move your body and if you don't move your body you're not like oh, I am a terrible human. But if you do decide to do it because it feels good, it's fun. It's great for your mental health. You might do it because for some people moving is awful, but they're doing it because they might need to manage some type of condition. So it's not always that you're like, oh my god, I love my body but you're not doing it being like okay, well if I work out on I burn X amount of calories and I'm going to lose X amount of weight, or I ate food this weekend and so I need to go to the the workout house and and work off this food. That's a good name for a gym. Isn't it workout house a bit? Yeah, that's already been taken. That's a good one. Ah, yes. Okay, so number four, you feel relaxed around food most of the time, and have reduced the number of disordered eating behaviors, or have none at all. I swear to babe a jazz as the amount of people who is so normalized, disordered eating is so normalized in our culture that we can't even see it. And so, you've unlearned, you've learned you've recognized RK saying we're mustn't or or feeling guilty for eating or, or doing fasts or intermittent fasting or, or juice cleanses or detox teas, or anything that we mentioned in the last episode. You're not doing that as much, or you're not doing it at all. Number five, you use critical thinking skills when a new alarmist headline on news story is shared. So we talked about that a few episodes ago, what to do what how to think how to approach when an alarm is like, fat people exist, and they're taken over the world and they're going to eat your children. When something like that comes out or something which is not as you know, isn't it? There's a little bit subtle, like, instead of being like, Oh, well, have you seen there's a new study out that says that fat people have really bad personalities? Oh my god. You can use critical thinking skills and be like, Okay, let's see, instead of immediately going into run for the hills as the sky is falling. Number six, the way that you talk about fat bodies, or your body is filled with compassion. You think about the way society at large talks about fat bodies, and we've got this new film coming out, called the whale with Brendan Fraser, which is a giant pile of steaming shit. The premise of the film is that he is a super super fat person. Of course, he's wearing a fat suit. And he's queer. Is he queer in real life? No. Cast in the queer out of queer actor to play a quick character obscene wouldn't happen. And he's apparently moments from death. I don't know how they know this. I haven't seen the film, but this is what we're saying. I think maybe just the fact that he's existing in a supersize fat body. I don't know. And then the resolution of the story can we guess what's gonna happen is the fat character and it's all about weight. Do they lose weight? Yes. Do they become happy? Yes. Yeah, so he loses weight and becomes happy yeah. So you the person this is from a play that film is from a play and so when we're thinking about fat bodies are we talking about fat bodies as Oh sad sack look at him in his house just in the apparently he has an eating disorder. They don't frame it as an eating disorder. They frame it as of course he's eating himself to death. Is that talking about compassion with about a fat person near and this is uh, this is this is you know, the fat folks are like oh my god, like all the people that well meaning fat phobes are like oh, this is such an uplifting story. No, it's not please don't go and watch it if you're if you're thinking about going to watch it. I might watch it and not pay for it just so I can talk about it here and tell you what an absolute fucking shit show is. And so do you think and I'm curious I want to see it but you don't want to fuck with your mental health? Don't worry, don't worry, I'll fuck with my mental health. So I can tell you not to not to go see it and I've not seen it but I'm already kind of you know, I don't think he's out yet. Anyway, whatever. So are you talking about your body on and and all fat bodies with compassion. Number seven, you recognize all the wonderful benefits of being fat and we talked about this on another episode the benefits of being fat and they keep coming and coming other people pointing out benefits that I had not realized. But I think we did a pretty good job of that. of covering that so if you want to know all of the benefits of being fat go to that episode because there's a lot of stuff or you can go to my Instagram and there's on that nice little overview of the benefits which were many, many. I'm trying to find it now. My tend to net my tend to net web.com has been a bit slow. Can it scroll? Scroll? Scroll, scroll. Oh 28 benefits of being fat. Let's give you a snippet. Let's do I'm gonna tell you what number nine is because that's my lucky number. Number nine strong. Yes, we are strong. 15 safety cushion reduce reduce risks from falls. Yes. Yeah. So it found we found out that older people who have a really high risk of terrible complications if they break bones, and people in bigger bodies were less likely to break bones because they had some cushion.

Visually interesting, lower risk of cancers and many other conditions. Great to have sex with. Really cool counterculture. Yeah, so amazing. So you're able to recognize those and be like, Fuck, yeah, fat people are a mover. Number eight, fighting your body is off the table. Instead, you're drawn to fighting institutional, ideological and interpersonal anti fat bias. So you're, you're you've stopped the war with your body. And now you're like, Ah, how was it wrong war with the wrong person. Actually, I need to continue to fight all of these systemic issues that made me feel like my body was wrong. Number nine, you call out fat phobia when you see it or recognize when it's happening. So it's not always, always possible to call out fat phobia. Sometimes you are not bothered. Sometimes you don't have the capacity. Sometimes there's a power imbalance, sometimes lalalalala. But you, you call it out, or you recognize it. And so you might be like, Okay, I see. fatphobia is happening right there. And I'm clocking it in my brain and I'm gonna be late later, I'm like, Oh my God, you can't believe what Sharon said. Or whatever. Number 10. You listen to what your body wants. So that might be rest, or food, and fight any shame that arises from that. And, you know, it's like fighting shame, because shame is probably gonna rear its head and be like, Look at you, fueling your body and resting like a human needs to do. You're so lazy. You're so good. Say we'd probably, you know, that shame that shame goblins probably always gonna be like, hey, look, are you having a fun time? Have you thought about this? But you're fighting it versus being like, yeah, yeah, shame. You're right. Yeah. I am a terrible person for having a little nap. Nap. Oh, nice little nap nap. Number 11. You're hungry for diverse media and understand how limited representation of bodies is harmful. Right? You've got hungry, guys, do you remember that song? But hungry a eyes, or ears or brain or whatever. Like, when you see all of this media, that is the normal stuff that we are normally presented with it for you. It feels like a bit boring. Like you'll see a show and you'll be like, holy shit. Why is everyone thin and white and 22 years old? Or you'll go on search it out. And you'll know that how how it's harmful for society to be only seeing these bodies, and how potentially it's harmful for you. I know it is harmful for me. If I've watched a lot of hours of normative bodies, that is a trigger for me for bad body image. And then I'm like, Okay, fine, I need to go and watch some more diverse media. Number 12. You have a community of fat positive and anti diet folks around you, whether it be virtually or in person. And when I say a community, it doesn't mean necessarily mean people that you engage with. But it might be people who you have a parasocial relationship with so people that you follow and that you you feel really good about a new feels like you're connected, right? And so you've got a lot of that surrounding you. You might not be friends with lots of other fat people depending on where you live. And virtual connections are just as important as in person connections. And so you're so you're swimming in the fat positive waters basically, and the anti diet waters. Number 13. You understand health is a complex topic and know that you can pursue health outside of weight loss, and also that health is largely a social justice issue. So when someone talks about health you're like, huh, huh? You're using those critical thinking skills and know that you didn't you you've internalized, you know, the idea is that diets don't work and you can, if you want to, if that's something that interests you engage in health promoting activities, knowing that there is a limit to that, because a lot of stuff is, is to do with with genetics has to do with where you live, what family you're born into, if you have access to, to, to money and food and all that type of stuff.

Number 14, people know not to talk shit about fatness or praise dieting in front of you, as ending body bigotry is a core value of yours. So the longer that you're doing this stuff, the longer that you are swimming in the fat positive anti diet waters, it will just become a part of who you are your personality, your core values. And to begin with, you will maybe no one knows that you're doing this stuff, right? And, and because you still kind of like a little a little baby, a little baby phone or something with wobbly legs and someone could be like, Oh, but you know, fat fatness is unhealthy and you were like, wobbly legs, I fell over and you're not so stable on your feet in regards to what you believe and, and how you're feeling about yourself. The longer that we do this work, it seeps into our relationships, you can't help but you can't help it because the more that you know about it, the more you're like, I can't unsee this shit and Oh, that's really problematic when my friend talks about that and I know it really triggers me and so I'm going to talk to talk to them about it and and etc etc. So it just becomes a part of who you are and a part of what your values are as it as a person and body bigger tree is something that is a value that you're committed to not perpetuating. And so eventually people will know not to talk shit about fatness and and talk about how someone's lost weight and this new diet and all that type of stuff because they know that you're going to be like Hawkins knows first or you know, they know that you're not interested or you know and obviously that comes with a kind of an asterix of relationships are complicated in some relationships and might be not not be like that. But on the whole alright 15 You understand that diet culture is an anti fat bias is spawned from a racism, eugenics and puritanical belief systems. Let me read that, again, you understand that diet culture, and anti fat bias is spawned from racism, eugenics and puritanical belief systems. And so if you want to learn more about that, go to Sabrina strings book fearing the black body. And it talks about all of that all the history and yeah, all of this stuff, you know, all of the all of these ideologies that are making you feel bad. You're now you're now they're connected to some sort of ideology, which is not great, right? It's like, Why do I feel bad about giving a guy a blowy? Is it because giving guys blowies are bad? Or is it because I'm, I'm, I'm, I'm feeling that Catholic guilt that I learned and from from going to Sunday school, when they said don't give boys blowies. They never said that. You know, where they were, you know, what they said, you know, and where does that come from? And where does that come from? And it's like, it's always like, oh, white supremacy. That's what I got was wrong. Yeah. Again, number 15. You understand that diet culture? Oh, no, we did that one number 16. You try. You don't try to hide your body for the comfort of others. So things like being out of breath when you're walking up a hill about you, but I used to be like, Oh, someone's coming, hold your breath. And just be like, hey, gliding up this hill without needing to use oxygen, because I'm so thin. And because my fatness doesn't impede me in any way whatsoever. Even though everyone walking up this giant hill is out of breath. And then there won't be any like close to death. Oh my god. So you breathe. You don't know don't hide yourself. You take up space, you wear what you want. You're in the photo, you know. And this is Shades of Grey too. You know? Sometimes it's not safe to do those things. But you don't see your body as an inherently negative thing that needs to be hidden. Right It feels it makes me feel so good. So there's I'm I'm at the top of a hill, right? And so whenever I walk in my neighborhood, I'm normally walking down a hill and then have to walk back up. And it makes me feel good. When I walk past someone if I'm walking down and they're out of breath. doesn't feel good. When you hear them being out of breath. It feels like I don't know why. Why I like it so much. I'm just like, yeah, look at you breathing. You're just breathing and you don't even care. I did love it.

Do you love it? Is that just is that amazing? I think everyone loves it is probably like, you know, when, when I you know, watching do go drink water, watching a dog drink water, and you're just like, yeah, you drink that water. You know, that's nice. And that's good for your body. You just drink that water up your good little puppy. And that's how I feel about when I see people out of breath. Walking up a hill. And when they're not out of breath, I'm not I don't trust you, motherfucker. What are you doing? How are you breathing? What is happening? Because I know your breath. Are you holding your breath? Are you waiting for me to pass? So then you can be like, ooh, the sound wasn't happening. Yeah. So yeah, breath, you just own it. Because it's like you're a human being that needs oxygen. Oh my goodness. 70. And you know that if people don't want to love you date you fuck you or be friends with you due to your body size, then that's a them problem, and not a you problem. So people don't want to date or fuck or be friends with fat people. And unlike me, whoa, you are missing out on this party. Imagine all the people who don't want to be friends with me or fuck me or whatever. You know that they're missing out, you know that they're missing out. And it's got nothing to do with me. It's got to do with them and the fact that they are stuck in anti fat bias. Right? If that's why they don't want to fuck me or be with me or whatever. And again, we mentioned this last episode. Fat acceptance liberation is not about forcing people to have sex with you. Just Just an FYI, in case I was listening, but like, Ah, I know it. This is what they're all about forcing them to be able to fuck them. No, no, I, I don't know about you. But I don't want to have sex with people who don't want to have sex with me. It's a weird kink of mine. That I really, I really like it. You know, when people who were gonna have sex with me one joke for me. It's I know, it's weird. It's weird. But yeah, that's me. Number 18, you're able to recognize when a clothing line is not actually inclusive when seats are not suitable for people of all sizes. And other ways. Larger fat people are excluded from the world. So what other times if you are not a larger fat person, or supersize fat person and Infini fat person. But you asked it, but you are a smaller fat person or a medium fat person. It's hard to understand the breadth of anti fat bias and how it manifests in the world. And so you're like, oh my god, this is an inclusive clothing line. And they go up to three eggs and then it's like love the 3x is actually like a US size. 12 But you know, we said three eggs are inclusive. And even if it is a true 3x I'm still excludes a shit ton of people. And so before I would be like, Oh my God, a clothing line goes up to XL. Wow. They are so they're thinking about the fats? No, no, no, no, no, no, no, no. So you know, recognizing that unless a clothing line is goes up to infinity sizing custom size and then it's not inclusive. You're able just to go to a restaurant. Aha, okay, I understand about people's experiences that are not similar to mine, I recognize that, you know, this restaurant doesn't have seating for people of all sizes. It's, you know, booths only in his arms with chairs and you know, you're able to put your shoes in people in in larger fat people's put yourself in their shoes, if you're not already if you're not a larger fat person, and so understanding the complexities of the fat experience obviously if you don't have that lived experience we can never ever fully understand it I'm I'm a medium fat person myself and and also knowing that those things are valuable too, right? Just because I'm included in a clothing range. Doesn't mean that I can be like, cool done with the fat activism. Managed to get Ivy Park Beyonce to go up to a 3x or whatever. All is right in the world. She's inclusive now. Now.

Do you really want either Park clothes, so I'm too poor to buy them. They're really expensive. Anyway, whatever. 90, you don't have scales in your house. And know that all they can tell you is your gravitational pull to the earth. And if you have scales in your house, as you know, you're there for something like, Oh, I like go traveling all the time. And so I weigh my suitcase, get one of those fucking weigh things. But sometimes, if you do, if your suitcase is too heavy, you can't pick it up. So anyway, yeah, you don't have scales, you're not getting on the scales. And if you are, for some reason, you're not making it about who you are. It's just your gravitational pull to the earth. And number 20, you can now see subtle fatphobia and diet culture that used to fly over your head. Like before, it it kind of sucks learning about anti fat bias and diet culture, because then you're like, for fuck sake is everywhere. You know, before I thought it was okay to say blah, blah, blah. But now I'm like, oh, that's, that's not cool anymore. So, you know, and I'm being facetious when I say that, but it is everywhere. And it can be exhausting. Whereas before, even like, no, no, it's all good. Like, for example, I here's an example agenda. So I've joined this new choir. And before I signed up and paid my fees, I message the choir director and I said, Hey, I'm non binary. Is this place inclusive to gender queer folks? And they they sent me an email back saying kind of like, yes. How dare you question us because we are in a queer neighborhood. And I was like, Okay, well, I'll you know, I'll give it a go. And already, there's been a couple of instances where they are not inclusive. Like, yes, I got an email and they've not met me, they've only talked to me on the phone. And so from the phone, even though my email is Vini, so they wouldn't have they would just presume that I was a man. Right. But then I, I spoke to them on the phone. And so I have a low voice, I have a alto tenor, anyway. Can tell contralto and whatever. I have a low voice. Not low, low, but low, lower on on the range of what a woman's voice would be. And, and so they sent me an email saying, Oh, you're a you're a there's female, female tenders and male tenders. And I said, what what tender would I be? Because I'm neither female or male? And they said, Oh, yeah. Oh, yeah. Yeah. So whatever your your 10 a one. So they change it to 10 or one or 10 or two, which is cool. But they're like, oh, yeah, with color said How dare you question our inclusivity. And everybody, like women wear the shirts. Men wear the shirts. Well, what, uh, what about the non binary people? Yeah, now, you know, and so we're, the more that you learn about this stuff. You you're like, Oh, well, I'm really inclusive. Like, even me. There's going to be stuff that I say in this podcast that I say, day to day life, that in a year in two years, whatever. I'm like, Whoa, I really wasn't not aware of that. Because we're all still learning this stuff, right? Our career so let's move into the signs that you're not unlearning anti fat bias and diet culture. Okay, so number one, you say things like, Oh, I mustn't, or only a tiny piece when talking about food. So it's a part of your language. It's a part of your thought process that they're shaming food. Number two, when you have a bad body image day, you spiral and dream about being thinner. Like the solution in your brain isn't isn't shit, we need to we need to destroy we need to destroy fatphobia and the patriarchy and racism, all of that type of stuff. And it sucks that I'm feeling like that and it's due to those things. Instead, your brain goes to a phony I was thinner, I would just feel so much better. Right? And it's kind of like a spiral thing. Number three, you think that organic food is superior? Guess what it's not and reduce fats. carbs, sugar are important things to focus on outside of having a legit medical condition.

I used to work for an organic food company and I was like Oh, gee, I thought organic food was better. Yeah, no. Basically the gist of it is we can charge rich white people more money for this food and so why the fuck not? They think they're gonna get something healthier. They ain't right organic foods still uses pesticides and chemicals and it's just a it's just a bigger wellness swindle in case you weren't aware. But I mean if you want to keep paying more money for food and it makes you feel better than you know, whatever but I mean it's it's not it's not better and neither is often he's he's having a little cough if you What is that noise? The exam a little cough Thank you baby. Okay. He says he's okay. Yeah, so none of those things are superior. Um, number four, you can see the beauty and other fat people or fat people but not yourself. This is a big one being like I can understand it, I can get it like fat people are fit us but not me. That tells me that you have a lot of beliefs and biases are still lingering and you can extend compassion to others but you cannot extend it to yourself which is what we all do right? You can be forgiving and compassionate towards other people but not ourselves because we have to hold ourselves to different standards because we believe that our safety is at risk if we're not perfect human beings. Okay, so number five you move your body due to fear of getting fat or fatter Yes, and you do in it because you just use us as guilt is guilt is guilt it's fair. It's shame it's all that type of stuff. And maybe you don't even like doing the exercise but because you were so motivated by thinness you do it number six almost everyone around you is into dieting is straight sized or talks about fat as a negative. And so when I talk to people who are new on their journey, I will say how many people around you are also into Intuitive Eating anti diet fat positivity and the answer will be normally zero or one person who is kind of interested a little bit but not really maybe and that's the kind of swimming in waters and I'm not saying okay go and you know get rid of everyone in your life but like sorry later there's because that's not realistic, right? But it just goes it just tells me that there's a lot of anti fat stuff and pro diet stuff getting into that gorgeous noggin of yours. And we want to be able to support your mental health as much as possible by making sure that you're surrounded by messages that feel good for you. Not make you feel bad Alright, number seven, you think often about how being thin will make you hot and fuckable and wish you could just be that so a lot of people this is a big one that kind of deep, dark desire of I wish I was hot. I wish I was that person on Instagram that guys would save their image and have a Wang Kovar. I wish that my partner was like for Blumenauer like you're so hot and I want to show my friends off to you. And I'm not and to get there. I will be I will strive to be thin. Right? Versus being like, oh, yeah, my, my partner really is objectifying me a lot. Sounds like they've got a lot of stuff that they need to go to therapy about or work out because turns out I'm not an object. And, and yes, I understand the desire to to to be seen as hot and fuckable. But you know, it's a temporary state. All of those people whose images are on Instagram making me feel like a piece of shit. They are aging, that's probably not a real image. They are, you know, their bodies are going to change. What does it do to for me to objectify them in that way? You know, so you're having these types of dialogues versus like, Oh,

I just feel sick with the desire to be hot unfuckable that was me. So Much like the pain of not being me believing and thing is, what is hot and fuckable? It is a very specific image. And it's not obtainable for most people. So, and who picks those images? Who decides what systems of oppression decides that a thin, white, young, non disabled English speaking? You know, etc, etc is the epitome of beauty. You know? Sounds like something that someone like Donald Trump would have picked out. Do you want Donald Trump to think that you're fuckable? No, no. No. And you know, obviously, it's not Donald Trump. But he is a good representation of the types of systems and people who uphold those systems that decide what is hot? That youth is superior that thinness is superior that white skin is superior that? No, no. So, I mean, when you start getting into that type of stuff, it takes that power away in it, and it makes me think, you know, and it's still in it was painful, right? It is painful. And I think about a time where I was super, super insecure with my my boyfriend at the time. And I looked through his phone. And he he had said to his work colleague that he had delivered a pizza to two women. And the guy said, what did they look like? And he said that they're smoking hot, and I'd never heard those words come out of his mouth before. He'd never referred to me as smoking hot. And it haunted me. And thinking about, you know, he was talking to a male colleague and thinking about, Oh, what you know, that machismo that sexism that was happening, right, then, you know, like, would hear if a female colleague said, what did they look like? Would he have also said that? What was he? Why was he? Why why did that happen? You know, anyway, so this is a you know, it's painful, right? It's painful, but we can pick it apart, we can pick it apart. Number eight, you see, you see being fat as an indicator of laziness being unhealthy or unattractive. And so if I said, corn, tell me your deepest, darkest, like, what do you think about being fat, and those types of things are coming out, that tells me that you've got a lot of work to do. Number nine, deep down you really can't shake the idea that being fat is bad for your health. You're like, Yeah, I know the studies but it's just because it's so deeply ingrained. And so you've got someone learning to do their the return you think about food a lot, but not in a joyful way, and stress about what to eat. So you're not like, Oh, I'm hungry. I'm gonna have some food. You're more like, oh, what can I eat? What should I eat? Oh my god, he must Jade. Number 11. You don't understand about size privilege, or call yourself fat, even though you're straight sized. So this is you know, it's like our body. It's like our self of our perception is warped. Because we see so many images of of which are digitally altered of what what is a desirable bodies, and then when you see yourself and you're not thin, thin, thin, thin, thin, thin, thin, but with a big bomb, and with big tits, and butt with thin waist, you know, so when you don't see that digitally altered image, when you look at yourself, then your brain is like well then you're fat, and not understanding size privilege and being like, well actually, Am I fat? I wear size 1214 Like does that make me fat? New? You know, am I am I am I really the most grotesque person walking the planet? Probably not. Is my life terrible because I am now a size 16 And I can't shop in the forever 21 Straight size section. I don't know what straight size forever 21 goes into and not realizing that there are people who are sized out of all stores, you know, plus sized stores.

And also recognizing that that is painful and it's okay to feel like shit and Feel sad if you're resized out of a straight size store, but also recognizing, I feel like shit. This is why I feel like shit is because of all these systems of oppression, but also, I've got so much privilege in my body. And so not understanding that that privilege that you might have and we've all got privileges, right privilege doesn't mean that you don't feel bad about yourself. And it doesn't mean that you don't deserve compassion and, and don't deserve to feel good about your body. It just means that you don't have that extra barrier that others do barriers that others might have in different identity factors that you might have. I have a post on my Instagram. thin privilege explained. So if you want to know more about that, go to my Instagram. I have a postcard podcast episode is about it as well. If you want to really get in dupe Yes, okay. Number 12, you have scales in your house and use them to dictate your worthiness, use got scales in your house, get rid of that shit, hide it, put it in the bin, do a shit on it. Whatever. We didn't don't need those nasty things. Because literally, the number is telling you if it's a number lower than what you thought, what does that tell you? I'm a good person, if it's higher, I'm a bad person. And the only difference is that, you know, that maybe one day yeah, you you happen to weigh more or having to weigh less for whatever reason, and it doesn't mean that you're, you're now a terrible human. And a lot of times, you know, we have these Oh, well, I'm so bad. And because I put on X amount of pounds. And it's sometimes it's like, you can't even you don't even know that that's how you didn't know that that had happened unless you had gone on a scale. So why do you have this torture device in your house? Why? For the odd chance that you stand on it for that one chance that you stand on and it says something lower than when what you want that you have that you're a good person, it's like being in an abusive relationship, you get fed loads of shit, shit, shit, and then you're moving away, and then you get a little bit of good. Okay, well, I'll stay No, get rid of that shirt. And you won't have someone in your houses into dieting. So just get put it in their room, tell them to hide it, you don't want to say that. It's not good for your mental health. Number 30. And you don't shut down diet talk or fat phobia, or sometimes even think that it's not that big of a deal if it happens. So again, shutting down diet talk or fat phobia, that is with an asterix of is it the right time? Do you have the spoons? What is the power? Different different difference there with you and that person? But if that's consistently happening, it's just washing over you washing over your brain? And you're like, Wow, is it that big of a deal? And you have no plans to ever one day set boundaries with people who continually do that, then that's probably going to be a problem. Number 14, you feel good about yourself for eating, quote, healthy food. So if you noticed that you're like, oh, yeah, I just ate a dust and toenail salad. I must be going to heaven. Because I'm such a good moral person. Oh, you know, we don't have those. We don't we don't think literally Oh, I'm gonna go to heaven. I'm a moral person, but you just you just like, ooh, ooh, I'm so good. Or, Oh, if someone came in now and saw me eating a salad, they be like, Oh, look at you good person. That's, that's, that's in control and has their shit together. And, and people might think that right, you know, regardless of what we're thinking, but we can be like, is it? Is it true? Is it true because I eat a tomato that I'm all of a sudden this house their shit together person? Or if I don't let I'm the opposite. 15 Most of the media you consume features normative body so and you don't even think about it right? And so have a little think about all the things that you're going into your brain and so that could be your Instagram feed your tick tock of movies, your watch the Netflix or whatever. Is it mostly thin, white? Or if it's you know, muscle muscularly, muscular, you know, whatever, normative bodies, bodies image standards we have today.

That's affecting how you think about bodies, right? And so, just recognizing it you're not I'm not saying that you don't watch these things. because some of these, these shows are really fucking good, right? Oh, they're so trashy, like I need to watch it. I'm not saying don't watch them. Oh, you could not watch them whatever. But recognizing that that is probably not helpful for society not helpful for your mental health and okay, what can I do to mediate that? And what can I do to help myself with that? I'm going to watch something which is a little bit more fat positive, a little bit more queer and a little bit more disabled or whatever? Yeah. Number 16. You struggle to connect that day to day fat phobia and diet culture, or connect to larger systems of oppression? Right. And so when I think about this stuff, like something that's really powerful for me is, I really want to be anti racist, right? I really want to be an ally to those who have marginalized identities that I don't have. And I'm sure you do, too. Right. And, and something that I will come back to is if I'm struggling with, with feeling shame around something is, Who am I hurting by perpetuating these myths? And of course, I'm not deliberately trying to hurt people, but connecting it back to those bigger systems that are bigger than the way that I'm feeling about myself, helps me really cut that shit out. Because why am i Believing these these racist beliefs? I'm not trying to obviously. But why am I you know, the, you know, because fat phobia and diet culture and all that type of stuff leads back to racism. So am I am I committed really to try to be trying to be anti racist? Well, then I'm not I'm, I'm gonna work on this stuff, right? I'm gonna continue to work on it. And I probably never get to the end destination because there is no end destination, but making that connection, making that connection with all of those formulas, stuff, you know, like, hoping that your husband thinks that your heart, okay, what what bigger system is at play here? What bigger systems are at play here? And making that connection and be like, Okay, do I want to support sexism and racism and transphobia and ableism? Now? Not really my bag. Okay, so I'm going to try and work on this. Number 17. You think all fat people are fat because they did something quite wrong to get that way or because they're traumatized. So we think about these tropes that we have about fat people is that they are fat, because they were out of control lazy. Eating too much food and watching video games or whatever, playing video games, or they're traumatized. And so they're like, Okay, well, I want to not be attractive. And so I'm going to decide to become fat. And of course, they there are fat people who these things might be true. And also, the majority of of the majority of stories about fat people are very complex, are probably wouldn't probably never know. Right? Really, we've got studies that show that the reasons why pack fat people are fat are in the hundreds. Right. And, and as well, kind of, I'm thinking about they're sort of like, Why Are Fat People fat? Like saying, quote, it's not their fault? Almost. When it does positions fatness is this negative thing. And there are fat people who are fat and who want it to be fat, right? Who who chose to become fat? And that doesn't mean that the bad. So yeah, so basically, it's that shades of gray thinking. So critical thinking skills. And I really deeply believed this. I was like, I thought that everyone who was fat needed to go to therapy. And then if they went to therapy, they would be thin. And then when I started going to therapy, and I didn't become thin, I was like, What the fuck? Why? Because I'm obviously fat, because there's something wrong with my brain. Not that you know, whatever. You know, I'm just, you know, genetically happened to be fat, whatever.

Yeah. Number 18. You believe everyone shares your opinions on fat people. If you think negative things about fat people, and aren't aware that many people love fat people think they are gorgeous, and that fat people have rich, fulfilling and successful lives. And it's hard to think things like that if if we're steeped in anti fat bias and diet culture to imagine that a fat person can have as good a life as a thin person or Guess what, maybe even a better life than a thin person? How is it possible? It's not it can't be because the idea is that when we think about fat people, it's like sad sack, no friends, desperate to be thin. Lose, you know all of this stuff. And to know that actually, as, as much as there's a variety of stories within people, it's the same with fat people. And there are many fat people who are just glorious human beings that that lead wonderful lives, same way. We're straight size people, right? And fatness is not a determinant of all of that type of stuff. And presuming that everyone thinks about fat people in the same way. Yeah. Number 19, you don't like being in photos and don't want them shared anywhere. So this is a big one, if you're if you're if you don't want to be in photos, it tells me that you are feeling uncomfortable in your body. And so we've got some work to do there. And that's just one way that it that it manifests other ways that it manifests is, is you know, struggling to decide what to wear, or only wearing stuff that hides your body or, or pulling down your clothes all the time, or not wanting to get in the pool with the kids or with your friends or whatever. So there's lots of different ways that it manifests. And so if you're doing any of those things, then it tells me that there's probably some diet culture, anti fat biased beliefs going on there. And number 20, you can get behind fat acceptance, but only as long as they're healthy. AKA, you feel more comfortable when fat people perform good fatty roles. I see this so often, right? You know, when I when I say if I get a new hairdresser, or whatever, because you know, I have 50,000 hairdressers because I can never get a good haircut. And when I'm making a new person, I tell them what I do. Often. Often they say, that's gray. I mean, at the end of the day, it's all about whether you're healthy. As long as you're healthy, then it doesn't matter. And I'm like, Oh, so close. Close. But no, no. Because what what we're wanting from fat people when we're saying that is for them to perform a good fatty role for us, I did a podcast on good bad, fatty versus bad, Fatty, good fatty is a fat person who is more palatable, according to society. So a fat person who is trying to lose weight a fat person who, who says, I know that I'm fat and disgusting. And I'm so sorry about that. A fat person who hides their body, a fat person who goes to the gym and eat salads. And, and by the way, it's absolutely okay if we are performing the good fatty trope, because sometimes that's the only way that we can survive in the world. Because fat phobia is so devastating that if we have to perform, then sometimes that's what keeps us alive. And so it's more about not that the fat person is doing it is that we expect fat people to do that. And then we give them a little bit of humility. Whereas if a fat person is like, I'm going to wear what the fuck I want, I'm going to share my body I am not gonna die. In fact, I'm going to in front of you eat this, quote, unhealthy food. I'm going to fuck you, I won. And I like being fat. Society is like, No, we can handle it if you were, if you are, are a pleading with us to accept you. But if you don't plead with us, then then you're bad, then you're bad. It's making me think of is called making the cut is on Amazon Prime. And it's designers and they design clothes. And at the end of the episode, they'll be like, some people are going home, someone's going home, whatever. They're so mean to them. And a few instances they've made people beg to stay. And it made me sick. I was like, Ah, this is so disgusting that they're doing this to these these people. And you know, the person was like, please, you know, I'll do anything to stay and and then there's the option to change their minds. That's the thing is, if they beg well enough, then there's the option for the people who voted them out to change their mind.

The judges like Heidi Klum and Paris Hilton sidekick? What's her name? Anyway? And then a, someone who works at a fashion design house. And they were like, Have you changed your mind? No, I have not changed my mind after the person's done the begging. So people don't do the begging. And I'm, like, good for you. But also, you know, there's some of the people, some of the people who've done the begging and have been let back in. So anyway, and so how even in in that in that instance? The people who who do the begging, they're seen as more likable, they're seen as more kind of like, Oh, fine, we'll give you another chance. Whereas if you were to just say, Okay, thanks. See you later, then it's kind of like, whoa, they were rude. It's like, no, they would, you know, they're not, they're not not doing anything wrong. They are leaving with with dignity, and not saying that the people who begged not leaving with dignity, but they didn't want to do that. And so they didn't want to perform, they didn't want to perform for us. And we're like, oh, wow, they're ungrateful. Did they really want it? And it's the same with it's the same with a lot of different roles and societies, if they are not, like, I'm so thankful, thank you so much, oh, you've changed my life. And we're not performing, then you're seen as less acceptable? And, you know, I think even like, with with jobs, you know, oh, my God, this, why do I want this job? Oh, you're the best company in the world. I've been dreaming about working for this company since I was a baby. And you know, and it's kind of like, you just, you're just trying to get a job to pay the bill? Doesn't mean it says, Why is it that I have to write a cover letter, which is basically fanfiction for the company that I'm applying for? And I was like, yes, exactly. You know, you need someone to do a job. I want to get paid with money. There we go. There's a transaction, I don't need to tell you that I have wet dreams about you every night to get the job. And, yeah, and and so if we can't get behind the fact that there are going to be fat people who, who we might not like because they might have, you know, a different personality to us. We might have fat people who, who don't want to exercise we might have fat people who like eating food that we we think is unhealthy. If we can't get behind fat acceptance is for all fat people, then that tells me that there is some bias going on there that we do. Earn, learn. All right, so that was my two to 20 thingamajiggy is the for you. What do you think? And I mean, this these these days, because could go on forever. I was like, I need to stop at 20 Because I can be like going on forever with these things of different signs. But these are the big ones that I see. And again, if you're like, Oh, well, Vinnie said I'm doing this so that means I'm a terrible boss, and I need to go and just leave the planet. No, no. And also, I am in this journey with you. I'm not this person who was like 100% always like some fat positive guru that's like, oh, I never have a bad thought about a fat person ever. How would I never know I'm perfect. No, I have a human brain. Right? Just like you. And I get influenced things influenced by things don't. So, but there's some like kind of key kind of low hanging things where like, Ah, okay, we've got a little bit more work to do here. And, and also, okay, I've been doing the work and I've, I think I'm doing pretty good with unlearning this stuff. Also knowing that the journey is never ending. Unfortunately, if only we could get to like fat utopia of I've arrived and I will never ever have a fat phobic thought or a bigoted thought in my life again. Yeah, that's not going to happen. Alright, well, thanks for hanging out with me today. I hope you have a wonderful rest of your day. And remember to stay a fierce fatty and I'll stay See you in a while. Alligator.

EP137 Transcript

You're listening to the Fierce Fatty Podcast episode 137. Fat shaming in kids media. My goodness, I'm your host, Vinny Welsby. Let's do it.

Hello, fatties and welcome to this episode and honorary fatties. Welcome to I got some law, fat shaming his media to talk to you about today. question Question, listen, is this is this ever happened to you? Is there a REIT? Can you provide me a reason why this is happening? So I was on the phone to my doctor the other day, you're gonna repeat prescription and before we ended the call, I said, Hey, Doc, can you? Can I tell you something, it's probably going to be a little bit weird. But you've probably had many people say it to you in the past? And she said, Yes, what is it? I said, my dog, Dougal licks, the same spot of my leg has been looking the same spot on my leg, not a spot as in pimple an area, same area on my leg for the last month. And I've seen TV shows where the the owner is like, my dog was sniffing my knee. And it turns out, I had knee cancer, and my dog saved my life. And I was like, my, my dad died from a blood clot in his leg that got loosened and killed him instantly. And so I was like, Oh my God, I've got a blood clot, and doggies licking this spot in my leg to warn me that I have a blood clot. And I said this to the doctor and she was like, No one in my whole career has ever asked me if the dog licking a certain area means that there's like some something there. And I was like, wow, really? I really thought it'd be so common because I don't know why I thought it'd be so common because I saw a show was someone in a shows and it was. And she was like, Listen, no, these are the signs of a blood clot like you'd know, blah, blah, blah. And I was like, Well, you know, I've got no symptoms of anything apart from Dougie licking the sales via my leg. And I know at first I thought, Oh, I must have dropped some gravy on my leg or something. Or maybe something splashed on my jeans but he's been he does it all the time. And he's been in so alarming. So listen, if there's some listener out there who's like yeah, oh my goodness, this happened and it turns out that something and nothing else has changed. It's not like I'm wearing some sort of new lotion or, or new new washing liquid or anything like that. Yeah. Next episode, we're like, oh, Vinnie, Vinnie. His dog was right. And yeah, I hope not. Anyway, so yeah. Hey, I've been thinking about this. So I've been thinking about this episode, right. I, I pick out episode topics in advance, and I let my brain more the topic. Because you know, I think you sometimes you need a little space. For mulling mulling things it happened to be that last week, I had a couple of things that I was like, Oh, this is great for this podcast. Man, I just wanted to mention if you wanted to go and look at these things, so first thing is on Netflix, there's a documentary called disclosure, and it's about trans people's depictions in the media. And it's really good, really interesting and talks about all of the fucked up ways trans nurse has been depicted. And from, from actually the first moving pictures was of gender non conforming, or gender non conforming person, potentially a trans person moving into the idea of transness and blackness as these two terrible characteristics of humans and and mocking them together.

And it's really interesting and obviously depressing to but and also like ends on a high note of like this and called Trans shows now you know, one of my favorite shows and it reminded me of one of my favorite shows and I'm gonna be watching it is pose. It's on. Currently, oh, it was on Netflix and it's currently on do Isn't he plus? And I think the original network was FX. I don't know if that's that's not a Canadian thing. So go watch it if you haven't, it's about the Bourne culture in the 80s and 90s, New York, and the cast is so caught the cast is like 80% trans people, like 90 plus percent, queer people. It's great. It's great. Lots of people of color. Black folks. Yeah, it's amazing. It's great. Yes, and another thing that I've been watching recently, too, I've only watched like three episodes of it. And it's just so heartwarming, and it's appropriate for younger, like teens, probably not kids, children, babies, you know, toddlers or whatever. But it's on Discovery plus, which is also para, question mark. And it's called Generation drag. It follows young, queer kids, some of them are trans, and some of them are gay and drag performers. And they're young, and they're going to perform at this. They've used the word drag in the word Debbie time, so debutante ball, but they call it a drag you taunt ball. And it's just so beautiful and affirming. And great. So if you've got kids, and even if you don't, it's not a kid show, right? It's just, you know, following young, young adults, I guess, a 1415. That type of age. As they do this. It's really good. So yes. Yeah. And what made me think about this episode was watching on Netflix, there's a there's an anthology series that's had three seasons called Love, love, death, and robots. And it was making me think, okay, so this anthology series is kind of like, you know, how Black Mirror every every episode is different. And it's kind of like a theme of, of the future with technology. But this is, like, futuristic, I mean, not even futuristic, but sci fi, whatever. And it just, it just is flabbergasting. How in love death and robots. I've not watched the first few seasons, I just started watching them, the search season. creative minds, how how far creativity can go and all of these different concepts that are related to love death and robots and how, you know, some are funny, and some are beautiful, and some of this and, and how expansive people's imaginations are, but not so expansive, that there could be a fat character that exists in his make believe universes, unless they are there to serve as comedic support. There was one episode a very short episode, and there was a fat man in it for like, one minute, and his purpose was supporting the little bit of comedy. It's just so out of the realm in sci fi, that there would be a leading character that is fat. Like it's just I was like, we could imagine aliens with tentacles coming out of his homes. But we can't imagine that a fat person is the lead character. That's just too wild. It's just an actually last week I watched a webinar from Asda, a s dah, I think as the sounds for oh, yeah, Association for sides of size, diversity and health so as to and then there's Nafa and a FA. So they're the two main kind of fat advocacy organizations and the event that I went to was Afrofuturism.

Changing the narrative on the future of bodies, hosted by Stephanie CRISM pronouns she, they and Afro futurism is Wikipedia says, cultural ascetic and philosophy of science and history that explores the intersection of the African diaspora culture with science and technology. It addresses themes and concerns of the African diaspora through techno culture, and speculative fiction, encompassing a range of media and artists with a shared interest in envisioning black futures that stem from Afro diasporic experiences. And so an example that's definitely said It's a good example of showcase showcasing Afrofuturism is a film Black Panther. And there's another another one, which is not a film, but there's an anthology written anthology series called dark matter. And it's all sci fi written by black votes, folks. And and so in this webinar on Afrofuturism, Stephanie talks about how often marginalized bodies, often fat and black and queer and trans bodies are not seen in media. And if they are, they're there to serve a purpose of being the villain or being the comedic relief and, and how negativity is is depicted by blackness and fatness. Really interesting, and how can we make a future where identities marginalized identities are at the forefront of media? Well, I don't know about you, I just find it's just so much more interesting. When you're watching a show. And there's, there's diversity. There's true diversity, you know, not like, I thought diversity in media was watching sex in a city and being like, oh, there's a blonde one, there's a brunette one, there's a gender one and there's a snotty one, true diversity, you know, like, you know, very fat people and lots of people of color and, and disabled people and neurodiverse people and then not just being like a side character. Just it just, you know, like with pose, pose. Pose doesn't have fatness. That's one thing. Like we pose, the SIS het white people are the outliers. And it just, it's just makes things makes it more of like, visually rich and interesting. And the storytelling is either the writers are a lot of the writers are queer and trans and they're sharing their stories. And so it's just, it's just great all around. Yeah, so a little bit from from Stephanie's webinar, you can go in, go to the Astor website and go find it again, the name is Afrofuturism changing the narrative on the future of bodies. And so brief history of Afrofuturism right, and Mark dari coined the phrase in his book flame wars the discourse of cyberculture describe the work of writers like Samuel Delaney and Octavia Butler, who wrote from not only a position in which their protagonists were black, but also in Delaney. Delaney his case, a queer sensibility. dari saw science fiction is a vehicle for black folk to truly narrate the black experience of ancestors and their descendants. Okay, so as well, Stephanie says in the culture teaching you to hate being fat, so she says, when we see images of so called fat people in popular culture, we are immediately altered to, or alerted to judge who they are as human beings by their body size black women are often seen as the mammy or Jezebel character, depending on their bodily dimensions. Yes, fat women especially are either deemed evil or dumb or sassy depending on the race of the individual. We are expected to especially feel sorry for the fat white woman because she has clearly not being able to control herself and therefore needs to be loved through her shortcomings, whereas fat women of color can only save themselves from themselves. White women, no matter how bad the characters are, can be redeemed. can be redeemed because fatness isn't an is not inherent in whiteness, women of color are fat because that's just how they are.

And also she says isms are feather flock together. So they say transphobic, queer, antagonistic language and stereotypes, racist and misogynistic stereotypes, fat equals evil. Fat people deserve violence. Fat people cannot control their hunger and must be forced to do it through violence. But people hate themselves and others because they hate themselves. And they deserve ridicule because they're lazy and gluttonous. Fat people even when they are skinny, will be fat because they cannot control themselves. So that's another kind of like overview of what Stephanie was talking about. So please go and buy the webinar. On the Aza website. The links to everything I'm going to talk about today is in the show notes first id.com forward slash one, three sub o Oh, and if you forget, it's always first friday.com forward slash podcast. Okay, so set. So I asked people on my Instagrams, tell me about the most fat phobic TV shows that you have seen for kids are fat phobic media that you've seen, because I am not a parent. Although I've mentioned before, I am a pebbling. So I have nibbling things. And so when I spend time with my siblings, they're across the channel in Ireland, and I'm in Canada, so I don't get to spend that much time with him. But when I do, we will watch shows, obviously. And that got me interested, you know, a few years ago being like, What the fuck? Why is his TV show saying all of this awful shit, but my exposure is limited. So anyway, I want to start out just by a little bit of what why this is a problem, you know, fat phobia in kids media. So this is from a blog, talking about fat shaming kid shows from Cafe mom, and it starts a 2013 study by Leeds University found that kids start demonstrating prejudice against fat people at just four years old. After reading stories with different versions of a character named Alfie, a fat healthy, a thin, thin Alfie, Alfie and an Alfie in a wheelchair and then being asked to compare the characters on certain attributes, kids said the fat version of Alfie would be less likely than the others to do well in school, be happy with his appearance, or have a lot of friends based solely on how he looked. And these biases don't just apply to fictional characters, and 2017 study found that kids who are fat are less likely less liked by their peers, and more likely to be bullied excluded starting as early as first grade. Kids are also increasingly afraid of becoming fat themselves. As many as 34% of five year old girls have tried to restrict their food intake in order to lose weight, and one in four kids of both sexes. All sexes should be but I guess they didn't study queer kids, queer gender queer kids, gender queer kids. So one in four kids have been on a diet by the age of seven. While the way we talk about bodies at home plays a major role in how kids view weight and body image researchers actually cite media exposure and appearance conversations as the strongest predictors of diet related behavior. Okay, so show show show. I got a lot of responses from from you lot. You family a lot a lot on the Instagrams and also doing some research coming up with the most egregious. So some shows, their theme is fat shaming, and other shows or TV or movies or books or whatever. They just have it woven into storylines, and I think the most egregious and every, not every response 50% of the responses I got was Peppa Pig and Peppa Pig. The theme is fucking Peppa Pig. Peppa Pig can suck my tits. Peppa Pig is all about how daddy pig has a big fat belly.

Daddy Pig. I mean like, that's not what this show is not Let's love it. Daddy Pig for being fat, but Daddy Pig. His character is there as being the comedic relief and shaming daddy paid constantly for his belly. So from this same post from Cafe mom, Peppa Pig, a cartoon aimed at preschoolers, in which the running joke is that Daddy Pig is fat. Someone wrote an op ed for half at Huffington Post all about Peppa Pig and it says okay, can Peppa Pig stop feeding shut fat shaming Daddy Pig all the time poor Danny pig. And the author of this Huff Post article highlights an episode although you could watch pretty much any episode and have your jaw agape feeling like whoa. So they described his episode on this episode. Peppa Pig makes a password to her tree house. The password is daddy's big tummy, and everyone laughs at him that he tries and fails to enter the tree house and and pepper tells him that his tummy is too pig big. And they say pepper girl, you're already burnt him with the password Now let the man live. So, of course Daddy Pig goes on to get wedged in the door although Mama Pig got in just fine and is roughly the same size as Daddy Pig poor Daddy Pig. And I watched that clip and eat like Peppa Pigs in the tree house and Daddy Pigs like can I come in and and she's like that the pep Daddy Pig, say the password Daddy Pig. And he says, Oh, I'd rather not. And you could see, I know. It's facial expression. He says I'd rather not say it and I'm like, Yes, Daddy Pig setting boundaries. Don't stand for that bullshit. You tell Peppa to shut the fuck up. And then and then Mummy Pig and everyone's like, Come on Daddy Pig. Save the password. And he says, oh, right then. And then he says, Daddy's big belly and they all go. Even the grandparents are there motherfuckers hanging around all laughing and then Daddy Pig tries to get into the tree house and he's too fat. And everyone's like, you're such a fat fuck Daddy Pig. And then as in the same episode, they go swimming and daddy pig says, I'm going to jump off the diving board and pepper comes comes back and says silly daddy. Your tummy is too big. And Daddy Pig is like, oh actually I'm really good at diving. And I'm actually naturally fit and Peppa Pig says you don't look very fit daddy. Your tummy is a bit big. Fucking that's when I would like dunk Peppa Pig and be like, Oh, I'm gonna go dive and live my fabulous fat pig life. Yeah, so the most egregious is Peppa Pig. So if your kid is watching Peppa Pig I would I know it's so popular right? There's even like Peppa Pig candy you can get in the UK like in a big store. Peppa Pig county is delicious is it's traveled to everyone likes it. And so it might be difficult but some some parents have said that what they do is we'll interrupt the fatphobia and say is it appropriate to shame Daddy Pig for being fat? No it's not we don't judge people on on on appearances but in this article here it goes on to show tweets talking about people saying oh shit like this is now starting to affect my my kids. One person says yes, it's caused my toddler to tell everyone that they have quote, Big Daddy Big Daddy Pig tummies and other words and says oh their regular dose of body shaming on Peppa Pig. Looking forward to one day explaining why such some cartoon pigs are wrong to my daughter. Someone else says might be time to ban Peppa Pig when the child starts declaring Daddy has a big fat tummy. Stupid bloody pig. Jesus the body shaming and pick up Peppa Pig is earn real I thought Daddy Pig got it bad but poor Uncle Pig is completely denied his pig nutty. I don't know what they do to Uncle Pig but it's worse than what they do to Daddy Pig.

The body shaming on Peppa Pig poor Daddy Pig. Some of us dads are in love with our very big tummies. Yes, exactly. So much fat shaming on Peppa Pig tonight. We should all be like Daddy Pig and love cookies. And that's the other thing is of course he loves cookies because he's had lungs. Yeah, okay, so. And another one. So Arthur, Arthur. This author says is a quote safe show in our house. So I was half listening as I stood at the counter slicing vegetables. But in the midst of my meal prep, I heard something that caught me off guard. Do I look Husky to you guys. Arthur asked his friends. They asked him what it that means it means I'm fat. He said I had to get new pants yesterday. I listened for a few seconds longer hoping Arthur was about to wade into progressive body positive waters. Instead, his friend said, I know what you need to do. You just need to go on a diet. That's when I told my daughter is time to turn off the tablet and set helped set the table. After the kids went to bed. I put the episode back on and was horrified by what I saw. In addition to negative fat and diet talk. The episode features a fantasy sequence in which a circus performer invites people to step right up and gaze at various horrors. One of them is Arthur or as he's identified in this clip, the laden lump of L Would city and the performer isn't shy about describing his him as a freak of nature. Large Lardy a lifeless lay about lump of lumpiness, the man hollows pointing to a gelatinous blob wearing Arthur's signature yellow sweater. The gist of the episode is that Arthur learns dieting is bad. And eating nutritious food and exercising is exercising, so the best way to stay healthy, but the way it arrives at that conclusion is through a plot thick with fat shaming and fat phobia. Yeah. I mean, it's like the kids heard it. And that's only because the mum had her ears pricked. Like the kid could have couldn't come in continued watching that episode. And I mean, you know, one isolated incident of horrendous fatphobia it might not affect a child, but that's not what's happening. Right? You know, kids are not in this media bubble where we can monitor what they're watching at all times. And we're swimming in the waters of dye culture and fatphobia our whole culture is just soaked in that shit. And of course, it means that the writers of the shows are also going to use them as storytelling devices and moralistic tales of don't get fat or else you'll end up in a circus show like Arthur did. So it's it's everywhere. And it's just frightening. Okay, continuing any Disney Channel show or Disney movie. So someone on my story said the Fat kids are pretty portrayed as unintelligent and sloppy, fat, fat, fat characters are evil. And then we have a whole someone who's holding a whole analysis on fat predictable notions, fat Disney and just fat Disney fat Disney. Again, link in the bio and talks about how fatness is protect portrayed in Disney and I would I would extend this to a lot of media, kids and otherwise and you know, not just animation as well. So the three areas they've they've grouped as is. The first one is the comedic relief. So we spoken about that before and they they show examples of the comedic reliefs in Disney and so we've got Angus chestnut from the a n t farm. And the different examples of fatphobia with Angus claw Howser from Zootopia we're going to talk more about that in a moment. Gus from Cinderella So Gus is a little mouse. Hook hand from Tangled. So these are all comedic relief. They're there to be funny. lifou from Beauty and the Beast.

The matchmaker from Mulan, the Sultan from Aladdin, Trish Dela Rosa from Austin an ally. What do you think from the live suite on deck? That's it for those for the comedic reliefs and that's I would say that that's not they're given examples here. It's not extensive and as well. There's new media is coming out all the time, right? Okay, so the simple turns a simpletons Gus from Cinderella lifou the Salton What do you think? So they're all portrayed as simpletons and the villains, the villains the map matchmaker from Mulan, Mulan, Mulan, Mulan, Mulan, Mulan, Mulan, Milan rouge, Mulan, Mulan. Anyway, the queen of hearts from Alice in Wonderland you remember that the 1951 version is no fat red faced angry. Stinky Pete the prospector from Toy Story to Ursula from The Little Mermaid now Ursula is really interesting because it's been said that Ursula was based on divine a drag performer and based on divine because Devine is fat and is a drag performer like I just said, because they want it to make the character so repellent It's so on feminine and queer in their representation of what woman was, and the most just unattractive version. And this is what they've come up with. I mean, if you ask me I think Sheila is fucking amazing, like looking at looking at her back rolls. And as well Stephanie from Afrofuturism was like, What color is Ursula now? The other characters? Little Mermaid she's white. Sheila is not she's purple. And you know, what is that purple portraying of you know, other nurse, a creature of color. And it's just yet all of the kind of marginalized identities not all of them a lot of marginalized identities are rolled up into a Sheila and she is literally this evil snickering grinning. Nasty. deranged, you know? And, and I think, you know, what, if you've got an Ursula tattoo, that better than looks so good. Like she's, I need to get some like artwork with Ursula because she's like an icon. Yes, so their comedic release a symbol, tons of villains. And so notice how in if you're watching a Disney movie, or any, any movie, any movie at all, like how are fat characters portrayed? Are they do they have a leading role and if they do have a leading role is the movie about how they are about weight? How they try not to be fat, how they are accepting their fat. It's got something to do often if there is a lead character who is fat? It's about fatness, right? It's not just like, oh, there's a human being, they will weave a fat storyline in there because you can't just be a fat person. And of course there are exceptions to this rule. It's like what what are they so, so, quote, even frozen the recent Disney blockbuster lauded for its progressive take on love, and its inclusion of a clumsy, awkward Princess character failed to break the slim waisted. Tiny told mode, Princess Anna's eyeball is even wider than her arm. Oh my God. Is that the standard we have to live by now? arms have to be thinner than our eyeballs. Sounds good. It sounds good. It sounds good. This other Tumblr board post, which is called fat media messages, A Brief History of Disney fat villains. And what this says quote dating back as early as the 1920s with Disney's earliest recurring character, Pete. So you just mentioned Pete Pete Disney has relied on tired stereotypes about size in a significant portion of its films.

These stereotypes have helped to reinforce the societal understanding of weight and the concept that thin is good and fat is evil. While not all of Disney's movies and shows rely on this trope, enough of them do that a pattern is apparent and those who look deeper into the ideas, Disney promotes and reinforces with the narratives it tells. Some of the main assumptions about fat people include the idea that they must be lazy and out of control, both of which likely contribute to contribute contribute to the fat villain trope for if one is lazy and therefore can't achieve or acquire things on their own, as well as out of control. Their accomplishments must depend on taking from or harming others, just as fat people are viewed as harmful and dangerous to the fabric of society. I really liked that last time, I'm going to repeat it for if one is lazy, and therefore can't achieve or acquire things on their own as well as out of control. Their accomplishments must depend on taking from or harming others, just as fat people are viewed as harmful and dangerous to the fabric of society. Yes. And this person lists all of the fat villains that they can think of Ursula, the Queen of Hearts Alice in Wonderland Governor Ratcliffe contents for Pocahontas Lawrence from the Princess and the Frog and Pete Mickey Mouse universe. A common traits in these characters include loudness, selfishness, greed, and unnecessary cruelty. Yeah, fat People are cruel, cruel, cruel, cruel. And if we're not if we if we if we know that kids are from the age of form forming opinions about fat people and being negative then, I mean, they're probably going to be pretty, pretty powerful if you're seeing certain people as the good guys and certain people as the bad guys. Okay, so continuing iCarly so i CARLY, I just read, listened to the book that just came out called I'm glad my mother is dead by Jeanette McCurdy, and she was Sam in iCarly. I never watched iCarly. But from that title, I was like, read that book. It's a good book. And it talks about the relationship she had with her mum, and how a mum basically abused her and taught her to have an eating disorder. And the her character on iCarly was like her shtick was that she loved food, which was ironic considering that she was not permitted to eat. And other things too. Like her mum showered her and her brother together until they were like 1718 Something like that really fucking weird. So anyway, on iCarly, the whole show is, you know, chock a block filled with fatphobia. But there is a character called Gibby. And people have said that he was a butt of fat jokes, and I watched a funniest Gibby moments thing because I wanted to see like, what what was going on with his Gibby character. And often the joke is look at him without his shirt on. And he's a kid, he's a fucking kid, like, this actor is a kid and even though he's an actor, he's not immune from the fact that this whole thing is like, okay, get the kid you take your shirt off, and everyone's like, Oh my God, there's a fucking child over there. And their body is gross. And it's yours. Yeah, and apparently he didn't come back for the reboot.

And people are like, Well, yeah, because he was treated like shit. I don't know. You know if that's true or not, but yeah, so Coco melon. So this is this the what started it for me it was we me watching Coco melanin, seeing the song Johnny Johnny. Yes, Papa. And being like, What the fuck is this and so the the idea of this, this cartoon, this this segment, not the whole cartoon is parents dad is in the in the kitchen with the lights off, sneaking around. And you can see like, there's a shadow of him sneaking around like, you know, a robber in the night. And he's eating quote, bad food. Mum comes in turns a light on catches him and he's shocked and then lies about eating the the quote bad food. And then the mum says Open your mouth. Let me see your mouth. And then the roles are reversed. The mum is that and then the dad says that so they eat. The first one is pizza, ice cream, donuts, and candy. I mean, if that's not telling you that pizza, ice cream donuts and candy are bad. And then at the end, that it culminates with the the kids catching both of them. And they say we've caught you eating quote, junk food. And then there's another version where the baby is eating sugar. I might if I saw any of these behaviors, and I know it's a cartoon, but if I saw any of these behaviors, I'm like, okay, um, I sounds like there's a lot of restriction and food shaming going on in this household. Because if you're all sneaking food in the night time, you're not getting enough food. So I mean, you need to you need to start normalizing it and pizza and ice cream and donuts and candy and sugar. Because there's a fucking baby who's coming out of his crib in the middle of the night to eat cubes of sugar. Someone called C called CBS over here. Like Johnny. He's so young can't even talk, but he's learning how to climb up into the cupboard and get some sugar. Oh my good. Another big one was Harry Potter and obviously Harry Potter. The author JK Rowling, Rowling is a human turd because of her transphobic. Her work to help her continue work to harm trans people. So someone has shed Harry's uncle and cousin are both described as fat and evil interchangeably. And so I I've never read or watched Harry Potter. She was never interested Me and so I Googled this because I wanted to learn more we have a blog from inside a.com I, I how I introduce Harry Potter to my kids as a fat minute millennial. So I know that people love Harry Potter and it's feels like it's probably like this really magical thing and how to take away the author from this from the stories and the the goodness that is Harry Potter. And also, this author is talking about how to take away the fat, the fat phobia. So this is what she's saying. After being disillusioned by Rowling's Rallings transphobic remarks, I began noticing places where Harry Potter fell short, including the books fat shaming, I have a history of an eating disorder that I'm dealing with in therapy as an adult and I want my kids to be free of diet culture. It's hard to pass on that lesson when I'm reading them as a book series where Rowling repeatedly puts down her fat characters DotEmu and Vernon Dursley are vicious bullies Rubeus Hagrid is overly emotional and dumb. Molly Weasley is controlling and over protective and I'm presuming they're all fat characters. On the very first page of the first book, Vernon is introduced as a villainous, beefy man, Hagrid, one of the good guys is later described as simply too big to be allowed because he is half giant, not a normal wizard. He's also regularly put down for his perceived lack of intelligence. In later chapters do blue. A bully who's very fat and hated exercise is pitted against small and skinny hairy. When Hagrid meets Dudley he jokes about the child not needing any more food and gives him a pig's tail on his fat bottom. Hagrid isn't remorseful about this abuse. In fact, he he meant to turn Dudley completely into a pig. Then we have Molly Weasley, who is pretty much depicted as powerful only in her capacity. As a mother. She first introduced, she's first introduced as the boy's mother, then that then more than once she's referred to as the plump woman. So yeah, so Harry Potter, another another thing that you have to be careful about. And so what this author is saying is that she will point out saying, Is it okay for Hagrid to make fun of that person? Because of their size? Even if that person is mean to them?

The answer is no. And I see that, you know, I see this playing out in adults, right? You know, the idea of we can make fun of Trump because of his size, or we can make fun of Trump because of his if he has he's an intelligent or he has some sort of mental health issue. And it's like, no, no, we can we can make fun of Trump because he is a an awful human. And the things that he says, are heinous. We don't make fun of the way he looks because we're stooping to, we're stepping to the level of others who make fun of others with the way they look. And we just don't do that. But you know, what we've learned, we've learned from kids that we do, you know, like, I used to always be like, Oh, when I was a kid, I used to always be like, well, if someone says, I'm fat, I can say, well, I can lose weight, but you can't lose. You can't lose ugly. You can't fix that face. Like and that felt so good to me that I could come back to them and say, I might be fat, but you're fucking ugly. And now I'm like, I understand why I'd say that. But I mean, this is you soon the same thing you know. But, but really like what could have young young me done at the time, but like, why are you saying that? That's where you know, you're being very, you know, that's what I did at the time, whatever. Okay, so the next one, and this is one that I remember, I remember it was really egregious and stuck with me for a very long time. And that's Wally. So someone said in my stories, Wally, essentially the world went a shit because all folks or fat folks do is eat and watch TV and are lazy. There's a slight piece that is about this, called pixels. Wally sends the wrong message about oh word and the environment. So quotes Pixar new animated feature Wally is more than a great movie. According to the critics. It's a trash ah, social commentary. New York's David Edelman Stein calls it one for the ages a masterpiece to be saved before or after the end of the world. A sublime work of art, a Oh Scott coos over a cinematic poem of such wit and beauty that its darker implications may take a while to sink in. Even New York Times columnist Frank Rich gets in on the action, lauding the film for being in touch with what troubles America and providing a gentle if gentle, if an unmistakable summons to remake the world before time runs out. So what is this powerful and profound message, Wally tells us, tells us that if we don't change the way that we live, we will all get really fat and destroy the world. The plot begins with the idea that a mega corporation called by and large has essentially taken over the planet and induced so much consumption and waste that humans must escape their dying planet on an enormous space faring cruise ship. Once on board their self destruction destructive tendencies only get worse after 700 years and drift humans have grown to rotate to walk to and too lazy to think it's this cartoon of oops commentary on modern life that so dazzles a critics. Slate Dana Stevens describes a richly detailed satire of contemporary humankind in which the world population is oh word. So fat infantile consumers who spend their days in mobile in hovering lounge chairs, staring at ads on computer screens.

In other words, American Adelstein sums up in five sum things up in five words. You should see these blobs and they're talking about depictions of fat humans. Continuing let me raise a voice of dissent. Wally is an innovative and visually stunning film but the satire in quotes it draws is simple minded. It plays off the easy analogy between fatness and ecological catastrophe, pushing the notion that Western culture has sickened both our bodies and our planet with the same disease of affluence. According to this lazy logic a fat body stands in for a distended culture. We gain weight and the earth suffers if only society could get off its big, fat ass and go on a diet. But the metaphor only works if you believe familiar myths about fatness. They're weak willed, indolent and stupid. Sure enough, that's how Pixar depicts a future of humanity. The people in Wally drink cupcakes in a cup. They never exercise. And if they happen to fall off their hovering chairs, they'll thrash around like babies until a robot helps them up. They watch TV all day long and can barely read. I mean, that is so much right that and I don't know if it's coming across to you the absolute violence of that, that sequence. I just remember I remember seeing it and I was in my in my dieting. Oh, my goodness, I've just realized that I'm like, I started like, I'm like, comforting myself. I started like hugging my arm and my face because it's so awful. It's so awful. I remember seeing that when I was deep in my dieting days and just being like, Oh my God, yes, I am so close to being that. You know, just so it's egregious. It really is. And it's, it's absolutely it's actually really really sad. It's really sad because I just what I went and what what rewatched a bit of the sequence like five minutes of it. And it's talking about don't get Don't Don't Don't put your stuff in put yourself through that if you're like, Oh, I'm gonna go watch it and you're just, I divide don't because it's really and the way that they animate these these people it's just you can see the vitriol through the animation through the way that the bodies move. You can see that they have put people in fat suits and, and and copied the way that they walk in a fat suit to make the animation look like fat people walking. I mean, ah it's fucked. It's fucked. Don't watch it. It's fucked up. I'm okay, so here's a little bit of a nicer one nicer story. Fucking Wally can suck my flopper debts. Okay, so The Very Hungry Caterpillar. So The Very Hungry Caterpillar, someone said he eats everything in sight and then becomes fat the next day he eats a single leaf and feels better. Someone else had sent me a message and they said, The Very Hungry Caterpillar, especially since Eric Carle, the author illustrator, didn't want the line about it becoming very sick after eating so much the morale moral, moral was supposed to be eat what you need to grow. But the publisher thought it sent the wrong message and forced him to include it. And it's like in every American classroom, yeah, I mean, I read it when I was a kid.

And so I found a piece about this, about what Eric said the author, so he was interviewed about his experience in 2015, with the Paris Review. And so while the message of The Very Hungry Caterpillar is about growing into the people that we dream of being Karl wanted to deliver another another message. He says, My publisher, world publishing company and I fought bitterly over the stomach ache seen in The Very Hungry Caterpillar, he revealed the caterpillar, you'll recall feasts on Cake, ice cream, salami, pie, cheese, sausage, and so on. He continued. After this banquet, I intended for him to proceed immediately to his metamorphosis, but my publisher insisted that he suffer an episode of nausea first, that some punishment follow who's supposed overeating. This disgusted me he said, honestly, it ran entirely contrary to the message of the book. Carl explained that the publishers were likely concerned about encouraging gluttony but he didn't believe that children should be concerned about such things. That caterpillar is, after all, very hungry, as sometimes we all are, Carl said he has recognized an immense appetite within him and has indulged it and the experience transform it transforms him, betters him, including the punitive stomachache ruined the effect. It compromised the book. I don't recognize childhood. Oh word he stated Pilate plainly. No one should I see children doing what they like which is eating and doing it without the shame or remorse later drilled into them by Judeo Christian ethics. Yes, Eric ha. He was straight size by the way. Ah. Let's like go out to find all the Hungry Caterpillar book books and rip out the page where the caterpillar is sick and eats a leaf and make the story the way it should have been. wouldn't have been a beautiful story if that's the way it was, but they couldn't they knew. publishers like well know what f what F children eat food to help their growing bodies just like a caterpillar needs food to transform into a butterfly. Yeah. I mean, what I read it as a kid, and I personally don't remember the him being sick. So I won't, but that doesn't mean that it wasn't in there. So I wonder if the British version didn't have that. I don't know. It'd be nice if it didn't. No, no. I just remember seeing all the illustrations of the food and just being like, Oh my God, that looks so amazing. Because I was in diet. I was in diet land at that time as a kid, Oh, bless me, and just thinking, Oh, that looks so amazing. So that's kind of cool to hear, but obviously sucks to see the outcome of that. Okay, so other ones trolls, one of the main characters, King Gristle Jr. asks a girl out and immediately goes home and hops on the treadmill. Because he wants to lose 30 pounds in the next eight hours. And this is this is seen a lot. There's a lot of cartoons where when there's a love interest, there's some type of thing happening around food either. I can't eat in front of the date. I need to lose weight before the day or I'm too fat to get a date. Like if there's a day if there's love and the fatness, even if there's not fineness is required for love. Zootopia so, we mentioned this earlier, but a little bit more about this The Sosua Zootopia is about the problems with stereotyping and prejudice while they stereotype and marginalize the fat cheetah, a police officer whose big comedic moment of glory is not is not realizing he has a doughnut lodged under his double chin and his almost exclusively shown as eating in every single scene. Because apparently the defining quality of a fat character in a kid's show is that they consume food nonstop. Hmm. Recently, there was a reboot of Snow White, I think it was made in South Korea originally, I don't know if putting them just in my brain somewhere it might have been picking out and that's a load of bullshit. But so so there was a new depiction of Snow White and I don't know if you remember but because they were calling it and the Seven Dwarfs and and we don't use the word dwarfs anymore, we use the word little people.

And what's his name from mosses name from Game of Thrones, Tyrion, and the actor's name is Peter Dinklage. He was a little person was like come on now when we still doing this and so it got got that kind of got a little bit of press. But what didn't get as much press is the advertising around it, which was basically what if there was opposed to saying what if Snow White was no longer beautiful? And what if the dwarfs were no longer short? And they showed the beautiful version, which is you know, just the same character and then the ugly version was a fat version of Snow White cocoa, so you know, double double double bigotry in that one. So we've got, you know, fatness and Dawkins talking shit about little people. So yeah, that's fun. The 2015 SpongeBob Movie Sponge Bob out of water includes a scene which to fish go on a date. In the background is a lonely fat fish whose chair breaks as he's gorging on a cheeseburger. Sounds cool. Sounds cool. Other mentions here, Fuller House. Shrek Shrek someone mentioned the Ogres are ugly and therefore fat or Gustus. gloop from Charlie in the Chocolate Factory. Yep, that has stuck with me. That is stuck with me and that song. And yeah, Bluey, which is a cartoon carbs are demonized and banned. It starts to become very body concerned. The Wiggles series two episode 48 is called Anthony has over eaten LazyTown Kung Fu Panda the plot being that he's fat and oh my god, what do you mean a fat person can be a kung fu star. Someone says it perpetuates fat phobic stereotypes, the notion that being fat is somehow somehow funny, but in my opinion, it wasn't too bad. At first, it had a it had a pass until Kung Fu Panda three went all the way. fat phobic like really really bad. Someone else says Adventures of Winnie the Pooh he gets stuck in rabbits door and refused food for days. Monster House is basically the entire plot of the film. So I went and googled, I went and watched the trailer for Monster House. It's a animated film. And I was like, Oh, I'm not seeing the fat failure in there. Is it because there's a there's a fat sidekick. And so I did some searching around and actually so there's a whole tumblr post about it. And it's really egregious, like it's it's getting into Walley territory, and you can't tell it from the trailer. Someone else's Hannah Montana, which is I think any 20 type thing like that this 100% chance is going to be fat phobia dot culture. So when I said the little blue truck, the book calls the mean dump truck, the big fat truck. Total Drama Island cartoon the VAT the fat character is the unintelligent one. The Berenstein Bears is a book about food junk food and exercise SpongeBob if they eat too many Krabby Patties they become instantly fat and then explode. And some people mentioned cartoons, which I think are more aimed at older people which is family guy in the symptoms which I mean another one that traumatized me It was the Simpsons episode where Homer get so fat, he has to wear a moo, moo. And he gets a that bird pecking bird thing to do his work for him because apparently he's so lazy because fat people are so lazy. They don't work and he gets a bird to pick the keys. And then I think the factory blows up or whatever, whatever. It's called a nuclear plant. And I mean, yeah, I Oh, oil. And there's actually a tick tock account called Maya garland and a why a GA R la nd underscore, and she talks about fatphobia, analyzing diet culture. So she talks about all of this, this type of stuff. And so she has like 50 billion different examples, because people are like, you know, show that, tell them to her and she shows them and it's like, Oh, gross.

So ending here with a little thing that Josie Blanc, shared shoot, Josie made a film called Tales of ordinary fat phobia. It's not a kid's thing. But it's a short film that you can watch. Talking about people's experience with fat phobia link in the show notes, tales of ordinary fat phobia, you can just Google it. And she talks about why this stuff is important. And so she says being reduced to a stereotype of what people see in the media is harmful. It creates bias and contributes to discrimination, especially when that there is one single, single single narrative that is portrayed over and over and over again, growing up the number of times I've heard, but you're not really black, or you're different from the other ones. Like we're just one size fits all. Spoiler alert, we're not got hiccups. We need a true diverse representation on screen. It makes the stories more authentic, which at the end creates better content. And this goes for all groups who are underrepresented black indigenous people of color, LGBTQ plus fat people and disabled people too. And with that, she shares a an image a image, quote, tweet from Rabbi Danya Ruttenberg that says we need diverse representation. Not only so every kid can see themselves as the hero of the story, but so that every kid can understand that other kinds of kids are also the heroes of the story. This is famous Coco. I can't remember who said it. You can't be who you can't see. And I think that is very true and and why it is so joyous when we do see people who look like us, portrayed in positive ways, is just so fucking amazing. Yeah, so saying that, there's end with things that do promote something a little bit better. And actually, this was really hard for me to find shows that a fat positive because there isn't, doesn't seem to be any kind of list. There's like body positive stuff. But there's not explicit fat positive stuff. We do have a list of books about body diversity. And we've got a it's like it's a good number long, it's probably 3030 30 long. But then again, I don't I'm not sure how many are explicitly about fatness. I know some of them are. And so let's go to and have a look. But this piece it says movies and TV shows that promote positive body image for kids. One of the I know I've seen my nibbling watch is seeing the movie. And it showed the characters in it. I mean, they're animals and so are they fat, but there's like an elephant and there's another quote fat animal. And so and there's no isn't there not plot points? And it just shows embrace being brave and singing. So that's one and I think that came out more recently. Okay, so let me give you some more. Oh, actually, this stuff is this is like, really? Is. Okay, so Earth to Luna age four plus, Doc McStuffins four plus, and droids Five plus exploration out of space. Terry, the tomboy scorpion and of Green Gables Spirited Away age nine plus, it's really Spirited Away. I don't know if that's a kids movie what deja age nine plus 23 blasts blast. The Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants. Real Women Have Curves age 814 Plus, I don't like the title of that Real Women Have Curves real woman have anything like fucking I hate real women anything? Fuck that.

Anyway, so, stare at there are some again, I'm going to have the link for this on the show notes. I mean, none really are explicitly fat like this, what the Real Women Have Curves America Ferrera stars in the movie, and it's about coming of age and body image. And America is actually not. She's not fat. She's chubby, you know, but still straight size, you know. And a Green Gables I think that you know, it's a straight size person. Anyway, so I think we're still we're still getting there with kidstuff. And so if you see any really good fat representation, specific, and it's not about how they're fat, and they're overcoming, it's just that they're fat. And they're cool. And oh, that movie came out recently with Disney. I can't remember the name of it. And the there's a character in it strong. Is it called strong, strong kids movie. Movie. It's called Encanto. Oh, my goodness. After for can five minutes is because it's the person is not the main character, there's as a strong woman in it. Who is I guess big. I want to say that they're fat. I think there's a whole there's a whole song as well with them being like I'm strong. And and let me give you the kind of what it is. They say people like it because of its diversity. A good songs. Plot is a Colombian teenage girl has to face a frustration of being the only member of a family without magical powers. Ah, that sounds good. I mean, if I can, if you're a parent, you probably like Yemen. Encanto came out a year ago, we've watched it 75,000 times already, on the off chance that you haven't seen it. And I haven't seen it either, right. But so I don't I can't even say that it's that positive. But I've seen people say that they appreciate that character. Which is which is nice. So go to the shownotes to find all the links for everything. So for the links are links for the book celebrating body diversity and the body positive TV show round up. And off the top of my head sing and Encanto are both movies that we can watch. And, and as well, like Take these with a pinch of salt in regards to body positive because it's probably not fat positive. And also, like, a lot of times people don't know, what is diet culture, they don't. They don't know. And so something that the the, the makers can say this is a body positive thing. Or, or and there can be, you know, diet jokes in there. And it's like, Why No, because they just they don't when people are so steeped in diet culture and fat phobia is everywhere and sometimes we don't know when something is die cultural fatphobia and so we're like, well, we're not egregious ly saying fat people are pieces of shit. But we are laughing about how big their tummies are, you know? So it's like when we're so positive. And so yeah, taken with a pinch of salt. And I think the thing is with, with all of this stuff, it's inevitable that kids all of us are going to be exposed to messages about what body should look like and the fact that fat is bad. And I think what we what we can do to overcome those things is having conversations around this stuff and instilling core values within our our communities. That says that that's not okay so that when younger people do see those messages, they've got that counter message from you. That's consistent in their life because No, that can't be like a one time conversation because I'm telling you that culture and fatphobia are after our brains. And they don't stop at kids, right? And they're going to be there every single day. And so we need to be spreading these values to our communities, our young people as much as possible and talking about it and, and living those values of not judging others for the way that they look and having food freedom mindset and all that type of jazz. So, all right, so again, the shownotes you can find at first fatty.com forward slash 137 and I will see you on the next episode. Have a wonderful rest of your day. Goodbye, fatty. Stay fearless. I'll see you later in a while. The bye.

EP136 Transcript

You're listening to the Fierce Fatty Podcast episode 136. Hypnotic Gastric Band and Herbs up your Vag to lose weight. What? Let's do it.

Welcome to the episode I just got a text through from some Indian friend of the show that she says that she shuts us off all day long. She's that's probably not true. She's probably she's probably joking. Who knows. So today we're talking about the wild shit. I have seen advertised late lately in regards to weight loss. One of my friends who lives in Australia has sends me things that she sees that she thinks that I would like or you would like and her and she's right, because the stuff you sent sends me is. It's primo free, primo ridiculous gone dent. So because I'm going to be talking about diets, if you are thinking it could be triggering in regards to hearing what's inside the diet. I'm not going to talk about any numbers or weights or anything like that. But I'm going to be talking about the products. They're all bullshit. I mean, every diet is bullshit anyway, but there's I'm not advertising them. I'm just talking about how ding dong delicious they are as in the people who were selling them a ding dongs. That is not ding dong as in good ding dong as in bad. Yeah. So when we talk about that, before I do, I've got I had something on my mind. And I just want you to talk about it. And and the reason why I want you to do kind of a light, more light hearted episode is that I have not been feeling a light hearted in the last week, I'm going to be talking about transphobia for the next 510 minutes. So if you don't want to hear about transphobia suicidal thoughts, a very brief mention of that. Yeah, then yes, go ahead, like 510 minutes. So yeah, so I'm trans non binary, as you know, or maybe you don't know, maybe you're new to the show. I am non binary. And trans gender means someone who does not align with the gender that they were assigned at birth, I was assigned female at birth, I am not a female, I am non binary. And so I am a trans non binary. Many people have different labels and different ways that they identify. And that's just how I identify as this is something that I have been working through for the last couple of years now. And unlearning fatphobia and weight bias and all the bullshit around femininity. And fatness has really helped me understand who I am in my gender. And the response from first fatty the first fatty community, it has been beautiful and affirming and wonderful, and so respectful. And you might not realize when I see you talking about me, typing about me not talking, it's not like, I'm going around, I'm following around the streets. I mean, like a user, what he's saying or how I say if I, if the page is flat, he gets tagged somewhere, or someone recommends me and, and someone correctly genders me, that always happens when people are tagging me, it just feels so nice. I just want you to know that that I might not always respond, because you might just be telling your friend, oh, hey, go check out face for a podcast or whatever. And then you say they agree. And I'm just like, Ah, thank you so much. Just to be correctly gendered is beautiful. And so that, you know, obviously, not all of the response has been positive, but from the face value community. That was that was a couple of couple of people who were like, I'm gonna unfollow you now, but that means they're very in the minority. And so I've I've been very lucky that I've been shielded from a lot of shit and also because of the gobs of privilege that I have in regards to appearing cysts, and so cisgender so when I walk through the streets, people don't think oh, that's a trans person. And then I don't experience marginalization due to people's perceptions. Have me, that's a whole different story in regards to how I want them to perceive me, I don't want them to perceive me as a woman. But I also want to dress the way that I want to dress which happens to align with a lot of feminine things what we as society has deemed feminine, it's fucking complicated. Anyway, because of that, I've got lots of privilege, right? Also, I have other privileges. Big one being white,

British, I am not physically disabled in regards to I don't use any member mobility aids. I lower middle class, I guess. Anyway, so I've got lots of privilege, I've got lots of privilege. And so I don't experience transphobia in the same way as say someone who is a trans woman who happens to also be black, for example, who also happens to be disabled, who also happens to be etcetera, etcetera, right. So I just want to point that out that I'm so lucky in regards to that. But also, that doesn't mean that I'm immune from experiencing transphobia in the last week or two, in the last couple of months, like, last three months or whatever. I've seen it and oh, sad face. So in the community that I live in, it is a queer community. It's amazing. I love it. And there's a guy down the road who is the caretaker of the church, the church isn't a queer friendly Church. The caretaker is actually not religious himself, but because I have Dougal the dog, the cute little baby puppy is another puppy. He's nine. Because I'm Dougal, I walk around the streets. And I talked to a lot of people who also have dogs, and he happens to be one of the people that I have talked to for the last 18 months. And he's a I what I presume is like an older guy, like maybe 65, maybe? I don't know, but he's kind of like a rocker. And he's cool. And I've enjoyed talking to him. And so I had, I think it's about couple of months now, a couple of months ago, I saw him and he was like, oh, have you heard about the new JK Rowling book? Or is it rolling? I don't know. I don't care to correctly pronounce her name. JK Rowling is a raging transphobic has said some done some awfully transphobic stuff. And she has penned a new book. The pseudonym she's used is a Robert Galbraith in the book is about a man dressing up as a woman to go into women's toilets to attack women. Now, that is a big deal. What is the word? trope? Is it a trope? Is it a it's a fear that trans folks have and people who are just learning about trans people is that trans people want to be trans so that they can fake being a woman, you know, in quotation marks so that they can be predators against women. And that's just not true, right? There's not true there's, there's no there's no issue with trans people going into toilets and assaulting, quote, real women. The opposite you know, the other way around is trans women, a very marginalized and vulnerable to attacks and murders and all that type of, of jazz. And actually really what people are scared about in that instance is not trans people. It's sis men, pretending to be women. So really, what they're scared of assessment. I know. So he's going on about Robert Robert Galbraith, this this book, which is JK Rowling. And I was like, yeah, it's not great, you know, and you're saying how, you know, his daughter is taught, told him about how all of these trans women are trying to have sex with her and she's like, I don't want to have sex with you go away and all this type of stuff and is his daughter's a lesbian, and saying how that they're, you know, forcing, they're forcing women to have sex with them. And as I think that that is what is going on. That is not what's that that's that's sexual assault, right? People are doing that, then that's wrong, but that is not the, quote, trans agenda to force people to have sex with someone against their will. That's how long a time So that's what people think about fat folks, too, is that if a fat person says, Oh, well I'm you know, when you're in school, a fat person is Oh, I really fancy this this boy, everyone's like, it's so weird. Oh, look, she's a stalker, because she fancies Johnny or whatever. But if a thin person says, Oh, my fancy Johnny, then people like, you know, or the idea that we want fat rights, because we want people to be forced to fuck us. It's not Oh, he doesn't want to be treated like a human being. It's so strange. It's really, really weird.

And it's common rhetoric with with retrans stuff, too. Anyway, he started going on blah, blah, blah. And I was just like, You know what, I think people should just be kind, and I didn't sound like that's where I kind of, you know, and eventually, he was going on about it on going on. And I was like, Hey, did you know that actually, I'm trans non binary. And he was like, taken aback, I don't remember what he said exactly. But the gist of what he said was, well, you're not like those trans people. Whatever those mean, and, and then I said, Listen, I'm gonna go Celada, baby. And he said, as I was walking away, the whole reason why this sparked was because I said, I need to go, that whole conversation started because I said, I need to go. I'm going to diversity presentation that I'm presenting to a company this morning. And he said, Oh, diversity, trans people, you need to hear my rant. And I was because I was literally like, oh, I need to go. And then he spoke at me for like, five to seven minutes. And, and then anyway, so when I was leaving, he was like, oh, have you heard of Ricky Gervais? His new comedy special? And I just said, yeah, he's a piece of shit. So I have avoided that walking that route, which is the main route, I would normally walk with Google for the last two months. And I saw him in the street and I went the other way, the long way round. And because it feels like here's this guy, and he also said shit about gay men. He was saying, aren't gay men around here, they just have sex in the streets. And I was like, Ah, wait, I live here too. And I have never once seen someone getting sucked off or people having sex industry and what and anyway, we're, we're like a block away from a few nightclubs. If we were in nightclubs. And it was nightclubs where there were straight people. I have seen straight before fucking I have seen men getting the decks by women, like in club districts, you just expect that right? And so if that has obviously that's happened around here that the guys are getting blowers in bushes, or whatever the same way is it happened in St. predominant straight areas. And he seemed to be have a problem with this anyway. So I had that and I was like, a hawk sake. And then a couple of weekends ago, I went away to a singing retreat with my singing group, and there was a lot of misgendering happening of me a lot of we're all women here and that song sing songs about being women. And, and that was really difficult for me, because I kept saying, Oh, hey, actually, oh, another woman? Can you include me, please? And I just gave up and at the end of it, I really had a tough time with it, actually, because it just felt really kind of like I was asking way too much for people to say, you know, say women or say women and other genders, or just to say, everybody, you know. And so I was just feeling really kind of a big theme of my life is you taking up too much space, you're being a troublemaker, you're asking too much. That's what I talk about in therapy all the time is that I am asking for too much by people correctly gendering me, which, FYI, I'm not. It's a really basic thing. Yeah, so I had all that type of stuff in my in my mind and then this weekend, Saturday afternoon.

I've spoken about this person on the podcast before. I'm not gonna say their name again. But it is someone who is very famous in the anti diet space, who has in the last couple of years or year I'm not sure about the timing, but certainly in the last year has turned their back on forward thinking, generous kindness. You left leaning ideologies and has turned into what looks like into a right wing conspiracy theory theorist She's thin and white, which is important to note. Straight cisgender all that type of stuff. Yes. So from time to time, I'll be like, Oh, what are they up to right now just being a bit nosy. What stuff has she said right now and I sat down, I was like, I'm gonna have a look. Big fucking mistake. So I went and had a look at her profile. And she has complained about posts of hers getting banned and, and Instagram, taking them down and stuff. And so I was like, what she said, what she said, so deeply affected me. And I had this ground, there's less ground work of this trans stuff. And other other other stuff had been going on to like other little, you know, other things like people misgendering me in my life. And anyway, so I looked at her posts, and I saved highlights, she asked her audience a question, what are your most controversial views. And people shared their most controversial views, and she shared them on her stories, and then saved the stories to highlights. And the idea behind this was that you're a big, you're a big person, you're in charge of your feelings. And if this upsets you, and if this offends you, it's got nothing to do with the person sharing the opinions, or the opinion, it's got to do with you and not being able to manage your emotions correctly. Which I think is a very unkind position to take. And, you know, because it's not like, we go around the world being like, Hey, you're a piece of shit, I hate your hairstyle. Oh, my God, you're really ugly. And then people say, hey, that hurt my feelings. And then you say, I don't give a shit, you should be big enough to be able to not be offended by that. And so she shared some really heinous things. For the things, we're anti trans sentiments, so this is our audience sharing. And I'm one of the trans things. She says, Yeah, I agree. I'm not gonna repeat the anti trans things, because, you know, we've had, we've had so much of any trans people listening. Anyone listening, we don't need to hear that stuff again. So I'm not going to share them. But if you're nosy you can try and guess who this person is and go and look at their save stories. And so I looked at them and I was just gobsmacked. Literally, I my jaw was like, my mouth opened my mouth was a gate, but like, I cannot believe she is sharing these and other egregious opinions harmful. And it made me think about you know, like, it maybe, you know, I sitting there thinking, What about her point of view of wow, you should just get over it. And I was walking, you know, I'd sat with it and just, you know, just just contemplating things and then eventually in the evening, I went down and walked away for his nighttime walking in the elevator downstairs, I had this feeling of you should just give up. You should just die in my brain me. And I had suicidal ideation flashed in front of me, which I think is quite a normal thing for a lot of people and it's something that I've experienced many times in my life and other times it's been a lot more difficult for me and and I've struggled with with

Yeah, thinking about suicide. And again, I think it's a pretty normal thing that we have those sorts and that I should just give up. Like, I should just stop asking people to correctly gender me I should stop asking I should just just stop being me being alive because clearly, in this community, this community of where I physically live, there's there's turfs, turfs is trans, exclusionary, exclusionary radical feminists, there are turfs lurking in places that I thought was safe, who else in my neighborhood thinks that my identity is not valid and thinks that I'm whatever for having my identity? In places where I find joy in my singing group, I am not being met with the level of acceptance that human beings need And then in places which are anti diet, which I knew, like, I knew go into this page, I'd see some shit. But it kind of just felt like, everywhere that I, you know, had everywhere that I am have community. It's like the secret opinions, like people on the surface are like, Oh yeah, trans it's fine, whatever. non binary Yeah, we love it. But then secretly they're like, not actually, if I get the chance to, you know, share my real opinions, I will two people who I think are cis, or people who people who ask this, and it feels so exhausting, so exhausting that it. Most places that I turn, my identity is not being validated. And not all places, there's lots of places that you know, like, I'm, I've recently got a new therapist, I've had one session with them, and they are trans non binary, cannot wait to continue with them. And I told her this, you know, this story about the guy and and, and the, the response was so affirming of being like, yeah, oh, my God. I got it. And it was great, right? So, so I was thinking about this. And then and then I'm just like, was really sad. And then I called a friend, the same friend who's in Australia. And was like, I cried, and I cried, this is the first time in my whole life I've ever called up a friend and cried, I cried to her. And I was like, everyone, you know, there's just transphobia is everywhere. It's just really sad. I feel I don't feel my normal self, my normal, fierce, fatty self, can you give me a bit of a pep talk, she gave me a pep talk, I watched the documentary about non binary kids from Australia that she shared with me, I'll put it in the show notes, in case you're interested. And I felt a lot better. And so I am so lucky. I have the support system, I have a trans therapist, I have family who are working to understand who I am, I have friends who deeply loves me. And who can take my call at 11:30pm at night, where I'm crying, and I say pump me up. And they say, right, I'm right to it. And so I was thinking about this idea of her saying, Well, tough shit, you should just deal with it. Because everyone has different views. And if you can't hack it, then that's, that's a huge problem. And I was thinking, you know, after I got, I got back to my normal, first fatty, non binary ban ourself, I was talking about this. And I was like, You know what, no, sharing those egregious views, normalizes those views, and empowers others who also have those views in secret to say, Oh, this is normal for us to have these views, which are filled based in misinformation and hate. And it directly hurts marginalized communities. it legitimizes those false beliefs, when I say it directly hurts those marginalized communities. Here I am, as an example, as someone who I think that I'm a very strong, resilient person, I have got a ton of privilege that I'm able to be that type of person, and a lot of genetic privileges in my brain to be that person. And not everyone has those things, same things. And it still hurt me to see those few words on a screen of anonymous strangers, being shared by someone who I once respected, and trusted, and it hurt me. And I was able to stop that suicide ideation pretty quickly. And, and reach out for help. In the past, I have struggled with that. And it's only because I've had years of therapy, and other privileges that I hold that I was able to get back past that. And that is not the case for every body.

Trans people. The average age, life expectancy for a trans person is 35 years. 35 years old, is the average life expectancy for a trans person. For sis folks, it's 70 to 80 years old, and the reason why trans folks die so young is because of transphobia is because of high suicide rates because we are not welcome. It's because of all of the negative health impacts that we see from bias is because trans women and trans men and gender non conforming people are murdered beat when they present in public in a way that is authentic to them. And so, sharing these beliefs is dangerous. Normalizing those beliefs is dangerous and legitimizing those beliefs which are based in false science, because people were talking about science stuff, and I was like, No, that's not true. And I'm, I'm not an expert on on, you know, free speech and, and philosophy and all that type of stuff. But I know someone who is, and I really urge you to go and watch their videos. Abigail Thorne is known as philosophy, philosophy tube on YouTube. And her videos are amazing. I'm going to link you to one I watched recently, which is the philosophy of Antifa. So Anti Fascist, so Anti Fascist people who don't like Nazis and all that type of stuff. And talking about that, and talking about, you know, the media positions, the right wing media positions, Anti Fascist says, like, quote, just as bad as fascists, and Abigail breaks all of this down. Now. Abigail is a trans woman, this video was filmed in 2017, before she had transitioned, so when you click on the link, just be prepared to see Abigail before transition, just a heads up there. But a really, really great video. And what Abigail was talking about was the idea that right wing ideologies always lead to violence. So if trans women are not women, and that belief is happily shared by folks, then that's a erasure of identity and and what happens when we seek to erase people, what has happened before, when society has said, These people are not welcome in regards to right wing fascists, we know what has happened. And of course, there is violence on the left, but the difference is that the left would attack people who are actively engaging in anti social fascist behavior, whereas the right will attack everyone who doesn't align with our worldviews. Do you think about terrorism in the United States, from young, white Christian boys, men, and who they attack great swaths of people who have never done anything to them. But they're supposedly ideologies are not aligned with the right wing thinking. So they all need to be exterminated. So the left will use targeted violence and the right indiscriminate violence. And there's violence in all political ideologies, but it's different. Um, Abigail also talks about appeasement and how, you know, the idea of let's just, let's just let them have this weird, just let's just not make a bit. It's not a big deal. If someone shares transphobic stuff, you know, let's just let them do that.

Let's just share their views with their Instagram audience with 100k followers. It's not hurting anyone. The thing is, as I mentioned before, trans people's average lifespan is 35 years. And trans folks, especially trans women and trans black indigenous people of color, and other marginalized trans folks have a higher risk, higher risk of dying young, due to transphobia suicide murder. And so we have a group of marginalized people and and everything intersectionality intersectionally, all of the different people within those communities how they can or have other marginalization. And so if we are sharing messages about people who are already marginalized, we're going to further marginalize them. So what does sharing anti trans rhetoric does? Do? What does it do? Does it help marginalize people? does it harm them? And we have free speech, right? We have free speech, but we cannot have free speech with also without consequence. So the consequence might be against someone that is not intended. And so this consequence of our free speech here, of this person sharing with her Instagram following is the consequence is, I am harmed. The consequence is I am telling you about it and maybe you might be harmed as well, maybe you might not, you know, who knows the consequences. People might say to this person, we don't like what you're saying, and she might lose followers. By the way, she claims to be canceled. She hasn't lost followers. Or I think like there was an episode that talked about it, and it was kind of like something like 100 followers out of 100 and plus 1000s Like When was nothing, right? So we cannot expect to be able to incite hate or incite violence. And I'm not saying that this person has. But we cannot expect to be able to incite violence or hate without seeing the consequences of that, and the consequences could be for the person speaking those things. And more likely it's going to be for the person for the groups of marginalized individual individuals who are on the end of that hate speech. And hate speech is protected. In the United States. There's no legal ramifications to hate speech unless it directly incites imminent criminal activity, and consists of specific threats of violence targeted against a person or group. And so when you hear about like, oh, censorship, censorship, people can say, pretty much anything they want. They can but there may be consequences is very rare, because as we know, the victims of crime, the victims of hate speech are victims of any type of harm. rarely get to see justice. And you know, talking about justice in the prison system, all that type of stuff is a totally different topic, but people are able to cause harm and get away. scot free. Yeah, so anyway, I just wanted to talk about that and kind of talk about me, because it's just been really bothering me. And on the flip side, when I hear affirming things, it's so fucking wonderful. It really is. It's so it just feels so like people care about me, you know, and I know people care about me, and, and I'm struggling with this stuff right now, because it just happens to be a lot of things converging at the same time. And it's made me think, and luckily, but you know, because of my privilege, I've not had to go deep in and think about this stuff before. Now, other people don't have the same privilege that I do, and having to deal with huge things constantly. And I'm not saying that this is also not huge in my mental health, but you know, just saying that some people, their experiences are different. So, okay, so that was way longer than 510 minutes. I wanted to talk about that, because and then I said, Oh, because I want this episode to be a little bit like more more lighthearted. Because I've been thinking about all that deep shit. So I feel a little bit better now telling you all that stuff. Don't worry about me, don't think that I'm, I'm, I might die or anything, because I am really lucky to have people who I trust around me. And I'm okay. Okay. So when that's why I can I can talk about it, right.

And if you're feeling any of those things, please reach out to people in your life and talk about it. And if you can get into seeing a therapist, and there's a lot of places that offer three free therapy, especially if you are a member of the Two Spirit LGBTQIA plus community. So and there's also free resources on Googly, Googly do glued or Google to do Google giggling. So anyway, my friend has shared some things with me and I want to share them with you and we've got some other things. Ridiculous diet bullshit. So let's talk a bout it so the first thing that we're gonna be talking about is these things called Yoni pearls. So Yoni is a different word for a vampire Jiang you know, maybe it means also vulva. Who knows? Actually, I don't need to say who knows I can just work in Google. Yoni. Yoni, Yoni yoni. Yoni is a Sanskrit word that has been interpreted to literally mean the womb. Oh, there we go. So it's neither of those things. The source and the female organs of generation. It also connotates a female sexual organs such as vagina, vulva, and uterus, and there we go have a little bit of light transphobia their female sexual organs um, men can have vaginas Volvos in the uterus is too as can gender non conforming non binary people. See how it's everywhere. It's everywhere. Anyway, so Yoni Javad so you only pearls helps you. This is the advert we've got on the Facebook's How To Detoxify Your Body. From all the impurities get in shape in three to six weeks. And so now I want to describe what this this thing is. Do you remember when we were kids, I don't know, I'm talking about my childhood like it was your childhood. But in my childhood, we had these things that were like little explosions wrapped in paper. And they came in something that looked like kind of like a matchstick or a paper box, and you'd throw them on the floor, and they'd go crack. So imagine something like that. But instead of a piece of paper wrapped around, dynamite type stuff, it is a piece of rag, it looks like hesi and SAC, so really rough, nasty looking material. And then a ball of brown in it. In the ball of brown are herbs and spices that include ginger, and black pepper. alongside other things, which are herbs, I'm not used to all stale extract, don't know what that is. But I mean, I know we're not an idea is you shove them up your badge, right? The instruction candidate like it's like it's inserting a tampon. I do not want to be putting black pepper and ginger up my badge. No, thank you. That's the premise. And you can get seven pearls or seven years of these little rags filled with spice. For 1997 you meant to wear one every day minimum. And they claim after four weeks visible body read the body detox results. 99.6% Lose pound. I mean, I don't know if they're selling this in UK pounds. But 99.9 100% of people lose a pound many pounds when they buy this product because they're going to be losing their money. And I didn't know and it's got an electric bass in our study of 2000 plus volunteers after six weeks of use hang on they said four weeks of this now it says six weeks. Where's where's the link to the study? Oh, it doesn't exist 96.7% Minus body toxins 98% Minus gynecological issues.

Oh my god cancel that appointment for your next pap. Just stick these spicy rags up your Vij because they're gonna cure 98% of gynecological diseases and increase 97% 97.8% of blood circulation 100% hair CO and big and bold on this 100% tightens your Yoni Thank fuck we've got a solution that's quick and easy to tighten your Yoni sticking these dirty rags up there. Because the next claim is 100% natural ingredients well natural doesn't mean that is gonna be any good. Prep of the match doesn't sound fun. After six weeks all user saw amazing results in terms of body detox and treatment of gynecological issues. And the sales page is beautiful. They show some before and after pics, you've got the normal before and after. If someone who is in the gym, sports bra. looking miserable. Someone who is half a size donor is the same person looking happy and smaller. Another person who has had a facelift apparently, Yoni rag, spice, brags will make you have a facelift. And then we have a stock image of a smiling person in a white coat, smiling person in a white coat. Then there's an image of hair follicles and what the fuck hairs got anything to do with it. And then an image of image showing how your liver detoxes you, so you don't need herb rags, because you have a liver, the detoxes you, then there's a picture of a swollen ankle and an after picture of an ankle that is not swollen. And if you've got any more questions about that they have an FAQ. And so FAQ reads, is it safe? Will it cause infection? Answer. It's ingredients are all derived from plants and it is inherently sterilizing, because that's what you want it to be advantage is sterilization. You want to put some chemicals up there to sterilize it, whether they're plant based or not. I want to sterilized verge plays, sterilizing cleansing and detoxifying it's very safe and it won't cause infection and we are certified by the US Department of Health I push it how often is it used every time use one pile and leave it in for 15 to 20 minutes and then take it out use daily for three to six weeks. How long does it take to get in shape usually keep using it for three to six weeks you will get good shape based on the analysis of 2000 consumers it also can eliminate toxins and resolves any pain and discomfort for all of Yoni if I stopped using my shape will back to will I go back to being as fat as let me read that again. If I stop using my shape will back to will I go back to being as fat as when you go back to being as fat as when you use this product to get in better shape your body can stay in shape for a long time even if you don't use it. Oh my god. It's a miracle cure Ah, thank God it's finally arrived away to fix all gynecologic No No What is it 98 98% of gynecological issues and not be as fat as a flat as I don't know as who as what I don't know the answer but we have got all of the wonderful things happening with these Yoni singing jigs. One of the reviews was one of the reviews that made the reviews all written by the same person who's written this this copy let me scroll in the past a little bit before and afters a fake FDA certificate and the Oh they're so disgusting.

The reviews obviously we've got 18 Five stars one four star and of course no three two and one stars of course Costco because they always Disgust is disgusting okay don't don't don't even look at don't stop looking. Don't look at this page. I'm not gonna give you the link of it anyway but they're showing pictures of like, I don't even describe it not that I'm not getting disgusted by pictures of verges or anything. It's nothing like that. It's just they're putting in they're claiming it detoxifies, right? I can't even open my eyes to look at this thing the claiming it detoxifies and so they're putting stuff that you think that you might get from detoxifying uni knees on images and it's just I'm not going to describe it. It's not what happens they've made it fake pictures basically but it's looks so disgusting. Someone get has given it five stars from America. Allegedly. My Yoni has always been loose. My husband doesn't like me. For this. It helps me tighten my Yoni my husband is very happy now. Thanks. Amazing my husband too doesn't like me because of my loose yoni. So you and I have got that in common. Not really, I don't have a husband, but I'm sure he would love my youth loose. Yoni if I did. Okay, so the next one we have is a hypnotic I feel just so much better not looking at those pictures. They are fucked up. They were fucked up. They're disgusting. Anyway, so hypnotic gastric band program. So you know I had a few episodes about stomach amputation stomach squeezing surgery. And now we have a solution. That is sarcasm by the way. You don't even need to do it anymore because you can buy a hypnotic gastric gastric band program for regular price 204 But just today only if you go on the website any other day, you will not get this this price. Again, sarcasm sale price to date 79. Doll hairs. So this is what it's saying surgery of any kind is not to be taken lightly. Yes, that is right. But what if there was a way to achieve similar results without the need for actual surgery? Tell me more. The good news is that hypnosis can help you make these changes using the power of your mind. Our gastric band hypnosis audio program saves you from the uncomfortable and potentially dangerous side effects of gastric bypass surgery or hypnotic back gastric band downloads have been designed to give you all the benefits without any of the dangers. All you need to do for hypnotherapy to work is give yourself a quiet space where you can avoid distractions. 90% of our clients have said that our audio therapies have changed in their lives, and they would recommend or share them with a friend. Oh my goodness. And so this is a claim that they're making lose weight with virtual gastric band therapy. So this is not even in person. This is some audio tracks of someone being like, you're really thin now, you've had actually, you know what they've got, they've got it. Pre surgery, during the surgery, post surgery and recovery from the surgery. And so they like, you're going into surgery, now, your stomach has been removed from your body and it's in the bin. I don't know what they're saying. Because obviously, I've not bought that in listen to it. But you know, that's the type of thing. So lose weight with virtual gastric band therapy success rate is a whopping 95%. And they've got a little one next with 95%, which tells me there's a study attached to this. Yay. Can't wait to see what that is. Turns out that one leads nowhere. There is no study link to that whole thing. 95% success rate. No long hospital waiting lists. That's correct. cost a fraction of the surgery price that is true. And no Pope no post surgery, side effects hang on a minute. This is meant to make me believe that I really have had the surgery. So why am I not also having the side effects? If I really believe that I've had the surgery, shouldn't they come with side effects do they've got a big they've got a big thing here saying diets don't work. See how I've mentioned before how diet companies are taking anti diet sentiments and sticking it in there things and so people get confused. If I had read this sales page 10 years ago, I would have probably bought this thing.

I'm telling you, I know it sounds silly. I would have I would have been like, fuck, it is only whatever it was less than 100 bucks. Maybe because I know it's I know the reason that I'm fat is because something's wrong with my brain. That was my thinking. The reason I'm fat is that I've got a mental health issue. And fatness is the result of you know, because of that mental health issue if I am a positive thinker. In fact, I did do hypnotherapy as I've discussed in other episodes, obviously it did nothing apart from heighten my eating disorder thoughts. Oh yeah. So I'm sure that this will help you with any eating disorder thoughts that you have and make them worse for you. So continuing they say by using the virtual gastric band you are convinced that you have undergone gastric band surgery thereby enabling you to eat smaller portions and have your hunger satisfied earlier I wonder how the power of positive thought can stop chemicals from from your body from your brain swirling around telling you that you're you need to eat food to survive. Like how how is that possible? The gastric band part of the process is a mechanism that helps you believe that your stomach is smaller with less capacity for food. This is why self hypnosis is the ideal tool to help you become a healthier person or once of once and for all they introduce you to the therapists and these images of the therapists seemed a little bit too good. So I did a little bit of a Google reverse image search and yes you're right they are both stock images. They are not real therapists and this program seems to be quite legit in regards to it has many 1000 reviews on Trustpilot it has a Facebook page presumably it's got people buying it Who the fuck knows right? So I had a little look at the reviews looks like the negative reviews are quickly deleted because the negative reviews are the ones that were one from an hour ago one from three hours ago. First one gives it two stars out of five and it says I bought for on offer however I was blind It was blatantly obvious obvious at the start of the hypnosis is all the same. And then subject matter was added after the sound quality was markedly different. I did not feel hypnotized at any point. Yes, because you're just listening to someone go you're no longer fat Lulu. This review a very poor effort all round is the title of this review. For God's sake don't waste your money time or endeavor. Sound quality is dreadful as is the editing as for the copy and pasted generic film Flim Flam waffle. Crikey this is So Patrick Hayes saying what the fuck is Flim Flam waffle? Flam waffle? Flim Flam waffle. Anyway, this sounds like a British or Australian person wrote this, because crikey is very Australian but waffle is very British. Anyway, the guy's voice is irritating at the best of times and it becomes even more aggravating when he ends his sentences abruptly due to diabolical audio production, another case of money grabbing and offering a poor service in return. God knows how many emails I have had suggesting I part with more and more cash for their pathetic products and yet none to explain the poor quality of the original purchase. The only thing clear here is this is a money grubbing calm that is not worth 29 Pence, nevermind. 29 pounds subjected to clear drivel is not a clear mind. Can't wait for the generic sorry, you feel this way and contact us via email so we can help response. I roll emoji. They didn't give that response. Not responded at all. So by the way, in case it's not clear, this thing doesn't work. It doesn't work. Okay. None of that. No, no anything I'm talking about today. Just a reminder, none of this works. If you think oh my goodness. Actually. I've been convinced. Please. Don't. You literally like this man says it's not worth 29 pence. Nevermind. 29 pounds. Next one is a Facebook ad which which reads, I pooped my way to my goal. Weight. I pooped my way to my goal. Weight. I really disliked the word pooped. I just like saying poo or shit. pooped just doesn't feel right in my mouth. I was not brought up on the word pooped. You know what word I was brought up on which I do not use anymore but I wish I did. Is jabi it's such so my mom is Irish, right? So I think it's an Irish. Scottish word. Did you do a job B? I did a job

Oh, still feeling sick about those Yoni Yoni pearls? The yummy pearls the fact that they call them pearls when they're nasty rough rags, pearls you like I could put a pile up my Yoni but they wouldn't so nasty. Anyway, so I pooped my goat and I get I pooped my gut, and I put my way to my goal or Wait, someone left a comment saying, if you've ever had Giardia you know how that diet works. Giardia is like Hatch had had to gute can't do go tested for Giardia recently because he had terrible diarrhea from swimming after swimming in a lake does not a lake a river doesn't always happen. Sometimes the river is a little bit more dirty than normal. And he didn't have it. He just had bacteria. Anyway, they show pictures. It's a video of two people who I perceive as women who are taking pills inside the pills, fennel seed, Milk Thistle and some other herbs, which presumably make you shit yourself. That doesn't work, you know the same way as the shit your tea detox teas things, you know? It? No, just just n o. But you know. I mean, it's fun to imagine shitting your way to your goal weight. Unfortunately, it's not a legitimate method. Some other things here that, that I found the magnetic diet. So this is all about the laws of attraction. But the creator of the diet claims to understand which foods attract health and disease into the body. So he advises dieters to only eat invigorating magnetism foods and avoid contaminating magnetism foods. You know, these are just things that he's made up right. So apparently you're going to eat something that is invigorating magnetism, and that is going to draw like a magnet to your body. Fineness and health, magic or magic. The haich C G diet involves being injected with the hormone human Shuri on IC o chorionic goner, dough trophic in which in which the body naturally produces while pregnant plans. While the shots themselves are technically legal, if administered by a healthcare professional follows of this diet also encouraged to take HCG Drops pellets and sprays, all of wick which are illegal according to the FDA fine blood type, the blood type of diet, so a naturopathic physician says that you should eat foods according to your blood type. Bullshit, the tapeworm diet does what it says on the tin, eat tapeworm eggs and have them eat your food. And then presumably have to go to hospital to have them removed. And then one that I spoke about in an episode with a friend of the show some n and n was the constant glucose monitoring. So I saw an ad of people putting this patch on their arm and wincing, and I thought what the fuck is that and so I looked into it, and it was a tool that diabetes patients you use, and it monitors their glucose levels and alerts them gives them the right amount of glucose so that they don't die diet culture has said oh, great, a tool that we can steal to use to try and get people thin. Basically, this tells you hey, you know, go out to eat now and hey, you need to go and do some exercise now. And hey, it's bullshit. It costs 175 for a two week program or $350 a month. So it's a nice inexpensive app and someone left a comment on the on the Facebook ad saying, You know what else helps people to lose weight? chemo, maybe humans should start selling that to Great point.

What else helps people you lose weight? Death? Have you tried the death diet is definitely gonna make you lose weight and become get the ideal Beachbody? Are you ready boys my dead body is going to be so she continues in the dominant comment the diet industry is out of control. Why? Because people are obsessed with the size of their bodies as a type one diabetic Betech I wish I had a healthy enough body to be able to live without the use of one of these things. If you are a person or the person being depicted in one of these advertisements, and you are contemplating this equipment, I seriously recommend you consider speaking to a coach or a therapist about your self image. You do not need to get skinnier, more toned, more fit, you need to learn how to love your child. Yes, and hey, here's a little tidbit of information that if you're diagnosed with pre diabetes, there is only a 2% chance that you will go on to have diabetes according to the CDC pre diabetes is a made up condition Yes, so fun times fun times. But the big thing here with all of these, quote fad diets is that they are no different from any other diet out there in regards to the fact that they don't work. They're taking your money and they are then being like Yes. Oh, it didn't work. Did you try this other product? Did you try the one not the Yoni not the not the Yoni rags up your bum up Javad yourself you bomb try the Yoni bomb rags now. Oh, you hypnotize? Oh, no, it's not going to be hypnotises it's meant to be that you're asleep. Oh, you know, oh, you pooped your way to losing weight actually is meant to be you paste your way. You paste your way to your goal weight. They're always moving, moving the goalposts. It doesn't work. Obviously, these are funny and ridiculous. And hopefully we're able to say, Oh my God, these are so silly. Of course, I'm not going to waste my money. But they are no different from Weight Watchers from neum. from anything else.

The only difference is those products have better marketing and have claims that we think are based in science, especially something like new where people are like, Oh, it's all about what is it? What is it? It's all about, like mental health and stuff. It's not. It's tech bros. who've made that made that app and it's not based in evidence. It is not based on evidence. It doesn't work with me This is what I've got to say. Here's what I've got to say. So round up a round of of everything, the newest, most ridiculous ways that we're being told to lose weight. The first one is the Yoni pearls, which are actually pieces of rag with herbs and spices in their herbs being herbs and spices being ginger, and black pepper, among other things, which is gonna be great, and is apparently meant to make you detox and also become not fat, and also cure 98.7% of your gynecological issues. It doesn't do any of those things. Another one that we've seen recently is the gastric band program done by hypnosis. And so this is hypnotizing people over an audio track, which is terrible quality, and making them believe that they have had gastric band surgery claims to have a success rate of 95% links to a study, but there's no study there. Another one is using herbs to shit yourself. So the product is I pooped my way to my goal weight. I think that goes without saying that that doesn't work. And finally, the diabetes tool that diet culture has stolen which is the constant glucose monitoring system which is putting a patch on your arm that has a little needle in there and people who have diabetes use it to tell them what their glucose levels are and help them be alive diet culture is taking this and selling it for $350 a month to tell you when you're a lab to eat and when you have to go exercise obviously not backed up with any science and none of these are but the big thing to remember are these are ridiculous and funny and we can see that they are silly, but so are all diets. Every diet out there is a fad diet which is not backed by any science doesn't work for the vast majority of people and just like these hilarious fad diets that will leave you take your money and make you feel conned because exactly is exactly what has happened when you buy any diet product. Okay, so that is our episode today. If you see any Helwig arounds new diet stuff, I would love to see one which is combining the I poked my way with the Yoni rags. I'd love to see a Yoni poo one if you see Yoni poo one chef's kiss gonna love it I'm not gonna link to any of those products because I don't want them to get any traffic and also I looked them up on frickin what is it? When you go incognito incognito? I hoped a fuck Vator please don't find me don't advertise to me play A's. I don't want to I don't want any of that stuff. On my on my Instagram. Yeah, so don't look don't look about it because you don't want to get the adverts because they're going to bombard you with adverts. All right. Just just take it take it from my mi unless you want to go on a incognito search or whatever. I'm going to put in the show notes the link for Philosophy Tube, excellent channel. There's an also another one that I really like called contra points. Another trans woman looks like a long form long form. Long Form article is what they call them. So it's like an hour long. So we and a lot of them are really beautifully shot there. And they wear costumes and it's very elaborate. That one that I'm going to send you to is is just talking to camera so which is fine, but also there's clips and things like that anyway, it's good. Hopefully I don't need to convince you anymore. It's really really good.

The philosophy of Antiva we've also got other things Oh, also, oh my god mass show recommendation. Please go and watch a league of their own. So there's a film right. I've never actually seen the film. I think I should but there's a new TV series, A League of Their Own. It's so fucking queer. It's so just gay and trans and, and there's a fat actor and there's just so good da ah and and and and A black folks and Hispanic folks. And Jeff was great. Anyway, so I was obviously I go and look up the fact actor, Melanie field she was already following it was what she the what the fat actor in A League of Their Own was already following me. Yeah, so I I made a post saying oh my god, Melanie field is already following me. She's great in a field of dreams. It's not a field of dreams. I just saw the word field and a field of dreams I think is a baseball shirt baseball movie, too, isn't it? Let me google it. field sports fantasy drama. So anyway, it's sports. I think it is baseball, basketball, whatever is whatever the thing is. So she must have thought I was the right fucking dingdong. And so she messaged me saying, of course I follow you with the name like best fatty. And then I was like, Oh, I got us at the wrong show. And she's and she didn't reply, saying she definitely hates me. She doesn't. I'm being an idiot. Yes, so yeah, go watch that. And what was the other show? That I was going to recommend? I'll tell you next time. I don't remember what it is. But I'll tell you next time, whenever I remember, I have these things. I'm like, I need to tell you about this thing. This is a new one. I'll have them saved on my phone and then I forget and then anyway. Yeah, so go go watch that is on prime. So good. I watched it in like 12 seconds. I need to go watch it again. It was it's really good. Anyway, thanks for hanging out with me today. Thanks for being a fierce fatty. If you want to donate to keep the show going. You can find my PayPal link in the show notes. It's just like PayPal me forward slash first party. And if you'd like to write a review for the show, that would be uncle Abler. That's French for incredible. And if you just want to just be your first family, that's great, too. All right. See you later. See you in a while alligator, okay. Perfect.

EP135 Transcript

You're listening to the Fierce Fatty Podcast episode 135. Food addiction, Sugar Addiction, Carbs Addiction?! Oh my goodness, let's do it.

Hello, and welcome to this episode. Did you miss me? Did you miss me? Did you think I was dead? I'm not dead. Whoo. Hey, so I had a few weeks off unexpected it was my birthday. So I was like fuck at this Leo needs like a month off. It wasn't a month it was two weeks. But there was one week where I was too busy to record the podcast. Anyway. So thanks for hanging around. Thanks for coming back for this new episode if you were waiting with breath that was baited. Or maybe you didn't even notice. Maybe you listened to all those years from now. And now you're like, What are you talking about? Anyway? Hi, hi. Hi. Hi. Hi. Hi. It's about 50 billion degrees. Today's I've got a couple of hands going. Hopefully the two not too noisy in the background there. I want to start off first with someone sent me a DM and was responding to I can't remember what episode it was. But in the episode I was talking about that shot that film Supersize Me synthesized made you remember that film where he Morgan Spurlock was the guy who filmed himself only eating McDonald's for I don't know how long. And then afterwards, the doctor looked at his body and was like, your body's fucked up. And there was something like you're going into liver failure. And they were like, Sue, this is what McDonald's does. If you eat McDonald's, you're gonna go into liver failure and die. Anyway. So when someone emailed me and said, actually, it came out, Morgan Spurlock revealed that he was a heavy alcohol user at the time and had been since he was a teenager. And so that's why his liver was not good shape. But they didn't reveal that in the movie, because then they wouldn't be able to blame McDonald's for killing people, I guess. So I thought that was interesting. I was like, Oh, well, well, well. Who knows? Who knows? Whatever. Just a little, just a little tip. tip, tip bit, no dead bit. Let's just call it tip bit from now one little tidbit for you. Another thing that's came out recently is the FAA, the Federal airline authority. American Airline authority, basically, federal American Airlines or who knows who the fuck knows. Anyway, they have said. They said Listen up here. We want to know how big you think the seats need to be. For safety. Right? I got an email from Anne who says My name is Anne. I'm a fatty from Brookline or Brooklyn. Not it's not Brooklyn, as in Ms. Nh New Hampshire. I'm guessing I've been following you on Instagram for a while now. And I love how passionately you advocate for all of us fatties. That's what I thought of you. When this idea opportunity arose. So she says as part of the FAA Reauthorization Act of 2018, the US Federal Aviation Association Well, there you go, that's what it is. Federal us aviation association is asking for public feedback on airplane seat size. They have stressed that the info opinions they are looking for need to be related specifically to passenger safety during an emergency, not comfort. According to CNN, the FAA conducted several simulated emergency evacuations in 2019 and 2020. And based on those simulations, they have decided that seat size and spacing did not adversely affect the success of emergency evacuations. However, the simulations were conducted on using, quote, able bodied adult subjects younger than 60. Obviously, larger people have much more difficulty moving through airplanes because of the narrow aisles and tight rows, but it seems that the FAA doesn't feel that they need to take this into consideration, even though almost 75% of Americans are fat. So I filed a complaint with them and I shared the link to Twitter, here's that link. And so on is saying here's the here's the links for the comments that you can make for the regulations.gov and ads left a great comment. So you can even just like kind of copy what an has done, and then leave a comment. We've got almost 10,000 comments there. So the more comments are better and some people are not are saying, Oh, I'm tall and and so it makes it uncomfortable. These motherfuckers don't care about your comfort, they care about getting sued because the seats are too close together and fat people can't get out.

That's what it's about, right? They're probably scared about losing money. It's about money right? So you need to you need to say how fat folks are going to be trapped in an airplane if they can't get out because the seats are so tiny and even strays eyes people's shit man like, it's like, the width between the seats, you know, the leg room, it's like, as wide as a slice of paper, you know, there's nothing there. So if you're a straight sides person listening right now, please go to the link in the show notes, which is facebook.com forward slash 135 facebook.com. Forward slash 135. For Episode 135, if you don't remember, it's always is always this way to comm forward slash podcast and leave a comment that will be your act of ally ship for two day and leave a comment and say it's way too tiny. Even I as a small person, or it should be this big. We need to be safe. Fat people need to be safe. If you want to and you're a fat person, you can do the same thing. You can go and look at Ann's comment. I'll leave the link for and comment too. And you can kind of see what she's written because it's good. Right? Great. Okay, so today's episode is talking about food addiction, sugar addiction, carbs addiction, and I've spoken about this previously, but it was quite a while ago and so maybe new listeners haven't heard it or you've probably forgotten even if you've listened already, but I'm I'm adding in new things. But shit like I can't even remember the episodes I've done. So how are you? How do you How are you meant to remember? People like Oh, remember that episode you did about blah, blah, blah. And I'm like, No, like I remember some of the key ones but most of it I don't remember what I've even spoken about. So how how why am I expecting you to remember every single word I've ever said. And anyway, we can talk about you know, the same top topics in different ways and it's all good. Yeah, so the idea of food addiction or sugar addiction or carb addiction or any type of subset of food addiction. I was thinking about it because you know we did I did an episode with some in an on Jvn Jonathan Van Ness and their TV show it was called it is called curious thing it's called getting curious with with Jvn Jvn uses he they cheap pre printed cheat sheet. I can't I can't look them up because he's blocked me on. He's blocked me on Instagram. After they had the episode or didn't. They didn't probably didn't hear the episode. They saw that I had tagged him in a post anyway, so I'm gonna be using their him pronouns. For Jvn, just an FYI. So in this episode, there was a dietician who was like, let's talk about FedEx. And jbn is like, yes. Tell me more about it. And she's like, let's look at the science. This is your brain on sugar. And then it was like, oh, jokes. This is like, oh, no, cocaine is people's brains on cocaine. It's the same. You're basically addicted to sugar food. You are a out of control person, oh my god, you need to go on a diet and wanting to kind of talk about this more go in depth more because I guarantee there are people listening being like, Well, I think I'm a food addict. I think I'm a sugar addict. I feel like Jvn and he was saying how, how they were sneaking food that nighttime or not eating any food all day long. And then at the end of the night being like, Oh, I ate some food. Now to me, to me, as someone who talks about this stuff, I'm like, okay, it seems really obvious that you just need to eat some food.

Ah, but I know that it can be very distressing for a lot of people. And in fact, I had a history with really feeling like I was a food addict, I really felt like I should be going to Oh, a Overeaters Anonymous, because I felt so out of control with food I was obsessed with it was the first thing that I thought of when I woke up in the morning saying, prayers, maybe Jesus, I can't eat some breakfast. And then it would be like, Okay, well, I've had my measly breakfast now, how long? Is it until I can have lunch? How many hours? Or is it almost sir, I can't wait to eat. And obviously, it seems very clear at the time to me that there was something wrong with me and I was addicted to food. It makes sense, right? Because you're having these feelings. Of I can't wait to wake up in the morning. So I'm allowed to eat. And I wish I could eat more food and dreaming about food. So and then when you when you think about what is the common rhetoric around this stuff, so the common rhetoric I did a little bit of looking up seeing what people are saying nowadays about it. At that time, that was, oh my goodness, 20 years ago now. When that was really, when that was really difficult for me. It is, most places are saying, Listen, it's not a real thing. Like as in it's not it's not. It's not recognized as a, an an addiction, but it's an addiction is what people are saying. So this is from Web MD, who says the idea that a person can be addicted to food has recently gained increasing support that comes from brain imaging and other studies of the effects of compulsive overeating on the pleasure centers in the brain experiments in animals. Now, if you didn't last episode, that should be a little thing should have gone off when I said that experiments in animals. And humans show that for some people the same reward and pleasure centers of the brain that are triggered by addictive drugs like cocaine and heroin are also activated by food especially highly palatable foods. So they're saying okay, well we've got science to show that food has the same effect as cocaine and heroin Okay. compulsive overeating as a type of behavioral addictions. So okay, so we so we've got we've got the the chemical addiction, and then the behavioral addiction. So compulsive overeating is a type of behavioral addiction, meaning that someone can become preoccupied preoccupied preoccupied with a behavior, such as eating, gambling or shopping that triggers intense pleasure. People with food addictions lose control over their eating behavior and find themselves spending excessive amounts of time involved with food and overeating and anticipating the emotional effects of compulsive overeating. So if you're reading that stuff, as someone who you know is struggling or who's you know, someone who's just interested you like, yeah, that sounds that sounds about right. But let's look and let's use our critical critical thinking skills. Let's look a little bit more or less knew a little bit more research research. Okay, so we've got another another article, which is the eight symptoms of food addiction. And they say here, while food addiction is not listed in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, DSM five so that's a big book that therapists and psychologists and psychotherapists will have that will tell you, Oh, this is what bipolar is, this is bipolar one. This is what depression is, this is the symptoms. This is like this huge big Bible of mental mental health stuff. So the DSM it tips so while food addiction is not listed in the DSM, it typically involves binge eating behaviors, cravings, and a lack of control around food. Hmm, interesting. While someone gets a craving or overeats occasionally probably won't fit the criteria for the disorder. There are at least eight common symptoms Okay, so now they're calling it a disorder when it's not in the DSM five. But here we've got eight symptoms.

So let's have a look what Healthline says the eight symptoms of food addiction is getting cravings despite being full of getting cravings despite being full. Could that be because you If eating the wrong things, like if you are like, Oh, I really fancy a cheese toastie. And instead you had a salad sandwich, you could be full on having a salad sandwich theoretically, and also still crave a cheese toastie because really, you were looking for that crunchy outside the warm, gooey, middle, little bit salty, little bit of tomato sauce. And instead, you had a salad sandwich does not match. Softer. You might have heard of crunch from the stuff inside, unlike a good salad sandwich me. But if I was craving a tea, cheese toastie, even if I was full, I'd still crave it. Okay, that doesn't mean that I am addicted to cheese to stews. Next one is eating more than intended. Okay, so eating more than intended is a really common occurrence. And people do it often. And it is not pathologize for example, you go out to a nice restaurant with your spouse, you have a few glasses of wine, you have a really nice meal at the end you like a horn, I really feel full. You're not then being like, oh my god, someone's a food addict. And you know, think about like Christmas dinner, you're gonna fall then thinking about so you know, you've got this really yummy thing and you get you eat more than then is feels comfortable. Yes, there is when there is the one we're doing more than serves us, then we can talk about it. But eating much more than intended is what they're saying here is not inherently a harmful thing. Right? Eating until feeling excessively stuffed. Okay, so this this, this too, could be something else. We're going to talk about that in a moment. But it's for a lot of folks this is just a normal behavior. Some folks it's not it doesn't feel good and there's other things that's going on behind that but it's not addiction that's a behind that. Okay, the next one feeling guilty afterward, but doing again soon. Feeling guilty after eating food. Wonder where that comes from? Die of culture and fat phobia. That's what's happening there because we shouldn't feel guilty for eating. So okay, so that's a symptom of being in a fat phobic diet, Culture Society, making up excuses. Let me see what they say about this. Brain can be a strange thing, especially in regards to addiction. Deciding to stay away from trigger foods can cause someone to create rules from themselves. Yeah, these rules may be hard to follow when faced with craving. Someone with a food addiction might find ways to reason around the rules and given to the craving. Okay, so that's just a natural response to restriction you because you cannot fight it. Your body is doing some incredible things if you're restricting if you're saying I'm not going to have that food that I am, quote addicted to your brain is going to blank page gave me that thing and doing all sorts of we're gonna talking about it in a sec. What it's going to what it's doing exactly. To get you to eat that thing. And it's not that you're addicted. It's because your body is like okay, well. They've told me I'm not allowed to eat it. Watch me, I'm gonna I'm gonna get them to eat it. That's what your that's what your brain is saying. Six repeated failures, that setting rules. Oh my god, like why the fuck do we need to have rules around food? Yeah, by seven eating, hiding, eating from others. Aha. Okay, so it could be that we've got an eating disorder on our hands that we're gonna talk about more in a moment.

Or it could be that as fat fat people, or people, people who have other marginalized identities, especially if you're a supersize, fat person, eating is not safe to do in front of other people. So you know, hiding eating from others, that a lot of times it's because it's not safe. You don't want judgment. And you feel shame around the fact that you're eating for whatever reason, which is, it could be something that's going on there which is a little bit deeper which is disordered eating or an eating disorder. It could be diet culture, right. Number eight, an able to quit despite physical problems. Oh, well. Hello, we're not able to quit eating food we would then become dad. There. Hello. And the more that we say okay, well, I'm gonna eat only quote good food. The more we do that then all of the all of the stuff that our bodies do to get a To eat the food that we're restricting is going to really ramp up until we're like, fine. I'm going to give it and I'm going to eat the food right? Right. And they say they say physical problems in the short term, quote, I'm not gonna say what they say. Food can lead to weight gain acne. What? Bad breath Oh for fuck sake, fatigue, poor dental, poor dental, health and other common problems. So why don't you just stop eating food? You're fat bastard. Like what? Oh my god, eating food apparently is gonna give you Alzheimer's dementia and cancer this is just they just come up with all sorts of shit. Oh, my goodness. Anyway, okay, continue. Okay, so that's what that one says. So for me those eight signs sounds like if someone says that I'm you know, I'm hiding what I'm eating and I'm not able to stop eating food. And I really crave it. I would say, you know, can you go to a therapist? Because it sounds like maybe you might have an eating disorder, disordered eating, or are just a victim, not just but you're a victim of diet culture, as is pretty much everyone. I feel like most people have disordered eating. And it's so normalized that we don't even realize that. Okay, so this this one Medical News Today says they, I think what they've said is a little bit more down to earth a little bit. Not not. If you eat food, you're gonna like, Oh, dear. So they say the human body needs food to provide energy and nutrition. Gray, thank you. That's the first time we've had that. However, people can feel addicted to food when they become dependent on that word dependent on certain types of foods, any food can can make a person feel addictive tendencies. Yes, and that's the thing, it can really feel like we're addicted, right. And if we try and stop eating that food, then that's when the feeling of being addicted, is really heightened. And if we think about addiction to different substances, you know, like, like, opioids, or whatever. And we think about what happens in those situations when they when someone doesn't have or isn't able to access, the substances that they normally use, and what difficult things that they go through. And we can see, it's different, it's it feel, it's a preoccupation that we might have with food, but our body is not going through this, this withdrawal or this, do anything to get it, you know, that you would with, with things that are actually chemically addictive, and it is a big thing here. Addiction is it's, it's an illness, right? It's it's a mental health condition. And so being addicted doesn't mean that you're a bad person.

Any type of addiction, even if you feel like you are addicted to sugar, or food or whatever. Or if if someone is addicted to other substances, they're not a bad person, it is something that is a very complicated topic. It's something that's really one side is very encouraged in our culture, if you think about substances, like alcohol, how that consumption is, is really encouraged. Whereas other things, it's very stigmatized. And, you know, if someone says I'm a, you know, I use alcohol versus someone who says, I use heroin, what we would think about those two people and the stigma that the person who uses heroin would face versus someone who uses alcohol and really, you know, both are maybe you know, and the thing is, you could be used and we know, you could use alcohol and it's not a big deal, right? You can just like I enjoy this right and if someone is enjoying other types of substances, and it works for them and their life is functioning and whatever, Who Who are we to say, you shouldn't be doing that? And I think about that with the foodstuff right is why are people why do people do certain things? Whatever it is, you know, it's, you know, for us to to live survive thrive. To be happy experience, joy, whatever. And I think about when I was in my stage where I thought I was addicted to food, I was trying to survive an abusive relationship. And it was literally one of the only joys that I had literally in the amount of joy that I felt from food that I snuck was something that kept me alive. And so was that a negative thing? At the time, I thought it was deeply shameful and awful. And now I'm like, Thank fuck for what I discovered was actually an eating disorder. Because it saved me, it means that I'm alive today, whereas who knows what could have happened? So let's see what people say about sugar addiction. So sugar consumption can create a short term high, and a spark of energy in the body. Some studies have suggested sugar is as addictive as cocaine have they have have?

Where's your link? This is from addiction. center.com. Do they link back to the studies? No, they don't have a studies study saying this. No. No. So what we know and it's pretty, it's well established. And, you know, therapists and people will say, Listen, studies have been done on human brains to see what happens when they eat food or have sugar or whatever. And it lights up. And so it's like, Dun dun dun. It lights up. Uh huh. Evidence that's we have a food addict on our hands. And oh, okay, now let's let's get them to have a hug from someone they love. Oh, it it like it lights up. Oh, they are maybe they're also addicted to hugs. Oh, and let's show them pictures of puppies. Oh, the light. It lights up? Oh, they're probably a fucking puppy addict too. You know? So the stuff that lights up. is is it's a reward is a reward. Right? And so anything that we enjoy, we're getting dopamine, we're getting reward in our beautiful brains from that thing. And if it happens to be food, or it happens to be watching someone, you know, hug a puppy on YouTube. It's the same thing is happening, right? So people who talk about carbohydrate carbohydrate, so copperheads a carbohydrate addicts.com This one was funny. As many as 75% of those who are fat are addicted to carbohydrates. Oh. Is that so 75% of fat people are addicted to carbohydrates. Wow. That's such great information where did that study come from? Oh, there is no study. Oh, you just seen it. They end with this craving reward negative consequence cycle suggests that yes, carbs are addictive.

So says So does it listen to the study. So this study is evidence for sugar addiction behavioral and neurochemical effects of intermittent excessive sugar intake. And I want to use their definition of addiction. So we can look at you know, does this sound like what happens with food? They say the diagnostic criteria for addiction can be grouped into three stages. Binging withdrawal role. Credit has three stages. It's not three stages is more. Anyway, they talk about the these are these are the stages. Okay group grouped into different ones. Okay, so binging, withdrawal, craving and sensitization I fucking hate that word. I can never say it right centralization. Okay, so let's talk about him. Binging Alright, so, as we know, there is there are times in our lives where we will binge and it will just be a normal part of life. It was my birthday last week. I was like okay, well, what can I what am I going to have for dinner? I'm gonna buy some things I really like. So did I buy something? Yeah, yeah, yeah, I got a I got an ice cream. And I got a Chinese takeaway. And I ordered from I really love cinema popcorn. So I ordered from the cinema, this popcorn. And I was like this jumbo popcorn and I was like, oh, it's probably, you know, the size of two larges. Turns out it was the size of six largers. So, I was eating, I was eating that popcorn and my, my Chinese hadn't arrived yet. And so I was like eating the popcorn and and the Chinese arrived to house in Chinese and I was like, oh my god, I'm really full. And so I forgot about the ice cream. Anyway, so there we go, that's a binge. I mean, you could suggest that oh, maybe, you know, a binges is if we're getting into like pathological like, you know, fast and, you know, other other things that are going on to make it more kind of less relaxed than what I was doing right? I was just like, chowing down on some on some nice food, and ate too much for what my body wanted at that time. And that's okay. Right. So, and then we also then have it then moving into something that is a little bit more harmful, maybe to my mental health. And that would be moving into BDD. So binge eating disorder. And so we can have signs and symptoms of BDD, but not actually, like full blown BDD. And I'll talk about that more later what that looks like. And so Okay, so with the for the diagnostic criteria of this is first is binging. Okay, so we know that someone can binge in a way that is not harmful for them away, that is just a normal part of being a human being. And we also know it's a part of, of something which is a mental health condition, an eating disorder. And so it is not necessarily addiction. Next is withdrawal. Okay, so let me tell you what, we're talking about withdrawal. They use withdrawal from opioids as their criteria. And so does this sounds familiar to you? When you have eaten food, and you or whatever it is sugar, whatever you feel like you might be addicted to Does this sound familiar? Of when you haven't had access to that food? Trembling and tremors, muscle pain or aches, hunger or loss of appetite, fatigue, sweating, irritability, agitation, depression, anxiety, nausea, vomiting, confusion, insomnia, paranoia, seizures, dilated pupils. I mean, maybe a few of them. Anxiety, maybe no. But really, that doesn't sound about right does it? That doesn't sound about right, that doesn't feel like the experience of what's happening when you are not getting access to this substance, which is sugar or food or whatever. By the way, our bodies need food.

Sugar, carbohydrates, right? Our bodies need that. And so, I mean, if you went long enough, without eating, you probably would start doing this stuff. But I'm talking about like the kind of say, between, you know, when you've had your lunch and to having your data or whatever, this stuff is not happening, because it's not like we need to keep fueling that, quote, addiction, because it's just a normal body function. Eating is like something that we just have to do. And yes, our body will say, Hey, I'm hungry, feed me and different things are happening with our body when we're hungry. But it's not because we're withdrawing from, we're in withdrawal from this quote, drug, right. Next, they say craving. So craving they say often has reference to extreme motivation, which can be measured using operant conditioning. So I'd say yes, we could, we could be craving. But I think what we're saying here is the extreme motivation. And I think when we're getting to the extreme motivation, that's when we're getting into eating disorder territory. That's when we're getting into maybe the IDI, right. of, you know, it doesn't matter if it's the middle of the night, I'm going to go drive to my 24 hour supermarket and buy the things that I want. And, again, that's not addiction that is falling into BDD, binge eating disorder. sensitization let me read what they say here. Behavioral sensitization is typically measured as an increased locomotion in response to repeat it administration's of a drug. For example, after repeated doses of amphetamine followed by abstinence a challenge dose, which has little or no effect in naive animals cause markethive For activity, animal synthesize to one seven is often show cross sensitization, which is defined as an increased local motor response to a different drug or substance. Cross sensitization can also be manifest in consumer Tory behavior. Animals synthesized to one drug may show increased intake of a different drug. In other words, one drug drug acts as a gateway to another. So we think about this what this is saying in plain language is you build a tolerance for food and then you can't get enough and then you are going to cross over into needing other substance substances because you know, eating food just doesn't do it for you anymore. And you know, you eat 75 Twinkies in an hour and it's not enough and that's not what happens right? That doesn't probably doesn't sound familiar to you. Where you one day will be having one square of chocolate and then the next day it's like okay, well I now I'm on 275 packs a chocolate you know because my tolerance is built up and now I forget food that food was such a you know that does nothing for me anymore now I've now I'm now I'm using different substances like that's not what happens. And this is what they're talking about. Right? They're talking about this and then this study. This study is a study that they've done on DACA guess what they did that on? They did on rats, Oh, rats, the pool rats. And then like, Oh, rats, like sugar water and they they will choose sugar water over plain water. Or fucking No shit.

Rats Don't, don't rats don't live in a world that says if you eat sugar, what are your piece of shit and have parents mums who say you look a bit fat or, you know, live in a society that values them for their parents, their rats? They're going to be like, Okay, what how can I live longer? I'm going to get as you know, this nice juicy sweet water. Because it fucking days good. We're not rats, right? Okay, so everything about the diet land swing, to the land, the diet, land swing is restriction to bench if you think about a swing, if you pull it up in restriction, it has to go down and it's going to go into binge and so you restrict binge restrict binge and the more you pull it up into restrict, the more it's going to go over into binge. So and that's restriction physically and mentally, and restriction makes you fixated on food. It makes food taste more delicious. And one thing one thing that it does is it increases our appetites when we restrict the hormones that make us feel hungry. Increase. Ghrelin is made in the stomach and it stimulates hunger by entering the brain and acting on the neurons in the hypothalamus to increase the activity of hunger, causing nerve cells and reducing the activity of hunger inhibiting cells. And as the stomach empties the release of ghrelin increases the hormones that make us feel full. What do you think they go down? So you're really craving food. Leptin is the most powerful appetite suppressing hormone and is made in fat cells. And so if we're not eating food, and we are our bodies is like, okay, what can that do to make them eat, I'm gonna make them feel really, really hungry. And even if they I'm gonna make them feel hungry still, because we don't have food. Also, your body will make the sight sound, taste and smell of food increase, it'll just make it way more appetizing. And so you'll be like, Oh my god, I'm just salivating I'm just walked by we I just walked by a food store and I'm fucking salivating what's wrong with me? That's your body being like, hey, fake mag me that thing that you've said that we're not allowed to have and your metabolism slows down. The other thing is that your muscle mass decreases and your your fat mass increases because muscle uses more energy so we don't need our body to be burning more energy we need to be burning less energy if we're literally starving. And so you don't want to move your body as much and so that's going to add to what you got to like, oh my god, I'm so lazy. I just can't be bothered to do anything. I'm just such a I'm addicted to food. I can't I don't want to move my body. I'm just a piece of shit. And all of this can be really alarming and feel Like addiction and feel like we're just out of control and food has his grip on us. And just really distressing. So was I addicted to food in the past? Well, I was addicted to food in the same way that I'm addicted to breathing air. I was addicted to food. And the same way I'm addicted to drinking water the same way I'm addicted to sleeping or having a nice poo, you know, it's a normal body function. And the moment that you were denied that, then you were going to need more of it. And we'll talk about the definition of addiction addiction is a brain disorder characterized by compulsive engagement in rewarding stimuli despite adverse consequences. Well, people are saying, well, the adverse consequences is fatness. But we know that some some folks can eat food and never gain weight. They can they really struggle with it, and they're really struggling to keep weight on. And so would they be a food addict? Because they don't have quote, adverse consequences. But what about if someone is already fat? And they are, quote, a food addict? But they don't have they don't put on any other way? Are they a food addict? Or is that a not a food addict? Because it seems like rewarding stimuli despite adverse consequences. And it's a framing of fatness as an adverse consequence and a framing of of eating food as a direct tie to gaining weight. And we know it's actually a lot more complicated than that. But reasons why people are fat are in the hundreds.

Yeah, all of this stuff, it's It's enough to make you feel irrational and desperate and imbalanced and feeling addicted. So really, when I was in that feeling, like as addictive stage, what was what I was experienced was binge eating disorder. And binge eating disorder is seen as this sister to bulimia, but without the purging. And so folks who experienced BPD may have a compulsion to eat more food than their body currently needs in one session, to the point where they feel like it's a problem, and they feel like it's disordered. As humans, we all binge all the time, right? As I discussed, and it's totally normal. The difference is the restriction phase and the guilt and the feeling of compulsion, and maybe eating alone or in secret or having binge foods, or maybe not even enjoying the food or the taste, just eating. And it's actually the most prevalent eating disorder in adults. And it's still a relatively new concept. It's only it was only formally recognized, and in 2013, one to 3% of the population have BPD, and is spread equally between men and women. We have no good information on gender nonconforming, non binary or trans people. But we do know gender queer folks experience EDS more than other groups, probably due to the stress of living in a marginalized body. When I was growing up, there was anorexia and bulimia right. As in, you know, that's what the general public talked about. And what an eating disorder looked like, to me was a thin white teenage girl who was not eating enough food. But the reality is that eating disorders come in many different forms. And the indiscriminate right, anyone can have an eating disorder. And the difference between disordered eating and an eating disorder is the impact it's having on your life. And so you remember I said before, like, I think, you know, most people in our society engages in some type of disordered eating. And I think that the, the, you know, someone could be engaging in daily restriction, for example, and it have a massive amount of impact on their life and their mental health or as someone else could be engaging in the exact same behaviors, and it could be okay for them, right? And so we can be getting engaging in the same behaviors and it just not have an impact or have an impact. It's about how much it's impacting your life. And people who have BPD tend to have higher levels of body dissatisfaction and lower self esteem and it's linked to being restrictive with food. Okay, dieting, and it can be a method for coping with other issues. Yeah, so what about sugar? Ah, so, studies have shown no conclusive evidence that sugar is addicted to human addictive for humans. So if you think about what behaviors someone who is addicted to a substance display, are we displaying them with sugar, you know, are we hitting rock bottom and, you know, stealing and ending up in in prison because of the things that you're needing to do to, to meet up with the supply of food or sugar that you need to hit because your tolerance is getting more and more? No, we're not seeing that, right. And if you were addicted to sugar, you'd be addicted to sugar in all forms, right? You'd be addicted to drinking catch up, or, you know, eating mangoes or, or iced tea, right. But it's when we often think about sugar addiction, we think about things that are, quote, the bad foods, right? What diet culture has told us of the bad foods versus just sugar, you know, eating a sugar cube the big thing here to think about is that symptoms of addiction increase with more access to the substance substance you're addicted to. Okay, so if you're taking more of something that is actually addictive, you're like you smoking cigarettes, you smoking 10 a day and then you're like, oh, let's get you know,

I've got a 20 pack on i 20, you're going to become more addicted, right. And so the next day, you're going to have to have a 20 pack again, because the 10 is not going to do it for you. Whereas symptoms of food addiction or sugar addiction, decrease and disappear, with access with more access to sugar and food. So the more we allow ourselves to eat sugar, eat food, the less those feelings of addiction are present. And that is the big difference is the source of feeling addicted, is restriction. Also, you don't need drugs, you do need sugar, you do need food, our brains need sugar, and carbs to function. Glucose, a form of sugar is the primary source of energy for every cell in the body. The less sugar sugar you eat, the more you're going to crave it. So no, we're probably not addicted to food, or to sugar.

I think about it too. Like you know, I've used this analogy before. About imagine if we were free divers and holding our breath and going down as deep as possible. Coming back to the surface, the first thing that we're going to do is gasping for air. Take a deep breath in because we have been starved of that air our body is saying get to that surface, hurry up. Quick breathe, taking a big gulp because we haven't had air for x x long. And our bodies are doing the same with food with sugar, whatever, whether what you know, those those those things that we need in our bodies. And when you restrict it's like you're going diving, you can't stay down there forever, or you'll die. And and so we need to surface and the more we say there's something wrong with me because I took a deep breath and the deep breath is binging is eating foods that we've we have decided is bad. The more we say that that was that is wrong and pathologize it the more we're going to try and force ourselves to beat living under the water. But like just stay under the water longer. And you won't need to breathe as much. It doesn't work like that. Because we need to breathe, it will be good. We need to eat or we'll be good. We need sugar or we'll be dead.

Yeah, so let's give a roundup of everything that we've we've talked about right now. So is food or sugar addiction real. So if you think about food all the time, and maybe you count down the minutes until you can eat again or you have a preference for foods that you label as bad or sugar filled or unhealthy. This can feel really distressing and can feel like we're addicted like There's something really wrong with us. However, there isn't any evidence to show that what happens in our brains is addiction in the same way as other substances. Our reward centers in our brains do light up, but they are the same ones that light up when we hug someone we love, or we watch a funny video or we see a cute puppy. And the big reason why people feel addicted to sugar because we really can feel addicted to sugar or food is one they are restricting that food or sugar or to they actually have an eating disorder. And for both scenarios, the food addiction symptoms will decrease and hopefully disappear when we fully physically and mentally allow ourselves those things into our lives that sugar that food and that's a big difference with substance addiction the opposite happens so the more the more substances are, are actually addictive that you have in your life the more you consume consume them those addictive feelings increase because they are actually addictive. Whereas with food with sugar the more access we have to it those addiction feelings decrease the more we allow ourselves and that's a big difference between something that's that's actually addictive and something that just feels addictive. So no food or sugar addiction isn't real but can it can really feel like it when we restrict ourselves so hopefully we can we can put that one to bed we can say okay, really I just need to know if you feel it if you're really struggling and you're feeling like you know out of control it would be if you can it'd be really good idea to go and talk to a mental health professional if that's available for you. And you know big compassion because this stuff is like this the rhetoric we have around addiction one around food and eating too much of it to and around fatness three, like Ha like imagine that amount of iron we need to say imagine well, we have a lot of us have felt it, you know, that amount of shame is overwhelming and powerful and sucks, right? And so if you're in that position then I sending sending out love to you all the love to you and hoping that you can find some comfort and some peace and know that you're not alone. You know, the most prevalent eating disorder is binge eating disorder. And Also heads up fat people can be anorexic. And it's not normal, or normal. It is normal for people to be stressed around food, but really, we should have a peaceful relationship with food if possible. So all right, well, thanks for hanging out with me. This is on pressure on aw and I'll see you in the next episode. Stay fierce fatty See you in a while and again.

EP134 Transcript

You're listening to the Fierce Fatty Podcast episode 135. Food addiction, Sugar Addiction, Carbs Addiction?! Oh my goodness, let's do it.

Hello, and welcome to this episode. Did you miss me? Did you miss me? Did you think I was dead? I'm not dead. Whoo. Hey, so I had a few weeks off unexpected it was my birthday. So I was like fuck at this Leo needs like a month off. It wasn't a month it was two weeks. But there was one week where I was too busy to record the podcast. Anyway. So thanks for hanging around. Thanks for coming back for this new episode if you were waiting with breath that was baited. Or maybe you didn't even notice. Maybe you listened to all those years from now. And now you're like, What are you talking about? Anyway? Hi, hi. Hi. Hi. Hi. Hi. It's about 50 billion degrees. Today's I've got a couple of hands going. Hopefully the two not too noisy in the background there. I want to start off first with someone sent me a DM and was responding to I can't remember what episode it was. But in the episode I was talking about that shot that film Supersize Me synthesized made you remember that film where he Morgan Spurlock was the guy who filmed himself only eating McDonald's for I don't know how long. And then afterwards, the doctor looked at his body and was like, your body's fucked up. And there was something like you're going into liver failure. And they were like, Sue, this is what McDonald's does. If you eat McDonald's, you're gonna go into liver failure and die. Anyway. So when someone emailed me and said, actually, it came out, Morgan Spurlock revealed that he was a heavy alcohol user at the time and had been since he was a teenager. And so that's why his liver was not good shape. But they didn't reveal that in the movie, because then they wouldn't be able to blame McDonald's for killing people, I guess. So I thought that was interesting. I was like, Oh, well, well, well. Who knows? Who knows? Whatever. Just a little, just a little tip. tip, tip bit, no dead bit. Let's just call it tip bit from now one little tidbit for you. Another thing that's came out recently is the FAA, the Federal airline authority. American Airline authority, basically, federal American Airlines or who knows who the fuck knows. Anyway, they have said. They said Listen up here. We want to know how big you think the seats need to be. For safety. Right? I got an email from Anne who says My name is Anne. I'm a fatty from Brookline or Brooklyn. Not it's not Brooklyn, as in Ms. Nh New Hampshire. I'm guessing I've been following you on Instagram for a while now. And I love how passionately you advocate for all of us fatties. That's what I thought of you. When this idea opportunity arose. So she says as part of the FAA Reauthorization Act of 2018, the US Federal Aviation Association Well, there you go, that's what it is. Federal us aviation association is asking for public feedback on airplane seat size. They have stressed that the info opinions they are looking for need to be related specifically to passenger safety during an emergency, not comfort. According to CNN, the FAA conducted several simulated emergency evacuations in 2019 and 2020. And based on those simulations, they have decided that seat size and spacing did not adversely affect the success of emergency evacuations. However, the simulations were conducted on using, quote, able bodied adult subjects younger than 60. Obviously, larger people have much more difficulty moving through airplanes because of the narrow aisles and tight rows, but it seems that the FAA doesn't feel that they need to take this into consideration, even though almost 75% of Americans are fat. So I filed a complaint with them and I shared the link to Twitter, here's that link. And so on is saying here's the here's the links for the comments that you can make for the regulations.gov and ads left a great comment. So you can even just like kind of copy what an has done, and then leave a comment. We've got almost 10,000 comments there. So the more comments are better and some people are not are saying, Oh, I'm tall and and so it makes it uncomfortable. These motherfuckers don't care about your comfort, they care about getting sued because the seats are too close together and fat people can't get out.

That's what it's about, right? They're probably scared about losing money. It's about money right? So you need to you need to say how fat folks are going to be trapped in an airplane if they can't get out because the seats are so tiny and even strays eyes people's shit man like, it's like, the width between the seats, you know, the leg room, it's like, as wide as a slice of paper, you know, there's nothing there. So if you're a straight sides person listening right now, please go to the link in the show notes, which is facebook.com forward slash 135 facebook.com. Forward slash 135. For Episode 135, if you don't remember, it's always is always this way to comm forward slash podcast and leave a comment that will be your act of ally ship for two day and leave a comment and say it's way too tiny. Even I as a small person, or it should be this big. We need to be safe. Fat people need to be safe. If you want to and you're a fat person, you can do the same thing. You can go and look at Ann's comment. I'll leave the link for and comment too. And you can kind of see what she's written because it's good. Right? Great. Okay, so today's episode is talking about food addiction, sugar addiction, carbs addiction, and I've spoken about this previously, but it was quite a while ago and so maybe new listeners haven't heard it or you've probably forgotten even if you've listened already, but I'm I'm adding in new things. But shit like I can't even remember the episodes I've done. So how are you? How do you How are you meant to remember? People like Oh, remember that episode you did about blah, blah, blah. And I'm like, No, like I remember some of the key ones but most of it I don't remember what I've even spoken about. So how how why am I expecting you to remember every single word I've ever said. And anyway, we can talk about you know, the same top topics in different ways and it's all good. Yeah, so the idea of food addiction or sugar addiction or carb addiction or any type of subset of food addiction. I was thinking about it because you know we did I did an episode with some in an on Jvn Jonathan Van Ness and their TV show it was called it is called curious thing it's called getting curious with with Jvn Jvn uses he they cheap pre printed cheat sheet. I can't I can't look them up because he's blocked me on. He's blocked me on Instagram. After they had the episode or didn't. They didn't probably didn't hear the episode. They saw that I had tagged him in a post anyway, so I'm gonna be using their him pronouns. For Jvn, just an FYI. So in this episode, there was a dietician who was like, let's talk about FedEx. And jbn is like, yes. Tell me more about it. And she's like, let's look at the science. This is your brain on sugar. And then it was like, oh, jokes. This is like, oh, no, cocaine is people's brains on cocaine. It's the same. You're basically addicted to sugar food. You are a out of control person, oh my god, you need to go on a diet and wanting to kind of talk about this more go in depth more because I guarantee there are people listening being like, Well, I think I'm a food addict. I think I'm a sugar addict. I feel like Jvn and he was saying how, how they were sneaking food that nighttime or not eating any food all day long. And then at the end of the night being like, Oh, I ate some food.

Now to me, to me, as someone who talks about this stuff, I'm like, okay, it seems really obvious that you just need to eat some food. Ah, but I know that it can be very distressing for a lot of people. And in fact, I had a history with really feeling like I was a food addict, I really felt like I should be going to Oh, a Overeaters Anonymous, because I felt so out of control with food I was obsessed with it was the first thing that I thought of when I woke up in the morning saying, prayers, maybe Jesus, I can't eat some breakfast. And then it would be like, Okay, well, I've had my measly breakfast now, how long? Is it until I can have lunch? How many hours? Or is it almost sir, I can't wait to eat. And obviously, it seems very clear at the time to me that there was something wrong with me and I was addicted to food. It makes sense, right? Because you're having these feelings. Of I can't wait to wake up in the morning. So I'm allowed to eat. And I wish I could eat more food and dreaming about food. So and then when you when you think about what is the common rhetoric around this stuff, so the common rhetoric I did a little bit of looking up seeing what people are saying nowadays about it. At that time, that was, oh my goodness, 20 years ago now. When that was really, when that was really difficult for me. It is, most places are saying, Listen, it's not a real thing. Like as in it's not it's not. It's not recognized as a, an an addiction, but it's an addiction is what people are saying. So this is from Web MD, who says the idea that a person can be addicted to food has recently gained increasing support that comes from brain imaging and other studies of the effects of compulsive overeating on the pleasure centers in the brain experiments in animals. Now, if you didn't last episode, that should be a little thing should have gone off when I said that experiments in animals. And humans show that for some people the same reward and pleasure centers of the brain that are triggered by addictive drugs like cocaine and heroin are also activated by food especially highly palatable foods. So they're saying okay, well we've got science to show that food has the same effect as cocaine and heroin Okay. compulsive overeating as a type of behavioral addictions. So okay, so we so we've got we've got the the chemical addiction, and then the behavioral addiction. So compulsive overeating is a type of behavioral addiction, meaning that someone can become preoccupied preoccupied preoccupied with a behavior, such as eating, gambling or shopping that triggers intense pleasure. People with food addictions lose control over their eating behavior and find themselves spending excessive amounts of time involved with food and overeating and anticipating the emotional effects of compulsive overeating. So if you're reading that stuff, as someone who you know is struggling or who's you know, someone who's just interested you like, yeah, that sounds that sounds about right. But let's look and let's use our critical critical thinking skills. Let's look a little bit more or less knew a little bit more research research. Okay, so we've got another another article, which is the eight symptoms of food addiction. And they say here, while food addiction is not listed in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, DSM five so that's a big book that therapists and psychologists and psychotherapists will have that will tell you, Oh, this is what bipolar is, this is bipolar one. This is what depression is, this is the symptoms. This is like this huge big Bible of mental mental health stuff. So the DSM it tips so while food addiction is not listed in the DSM, it typically involves binge eating behaviors, cravings, and a lack of control around food. Hmm, interesting. While someone gets a craving or overeats occasionally probably won't fit the criteria for the disorder. There are at least eight common symptoms Okay, so now they're calling it a disorder when it's not in the DSM five.

But here we've got eight symptoms. So let's have a look what Healthline says the eight symptoms of food addiction is getting cravings despite being full of getting cravings despite being full. Could that be because you If eating the wrong things, like if you are like, Oh, I really fancy a cheese toastie. And instead you had a salad sandwich, you could be full on having a salad sandwich theoretically, and also still crave a cheese toastie because really, you were looking for that crunchy outside the warm, gooey, middle, little bit salty, little bit of tomato sauce. And instead, you had a salad sandwich does not match. Softer. You might have heard of crunch from the stuff inside, unlike a good salad sandwich me. But if I was craving a tea, cheese toastie, even if I was full, I'd still crave it. Okay, that doesn't mean that I am addicted to cheese to stews. Next one is eating more than intended. Okay, so eating more than intended is a really common occurrence. And people do it often. And it is not pathologize for example, you go out to a nice restaurant with your spouse, you have a few glasses of wine, you have a really nice meal at the end you like a horn, I really feel full. You're not then being like, oh my god, someone's a food addict. And you know, think about like Christmas dinner, you're gonna fall then thinking about so you know, you've got this really yummy thing and you get you eat more than then is feels comfortable. Yes, there is when there is the one we're doing more than serves us, then we can talk about it. But eating much more than intended is what they're saying here is not inherently a harmful thing. Right? Eating until feeling excessively stuffed. Okay, so this this, this too, could be something else. We're going to talk about that in a moment. But it's for a lot of folks this is just a normal behavior. Some folks it's not it doesn't feel good and there's other things that's going on behind that but it's not addiction that's a behind that. Okay, the next one feeling guilty afterward, but doing again soon. Feeling guilty after eating food. Wonder where that comes from? Die of culture and fat phobia. That's what's happening there because we shouldn't feel guilty for eating. So okay, so that's a symptom of being in a fat phobic diet, Culture Society, making up excuses. Let me see what they say about this. Brain can be a strange thing, especially in regards to addiction. Deciding to stay away from trigger foods can cause someone to create rules from themselves. Yeah, these rules may be hard to follow when faced with craving. Someone with a food addiction might find ways to reason around the rules and given to the craving. Okay, so that's just a natural response to restriction you because you cannot fight it. Your body is doing some incredible things if you're restricting if you're saying I'm not going to have that food that I am, quote addicted to your brain is going to blank page gave me that thing and doing all sorts of we're gonna talking about it in a sec. What it's going to what it's doing exactly. To get you to eat that thing. And it's not that you're addicted. It's because your body is like okay, well. They've told me I'm not allowed to eat it. Watch me, I'm gonna I'm gonna get them to eat it. That's what your that's what your brain is saying. Six repeated failures, that setting rules. Oh my god, like why the fuck do we need to have rules around food? Yeah, by seven eating, hiding, eating from others. Aha. Okay, so it could be that we've got an eating disorder on our hands that we're gonna talk about more in a moment.

Or it could be that as fat fat people, or people, people who have other marginalized identities, especially if you're a supersize, fat person, eating is not safe to do in front of other people. So you know, hiding eating from others, that a lot of times it's because it's not safe. You don't want judgment. And you feel shame around the fact that you're eating for whatever reason, which is, it could be something that's going on there which is a little bit deeper which is disordered eating or an eating disorder. It could be diet culture, right. Number eight, an able to quit despite physical problems. Oh, well. Hello, we're not able to quit eating food we would then become dad. There. Hello. And the more that we say okay, well, I'm gonna eat only quote good food. The more we do that then all of the all of the stuff that our bodies do to get a To eat the food that we're restricting is going to really ramp up until we're like, fine. I'm going to give it and I'm going to eat the food right? Right. And they say they say physical problems in the short term, quote, I'm not gonna say what they say. Food can lead to weight gain acne. What? Bad breath Oh for fuck sake, fatigue, poor dental, poor dental, health and other common problems. So why don't you just stop eating food? You're fat bastard. Like what? Oh my god, eating food apparently is gonna give you Alzheimer's dementia and cancer this is just they just come up with all sorts of shit. Oh, my goodness. Anyway, okay, continue. Okay, so that's what that one says. So for me those eight signs sounds like if someone says that I'm you know, I'm hiding what I'm eating and I'm not able to stop eating food. And I really crave it. I would say, you know, can you go to a therapist? Because it sounds like maybe you might have an eating disorder, disordered eating, or are just a victim, not just but you're a victim of diet culture, as is pretty much everyone. I feel like most people have disordered eating. And it's so normalized that we don't even realize that. Okay, so this this one Medical News Today says they, I think what they've said is a little bit more down to earth a little bit. Not not. If you eat food, you're gonna like, Oh, dear. So they say the human body needs food to provide energy and nutrition. Gray, thank you. That's the first time we've had that. However, people can feel addicted to food when they become dependent on that word dependent on certain types of foods, any food can can make a person feel addictive tendencies. Yes, and that's the thing, it can really feel like we're addicted, right. And if we try and stop eating that food, then that's when the feeling of being addicted, is really heightened. And if we think about addiction to different substances, you know, like, like, opioids, or whatever. And we think about what happens in those situations when they when someone doesn't have or isn't able to access, the substances that they normally use, and what difficult things that they go through. And we can see, it's different, it's it feel, it's a preoccupation that we might have with food, but our body is not going through this, this withdrawal or this, do anything to get it, you know, that you would with, with things that are actually chemically addictive, and it is a big thing here. Addiction is it's, it's an illness, right? It's it's a mental health condition. And so being addicted doesn't mean that you're a bad person.

Any type of addiction, even if you feel like you are addicted to sugar, or food or whatever. Or if if someone is addicted to other substances, they're not a bad person, it is something that is a very complicated topic. It's something that's really one side is very encouraged in our culture, if you think about substances, like alcohol, how that consumption is, is really encouraged. Whereas other things, it's very stigmatized. And, you know, if someone says I'm a, you know, I use alcohol versus someone who says, I use heroin, what we would think about those two people and the stigma that the person who uses heroin would face versus someone who uses alcohol and really, you know, both are maybe you know, and the thing is, you could be used and we know, you could use alcohol and it's not a big deal, right? You can just like I enjoy this right and if someone is enjoying other types of substances, and it works for them and their life is functioning and whatever, Who Who are we to say, you shouldn't be doing that? And I think about that with the foodstuff right is why are people why do people do certain things? Whatever it is, you know, it's, you know, for us to to live survive thrive. To be happy experience, joy, whatever. And I think about when I was in my stage where I thought I was addicted to food, I was trying to survive an abusive relationship. And it was literally one of the only joys that I had literally in the amount of joy that I felt from food that I snuck was something that kept me alive. And so was that a negative thing? At the time, I thought it was deeply shameful and awful. And now I'm like, Thank fuck for what I discovered was actually an eating disorder. Because it saved me, it means that I'm alive today, whereas who knows what could have happened? So let's see what people say about sugar addiction. So sugar consumption can create a short term high, and a spark of energy in the body. Some studies have suggested sugar is as addictive as cocaine have they have have?

Where's your link? This is from addiction. center.com. Do they link back to the studies? No, they don't have a studies study saying this. No. No. So what we know and it's pretty, it's well established. And, you know, therapists and people will say, Listen, studies have been done on human brains to see what happens when they eat food or have sugar or whatever. And it lights up. And so it's like, Dun dun dun. It lights up. Uh huh. Evidence that's we have a food addict on our hands. And oh, okay, now let's let's get them to have a hug from someone they love. Oh, it it like it lights up. Oh, they are maybe they're also addicted to hugs. Oh, and let's show them pictures of puppies. Oh, the light. It lights up? Oh, they're probably a fucking puppy addict too. You know? So the stuff that lights up. is is it's a reward is a reward. Right? And so anything that we enjoy, we're getting dopamine, we're getting reward in our beautiful brains from that thing. And if it happens to be food, or it happens to be watching someone, you know, hug a puppy on YouTube. It's the same thing is happening, right? So people who talk about carbohydrate carbohydrate, so copperheads a carbohydrate addicts.com This one was funny. As many as 75% of those who are fat are addicted to carbohydrates. Oh. Is that so 75% of fat people are addicted to carbohydrates. Wow. That's such great information where did that study come from? Oh, there is no study. Oh, you just seen it. They end with this craving reward negative consequence cycle suggests that yes, carbs are addictive.

So says So does it listen to the study. So this study is evidence for sugar addiction behavioral and neurochemical effects of intermittent excessive sugar intake. And I want to use their definition of addiction. So we can look at you know, does this sound like what happens with food? They say the diagnostic criteria for addiction can be grouped into three stages. Binging withdrawal role. Credit has three stages. It's not three stages is more. Anyway, they talk about the these are these are the stages. Okay group grouped into different ones. Okay, so binging, withdrawal, craving and sensitization I fucking hate that word. I can never say it right centralization. Okay, so let's talk about him. Binging Alright, so, as we know, there is there are times in our lives where we will binge and it will just be a normal part of life. It was my birthday last week. I was like okay, well, what can I what am I going to have for dinner? I'm gonna buy some things I really like. So did I buy something? Yeah, yeah, yeah, I got a I got an ice cream. And I got a Chinese takeaway. And I ordered from I really love cinema popcorn. So I ordered from the cinema, this popcorn. And I was like this jumbo popcorn and I was like, oh, it's probably, you know, the size of two larges. Turns out it was the size of six largers. So, I was eating, I was eating that popcorn and my, my Chinese hadn't arrived yet. And so I was like eating the popcorn and and the Chinese arrived to house in Chinese and I was like, oh my god, I'm really full. And so I forgot about the ice cream. Anyway, so there we go, that's a binge. I mean, you could suggest that oh, maybe, you know, a binges is if we're getting into like pathological like, you know, fast and, you know, other other things that are going on to make it more kind of less relaxed than what I was doing right? I was just like, chowing down on some on some nice food, and ate too much for what my body wanted at that time. And that's okay. Right. So, and then we also then have it then moving into something that is a little bit more harmful, maybe to my mental health. And that would be moving into BDD. So binge eating disorder. And so we can have signs and symptoms of BDD, but not actually, like full blown BDD. And I'll talk about that more later what that looks like. And so Okay, so with the for the diagnostic criteria of this is first is binging. Okay, so we know that someone can binge in a way that is not harmful for them away, that is just a normal part of being a human being. And we also know it's a part of, of something which is a mental health condition, an eating disorder. And so it is not necessarily addiction. Next is withdrawal. Okay, so let me tell you what, we're talking about withdrawal. They use withdrawal from opioids as their criteria. And so does this sounds familiar to you? When you have eaten food, and you or whatever it is sugar, whatever you feel like you might be addicted to Does this sound familiar? Of when you haven't had access to that food? Trembling and tremors, muscle pain or aches, hunger or loss of appetite, fatigue, sweating, irritability, agitation, depression, anxiety, nausea, vomiting, confusion, insomnia, paranoia, seizures, dilated pupils. I mean, maybe a few of them. Anxiety, maybe no. But really, that doesn't sound about right does it? That doesn't sound about right, that doesn't feel like the experience of what's happening when you are not getting access to this substance, which is sugar or food or whatever. By the way, our bodies need food.

sugar, carbohydrates, right? Our bodies need that. And so, I mean, if you went long enough, without eating, you probably would start doing this stuff. But I'm talking about like the kind of say, between, you know, when you've had your lunch and to having your data or whatever, this stuff is not happening, because it's not like we need to keep fueling that, quote, addiction, because it's just a normal body function. Eating is like something that we just have to do. And yes, our body will say, Hey, I'm hungry, feed me and different things are happening with our body when we're hungry. But it's not because we're withdrawing from, we're in withdrawal from this quote, drug, right. Next, they say craving. So craving they say often has reference to extreme motivation, which can be measured using operant conditioning. So I'd say yes, we could, we could be craving. But I think what we're saying here is the extreme motivation. And I think when we're getting to the extreme motivation, that's when we're getting into eating disorder territory. That's when we're getting into maybe the IDI, right. of, you know, it doesn't matter if it's the middle of the night, I'm going to go drive to my 24 hour supermarket and buy the things that I want. And, again, that's not addiction that is falling into BDD, binge eating disorder. sensitization let me read what they say here. Behavioral sensitization is typically measured as an increased locomotion in response to repeat it administration's of a drug. For example, after repeated doses of amphetamine followed by abstinence a challenge dose, which has little or no effect in naive animals cause markethive For activity, animal synthesize to one seven is often show cross sensitization, which is defined as an increased local motor response to a different drug or substance. Cross sensitization can also be manifest in consumer Tory behavior. Animals synthesized to one drug may show increased intake of a different drug. In other words, one drug drug acts as a gateway to another. So we think about this what this is saying in plain language is you build a tolerance for food and then you can't get enough and then you are going to cross over into needing other substance substances because you know, eating food just doesn't do it for you anymore. And you know, you eat 75 Twinkies in an hour and it's not enough and that's not what happens right? That doesn't probably doesn't sound familiar to you. Where you one day will be having one square of chocolate and then the next day it's like okay, well I now I'm on 275 packs a chocolate you know because my tolerance is built up and now I forget food that food was such a you know that does nothing for me anymore now I've now I'm now I'm using different substances like that's not what happens. And this is what they're talking about. Right? They're talking about this and then this study. This study is a study that they've done on DACA guess what they did that on? They did on rats, Oh, rats, the pool rats. And then like, Oh, rats, like sugar water and they they will choose sugar water over plain water. Or fucking No shit.

Rats Don't, don't rats don't live in a world that says if you eat sugar, what are your piece of shit and have parents mums who say you look a bit fat or, you know, live in a society that values them for their parents, their rats? They're going to be like, Okay, what how can I live longer? I'm going to get as you know, this nice juicy sweet water. Because it fucking days good. We're not rats, right? Okay, so everything about the diet land swing, to the land, the diet, land swing is restriction to bench if you think about a swing, if you pull it up in restriction, it has to go down and it's going to go into binge and so you restrict binge restrict binge and the more you pull it up into restrict, the more it's going to go over into binge. So and that's restriction physically and mentally, and restriction makes you fixated on food. It makes food taste more delicious. And one thing one thing that it does is it increases our appetites when we restrict the hormones that make us feel hungry. Increase. Ghrelin is made in the stomach and it stimulates hunger by entering the brain and acting on the neurons in the hypothalamus to increase the activity of hunger, causing nerve cells and reducing the activity of hunger inhibiting cells. And as the stomach empties the release of ghrelin increases the hormones that make us feel full. What do you think they go down? So you're really craving food. Leptin is the most powerful appetite suppressing hormone and is made in fat cells. And so if we're not eating food, and we are our bodies is like, okay, what can that do to make them eat, I'm gonna make them feel really, really hungry. And even if they I'm gonna make them feel hungry still, because we don't have food. Also, your body will make the sight sound, taste and smell of food increase, it'll just make it way more appetizing. And so you'll be like, Oh my god, I'm just salivating I'm just walked by we I just walked by a food store and I'm fucking salivating what's wrong with me? That's your body being like, hey, fake mag me that thing that you've said that we're not allowed to have and your metabolism slows down. The other thing is that your muscle mass decreases and your your fat mass increases because muscle uses more energy so we don't need our body to be burning more energy we need to be burning less energy if we're literally starving. And so you don't want to move your body as much and so that's going to add to what you got to like, oh my god, I'm so lazy. I just can't be bothered to do anything. I'm just such a I'm addicted to food. I can't I don't want to move my body. I'm just a piece of shit. And all of this can be really alarming and feel Like addiction and feel like we're just out of control and food has his grip on us. And just really distressing. So was I addicted to food in the past? Well, I was addicted to food in the same way that I'm addicted to breathing air. I was addicted to food. And the same way I'm addicted to drinking water the same way I'm addicted to sleeping or having a nice poo, you know, it's a normal body function. And the moment that you were denied that, then you were going to need more of it. And we'll talk about the definition of addiction addiction is a brain disorder characterized by compulsive engagement in rewarding stimuli despite adverse consequences. Well, people are saying, well, the adverse consequences is fatness. But we know that some some folks can eat food and never gain weight. They can they really struggle with it, and they're really struggling to keep weight on. And so would they be a food addict? Because they don't have quote, adverse consequences. But what about if someone is already fat? And they are, quote, a food addict? But they don't have they don't put on any other way? Are they a food addict? Or is that a not a food addict? Because it seems like rewarding stimuli despite adverse consequences. And it's a framing of fatness as an adverse consequence and a framing of of eating food as a direct tie to gaining weight. And we know it's actually a lot more complicated than that. But reasons why people are fat are in the hundreds.

Yeah, all of this stuff, it's It's enough to make you feel irrational and desperate and imbalanced and feeling addicted. So really, when I was in that feeling, like as addictive stage, what was what I was experienced was binge eating disorder. And binge eating disorder is seen as this sister to bulimia, but without the purging. And so folks who experienced BPD may have a compulsion to eat more food than their body currently needs in one session, to the point where they feel like it's a problem, and they feel like it's disordered. As humans, we all binge all the time, right? As I discussed, and it's totally normal. The difference is the restriction phase and the guilt and the feeling of compulsion, and maybe eating alone or in secret or having binge foods, or maybe not even enjoying the food or the taste, just eating. And it's actually the most prevalent eating disorder in adults. And it's still a relatively new concept. It's only it was only formally recognized, and in 2013, one to 3% of the population have BPD, and is spread equally between men and women. We have no good information on gender nonconforming, non binary or trans people. But we do know gender queer folks experience EDS more than other groups, probably due to the stress of living in a marginalized body. When I was growing up, there was anorexia and bulimia right. As in, you know, that's what the general public talked about. And what an eating disorder looked like, to me was a thin white teenage girl who was not eating enough food. But the reality is that eating disorders come in many different forms. And the indiscriminate right, anyone can have an eating disorder. And the difference between disordered eating and an eating disorder is the impact it's having on your life. And so you remember I said before, like, I think, you know, most people in our society engages in some type of disordered eating. And I think that the, the, you know, someone could be engaging in daily restriction, for example, and it have a massive amount of impact on their life and their mental health or as someone else could be engaging in the exact same behaviors, and it could be okay for them, right? And so we can be getting engaging in the same behaviors and it just not have an impact or have an impact. It's about how much it's impacting your life. And people who have BPD tend to have higher levels of body dissatisfaction and lower self esteem and it's linked to being restrictive with food. Okay, dieting, and it can be a method for coping with other issues. Yeah, so what about sugar? Ah, so, studies have shown no conclusive evidence that sugar is addicted to human addictive for humans. So if you think about what behaviors someone who is addicted to a substance display, are we displaying them with sugar, you know, are we hitting rock bottom and, you know, stealing and ending up in in prison because of the things that you're needing to do to, to meet up with the supply of food or sugar that you need to hit because your tolerance is getting more and more? No, we're not seeing that, right. And if you were addicted to sugar, you'd be addicted to sugar in all forms, right? You'd be addicted to drinking catch up, or, you know, eating mangoes or, or iced tea, right. But it's when we often think about sugar addiction, we think about things that are, quote, the bad foods, right? What diet culture has told us of the bad foods versus just sugar, you know, eating a sugar cube the big thing here to think about is that symptoms of addiction increase with more access to the substance substance you're addicted to. Okay, so if you're taking more of something that is actually addictive, you're like you smoking cigarettes, you smoking 10 a day and then you're like, oh, let's get you know,

I've got a 20 pack on i 20, you're going to become more addicted, right. And so the next day, you're going to have to have a 20 pack again, because the 10 is not going to do it for you. Whereas symptoms of food addiction or sugar addiction, decrease and disappear, with access with more access to sugar and food. So the more we allow ourselves to eat sugar, eat food, the less those feelings of addiction are present. And that is the big difference is the source of feeling addicted, is restriction. Also, you don't need drugs, you do need sugar, you do need food, our brains need sugar, and carbs to function. Glucose, a form of sugar is the primary source of energy for every cell in the body. The less sugar sugar you eat, the more you're going to crave it. So no, we're probably not addicted to food, or to sugar.

I think about it too. Like you know, I've used this analogy before. About imagine if we were free divers and holding our breath and going down as deep as possible. Coming back to the surface, the first thing that we're going to do is gasping for air. Take a deep breath in because we have been starved of that air our body is saying get to that surface, hurry up. Quick breathe, taking a big gulp because we haven't had air for x x long. And our bodies are doing the same with food with sugar, whatever, whether what you know, those those those things that we need in our bodies. And when you restrict it's like you're going diving, you can't stay down there forever, or you'll die. And and so we need to surface and the more we say there's something wrong with me because I took a deep breath and the deep breath is binging is eating foods that we've we have decided is bad. The more we say that that was that is wrong and pathologize it the more we're going to try and force ourselves to beat living under the water. But like just stay under the water longer. And you won't need to breathe as much. It doesn't work like that. Because we need to breathe, it will be good. We need to eat or we'll be good. We need sugar or we'll be dead

Yeah, so let's give a roundup of everything that we've we've talked about right now. So is food or sugar addiction real. So if you think about food all the time, and maybe you count down the minutes until you can eat again or you have a preference for foods that you label as bad or sugar filled or unhealthy. This can feel really distressing and can feel like we're addicted like There's something really wrong with us. However, there isn't any evidence to show that what happens in our brains is addiction in the same way as other substances. Our reward centers in our brains do light up, but they are the same ones that light up when we hug someone we love, or we watch a funny video or we see a cute puppy. And the big reason why people feel addicted to sugar because we really can feel addicted to sugar or food is one they are restricting that food or sugar or to they actually have an eating disorder. And for both scenarios, the food addiction symptoms will decrease and hopefully disappear when we fully physically and mentally allow ourselves those things into our lives that sugar that food and that's a big difference with substance addiction the opposite happens so the more the more substances are, are actually addictive that you have in your life the more you consume consume them those addictive feelings increase because they are actually addictive. Whereas with food with sugar the more access we have to it those addiction feelings decrease the more we allow ourselves and that's a big difference between something that's that's actually addictive and something that just feels addictive. So no food or sugar addiction isn't real but can it can really feel like it when we restrict ourselves so hopefully we can we can put that one to bed we can say okay, really I just need to know if you feel it if you're really struggling and you're feeling like you know out of control it would be if you can it'd be really good idea to go and talk to a mental health professional if that's available for you. And you know big compassion because this stuff is like this the rhetoric we have around addiction one around food and eating too much of it to and around fatness three, like Ha like imagine that amount of iron we need to say imagine well, we have a lot of us have felt it, you know, that amount of shame is overwhelming and powerful and sucks, right? And so if you're in that position then I sending sending out love to you all the love to you and hoping that you can find some comfort and some peace and know that you're not alone. You know, the most prevalent eating disorder is binge eating disorder. And Also heads up fat people can be anorexic. And it's not normal, or normal. It is normal for people to be stressed around food, but really, we should have a peaceful relationship with food if possible. So all right, well, thanks for hanging out with me. This is on pressure on aw and I'll see you in the next episode. Stay fierce fatty See you in a while and again.

EP133 Transcript

You're listening to The Fierce Fatty Podcast Episode 133. I'm your host, Vinny Welsby. What is the title of this episode? Is the opioid crisis a myth? Let's do it.

Hello Hello sorry, I didn't have my my page I didn't have my my screen on the front of my scroll down in my document. Okay, I'll scroll down to my document. I wasn't at the title.

Is the obesity epidemic Demick real that was the title is the obesity epidemic real I'm sure you'll you'll get it you'll get it. Hey, welcome to this episode. Nice to see. To see you nice. If you're British, you'll recognize that if you're British and about 37 years old. Welcome to this episode. I'm feeling a I'm filling like a seven at attend today on the life satisfaction scale. But I just made up.

I did a training yesterday. for healthcare professionals or anyone who has clients who are fat, dietitians, fitness influencers, that type of thing called How to make your social media presence fat, positive, critical mistakes to avoid and what to do instead.

It was so fucking good, I'm tooting my horn to eat the shit out of it. So I shared case studies and examples on what to do what maybe what you want to avoid doing on social media or if you have clients like aka how to not fuck up fat people with your contact with a huge kind of disclaimer of we're all going to fuck up and I've made all of the mistakes, pretty much, pretty much have made. So many of the mistakes anyway, so that was really good. If you want to catch the replay the recording you can I'll put a link in the show notes. But if you ever want to do consulting with me in any way, shape or form, like having me come to talk to your company or train your dieticians or do an audit of your stuff, you can always go to first fatty consulting.com First fatty consulting.com Okay, so

I can't believe I've not already done an episode specifically on the quote, obesity epidemic, huge trigger warning, I'm going to be using the Oh words, I'm going to try and like get rid of them get rid of that show. As much as possible. But I mean, is in the title, right? So.

So if that's like, if you're like, I just don't want to hear the words, I don't want to have any say quote unquote, 75 times, then skip this episode. But I feel like you know what, they're sometimes when you're talking to folks. And like you when I say you, I mean you not me? Well, me too, I guess. But when, when we're talking to people about like this stuff, like, oh, how you know how fat people are human and stuff? And, you know, people are like, ooh, gross, no, they're not.

They will come up with speaking points that they don't really know much about. It's just kind of like regurgitated information that they've heard online or the we'll know stuff, which is we all know that fat people are unhealthy and they're gonna die, and all that type of stuff.

And so, I thought, you know, an episode talking about the obesity epidemic, like what it is where it's come about, is it real? Like, is it valid?

At the end, I'll give kind of like a, an overview. So you've got that kind of overview. Also, I'm going to make it into a little social media posts, like, you know, bullet point thing. So, if you're listening to the episode, then it's probably going to be up on my Instagram already, kind of like a bullet point of everything that I'm sharing so that you can share that on your social media if you want or if you just want to reference it.

About this pandemic of fat people going round and eating babies off the street.

Wait, oh my god. Yeah, so fun time.

I'm gonna be reading from a few different sources here. I've decided this one article is just so fucking good. I'm just gonna read the whole thing. I was like, oh, pick up this quote, and then I'm like, no pick up this quote, or this one to listen to. I was like, it's a whole fucking article. It's just so good. It's not that long anyway, so, but it's so good. It was just like, the person that they're the person they're interviewing is, is no longer alive because this is an interview from I think, like 10 years 1012 years ago. Anyway. So I'm, like, are so sad that they're not alive anymore, so we can talk about this stuff.

Anyway, so basically, basic, basic, I think, basically, we're starting a probably hour long podcast. Exactly. talk for an hour. Let's start with let's start with this. Let's start with an excerpt from a book, a book written by Harriet brown that came out in 2015. I read it in 2015. And like, kind of heads up this she uses yo words, right.

And the book excerpt was made into a kind of post for the New York Post. So it's an excerpt of the book, but you can read it on line link to all the show notes. All the All, all the all of the studies, everything I mentioned is going to be in the show notes. Or fist fighting.com. Forward slash one, three through.

Yes. So the title of this article is, the obesity crisis is a myth. The book by Harriet Brown is called body of truth.

Harry Brown author of brave girl eating, I read that one too. I think it was I think that was about her daughter who hadn't Edie correct me if I'm wrong. My person who is not here who's you can't respond? Nobody. There's not right. Anyway.

So yeah, kind of like take this with a kind of grain of Harriet's maybe not as clued in on social justice language, versus looking at science and that type of stuff. Okay, so here's a quote from that.

Back in 1958 AJ stunk ARD a well known obesity researcher and professor at the University of Pennsylvania wrote of, of obese people who lot lose weight, most will regain it.

Just a heads up that is. So FYI, that is the first study what what Harriet is talking about here. 1958 simcard study is the first study that says 95% of diets fail. So

people who are pro diet will say, well, there was just one study from the 50s that says that 95% of diets fail. And that's what people are quoting. And that's what people are using. So that is data is so out of date. If that was the only study then yeah, 1958 that data would be so out of date, but this is the first time it was established. And it's been reestablished many times over many times over really good science on that. But that's that's just like the inception of it. Okay, just a heads up. Continuing in the 1970s and 1980s site and scientists like Paul urns and urns Berger now a nutrition pressure professor and researcher at Case Western University began to document the ways dieting did and usually didn't work.

nearly 30 years ago, urns burger and a colleague published an exhaustive, exhaustive review of the links between health and obesity. They pointed out that 16 long term international studies had found that overweight and obesity were not major risk factors for death, or heart disease. A US panel on obesity had relied heavily on data from the insurance industry. And since fewer heavy people bought life insurance because they had to pay more for it. The mortality rates linked to obesity skewed higher urns, Berger also drew attention to the fact that the mortality rates were lowest in the overweight category on the BMI chart chart. He and his colleagues hypothesized that some of the conditions associated with obesity, like hypertension, and elevated cardiovascular risk actually came from failed treatments that is weight cycling or losing and regaining weight over and over. And they suggested that many do

Doctors disapproval of fatness was based on moral and aesthetic biases rather than medical facts, a suggestion that has since been borne out of research into doctors clear prejudices around obesity. In 2002, William clish and a pediatric gastroenterologist featured in the movie Supersize Me Did you watch that movie? I fucking love that movie. Oh my god that was Supersize Me was that what was that guy's name? Morgan gingerols he went no the premise of the movie was he was only allowed to eat McDonald's for X amount of days let's say a month two months whatever.

Unknown Speaker 10:40

And then they they couldn't he was a vegan before and if they offered to supersize at the at the McDonald's he had to accept it

Unknown Speaker 10:52

turns out he got fed up of eating McDonald's surprise fucking surprise

Unknown Speaker 11:00

and the thing is right like this whole

Unknown Speaker 11:04

I don't think most fat people are eating McDonald's three meals a day

Unknown Speaker 11:11

is the whole thing is just the whole movie was fucked up right? Oh, maybe it's fucked up. Anyway, continuing on. If you've not seen it, don't bother. It's fucking I loved it at the time because it was fat phobic. But you know, anyway, okay, so the the, the pediatric gastroenterologist featured in the movie Supersize Me told a reporter from the Houston Chronicle. If we don't get this obesity epidemic in check, for the first time in this century, children will be looking forward to a shorter life expectancy than their parents. Now, have you heard that before? That the children are going to be we're going to be bearing children, because they're going to be so fat and unhealthy? You've heard that before? I've heard that before. Maybe you haven't. But you know, it's very common rhetoric.

Unknown Speaker 12:01

Think about how much data and science is behind that.

Unknown Speaker 12:07

What we had to look into to get that that data that this gastroenterologist on the Supersize Me movie, saying that kids are going to die before the parents continuing as clish later admitted he had absolutely no evidence for this frightening seems scenario. It was based on his quote, intuition,

Unknown Speaker 12:29

which didn't stop it from being replayed in the media and cited by researchers of course it didn't because it's That's a sexy thing to say. Kids are dying before their parents because they're so fat.

Unknown Speaker 12:42

Evidence.

Unknown Speaker 12:44

Evidence. I've got a crystal ball. My mystic mag brain is saying kids are so fat they're gonna die.

Unknown Speaker 12:55

Research.

Unknown Speaker 12:57

Study silly.

Unknown Speaker 13:01

Yes, so continuing so plushies doomsday scenario lives on, in part because it's frightening. And fear, whether justified or not is a big part of the way that we talk about weight, especially when it comes to children. According to most recent numbers from the CDC, almost half of American kids and teens fall into the either overweight or obese category categories blah, blah, blah. The problem with a BMI is it's not accurate measurement and measurement or predictor of health

Unknown Speaker 13:26

blubbery blue blue, it says nothing about a person's future risk of disease or death and it was never intended to its creator. As we know its creator Belgian mathematician Adelphi

Unknown Speaker 13:40

quitter let came up with a BMI in the 1830s as a way of looking at trends in populations, not in people. We'll talk about that a little bit more.

Unknown Speaker 13:53

Meanwhile, the cuts of points for BMI have been moved somewhat arbitrarily within the last 15 years starting in 1994. The National Institutes of Health considered children in the BMI whose BMI put them in the 95th percentile or above for the age overweight. Those in the 85th and 95th percentiles were labeled at risk of being overweight,

Unknown Speaker 14:17

and 2005. The category shifted now kids above the 95th percent percentile are labeled as obese, while those in the 85th and 95th percentile are overweight. And according to Colorado law professor Paul campus, author of the obesity myth, another little known change happened at the same time. Those percentiles were defined using data from the 1960s and 1970s rather than data on kids today, who are both taller and heavier than kids back then. In other words, or its campus when Michelle Obama claims a third of our children are too fat. What she's really saying is that what was the 85th percentile on the

Unknown Speaker 15:00

height weight charts top 40 years ago is about the 67th percentile. Today, the changing definitions make it harder to track how kids weights rather than their weight categories have actually changed. Like adults, kids average weight rose between 1980 and 2000. When they more or less stabilized, let me read that again. Like adults, kids, average weights rose between 1980 and 2000. When they more or less stabilized. Childhood fatness is commonly referred to as both an epidemic and a call to action in 2010, when First Lady Michelle Obama launched her Let's Move campaign Her goal was to, quote solve the challenge of childhood obesity within a generation. Are we really raising a generation that for the first time will not live as long as their parents craft, Catherine Fleagle. We talked about Katherine Fleegle, a couple of episodes ago, an epidemiologist at the CDC National Center of health statistics set out to map the relationship between BMI categories and mortality, they expected to find a linear relationship, the higher a person's BMI, the greater risk of them dying prematurely. But that's not what they found. Instead, Fleagle and her colleagues discovered what statisticians called a U shaped curve with the bottom of the curve, the lowest risk of death, falling around 25 to 26 on the BMI chart, making the risk of early death lowest for those now labeled overweight.

Unknown Speaker 16:37

The differences we're talking about are overall pretty tiny, explains Catherine Flugel. So so so so that's all I'm going to read about that. But there's more to that article. So if you want to go read it, or read the book for lawyers do so.

Unknown Speaker 16:54

But I wanted to start with that kind of like talking about a few of the things I want to point out today

Unknown Speaker 17:01

about

Unknown Speaker 17:05

is there an epidemic?

Unknown Speaker 17:09

Is it right to class it as an epidemic? What if there is an epidemic? What could we do?

Unknown Speaker 17:18

And so we mentioned that article weights in children and adults going up from 1980 to 2000. And then stabilizing right and

Unknown Speaker 17:31

people have slowly got have slowly become higher weight over a number of decades, decades, right?

Unknown Speaker 17:43

Kind of like a slowly uptrend, what we know is not a lot.

Unknown Speaker 17:50

We don't know why. But the there is a theory that the 70s is when we started really going balls to the wall with dieting.

Unknown Speaker 18:06

And here's the thing with people are getting a you know, a little fatter, people are getting a little fatter, right? So what we're talking about here is fat people. So people who were already fat, getting a little fatter.

Unknown Speaker 18:21

What we're not seeing or saw, because since 2000, stabilized what we didn't see was

Unknown Speaker 18:32

thin people becoming fat.

Unknown Speaker 18:36

Okay, so this rise in oh my god, you know, in 1960, everyone was thin, and there was a couple of bad fatties walking around. And now it's 2002 and this fat people everywhere.

Unknown Speaker 18:53

It's just not true, right? It's just not true, right? It's not like, there was this huge change in body sizes and thin people overnight was suddenly you know, very fat people and oh my god, it's spreading. It's you know, contagious. It's a terrible thing that's happening. It's just not happening. I'm gonna talk more about that in a shark arms.

Unknown Speaker 19:22

But I this is this is the next kind of this is the thing that I'm going to read out totally and then we're going to have shorter quotes. So this next article is from the Atlantic and it's called America's moral panic over obesity by Megan McArdle. Megan McArdle

Unknown Speaker 19:43

actually both Megan and Paul in this article,

Unknown Speaker 19:48

poor campus are say kind of things which I'm like they're a little bit ableist Megan is saying things that you're good diet culture II, so

Unknown Speaker 19:58

I don't want to just point them out when they come up.

Unknown Speaker 20:00

up. So kind of just a heads up.

Unknown Speaker 20:04

But Megan interviewed Paul. And I was just like, This is so interesting. I wish I could hear the audio for this. But so this is how it goes.

Unknown Speaker 20:13

With healthcare in the news, everyone's looking for magic bullets to save money. Obesity seems to be a growing favorite wouldn't be, it'd be great if we could make everyone look like Jennifer Aniston and be cheaper to treat. By the way, this is written in 2009. If you're thinking what the fuck is she referencing Jennifer Aniston? What it's like me when I'm like, was a stereotypically attractive Hollywood celebrity. And I'm always like Brad Pitt. And it's like,

Unknown Speaker 20:41

Brad Pitt is like 75 years old now. So, like, come up with a new example. Right? So yeah.

Unknown Speaker 20:50

And of course, He's not 75 He's 60 or something. 50 Whatever. So continuing, there are a lot of holes in this theory. And also, even if he is 50, or 60, doesn't mean he's not attractive anymore, but I'm just thinking of, you know, the stereotypical hunk Hollywood hunk. Anyway, there's a lot of holes in his theory. The morbidly obese are very sick but die young, while lower levels of overweight slash obesity aren't so well correlated with poor health. But still the idea that ideas power seems to be growing every day.

Unknown Speaker 21:22

This week again, take take what she's saying with a pinch of salt. This week, Health Affairs published a new study showing that kill Sopris obesity accounts for an ever growing share of our health care costs. They put the number at about 10%.

Unknown Speaker 21:39

I found that very interesting. Right, so 10% of health care costs, is treating fatness man a minute.

Unknown Speaker 21:48

I thought that we were in an epidemic where everyone's fat. Should I be like be like, I don't know. 90%. Like, it'd be a higher number than 10%. I was like 10%. And anyways, we just established another episodes. Those numbers are really faulty. And we're talking about but anyway, Keep coming. Keep going. giving it all away. So I decided to ask Paul kamphaus, the author of the obesity myth, what he thought the book which everyone should read, argues that the health benefits of losing weight are largely imaginary, that we are using, quote health to advance our class bias in favor of thin people, particularly thin women, women, women, women, we mean

Unknown Speaker 22:36

that's how my mum says women women, my mum says women in a really weird way. Okay, so Megan,

Unknown Speaker 22:43

Should I do a different voice for Megan? So you know, when Megan speaking and when Paul speaking?

Unknown Speaker 22:48

Yeah, I do. Like I'll do like a slightly different voice for Megan. And then just in my normal voice. Well, Paul,

Unknown Speaker 22:54

what's always going to be the CDC is sponsoring a conference on obesity this week. In conjunction with this, the journal Health Affairs just published a study showing that almost 10% of US medical costs may be due to obesity. As we're debating the cost of public health care plan. Controlling obesity is moving even further to the forefront of American public health agenda. What should we think of this pool?

Unknown Speaker 23:23

It's a terrible idea on all sorts of levels. There are three big problems as attempting to control healthcare costs by reducing so called obesity. First, it's a vague problem. Second, the solutions for the problem a nonexistent even assuming the problem existed. Third, focusing on making American Center diverts resources from real public health issues.

Unknown Speaker 23:47

Megan, let's start with the first. Is there some one thing is that if there's one thing that everyone in America knows is that being fat is really unhealthy? Why do you call it a fake problem?

Unknown Speaker 24:04

The correlations between higher weight and greater health risk are weak except at statistical extremes. The extent to which these those correlations are causal is more is poorly established. There is literally not a shred of evidence at turning fat people into thin people improves their health. And the reason there's no evidence is that there's no way to do it. So saying let's improve health by turning fat people into thin people is every bit as irrational as saying let's improve health by turning men into women or old people into young people. Actually, it's a lot crazier ableist because there actually are significant health health differences between men and women and the young and old, much more so than between the fat and the thin.

Unknown Speaker 24:54

So why is it that the health public health community is so set on this issue?

Unknown Speaker 25:00

You as a major driver, or healthcare costs,

Unknown Speaker 25:04

because we're in the midst of a moral panic over fat which has transformed the heavier than average folk,

Unknown Speaker 25:12

heavier than average into folk devils, to whom all sorts of social ills are ascribed,

Unknown Speaker 25:19

assigned aside from rising healthcare costs, well, according to the obesity mafia,

Unknown Speaker 25:26

love that phrase, NBC mafia, kids are all going to die sooner than their parents, which sounds like a moral problem as well as one of one of healthcare costs. It's all complete nonsense. Do you think being overweight is a proxy for for things that do make a difference like fitness?

Unknown Speaker 25:46

It's a weak proxy. But yes, it has some magical marginal significance. It's good to encourage people of all sizes to be active and avoiding eating disorder behaviors, like dieting, but this isn't because lifestyle changes will make fat people thin. They won't. I'd like to talk a little bit about the statistics, if I may, please, we're all about statistics here. Okay. The CDC honchos and the authors of this study you referenced are in hysterics, because the obesity rate, so called has roughly doubled in the last 30 years, but let's consider what that actually means. Obesity is defined completely arbitrarily as a body mass index of x x x. Now, body mass follows more of a less normal distribution, more or less a normal distribution, which means if the mean body weight is in the mid to high 20s, which it has been for many decades now, then 10s of millions of people will have BMI just below or just above the magic 30 line. So if the average weight of the population goes up by 10 pounds, 10s of millions of people who were just under the line will now be just over it. This might be meaningful if there were was any evidence that people who have BMI in the low 30s have different average health than the people with BMI is in the high 20s. But they don't at all. So the obesity epidemic is 100%, a product of 10s of millions of people having their BMI is creep over an arbitrary line is exactly as sensible as declaring that people who are 511 are healthy, but people who are six one are sick. Adding to the absurdity of all of this people with BMI in that mid to high 20s actually have the best overall health and longest life expectancy, more so than those in the so called quote normal BMI range.

Unknown Speaker 28:03

So we can't save billions of dollars by making people thinner.

Unknown Speaker 28:08

Consider the methodology of this study, it tried to calculate changes in health costs, if everybody with a BMI over 30 had a BMI under 25. But leaving aside the preposterous assumption that all increased health risks associated with a level of body mass are caused by that level of body mass. The idea that somehow we could make fat people into thin people is bizarre. A study like this isn't talking about turning an 180 pound woman into 165 pound woman, which, at least in theory might actually be possible. He's saying that because with when you're in a set weight range, right, our set weight is you know, been between 10 and 20 pounds. And so it's kind of like losing weight to be in that set weight range is is more likely possible. And especially short term it is then losing weight from outside of your setpoint range continuing it's talking about turning a 200 pound woman into 130 pound woman on statistical average, the success rate for such attempts is around about 0.1% I'm going to read the whole thing I started like this isn't talking about turning in 180 pound woman into 165 pound pound woman is talking about turning a 200 pound woman into 130 pound woman. On statistical average, the success rate for such attempts is around 0.1% Even stomach amputation does not turn fat people into thin people. So even if there are if it is true that we knew it would be beneficial to turn fat people into thin people, which we don't. It's not something we have any idea how to do the statements in the study indicating that there are known methods for doing this

Unknown Speaker 30:00

are simply lies of the most egregious sort. Now let's talk about excess health care costs. If you look at the study, nearly half of the excess health care costs associated with being fat, have our higher rates of drug prescription. But Why Are Fat People being prescribed more drugs and largely because they have the quote disease of being fat, which is then treated directly and indirectly by prescription drugs, for instance, statins, statins are a multibillion dollar business, but there's very little statistical evidence that they benefit the mass vast majority of people to whom they're prescribed. Basically, the only people who have lower CVD cardiovascular disease, mortality after taking statins are middle aged men with a history of CVD. But the heavier than average are prescribed statins at higher rates simply because they're heavier than average, even though that's no evidence this is beneficial for them. And of course, this doesn't touch touch on the cost of all the treatments for obesity in itself which are uniformly ineffective. Also here I would add in that Paul's not mentioned is that fat people are are treated or tested more often, right? So fat people if a fat person walks in, and it's like oh shit, we need to test that motherfucker for for for diabetes because they're fat. Whereas a fat whereas a thin person is under diagnosed because it's not likely that that a doctor and nurses has some sort of history or signs or whatever is one thing person's body and say we need to run tests.

Unknown Speaker 31:37

I know like my blood work might fucking how like, you've got a history of my life and blood work

Unknown Speaker 31:44

forever, right? I feel like I've been tested for everything.

Unknown Speaker 31:48

And I wonder if that would be the same if I was thin? I don't know. But I know that that fat people are more routinely checked for certain things because people are just doctors, healthcare providers presume that

Unknown Speaker 32:03

there's health risks there. And therefore then there's going to be more money spent on fat people versus thin people because thin people aren't getting the treatment that they deserve. And fat people are being tested more often for things that they might not have.

Unknown Speaker 32:18

Continuing so this is Megan, you're saying that increased risks from being heavy come from what having gained weight in the first place bad genetics or dieting.

Unknown Speaker 32:29

As for where the increased risks associated with being heavy come from, such as they are, many of them come from weight cycling, which is clearly bad for people and which is the outcome of 98% of diets. Others come from the stress and stress and social discrimination generated by having what's considered an inappropriate cult body and its culture. Other comes from diet drugs, eating disordered behavior, like dieting poverty, all the things strongly associated with higher higher than average weight.

Unknown Speaker 33:00

This is me talking now since this this article since Paul's been speaking about this research has come out to show that there's there's literally hundreds of reasons why white people are fat. And

Unknown Speaker 33:14

and the risks are exactly what he's saying. Is this stuff, right?

Unknown Speaker 33:20

Yeah, continuing Megan says, What about gastric bypass? The quoted figures for gastric bypass seem pretty impressive when doctors talk about them on television. Great question, Megan. I'm thinking gastric bypass is surgically induced bulimia people start for the first few months. So of course there but blood sugar levels go down at five and 10 year follow up. The average weight loss from these procedures is about 10 to 15% of body mass. It's actually less than that since lots of people drop out from the studies, which means most of these people will still end up quote, morbidly obese and they can never eat normally again. Why do you think that we never see the actual stats for weight loss on stomach from stomach stapling. If they were good, they'd be on Billboard's 50 feet high. Yeah, right.

Unknown Speaker 34:09

Right. Megan says those shows on TLC that basically invite the audience to go get fat people usually say they'll lose 50% of their excess body weight. Notice how Megan says excess body weight as if the body weight is bad. Paul says if you put people on starvation diets, which is what these methods do, of course, you'll get huge amounts of weight loss, then most of all, or all of it will be gained back which among other things is a recipe for congestive heart failure? I'd love to do a quick reality show on the contestants on shows like The Biggest Loser three years down the road, but that would be probably a little bit too much reality. And actually since this has come out there wasn't an article study kind of follow up on the biggest losers to see how they're doing. What was it

Unknown Speaker 35:00

it what it was in the New York something, whatever.

Unknown Speaker 35:03

And basically, that they're fat right?

Unknown Speaker 35:07

On the ones that who have kept it off or are having to do really disordered things to keep it off.

Unknown Speaker 35:15

Paul continues, gastric bypass is the most radical method available for weight loss and it basically doesn't work. Everything else is is even less successful, though usually not quite as dangerous. Over the last five years or so I've noticed that public health efforts about obesity are not just amping up the volume, but exploring increasingly coercive methods to induce weight loss, taxes on junk food, lawsuits against fast food companies, which are basically tax on junk food and so forth. Does that match your analysis? Notice here how Meghan uses words like junk food, and that's that's stigmatizing right? A lot of people will eat convenience food. And that's what's available. That's what's easy. That's what filling and nutritious to feed the family. If you're you know, for many different reasons, and it doesn't make it junk.

Unknown Speaker 36:07

That's that's not Paul. That's me saying that it's kind of like pointing out the things which are my color, though. We weird. No, this is 10 years later, I probably change a few things here.

Unknown Speaker 36:19

Not that I did it. But you know, Paul says it's a classic pattern of moral panics. As public concern about the damage being done to the fabric of society by the folk devils increases, increasingly intense demands are made on public officials to do something about the crisis, usually by a limited eliminating the folk devils.

Unknown Speaker 36:41

Yeah, that kind of hand wringing, do something about this, you have to do something. And you know, policymakers who, who don't understand. Don't know what's going on is like, oh, okay, well, I'll put a tax on, on food and

Unknown Speaker 36:58

taxing food that's going to help make sure that poor fat people die. Yes, great idea. Continuing that, that, of course, is a strategy for this crisis crisis. If fat people are the problem, then the solution is to get rid of them by making them thin people. The most amazing aspect of this whole thing for me has always been the imperviousness of policymakers, and even more so people who consider themselves serious academics and scientists, the overwhelming evidence that there is no way to do this. I mean, there's no better established empirical proposition in medical science that we don't know how to make people thinner. But apparently, this proposition is too disturbing to consider, even though it's it's about as well established as cigarettes causing lung cancer. So all of these proposals about improving public health by making people thinner are completely crazy. ableist they are nonsensical as anything being promoted proposed by public officials in our culture right now, which is saying something.

Unknown Speaker 38:00

Yeah, like, it makes me think about, you know, policymakers or scientists or whoever.

Unknown Speaker 38:08

And now even in nowadays, right, it's very well established that we can't make fat people thinner.

Unknown Speaker 38:16

How it's almost like,

Unknown Speaker 38:20

then like zombies, right? Something has overtaken their brain.

Unknown Speaker 38:25

Right? This, whatever it is, that happens to zombies. And in our society, we've got the idea of fat people or unhealthy fat people who just lose weight, you know, all of these things that we just quote, no.

Unknown Speaker 38:40

And no amount of evidence, even if they're there, they're doing the work themselves, and they know that there is no evidence to prove that we can make fat people thinner. And that fat is not necessarily unhealthy. It doesn't matter like same with a zombie. It doesn't matter if you would reason with a zombie. If you said, Hey, zombie, please don't eat me. The zombies like give me your brains. Give me your brains. And it's the same with, you know, like, obesity researchers. They're just like, I don't care. Because I think that it's bad to be fat. There's no reasoning, there's kind of like they just want to they just come in for the phase, you know, they come for the phase, I think the phase should just go away and stop being fat.

Unknown Speaker 39:22

And that's how I kind of see it of, Oh, my goodness, sometimes there's just no reasoning. You just have to run yes or run.

Unknown Speaker 39:32

Continuing, it's conceivable that through some massive policy interventions, you might be able to reduce the populations average BMI from 27 to 25, or something like that. But what would be the point there aren't any health differences to speak of for people between BMI of about 20 and 35. So undertaking the public health equivalent of the Apollo program to reduce a populaces average BMI by a unit or two and again,

Unknown Speaker 40:00

Then I will emphasize that we don't actually know if we could even do that is an incredible waste of public health resources.

Unknown Speaker 40:10

The idea I'm hearing now is that we need to change the environment. But of course, if losing a great deal of weight actually makes you unhealthier, that might not save us money. The other idea I'm hearing a lot is these days is that we have to save the kids intervene when they're young, so they're no get fat in the first place.

Unknown Speaker 40:28

So the strategies that have failed, so spec tacular, Lee with adults, tell them to exercise more and eat less and shame them about their weight will work with children. Because if there's one thing that kids need, it's to be made to feel bad about being fat. The current stigma stigmatization of fat kids is essentially child abuse is government policy. And the people behind it are, as far as I'm concerned, either incredibly stupid, ableism or very evil, or in some cases, both. Here's an idea, stop harassing people about their weight, because it appears that focusing on the idea that fat actually makes people fatter, because it appears that focusing on the idea, but focus on the idea that being fat actually makes people being paid, make people fatter. This would I'd say this would be a little bit I want to like point out here that that's not necessarily a bad thing, right? We're present we're positioning it as fatness increased fatness is a negative outcome, whereas it's just, you know, a different body size. And yes, there could be negative outcomes in regards to increase stigma and, and everything that comes from that. And, and what Paul's saying here is that it's doing the opposite that what people are trying to do, right, so if they genuinely want people to be thin, harassing them about being fat is not going to do that, right. At least there's an extremely strong correlation there. I bet if we stop demonizing fatness people would actually be a bit thinner. There, they'd certainly be happier and healthier.

Unknown Speaker 42:00

Megan says, What should we do instead, if you want to reduce healthcare costs, here are some proposed ideas I've heard taxes on soda, new urbanism, making people walk more. That's what new new urbanism is, bringing back physical education and schools make gym memberships tax deductible menu labeling? Will any of this make us healthier? If not thinner? And if not what will

Unknown Speaker 42:26

some of those ideas may have merit and merit independent of whether they'll make pin people thinner? They won't. It's good to encourage physical activity, but not if the purpose of encouraging it is to try and make people thinner, then it's counterproductive. People will be healthier if they're more active, and don't smoke, and if they avoid eating disorder behaviors, like dieting in particular, but Americans are actually very healthy and getting healthier all the time, despite the massive inefficiencies and dysfunctions of our healthcare system. Paul says another thing here, I'm not going to finish reading this but But Paul says nothing here is

Unknown Speaker 43:02

how people don't engage in, in, quote, health promoting behaviors because their health promoting it's because they will make them thin.

Unknown Speaker 43:13

And he says here, I know for a fact because they've told me that some public health officials engage in what they think of as a noble lie about the effects of physical activity on weight because they know people won't become more active just to be healthier. So the he's saying that public health officials are gay, he public health officials have told him that they lie about the fact that working out will make people thinner because it doesn't really it doesn't it doesn't have any effect on our on our weight.

Unknown Speaker 43:44

And so they lie about it, because people won't do it if they think this is what you know, the public health officials, people won't do it if they think that it's just going to be good for your health. They're doing it because

Unknown Speaker 43:58

they want to become thin. Yeah, so that's from the Atlantic so we talked about like the Oh, word epidemic of there and I want to go to a an oldie but a goodie. Well, it's actually a lot more recent underneath ones but

Unknown Speaker 44:16

the piece by your fat fat friend, Aubrey Gordon, the bizarre and racist history of the BMI. I'm going to tie all these things we're just I'm just putting all these like we're all these like ideas, concepts or whatever information out there and then I'm going to sew it all together. Okay. So I their bizarre and racist history of their BMI. So they just want to call it quote from here the body mass index was invented invented nearly 200 years ago by a Delphi quitter, let notably Cadillac and was not a physician, nor did he studied medicine. He was best known for his sociological work aimed at identifying the characteristics of long Moya, the average man whom do

Unknown Speaker 45:00

To quit let represented a social ideal Quizlet was Belgian publishing works in Western Europe during the early 19 century, a boom time for racists science. He is credited with CO founding the school of positive criminology, which asserted the dangerousness of the criminal to be the only measure of the extent to which he was punishable. That positive school laid the groundwork for criminologist like Cesar Lombroso, who believed that people of color was separate were a separate species. Homo criminalists long Lombroso argued were, quote, savages by birth, identified by physical characteristics that he claimed linked them to primates. For Lombroso people of color were some kind of subspecies congenially driven to commit crimes, in addition to paving the way for Lombroso his work what led was also credited with founding the field of Anthro

Unknown Speaker 46:07

poetry including the racist Sudha pseudoscience of phonology so phonology you remember in

Unknown Speaker 46:15

Django, when when Leo DiCaprio brings out

Unknown Speaker 46:22

a skull and so saying, okay, we can tell different races

Unknown Speaker 46:29

by this girl and this is why white people are better obviously, all of that is fucked up on bullshit

Unknown Speaker 46:36

and

Unknown Speaker 46:38

not true you know?

Unknown Speaker 46:40

But you know, this this is kind of like finding out the long way in the ideal man and man being the word exactly. Anyway, continuing to like believe that the mathematician mathematician, mathematical mean of a population was its ideal.

Unknown Speaker 47:00

And his desire to prove it resulted in the invention of the BMI a way of quantifying law Moya has weighed in initially called the Quizlet index Quizlet derived the formula basically, so based solely on the size and measurement of French and Scottish participants, that is the index was devised exclusively by and for Western Europeans. By the turn of the next century credits long Moya would be used as a measurement of fitness to parent and, and as a scientific justification for eugenics, the systemic sterilization of disabled people or autistic people, immigrants, poor people and people of color. While cat cutlets work was used to justify scientific racism for decades to come. He was clear about one aspect of the BMI. It was never intended as a measure for individual body fat build or health. For its invented, the BMI was a way of measuring populations, not individuals. And it was designed for the purpose, purposes of status statistics, not individual health.

Unknown Speaker 48:09

So

Unknown Speaker 48:11

do you remember Do you remember the episode where we talked about the psychology of hunger?

Unknown Speaker 48:19

And in there, we'll see Minnesota starvation experiments.

Unknown Speaker 48:25

The Minnesota starvation experiment was ran by Ancel Keys. So Ansell, so it worked, because the BMI wasn't called the BMI until Ancel. Keys got his hands on it. And he was basically like, Okay, well, we need to identify who is fat. Because,

Unknown Speaker 48:47

like, it might seem obvious to us now like us in this year that will obviously we know who's fat, because we will weigh them and because our eyeballs will tell us that they are fat. But actually, that's not helpful, right? It's like saying, Okay, here's a bag,

Unknown Speaker 49:12

we can see the size of the bag, but we don't know what's in the bag. So let's just measure the size of the bag to guess

Unknown Speaker 49:22

how much is in the back. And so how much fat tissue is in the body. We're going to measure how wide the bag is and how tall the bag is. And that's going to measure how much fat is in the body. Which you could open the bag and it could be filled with who knows what right. And anyway, even if it was filled with 100% fat or whatever. We don't know. We don't have the evidence to show that that is

Unknown Speaker 49:54

a negative thing. Right? So even if we could say okay, so this person is just

Unknown Speaker 50:00

Just 100% fat,

Unknown Speaker 50:03

no brain is just flat. And the BMI has told us this because we've measured their height and their weight. And the weight is how much gravity that they have.

Unknown Speaker 50:15

It's not then telling us much else. Right? And it's like this categorization of it's a disease but one of the the only thing about a disease

Unknown Speaker 50:28

what are the commonalities between diseases, you know, like, okay, so we can say that if someone has asthma, like me, I have asthma.

Unknown Speaker 50:39

Everyone who has asthma experiences,

Unknown Speaker 50:44

to certain degrees, shortness of breath,

Unknown Speaker 50:48

tightening of the airways,

Unknown Speaker 50:51

they will take an inhaler, they may need to have other

Unknown Speaker 50:56

things they also might have eczema.

Unknown Speaker 51:01

But the main thing is everyone will have tightening of my tightening of the chest some restriction and they won't be able to breathe properly. What is the what is the commonality between fat people apart from nothing? Right? There's no There's no kind of common outcome. There's no common.

Unknown Speaker 51:21

There's no I mean, connected clear kind of like okay, so fatness, the disease

Unknown Speaker 51:28

is here or the hearing here is what the outcomes of having the disease are. You know, every fat person, every fat person has heart disease, every fat person has type two diabetes every fat person, because that's not true. But hang on, they all have the disease of fatness.

Unknown Speaker 51:47

So surely it makes sense that there is commonalities. There's because it's not actually a disease, but it's been labeled a disease.

Unknown Speaker 51:56

So that we can sell drugs and get insurance companies to pay for drugs and we can continually stigmatize fat folks, because you know, and even though,

Unknown Speaker 52:07

you know, some people were like, well, if we say that fatness is a disease, it's going to stop stigma, stigmatization.

Unknown Speaker 52:16

Does anyone? Has anyone looked at the talk to the disability rights advocates, and said, how much how much stigmatization? Do people who have chronic illnesses disabilities experience do?

Unknown Speaker 52:32

Do they have a lack of stigmatization? No, they are really stigmatized. And obviously, it's, it's different for everybody with different marginalization that might come into play and different diseases be or disabilities being seen, as you know, quote, better than others, but I mean, shit that. No,

Unknown Speaker 52:55

no, no.

Unknown Speaker 52:59

Anyway, so, yeah, what I was going on talking about that was, yeah, Ansel keys, even when he was doing his kind of like, why do we define fat people? He was like, wow, the BMI is not that good, but it will do pig. You know, it's the best we've got. Because he was using calipers and water retention.

Unknown Speaker 53:24

And now we think about like water retention, that seems so funny and weird, like how we would decide a fat person about how much water they had in their body. And it seems funny and weird, because

Unknown Speaker 53:35

we're not used to it, but and it seems so obvious that will fatness is, is defined by way, but that's not obvious, because it doesn't make sense, right? The same way, like if you had gone with water, we'd be like we're obviously fatness is how much water you have in your body. And what do you mean, it's how much you gravity you have compared to the earth?

Unknown Speaker 53:58

That sounds weird. You know, it's just because it's just so normal for us.

Unknown Speaker 54:04

So, so, so, so So, so let me read this a little bit from here from Reagan. Chastain who it's it's titled Is it or it is wrong to charge large people more for insurance. And in this, Reagan talks about the newer history of the VMI, and it's categories. So three members of the committee responsible for releasing the standards for obesity, including BMI as a risk measurement at the NIH, the National Institute of Health, I've should have included that but had ties had direct ties to pharmaceuticals, that managed manufactures diet pills for profits. Let me read that again without me interjecting. So and at the NIH, the three three members of the committee responsible for releasing the standards for OB

Unknown Speaker 55:00

BCT including BMI as a risk measurement had direct ties to pharmaceuticals that manufactured diet pills for profit. A fourth member was a lead scientist for the program advisory committee of Weight Watchers International. This committee advocated dieting for everyone who has a BMI more than 24. They shave 15 to 20 pounds off the definition of quote, ideal weight, which made over 60% of Americans overweight. Overnight. Soon, we were hearing that 300,000 deaths a year were attributable to obesity. In January 2005, the CDC came out with the new quote obesity and death figures, these figures stated that no more than 110,000 deaths per year could be connected in any way with obesity. That's a Catherine Fliegl thing. They also stated that the link may be a weak one. And so even with that 110,000 ones that's associated with fatness, the link quote, maybe a weak one, the lead scientists of the CDC also said that a critical analysis of their data found that people whose weight fell within the overweight obese and severely obese BMI ranges tended to live longer than those whose weights fell within the so called, quote, normal BMI range, Jules.

Unknown Speaker 56:28

Also,

Unknown Speaker 56:30

I want to point out here is that, you know, how, you know, everything that we talked about, it's so kind of US centric, right? And, and, and then also, like UK centric, maybe in Canada centric. Did you know that the BMI categories all over the world are different? Right? So you could go travel to

Unknown Speaker 56:52

one country and then suddenly be quote, a normal way and then travel to another one and then suddenly be overweight?

Unknown Speaker 57:00

And it's not true, right? In regards to us, your weight has not changed is that someone? Somewhere? A group of people have decided to fuck it. I think that's what fat is. Yeah, fuck it. Wow, why not? You know? And also the numbers the numbers of, okay, well, you know how it's 25 to 3030 to 3535 to 40. They just said,

Unknown Speaker 57:29

it sounds good.

Unknown Speaker 57:31

If the if five, five point difference between them. That sounds good. There's no stats behind it. There's no evidence to say, actually, you know, what, if someone it goes from 29 to 30, then that's when shit gets real. And I really just go into like, you know, death fat? No, they just thought it sounded easy to remember.

Unknown Speaker 57:55

Science. So is obesity is every see epidemic real. So I want to kind of wrap it, wrap it wrap this with a ribbon. epidemic, the word

Unknown Speaker 58:11

means

Unknown Speaker 58:13

affecting or tending to affect a disproportionately large number of individuals within a population, community or region at the same time.

Unknown Speaker 58:23

Excessively prevalent, contagious, right? So

Unknown Speaker 58:29

what we know is,

Unknown Speaker 58:32

slowly over a few decades, people got fatter. The people who got fatter were the people who are already fat and straight size people didn't tend to get fat, this is leveled off.

Unknown Speaker 58:49

And even if there was like this huge rise in fatness, oh my god, everyone is fat overnight. Which, by the way, you know,

Unknown Speaker 59:01

when that happened is when the NIH was like, let's just change the let's change the numbers.

Unknown Speaker 59:11

Even if people even if 100% of the population was fat, okay, imagine that the population was fat. We don't have evidence to suggest that

Unknown Speaker 59:23

fatness causes poor health outcomes. Correlation is not causation. We have evidence to show that being fat

Unknown Speaker 59:34

reduces mortality.

Unknown Speaker 59:38

And we have no evidence to show how we can make fat people thin or even if we could make fat people thin that it would have any health benefits. In fact, we have evidence to show that it does the opposite has health consequences. So

Unknown Speaker 59:59

it's like say

Unknown Speaker 1:00:00

Hearing

Unknown Speaker 1:00:02

We have an epidemic of people with brown hair.

Unknown Speaker 1:00:08

Since 1980, to 2000, the number of brown haired people walking around the streets with their brown hair is disproportionately large. It's excessively prevalent, and it's contagious.

Unknown Speaker 1:00:28

And the reason why that sounds silly is because we know that brown hair is just a normal trait of being a human being.

Unknown Speaker 1:00:37

We don't think brown hair,

Unknown Speaker 1:00:42

it means that the person is unhealthy, that they're going to die. And that they should just change their hair color to red hair or whatever.

Unknown Speaker 1:00:53

We're just like, Well,

Unknown Speaker 1:00:57

okay, so there's more brown haired people. That's interesting. I wonder why, you know, you might be like, well, you know, whatever. Or, you know, whatever, whatever characteristic about a person which which is not actually

Unknown Speaker 1:01:12

something that we need to be alarmed about.

Unknown Speaker 1:01:15

But because of the way that we view fatness in our society, we're alarmed if there are more fat people around, even if it's not that many more fat people.

Unknown Speaker 1:01:28

Even if we know that you can be fat and healthy.

Unknown Speaker 1:01:33

Even if we know that

Unknown Speaker 1:01:37

fat people can't die from being fat, right? You can't die from being fat you you die from things that are related to fatness and we know that we can treat those things outside of weight loss. There are more

Unknown Speaker 1:01:50

fat people than there were.

Unknown Speaker 1:01:54

Previously, we are

Unknown Speaker 1:01:58

healthier

Unknown Speaker 1:02:01

as a society than ever before in human history.

Unknown Speaker 1:02:06

So fatness does not mean that story increase of fat people does not mean that we are unhealthy, that that that well known quote of children are going to die before their parents was based on some gastroenterologists quote, intuition. Yeah. So basically, in a nutshell, I'd say, you know, there we say everyday America is just a load of bullshit, right? It's just a load of fat stigma. It's just a load of fat phobia. It's just loaded up shirt.

Unknown Speaker 1:02:37

Okay, so let's get all that information. And just one little thing here. So is the O word epidemic real. So first, let's look at the word epidemic epidemic means affecting a disproportionately large number of individuals within a populous community or region at the same time, excessively prevalence, contagious. So the only reason that there were suddenly millions more fat people overnight is because the National Institutes of Health changed the BMI categories. Fat people have been getting a little bit fatter since the 1970s 1980s, up to the 2000s. But straight size, people haven't been getting fatter. So the fat people have been getting a little bit fatter, but straight sides, people haven't been moving into that fat category.

Unknown Speaker 1:03:31

The obesity epidemic is based on the BMI which is 200 years old, the data was collected from European white, presume is presumably sis men was never meant to measure individuals or health at all. It's just really just not based in science and is just no way to measure anything apart from someone's height divided by their,

Unknown Speaker 1:04:03

their weight.

Unknown Speaker 1:04:05

The third thing here to consider is that the categories of what normal weight and overweight have been that they've been changed many times. And and that's because of the influence of lobbying, influence and lobbying of diet companies. Also their arbitrary numbers, they're literally made up and they said, let's just round it to five because five sounds good. It's easy to remember. So 25 To 3035 to 40, etc.

Unknown Speaker 1:04:36

is not based on anything. It's just because it was sounds good. And it's easy to remember, the most recent change in 1998 from the NIH sparked the rhetoric around this epidemic, which came from that overnight change in numbers on our chart. So a group of people got together in a room and was like, okay, so we think we should lower what fatness is

Unknown Speaker 1:05:00

is lower the numbers? Oh, turns out we've got millions of fat people just rolling around the streets and yesterday we didn't it's an epidemic, is it? Or is it just a change in some numbers.

Unknown Speaker 1:05:14

It also then presumes that people who fall into higher weight categories are automatically unhealthy and a burden on society do due to increased fat or weight on their body. There is no evidence to prove that actually having more adipose tissue which is fat tissue on your body leads to poor health outcomes. What we do know that causes poor health outcomes is one weight cycling, which is yo yo dieting or dieting to subpar or lack of access to health care, and three experiencing weight bias or stress, or that comes from that. Remember, correlation is not causation. We also have great evidence to show that quote, overweight people have reduced mortality compared to quote normal weight people, which is called the obesity paradox, a paradox being hmm, we thought that fat people were dying all over the place, but they ain't. It's a paradox. And the word paradox means a seemingly absurd or absurd or self contradictory statement or proposition that when investigated, or explained, may prove to be well founded or true. And so yeah, for years, we've had have evidence that we, you know, health outcomes of fat folks is not due to increased fat tissue.

Unknown Speaker 1:06:50

And so we know that it's coming from if it's if it is there, from other things, but then when evidence show there's there's decreased mortality in fat folks, people are like, Oh my God, it can't be true, even though there's many, there's many years of evidence to show that it's okay to be fat.

Unknown Speaker 1:07:10

Also, you cannot die from fatness, right? You can die from things that are associated with fatness. But again, it is not proven, that fatness in and of itself causes these negative outcomes. And let's just say we ignore all that, let's say that we are in an obesity epidemic. Making a fat person into a smaller person doesn't mean that they will then same that have the same health outcomes as that smaller person pursuing health outside of weight loss is possible and proven. Also, there are zero peer reviewed, controlled clinical studies that show any method of internet intentional weight loss works in the long term. So is the obesity epidemic real doesn't show that there's any evidence that it's this thing where fat people are running around the streets and eating babies. And even if it was real, we don't have evidence to say that being fat makes you inherently unhealthy. Or that we can

Unknown Speaker 1:08:26

lose weight in any way. So I mean, the obesity epidemic basically, is just a load of fat phobia, weight stigma, weight bias, moral panic about fat bodies, and we need to stop talking about it. Because it's not real and it's fucked up. Air Okay, so

Unknown Speaker 1:08:52

hopefully I tied everything together for you there.

Unknown Speaker 1:08:59

Yeah, so when you're at the new next dinner party, and, you know,

Unknown Speaker 1:09:04

cousin Keith says Allah

Unknown Speaker 1:09:09

says that basically, they'll say something about fatness and you'll hear blah, blah, blah. And then you can say you did but if you do hear you

Unknown Speaker 1:09:19

that's what you know, we've talked about in this episode, as

Unknown Speaker 1:09:24

well, thanks for hanging out with me today. If you like the show, when you really want to you can send a review on Apple podcasts. That would be cool. It would make me happy. If you don't want to you don't have to, but it would be really cool if he did.

Unknown Speaker 1:09:45

That's the show. Thanks for having hanging out. Stay fares, fatty and I'll see you in a while.

Unknown Speaker 1:09:51

Alligator Guggulu.

EP132 Transcript

You're listening to The Fierce Fatty Podcast Episode 132 “Raising fat positive kids”. I'm your host, Vinny Welsby. Let's do it.

I'm Vinny Welsby, TEDx speaker, Best Selling Author, and fat activist. I have transformed my life from hating my body with desperately low self-esteem to being a courageous and confident fierce fatty who loves every inch of this jelly. Society teaches us living with a fat body is bad. But what if we spent less time, money, and energy on the pursuit of thinness and instead focused on the things that actually matter? Like if pineapple on pizza should be outlawed? Or if the mullet was the greatest haircut of the 20th century? So how do you stop negative beliefs about your fat body controlling your life? It's the Fierce Fatty Podcast. Let's begin.

Hello, hello. Welcome to our episode. Dude, how you doing? How's life is it great, I hope it is. And back after a week off you might be able to hear Dougie Dougie my dog. In the background today. He's he's running around a little anxious, a little anxious because he's so sensitive. A neighbor two doors down their smoke alarm battery needs changing. And you know that little beep that it does, that he's terrified of that beep and he can hear it through the hallway into our apartment. And it's been going on for like three days. And it really scares him. I left a note on the door neighbor's door being like, I'm sorry, but my dog is a baby. And yeah, he can hear it through the night with the bedroom door close with the two two front doors. And then a bedroom three doors in between the beeping and he can still hear it. And he's like sitting on my head at night and pacing and pull baby. And because he last this weekend, I took him to a river here in Vancouver and we threw some steaks, we had a gay old time, it was very fun. And then he got a parasite. And so we had to he was shitting his pants for four days until he started medication through the night. It felt like I had a child. And I don't want children and so it reinforced my child free status. Because I was like how do parents do this? Like waking up to five, seven to take him downstairs to so you can do a poo? That's like how to fuck how how do people go and then like, go to work. And, and it's not just, you know, the few days I experienced. And when I took him to the doctor was like, let's monitor him see how he gets on. And then eventually it was like to come in and and they were like, oh, their medicine would take 48 hours to work and I was like 48 hours I can't handle not getting enough sleep for another 48 hours. Luckily, he it worked immediately. So I was like oh thank god. So I mean kudos to any parent who is even like getting up once in the night. And that's like, you know, if you have a baby then I'm sure it goes on for like a year or two or three or fuck fuck have I know. 10 2018 years? Yeah, so and then the weekend before bless Dougie, what a little baby. We're at the beach, different beach at the seaside this time Florin sticks having a gale time again. And he rips off his two claw which is just some cloth. If you're not a dog owner or you know just hanging off and he was like my foot and I was like oh my God took him to the emergency vet and had to have to cut it off and he had a little bandage on his foot in the color of a giraffe and a cone on his head for a week and medicine and stuff. So he just he just recovered from that and then I was like let's have some fun and go to the lake and then he got gets a bag parasite. We haven't confirmed what it is. I've just sent his poo off for testing to confirm what it is what's going on or some bacteria whatever. So now the fire alarm thing so if you hear him running around, he's like I'm scared like and during the podcast I can't be playing music. So that's what I've been doing playing music should distract him. So he can't hear. And so I stopped, stopped, the music stopped recording the podcast. And he's like, okay, that again, what are you doing? Why is it so scary?

Yeah, so hey, here's a little update for you, if you are an Instagram user, and I think even if you're a Facebook user, too, it might work for Facebook, too. There is a new way. Face, Instagram has made a change so that you can remove weight loss, add weight loss ads. So what you do, I'm going to link to a post in the show notes. So if you forget, and you need a reminder, or images to point you how to do it is you go to your Instagram, and then you go to your profile. And when you're on your profile, there's the three lines, the burger icon thing, you click the three lines, you go to settings, the gear icon, which is at the very top. From there, you go to ADS, click that, then you go to add topics. And then your search. For body weight control, body weight control, now, I'm in Canada, body weight control didn't come up for me. So it might be if you're elsewhere, body weight control will come up. But I did search the word diet. And so lots of different diet stuff came like weight loss diet, there was no weight loss on such a weight loss too. But for many people, it's probably going to work for some reason, my Instagram is all over the place. And I'll get some features for the feature. So hopefully, this is a feature that you can have. If you don't have body weight control, you can maybe do diet and look at for the diet stuff and you just say see less, and so you can't say don't see but see less. It's either no preference or sealer so little tip the other. Also, I noticed I changed my agenda on Facebook to male. And I got like adverts for things like beef and shaving and man and muscles and cars and shit. You know, I think my gender there is non binary. And so they're like, Now I change it and they're like, oh, okay, non binary, these motherfuckers are gonna get dyads Yes, so no tip for you that little tip for the year though. Now, today's episode, we're talking about children, those children and you know those things, you know, I said, I'm child free, but I do like children used to be one all those years ago, like children just don't want them for myself. And one of my members of face fatty Academy, which is my program to help people learn fatphobia recently had the experience of taking her son to the doctor who proceeded to lecture on how her son was too big and questioned what she feeds him and how much he exercises that's where I wish I could be like buddies, buddies with, you know, be like a little like, no, come up on your shoulder in those moments and be like, really, this is what we're gonna say to this motherfucking doctor, oh, I just like manifest in the room like poof, like, you know, what was that? I Dream of Jeannie. And then the mum would just come into the room and she was like a genie or something anyway, you know, you just be like, shaking knows what we're going to twist your nose, do a little nod. And then poof, here I go. non binary fat positive. Got x there, too. We're like we're not doing this a BS today. Yes. So I wanted to talk about, you know what I would do in that instance, if everything was perfect. And you could do all the perfect thing, which is probably not likely, but you know, the perfect solution to that. And then like the imperfect, we're trying to be the best we can be. And talking about child stuff and something that a stat that I had seen a couple of years ago from I'm going to link to the account.

Go back, go back. Go back. Come on. Yeah, so the account is early. So, Rumsey our D are registered dietitian, thin white person, just just a heads up that shared the stack because she'd looked at information on she she's written a book a couple of years ago. And she looked at information on well, how prevalent is things like eating disorders and kids? How prevalent is things like type two diabetes, which society says is caused by fatness? And so we see the message that oh my god childhood, oh, word rates, childhood fatness rates are out of the truth. There's just fat kids roaming around eating the good thing kids and destroying the world. And yeah. We No, no, it's no, I'm gonna go through some stats here. But basically a stat that Alyssa shared, which, like a heads up, she's not saying that fatness is caused by type two diabetes, but people think that right? So this is a stat that she shares, children are 242 times more likely to suffer from an eating disorder than they are from type two diabetes. If you took a sample of 100,000 children, only 12 would have type two diabetes, but 2900 would meet the criteria for an eating disorder. And again, fatness does not cause diabetes, you cannot eat your way into diabetes. Diabetes is a genetic condition. We have higher rates in we have like other things that might affect it in regards to marginalization and oppression, race, things like that. But it's not something that fatness causes, or you can eat your way into being diabetic. And so if we're worried about fat kids, what we should be worried about is the stigma that those fat kids are experiencing and not telling them to not be fat, because it's not helpful. And they're 242 times more likely to experience disordered eating eating disorder, you know. So, I'm going to link to these but we've got stats from National Eating disorders.org. And I'm going to link to Ulisses story highlights, which also links to the studies that show like what uh, rates of childhood diabetes, what are rates of eating disorders in children, what are let's talk let's look at the rates of childhood fatness. And then and big content warning there because there's Oh, words all over the place and this stigmatizing language all over the place, because some of the stuff about like, Oh, my God, oh, no, the kids are fat, and they're just so terrible and stuff.

Obviously, Coke has a shit ton of awful stuff in it. And then then then they're like, Oh, sure, you just, you know, whatever, a few kids that whatever, no big deal, but there's terrible. So just a caution on that. And also in this episode, I'm just going to be briefly talking about things like eating disorder, prevalence, and things like that. So if that doesn't feel good to you, or you know, concerns about weight and kids, then skip this episode or skip like 15 minutes ahead, because then I'll be talking about how to raise a fat positive kid. Okay, so some stats and stats give me some stats, a lot of stat. By age six girls especially start to express concerns about their own weight or shape. 40 to 60% of elementary school, girls aged six to 12 are concerned about their weight, or about becoming too fat, and this concern endures through life. So kids are at the age of six, picking up this message. And this is what this study is saying. But I would hazard to guess that it's a lot younger than six. And I'm thinking about when kids start to understand like, who's part of the ingroup and who's part of the out group and who's friends and who's not friends and you know, if they're not exposed to certain types of people, then they can see them as the out group and I I guess I hate to say this is against just me thinking about Me sitting and watching cartoons with my siblings. The fat phobic food restrictive diet culture and messages from like fucking Coco melon. so awful. I'm just like, what? You know, like the one the one if you know Coco melon the one it's like, ooh, Daddy's not tonight some sugar one a naughty daddy, or mommy and mommy and binge eat some things or What a naughty Mommy. Oh, we've caught Timmy or whatever his name is Jimmy and Jimmy ate some cookie. Oh, what? Oh dear. We're going to be a good family now and eat some vegetables and fruit. What that are like Peppa Pig, where it's always like, Dad, you're a fat fucking bastard the whole time really, is that the dad's character is all just that he's a fat slob. Like, and he needs to lose weight. What? What I thought Peppa Pig was, you know, the source of the source of American children picking up British accents, not visible shit. But yeah, it turns out it is. And you know, I've probably only watched 1000 hours of kids shows with my siblings. And so, you know, I don't have as much of an idea as people who watch more right, you know, kids and stuff and parents, and caretakers. So okay, the best known environmental contributor to the development of eating disorders is social socio cultural idealization of fineness. Let me read that again. The best known environmental contributor to the development of eating disorders is the idealization of fineness of American elementary school girls who read magazines 69% say that the pictures influence their concept of what the ideal body shape is. 47% said the pictures make them want to lose weight. Children of mothers who are overly concerned about their weight are at increased risk of modeling their unhealthy attitudes, and behaviors. An estimated 90 to 95% of college students diagnosed with an eating disorder also belong to a fitness facility. In trustor, 42% of first or third grade girls want to be thinner. In elementary school, fewer than 25% of girls directly Yet those who do not know what dieting involves, can talk about calorie restriction and food choices for weight loss fairly effectively. Yeah, so that was that was definitely me, you know, I engaged in behaviors, which now I would say is like, over exercising dieting, eating disorder, you know, things like not eating.

And I wouldn't have said like, this is a diet Oh, this is, this is me trying to lose weight. You know, I knew that I was doing those things to try and be thinner, but it wasn't you know, I didn't connect the dots it was just behaviors versus understanding what those behaviors were at 1% of 10 year olds are afraid of being fat 46% of nine to 11 year olds are sometimes or very often on diets and 82% of their families are sometimes are very often on diets, oh 82% of nine to 11 year olds, parents families are sometimes or very often on diets.

Just as thought of kids being I know, experienced it, and millions of millions of people do and kids do and I mean, like how many people listening to the show is a fat person who experienced their parents, or caretaker or someone influential in their life when they were younger, dieting or wanting to be thinner, or having food rules and all that type of diet culture behavior, like loads of us. Over 50% of teenage girls and nearly 1/3 of teenage boys use weight control behaviors such as skipping meals, fasting smoking, cigarettes, vomiting and taking laxatives just a head up heads up a lot of this data is it's it's very it's very white. It's very sis. There's there's there's a real lack of information on compared to you know, white sis, kids on it You know, studies doing looking at trans kids or queer kids or kids from different backgrounds, there's more of the stuff for for, you know, people of color more so than maybe gender diverse kids, but still compared to the, you know, the white sis stuff, it's like, you know, night and day with the amount of information but still, there's still not enough information about all of this stuff. There was an all of these these if you want links to all of these studies are all under this to documents that I'm going to link to in the show notes show notes, for this one is facebook.com, forward slash 132132. So there's a table here on prevalence versus funding. Despite the prevalence of eating disorders, they continue to receive inadequate research funding, so they they're showing different things and the prevalence, so outsiders disease prevalence is 5.1 million. The NIH research funds 450 million autism, 3.6 million prevalence and the funds 160 million schizophrenia, 3.4 million prevalence and 276 million in research funds eating disorders, which are there are many, the prevalence is 30 million. So all of the other prevalences were 533 million, and this one is 30 million. So the research funds is 28 million. So the other ones were 450 160 267 million, and then intersections only 28. So they say here, research dollars spent on Alzheimer's disease average $88 per affected individual in 2011. For schizophrenia, the amount was 81 for autism 44. For eating disorders, the average amount of research dollars per affected individual was just 93 cents. And this is from the National Institutes of Health 2011. And I wonder what the autism one How much is that is is the you know, what was that? You know that that model who used to wish like a playboy or Jenna McCarthy, who was like autism, vaccines cause autism. And so there's been an A bananas amount of research to prove that vaccines don't cause autism way too much, way too much. And so I wonder like, how much of that 3.6 million? I mean, this is 2011? I don't know. Yeah, it would have been going on in 2011. That is to debunk pseudoscience. So, yes, yes, yes. Yes, yes. So they said we've got links to all of this, this juicy stuff.

And basically, the research that we do have on people who are not white and sis is that it's it's more prevalent and obviously treated less. And there are more other things going on at the same time. So if someone's got BDD binging disorder, then they've also got things like PTSD or low self esteem. More likely, if you're also marginalized in other ways, is what the research is, is kind of beginning to show but again, it's not robust enough to have any really clear conclusions. So just kind of pointing that out of if there, if there's any other marginalization is going on, then, you know, it's probably even more difficult to deal with and to get diagnosed and to get help. As it is for kids as it is for adults, right. So so so so so so so what we know about kids is that they're fucking going through it, they are going for it when it comes to learning that thinness is best. And there they are. Learning that they need to be thin in order to be whatever it is that they've been taught that fitness entails. And if you think about what you might have learned, fitness entails and what comes with fitness as a kid, then it's probably pretty heartbreaking. I know for me, a big part of what I learned in my childhood was that because I'm fat, I will never get a boyfriend. That's a big message. I heard that you never gonna get a boyfriend and no one's ever gonna love you You and also don't dream too big because your fatness is going to stop you achieving things. And the big one, like I remember is seeing an opera singer on songs of praise if you're British, you will know that song which was a no that that TV program which was on our Sunday, really fucking boring, and it was just people singing songs for Jesus. Right very boring program. Anyway, that was not pressing on songs of praise. And I was like, Mommy, I want to be an opera singer. And she said, No, you can't be an opera singer because you're fat. She I think she'd heard of the you know, the fat lady sings and foul bro thing? Because isn't that like the cliche that you know, Pavarotti and opera singer is a fat right? I don't know. But I think I think she was thinking about, you know, being a pop star or whatever. Yeah. So and, and. And me saying the story about my mom, it's not like my mum was like, What can I do to fuck up this child's life? She was thinking, I'm presuming obviously. I can't read her mind. But she was thinking, Okay, well, if my child wants to be a singer, what do they have to do to become successful as a singer, they need to be thin. So I'm going to help them by telling them great idea. Being a singer is a wonderful thing. So why don't you become thin, so you can make it happen, like, I'm presuming that that was a thought process behind thinking, but the message that I got was a little bit different, you know, the message I got was, you know, you're a fucking fat loser. And even if you are good at singing, it doesn't matter because you're fat. And no one wants to see a fat person singing is what I heard.

And, and with the, with the saying, You're never going to get a boyfriend, if you're fat. I'm I, again, you know, something, maybe there was a little bit of malice of, you know, I was misbehaving. And she was like that, I'm gonna stick it to them. But I think mostly it was, I really want you to be in the best position in life to achieve what you want to achieve. And fineness is going to get you there. And so you should become thin. Same way, as my mom would encourage us to go to university and I played the trumpet for years, and she would encourage me to do that. And because we came from a very, very poor household with a lot of other things happening to you, and like my dad was, my dad was using alcohol, and you know, we lived in an awful neighborhood, and I'd experienced sexual sexual assault as a young child and things like that. So I'm thinking that she wanted us to do these extracurricular things get to university, be attractive, be healthy, so that we could get out of poverty, we could get out of abusive situations. And the in some ways, it that was helpful, because, you know, three of the four of us who grew up together and actually, my, my other siblings, too, they all happen to go to university too. But three of the four of us growing up growing up, we grew up together, we did all go to university, which was which was coming from where we came from, was very surprising. Like I wouldn't know anyone else in my neighborhood who would have also gone to university right? And luckily in the UK, if you're poor the government pays for university which is wonderful. And that's how we how we managed to get there and because my mum was already kind of like let's say you're smart she would tell us that you were smart but with the with the telling me that I was fat because I was the fat one right? That did not help me get out of shitty situations. In fact it put me into shooting 66 Shitty situations right because empowering you know, empowering me to say you know, you're smart, you can go to university was was was empowering and felt good, whereas you are fat and you should be thin, was not empowering. It was filled with shame. And what we know when we shame people to not be fat, is it just the opposite not that being fat is a bad thing, but shame is not a good motivator. And you know, that fear of oh my god, what if you do become fat and I I'm guessing a lot of parents are like, Well, I'm trying to protect my kid because the world doesn't like it. If you don't conform, I don't want my kid to be queer or trans or fat, or, you know, any of the things where they could be a target for discrimination thing is, though, you're starting the discrimination at home, you know, you know, it's like, kind of like, I'm going to, I'm going to make sure that they feel marginalized. So here, so they can form so they don't feel marginalized outside, but they're going to, they feel marginalized at home and outside, because they're not going to change their identity, probably. And then they know that the place that should be filled with love and acceptance is not so but I know, like, it's, I just kind of feel like I get it. But the logic is faulty. And especially, you know, I'm 37. So, you know, 3730 years ago, whatever. We weren't really talking about this as much this stuff. So hopefully the next generation is going to kind of if I had kids, hopefully I would not fuck my kids up as much in regards to that, that, you know, body stuff and food stuff. I probably fucked them up in some other way. And they'd be and then 30 years time that'd be on a podcast being like, yeah, man, my parents Vinnie. They were just a fucking piece of shit. And they did these and I'm like, Yeah, but you're not ashamed to your body? Yeah. And I'm like, Yeah, but you ruined my life in this way.

Yeah, so so so so so so. So yeah. When I was saying about how being taught that being fat was bad. What that led me to was, and I've spoke about it on the show before at the age of 17, my first boyfriend was 30 year old and he was abusive in many different ways. And I always just thought, I'm so lucky that he would even talk to me that he would want to be with me. Because I'm fat, right? Like, this is all I deserve. Because I'm fat, you know, because I had that you never gonna get a boyfriend if you're fat. Oh my god, I've got a boyfriend. I am having sex with someone. Someone wants to have sex with me. Even though I am this awful, disgusting. person. And now I'm like, nah.

Oh, my God, and obviously experienced abuse, which was awful. Yeah, so it didn't help me because I was constantly just like, how can I get thin? I need to be thin because you are thin. And I'm going to receive love and praise, and lots of good things. Okay, so how can we protect our kids? And obviously, I don't have kids. So I'm not an expert on how to talk to kids. But I know about creating environments, which are supportive to fat positivity. So in this example, the story that I shared at the beginning the doctor saying your child is fat, and oh my god, it must be because they are doing XYZ and you're a terrible parent. And you know, kids have been taken from their parents because they are fat, which is fucked up 1,000,000,000% totally fucked up. Not okay. Because guess what? Fat kids exist, have always existed, will always exist. fatness is just a normal part of being a human being, you know, AI now. And I think about why we're so stressed about is Oh, my kid fat. Let's not have fat kids. Because it's gonna mean that this and that. And whatever, that as soon as a kid starts showing any signs of like, you know, being chubby or fat or whatever, then, you know, people are like doing the sign of the cross and being like, Oh, my God, police. We need to stop this, this this before it gets out of control. And they pathologize a normal kid's body and start messing around with it, you know? And I think about how kids, you how humans grow. And how if you've not seen a kid for a couple of years, or a year or over the summer or whatever, and they're like 10, and they've gone from 10 to the age of 10 and a half or 11. And then you see them and you're like What the fuck? You've grown like 17 feet like you used to be at my knees and now you're taller than me what the heck. And it's, you know, we wouldn't be like oh my god, Quick, get them to the doctor. They've got this weird stretch thing going on. We've got a really stretched kids going out here and just being tall and know we'd be like, Oh, well, that's just a normal part of growing and, and just because some kids might grow taller, quicker and some kids might Like grow wider, and then tall and then maybe wider, some more and then maybe a little bit taller, but maybe not, you know. And so if the kid is not doing the wide and the tall at the same time, or the just the tall or not the wide, then we're like, oh my god, a kid can't just do the wide. And we just be like, Oh, we know, they kid the child is growing. You know, I just think about how it's kind of like, just overreacting, when I say overreacting, there should be no reaction apart from supporting a kid in living maybe temporarily in a body, that is marginalize, maybe they're just, they just happened to be a fat child that turns into a fat adult. And that's absolutely fine, too. And that's no problem whatsoever. And so the only thing that we would need to do to react to that, and even if we have small kids, is to talk about discrimination. And talk about body diversity. So in this instance, the doctor is like, ah, yo, kids fat, and you are a piece of shit because you have a fat kid. So this is Dreamworld this is, if you knew it was coming, had rehearsed your script, beforehand, was feeling great had no social anxiety, there was no power imbalance between you and the doctor. All of them, you know, perfect stars need to align, that is probably not going to happen for most people. And that through no fault of your own, is, if the doctor starts talking about the child's weight is saying, I'm gonna stop you right there. Hey, child, can you step outside? If that's possible? Or can we talk in private doctor or healthcare provider? So that's the first thing, can we remove the child from experiencing potential trauma, we might not be able to do it, right. Like, if it's a three year old, you can't be like, Oh, three year old, go and unclick go outside and you know, play with some traffic.

But if that's possible, we want to try and avoid the kid experiencing it. Then saying to the doctor, I don't expose my kids to weight bias. So we don't talk about that. We don't talk about weight, like it's a problem. That's not going to happen. Again, this is dream world. That you might say this, if you if you ever if you can say this, like if someone can say this during the doctor's visit, I would be like, Wow, because there's so much going on, right? You know, you're gonna go in for a doctor's visit, and you're not expecting the doctor to be a bellend. Well, maybe we are if you're fat, then you probably are. But in that moment, even someone like me, you know, your brain is like, Oh, my God, oh my God, what's happening? How shit is happening? Oh, my God, the time this thing? Oh, God, the child is hearing it? Oh, what do I say? And then you're like, Well, I think it's fine. You know, you'll come out with something. And that's normal. Because our brains are like, you know, fight flight, freeze that type of thing. So and so if you can't say to the doctor, Listen, I'm not gonna, let's not talk about this. You could, you know, just nod and smile and be like, yeah, sure, great, whatever, and defend your child as much as you can. But if you if you can't do that, for whatever reason, then you can do damage control after you leave the doctor's. So it's that remove reduced protect that I've spoken to you law about before. Can you remove the thing? Maybe, maybe not? Can you reduce the exposure? Can you like say okay, and have conversation? Oh, actually, I'm here today to talk about little Timmies knees or whatever? Can we get back to that? And they're like, yes, because he's got sore knees because he's fat. And then if you can't reduce, can you protect and so protect that gorgeous brain of yours and of your kids, kid, children, multiple, whatever. And so depending on their age, you may want to have a conversation with them afterwards about what happened and how they feel about that about it and reassure them that there's nothing wrong with their body and that doctors can hold biases and stigma. They might be a little bit too young for that stuff. You might want to not have a direct conversation and instead make a bigger effort to fill their brain with fat positive goodness, whether that's not watching Peppa Pig that day and instead watching something which is more fat positive and watching I don't know. I can't give you a recommendation on shows. I'm sure there's probably lots there's probably lots of talk about fat stuff. You can you can give them order some some books or get it from the library. And in the show notes. I have got a list of books for you. Whew, a list of like 30. But for ebooks in a range of ages for you. So, yeah, filling their brain with fat positive goodness, because a lot of the books, even if we don't have media that, you know, kids are consuming, that is specifically anti fat, the media that kids will consume the same as us. It's so it's so there's no diversity, right? There's no diversity. And so even if it's like, oh, it's Power Rangers, but you know, where's the fat Power Ranger? You know, there's only one isn't? Or is it one or two? Like, there's maybe it's a one Black Power Ranger, and then there's one Asian power ranger. But anyway, they've got hats on, so you can't even see. But but, you know, I'm saying that, can we? You know, remove the egregious stuff, if possible. Not always. But can we also see if there's something that's a little bit more diverse, and the same with books like that, like, when I'm reading books to my siblings, I'm like, wow, like, every fucking character is why.

And he's just just standard, right? The toys is just white, and thin, you know? So yeah, if we can make some type of changes there, but you know, what the biggest thing that that you can do is to work on how you think about yourself, how you talk about yourself, and the modeling of behaviors for your kids. If they see someone who's dieting and saying fat is bad, and all that type of stuff, then they're probably going to pick it up. They see people being chill around food and around bodies and saying, Oh, if our bodies are cool, and just not making a big deal, then they're going to pick up on that too. They're obviously going to pick up on the ship stuff when they leave the house too. And we can't stop that happening. But we have such power in those more intimate relationships that we'd have with with family. And, you know, everyone's gonna fuck up, right? Everyone is trying to do their best in life. And so there's gonna be times where you fuck up and you're like, Oh, God, but if we're moving towards a place where kids know that they're safe, and they have a safe spot to land in regards to their body, and their uniqueness is it's beautiful, right? And we'll talk about food. If you want to learn more about raising an intuitive eating kid, then. Oh, and there's that book Body happy kids that I'm in. And then Ellen Ellen SATA Institute talks about the division of responsibility from toddlers onwards. So division of responsibility with kids this is raising Intuitive Eating child is you decide what, when, and where a child is fed, and the child decides whether and how much so like a simple thing that I see is a simple switch we can make is thinking about how the way that we talk about foods like sweets, oh, they're bad the sweets you have after dinner, the sweets of the tree, eat the dinner first. Because that's the yucky food that's a boring food. And then you can have the good foods a little switch you can do is is giving dessert with dinner at the same time. And knowing that the kid is probably at least for the first bit going to be having the thing which is a dessert item and asking for more and then you're going to give them as much as they want because they have learned that that thing is like magical and, and maybe a little bit taboo and you can't have it because if you do then you're gonna get fat and oh my god, fat is bad. And, and, you know, imagine if we gave that message about other things, you know, like, if you're like, Oh, don't eat so many peas. No, you can only have peas after you finished your cookie. No, you can only have three peas you can't have four peas. Oh, and hiding the peas in a high cupboard so they can't get access to them and and, you know, you secretly MPs and then saying, oh my god, I had some peas. I'm such a bad person and I should stop eating the peas. They're gonna start being like, Please give me the peas. I'm gonna have my peas Come on now, I want some pays. And of course, you know, you know, cookies probably do taste nice doesn't nicer than peas to kids and but you know, we're really, really working hard to help kids be disordered around food, right and make it a big deal. And if we work to not make it a big deal, and just give kids as much food as they want, within, you know, there are there will be rule set to like, I'm not an expert in this, but you know, for example, you're just about to make dinner. And the kid says, Oh, can I have food? And you say, oh, you know, it's not because you decide when, right? Because I Yeah, absolutely, we're gonna have dinner in 10 minutes. And so we're gonna eat then or, or they might say, at nighttime, you know, how kids stall to get into bed, and they're like, I'm thirsty.

I'm hungry, I need to go to the toilet. So, you know, if they like I'm hungry. The messaging that you are, you know, that you're saying of like, you know, you're not hungry, you're being greedy, or whatever, something like that. Versus Oh, yeah, absolutely. The kitchen is closed right now. But if what I'm going to do tomorrow's I'm gonna remind you, when the kitchen is open again, so that you can have some food, and not, you know, shaming them or telling them, you know, making out like, it's a bad thing. Yeah. So that's a simple thing that we could do. So let me let me let me round up everything that we're talking about how to raise a fat positive child. So talking about fat phobia, and body politics, and depending on the age of your kid talking about how the world has fucked up, and we. But we don't fix bullying by giving the bully or lunch money. And so we're not going to change our bodies in order to adhere to what society might say, or do to us or say about us. Because it's not okay to judge people, and especially in the home environment, as well. And tell them that they are worthy no matter what they look like or what they do. Never put them on a diet, unless it's like a diet for medical reasons. Like, you know, your child has epilepsy and they need to do keto, but never putting them on a diet standing up for their rights. If the doctor tells them that they need to lose weight, or if the school sends a letter home saying your kid is fat, or they've got work to do, which is weighing themselves standing up for them and saying that that's not appropriate to the school or the doctor if you can do that, that is beautiful. Don't shame their body in any way or shame them for wearing certain types of clothes. Don't bully them into moving their body. Yeah, movements great and all but it's more important to not cause damage to their relationship with movement. And that's something that a lot of adults bring into life is trauma or around being forced to do the 1500 meter run at pe 1500 I hated it and monitor what the the media they're consuming. So are they watching hours of Peppa Pig? Were they constantly gone about habit ads a fat bastard and he needs to lose weight? Can we also sprinkle in something that's more positive? Can we buy books celebrate body diversity? Don't force him to spend time with people who are raging weights, bigots, or diet culture zealots if they have to, for whatever reason, talk to them about the types of things have been exposed to and how it's, you know, it's not okay, and all that type of stuff. But the number one thing that you can do is unlearn all of that stuff that we learn as kids and model behavior to show that your body is a okay the size it is, food is not a big deal. And remember the stat about kids being 242 times more likely to suffer from an eating disorder than type two diabetes. Not that being fat causes diabetes at all. But if you have a fat kid, and the doctor is like, Oh my God, they're, they're about to spontaneously combust and get all these terrible things. The chances are, that they are 242 times more likely to You get an eating disorder than they are type two diabetes and so what we really need to worry about is protecting children's gorgeous brains and not making a big deal if they're fat because being fat is just a normal part of being a human being so if you want the list of books so this is the books like I've been gathering it for you know list of different types of books and stuff so this is kids books but the new one that came out is celebrate your body and it's changes to by Sonya Renee Taylor. The ultimate puberty book for girls that looks fun. And body image because all bodies are great by Tierra Han. We've got also things like C is for consent. It's okay to be different by Todd Parr.

Unknown Speaker 51:00

Comma colors mustache, how sounds fun. So we've got you know, like young adult, we've got, you know, baby stuff and everything in between, right. So the intuitive eating workbook for teens a non diet body positive approach to building a healthy relationship with food by Elise rash. So yeah, so go go check out the show notes for a different book, recommendation, show notes at food started.com. Forward slash 132. also links to all the studies for the things that I was talking about. And listen, if you're a parent, I mean, if you're a human, you've you've you've fucked up, right? We've all fucked up and done things and been like, Oh, good. We're all trying our best. And we're all you know, kind of working towards moving to be better and all that type of stuff. And even if you have fucked up, we can have conversations and say, Hey, I think I fucked up with that. You know, like, it just I was talking to my mom a couple of weeks ago, and she was like, You know what, I feel really guilty about one of you, I can't remember which kid she said, Oh, but you got your your exam results, and I was disappointed, and it made you cry. And I was like, oh, yeah, that was me, actually. And I was like, Yeah, I remember that. And she's like, I feel really guilty about it. And I just want to say sorry, and I was like, Oh, shit. Yeah, well, thanks. I appreciate that. And, you know, that was like, 20 years ago. And she, she, like, remembered it. And it's been on our mind and apologized. And obviously, we've talked a lot about, you know, the fat stuff, and dieting and all that type of stuff. So even if we do fuck up, I think sometimes fucking up means that we can also have the chance to build nice relationships. To say, Yeah, we fucked up and what can we do to make it better, and I really saw that when like I was doing a course it was called daring, greatly. Brene Brown, brainy Brown is I've since learned by doing this course, super fat phobic. And so I was doing this course and with my therapists office, and my therapists office is great. Really, really good. And so they were showing videos of brandy Brown had made and we'd be going through his course material. And one of the videos she was saying some really fucking inappropriate shit. And I was like, what? Oh, my God, I thought that this would be safe. How often do I do like self self help stuff? It's just so fat phobic. It's just, you know, you just expect it right? You know, like, oh, how to improve your productivity. And you'll be like, don't be fat. How the fuck did you grow Baba into there? You know, and they'll talk about diet and stuff. It's, it's just, that's why I can't read health self help stuff anymore. But anyway, I thought this was going to be safe because it's run by my therapists, company group. And they are they are excellent. Right? And so afterwards, me and another fat person watching this video. We're both like, in the group saying, Oh, wow, that was fucked up. And then the leader was like, Yeah, that was fucked up. And then afterwards, I sent an email saying, Hey, that was really fucked up. And and so she sent a beautiful email response, she had contacted Brene Brown Company and saying, Hey, this is fucked up. And she said, I'm never gonna, we're never going to share that that thing again. And also, to think give me like a free session or something. I'll come up with something. What is something it was like? They did something and I was like, actually, I feel so even though the bad thing happened, right? And it wasn't the worst thing in the world. Um, but you know, I thought I was in a safer space and then Brene Brown comes with roll. That'd be bad even though that happened, the my respect and and comfort and and feeling seen and heard level increased afterwards. And that was like a really beautiful thing for me to experience because it really made me feel like it's okay if I fuck up and obviously I've been you know, we quote, know that it's okay for us to fuck up. But seeing that the fuckup made the relationship better. And it's almost like you will fuck up and it's a way that react. And so with kids like you will fuck up same with everyone else. And then it's a way that you can humbly say I fucked up and what can I do to make it better?

Is probably even more than was it because even better lesson maybe? Maybe we can try not fuck up people but you know, that's just not possible a lot of times because it's humans talking to other humans. Yeah, so, okay.

Remember there's that that that removing the weight loss ads from your feed hack as well in the show notes and if you enjoyed the episode and you feel like it why don't you write a review?

Hmm, that would be amazing. And you can add to the review list of saying the shows and mutts nuts there than mutts nuts because we've already got a couple of months nuts on there I think some time I must have said much nuts and anyway go go and add a review if you feel inclined. Um and I'll see you in the next episode. Okay, see you in a why y'all alligator stay face fatty Good boy.

Thanks for listening to the episode and if you feel ready to get serious about this work and want to know when the doors open to fears fatti Academy which is my signature program, where I teach all about how to overcome your fat phobic beliefs and learn to love your fat body, then go to first fatty.com forward slash waitlist again that is fierce fatty.com forward slash waitlist to get your name on the waitlist. For when first fatty Academy my signature program opens

EP131 Transcript

You're listening to The Fierce Fatty Podcast Episode 131. "Help! I’m Surrounded by Fatphobes!”. I'm your host, Vinny Welsby. Let's do it.

I'm Vinny Welsby, TEDx speaker, Best Selling Author, and fat activist. I have transformed my life from hating my body with desperately low self esteem to being a courageous and confident fierce fatty who loves every inch of this jelly. Society teaches us living with a fat body is bad. But what if we spent less time, money, and energy on the pursuit of thinness and instead focused on the things that actually matter? Like if pineapple on pizza should be outlawed? Or if the mullet was the greatest haircut of the 20th century? So how do you stop negative beliefs about your fat body controlling your life? It's the Fierce Fatty Podcast. Let's begin.

Hello, and welcome to this episode. How are you doing? How's life? You're feeling? Good. I'm feeling good. I'm feeling good. Hey, I got a couple of recommendations for you for stuff to watch. That's positive. Might be behind the times on this one. Well, actually, no, we came out 2022 2022 This year, so it's called somebody somewhere starring Bridget Everett. See comedy drama. And in Canada, I watch it on crave which is which has had HBO. So wherever you watch HBO stuff, then you should be able to find it. And Bridget, Bridget Everett is a fact. Actor. She's 50 years old. And this, like I'd seen this advertised and I was just like, What is this? And it took me a few times to want to watch it. But it was so good. I like watched the whole first season. There's only one season so far. In like three minutes. It was it was that good. It just so endearing. No. No fat, negativity, really. Just she's a cool person, just living life and she happens to be fat. It's really good. It's really it's really good. And we have also a trans actor in the main the main cast there, as well. So yeah, it's cool. And so you might know Bridget Everett from Patty cakes have had cakes as a movie. Because it's came out on like 2018 I think which stars Danielle MacDonald which you should You probably recognize you probably recognize these people. Danielle MacDonald stars and Patty cakes. Daniel McDonald was also in dumpling with Jenna at Jennifer Aniston and Danielle McDonald in Patek. If you haven't seen Patty cakes, go watch it. It's so good. That was on. Oh, you can watch it on Disney plus, is what Google is telling me. You can watch it on Disney plus, so and the music and it's so good. PATIC aka dollar signs. Paddy cakes. Patty cakes Paddy. It's really good as a running gold. Yeah, if you don't seem Dumplin that's probably like us. That's a really popular one too. And I found stuff that stuff but somebody somewhere on crave slash HBO. Wherever you get crave HBO starring Bridget Everett. I'll put it in the show notes just in case you forget. And you're like, What the fuck are they talking about? So you can always find the show notes at face value.com For slash podcast or for this episode is one free one. Also just an FYI. As a reminder, you can also get this transcript for every single episode. That's a lie. I am boldface lying for every new episode. And also, we're working on doing transcripts for the old episodes. And we're almost done. So we're doing three transcripts a week. So we're like back to like Episode II or 20 II so and then the first 10 episodes I think had transcripts. So we're almost done of every single episode. So I'd say 90% of episodes have transcripts. So tell your friends if they want transcripts. If you want a transcript. We've got transcripts there in the show notes for certified.com forward slash podcaster for this episode, one three along so yes I'm talking about podcasting thing I was having dinner at dinner with him on Monday to gorgeous a Mexican restaurant with at Summit in an imino summer friend of the show. Also friend of mine in real life and she has a podcast too which is really good go check that out. It's called Eat the rules. And we were she had texted me the day of this screenshot of a review that someone had had left for her podcast one of the episodes that we remember we did like def two diets which was six episodes where we were kind of testing something out and we had an episode about Jvn Jonathan Van Ness and the suppose it sugar addiction Jvn uses he him them they I think she is well pronouns let's see him I know for sure and they them I know for sure maybe she her

Oh Do you know what JB and blocked me Ah Oh shit because of that episode Jeremy. I gotta tell you is ever uses she is well as they and he because I, JVM, JVM. Whoever criticized JVM for that there was a super fat phobic episode he did with getting curious. And some fat activists call it called him out and he blocked them sad I mean, come on now. Come on. Goodbye. But I mean, like if I was him, I'd be blocking us as well. Not that we did it said anything wrong. But yeah, because I probably haven't got time for these fucking bitches. These idiots whatever. Anyway, in the episode, we'll JVM will just saying how sugar addiction isn't a thing. And Jvn sounds like it sounds like they have struggled with being a diet culture and being fat phobia. And they had a meeting with a I don't know what she called us, I think she was she might have been a dietitian, something like that. Some sort of food professional. And he was saying that food addiction is is real and told Jvn that he had sugar addiction with some very dubious science. Anyway, so someone had sent in a review for some as podcast saying that the lines of I came here to listen to stuff to help me feel good about my body. And they just made fun of the let's say they're a dietitian, the dietitian because she was sitting made fun of her thin body. And I'm here to get to love my body. And they're just making fun of thin people. And we were somewhere and I we were like texting back and forth kind of laugh at laughing about the thin fragility, the fragility in that, that that review and then when we had dinner on Monday night, we were like, wonder what's going on though behind it. Like what's going on behind this person is mad. Because we were laughing because it's kind of like, what? We didn't make fun of the dietician for being thin. We have what summer said was the so the dietitian was like obviously in diet culture and in in fatphobia and believes that sugar addiction is a thing and in summer, I said oh, she wasn't very friendly. She wasn't very entertaining, right? So if you're gonna be on TV, you might as well also be like entertaining and an interesting and funny or something, you know, but she wasn't very entertaining and and summer said, yeah, she's probably hungry. And that was a good old knees up. Yep, she's probably hungry because she's in diet culture. She's, she's restricting food. She's not eating enough food. She's not eating any sugar. Whereas we think that this person think thought that we were making saying she's hungry because she's thin. Like we're somewhere and I didn't even connect to that because something that we realized we were talking about was that for people who are new to anti diet, fat positivity, they might hear some or or I or anyone else talking about thingness talking about whiteness, and think that we are talking about individual people and not structures systems. of oppression. And we're gonna be talking about individual people who are buying into structures of oppression. So this dietitian was buying into, you know, fatphobia dot diet, culture and the, and the privilege that comes from being thin, right. But, like, that's, that's kind of like to us a given, and to people who've probably listened to our podcast for a while, like, that's a given, we're talking about the structure of privilege, in this instance, thinness. And we're not talking about how thin people are bad or thin people are unattractive or thin people are need to be, you know, thrown into outer space or something. Fineness, the concept of fineness as a superior body type and as a way to oppress others, that system should be thrown into space, but not thin people. The ideology, you know, the oppressive ideologies. And so we were like, Oh, shit, yeah, like, you wouldn't maybe we need to be more explicit. And also, this is a shit ton of, you know, thin fragility of, there's no way in the world that similar and I wouldn't make fun of someone for their body size. I mean, come on. Go. Nah, like, that's what we were like, what would you mean, we would like, is making fun of this person for their her body size. I was like, that doesn't that doesn't make sense. And then we looked into it, and it's like, I can see why someone might think that question mark. Anyway, so long story short, just saying. Just an FYI.

That always, we're talking about what I'm talking about for myself, I'm talking about you know, if I'm talking about thin privilege, I'm not saying thin people need to go away and die. You know, I'm not saying that white people need to go away and die. Just you know, the idea of, of whiteness or fineness or able bodied pneus as a superior quality of a human. Yeah, now. Anyway, somebody else at some I said, because I was like, where did you just find this review? Because I don't go i i don't normally go and check reviews unless I've asked you not to do a review and then I'll go and see if you've done it. And you certainly do. Thank you. And anyway, she says she's got some there's a thing that you can go and look at your reviews around the world I keep forgetting about it's called charitable in case you have a podcast or you want to go and nosey on other people's podcasts, but reviews from around the world well, because Apple podcasts are super annoying. They only do regional reviews. And so if you live in one country you can only see the reviews from that country. So anyway, so I've just gone and checked out my most recent reviews. Thank you, so I'm gonna read out a few of them. So reviews were first of all the podcast entertaining a thought provoking, very nice narration is so so in capital's entertaining, that it captured my attention and kept me listening. And before long, I was learning and becoming more and more supportive of fact, acceptance. Love it. Thank you so much for the podcast and highly recommend to anyone and that is from someone who lives in Japan. Amazing. Konnichiwa Genki deska Domina. Gattaca is a mass and that our super Raschi Janay matinee that is a study Japanese. And that was Hello. How were you? Thank you. You're awesome. See you later. See you later, crocodile. I didn't say See you later. Crocodile just said See ya. So I get out my little bit of Japanese that I remember for that to Japanese. This is like review from Japan's super cool. Okay. Another review is from Denmark. I'm a Danish English English listener. The listener and I'm so glad that I found this podcast Vinnie is voice always calms me down. And I love to hear their perspective on things. They talk and educate about fat phobia and also about a lot of other important stuff is kinda enjoyable to hear them talk about their private life and life and dating etc. Heart kinda. I think they probably made it just like casual is kind of interesting. Thank you. And that is from Kim, Malia some of these you know I can't read out the user names because it's like this next one is cuckoo cuckoo cuckoo. BBB BBB. Why? Well, anyway, this next one five stars. This podcast is full of great information. I really appreciate Vinnie sense a humor. They are also very compassionate and thought full about how they present information about fat phobia. In our culture, they are a unique voice in the fat positive movement and their unique identities bring a great perspective to the man. Thank you. And that's from United States of America. Well, I appreciate it. Thank you all for your reviews. And you know what, it's so heartwarming to see. You all use my pronouns, and my name Vinnie. And they them. Beautiful. Thank you. It's so affirming to read that really. And just one more Australia, Vinnie is and that's nuts. laughing face. I must have said, Hey, could you want to go and do a go do a review and you can just say, they're the mutts nuts. You know, that's all you need to say. And that's probably why that person has written that. Yes. So thank you. Thank you. Thank you. And let's get on to talking about what we're talking about today, which is when you're surrounded by fat foods, by body bigots by people who invest in a weight stigma and anti fat bias. Fun times, fun times. So when I talk to people who are struggling with body image stuff, I will ask them some questions about what's going on in their brains currently, what's going into their brains, what they're being influenced by what messages they're absorbing. So when you know, when people are asking me for advice, you know, like in coaching settings,

I don't know why I'm really struggling with you know, the question, or I'll be like, I'm really struggling with my body, even though I've been doing this work for XYZ amount of months or whatever. And I'll say, Okay, well, let's, let's get our detective Spyglass monocle. thing on. And let's do some detective work to work out what might be helping you and maybe what is not so helpful that's going on in your life. And I'll ask them certain questions. Now, if you've done no work on body image, or if you're new to the concept of I anti diet, or fat positivity, then I can probably guess what's going on, with the messages that you're receiving into that gorgeous brain of yours, you're probably getting a shirt ton of dog shit into your brain dogshit being like culture and fat phobia, and lots of different, unhelpful things. And just the average person on the street, you know, somewhat, you know, just an average person who isn't, you know, has no idea about anti diet or fat phobia. I feel like I could just take their phone and be like, let's have a look. Let's see what's going on with just like your phone, or the people you're talking to, or whatever. And it's just going to be covered with loads of unhelpful messages is just, you know, so often, that's the way it goes. And so, here's my first thing for you. So, I am giving you a challenge. I'm giving you a challenge to open up your phone and go on social media, whatever one you use, most often, and scroll through. And notice you might want to write it down or something. Notice all the first the posts that you're seeing when you first open the your social media, whatever it is, so are they messages that are going to support your journey to unlearning fatphobia? Is it a ton of diety stuff? Is it a ton of normative bodies? Like with Facebook, it could be whatever you know, it's just my friends saying oh look at my kids looking cute or whatever. And you know, is that you can decide is Does that feel good for you? You know, maybe maybe not. But you know, is it that all your friends are have certain body types is it that they're like, oh my god, I just tried this this keto diet and it's amazing. If it's on Instagram, you know, who are you following? On Tik Tok? etc. So is it a mix of of harmful stuff and help maybe some neutral stuff? Is it mostly positive stuff? So take note of the first 10 posts and so I did this with mine so I opened my Instagram. And this is what I saw on my Instagram just to give you an an idea of the stuff that's going into my brain and this is totally random. No, nope, nope. No, fudging it no kind of getting rid of things that I didn't look made me look good. So the first one was an anti diet dietician sharing something the next one As a black body positive personal trainer, who's also a friend of mine. The next one was a kid playing with a chicken. Specifically, it was a rooster. The next post was a kitchen gadget. Next post was a funny post about rainbow washing. And the office. It was a scene from you. Anyone knows the office is a scene from the office where Michael is teaching about diversity. And he, what's that gay guy's name? I can't remember his name. Anyway, there's one of the people in the office is gay. And so he says, Come up here, gay person, I'll show you how diverse I am. And he forces himself onto the person and makes him kiss him. And, but it's like really slow. And they're both like, gay guys like, pulling his neck back. Like, don't kiss me. And then Michael is like, I'm gonna kiss you and show you how brave I am.

I'm not a homophobe. And yet anyway, this post was like, That's companies, you know, Rainbow washing and the company's unlikable and then the the gay guy getting kissed was US consuming the the post. Next post was a black joy post. So it was a post about black people doing gymnastics and having fun. Next one was a great ready with me post which was, you know, a fat black person trying on clothes. Next post was about guns, banning guns. Next was another anti diet dietitian, then we have a funny post about a family with a setting as a family barbecue and someone gets on an ATV, and crushes into the barbecue. And next one, a fat cat meme. And finally, squishing jelly with spikes really satisfying contents. So all of this stuff, and it's actually less I think that's like 12 or 13. I said all supports my mental health a little bit of fun, a little bit of politics, joy, squishing blah, blah, blah, good. Right? So is that what your social media is looking like? Something like that? If, if not, how can we change it up? And and what a lot of people do is they're like, Hi, great. I'm gonna change up and then go and follow. Like, this is what people do. They'll go follow people, they'll don't follow just like three accounts. And then you say how many people are you following on Instagram? And they'll be like, 3000. And then you're like, Okay, so those three accounts aren't going to be a drop in the bucket, you know. And the three counts that they follow a normally small fat people who were very conventionally attractive, you know, and so it's like, oh, isn't really gonna help, you know. So you just have to go balls to the wall, you know, and I say to people, just go and see who, someone who likes, go and see who they follow, go and check out who I follow, if you don't mind. Also seeing being exposed to pimple popping videos, satisfying, you know, like, ASMR stuff, and probably some gross medical things. That, and also, then you've got all of the other you know, cool, interesting content. What I mean, for me, if you asked me people probably was interesting, too. Yeah, so you can just go and just go, follow, follow, follow, follow, that's a really good way just to go like blast. And so it makes a message of, this is what humans look like. It like normalized. And also this is what human looks humans look like who are, who are joyful, who are successful, who are happy, who, who are in love, who have a full range of human emotions, because a lot of times when we see people with marginalized identities being portrayed, it's almost always not always but mostly tropes, right? The angry the angry black woman, the sad sack fatty the inspiration porn disabled person, you know. And so you can learn just from from from seeing these, these accounts, that human diversity is normal, because really, and complex because most of what we're seeing in the feeds is, is just a load of like diet recipes. People with aspirational bodies that you might want to look like, all that type of stuff, or people who just just don't make me make us feel good. I mean, I'm so ruthless with ruthless ruthless with that shit, if I give people two chances. So if I say posted on my air. I'll give them a pass. The second post that makes me go, they're getting muted, or blocked depending on depending on if they were like an actual friend because I don't want to have an awkward conversation with someone. Like my uncle or aunt it was. I mean, why did you block me on Instagram? Gumby welcome with that. But yeah, so what else? Things like what shows that you're watching? And I mean, don't feel guilty for watching. You know, shit, silly, trashy type shows. If they blink bring you pleasure and fucking go for it. But notice if the if you feel triggered by it. And I know what is it that show love Island?

British show right? And it's on every single night. Every single night watching, I'm guessing it's an hour, an hour of content with really normative bodies. That's going to have an effect. So I'm not saying you can't watch love Island. I'm saying how about we also add in something that's good, you know, so it could be that you're watching Love Island. And while you're watching Love island because we have to be doing two things at the same time. Am I right? Yes. Me on on the Instagrams and being on love Island. And then also going and following some some, you know, people who don't have thin white bodies, or adding a show which has diverse bodies in go and go and watch that someone what is it called again? Someone, somebody somewhere? Or, you know, if you're like me, what I'm doing right now is I am binging on 90 days fiance. Happily ever after question mark. And I swear, how many hours is in a series? It feels like there's like 75 hours in a series? And it's like, am I ever going to get to the conclusion of this. But also, I really want to watch what happens because it's just so scandalous. But he's like taking up my whole life to watch a whole season of something. Because it's long, right? Versus British TV. It's like six episodes, and you're done. And you're like, Yeah, that was you know, but sometimes you do want a little bit longer. Anyway. So if I, if, for example, 90 day fiance was a trade show that I found triggering, I might maybe say, Okay, well, I'm going to going to watch three episodes tonight. And then maybe I'm going to do something, I'll put something in my brain watch something, look at something which is fat positive, or just not, you know, scratch my bum or whatever. Because it's not as helpful for me, but it does bring me a certain level of joy. You might say, You know what, this is just fucking me up watching Love Island every single night is fucking me up. And it might be that you just have to just not watch it for a while. Maybe in you know, six months time you feel a little bit better. And you can try again, you know? Or maybe not. Like, I personally wouldn't watch love Island, even though I know that I'd like it. Just because it's a lot of normative bodies a lot over a long period of time. So it's just quite risky for me, you know, and I do this for a job, right. And if someone like me, can see that, that is a risk. It might not be for you. But I just want to point it out that that could be different. So I would say here's another challenge, if you want to if you're curious if you're curious, do an evening or two when you're watching TV, and just count the number of normative bodies. So that's thin, white, young, not disabled. If it's men, like muscular, sis straight, so how many people do you see who fit those standards? Those Those have those privileges? And how many fat people do you see how many wheelchair users or or mobility aid users? How many trans or queer folks how many black indigenous or people of color, how many neurodiverse people are depicted, etc, etc, etc. And I think you may be surprised by how many ticks you have in that thin white, etc, etc column and how little ticks you have in the other column. And me too, right because we just don't have that many shows with with diversity. So yeah, who do you spend time with how many of these people are fat positive anti diet so you're free friends, your family, your colleagues, we are so influenced by the people that we spend time with. And it's so hard not to adopt that group think, and not to want to be accepted by joining in, when they're talking about diet stuff, or anti fat stuff. It's so hard not to, even if you're not joining in, to, in the back of your mind be like, Okay, well, this group of people, they're not on board with my thinking, even though I might not even told them what I think. And so maybe my thinking is wrong. Maybe me exploring this is wrong.

So do you have anyone that you're, you're, that is kind of like an island in the middle of that. I mean, you might have everyone in your life, that's anti diet. For me, I have lots of people on the outskirts, say, for example, neighbors, you know, the people that I see at the dog park, people who, you know, maybe I don't really know their names, and I don't know their politics in regards to anti diet, whatever. If I found out that they were pro diet and hated fat people, then I probably wouldn't be able to talk to them, because I'd be like, fuck you. But those people could theoretically be anti diet, and I just, I mean, pro or pro or anti diet, I just don't know. Because, you know, you're like, Oh, look at your dog. Oh, it's so cute. Look at this citizen, fluffy, blah, blah, blah. And you just don't talk about that. Sometimes you might, but so I might have people who are pro diet and all that type of stuff in my life. But the people with relationships, the people who I've got meaningful relationships with in my life, absolutely. There is not there's not one person who is not pro fat. Anti diet everyone is the has the same politics as me. And so many, cuz it's just like a for me, it's like a fundamental it's fundamental, basic human rights stuff, right? And not to saying not to say that I would never be friends with someone who hates fat people. But they would be they'd have to be changing their mind real quick. You don't I mean, I couldn't be friends with someone who was like fat people who fucking disgusting. I never want to be fat. Like, I could not do that. Because it just goes against my values. It goes against my values, my core, like core values of, you know, respecting other people and all that type of jazz. Anyway, so how much are you surrounded by people who are like, Oh, I don't want to be fat. Oh, I want to go on a diet, all that type of stuff. And by the way, I'm just gonna ask him the question just so that you can see. And then we can talk about what to do with those people, right? Because it's hard. It's Hey, H A R D. Hard. Because I mean, shit. There's so many reads like, what are you going to do just blow up your life because these people are, are, are far phobes you just want to say fuck you all and then you know, have no connections and just die. And it's not realistic, right? But it's, you know, just being aware of it is a really good stuff. Some of the questions before we get into like the kind of the core of what we're talking about. Where do you live? What types of bodies do you see on the street? Or at work? What's in your closet? Is it a bunch of things that don't fit? Does that make you feel good? Clothes? It's you know, covered in shit stains and holes, or you know, is it you know, things that you like, Oh, I feel okay in that. Or even maybe, oh, I feel good in that. I know that's not acceptable for a lot of people. But what are you feeling when you open your closet? What are you spending your money on? you spending your money on subscriptions to things that don't make you feel good? Like that gym down the road that advertises how much how many calories you're burning, if you go in there? That's, that's me. There's a gym on my street, outside in huge letters saying you're gonna burn 600 million calories. If you come in here and breathe the air for 12 seconds. I'm like, Well, how the fuck can you say that? Obviously I'm exaggerating. That's not what they say. But it's just wise. How can they say that people are going to burn X amount of calories and why? Why What are I know why but I'm like, Why would I care? rubber, I don't care about that. Why not have a sign saying you're gonna come in here and we're gonna have so much fucking fun? Shit, man, I'd be in there. But no, I see them doing these these wild workouts, because I want to burn calories, presumably to be thin. And I'm just letting obey me my name. So, yeah, I don't give them my money at all. Okay, so I have a post on the Instagrams that I posted this week, which is how to protect yourself from fat phobia. And so this is what we're going to do if we are surrounded by fat phobe and fat folks. And fat phobia is every

Unknown Speaker 35:38

route. And by the way, you know, I mentioned like everyone who I'm having, you know, genuine connections with in my life are fat positive. It's taken years. It's taken years. And it's only a kind of not, I'd say new, newish thing in the last maybe four years. Yeah, yeah. Yeah. Yeah, that's right. Yeah. And before I would have had, because for many different reasons that we're going to discuss, I would have had people who don't have the same beliefs as me and my life who had beliefs that will hurtful towards me. Because fat phobia is everywhere. Yeah, so. So what's a fatty got to do to protect themselves from this fucked up? fat phobic society. Something that I teach is called remove, reduce and protect. So the gold star is can you remove that source of fatphobia from your life, if possible, and a big Asterix all over this, this is often not possible, possible. So if it's, you know, you've got in your closet, a goal outfit, even something like that, you know, I'll say get rid of it. But that might not even be that easy. Because you're holding on to it for many different reasons of you know, hope and, and it's really sad to get rid of that goal outfit. So maybe you can if you've got a goal outfit in your in your wardrobe that you see every day, that's like whispering to you, you're so fat, you're a piece of shit, you don't fit into me. What a loser. That, you know, that's what you think when you see that outfit. Maybe you can just put it in the back of a closet, maybe you can put it under your bed, put it in a box, and you know, put it in the basement or attic, or, you know, very in a hole or whatever, you don't have to get rid of it. But that's like the Goldstar if we can get rid of something great. And if that's an option, great, so they could be really supportive, could be really supportive for our mental health. Not always. And it's not always an option right now. And all could take time. So an example, your boss is a raging fat phobe, you probably don't want to send them an email email saying, Hey, I've decided I ain't take talking to you anymore. Because you're a bellend. Not if you want to keep your job anyway. But you can perhaps work towards finding a new job, if that's an option for you. You can work towards you know, documenting the the incidences of bigotry that you're experiencing. And then you know, presenting it to HR if that's an option, but there's lots of if, if if you know, and as well thinking about the power dynamics, what power dynamics are at play. So, here's another example. You are a single parent and you are struggling financially. And so you're living with your mum, and your mom is just not great. But she supports you financially, she helps you out with childcare as well. She is not reasonable. And so is it going to be helpful for you to say hey, Mum, can you not ever talk about diets again, knowing that say if your mum's volatile, knowing that your mum could say get out of my house, I'm not going to help you anymore. That's probably you know, not the best for you. And so, when I say like the gold star is remove big Asterix is not always the best decision for you. But as we move on in this journey, we'll start to notice that things do Shift and those sources of fatphobia are removed from our lives in ways that feel good to us. All we might decide, You know what?

I'm just gonna put up with With grandma saying, I look fat because I only see her once a year, and she's probably going to be dead soon. You know, you might be you might say, you know, what? Is it worth it? Is it worth it? And you might just say no. But a lot of times, it is worth it if possible. So, if you're not removed, the next thing to do is reduce. So we've got removed, reduce and protect. So the next thing you do is reduce. So, for example, do you need to spend all day Sunday with your fat phobic family? How about you spend just three hours instead of six, the less exposure, the less chance that Uncle Barry is going to comment about how much weight you've put on? And go back to that TV show? TV shows that you'd like to watch? Would it be helpful for your mental health to reduce how long you spend watching, even temporarily. So what can we do is to redo to reduce exposure. Now protect. So sometimes, neither of those is possible. If we go back to the work example, if you have to work, nine to five sitting next to Susan, who has a diet culture and fat phobia, vortexing, the best thing that you can do is try to protect yourself from her. If there's nothing else that you can do, you can't say to your boss, shut up, whatever. You know, Susan's being a bell and again. And you know, Susan's telling you all about her new diet, where you put chili peppers up your bum and snow dust. Can you be browsing fat positive content while she does that? Can you put earphones in for a very important call that you're getting? Can you incorporate, reduce and protect together? So can you step away from your desk when Susan's like really getting on your flaps? You've like are Susan, I just need to go and do a poo. So I'll see you in a minute. Susan, you're talking about this new Daya gray shirt. Absolutely, then. Yeah, so it could be that you're you putting on your on your earphones and you start listening to an episode of First party podcast. It could be that you are in a Facebook group. And you go and make a post saying you never guess what Susan is sat here talking about this. And it just really is fucking getting on my tits. So remove reduced protect. And most of what we're doing is protecting because weight bias is systemic, right? Like an example, an example of going to the doctor's, we cannot control. Even if we say before we go and we repeat to the doctor, Hey, don't talk about wait. We can't control what that person does. And where we've made the decision to go and expose ourselves to potentially life endangering fatphobia. And they're going to be fat phobic anyway, not always. But you know, that's the risk. So what we can do is to do a little bit of protection, self care, you know, do what we can. When we do have, you know, all the stars align, and we can can do reduce and remove. And that's great. So I'm going to talk about boundaries. Now. This could be how we remove people from my life, and maybe we don't, who knows? I'm not saying that boundaries means that you're going to cut people from your life. But sometimes that happens, sometimes it doesn't. And boundaries really, I talk about boundaries a lot. And they really are an act of love. And I think about when I was not a boundary person. I was just like, in my head all the time being like, oh, that person is such a dickhead. I can't believe they did that or said that and bla bla bla bla and I can't believe that they think that's appropriate. I can't believe that there were 20 minutes late and they didn't even say sorry, I hate them so much. You know, and I would never say hey, hey, I'm not cool with you being 20 minutes late for our lunch or whatever.

Because I'd be terrified that they'd be like, Okay, well fuck you. I never want to be your friend again. And then I'll be like sad because you have to be courageous to say hey, that thing doesn't feel good for me. And by not setting boundaries I was making it so people could not get close to me they had no chance they I'm they're saying a hi nice. So nice to see you in my head thinking fucking idiots. 20 minutes late, and they think they're building a nice relationship with me and I'm like secretly hating them. It's if they had that gift of me saying hey, that really He actually bothers me that you're 20 minutes late. Then they could either adjust their behavior or whatever, we can come up with some solution. Or they could just be like, I'm not bothered, I'm going to be 20 minutes late. And I can choose to do that with that what I want, you know, whether that be saying, Okay, well, fine, I like you're not enough. And it's not that big of a deal to me, or, or actually, it is a big deal to me, and I'm not really into it. So not everyone can set boundaries, in regards to there being a power imbalance, like we talked about before, nor is it always appropriate. You know, I've given the examples before of that girl slapping me at that party, because she thought it was a great way to display what the phrase bitch slap meant. And then she saw me again in the street and slapped my bum. And that, in that second time, I decided not to reinforce my boundary, because I thought you're dead to me, I'm never gonna see you again, right? Sometimes, there's no, there's no way to get out of setting a boundary. So in that same example, girl slaps me at party. And immediately, I had to say, Do not ever do that to me again, because it was so egregious. So yeah, so just like a big caveat. And if you don't set boundaries, please, you're not? You're not less than for not setting boundaries. It is so hard. Why do we have to be? Why do we have to be good at communicating with other people? Why? Why can't they just read our minds? Come on now. And people have known you, potentially for years, as someone who loves a better diet, or who loves talking about how, you know, they want to lose weight and not be fat and Bella. And so this is this is a process if you want to say to people, Hey, can we not talk about diet stuff anymore? It's, it's gonna maybe be a shock for people and be difficult. And so this is what I say this is the way that I like to approach it is saying, Can you help me with something? So this is for people who you care about, who you want a relationship with? Who you want to be open and honest with? When you set boundaries, that's not always the case. Right? It could be just some, you know, it could just be Susan at work. And you're like, Susan, Listen, can you not talk about that anymore? But when it's someone that I care about, I'll say, Hey, I'm wondering, can I help you help with help on something? And they'll say, yes. You know, when someone says, Can I have your help? Yes. Oh, my goodness, I would love to help. I'm, I'm doing this thing where I'm unlearning all of the kind of unhelpful fatphobia and diet stuff that I've learned, I've realized that it's really affecting my mental health. And what I've recognized is that when I hear people talking about food, or dieting, or, or their way, is really triggering for me. So I'm wondering if, if you can, if I can get your help, and you can avoid talking about those things while I'm around. That's my favorite go to have, you know, Hey, can I help? Can Can you Can I get some help? And so you're not saying, Hey, listen up here, you are a GIANT TURD. And you are a bad person, because you talk about diets, which is people might hear you say that anyway, even if you don't say that. And I always thought that saying to someone, Hey, can you not do that meant that they were probably going to flip a table? They will probably going to be like, What the fuck? Who do you think you are? To ask me? Like, I would be so like, or if they didn't say that. They'd be leaving going like, you're right. Never going to do that. Who do they think? You know, that type of thing. But guess what?

People were just like, Oh, okay. Not everyone. But let's say a good 95% People are like, Oh, okay. Can you tell me more about that? And I'm like, oh, because I really thought that they were going to be like, Fuck you, you're dead to me. And the more that I practiced it, the more I was like, oh, people, a lot of them are actually very kind. And a lot of them want to do good by me. Wow, that's really nice to hear. Wow, we can strengthen our relationship. Wow, we have a really good relationship now. Whereas before I secretly hated them, because they were doing normal things. You know, they didn't know bothered me. So, here's the thing, you'll do that first thing, and then you're like, how was fucking hard, but it went? Well, you know, they're probably never going to say diet Kotori things again, and of course, the next time you see them, they would have forgotten that conversation, maybe not forgotten it, but it will, they'll just slip up. No fault of their own. Well, you know, whatever, else slip up. Same with me with my pronouns, right? The people will just slip up. The, the way they react when they what you need to do, and the way they react, when they slip up is a really good indicator of who they are. And so you just taking the stance of how when someone gets my pronouns wrong, I will just say, Oh, they, or I'll just say, oh, yeah, and non binary, something like that. I'll just say just simple as that, no, kind of like, hey, that really Brotherbrother unless they're being really, you know, rude about it. And it's just not a big deal. So you could say someone's like, Oh, my God, have you tried this new diet? And you're like, Oh, hey, you remember, I'm not talking about diets? And they will? Oh, yeah. Because remember, they might have known you for years as someone who likes talking about diets. So it's going to take time for them to get used to it. And so you might have to do this a few times. It's up to you, if you want to do it at all, or how long you want to do it for. You might say, You know what? I'm just gonna keep doing it until they get it because there's the, they're a big part of my life, and I'm just gonna keep helping them understand until they get it. It could be that you know, that you're like, Okay, well, shit, man, I've seen this person, five times. Now, every single time I've had to say this, I'm going to reduce the amount of contact with them. Or I might even choose to remove them from my life eventually, maybe? Who knows. So how is this life played out for me in real life. An example of someone who I chose to remove from my life is someone I gave many chances to, and there are a core core member of my family. And when it became clear that they had no intention of not being a bigot, that's when I said that's, you know, unfortunately, that's the end of our relationship. And, and so my tolerance level was, you know, a certain amount, but then when they were like, I don't care about hurting your feelings, then I was like, Okay, well, there's nothing to work with there. So see you later. And that happens to be three, three years ago. So it's been so nice, not having them in my life. Because they just weren't very good. They didn't care about it, they didn't care about my feelings or wanting to be close to me, they cared about their own beliefs. Right. And, and that was difficult. And that was years and years and years in the making, because there's lots of different issues at play, right? Now, let's think of someone like my mum, who had spent her whole life in diet culture and fatphobia. It took time, and many times me saying, hey, sometimes it took longer, because we don't you know, she lives in Ireland, and I'm here in Vancouver, and I maybe wouldn't see her and, you know, speak to her on the phone long enough for it to come up. But then when I would see her in person, it would be triggered more, because, you know, maybe she'd see me eating food. Or maybe she'd see me wearing clothes. And then that's where the opportunities where she might say things. And so it took a while and now she is great.

She is you know how people say all the time, well, I can't change my mum, I can't change my granddad. They're old. And I'm like, what the, that's got nothing to do with anything to people who are older not have capacity for kindness, to learn things? I don't think so I think that's kind of ages, ages to suggest that just because someone has, you know, spent seven decades in this thing that they have no capacity to change. They do. Yes, it's going to be harder. But there are many people who are older, who are on the frontlines of of changing the way that we think about identity and advocating for others. So kind of just writing off your parents or your grandparents because they're old, and they won't get it, I don't think is very fair to them. And if they're using that excuse of I'm old I don't get it. Well, sorry. Sorry, mom. There's lots of people who do get it. And you know, my mom's one of the examples, my mom's 70. Right? So, yeah, there's that there's a lady that I talked to I look at her a dog, sometimes she's 70. She's the most, she's so forward thinking, like, and she's like, how can people think like this? And that, and I'm like, Yeah, right. So, and there's young people who are the opposite, who will have really fucked up views. So I really don't think age has got a huge amount to play with it. And I don't think it's appropriate to just give older people a pass because of their age. And also recognizing, there could be many cultural differences that make it more difficult, right, because, you know, it could be the you don't never talk back to your elders in your culture or your community. And that that is really just a no go. And that's where it comes with a big Asterix again, of it might not always be appropriate or the best time because say, if you wanted to set a boundary with, uh, you know, your auntie, or whatever, and if you did that, it would mean that your mum would disown you, and you you know, everyone in your family would be talking about you? And did it? Uh, is that going to be supporting your mental health? Probably, maybe not, you know, so maybe it is better for your mental health. To see auntie who says, Oh, look how fat you are. And then go and be like, Oh, thanks for RTC later, and go listen to you know, fat positive podcast, go read fat positive book, Nazi Auntie as much, you know. So all of this stuff is a beer kind of. But who knows? Who knows? And the other thing is with boundaries, sometimes you have you can have really rigid boundaries and say no, absolutely not. Someone does this. And that is a hard kind of like, No, I'm not into it. And sometimes you can have really rigid boundaries that can soften sometimes, because for many different reasons. And so you can have more flexible boundaries. And here's the thing, though, is I think, if we're going to be setting boundaries, if we can, not consistently not stick to them, you know, so So if you say, Hey, listen, Mum, if you talk about diets, I'm gonna have to leave. And then mum talks about diets, and you don't ever leave, then I think that it's counterintuitive to even say, the boundary in the first place.

Because what mum is hearing is that they're not serious when they say this, they're not serious. And so I'm never going to take them seriously. In fact, I can just, you know, walk all over that boundary, because it's just, it's just a, it's just a wish and a hope. versus going to, you're going to follow through with it. But then again, something might come up where you can't, for whatever reason, so. So again, like big caveat with that, whatever you do to try and survive fat phobia is great. Whatever that looks like, if you're, if you're a fat person, and you are alive, and you you've survived fatphobia for this long, is you've done it, right, you're doing it. And there are options that we can explore, which might make it even better, that might be even more helpful. And there is always going to be times where you're like, right, okay, next time someone says this, I'm going to say, you know, studies show this and blah, blah, blah, and then it happens. And you're like, Oh, hi, yeah, I would love to know more about your diet, because you're in the moment, and then all of a sudden, all our information that you've got in your brain is you know, just flying off somewhere else because you're in a moment of panic, and all you can do is just nod and agree. And that's fine, too. Really, so don't don't be getting down on yourself if that's what you have to do. And also you don't have to be verbally or written. Resisting in that way you can resist fat phobia and diet culture in many ways. Example, you're out of your friends. They're all like, Oh my I'm going to have a salad. You're at dinner. I'm just going to have a salad. Oh, I couldn't possibly eat anything else worse. Yeah. Oh my god, me too. I'm so greedy today. i i I looked at some sugar and the osmosis of the sugar went into my brain and I'm just sure I've put on loads of weight because of it. Yes, the other friends is like, oh my god, yeah, all I want is just some carrots. And you could say nothing. And be like, yeah, actually, I'll have some, some dinner, you know, I'll have something was not a salad. And that can be in incredible, that could be so brave in the face of that. Or you could just not say anything, not engage. That too, is incredible. And I think about, you know, like, the, the often the ways that fat people, you know, the kind of like, the common things that people do, when they're learning to accept their bodies, you know, wear a bikini, or, you know, eat donuts, or whatever. And I feel like, you know, it's resistance, right, that's what I see that as a as an act of resistance. I'm going to do this thing anyway, even though you are shaming me indirectly, because you're not saying, Oh, you're so fat, and you shouldn't eat a salad, I'm not going to accept that shame. And so that could be what you're doing. And it could be that you're not even doing it like in front of your friends, you go home and, you know, you order the salad, then because you're under so much pressure to only a salad. And then you go home, and allow yourself to eat what you really want it to eat. You know, it doesn't have to be in front of people. It could be something that you do on your own. And that is incredible to anyway that you can resist. And you don't have to resist, by the way, because it's not safe. A lot of times it's not safe. Sometimes you have to play along, you know, and an example is going to the doctors and they say hey, you need to do this and that and or we're not going to give you health care. And you could just be like, yeah, absolutely. You might even you might even, you know, go on a diet because you have to because the doctor says so because they're going to deny health care to you unless you do this thing. You might have to put your act of resistance in that could be just be like, You know what, I'm not going to, I'm going to work to not internalize all of this shame that this doctor is trying to give me. So share. Do you remember I don't know if you remember I just saw this recently on Facebook and update from there was a trigger warning. I'm going to talk about medical fat phobia. an egregious case and don't worry, no one died.

Or towards the end of the episode. There was a case like a it feels like it was about a year ago, there was a video of this girl. And she says I just got at the doctor's and she was sobbing. She was really crying. And the doctor had said to her she had been really sick, she has not been able to eat anything because she'd been really sick, couldn't keep anything down. And she'd lost lots of weight. She was still fat though. And the doctor says it's probably a good thing that you've not been able to eat anything because you've lost weight. And so she went out into her car. And then she went actually went back into the doctor's surgery and confronted the guy and said that was fucked up. And he said sorry, you can't handle my jokes. Anyway, she posted that video on I think originally Tik Tok and then also Instagram. It blew up and lots of people were like, you deserve care go for it's complete please keep going to find find another doctor. She did. She resisted. She took that shame and said it's not for me. went to another doctor. Turns out she had stage three no feels bowel cancer. She had cancer basically stage three because it was to do with her stomach is one of the issues was see her she had surgery and she's she's recovering.

If that should never have happened, it happens all the time. There are so many deaths at the hands of doctors who are fat phobic. She was able to resist because she posted that video and got lots of support. She probably got a lot of hate as well, obviously. And for whatever reason she was able to get another doctor and her persistence saved her life. So yeah, I don't know why I'm I'm telling this story, but I just saw that yesterday and I was like, oh shit, I remember her and, and oh, and that's what happened. She had fucking cancer. So yeah, if you can, if you can show resistance in any way. And it could have been that, that in that first doctor, she just said, yeah, oh, yeah, it is a good thing that I'm thinking now. Can you do some tests on me, please? You know, and that could have been the outcome. And then the tests were done. And she she could they could discover what was wrong with her. Obviously, that didn't happen, but in no way is it her fault or totally, you know, in case anyone is coming across, like she should have done this. You know, she should never have had to experience that ever, ever, ever, ever, ever. If she had a thin body, she would have had that diagnosed ages before because she'd been suffering for I think she said, five to seven years, because she switched something about early 20s. And she said she was 27. And yeah, so she would have been suffering for years. If a thin person had lost a lot of weight, and someone's and they said, Oh, I'm not I'm losing loads of weight. I can't eat. The doctor would say sounds like something is not right. For that person. They say good. It's probably a good thing. Yeah, so resistance could be life saving for for many people. And I just you know, big big breath air because it's a nice feeling kinda feeling kind of a lot that you know, knowing that that type of stuff. And also you deserve you deserve we all deserve to live in an environment where we are free from stigma, bigotry, marginalization, all of that stuff. You deserve to be able to watch Patty cakes and dumpling and somebody somewhere and just have live a happy family life without having to come across all of this bullshit but it's not where we're at right now. Unfortunately. Oh, ending on such a shit note. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. Yeah, so anyway, well, if you if you want to learn more about all of this stuff dealing with this stuff, so I have faced by the Academy I am I've not revealed this to anyone yet but I will be changing the way that I do First Flight Academy. So the next time I launch First Flight Academy it will be as a self study program and so it's going to be 50% off because it's going to be self study so all the materials are there and so it means you don't get calls with me. But you get everything and all of the previous calls like few years of calls in there so yeah, so it's good so because of that it's going to be 50% off so that's coming up I'll let you know when that happens. I'm not sure when yet but it's in my brain to do that. Yeah, and I hope you have an landline the rest of your day and I will see you in a while alligator remember to stay first fatty Good boy

thanks for listening to the episode and if you feel ready to get serious about this work and want to know when the doors open to fears fatti Academy which is my signature program, where I teach all about how to overcome your fat phobic beliefs and learn to love your fat body, then go to first fatty.com forward slash waitlist again that is fierce fatty.com forward slash waitlist to get your name on the waitlist. For when first party Academy my signature program opens.