EP130 Transcript

You're listening to The Fierce Fatty Podcast Episode 130: Mistakes well-meaning dieticians make that can hurt fat folks. I'm your host, Vinny Welsby. Let's do it.

I'm Vinny Welsby, TEDx speaker, best-selling author, and fat activist. I have transformed my life from hating my body with desperately low self-esteem to being a courageous and confident fierce fatty who loves every inch of this jelly. Society teaches us living with a fat body is bad. But what if we spent less time, money, and energy on the pursuit of thinness and instead focused on the things that actually matter? Like if pineapple on pizza should be outlawed? Or if the mullet was the greatest haircut of the 20th century? So how do you stop negative beliefs about your fat body controlling your life? It's the Fierce Fatty Podcast. Let's begin.

Hello, fatty Welcome to this episode. How were you? How's live, you're doing good. I realized that I have not ever done a land acknowledgement. For the podcast, I'm thinking about the new podcast, Intro music, whatever, I need to change it because it's got my old name in it. And in that I'm going to put a land acknowledgement but just an FYI. You may know that I live in Canada in Vancouver, which is the traditional ancestral and unceded territory of the Coast Salish people, the People's Squamish slaver tooth and Musqueam nations. Yes, and that's where I live. And I've been thinking about this and how it needs to be part of every episode so I thought in the in the intro would be great if I'm gonna put it out. So anyway, that's the First Nations community lands here that I live on in what is currently known as Vancouver. So today, I am talking about her Oh, hello, health. And I'm doing this episode because someone asked me someone asked me to and I was like, That's a great idea. You You're you clever a lot. You know what, because I forget what I talk about on I forget what episodes I've done and not done. And I know that I've talked about health being a social construct before but I looked and I was like, Oh, shit, I've never even done an episode on it like Episode Episode dedicated to it. Because I had shared a post on the Instagrams and someone said, oh, you should do an episode focusing on this. And the post that I shared was the social determinants of health. This is a caption that I wrote, there are so many things that influence health, and most are not in our control. Weight is not a behavior. And it is not in our control. For the vast majority majority of people. The moralistic value that society places on quote, healthy bodies, is ableism health ism, and not helpful for anyone. Health is largely a social justice issue. Health is not attainable for many healthy the temporary state health is a social construct. And someone left left a comment saying you need to talk about that more. And I said, in my brain, you got it. You got it. I'm gonna do it. I'm gonna do it. Because you know what, sometimes I like these points that I think that I've made. Because I've spoken about them, like briefly on the podcast in different posts, and whatever. And really, actually have I spoken about them? Have I made an episode so someone can Google Health as a social construct and find my stuff? No, I have. No. So yeah. Today's Friday fitting good. Dude, you just got back from a spa day.

Don't get the dog he has had his hair cut for the first time in his whole life actually, well, I've cut his hair before but professionally, I mean, he went to the groomer for the first time and normally I just groom him myself but something good that happened in the pandemic was that did he have to go into the vet on his own? Obviously, I drove him there. He didn't just you know, make an appointment himself and go, I would drive him there and then pass them on to the The vet because COVID wasn't loaded. And they reported back saying he's an angel when you're not there. So this motherfucker has been going around growling and snapping up people. He doesn't bite. He just snaps which is scary, though, right? And he's a little dog, but he's still scary. And seems to be really stressed out. And so I was like, Well, I can't ever take him to the groomer, because he's just going to one like, scare the groomer. And to, he's going to be really upset and terrified. Yeah, that's what that's like. That is fine. He's like, wanting cuddles. It's like you tricky little motherfucker. So yeah, so I've made an appointment for him to go to the groomers. I just, we just started out last week. We've just London now clip just to see how I liked it. And he didn't want to leave afterwards. Yeah, so I had to go in, go grab him because the groomers is just half a block away. And she was going to take it back. But anyway, he, he didn't want to leave. And today he's gone for the full, full spa treatment. And now he looks like a fucking teddy bear. So get out. I want to murder him because he looks so cute, his little bomb. Because nobody has what I call his skirt on the back. Because he has really long hair. And I was like that needs to go. And they made it into like a teddy bear bomb. And yeah, so he might be murdered by the end of the day, because I'm gonna be loving on him so much because he looks so cute. Yeah. So if your dog is like, doggy, maybe, maybe they just do it when you're around? Maybe not. You know? Who knows? And he can't tell for sure he enjoyed it. But I'm guessing he did. Because he seemed pretty happy and excited. So, yes. Okay, so talking about this, today's Health is a social construct. I'm going to just define what is health? And what is social construct? what do what do they mean. And they get into the concept of health being a social construct. And that related to fatness and ableism, and health ism, and all that type of job so, so even Google Health, we just did a little Google, which I did. And the word health is a noun and the state of being free from illness or injury, or a person's mental or physical condition. And that's pretty limited, right? So that's a DEC dictionary definition to being free from illness or injury. But we have other definitions. And so this is from the Government of Canada, who is quoting the World Health Organization, who says the World Health Organization offers a simple definition of health as a state of complete, physical, mental and social well being, and not merely the absence of disease or infirmity. social well being is an important aspect of this desh definition that may not always occur to us in thinking about health. So what does that mean? What does that mean? A state of complete physical, mental social, well being a state of complete physical, mental and social well being and not merely the absence of disease. So well, beingness is what the what who says it is, okay, so well being well being pneus. Or if we look at the simple definition, being free from illness or injury, Injury is a social construct. So let's look at the the dictionary definition the Merriam Webster says that it is an idea that has been created and accepted by the people in a society. So an idea that has been created and accepted by the people in a society. Well, I hear you, I hear you. Isn't that everything? Yeah, it's a lot of it's a lot of things, a lot of things.

So what is a social construct? We're gonna go to another site that gives us some examples. So this is what they say social constructs developed within a society or group. They don't represent objective reality, but instead are meaningful only because people within the society or group accept that they have meaning. Simply put social Your constructs do not have inherent, meaning, the only meaning they have is the meaning given to them by people. For example, the idea that pink is for girls and blue is for boys is an example of a social construct related to gender, and the color of items. The collective perception that a particular color can be associated with a certain gender is not an objective representation of truth, or fact. Instead, it is a social convention that came to have meaning within the context of society. And so they go on to list some examples. There are many examples of social constructs. Most common practices and behaviors that are generally accepted within a societal group represent social constructs. These societal norms don't have to be accepted by every single person in order to be social construct constructs, they can and often do change over time. So some examples here, there's lots of different exams, but I'm just going to read out the ones which are related more to what we're talking about today. So adulthood, the specific of when a person is considered to be an adult is a social construct. In the United States, and most of the EU people are considered to be adults at the age of 18. However, in Scotland, people are considered to be adults at the age of 16. And in reality, so if we're talking about reality, if we were to define adulthood, as the time where our brains are more developed, where we are at a certain level of maturity, then it will probably actually be 25. But then we have to think about like, well, do we let people who are under 25 do stuff, even though maybe their brains aren't totally fully developed? Well, yeah. And so it's kind of like, we have to come to a decision about what being an adult means by society standards. I mean, like, you know, for some things, I think it's appropriate to say 16, or 18, but other things, I think, maybe not. So gender behaviors, the concept of certain behaviors, being specific to a person's gender is a social construct. This applies to the idea that men should keep their emotions bottled up, or the notion that women are overly emotional. It also applies to the belief that boys should play with trucks and girls with dolls. Gender roles are also social constructs associated with gender roles, such as formally widely held belief that women should stay at home and men should work. This also relates to the belief that certain types of jobs are women's work, while others represent men's work. Disability, the concept of disability is a social construct. The social construct of disability often relates to visible indicators of disability, such as using a wheelchair or missing a limb. People who have less visible disabilities are often misunderstood because their conditions don't fit into the social constructs of others. Like you hear many stories of people parking in the disabled spot, and someone rushing out being like this is for disabled people, because they're not in a wheelchair, and then the person you know, being like, well, you know, and they take their, you know, they take their leg off or whatever to reveal that. They're using a leg to help them walk or, or they have a disability, which is not visible. It gets on my tits that really gets on my tits when people are saying, you know, you can't use that washroom because it's for disabled people who's on what how can you tell whether your eyeballs that someone is disabled or not? It's none of your fucking business. You know? But I can see why people do that because they want to protect disabled people, but in that they are harming disabled people.

Yes, and if we think about like with disability, everything about glasses, whereas you wouldn't, if you will, glasses probably describe yourself as having a disability. Whereas maybe a few 100 years ago, before we were able to access glasses, or I don't know when glasses were invented. I know sunglasses were invented a really long time ago. Yeah, so then if you depending on your level of sight, that would be a disability. So it like if I didn't have my glasses, I couldn't I couldn't drive I you know, sometimes struggle to get around. My mom it really has very limited vision without her glasses and she could barely get around the room and so then that would be classed as a disability. But now, this this age that I have that I wear glasses are seen as cool, right? Not everyone thinks they're cool I do but But it's just no big deal. You wouldn't think, Oh, look at that, look, that's that person to say, well, because they're wearing glasses, it's just a normal thing. And that's, that's a social construct to say that that wearing glasses is not a disability, whereas using a wheelchair, or mobility aid is a disability. And so some folks with disabilities don't see themselves as disabled. And some do isn't, you know, disabled people are not a monolith. But anyway, it's a social construct is what we're talking about. And some people buy into that construct, and some people don't. Illness. Illness is also a social construct. The word illness doesn't mean the same thing to everyone. Some only perceive medical medical conditions as illnesses, if they would cause a person to be, I don't know this word, bedridden, I don't like that. That's like, a negative thing to be in bed, or contagious, while others perceive a wide variety of medical circumstances to represent illness. Yeah, so for example, illness and let's like, extend this to health. I've used this example before, but one time that really made me think about this was going to the doctors, and had had like an annual checkup, or whatever, had my blood work done. And the doctor says you Oh, absolutely healthy. And she handed my script for all the different various things that medication I need to take to make sure that I can live, you know, I won't die without the medications removed before we would. But I should be saying I am healthy. But am I healthy, is the way that I'm I and she is perceiving these conditions, because they are easily, somewhat easily remedied remedied with medication means that they are no longer a barrier to so called health status, or health status. But then if say if I had no i didn't have access to medication or couldn't afford to pay for medication, because I have to pay for my medication in Canada. would then I not be healthy? is health. Only for those who are able to manage their health condition? Does that then make someone healthy or unhealthy? Like am I healthy? Because I can take antidepressants that make my depression symptoms? Mostly go away? Does that then mean I'm healthy? But then you might say yes, but then if say if a week I didn't take my antidepressants, then maybe then I would not. But the difference is between me medicating it or not. So is what. It is complicated, right? It is complicated. I get the last example of a social construct here that they're giving is time. Time is a social construct that isn't meaningful only in the context of human created systems that are used to describe time, seconds, minutes hours, and make it meaningful in some places. Daylight Savings Time is not observed. Oh, I want to be one of those places. The concept of seasonal time changes does not exist where they are not practiced. Yeah, we need to get rid of daylight savings that shifts away. We're not farming anymore. Anyway. Yeah. So other examples of social constructs money, governments. They mentioned gender here. Yes. So it's anything that which is not a fact, I would argue that, you know, how much of stuff is factual? It's as factual as we know it, according to science today, right. And that's the thing is, you know, like science, scientists will always say like, this is the best we know today.

And, and so we're with a lot of things like it's pretty much very well established. So uncertain things, but other things. We've just kind of made it up. And everyone said, Oh, that sounds about right. Yeah, yeah. Even though maybe at the time it sounded about right. You know, women have to stay in the home and have to do this and your men, men or men's personality traits are this and all that type of stuff may have worked. I mean, did it ever work? No. But maybe it may have been more relevant 200 years ago, but it's no longer such. So you know, we could change, you know, 200 years and we'd be like, lol, remember, in the olden days when they used to think that women should stay at home. So yeah, so yeah, so yeah, so yeah, also, let's just finish off there. He's here. For this, this this bit, by the way, links in the show notes, this is episode 129. So facebook.com, forward slash, one to nine finishing off this this little bit is expand your understanding of social constructs, expanding your understanding of social constructs involved considering, which are the things that you know, actually have objective meaning, versus which ones are meaningful only because people in a group, assign meaning to them, and continue to allow that assigned meaning to persist. Explore your perceptions versus those of others by reviewing some examples of sociological imagination. This will allow you to consider situations from other points of view and will come to appreciate perspectives other than your own. So another example is religion. So this line here they're saying, people in in group assign meaning to them, and continue to allow that Mitt that assign meaning to persist. And so I was watching something on Netflix. I started watching it last night about the the Mormon group that's led by Jeff, what's his name? They are called the Latter Day Saints of fundamental Latter Day Saints. flts. Anyway, religious group, very conservative, and they had the Prophet which was this guy, Jeff's dad, and the Prophet was meant to live forever because he was a prophet and what up see he died. And so they're like, What the heck, we're not prophet was in live forever. And so then the son was like, huh, one of they had what, how many? How many children did this guy have? Because they believe in plural marriages. This guy had like hundreds of hundreds of children. Um, so one of the favorite sons, who was who was said to be magical in some way was like, Well, turns out dad's dad's come back, he's in my body now and I'm the Prophet. And so then the group had to get behind that idea. And then you anyone who was a threat to the idea that there's this guy, Jeff was actually the Prophet reincarnated. The dad reincarnated in his body was ousted. And then that became, you know, the new group belief, the that the prophet had reincarnated into the son's body, and, and that you had to do certain things and wear your hair in a certain way and wear underwear down to your ankles, and up to your wrists and lalalalala because that's what they all believed, right? And still believe.

So let's look at sociology. Because we can also look at this from a sociological frame. And I'm looking at the social construction of health, from open texts BC, which is open text off of a sociology course. And so I'm going to read a few quotes from here. So medical sociology is the system systematic study of how humans manage issues of health and illness, disease and disorders, and health care for both the sick and the healthy. The social construction of health explains how society shapes and is shaped by medical issues. The social construction of health is a major research topic within medical sociology. At first glance, this concept of a social construction of health does not seem to make sense. After all, if disease is measurable, physiological problem, a measurable physiological problem, then there can be no question of socially constructing disease, right? Well, it's not that simple. The idea of the social construction of health emphasizes the socio cultural aspects of the disciplines approach to physical, objective definable phenomena. Sociologists Conrad and Barker. 2010 offer a comprehensive framework for understanding the major findings of the last 50 years of development in this concept. Their summary categorizes the findings in the field under three subheadings the cultural meaning of an illness, the social construction of the illness experience, and the social construction of medical knowledge. Many medical sociologists contend that illness has both a biological and an experiment, experimental component and that these components exist independently of each other. Our culture, not our biology dictates which illnesses are stigmatized, and which are not which are considered disabilities and which are not, and which are deemed contestable, meaning some medical professionals may find the existence of this ailment questionable As opposed to definitive illnesses that are unquestionably recognized in the medical profession, Conrad and Barker 2010. For instance, sociologist Erving Goffman 1963 Describe how social stigmas hinder individuals from fully integrating into society. In essence, Goffman suggests we might view illness as a stigma that can push others to view the ill in an undesirable manner. The stigmatization of illness often has the greatest effect on the patient, and the kind of care they receive. Many contend that our society and even our healthcare institutions discriminate against certain diseases like mental disorders, AIDS, venereal diseases, and skin disorders. I think for those that don't think you say VD anymore. And that's from Satorious 2007 facilitator, these diseases may be subpar, they may be segregated from other health care areas, or relegated to a poorer environment, the stigma may keep people from seeking help for the illnesses making it worse than it needs to be. So. So if you want to learn more about like the sociological side of looking at that, and how, how we view conditions and how doctors or healthcare professionals view conditions, then there's a whole whole field of study that's been going on for a very long time, because health is a social construct. Because it's not just as we're saying, in this, this, this bit, I just read out, it's not just this definable thing, it's this thing, it's, it's something that changes depending on how society and individuals who adhere to the social constructs in society interact with health, and what they think health is, and different types of illness, conditions, etc, etc. So I like to think about this concept. And the, the construct of health in regards to health as a destination, and health as a status and its influences. So what I'm talking about when I say one health as a destination,

thinking about how society views, health is something that you can arrive at, like it's the terminus station. And that if you do do certain things, and you're going to arrive, just hop on the health train, and we're going to get to that station, and the station is called Health. And if you maintain taking certain actions, and those actions being being thin, exercising, and eating the quote, right food, then you're going to get to that destination of health is what largely we believe in society and what kind of the average everyday person believes. And it boils down to it, it boils health down to a very simple, unlimited equation, or definition. You know, like, you get your you get your luggage, you got your luggage, which is eating right, exercising, right, and being thin. Now we can jump on the train and the train is gonna get us to the destination of health. So, that's a construct in regards to that is what many of us in design a society have decided, is the reality of what health is. And and yes, there's some nuance in there. Like I'm boiling it down to the very simplest ideas, but you know, people were like, oh, yeah, you know, you do need to also get a good night's sleep and drink water and, you know, all of those types of things and or maybe maybe you should do some yoga as well, you know, we want to be holistic about it, but then we can jump on that train and, you know, maybe the train might hit some some, you know, leaves on the ground, like happens in the UK leaves on the track and it needs to have maybe, maybe there's a little stop or, you know, a delay, but basically we've put those, we've got the luggage we've the inputs are there. Therefore we know that health is going to be out the outcome and That's just not the reality, right? That's just not reality. So when we think about health as a destination, something that you can put in a little bit input stuff, you're going to arrive that, you know, there might be a little bit of, you know, things that might pop up from time to time that is out of your control, but you've done the quote, right things, therefore, you're going to get to the destination, or you're at the destination, we're going to stay at the destination. So this concept and the construct of this is it says that health or lack of health is totally down to an individual and what they do, what control they have, because why would someone not be healthy when it's so easy, all you need to do is eat quote, right? Exercise. And be thin. Easy peasy, lemon and lime. So So you know, you've got this choice to be healthy. Why wouldn't you do it if it's so easy. And the reason is, because people who decide, quote, you know, decide to be unhealthy. They're bad in some way, they are lazy or unintelligent, or poor. And it says, if you get sick with some with some things, then it's okay. But something else, that's a moral failings or an example, if you get sick, because or you have an illness injury, because you're doing something that supports the idea that health is being thin, exercising, and eating right, and you come up against something, that means that you get an illness or an injury from that, then that's good, that's okay. But if it's outside of that, then it's not good. Okay. So an example would be an injury that I have had is I went skiing,

I used to go skate all the time, fell to a couple of ligaments in my knee. And I need surgery to have time off work. But never once did I think, or come into the kind of like, oh, well, if you weren't so so much of a skier, you never would have encountered that. What is your own fault for skiing? No, because I was doing an activity I was exercising, therefore I was being a good fatty I was doing the things that I needed to do to do. According to this construct that we have currently around health, the things I needed to do to be at that destination of healthy. But what if someone is diagnosed with something that we associate associate with fatness and they're a fat person, for example, the classic one is type two diabetes. And what we know about type two diabetes is it is predominantly a genetic condition. And the you cannot eat your way into getting diabetes. It is not anyone's fault if they have type two diabetes, but that is not the message that we get. That's it's an inevitable, inevitable because you did something bad, which is being fat, you weren't doing the things you want, you are adhering to the inputs, being thin, eating the right foods and exercising. So therefore you are not going to arrive at the destination of health. And the idea that, you know, when a thin person gets sick, and oh, that's just the way life is maybe they were unlucky. It wasn't because of something they did or didn't do. But when a fat person gets sick, it's because they're fat. What can we expect? Is what society says. So, and then outside of fatness we think about fatness we have other things which are, you know, something that's seen as good or bad. So say if you got you had the flu, that's fine. You know, no stigma around that. Maybe you know, people don't want you to go make out with them if you've got the flu, but people are not like what type of person gets the flu? Mm hmm. Whereas say if you got an STD, you had syphilis. Well, then that's bad. That's shameful. But both are equally morally the same with engaging properly in similar types of behavior contact with other human beings. You know, so then why is one devastate bitingly shameful, potentially for people and stigmatized, but the other is just part of being a human being. And that is because we view health in a certain way, right? This, this, this also the definition of, you know, the, the idea of health as a destination, it positions fat people as being so willfully ignorant of the very easy Health Formula. And according to this fat people, we stick our fingers in our ears and are determined to make other people and the government pay for our recklessness. The formula is so simple. Why don't you just do it, then you'd be healthy, is what we know about this version of health? And the answer to that is because, you know, isn't it? That's not the reality. This construction of health that we currently have in society is almost exclusively exclusively exclusively focused focused on physical health. And it's super super laced with white supremacy, and ideas from white culture of what health is. And I'm gonna be talking about First Nations ideas about health shortly, just to show how different it can be their constructs around health. It also denies, you know, that's the holistic way, you know, many cultures, think about health, not even just some First Nation cultures, many cultures like this is this is a very Western, you know, American view of, of what health is. And in many cultures, right, you know, but then also in many cultures is different.

But this is our perception. This is our perception of what health is and differences, sometimes can even be hard to imagine, because we all know is that we'll know if you do this and that then you're going to be healthy probably. It also implies health is a choice, and denigrates, those who do not, quote, choose health. It disregards those who can never be healthy or able bodied and leaves them at the sidelines. as second class citizens, you're disabled. Well, sorry. So well. And it's all about how people view your health, which in turn affects your health negatively, right. It's, you know, if you are on a desert island, and you've got type two diabetes, you and you and your doctor on a desert island together, and the doctor says, Sorry, you got type two diabetes, would it seem as devastating if you didn't have anyone to? To judge you? If you didn't have anyone to view or make assumptions about who you were as a person? It would probably be a lot easier to deal with. Because of the way that society view certain conditions. And what if we removed shame from health? What if we did remove all of that kind of learned shame from health and we might go to the doctors more, we might be connected with the community more because we realize that we have more health conditions in common. You know, like, I bet, the health condition that you feel shameful about loads of other people have it and because no one's talking about it. You know, we feel shame. And it's like, oh, well, actually, who knew that? Brad Pitt has HSV genital herpes? Oh, well, if Brad Pitt came out and said, Hey, I have genital herpes. Maybe we wouldn't be viewing it so negatively. As an example, I need to get a new fucking, I would say Brad Pitt. I think it's showing that kids are talking about Brad Pitt, as in the most like the idol of celebrities nowadays. I need to get like a new one. No, Hugh Jackman. No, he's like, I bet you're the kids with like, oh, Brad Pitt is like an old man or something. When in my mind, like Brad Pitt is the epitome of hunky Hollywood celebrity. I don't know. I don't even I don't even I don't even know. Yeah, so. So. If we remove that shame, then we'd also probably get better treatment. We wouldn't be shy about talking about sexual health and other types of health which would would protect protect our health and other people's health. Yeah, so So let's look at the health as a status, and what influences health. So if you think about society, think of how society thinks of what makes someone healthy is that then exercise, eating healthy food. And in reality, it's pets way more complex, and is influenced by the social constructs we have in place currently, never repeat that. Health is super complex, and is influenced by the social constructs we have in place currently, is influenced health is influenced by the way we view health. And so I have a post that I first created a few years ago, but then I reshard it recently on Instagram, and it is the social determinants of the sorry, the determinants of health. And so you can go and look at go and you can go and look at I'll also put in the show notes. The, the so I've, I've summary, summarize it down into the big components, okay, so I'll read them out, okay. So we've got in our mind that if you if you're thin, you eat the right food, you exercise, maybe a sprinkling of some other things,

things that are in your control, and maybe a little bit of genetics, then you'll be healthy. But really, the determinants of health, two thirds of it is not our behavior, two thirds of it is other things and so 24% is social circumstances. 22% is genetics and biology 11% medical care, 7% environment, and 36% individual hate behavior. And so individual behavior, aha, okay, so that is eating the right food being thin. And exercising, isn't it? Question mark? No, not necessarily. Okay, so in individual behavior, but so that the if you go to the where I got this information from, it's this huge thing that you could not fit on Instagram. And so I've summarized it to to the main points. And then the main points are then go into other points of what that means. So individual behavior, psychological assets, negative mood and affects other risk related behavior, like gun behavior, sexual activity, motor vehicle behavior, physical activity, sleep patterns, and diet patterns. And when we think about diet patterns, is it that we're getting enough food? Did we get a variety of food? Right? It's not, did you ever eat a Twinkie? No. It's so so those two things are 6% Right. But hang on a minute, I thought it was simple. You just input this and then an output is the destination of health. So yeah, I mean, like when you think of individual health, are you thinking about so negative mood and ethics and so that is, anxiety level, depression level, hopelessness, level and stress level, psychological assets, conscientiousness level, self efficacy, optimism levels, life satisfaction level, cognitive function in late life. risk related behavior, gun behavior, sexual activity, motor vehicle behavior. So you know, we're not we're not saying listen, I'm really interested in becoming healthy. So I am going to not go to the gun range next week. I doubt that there's a lot of people who who are gun users listening, listening to the show, but we don't think that right and that is like our individual behavior.

Right, we're not gonna We're not like, you know what, I really want to be healthy. So I am going to work on my optimism level and that's remember that's just like, that's 36% Right. And so, the other the other parts of what health are in you know, so if we look at social circumstances, so if we go in deeper in that is is gender identity, military service, sexual orientation, citizenship status, race and ethnicity, social status, history of incarceration, culture and tradition, social connectedness, early childhood education and development, discrimination, work conditions, I am going to improve my health and so I I'm gonna make some more friends wouldn't probably wouldn't say that right. And each of these things has like lines underneath them, you know, like religious involvement, cultural norms, quality of friends, civic participation. Oh, I really want to be improved my health, so I'm going to engage in civic participation. But what you know, is that the CLO it's part of what makes up health. And, you know, this, the so called social circumstances, are on par with all of these other things that we're talking about. So, genetics and biology. So, that includes genetic body structure, body function, oh, look at that, this is look at this body structure is under genetics and biology. And that is weight. Notice how weight is not under a behavior. So yeah, yeah. And so this information by the way, this this information is, let me read out quote, information in this pie chart is from go in vo 89% of health occurs outside of the clinical space, through genetics, behavior, environment and social circumstances. These factors are known as social determinants of health. Despite their importance attempts to integrate the determinants into a single visualization visualization have been limited because there's so many go in vote identify a gap based on their extensive work as a healthcare design studio and conducted a literature review of sources the World Health Organization and the Kaiser Family Foundation and face to face interviews with public policy analysts health IT experts and Clinical Professionals relying on the experience of mapping complex systems within healthcare go in vo created a comprehensive open source visualization of the social determinants of health. Yeah, so insane, all these different strands on this, you know, there's many many, many different things right? Many different things. We also you know, medical care. So underneath that is health literacy, quality of health care, access to health care, patient engagement, distance to resources, provider availability, vaccinations and immunizations, quality of insurance, under physical environment, pollution, location, exposure to firearms, allergens, walkability, water quality, air quality, crime level, crowding conditions, job opportunities. Right. So hang on, this doesn't this doesn't align with what we view health as the social construct we can't we currently have of what health is. So someone's health status, which is a social construct is going to be affected by the social constructs they come into so example, because a part of the

social circumstances affect health, right? So your gender identity, if you're if you're gender diverse, then for example, trans folks, average life expectancy is 30 to 35 years, if you're a black trans person, then it's even lower. And so we're thinking about gender identity and someone's health status. And and then we also look at the social circumstances, someone's race, and then we can throw in their like sexual orientation. If they're also queer, then it's going to affect their health outcomes. Because are they going to be able to then we look over the other things, we look at the medical care, are we are they going to get quality of health care? Are they going to get access to health care? Are they going to be able to engage with that healthcare? Right, so all of these things are playing off each other. And so the way that we perceive as an example transvenous in our society affects the health outcomes of trans folks and even, you know, people's perception of health and what house health this is, this is not universal, so, and it changes from individual to individual, like for example, experiences that we think are universal to are not necessarily universal. If we think about the pain scale, you know, like how much pain are you in from a scale of one to 10 which was developed by who was the company? Basically it was developed by a opioid manufacturing company so that people could be prescribed opioids, opioids more in hospital because we couldn't be letting people stay in pain, we need to give them opioids. And so anyway, so anyway, pains girl, my perception of pain is different from other people's, you know. And even like your own perception of your own health, my aunt who lives next door to my mum, she's like 75 or something, and has has not been to the doctor in anyone's recent memory. And she's she's hard of hearing, and she has signs of dementia. And she talks all the time about how healthy she is. An issue is a ishi Ishee issue though. I don't know the answer to that. You know, she walks her sheepdog for hours every day, all day, every day she walks to the beach with a dog. She gets on with her life fine. Does my perception of her health and my perception of her age change? Her health status? What even is her health status? What if she does have some unchecked illness or condition? Does that then mean she's unhealthy? And what does my perception of her being unhealthy mean? And so my mom's perception of her being unhealthy in whatever way means that my mom go my mom who's 70, right?

My mom 70 goes around and does gardening for her sister. She does the weeding and stuff. Even though the sister is absolutely capable of doing it, but because my perceives her as she hasn't gone to the doctor in many, many years, therefore, she's probably sick, I must go around and do a reading for her. And so then how does that impact her health? If people are perceiving her as unhealthy? I mean, she's very, she's happy with for my mom to go around and do the weeding, you know, but everyone went to her and said, Listen, you need to go to the doctor, you've not been to the doctor in years, you're probably really unhealthy, you're probably about to die, would that then actually affect our health? Which could be potentially a okay. But then again, what is? What is it? You know, so let's look at, I'm just going to have a look at the First Nations perspective of health and wellness. And so again, link in the show notes. So this is from the First Nations Health Authority, says health through wellness. And they've got a visual depiction of what health is. And what we have here as we've got like a bullet like a target type shape, and in the middle, we have the word human being. And so the center circle represents individual human beings, wellness starts with individuals, taking responsibility for our own health and wellness, whether we are First Nations or not. The second circle illustrates the importance of mental, emotional, spiritual, and physical facets of a healthy, well balanced life. There it is critically important that there is a balance between these aspects of wellness, and that they are all nurtured together to create a holistic level of wellbeing in which all four areas are strong and healthy. The third circle, so this is going out from the middle, the third circle represents the overarching values that support and uphold wellness, respect, wisdom, responsibility, and relationships. All other values are in some way essential to the four below which is respect, wisdom, responsibility and relationships. And so then the fourth circle depicts the people that surround us and the places from which we come, land, community, family and nations are all critical components of our healthy experiences as human beings. And so the fifth circle depicts the social environmental, cultural and economic determinants of our health and well being. And so like for example, cultural cultural cultural determinants include language, spirituality ceremonies, traditional foods and medicines, teachings, and a sense of belonging. Environmental is land, air, water, food, housing, and other resources that need to be cared For and considered in order to sustain healthy children, family and communities, and then we've got the outer circle, which is the people, people who make up the outer circle represent the vision of strong children, families, elders, and people in the community. The people are holding hands to demonstrate togetherness, respect, and relationships, which in the words of a respected BC, elder can be stated as one heart, one mind, children are included in the drawing, because they are the heart of our communities, and they connect us to who we are and to our health. So see how it's different, right, and even like talking about the land, and land being connected to, you know, respect of the land connected to our health. And so that the way that most of us if we're not a part of communities who have diverse, more diverse understandings of what health is and what contributes to health, we wouldn't think of these things, right.

Because the construction, the construct, of what health is, to us, to us, our perception is different. And because our perception is our perception, we view it as the right perception, when it's just one way to view something. And there are actually many different ways to view something. And, and when we're viewing health as this limited, black and white input output type of thing. It's, it's ignoring the current information that we have about what health is that, that construction, that construct of health is old fashioned, right, you know, like, apple a day to keep the doctor away? And where does that come from? And you know, like, oh, drink milk for healthy bones, and it was the milk industry that, you know, lobby to get children to have milk at school. And so where do these ideas of health come from? What are they influenced by? Do we want to look at different different people's views on health and and see how how they are more holistic and and look at the actual science and evidence and see what is it telling us now? And is it helpful for us to view health in that way? And, and not question things and not not be like, the fuck even is health? What is going on? And why are we so so single mindedly in the pursuit of this narrow definition of health, when it damages our mental well being and, you know, other maybe physical aspects of health? You know, the, the current definition we have of health isn't leading us to be as health full, whatever the fuck health means, as we could potentially be, you know, and I mean, is it helpful to we can we can stick with this, you know, we can stick with our, you know, health, the way that we view health the way that we've, we've, we understand how we can stick with that if that's working for you, and it feels good for you, then you mean do it. I don't think it's going to be the reality of what we believe health to be. You know, in the future, I think it's going to become more nuanced. Because we're going to have collective understandings that will change with with new knowledge and information. But I mean, if it works for you, go for it, but I think it probably will help a lot of people to expand their understanding of what health could look like and and can I even be healthy? What does it mean if I'm not healthy? What does it mean if I'm not able bodied? What does it mean if I value able bodied people over disabled people? What does that mean for me and my own well being what does it mean for me as I age what does it mean for me? Now that I temporarily able bodied when if I'm lucky enough, I will get old enough and will need to have assistance? and mobility aids and, and does that mean then I am a worthless person because I'm older. If I adhere to this idea of what health is, and what human bodies are valuable, then that's not going to help me as my health changes, if I'm lucky enough to live longer, you know. So I just I just don't think that it's helpful for us, for all of us collectively and individually to not think about this in a more nuanced way. And again, like, I started the show with Mike, like, what I was talking about healthcare being a social justice issue, a lot of what would help people be more quote, healthy is ending racism and sexism and, and stigmatization and marginalization of different people.

And paying people more or giving people more more vacation days. free health care, gun control, right? That is, things that we can control or, you know, and, and even if, you know, the idea that even if we did do those things, you know, say if magic happens, and we live in utopian society, it's held still might not be attainable for many people. Right? And so it's kind of like there is no train that we can get on with certain sets of luggage and arrive at healthy you might do that and the train may never leave the station. And that's okay. It doesn't mean that you're less than or that people who are able bodied, quote healthy whatever the fuck it means are better. Although society today gives us a different measures, but the reality is, that's not true. Okay, I'm gonna leave it here for today. Um, yeah, hope you have a nice, nice rest of your day. And I want to remind you to stay first fatty, and I will see you in a while. Alligator Okay, bye Thanks for listening to the episode and if you feel ready to get serious about this work and want to know when the doors open to fears fatti Academy which is my signature program, where I teach all about how to overcome your fat phobic beliefs and learn to love your fat body. Then go to fifth fatty.com forward slash waitlist again, that is first fatty.com forward slash waitlist to get your name on the waitlist. For when first party Academy my signature program opens.

EP129 Transcript

You're listening to The Fierce Fatty Podcast. Episode 129: Health is a social construct". I’m your host, Vinny Welsby. Let's do it.

I'm Vinny Welsby, TEDx speaker, best-selling author, and fat activist. I have transformed my life from hating my body with desperately low self-esteem to being a courageous and confident fierce fatty who loves every inch of this jelly. Society teaches us living with a fat body is bad. But what if we spent less time, money, and energy on the pursuit of thinness and instead focused on the things that actually matter? Like if pineapple on pizza should be outlawed? Or if the mullet was the greatest haircut of the 20th century? So how do you stop negative beliefs about your fat body controlling your life? It's the Fierce Fatty Podcast. Let's begin.

Hello, fatty Welcome to this episode. How were you? How's live, you're doing good. I realized that I have not ever done a land acknowledgement. For the podcast, I'm thinking about the new podcast, Intro music, whatever, I need to change it because it's got my old name in it. And in that I'm going to put a land acknowledgement but just an FYI. You may know that I live in Canada in Vancouver, which is the traditional ancestral and unceded territory of the Coast Salish people, the People's Squamish slaver tooth and Musqueam nations. Yes, and that's where I live. And I've been thinking about this and how it needs to be part of every episode so I thought in the in the intro would be great if I'm gonna put it out. So anyway, that's the First Nations community lands here that I live on in what is currently known as Vancouver. So today, I am talking about her Oh, hello, health. And I'm doing this episode because someone asked me someone asked me to and I was like, That's a great idea. You You're you clever a lot. You know what, because I forget what I talk about on I forget what episodes I've done and not done. And I know that I've talked about health being a social construct before but I looked and I was like, Oh, shit, I've never even done an episode on it like Episode Episode dedicated to it. Because I had shared a post on the Instagrams and someone said, oh, you should do an episode focusing on this. And the post that I shared was the social determinants of health. This is a caption that I wrote, there are so many things that influence health, and most are not in our control. Weight is not a behavior. And it is not in our control. For the vast majority majority of people. The moralistic value that society places on quote, healthy bodies, is ableism health ism, and not helpful for anyone. Health is largely a social justice issue. Health is not attainable for many healthy the temporary state health is a social construct. And someone left left a comment saying you need to talk about that more. And I said, in my brain, you got it. You got it. I'm gonna do it. I'm gonna do it. Because you know what, sometimes I like these points that I think that I've made. Because I've spoken about them, like briefly on the podcast in different posts, and whatever. And really, actually have I spoken about them? Have I made an episode so someone can Google Health as a social construct and find my stuff? No, I have. No. So yeah. Today's Friday fitting good. Dude, you just got back from a spa day. Don't get the dog he has had his hair cut for the first time in his whole life actually, well, I've cut his hair before but professionally, I mean, he went to the groomer for the first time and normally I just groom him myself but something good that happened in the pandemic was that did he have to go into the vet on his own?

Obviously, I drove him there. He didn't just you know, make an appointment himself and go, I would drive him there and then pass them on to the The vet because COVID wasn't loaded. And they reported back saying he's an angel when you're not there. So this motherfucker has been going around growling and snapping up people. He doesn't bite. He just snaps which is scary, though, right? And he's a little dog, but he's still scary. And seems to be really stressed out. And so I was like, Well, I can't ever take him to the groomer, because he's just going to one like, scare the groomer. And to, he's going to be really upset and terrified. Yeah, that's what that's like. That is fine. He's like, wanting cuddles. It's like you tricky little motherfucker. So yeah, so I've made an appointment for him to go to the groomers. I just, we just started out last week. We've just London now clip just to see how I liked it. And he didn't want to leave afterwards. Yeah, so I had to go in, go grab him because the groomers is just half a block away. And she was going to take it back. But anyway, he, he didn't want to leave. And today he's gone for the full, full spa treatment. And now he looks like a fucking teddy bear. So get out. I want to murder him because he looks so cute, his little bomb. Because nobody has what I call his skirt on the back. Because he has really long hair. And I was like that needs to go. And they made it into like a teddy bear bomb. And yeah, so he might be murdered by the end of the day, because I'm gonna be loving on him so much because he looks so cute. Yeah. So if your dog is like, doggy, maybe, maybe they just do it when you're around? Maybe not. You know? Who knows? And he can't tell for sure he enjoyed it. But I'm guessing he did. Because he seemed pretty happy and excited. So, yes. Okay, so talking about this, today's Health is a social construct. I'm going to just define what is health? And what is social construct? what do what do they mean. And they get into the concept of health being a social construct. And that related to fatness and ableism, and health ism, and all that type of job so, so even Google Health, we just did a little Google, which I did. And the word health is a noun and the state of being free from illness or injury, or a person's mental or physical condition. And that's pretty limited, right? So that's a DEC dictionary definition to being free from illness or injury. But we have other definitions. And so this is from the Government of Canada, who is quoting the World Health Organization, who says the World Health Organization offers a simple definition of health as a state of complete, physical, mental and social well being, and not merely the absence of disease or infirmity. social well being is an important aspect of this desh definition that may not always occur to us in thinking about health. So what does that mean? What does that mean? A state of complete physical, mental social, well being a state of complete physical, mental and social well being and not merely the absence of disease. So well, beingness is what the what who says it is, okay, so well being well being pneus. Or if we look at the simple definition, being free from illness or injury, Injury is a social construct. So let's look at the the dictionary definition the Merriam Webster says that it is an idea that has been created and accepted by the people in a society. So an idea that has been created and accepted by the people in a society. Well, I hear you, I hear you. Isn't that everything? Yeah, it's a lot of it's a lot of things, a lot of things.

So what is a social construct? We're gonna go to another site that gives us some examples. So this is what they say social constructs developed within a society or group. They don't represent objective reality, but instead are meaningful only because people within the society or group accept that they have meaning. Simply put social Your constructs do not have inherent, meaning, the only meaning they have is the meaning given to them by people. For example, the idea that pink is for girls and blue is for boys is an example of a social construct related to gender, and the color of items. The collective perception that a particular color can be associated with a certain gender is not an objective representation of truth, or fact. Instead, it is a social convention that came to have meaning within the context of society. And so they go on to list some examples. There are many examples of social constructs. Most common practices and behaviors that are generally accepted within a societal group represent social constructs. These societal norms don't have to be accepted by every single person in order to be social construct constructs, they can and often do change over time. So some examples here, there's lots of different exams, but I'm just going to read out the ones which are related more to what we're talking about today. So adulthood, the specific of when a person is considered to be an adult is a social construct. In the United States, and most of the EU people are considered to be adults at the age of 18. However, in Scotland, people are considered to be adults at the age of 16. And in reality, so if we're talking about reality, if we were to define adulthood, as the time where our brains are more developed, where we are at a certain level of maturity, then it will probably actually be 25. But then we have to think about like, well, do we let people who are under 25 do stuff, even though maybe their brains aren't totally fully developed? Well, yeah. And so it's kind of like, we have to come to a decision about what being an adult means by society standards. I mean, like, you know, for some things, I think it's appropriate to say 16, or 18, but other things, I think, maybe not. So gender behaviors, the concept of certain behaviors, being specific to a person's gender is a social construct. This applies to the idea that men should keep their emotions bottled up, or the notion that women are overly emotional. It also applies to the belief that boys should play with trucks and girls with dolls. Gender roles are also social constructs associated with gender roles, such as formally widely held belief that women should stay at home and men should work. This also relates to the belief that certain types of jobs are women's work, while others represent men's work. Disability, the concept of disability is a social construct. The social construct of disability often relates to visible indicators of disability, such as using a wheelchair or missing a limb. People who have less visible disabilities are often misunderstood because their conditions don't fit into the social constructs of others. Like you hear many stories of people parking in the disabled spot, and someone rushing out being like this is for disabled people, because they're not in a wheelchair, and then the person you know, being like, well, you know, and they take their, you know, they take their leg off or whatever to reveal that. They're using a leg to help them walk or, or they have a disability, which is not visible. It gets on my tits that really gets on my tits when people are saying, you know, you can't use that washroom because it's for disabled people who's on what how can you tell whether your eyeballs that someone is disabled or not? It's none of your fucking business. You know? But I can see why people do that because they want to protect disabled people, but in that they are harming disabled people.

Yes, and if we think about like with disability, everything about glasses, whereas you wouldn't, if you will, glasses probably describe yourself as having a disability. Whereas maybe a few 100 years ago, before we were able to access glasses, or I don't know when glasses were invented. I know sunglasses were invented a really long time ago. Yeah, so then if you depending on your level of sight, that would be a disability. So it like if I didn't have my glasses, I couldn't I couldn't drive I you know, sometimes struggle to get around. My mom it really has very limited vision without her glasses and she could barely get around the room and so then that would be classed as a disability. But now, this this age that I have that I wear glasses are seen as cool, right? Not everyone thinks they're cool I do but But it's just no big deal. You wouldn't think, Oh, look at that, look, that's that person to say, well, because they're wearing glasses, it's just a normal thing. And that's, that's a social construct to say that that wearing glasses is not a disability, whereas using a wheelchair, or mobility aid is a disability. And so some folks with disabilities don't see themselves as disabled. And some do isn't, you know, disabled people are not a monolith. But anyway, it's a social construct is what we're talking about. And some people buy into that construct, and some people don't. Illness. Illness is also a social construct. The word illness doesn't mean the same thing to everyone. Some only perceive medical medical conditions as illnesses, if they would cause a person to be, I don't know this word, bedridden, I don't like that. That's like, a negative thing to be in bed, or contagious, while others perceive a wide variety of medical circumstances to represent illness. Yeah, so for example, illness and let's like, extend this to health. I've used this example before, but one time that really made me think about this was going to the doctors, and had had like an annual checkup, or whatever, had my blood work done. And the doctor says you Oh, absolutely healthy. And she handed my script for all the different various things that medication I need to take to make sure that I can live, you know, I won't die without the medications removed before we would. But I should be saying I am healthy. But am I healthy, is the way that I'm I and she is perceiving these conditions, because they are easily, somewhat easily remedied remedied with medication means that they are no longer a barrier to so called health status, or health status. But then if say if I had no i didn't have access to medication or couldn't afford to pay for medication, because I have to pay for my medication in Canada. would then I not be healthy? is health. Only for those who are able to manage their health condition? Does that then make someone healthy or unhealthy? Like am I healthy? Because I can take antidepressants that make my depression symptoms? Mostly go away? Does that then mean I'm healthy? But then you might say yes, but then if say if a week I didn't take my antidepressants, then maybe then I would not. But the difference is between me medicating it or not. So is what. It is complicated, right? It is complicated. I get the last example of a social construct here that they're giving is time. Time is a social construct that isn't meaningful only in the context of human created systems that are used to describe time, seconds, minutes hours, and make it meaningful in some places. Daylight Savings Time is not observed. Oh, I want to be one of those places. The concept of seasonal time changes does not exist where they are not practiced. Yeah, we need to get rid of daylight savings that shifts away. We're not farming anymore. Anyway. Yeah. So other examples of social constructs money, governments. They mentioned gender here. Yes. So it's anything that which is not a fact, I would argue that, you know, how much of stuff is factual? It's as factual as we know it, according to science today, right. And that's the thing is, you know, like science, scientists will always say like, this is the best we know today.

And, and so we're with a lot of things like it's pretty much very well established. So uncertain things, but other things. We've just kind of made it up. And everyone said, Oh, that sounds about right. Yeah, yeah. Even though maybe at the time it sounded about right. You know, women have to stay in the home and have to do this and your men, men or men's personality traits are this and all that type of stuff may have worked. I mean, did it ever work? No. But maybe it may have been more relevant 200 years ago, but it's no longer such. So you know, we could change, you know, 200 years and we'd be like, lol, remember, in the olden days when they used to think that women should stay at home. So yeah, so yeah, so yeah, so yeah, also, let's just finish off there. He's here. For this, this this bit, by the way, links in the show notes, this is episode 129. So facebook.com, forward slash, one to nine finishing off this this little bit is expand your understanding of social constructs, expanding your understanding of social constructs involved considering, which are the things that you know, actually have objective meaning, versus which ones are meaningful only because people in a group, assign meaning to them, and continue to allow that assigned meaning to persist. Explore your perceptions versus those of others by reviewing some examples of sociological imagination. This will allow you to consider situations from other points of view and will come to appreciate perspectives other than your own. So another example is religion. So this line here they're saying, people in in group assign meaning to them, and continue to allow that Mitt that assign meaning to persist. And so I was watching something on Netflix. I started watching it last night about the the Mormon group that's led by Jeff, what's his name? They are called the Latter Day Saints of fundamental Latter Day Saints. flts. Anyway, religious group, very conservative, and they had the Prophet which was this guy, Jeff's dad, and the Prophet was meant to live forever because he was a prophet and what up see he died. And so they're like, What the heck, we're not prophet was in live forever. And so then the son was like, huh, one of they had what, how many? How many children did this guy have? Because they believe in plural marriages. This guy had like hundreds of hundreds of children. Um, so one of the favorite sons, who was who was said to be magical in some way was like, Well, turns out dad's dad's come back, he's in my body now and I'm the Prophet. And so then the group had to get behind that idea. And then you anyone who was a threat to the idea that there's this guy, Jeff was actually the Prophet reincarnated. The dad reincarnated in his body was ousted. And then that became, you know, the new group belief, the that the prophet had reincarnated into the son's body, and, and that you had to do certain things and wear your hair in a certain way and wear underwear down to your ankles, and up to your wrists and lalalalala because that's what they all believed, right? And still believe.

So let's look at sociology. Because we can also look at this from a sociological frame. And I'm looking at the social construction of health, from open texts BC, which is open text off of a sociology course. And so I'm going to read a few quotes from here. So medical sociology is the system systematic study of how humans manage issues of health and illness, disease and disorders, and health care for both the sick and the healthy. The social construction of health explains how society shapes and is shaped by medical issues. The social construction of health is a major research topic within medical sociology. At first glance, this concept of a social construction of health does not seem to make sense. After all, if disease is measurable, physiological problem, a measurable physiological problem, then there can be no question of socially constructing disease, right? Well, it's not that simple. The idea of the social construction of health emphasizes the socio cultural aspects of the disciplines approach to physical, objective definable phenomena. Sociologists Conrad and Barker. 2010 offer a comprehensive framework for understanding the major findings of the last 50 years of development in this concept. Their summary categorizes the findings in the field under three subheadings the cultural meaning of an illness, the social construction of the illness experience, and the social construction of medical knowledge. Many medical sociologists contend that illness has both a biological and an experiment, experimental component and that these components exist independently of each other. Our culture, not our biology dictates which illnesses are stigmatized, and which are not which are considered disabilities and which are not, and which are deemed contestable, meaning some medical professionals may find the existence of this ailment questionable As opposed to definitive illnesses that are unquestionably recognized in the medical profession, Conrad and Barker 2010. For instance, sociologist Erving Goffman 1963 Describe how social stigmas hinder individuals from fully integrating into society. In essence, Goffman suggests we might view illness as a stigma that can push others to view the ill in an undesirable manner. The stigmatization of illness often has the greatest effect on the patient, and the kind of care they receive. Many contend that our society and even our healthcare institutions discriminate against certain diseases like mental disorders, AIDS, venereal diseases, and skin disorders. I think for those that don't think you say VD anymore. And that's from Satorious 2007 facilitator, these diseases may be subpar, they may be segregated from other health care areas, or relegated to a poorer environment, the stigma may keep people from seeking help for the illnesses making it worse than it needs to be. So. So if you want to learn more about like the sociological side of looking at that, and how, how we view conditions and how doctors or healthcare professionals view conditions, then there's a whole whole field of study that's been going on for a very long time, because health is a social construct. Because it's not just as we're saying, in this, this, this bit, I just read out, it's not just this definable thing, it's this thing, it's, it's something that changes depending on how society and individuals who adhere to the social constructs in society interact with health, and what they think health is, and different types of illness, conditions, etc, etc. So I like to think about this concept. And the, the construct of health in regards to health as a destination, and health as a status and its influences.

So what I'm talking about when I say one health as a destination, thinking about how society views, health is something that you can arrive at, like it's the terminus station. And that if you do do certain things, and you're going to arrive, just hop on the health train, and we're going to get to that station, and the station is called Health. And if you maintain taking certain actions, and those actions being being thin, exercising, and eating the quote, right food, then you're going to get to that destination of health is what largely we believe in society and what kind of the average everyday person believes. And it boils down to it, it boils health down to a very simple, unlimited equation, or definition. You know, like, you get your you get your luggage, you got your luggage, which is eating right, exercising, right, and being thin. Now we can jump on the train and the train is gonna get us to the destination of health. So, that's a construct in regards to that is what many of us in design a society have decided, is the reality of what health is. And and yes, there's some nuance in there. Like I'm boiling it down to the very simplest ideas, but you know, people were like, oh, yeah, you know, you do need to also get a good night's sleep and drink water and, you know, all of those types of things and or maybe maybe you should do some yoga as well, you know, we want to be holistic about it, but then we can jump on that train and, you know, maybe the train might hit some some, you know, leaves on the ground, like happens in the UK leaves on the track and it needs to have maybe, maybe there's a little stop or, you know, a delay, but basically we've put those, we've got the luggage we've the inputs are there. Therefore we know that health is going to be out the outcome and That's just not the reality, right? That's just not reality. So when we think about health as a destination, something that you can put in a little bit input stuff, you're going to arrive that, you know, there might be a little bit of, you know, things that might pop up from time to time that is out of your control, but you've done the quote, right things, therefore, you're going to get to the destination, or you're at the destination, we're going to stay at the destination. So this concept and the construct of this is it says that health or lack of health is totally down to an individual and what they do, what control they have, because why would someone not be healthy when it's so easy, all you need to do is eat quote, right? Exercise. And be thin. Easy peasy, lemon and lime. So So you know, you've got this choice to be healthy. Why wouldn't you do it if it's so easy. And the reason is, because people who decide, quote, you know, decide to be unhealthy. They're bad in some way, they are lazy or unintelligent, or poor. And it says, if you get sick with some with some things, then it's okay. But something else, that's a moral failings or an example, if you get sick, because or you have an illness injury, because you're doing something that supports the idea that health is being thin, exercising, and eating right, and you come up against something, that means that you get an illness or an injury from that, then that's good, that's okay. But if it's outside of that, then it's not good. Okay. So an example would be an injury that I have had is I went skiing,

I used to go skate all the time, fell to a couple of ligaments in my knee. And I need surgery to have time off work. But never once did I think, or come into the kind of like, oh, well, if you weren't so so much of a skier, you never would have encountered that. What is your own fault for skiing? No, because I was doing an activity I was exercising, therefore I was being a good fatty I was doing the things that I needed to do to do. According to this construct that we have currently around health, the things I needed to do to be at that destination of healthy. But what if someone is diagnosed with something that we associate associate with fatness and they're a fat person, for example, the classic one is type two diabetes. And what we know about type two diabetes is it is predominantly a genetic condition. And the you cannot eat your way into getting diabetes. It is not anyone's fault if they have type two diabetes, but that is not the message that we get. That's it's an inevitable, inevitable because you did something bad, which is being fat, you weren't doing the things you want, you are adhering to the inputs, being thin, eating the right foods and exercising. So therefore you are not going to arrive at the destination of health. And the idea that, you know, when a thin person gets sick, and oh, that's just the way life is maybe they were unlucky. It wasn't because of something they did or didn't do. But when a fat person gets sick, it's because they're fat. What can we expect? Is what society says. So, and then outside of fatness we think about fatness we have other things which are, you know, something that's seen as good or bad. So say if you got you had the flu, that's fine. You know, no stigma around that. Maybe you know, people don't want you to go make out with them if you've got the flu, but people are not like what type of person gets the flu? Mm hmm. Whereas say if you got an STD, you had syphilis. Well, then that's bad. That's shameful. But both are equally morally the same with engaging properly in similar types of behavior contact with other human beings. You know, so then why is one devastate bitingly shameful, potentially for people and stigmatized, but the other is just part of being a human being. And that is because we view health in a certain way, right? This, this, this also the definition of, you know, the, the idea of health as a destination, it positions fat people as being so willfully ignorant of the very easy Health Formula. And according to this fat people, we stick our fingers in our ears and are determined to make other people and the government pay for our recklessness. The formula is so simple. Why don't you just do it, then you'd be healthy, is what we know about this version of health? And the answer to that is because, you know, isn't it? That's not the reality. This construction of health that we currently have in society is almost exclusively exclusively exclusively focused focused on physical health. And it's super super laced with white supremacy, and ideas from white culture of what health is. And I'm gonna be talking about First Nations ideas about health shortly, just to show how different it can be their constructs around health. It also denies, you know, that's the holistic way, you know, many cultures, think about health, not even just some First Nation cultures, many cultures like this is this is a very Western, you know, American view of, of what health is. And in many cultures, right, you know, but then also in many cultures is different.

But this is our perception. This is our perception of what health is and differences, sometimes can even be hard to imagine, because we all know is that we'll know if you do this and that then you're going to be healthy probably. It also implies health is a choice, and denigrates, those who do not, quote, choose health. It disregards those who can never be healthy or able bodied and leaves them at the sidelines. as second class citizens, you're disabled. Well, sorry. So well. And it's all about how people view your health, which in turn affects your health negatively, right. It's, you know, if you are on a desert island, and you've got type two diabetes, you and you and your doctor on a desert island together, and the doctor says, Sorry, you got type two diabetes, would it seem as devastating if you didn't have anyone to? To judge you? If you didn't have anyone to view or make assumptions about who you were as a person? It would probably be a lot easier to deal with. Because of the way that society view certain conditions. And what if we removed shame from health? What if we did remove all of that kind of learned shame from health and we might go to the doctors more, we might be connected with the community more because we realize that we have more health conditions in common. You know, like, I bet, the health condition that you feel shameful about loads of other people have it and because no one's talking about it. You know, we feel shame. And it's like, oh, well, actually, who knew that? Brad Pitt has HSV genital herpes? Oh, well, if Brad Pitt came out and said, Hey, I have genital herpes. Maybe we wouldn't be viewing it so negatively. As an example, I need to get a new fucking, I would say Brad Pitt. I think it's showing that kids are talking about Brad Pitt, as in the most like the idol of celebrities nowadays. I need to get like a new one. No, Hugh Jackman. No, he's like, I bet you're the kids with like, oh, Brad Pitt is like an old man or something. When in my mind, like Brad Pitt is the epitome of hunky Hollywood celebrity. I don't know. I don't even I don't even I don't even know. Yeah, so. So. If we remove that shame, then we'd also probably get better treatment. We wouldn't be shy about talking about sexual health and other types of health which would would protect protect our health and other people's health. Yeah, so So let's look at the health as a status, and what influences health. So if you think about society, think of how society thinks of what makes someone healthy is that then exercise, eating healthy food. And in reality, it's pets way more complex, and is influenced by the social constructs we have in place currently, never repeat that. Health is super complex, and is influenced by the social constructs we have in place currently, is influenced health is influenced by the way we view health. And so I have a post that I first created a few years ago, but then I reshard it recently on Instagram, and it is the social determinants of the sorry, the determinants of health. And so you can go and look at go and you can go and look at I'll also put in the show notes. The, the so I've, I've summary, summarize it down into the big components, okay, so I'll read them out, okay.

So we've got in our mind that if you if you're thin, you eat the right food, you exercise, maybe a sprinkling of some other things, things that are in your control, and maybe a little bit of genetics, then you'll be healthy. But really, the determinants of health, two thirds of it is not our behavior, two thirds of it is other things and so 24% is social circumstances. 22% is genetics and biology 11% medical care, 7% environment, and 36% individual hate behavior. And so individual behavior, aha, okay, so that is eating the right food being thin. And exercising, isn't it? Question mark? No, not necessarily. Okay, so in individual behavior, but so that the if you go to the where I got this information from, it's this huge thing that you could not fit on Instagram. And so I've summarized it to to the main points. And then the main points are then go into other points of what that means. So individual behavior, psychological assets, negative mood and affects other risk related behavior, like gun behavior, sexual activity, motor vehicle behavior, physical activity, sleep patterns, and diet patterns. And when we think about diet patterns, is it that we're getting enough food? Did we get a variety of food? Right? It's not, did you ever eat a Twinkie? No. It's so so those two things are 6% Right. But hang on a minute, I thought it was simple. You just input this and then an output is the destination of health. So yeah, I mean, like when you think of individual health, are you thinking about so negative mood and ethics and so that is, anxiety level, depression level, hopelessness, level and stress level, psychological assets, conscientiousness level, self efficacy, optimism levels, life satisfaction level, cognitive function in late life. risk related behavior, gun behavior, sexual activity, motor vehicle behavior. So you know, we're not we're not saying listen, I'm really interested in becoming healthy. So I am going to not go to the gun range next week. I doubt that there's a lot of people who who are gun users listening, listening to the show, but we don't think that right and that is like our individual behavior.

Right, we're not gonna We're not like, you know what, I really want to be healthy. So I am going to work on my optimism level and that's remember that's just like, that's 36% Right. And so, the other the other parts of what health are in you know, so if we look at social circumstances, so if we go in deeper in that is is gender identity, military service, sexual orientation, citizenship status, race and ethnicity, social status, history of incarceration, culture and tradition, social connectedness, early childhood education and development, discrimination, work conditions, I am going to improve my health and so I I'm gonna make some more friends wouldn't probably wouldn't say that right. And each of these things has like lines underneath them, you know, like religious involvement, cultural norms, quality of friends, civic participation. Oh, I really want to be improved my health, so I'm going to engage in civic participation. But what you know, is that the CLO it's part of what makes up health. And, you know, this, the so called social circumstances, are on par with all of these other things that we're talking about. So, genetics and biology. So, that includes genetic body structure, body function, oh, look at that, this is look at this body structure is under genetics and biology. And that is weight. Notice how weight is not under a behavior. So yeah, yeah. And so this information by the way, this this information is, let me read out quote, information in this pie chart is from go in vo 89% of health occurs outside of the clinical space, through genetics, behavior, environment and social circumstances. These factors are known as social determinants of health. Despite their importance attempts to integrate the determinants into a single visualization visualization have been limited because there's so many go in vote identify a gap based on their extensive work as a healthcare design studio and conducted a literature review of sources the World Health Organization and the Kaiser Family Foundation and face to face interviews with public policy analysts health IT experts and Clinical Professionals relying on the experience of mapping complex systems within healthcare go in vo created a comprehensive open source visualization of the social determinants of health. Yeah, so insane, all these different strands on this, you know, there's many many, many different things right? Many different things. We also you know, medical care. So underneath that is health literacy, quality of health care, access to health care, patient engagement, distance to resources, provider availability, vaccinations and immunizations, quality of insurance, under physical environment, pollution, location, exposure to firearms, allergens, walkability, water quality, air quality, crime level, crowding conditions, job opportunities. Right. So hang on, this doesn't this doesn't align with what we view health as the social construct we can't we currently have of what health is. So someone's health status, which is a social construct is going to be affected by the social constructs they come into so example, because a part of the social circumstances affect health, right?

So your gender identity, if you're if you're gender diverse, then for example, trans folks, average life expectancy is 30 to 35 years, if you're a black trans person, then it's even lower. And so we're thinking about gender identity and someone's health status. And and then we also look at the social circumstances, someone's race, and then we can throw in their like sexual orientation. If they're also queer, then it's going to affect their health outcomes. Because are they going to be able to then we look over the other things, we look at the medical care, are we are they going to get quality of health care? Are they going to get access to health care? Are they going to be able to engage with that healthcare? Right, so all of these things are playing off each other. And so the way that we perceive as an example transvenous in our society affects the health outcomes of trans folks and even, you know, people's perception of health and what house health this is, this is not universal, so, and it changes from individual to individual, like for example, experiences that we think are universal to are not necessarily universal. If we think about the pain scale, you know, like how much pain are you in from a scale of one to 10 which was developed by who was the company? Basically it was developed by a opioid manufacturing company so that people could be prescribed opioids, opioids more in hospital because we couldn't be letting people stay in pain, we need to give them opioids. And so anyway, so anyway, pains girl, my perception of pain is different from other people's, you know. And even like your own perception of your own health, my aunt who lives next door to my mum, she's like 75 or something, and has has not been to the doctor in anyone's recent memory. And she's she's hard of hearing, and she has signs of dementia. And she talks all the time about how healthy she is. An issue is a ishi Ishee issue though. I don't know the answer to that. You know, she walks her sheepdog for hours every day, all day, every day she walks to the beach with a dog. She gets on with her life fine. Does my perception of her health and my perception of her age change? Her health status? What even is her health status? What if she does have some unchecked illness or condition? Does that then mean she's unhealthy? And what does my perception of her being unhealthy mean? And so my mom's perception of her being unhealthy in whatever way means that my mom go my mom who's 70, right?

My mom 70 goes around and does gardening for her sister. She does the weeding and stuff. Even though the sister is absolutely capable of doing it, but because my perceives her as she hasn't gone to the doctor in many, many years, therefore, she's probably sick, I must go around and do a reading for her. And so then how does that impact her health? If people are perceiving her as unhealthy? I mean, she's very, she's happy with for my mom to go around and do the weeding, you know, but everyone went to her and said, Listen, you need to go to the doctor, you've not been to the doctor in years, you're probably really unhealthy, you're probably about to die, would that then actually affect our health? Which could be potentially a okay. But then again, what is? What is it? You know, so let's look at, I'm just going to have a look at the First Nations perspective of health and wellness. And so again, link in the show notes. So this is from the First Nations Health Authority, says health through wellness. And they've got a visual depiction of what health is. And what we have here as we've got like a bullet like a target type shape, and in the middle, we have the word human being. And so the center circle represents individual human beings, wellness starts with individuals, taking responsibility for our own health and wellness, whether we are First Nations or not. The second circle illustrates the importance of mental, emotional, spiritual, and physical facets of a healthy, well balanced life. There it is critically important that there is a balance between these aspects of wellness, and that they are all nurtured together to create a holistic level of wellbeing in which all four areas are strong and healthy. The third circle, so this is going out from the middle, the third circle represents the overarching values that support and uphold wellness, respect, wisdom, responsibility, and relationships. All other values are in some way essential to the four below which is respect, wisdom, responsibility and relationships. And so then the fourth circle depicts the people that surround us and the places from which we come, land, community, family and nations are all critical components of our healthy experiences as human beings. And so the fifth circle depicts the social environmental, cultural and economic determinants of our health and well being. And so like for example, cultural cultural cultural determinants include language, spirituality ceremonies, traditional foods and medicines, teachings, and a sense of belonging. Environmental is land, air, water, food, housing, and other resources that need to be cared For and considered in order to sustain healthy children, family and communities, and then we've got the outer circle, which is the people, people who make up the outer circle represent the vision of strong children, families, elders, and people in the community. The people are holding hands to demonstrate togetherness, respect, and relationships, which in the words of a respected BC, elder can be stated as one heart, one mind, children are included in the drawing, because they are the heart of our communities, and they connect us to who we are and to our health. So see how it's different, right, and even like talking about the land, and land being connected to, you know, respect of the land connected to our health.

And so that the way that most of us if we're not a part of communities who have diverse, more diverse understandings of what health is and what contributes to health, we wouldn't think of these things, right. Because the construction, the construct, of what health is, to us, to us, our perception is different. And because our perception is our perception, we view it as the right perception, when it's just one way to view something. And there are actually many different ways to view something. And, and when we're viewing health as this limited, black and white input output type of thing. It's, it's ignoring the current information that we have about what health is that, that construction, that construct of health is old fashioned, right, you know, like, apple a day to keep the doctor away? And where does that come from? And you know, like, oh, drink milk for healthy bones, and it was the milk industry that, you know, lobby to get children to have milk at school. And so where do these ideas of health come from? What are they influenced by? Do we want to look at different different people's views on health and and see how how they are more holistic and and look at the actual science and evidence and see what is it telling us now? And is it helpful for us to view health in that way? And, and not question things and not not be like, the fuck even is health? What is going on? And why are we so so single mindedly in the pursuit of this narrow definition of health, when it damages our mental well being and, you know, other maybe physical aspects of health? You know, the, the current definition we have of health isn't leading us to be as health full, whatever the fuck health means, as we could potentially be, you know, and I mean, is it helpful to we can we can stick with this, you know, we can stick with our, you know, health, the way that we view health the way that we've, we've, we understand how we can stick with that if that's working for you, and it feels good for you, then you mean do it. I don't think it's going to be the reality of what we believe health to be. You know, in the future, I think it's going to become more nuanced. Because we're going to have collective understandings that will change with with new knowledge and information. But I mean, if it works for you, go for it, but I think it probably will help a lot of people to expand their understanding of what health could look like and and can I even be healthy? What does it mean if I'm not healthy? What does it mean if I'm not able bodied? What does it mean if I value able bodied people over disabled people? What does that mean for me and my own well being what does it mean for me as I age what does it mean for me? Now that I temporarily able bodied when if I'm lucky enough, I will get old enough and will need to have assistance? and mobility aids and, and does that mean then I am a worthless person because I'm older. If I adhere to this idea of what health is, and what human bodies are valuable, then that's not going to help me as my health changes, if I'm lucky enough to live longer, you know. So I just I just don't think that it's helpful for us, for all of us collectively and individually to not think about this in a more nuanced way. And again, like, I started the show with Mike, like, what I was talking about healthcare being a social justice issue, a lot of what would help people be more quote, healthy is ending racism and sexism and, and stigmatization and marginalization of different people.

And paying people more or giving people more more vacation days. free health care, gun control, right? That is, things that we can control or, you know, and, and even if, you know, the idea that even if we did do those things, you know, say if magic happens, and we live in utopian society, it's held still might not be attainable for many people. Right? And so it's kind of like there is no train that we can get on with certain sets of luggage and arrive at healthy you might do that and the train may never leave the station. And that's okay. It doesn't mean that you're less than or that people who are able bodied, quote healthy whatever the fuck it means are better. Although society today gives us a different measures, but the reality is, that's not true. Okay, I'm gonna leave it here for today. Um, yeah, hope you have a nice, nice rest of your day. And I want to remind you to stay first fatty, and I will see you in a while. Alligator Okay, bye Thanks for listening to the episode and if you feel ready to get serious about this work and want to know when the doors open to fears fatti Academy which is my signature program, where I teach all about how to overcome your fat phobic beliefs and learn to love your fat body. Then go to fifth fatty.com forward slash waitlist again, that is first fatty.com forward slash waitlist to get your name on the waitlist. For when first party Academy my signature program opens.

EP128 Transcript

You're listening to The Fierce Fatty Podcast. Episode 128: The Benefits of Being Fat". Oh yeah, Let's do it.

I'm Vinny Welsby, TEDx speaker, best-selling author, and fat activist. I have transformed my life from hating my body with desperately low self-esteem to being a courageous and confident fierce fatty who loves every inch of this jelly. Society teaches us living with a fat body is bad. But what if we spent less time, money, and energy on the pursuit of thinness and instead focused on the things that actually matter? Like if pineapple on pizza should be outlawed? Or if the mullet was the greatest haircut of the 20th century? So how do you stop negative beliefs about your fat body controlling your life? It's the Fierce Fatty Podcast. Let's begin.

Hello, welcome to this podcast episode. I missed you how you do when how's your life go when I hope you're happy and you're laughing and doing fun things. Yeah. I fit in pretty good today. It's Friday, that number and I'm recording this and I'm thinking about I'm thinking about so go to the singing class. Once a week go to the singing class and it's a singing group singing group, a group of singers who liked singing, but aren't great at singing. But give it a go. This is one woman in the group who I think she thinks that she's like, more at Mariah Carey or something.

Funny, she's like, okay, so we learn songs right? And you say like, we're like, Twinkle twinkle. And then the you know the instructor pilot. Okay, listen, Okay, listen. This is how we do it. Twinkle twinkle. We don't we don't learn Twinkle Twinkle but you know example. And this woman is like I really like she like really likes going doing like I don't know what the right word is riffs. That's the right word but this is like she she be like okay, got it Twinkle Twinkle and so we can go to see you yeah and we're going to be singing in unison right is one woman who you know finger to the air like like like we're in some charity record recording with Bono from you to empty is just going for it it's simultaneously funny and really fucking annoying annoying because it's like I'm trying to listen to what the actual words I hear we don't need you doing your but anyway she I you know what, maybe you will need to challenge Challenge Challenge Challenge Challenge channel channel. Not challenge channel her because she doesn't give a single solitary fuck and she like her she's I know she's she's you know okayish singer probably the same like level I am like, not not terrible but not good.

But I feel like in her mind, she's She really is like, oh shit, man. I'm so fucking good. You know? Because he's always like, Oh, I'm I'll do it first. I'll jump off on stage first let me do it first. over it, get over it. Anyway, so feeling good. Want to do some positive talk about some positive stuff because you know with this podcast and all this tip, topic of fatness how often is it?

We're all gonna die. Everyone hates fat people. Nothing's changing. And you know, that's just the same fun and normally, I mean, it's interesting. It's interesting to talk about right and but you know what, generally in life I'm a pretty happy upbeat type of person and and so I thought you know, episode on the benefits of fat I cannot believe I've never thought about doing this because she it like the research I've done for this, it's like fuck is so so far, I've come up with 24. I say, I, the fat community has come up with this because I read I shared on my stories. And then I shared, I asked a question in a Facebook group, what do you think are the benefits? And some people, which I loved said, I don't think there are any benefits? Or I'm not sure the answer to this question. And so for those people, I'm ready to give you some juicy ideas of the benefits and, and if you're like, Oh, I know lots of benefits. I mean, there's even more, because even more maybe, or maybe you already know all of these benefits, and you're gonna be like, Vinay add on 2526 2720 and Alana Lola to a billion because there's infinite reasons that being fat is a Moore's law. I mean, is obviously, because fat is our more yarn.

But anyway, let's, let's get into it. No particular order, some of you come up with some really creative things. And actually, I'm gonna add on, I'm gonna add on 25 There we go. I already revealed 25 years because I just remembered a comment from someone else. So in no particular order, number one is buoyancy. So we had a lot of people, this is the first thing that they said is buoyancy. And so I'm gonna I'm gonna give my commentary and also comments from other people.

Unknown Speaker 6:41

So someone says, anecdotally, anecdotally, I recently went swimming for the first time in years, and I noticed my fat body is very buoyant. I thought it was awesome. Someone else says, I float in water. Ideal lifeguard, no effort to keep myself afloat. And I felt this very, very real for me,

Unknown Speaker 7:06

in an annoying way, because I remember when I was

Unknown Speaker 7:10

back in the UK, one of my goals was to swim to the bottom of the diving pool. And no matter how much I tried, I couldn't get there. And my boyfriend at the time who was thin, he could, and I just, my body was just like, No bitch, you're floating. And I would get like three quarters of the way down. I'm like, I'm so close.

Unknown Speaker 7:33

And I would have to swim like 1000 miles an hour, just to get to that bit and then you know, my fin boy from Uber like Ruben Uber, Uber blue picking up bricks from the bottom. And that it was annoying, but you know what?

Unknown Speaker 7:46

I can just hang out and water. And I don't have to tread water. Someone else said I second this, I can just float suspended without treading water, when my fin friends get exhausted and have to return to shore. Yes, so buoyancy, which is also increased play time in the water, and decrease in

Unknown Speaker 8:10

drowning. If you are left at sea. You know what, I've got it in my mind. I've been watching.

Unknown Speaker 8:17

Probably mentioned on the show before, I shouldn't be alive, you can find him on you can find him on YouTube, I shouldn't be alive. These fucking episodes is so

Unknown Speaker 8:28

compelling to watch is like, lost in the Sahara Desert.

Unknown Speaker 8:33

Death in in the canyon and

Unknown Speaker 8:37

boys adrift at sea is the one I watched last night. And, you know, just people just regular people are going out on a hike, and all of a sudden, they've been attacked by a grizzly bear, and then they have to survive crawling on the belly out of a forest over 25 days. And eventually they get rescued. And you know,

Unknown Speaker 8:54

and obviously, the person is telling the story. And so you know, that the person telling the story is alive. And so it's, you know, it's good that way, so you're not like, frustrated with the fact that you know, oh, shit, actually, they just die in the end. Yeah, so and one of the episodes was

Unknown Speaker 9:11

free fall from the sky.

Unknown Speaker 9:14

You're just remember the show cards, you know, the images on YouTube. And these parachutes parachute his parachute? Yeah, we're in a plane, the plane crashed, and they all jumped out of the plane. And one of the guys who was a fat guy, and he was the only one who survived and you survived at sea floating just on his own, and then he found a piece of wood. So he floated for many days at sea.

Unknown Speaker 9:43

And I just thought, oh, you know, he's fat. And so he probably had that benefit of not having to expend as much energy to keep his body afloat, and he could probably rest more by putting his head on the the wall

Unknown Speaker 10:00

would, and then he let his head rest or he could sleep and then his body would float. Whereas maybe, I mean, this is all conjecture for me watching this show. But he doesn't, these are the things that I'm thinking about, like, Oh, he's so lucky that he was fair

Unknown Speaker 10:16

that he was able to flow. And I mean, you know, more fat is you know, flat fat is like that tissue is, is floaty anyway. So next, moving on to the next one safety cushion. This is so interesting. I never thought about this, I knew that I knew the older people do well, by having weight versus being being thin. And one of the reasons is that

Unknown Speaker 10:45

so I'm going to link all studies in the show notes show notes for this one is facebook.com, forward slash 128 four@facebook.com, forward slash one to eight, the first study we're going to be talking about is called and trigger warning, when I'm referring to, there's going to be, oh, words are going to probably slip out, I'm going to change them to,

Unknown Speaker 11:11

to fat, but just a heads up, there might be some that slip out. Fat patients who fall have less injury severity, but a longer hospital stay than, quote, normal weight patients. And so

Unknown Speaker 11:25

and so this study is saying that you have less injury if you fall, if you are fat. And I like to, I don't like but it's interesting to say like, they have less injury, but they stayed stayed longer in hospital. And what we see a lot of the times were fat people When fat people go into hospital, that their treatment is different than if they were straight sized. And so that can account for that the difference in how long they have to stay in hospital, maybe.

Unknown Speaker 11:59

Maybe it's harder to

Unknown Speaker 12:01

I mean, who knows.

Unknown Speaker 12:04

So anyway, here's a link to the study in the show notes. And here we've got fat patient patients who had experienced a fall this is a quote from them from them had a fall had a significantly lower I S S is S stands for injury severity score.

Unknown Speaker 12:22

Falls are a leading cause of injury and a significant public health issue. The incidence of falls that lead to emergency unit admission in the group is growing with an increased sized and rapid growth in the geriatric population. So 80% of deaths are of people 70 above. And one of the most common

Unknown Speaker 12:47

injuries and reasons for death is death. And disability is falling when you're old. Specifically breaking a hip which can be devastating, and 1/3 of people who break a hip within a year will die. And the thinnest people are more likely to die after a hip fracture. So so fat people get have less injury, and they are least likely to die after a hip fracture.

Unknown Speaker 13:23

So and then, so that's the science shit, but a lot of people were saying about their experiences being fat, and falling, and the cushion, the safety cushion that their fat afforded to them. And so this is what people are saying. My elderly father Father has fallen several times and I'm really confident that his hips have gotten horribly bruised, but he has never broken hip because he's got extra cushion. Someone says ditto, I fallen a couple of times in the last few years. My belly broke my for someone else says yes, when I fell off my bike, the doctor told me I would probably have broken my arm if I wasn't so well padded.

Unknown Speaker 14:09

And I said, I guess then people's bones can just stick out and they just have their skin as the protecting force. That padding is so helpful. Yeah, because if you think I was thinking about this, because I've never even considered this thin people because I'm a fat person. I just think about a fat body. But I don't have like my collarbone isn't sticking out and and if you were to press my hips, there's, you know, a good few inches of fat there between me touching my hips, but you know, this is how I'm so like, not exposed to thin bodies. I've seen thin bodies like you can see the

Unknown Speaker 14:50

the hips stick out, right? Like if someone's lying down. Sometimes I've seen that like, you can see people's hips, bone, hip bones, and I presume

Unknown Speaker 15:00

Like, I mean, I mean, it makes sense, right? If you hadn't literally if you had a cushion around you and you fell over, if there's something that's breakable in there and there was a crowd of Christians surrounding it, it would be a little safer, wouldn't it?

Unknown Speaker 15:15

Someone else said anecdotal, but I fell off a moving horse recently and didn't break anything. I seriously think it was due to the extra padding.

Unknown Speaker 15:24

Someone else says it helps protect your bones and internal organs in car accidents and falls. I read an article years ago about a woman who started loving her fat after a doctor told her her fat saved her life in a car accident. And that's really cool. I wish I could find that that article. That's really cool. But here's the thing as well, is that we have that that cushion, but seatbelts are not made for basically, seat belts are made for thin men, straight size men.

Unknown Speaker 15:58

And so fat people can get injury from the seat belt not being if you've got underneath your belly, it's better that the bottom half of the seat belt was underneath your belly. So it's hitting where your hip bones would be versus that that bottom belt being across your belly. So a little reminder for when we're getting into to places with a seat belt like that is to not have it across the belly. Because then if we have an accident, it's going to squish if we have it under the belly. It's got the squishy and then we've got the bones there to stop us even better versus in the middle. I guess we just have the spine if it's underneath the ribs, right?

Unknown Speaker 16:44

Yeah, and even like you know driving with with tits, and I'm by you, but it gets on my gets on my tests, that the seatbelt is on my tats and it's just it. It's either like goes across my neck, or I have to put it under my tits. You know what I mean? You know what I mean?

Unknown Speaker 17:03

Or maybe you don't maybe you don't have to it's and you're like, I don't know what you mean or your tastes are different domains it some people will know what I mean.

Unknown Speaker 17:10

Yeah, so anyway,

Unknown Speaker 17:13

this person is saying that someone started loving their body after a doctor told them that their fat saved their life.

Unknown Speaker 17:21

Someone else said this might be weird, but I find that as opposed to smaller, my smaller counterparts I don't get hurt when I fall down. This has also come in handy in stage combat and physical theater. And while I've had lots of physical mishaps throughout my life, I've never broken a bone. I know bodies vary greatly, but I genuinely think the padding my fat gives me is responsible for this phenomenon. Someone else says I agree with this. I have horses and was once kicked by my favorite my favorite square on the thigh. And when a person would have a broken femur, I just had the mother of bruises.

Unknown Speaker 17:56

Yes, stage combat that's pretty cool.

Unknown Speaker 18:01

Not that to another one can do sketch stage combat minus breaks. And I was thinking about this how many breaks have I had in my life? The only breaks of bones I've had in my life are the sticky ality ones my nose when my then boyfriend accidentally head butted me on the way down on a waterslide when the instructions were to keep your chin down, this motherfucker didn't and he had a huge head knocked me in my nose broke my nose blood everywhere. look pretty cool. Kids were screaming that kids weren't screaming but I'm sure they were internally screaming

Unknown Speaker 18:36

and my finger and my toe my finger when my sister rudely shut the door on my on my finger. Yes, but I've not had any other breaks. And I mean, you know, that's anecdotal. But I was kind of like, oh, yeah, shit. Is it because

Unknown Speaker 18:54

I have this special padding.

Unknown Speaker 19:01

Next, survive disasters. And so you know, I'm thinking about, I shouldn't be alive. But someone says

Unknown Speaker 19:09

someone said we float really well and hard to sink or be drowned. Yes. And I was thinking about like, if we're in like, so if we're in a like natural disaster like a flood, then it will be easier to not drown in that flood.

Unknown Speaker 19:27

Or if we're in a

Unknown Speaker 19:30

if it's really windy gale force winds were less likely to be swept away. You know, like in that film Twister where, you know, the cows are being all swept away and stuff. Did you ever watch that film in like the 1990s

Unknown Speaker 19:43

terrifying.

Unknown Speaker 19:45

But maybe a thinner person is going to be in the tornado. And that'd be well I'm not going to be in the tornado until the until the wind goes up even more and then we're there. Then we're in the tornado so maybe gives us two seconds. extra time to escape a tornado.

Unknown Speaker 20:00

or if you're like stuck in the desert with no food.

Unknown Speaker 20:04

But you have water, I don't know where you've got water from, but you found a natural spring,

Unknown Speaker 20:09

you've got more energy resource on your body you're carrying around this result. So I wonder if you might survive longer, you might be able to make an episode of I shouldn't be alive because I got stuck in the Grand Canyon in some like a weird section or in the desert because my plane crashed or whatever. And you can be like, listen up here. I survived because I'm a fat motherfucker.

Unknown Speaker 20:37

And your thin friend died on May Day Two or something. I don't know. Who knows? Who knows who knows what the future is gonna hold. But

Unknown Speaker 20:47

I thought like surviving disasters as a pretty good tongue tongue in cheek one.

Unknown Speaker 20:52

Next, we are great to have sex with.

Unknown Speaker 20:57

We are great to have sex. So I've got an article here from Jean atomic, written for cosmopolitan. And it's called Why I only want to have sex with fat bodies.

Unknown Speaker 21:11

There is so much on the internet, if you think oh, no one wants to have sex and because I'm fat, Google like, why is it great to have sex with fat people. You have got people writing poetry about the incredible nurse of having sex with fat people. And and, you know, obviously we've got the fat fat chips, but then which are not necessarily bad. But also we've got people who just really appreciate a variety of bodies, and fat being in one of them.

Unknown Speaker 21:43

And Gina is has made a beautiful point in this in this piece. For cosmopolitan. Let me read some with 1x, whose body resembled mine, we settled into a regular routine of smoking a joint eating a massive takeaway and shagging the night away. It didn't matter that the fried rice made me bloat because we were already big or anyway, afterwards, we will press our bodies together and it was a best because we were the same. My belly boobs or any part of my body wasn't feeling a groove under his ribs like a jigsaw piece, but our fat spread against each other and left me fulfilled. This secret ceremony was ours and it was one we held most nights during my second year of uni. It changed the way I fucked and the way I felt about myself forever.

Unknown Speaker 22:38

Continuing I've discovered that fucking thin people who want to fuck fat people, and fucking fat people who want to fuck fat people is different in it's a tent. When a skinny man grabs my belly and begs me to sit on his face. It is him seeking what is alien to him and getting off on it. When a fat person pulls my body on top of theirs next to theirs and into theirs. It is them looking for themselves. For both of us. It's finding ourselves at home.

Unknown Speaker 23:10

When I'm sleeping with fellow fatties, I'm finding desire in myself. This comes from their desire for me and my desire for them. The physical joy I can receive from a fat body means not just that mine can have worth but that my body can give me delight I previously thought was only available to thin frames. Cool.

Unknown Speaker 23:35

Calm

Unknown Speaker 23:38

like it. Yeah, so I've called fat people are great to have sex with I mean a DA.

Unknown Speaker 23:45

Okay, next, we're soft and cozy. Someone says my body is so soft and cozy. My kids love snuggling me. I love snuggling my fat friends, I can inspire my other fat friends to love their bodies by sharing my love for my own.

Unknown Speaker 24:02

Someone else said big fat arms to big fat, big fat arms make a nice warm surface for my turtle to rest on. And then we got a picture of turtle resting on big fat arm. And I mean, you can't really tell the turtles expression but I think the turtle seems pretty content. It's just kind of hanging there. You know, its limbs on either side of the arm, and its neck sticking out. Having a look. Having a look, you know?

Unknown Speaker 24:33

And this is so true. Like

Unknown Speaker 24:36

I think about like my mom's friend who grew up she was kind of like a second mom. She was my mom's best friend lived down the street. Her name is Jane and Jane is a fat person and her hugging me and that kind of softness of her bosom and her like you know nice shirts nice kind of like silky type shirts that she might wear the comfort

Unknown Speaker 25:00

From that, and the softness of I mean, softness is just nice, isn't it? You know, falling into a nice big, soft, cozy bed with lots of blankets and pillows and always just feels nice and why would that then not feel nice on a human? It does. You know, if we had, like, you know, you know those squishy things like those fidget things that we touch, you know, they're just like squishy and, you know, they're like balloons filled with flour, and it just feels nice to squish, doesn't it? It does. That's a universal experience of many people liking to squish, to squeeze. And so squeezing flesh and feeling that softness, I think is just

Unknown Speaker 25:49

aerial obvious one of softness feels nice. Feels nice. Okay, so next, more tattoo space. I hadn't never thought about this one.

Unknown Speaker 26:03

Someone says more tattoos based softness is nice. Fat bodies are beautiful, varied and visually more interesting, at least in my opinion. Yeah, so tattoos, but it's I mean, you know, some people love a tattoo. I don't have any tattoos myself. But I'm sure I can imagine that if you have less space less skin, then it might get frustrating that you might have to cover over old new old tattoos to get a new tattoo or you just have to be like, Oh, if I get that set, I'm gonna have to tattoo my eyeballs now or my lips, because I've got nothing else to tattoo with. Maybe a fat person is like, you know, I've got some more leg left, you know?

Unknown Speaker 26:40

And following on from that, from this person said more visually interesting. That's our next point. visually interesting. And I've mentioned it I don't think I even mentioned it last time on the podcast. How I find fatness. I mean, all body variants I find interesting. But, you know, because people struggle with the idea that fatness is beautiful or visually interesting. It just is. There's just so much to see. And the back rolls give me a back roll. I mean, really, I mean, not just one I want to see, you know, all of those undulations you know, and the dimples and the different shapes of body parts. And you know how one person's fatness can manifest on their body in different ways. And so it makes them have this really unique like, fingerprints, because, you know, maybe one person's fatness is ever so slightly more on that hip and then dips down and then goes into their legs and maybe someone else like the fatness is more at the bottom of their belly and more maybe someone else's like like their belly cuts in the middle and maybe someone else's, you know, it's just interesting.

Unknown Speaker 27:55

Really visually interesting.

Unknown Speaker 27:58

And I can see why a lot of artists will use fat models in their work. Because there's, there's so much there to look at. And there's so much differences there.

Unknown Speaker 28:13

Yeah. Next one, strong.

Unknown Speaker 28:20

Okay, so I love the benefits. This is someone I love the benefits of being fat while pregnant, my body was strong, and I am already used to carrying weight. I wasn't horrified quote, by how my body was changing or worried other people would think. Just think I was fat. Like some of my thinner friends. My clothes were mostly why fitting and could easily accommodate some extra, so I didn't have to buy maternity clothes. And since I already had a big belly, I could hide my pregnancy for as long as I wanted. So that's another point hide your pregnancy for as long as you wanted. And that was my 25 Remembering this one. Because I was thinking you know, some a lot of times people don't want to say that they're pregnant. And if you're straight size, you've got short time to have to be able to be able to not tell people unless the way that you're carrying a pregnancy is different. You know, there's all those stories on you know, chat magazine and okay magazine of I didn't know I was pregnant because someone's body didn't change at all and and so of course that is absolutely

Unknown Speaker 29:23

a reality. But on the whole if you're showing a pregnancy if you have a smaller body, then

Unknown Speaker 29:31

you probably got home if I can how long? I don't have kids. No 17 MONTHS BEFORE YOU TELL I don't know how long is it gonna say?

Unknown Speaker 29:40

So you've probably got less amount of time then you do if you have a fat person I can imagine that probably affects things like work. If you have a decade boss who doesn't like

Unknown Speaker 29:52

it won't promote you if you're pregnant or, or if you're finding a job and someone won't hire you if you're pregnant, which is obviously a lie.

Unknown Speaker 30:00

Eagle but people are gonna do it anyway even if it's not illegal. Ah, yeah, so maybe this is one way that fat people can get a leg up in regards to making money getting a promotion, because they can hide their pregnancy a little bit longer.

Unknown Speaker 30:18

Anyway, so going back into to strong

Unknown Speaker 30:23

someone else someone else says being fat can make you strong when I started powerlifting my coach told me that I had been weight training my whole life moving my best fat body through the world. I can outlive anyone at the gym.

Unknown Speaker 30:38

Someone else says heck yes. You know, I'm already benching several hundies several 100 pounds. I don't know. I mean, that sounds like a lot but

Unknown Speaker 30:50

several 100 pounds is that they? They exaggerate and or is that? Is that real? Is that weightlifters? Is that sounds like loads? Like isn't that like the weight of a car or something? No cars or cars way more than that. But anyway,

Unknown Speaker 31:05

someone else says when I was in high school, I used to bet the boys I could leg lift more than them one every time couldn't bench couldn't bench 40 pounds, but my legs have always been hella strong. I think bench is when you lie down and you lift the weights above your head.

Unknown Speaker 31:26

You know, that's the one where you see all those kind of funny fail videos where someone you know, they can't do it and then it like lands on lands and lands on the their torso and then they roll over and then they don't then they're like, oh,

Unknown Speaker 31:40

no, I think that's what benching is. But there's better there's got strong legs. Someone else says, I box and it makes your punch land much harder. That's interesting. It also makes you

Unknown Speaker 31:53

I'm not going to read that book because I think that is not relevant. I read a lot of them and I said I wonder as well. Do you think it helps absorb punches as you'd be able to be punched with more force to hit muscle you'd have to be punched with more force to hit muscles where it would really affect your ability to keep fighting and this person says that's a good thought that I'm not really sure the answer to I do know that the pro at my old gym was woman and she had a lot of trouble finding finding fights because of this and her weight class and the coach would not ever let her fight anyone even a pound

Unknown Speaker 32:31

a pound over her weight so weight is truly an advantage. Hmm Interesting. Interesting. Yeah, cuz I thought Oh, interesting on the physics of because it would make sense if from falls and from getting kicked by a horse and all that type of stuff. That's protective, then surely getting a punch in the belly. Or wherever in the bum. I don't think boxers punch in the bum. That'd be really funny. Are they did they do to scoot around in the bum? Maybe they do shit? I don't know. I don't know. I've do boxes punch bums? Do they punch a bum hole? You know how like rugby players? They they fight it by putting their fingers up their opponent's bum holes.

Unknown Speaker 33:16

If that's fighting your first sexual assault yep, that's sexual assault. Yeah, so I wonder if that's probably against the rules. No, no punching people's bum holes is probably a rule.

Unknown Speaker 33:27

Yeah. Anyway, continuing what a great thread. It's taking a lot for me to find the right fitness for my hyper mobile body. But lately I'm stronger and more stable than ever before. And I feel like such a powerhouse. Okay, so next stronger bones ie unlikely to get osteoporosis as bone density. Density is relative to the load it's under. So more load equal more density equals more strength and I guess that one could fall under. We've got a health section so

Unknown Speaker 34:00

but I mean, this is strength, right. And osteoporosis, I know is a big issue for for older folks. Okay, next. Not sure. Specifically, I haven't looked but when I studied anatomy the risk factors for osteoporosis, or low body weight, underweight, particularly older, a fab assigned female at birth. Although a Mab assigned male at birth do get it to calorie restriction. chronic dieting is another ways to improve risks is strength training, which increases bone mass, there would be studies about how bone mass is increased. A larger body person naturally carries more mass meaning their bones are under a larger load all the time as compared to a smaller person. This constant load keeps their bones strong, but strength training is a larger body person would add extra strength again, it's I think it's called Wolf's law. Ari bone regeneration and I should have googled that to find this study, but I forgot

Unknown Speaker 35:01

I will have a look and then add it in. Come on brain remember that remember that loves law most law I'm gonna Google it right now wolf slow bone regeneration W O LFF. Wolf slow bone. Here we go, what's the law of bone? Here we go. How gar

Unknown Speaker 35:23

Wolf's law is the idea that natural healthy bones will adapt and change to the stress that is subjected to for example, if the bones are subjected to heavier and heavier loads, they will naturally reconstruct themselves to accommodate that weight. This is just how bones typically respond to stress. That's cool.

Unknown Speaker 35:43

Love it we got fucking bones made of steel.

Unknown Speaker 35:49

Loving It's Okay, so next let's move to decreased mortality term. I'm in the middle. Okay, so someone had actually written a paper on the hoo ha, that is

Unknown Speaker 36:06

the CDC Centers of Disease Control and there

Unknown Speaker 36:14

there Okay, so this is what happened. This is what happened. So the CDC came out with a study that says that fatness causes 365,000 deaths per year

Unknown Speaker 36:28

so

Unknown Speaker 36:30

the CDC came up with that study

Unknown Speaker 36:33

and this study has been touted as the you know, anytime anyone wants to come out with a stat about why fat people are roaming the streets and you know eating babies and the with terrible is a tablet study 365,000 deaths per year because of fatness. Now, this study was really shit. It was really flawed. Basically if you die whilst being fat then you have died because of being fat. Fat person is hit by a car they died from fatness fat person drowns they died from fatness fat person sneeze and their brains fall out of their nostrils they died from fatness right.

Unknown Speaker 37:16

And it's just if you die while fat you died from fat basically. And yeah, anyway, so this study is like, you know

Unknown Speaker 37:29

that and so a year later, the CDC came out with another study that says that that study was wildly Interac inaccurate and actually the number of the deaths caused by fatness is very different and the person who who led that study is someone called Catherine Fleagle.

Unknown Speaker 37:53

And so, her paper shows that fatness causes 112,000 deaths, but it also reduces deaths by 86,000 a year because smaller fat people have lower mortality, which equals 26,000 deaths a year due to fatness is what this study is saying the study before said 365,000. So, big difference. So 26,000 deaths due to fatness every year and that is called famously the quote obesity paradox The obesity paradox being well hang on, we all thought fat people were just unhealthy slobs dying, left, right and center. But how is it that fat people can live long, healthy lives? That's weird, is a paradox. It's not a paradox. It's just this is a fact people can live long, healthy lives.

Unknown Speaker 38:53

Also something to note is that we don't know why these fat people have been classed as dying from fatness because like, what mechanism is at play here? We don't know. We don't know. And that's a big question that scientists are trying to answer. Why would someone die of fatness?

Unknown Speaker 39:13

And you can say well, you know, because we all know fat people have heart attacks and we all know that people you know, whatever.

Unknown Speaker 39:20

But why? Okay, so what but why? Why would a fat person be at increased risk from a heart attack?

Unknown Speaker 39:26

And so it's kind of like going back what is what what is going on? And what we do know is that fat people have a history of dieting.

Unknown Speaker 39:38

More likely to have a history of dieting, which is really not great for you

Unknown Speaker 39:43

will experience a shit ton of modularization and oppression and shame which is really not great for you and are less likely to engage in health care, and when they do, they're more likely to receive subpar health care. So we're saying 26,000 People

Unknown Speaker 40:00

die a year due to fatness? We don't know why but we can probably guess that. Is it fatness that they died from from or is it fat phobia that they died from? I mean,

Unknown Speaker 40:15

my guess is it's the fat phobia. So.

Unknown Speaker 40:20

So, quote, given current government guidelines, it appears that the average person is better off to be 50 or even 75 pounds overweight than five pounds. underweight. Mm hmm. So the thinness people are more likely to die versus the fattest people, people.

Unknown Speaker 40:43

Link to studies there and then meta analysis to and then someone who was talking about that talked about the medical the weight of medical authority. This is by Julia Rogers, who was in the Facebook group talking about this. This is her dissertation, the making an unmaking of knowledge in the obesity epidemic. And yeah, the other part of the obesity paradox is

Unknown Speaker 41:13

there's more and more fat people. Why is there more and more fat bald people? Who knows? There's more and more fat people but we're living longer and longer and longer.

Unknown Speaker 41:24

We're surely if we have more and more fat people surely that means that we need to we are going to live not as long and the evidence is not showing it right. i People have predictions like oh, we're all gonna die. This is the first generation that's going to die before their parents and shit like that. And this is dogshit recent research right?

Unknown Speaker 41:43

Kara? So there's that so reduced decreased mortality, next lower risks of cancers and many other conditions and improved prognosis so

Unknown Speaker 41:58

there's a

Unknown Speaker 42:00

Paul earns Berger PhD, he was a professor at Case Western Reserve University the Department of Nutrition. He did a lot of work on fatness although he wasn't the greatest fat ally. He has a book Paper it's pretty big. I don't think it's I don't think it's big enough to be anyway whatever link link in the show notes called rethinking obesity

Unknown Speaker 42:30

and and it goes into great detail on all of these I'm going to read out and so it goes into into the studies of all of these all of these things there's so many because I thought you know, okay, lower risk of cancers lower you know, other conditions there's going to be like five there's fucking law loads there's loads and I bet you there's even more research now that's come out with even more

Unknown Speaker 43:00

is list is so long that I don't even know if I'm going to read it out on Fuck it. I'm going to read it out. So you have that. Okay, so health benefits of fatness he calls it the O word. fatness is associated. So I'm reading from his his, his it's from the Journal of

Unknown Speaker 43:16

O word and weight regulation.

Unknown Speaker 43:20

Okay, so fatness is associated with a lower incidence of cancer, overall cancer incidence, cancer mortality, premenopausal breast cancer, stomach cancer, lung cancer, colon cancer melag. It's not melanoma. It's mentioning glioma

Unknown Speaker 43:40

respiratory disease, chronic obstructive polymer, COPD, pulmonary disease COPD, which is so interesting because a lot of COPD is like that. Chronic bronchitis, infectious infectious disease, overall fatalities it from infection of infectious disease to nobilo Turbo Ulos to Bert tuberculosis, urinary tract infection, bone disease, osteoporosis, hip fracture, vertebral fracture, cardiovascular disease, mitral valve prolapse intermittent

Unknown Speaker 44:18

fucking What is this word? Claw

Unknown Speaker 44:21

sedation Oh fucking another big one. If

Unknown Speaker 44:27

why you're making me read these long words. I fiscal heroic renal artery stenosis renovascular hypertension due to fibromuscular hyperplasia plezier GYN a lot gynecological and ops Obstet stuff about Cedric eclampsia, premature birth, vaginal laceration, hot flashes, premature menopause and so these are all lower incidence of all of these if you're fat

Unknown Speaker 44:59

and need

Unknown Speaker 45:00

meah type one diabetes, peptic ulcer scoliosis suicide.

Unknown Speaker 45:06

fatness is associated with a more favorable prognosis in diabetes type two hyperlipidemia hypertension and rheumatoid arthritis.

Unknown Speaker 45:21

It feels like you know what that should be made into a song you know like the medical love song from Monty Python. Do you know that song? I love that song. Inflammation of the foreskin reminds me of your smile. I have Bala nikal shank roids for quite a little while. I gave my heart to MSU that lovely night in June. I like for you my dog

Unknown Speaker 45:49

and I know you'll get well soon. My pee no warts your herpes my syphilitic sore millennia infection how I love you more and more. Your Dobies itch my scrub box your lovely gone Oh rah. I wish we both were lying. When we said that we were clear

Unknown Speaker 46:19

that is Monty Python. We should can someone who is very Come on now come up with a health ministers of fatness and he would like

Unknown Speaker 46:29

urinary tract infection. Asti yo pyrosis mitral valve prolapse, eclampsia and fashional laceration hot flashes anemia overall cancer incidence and lung cancer colon cancer stomach cancer infectious disease overall vitality is

Unknown Speaker 46:54

talent a guide when that now would be good. Um, if I can token shit about the woman who's like singing see saying that the singing group and I'm forcing you to listen to me sing for like a minute. No. Okay, continuing on this health benefits of fatness. Here's just like a little snippet of

Unknown Speaker 47:17

of what he's saying because we've got this whole giant list but Okay, so the chief benefit of moderate fat seems to be a decrease in overall cancer deaths. So that's like the number one thing is cancer. Nothing's if you're fat, you've got a lower incidence of it. This has been documented in the seven countries and Framingham studies, as well as studies led by Wallace in Iowa, Avon in France, Rhodes and Kagan. Kagan among Japanese Americans in Hawaii, wallet in Norway, Garcia Palmieri in Puerto Rico, and gom in Scotland. Among the nearly 11,000 participants in the hypertension detection and follow up program a highly significant inverse relation between added positivity adiposity and cancer incidents were observed even after controlling for smoking, age, race, sex education and cholesterol level and the findings has been repeatedly replicated. All of these studies considered the possibility that thin people may die of cancer more often because disease related weight loss enlarges the population of sick people who are underweight this confounding effect was minimized by giving physical examinations and tests to all participants and excluding from the studies all those were detectable disease.

Unknown Speaker 48:40

Yeah, continue continue continue for many, many, many pages. And what he says to begin with about the improved prognosis of fatness. So fatness may have an immune or ameliorating influence when it CO is in excess with major risk factors, though or mortality in fat hyper tensive than in Lean hypertensives have been reported in five studies reviewed by Barrett Connor and caught an eight others in one study 43% of nonfat hypertensive men died during follow up while only 26% of fat hypertensive did

Unknown Speaker 49:19

lalalalalala continuing with that, and under the same vein of the health stuff is that you were less likely to you are able to recover quickly quicker from when hospital hospitalized from COVID. So let's read the so there's there was a mention on the show before

Unknown Speaker 49:49

a huge study done among 10,000 veterans who got COVID And so the risks they will look at the risks

Unknown Speaker 50:00

factors for in this study. And so Regan Chastain has a post that kind of just talks about this quickly.

Unknown Speaker 50:08

The in the post she is talking about the name of the study is risk factors for hospitalization, mechanical ventilation, or death among 10,131 US veterans with SARS cov, two infection or link in the show notes and link to

Unknown Speaker 50:27

Reagan's article. And so, quote, the large study

Unknown Speaker 50:32

of more than 10,000 people with COVID found that having a high BMI is not a risk factor for hospitalization, but kind of a mechanical ventilation or death. This is one of the few studies on this topic to fully adjust for confounding variables, and definitely one of the largest I've seen to date. Interestingly, it found that although black patients were more likely to be hospitalized and receive mechanical ventilation than white patients, they weren't more likely to die. This unusual finding may have to do with the fact that the healthcare healthcare access is far more equalized. In the Veterans Administration, the VA system where this study was conducted outside that system, unequal access to care means that folks who are black Indigenous and People of Color tend to have higher mortality, as well as other poor health, health outcomes. So risk factor there is racism. This study also found that Hispanic ethnicity was not associated with an increased risk of adverse outcomes, which again may reflect the better access to quality of care that people patients of color receive in the VA system, that access and quality may be why larger body patients fare just as well, and in some cases, even better than smaller body patients in this study. So again, that big thing of are we looking about?

Unknown Speaker 51:57

Why?

Unknown Speaker 52:00

Why, when, you know, why are they more why why are black people more likely to be hospitalized? Why is it that

Unknown Speaker 52:13

black people are more likely to be put on a ventilator? And then oh, when they when they are put on a ventilator? They they die at the same or lower rate than white people? Is it because they have experienced systemic racism? Up until that point? Yes.

Unknown Speaker 52:33

Yes.

Unknown Speaker 52:35

Mara, man, incredible elder in the activism community.

Unknown Speaker 52:41

Talk about Paul earns burger, which is the stuff that I just spoke about before.

Unknown Speaker 52:46

And she says I feel like Paul wrote about correlations between higher weight and health benefits in his first big publication.

Unknown Speaker 52:54

The one authored by ERNs burger and how skew stuff like fat people who have type two diabetes or heart disease are living longer, being more likely to survive car accidents.

Unknown Speaker 53:04

Ken Thompson who wrote RT agony for the fatso Z always enjoyed putting out that she pointing out that she had built in hand warmers.

Unknown Speaker 53:15

I don't know where the hand warmers are, is it built in hand warmers? Because you're going to put your hands into the flesh of a fat body into the armpits or the under the breasts? Or?

Unknown Speaker 53:30

Or is it fat hands or hot? I don't think fat hands are hotter.

Unknown Speaker 53:34

But Kath says she has built in a hand warmers, I think it's having a fat body being able to put in, you've got all of that space to stick your hands in.

Unknown Speaker 53:46

Next, bigger to filter. So I've spoken about this before being fat filters, a lot of jerks out of my life. Someone else says right? They tell themselves so much sooner than the racists. Someone says yep. Oh, not someone me. Yep. I feel sorry for people who are temporarily thin, who may be inadvertently surrounded by fat folks and only realize it if they put on weight. Yeah, so that's I think a big thing is that especially because you know, dating and stuff, if someone won't date me because I'm fat, then it's kind of like the canary in the coal mine of even more bigotry that they are hiding or you know, not doing a very good job of it. Because not doing something because they're fat is bigotry.

Unknown Speaker 54:31

But yeah, I mean someone who could be thin and white and able bodied and could marry or be with someone fall in love with him being connected to them and then they have an accident they become disabled. They put on weight and then all of a sudden their partner's like I don't like fat people. I don't like disabled people. I don't like cats. Can you change your body for me because I'm gonna fuck someone who's been a

Unknown Speaker 55:00

And then you're like, oh shit, I'm gonna fucking Biggert, which is not what most people do. Most people do. Say, oh shit, I am horrible, and I need to lose weight, which is, I want to tell them

Unknown Speaker 55:13

that relationship. And I mean, shit is complicated. That's the thing is once you're in a relationship and you love someone, you look your overlook flaws, like being a bigot.

Unknown Speaker 55:25

Which, you know, but anyway, you know, and the bigger your body, the bigger bigot filter, you have the better bigger filter because, you know, someone could be like, oh, you know, it's okay, if there's a small fat person, but a big fat person, I'm interested, which is, again, is just a sign of their fat phobia and all that weight bias they have, which sucks. So yeah, that's great. I'm not going to end up with an accidental fat flu. I mean, shit, they could be lying to me. They can rely on me like, another day. But I mean, don't think so. I don't think so. And I think, you know, I really don't think so. Because

Unknown Speaker 56:08

someone has to be somewhat attracted to you. I mean, of course, there's people who, who are not sexually and physically attracted. That's just the

Unknown Speaker 56:18

way they are on the LGBTQ i A to S spectrum, right? Is asexual a romantic? Not talking about that, talking about? If you if someone is attracted to humans and wants to be wants to have sex with humans, and they're having sex with you, chances are they're attracted to you. Yeah. Now while I'm saying, you know, because they're not going to be there being like, gross, and then also choosing you. Right? Next, being seen slash not being seen. So someone says, as someone with social anxiety, there are two huge benefits. One, people actively avoid sitting next to me on public transit, I usually have plenty of space to I'm invisible to men, I almost never get catcalled or creeped on in public. And so that's not being seen. Someone else said, being five foot one, being fat makes me easier to spot in crowds. And so if there's five foot one person was not fat, they'd be even harder to spot but because luckily they are fat, they're easier to spot in crowds. So being seen or not being seen. Next, belly as a snack shelf. Mm hmm. I'd say snack and love shelf. So fat bodies. This person says fat bodies are strong bodies. I love how effortlessly I can float. I think my body is very comfy and pleasant to cuddle with. And when I'm sitting my belly provides a great shelf for snacks.

Unknown Speaker 57:52

And you know what? That made me think about my belly.

Unknown Speaker 57:55

And when Dougie the dog is sitting on my knee. He looks up at me from he puts his head on my belly. And he looks up and he says I love you. And I say oh my god, I love you.

Unknown Speaker 58:09

And

Unknown Speaker 58:12

sorry, someone's just started jackhammering outside my fucking window road.

Unknown Speaker 58:18

Save you know, the jackhammer, literally, outside my window and then yeah, just ignore it. City noises. Yeah, so so so a doggy loves shell. So I feel good about this. But if I was sitting, he could do it on my tips. But then I was like, You know what, no, it's not the same. Because my palate bellies lower down, my tips are higher up. So if he did the looking up at me, and using my tips as a, as a pillow, his nose would be too close to my face, I wouldn't be able to view his cute little face as well. But I can when he uses my belly as a pillow, and looks lovingly into my eyes. And I say you're so cute. And this person is using their belly as a snack shelf. Amazing. Love it. And also,

Unknown Speaker 59:13

you could probably depending on your type of body, using you're using the space between your tips and your belly as a like shopping bag. You know, as in you know, you're you're going around the house, you're naked obviously. Well, maybe you're not you know, you're just in the store. And you've got like, you know, your bag of oranges in one hand and you've got your, your cheese in the other and then you're like, oh, I want some Pringles where am I going to put them in underneath the tips above your belly? Perfect Pringles tube storage, or any other things. Probably not chocolate because it's going to melt because it's all something that needs to be kept warm. Oh, it's like a

Unknown Speaker 1:00:00

frickin little microwave thing, isn't it, it's microwave oven, you could buy a pastry or something that you might want to have warmed up, stick it under your tits in between your belly wart that's warming it. And by the time you get home, it's gonna be partially warm for you to then be able to put it in the oven, or the microwave to warm it even further. Whereas if you didn't have a fold to put in your pastry, you're gonna have to wait three seconds longer for that to warm in the oven. So who's the winner now? Thin people I'm sorry. But your snack eating capabilities are seriously hampered. Because you don't have folds to stick a pastry into.

Unknown Speaker 1:00:44

Very sad for you.

Unknown Speaker 1:00:46

Now, everyone who has a fold,

Unknown Speaker 1:00:51

I mean, shit. I mean, I guess fat people, I mean, thin people could

Unknown Speaker 1:00:55

sticking down the pounds underneath their balls in between, like, bum cheeks or something. But it's probably a little bit harder to do that in the store versus shoving it down your bra. You know?

Unknown Speaker 1:01:10

And a lot of people I know, a lot of people with very big tits. I mean, not even not even will use their bra as their purse. Right? You know, you see that a lot. You mean even you see that? See the signs? Like, we don't accept money that's come from your bra.

Unknown Speaker 1:01:27

But, you know, like, have you seen the videos on Tiktok, where like, this is like a woman who takes out a whole bottle of wine from her bra bra, because she has fat hits.

Unknown Speaker 1:01:38

I mean, that was just from one side, she could have had another bottle from the other side.

Unknown Speaker 1:01:44

Okay, next mental health is good for your mental health to stay out of toxic diet culture that can cause disordered eating, is what one person says another person says being fat and good with it is a blessing to mental health and wellness. The amount of space that gets freed in one's brain when you stop worrying about food and dieting is immense. You suddenly have so much extra time and energy to focus on things that actually bring you pleasure, pleasure or move your life forward. And this one, I mean, I give this, I'll do this with an asterix because anyone can experience that right? You don't have to be unnecessarily fat. But But But But okay, here's how this works with fat folks, is that fat people experienced more experienced marginalization and stigma and bigotry because of the size of their bodies. And so that's something that straight size people don't experience because of the size of their bodies. Therefore, if we are saying no, we're not going to buy into that, that bullshit anymore.

Unknown Speaker 1:02:48

We are potentially going to have increased satisfaction.

Unknown Speaker 1:02:53

Like a you know, most improved, that's what most improved most improved, because from the starting point, it might be a little bit more difficult.

Unknown Speaker 1:03:02

Okay, next, we are incredible and resilient. And so this post that fat Doctor UK

Unknown Speaker 1:03:13

that I saw, and I was like, yes.

Unknown Speaker 1:03:18

Yeah, so Asha says, Why are people so utterly threatened by fat people? Oh, no, wait, it's because we're fucking incredible. We're the people society rejects and somehow find a way to make something of ourselves with a bunch of everyone's jokes. And yet, we're still the funniest people in the room. I just want to take a moment to celebrate our collective awesomeness. We are some of the most creative, entrepreneurial, resilient, compassionate, intelligent and capable people on this planet. And we're like this because we're fat. Every time Society said no, we said we'll see. Every time Society said there's something wrong with you. We said no, there's not. Every time Society said you're not welcome here. We said let's make our own space where we are welcome, fat folks, no matter where you are right now and what you're going through take a moment to reflect upon how far you've come in spite of all those people who were cheering for you to fail. You are may Zoe

Unknown Speaker 1:04:19

ah, and then and then Ash is saying Oh, tagging me in.

Unknown Speaker 1:04:27

In people who has has affected their life in a positive way.

Unknown Speaker 1:04:33

Thank you and someone else has tagged me too.

Unknown Speaker 1:04:36

I didn't even know is that like you?

Unknown Speaker 1:04:39

You

Unknown Speaker 1:04:41

that's nice little surprise.

Unknown Speaker 1:04:44

Yeah, I mean shit.

Unknown Speaker 1:04:48

how resilient are we have to be to have to have currently survived fat phobia. And depending on your size, even more levels

Unknown Speaker 1:05:00

of discrimination and oppression. If you're a big fat person, I mean, Whoa, that is some feet. In this violently fat phobic world, you know that

Unknown Speaker 1:05:14

advocating for ourselves, not internalizing shame.

Unknown Speaker 1:05:20

saying no, I'm not going to stay small.

Unknown Speaker 1:05:27

And just surviving and living. I mean, even if you you're not at a place where you're able to advocate for yourself or, or feel, okay, you're alive, and you're fat, that's taken resilience. And that is wonderful.

Unknown Speaker 1:05:44

Okay, next fat community, which is what Asha was talking about, as well in there.

Unknown Speaker 1:05:53

Someone says, the special communities of fat folks that I'm a member of online places where everyone is accepted, loved and praised for who they are places that you know, are safe, and that everyone has kind where anything other than respect, kindness and compassion is not tolerated at all. I think we fatties are lucky in that respect the thins miss out on those utterly welcome welcoming online places. Yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes. And then someone below said, Oh, can you tell me some of those groups that you're a member of, and I'm going to link them below, but you can just pop these into Facebook. The first one is fat acceptance cloud. The next one is fat chat community. And the next one is chat with fat feminists. And I am personally a member of a local group here in Vancouver.

Unknown Speaker 1:06:39

If you're in Vancouver,

Unknown Speaker 1:06:43

and you want to be a member of that Facebook group, let me know I think I might have to add you. If not, it's kind of hard to find. Let me let me tell you the name of it. So you see if you can find it. It's called fat club Vancouver. But it's got a

Unknown Speaker 1:07:01

it's got a

Unknown Speaker 1:07:03

punctuation mark before and after that I can't I don't know the name of this. It's like a, it's like a dash. It's like a dash but it's a it's a wiggly dash. So it looks like a little tiny little wave. So it's a tiny little wave. And then Fackler Vancouver, and then another tiny little wave. And I love that that community of a face because we get together for clothing swaps. People get recommendations for places where you know, hey, I want to go to a massage. She's been to a massage place that has that isn't that phobic? What are the chairs like in this restaurant, you know, bla bla bla bla.

Unknown Speaker 1:07:44

I mean, I'm just looking at a post now I don't know if you know yet. But I'm at Mountain Equipment Co Op in Vancouver, and they have apparel up to 6x. And the plaid plus eyes are actually in stock.

Unknown Speaker 1:07:57

And people are like, Oh my god, oh my god, or like, Hey, you go into this Walmart and they've got a selection of what en la

Unknown Speaker 1:08:06

is great. It's a great resource. And I feel like, I feel like I'm a part of this really cool community.

Unknown Speaker 1:08:14

That is like, under, you know, a community of people who are like, seen as a misfits of society. And,

Unknown Speaker 1:08:24

and we're like, it's like this cool club, that people are like, I don't want to be in that club. And we're like, Fine, you don't have to be a nightclub. And it's fucking, like, poppin off, you know, like, we're in a tree house. And all the facts are there. And we're having a little party, and people below are like, Oh, that looks rubbish. And we're like, Yeah, you think it looks rubbish? That's fine. We don't want you inhale. And meanwhile, we're up there with our Pringles tubes under our tests with, you know, doing all the cool fatty things, lifting cars off people and floating.

Unknown Speaker 1:09:02

And, and I get to be a part of that. And that's really, really cool.

Unknown Speaker 1:09:08

And I think that community is what

Unknown Speaker 1:09:13

has saved a lot of people.

Unknown Speaker 1:09:18

And someone else said that they did they this person cat who has a podcast called matter of fact says, we did a topic. We did an episode on this topic.

Unknown Speaker 1:09:29

A few seasons back, and she says we talked a lot about how the way we grew up and connected with others was shaped by our fatness in many ways that we're grateful for. Yeah, I mean,

Unknown Speaker 1:09:43

I feel safe around fat people. I feel seen. I feel like I can relax. I mean, of course, that's not always true that all fat people are going to be our best friend. And in fact, a lot of fat people

Unknown Speaker 1:10:00

are fat phobic. But even if a fat person is fat phobic, they still have maybe a similar lived experience in regards to their size as me. And so we have that connection at a minimum.

Unknown Speaker 1:10:15

Yeah, so I mean fat community is just

Unknown Speaker 1:10:19

one wonderful. Really I think. I think that's like one of the top I think for me one of my favorites

Unknown Speaker 1:10:32

visually interesting.

Unknown Speaker 1:10:35

safety cushion that's like a

Unknown Speaker 1:10:38

one that I didn't have. And actually I'm gonna go I'm gonna go back to this whole big list that I've got because I think I've missed a few

Unknown Speaker 1:10:47

but a lot on the lung out harder to kidnap Yes.

Unknown Speaker 1:10:55

Warmer, warmer, that's one that was one a lot of people were saying is that they are warmer in the winter. Someone said that.

Unknown Speaker 1:11:05

That their sister got hypothermia in the same conditions that she was absolutely fine. A sister is a thin person and she is a fat person.

Unknown Speaker 1:11:15

Someone else says

Unknown Speaker 1:11:18

being underestimated. And sometimes being able to surprise people. So you know, like, we're fat people, you know? Oh, they don't work out. Oh, they are smelly and oh, they are unintelligent and oh, they are all of the stereotypes of fatness and not saying that

Unknown Speaker 1:11:39

not working out and blah blah all those things are negative but then being able to kind of crush a stereotype and sometimes you will you know adhere to a stereotype and that's absolutely fine too.

Unknown Speaker 1:11:53

Is is really cool, right? Kind of like what is it? You know, something like hold my drink and and then go and you know that that person who says oh in high school, I out benched or not are benched because it wasn't bench was it was an eye out lifted all of the other guys in the class? Like, that's kind of like, like you see in a movie being like, Whoa, this is strong. And I'm like, Yeah, fucking told you dickered.

Unknown Speaker 1:12:24

And the final one, the final thing that I want to mention is

Unknown Speaker 1:12:30

we are counterculture. Right the

Unknown Speaker 1:12:35

the culture is, if we look at what is prevalent, what we're seeing in in advertising, and all that type of stuff, is what people think people able bodied people bla bla, and in the fatness category, we're not seeing fat people as being a part of what is represented in our cultural dialogue. And therefore we're counterculture. Therefore we are cool as fuck, just because we're not part of that main messaging. It makes us edgy. It makes us interesting. It makes us forget uncool.

Unknown Speaker 1:13:13

Because we can because we're counterculture.

Unknown Speaker 1:13:17

And I bet there are 75 billion other things that I've not even thought about and, you know, the community has, has not thought about in the two days that I've been researching this.

Unknown Speaker 1:13:31

I mean, we're up to 26 I reckon we could get up to

Unknown Speaker 1:13:36

I mean, shit, if we looked at all of the health benefits of fatness. It'd be

Unknown Speaker 1:13:42

100

Unknown Speaker 1:13:44

AJ, AJ, and let me read like I've got I've got this, this one post that I just really

Unknown Speaker 1:13:53

like it this one is okay. So someone says, Oh, yes, great question. And this is their overview.

Unknown Speaker 1:14:04

Buoyancy not only makes easy, makes water easy, but makes me safer installation I stay warmer in the cold wind resistance. I don't get blown blown over easily on my bike or on the ice softness. Children love to snuggle with me because I'm soft awareness. I know what it's like to experience hatred and disgust. Yes. So these are a couple more that I can add a you know, a wellness awareness, compassion and wind resistance.

Unknown Speaker 1:14:31

Self Compassion because of my experiences of hatred and disgust. I've had to learn to love myself, or let that be my driving force. Rather than rely on the judgments of other, save for bad at bad energy. Anyone who wants to judge me for my size is not worth my attention. So I don't waste our time on people. As soon as they show me they're judging me community. When I found fat community bonds have been made that were made that those who are not challenged by Stuart stigma. Do not get to explore

Unknown Speaker 1:15:00

perience empathy, I can know what it's like to experience hatred and disgust and can empathize with those who have had similar experiences for reasons other than or in addition, addition to fatness joy. When I finally when I finally after years of struggle learn to love my body, the joy of being hold feels greater than I've been alive than if I'd never had to struggle. Yes. That's not like that most improved.

Unknown Speaker 1:15:30

Someone else says, As Homer Simpson said, pro I'm drought and famine resistant.

Unknown Speaker 1:15:43

This is what this person says, when I'm 35 have no wrinkles on my face, not even forehead wrinkles. So here's, here's one thing that I kind of edited out from other responses is a lot of people said this, like, fat people don't age. That's ageist because we're placing a value on looking younger, looking younger, or looking older, is not inherently good or bad. And so I'm not including that in

Unknown Speaker 1:16:13

in my round up, because I don't personally think that looking having wrinkles or looking older is better. What I mean worse, worse. And so I'm not going to perpetuate that idea that

Unknown Speaker 1:16:30

being older or looking older is a negative thing because it's an absolute privilege to be able to age. Okay. They also say I'm not afraid of walking down the street by myself because I know weighing so much, it's going to take a lot to take me down. I know this isn't everyone's experienced, but I love my strength. I've always been really strong as a fat girl. People don't like sitting next to me so I get more space on buses or in theaters. It's great for social anxiety. I don't bruise and have never had a broken bone and I would literally climb chain link baseball backstops and jump off this one. I don't know it's a cause of my fatness. Or if I was just a resilient kid. Six, I don't get cold. Okay, so let's do a roundup let's do a roundup of all the things we've we're up to 28 I just added a few more from that last, last. Last thing. The benefits of being fat one, community. Two, we are incredible and resilient. Three mental health for easy to find in a friend in a crowd five, le shelf slash snack shelf, six bigot filter, seven harder to kidnap eight decreased mortality, nine better cancer survival 10 strong and 11 more tattoos, space 12 stronger bones and less risk from osteoporosis 13 Straw soft and cozy. 14 more likely to survive disasters. 15 great from though great for those who have social anxiety, as pets people are less likely to talk to you or sit next to you 16 A safety cushion with that fat around our body protecting our organs and bones 17 keeps us warm 18 lowers the risk of cancers and many other conditions. 19 buoyancy 20 recover quickly when hospitalized from recover quicker when hospitalized from COVID 21 being underestimated and sometimes being able to surprise people 22 visually interesting 23 Great to have sex with 24 increased wind resistance 25 were really cold we are counterculture. 26 were able to hide pregnancy for longer 27 empathy, self compassion, and increased awareness and understanding of bigotry. 28 Fat Joy overcoming fat hate to live our lives minus shame. And, of course an FYI This isn't as isn't fat people are not a monolith. And so, not every fat person is going to experience all of these. I mean, I get cold. I mean, I do get fat. I do get I do get I do get hot, though.

Unknown Speaker 1:19:18

And, you know, all of these wouldn't be relevant to me, like I'm not going to be pregnant. And so this might not be every fat person's experience, but there's 28 things there that, you know, just off the top of the fat community's head that we've been managed managed to think of. And many many health benefits. And yeah, so the benefits of being fat are amazing. Fat people are really fucking cool and gorgeous, and worthy. And yeah, just fucking awesome. Okay, so oh my goodness, this episode has gone to one hour 20 minutes I was like, I'm just going to do a quick

Unknown Speaker 1:20:00

Every time I say this ad, which I'm just gonna do a quick episode, and then have some lunch, like and now it's 222 and I'm hungry. And you know what I've ordered for the first time in life I've ordered

Unknown Speaker 1:20:12

and table and chairs, table and chairs, kitchen table and chairs new in my whole life. I'm 37 I've always had used used and so I'm taking a step by step into adulthood and I bought a

Unknown Speaker 1:20:30

table and chairs from two different places not that you need new stuff to be an adult. But yeah, anyway the two chairs arrived on time and now the tables when it arrived day and then I got a message saying it's not gonna be here for two weeks and I had a kitchen table and chairs and I gave away to someone on Facebook Like as soon as the chairs arrived because the table is going to arrive like two days later. Now don't have a fucking table and I like eating my lunch at the table some some man because you know what if I sat on the sofa it feels like

Unknown Speaker 1:21:04

no longer work time like I'm no longer in the workday and then I'm like oh, just start to watch this and maybe I just watched you know, 90 day fiance before the 90 day is another episode.

Unknown Speaker 1:21:17

Yeah, so anyway, gonna go eat some lunch.

Unknown Speaker 1:21:22

And I'll see you in the next episode. Hope you enjoyed this. Have an amazing day of May

Unknown Speaker 1:21:32

thanks for listening to the episode and if you feel ready to get serious about this work and want to know when the doors open to fears fatti Academy which is my signature program, where I teach all about how to overcome your fat phobic beliefs and learn to love your fat body. Then go to fifth fatty.com forward slash waitlist again that is fierce fatty.com forward slash waitlist to get your name on the waitlist. For when first party Academy my signature program opens.

EP127 Transcript

You're listening to The Fierce Fatty Podcast. I'm your host, Vinny Welsby, episode 127: Funny ways I used to try and disguise my factors. Let's do it.

I'm Vinny Welsby, TEDx speaker, best-selling author, and fat activist. I have transformed my life from hating my body with desperately low self-esteem to being a courageous and confident fierce fatty who loves every inch of this jelly. Society teaches us living with a fat body is bad. But what if we spent less time, money, and energy on the pursuit of thinness and instead focused on the things that actually matter? Like if pineapple on pizza should be outlawed? Or if the mullet was the greatest haircut of the 20th century? So how do you stop negative beliefs about your fat body controlling your life? It's the Fierce Fatty Podcast. Let's begin.

Hey, guess what it hits? How I or if you don't have a ticket? sace what he nipples Oh, and if you do it was a sweaty just a sweaty? If you're not have sweat glands Hey, not sweating. When I get when how's life? Sorry, you were you were missing an episode last week.

I've been super duper busy with consulting stuff. Can tell consulting with companies and individuals and dieticians and it's all good. But you don't want to just too busy to do a podcast episode, which is not like me.

Noticing, like who's listening anyway, so it doesn't want anyone notice? And I thought you know? Yeah, I think someone will notice and be like, Oh, I thought that was an episode today. Where is it? I don't know. I get like that sometimes with my podcasts if they don't if they don't release an episode, but it takes me maybe like two or three weeks before they realize I haven't released that episode. And then we're like, where the fuck? Maybe I should do that. Just to just to? I don't know, give myself a break. Because maybe it's okay, if I don't do an episode every week? I don't know.

Yeah. And people do listen to the show. I keep going out with my mom. That lesson is not even my mom because she doesn't listen to podcasts. But people do listen to the show.

So, welcome to this episode. Hey, I thought of something. And thanks to one of the listeners who emailed me and said that they had listened to I guess it was the last last episode about weight loss surgery stories, part two. And they said, Oh, if you ever going to do a part three, I've got a story. And I thought, You know what, anytime I anytime I share anything about bariatric surgery, there's always so many stories, and they deserve to be heard. And a lot of times people have never had a place to share the stories. And so what I've done is I've created a Google form, the link will be in the show notes, the show notes are at face value.com forward slash, one to seven, forward slash one to seven, forget that forward slash podcast.

And there's a link there for you too. If you want to if you've had stomach amputation surgery, bariatric surgery, quote, weight loss surgery, if you're thinking about having it, if a loved one had it, and you have a story to tell, then go fill out this survey. I mean, it's like you know, this kind of like standards like

Where where are you? What's your name and things like that? And then I thought, You know what, it'd be really good if we get a lot of responses to have kind of like data of

Where Did you have surgery? What type of surgery? How old were you when you had the surgery? What was your life before and after? What made you have the surgery? Did you lose weight? How long did you lose weight for did you gain weight?

So all of the questions are apart from one or two. You can choose to answer them basically your name, you can choose to be anonymous. And do you agree for the information to be shared on the podcast or whatever, or some other way that I might share it

And you can choose just to share your story just so that I read it, or you can choose to share your story so others can read it.

Whatever you want, whenever you want. Because you know what this is making me think there's not a lot of, you know, I'm not a scientist, I'm not a sociologist. I have a degree in illustration. So totally unrelated to this stuff. But I think this collecting stories is, apart from that one study that I share, as you know, literally, it was just collecting stories, and it was kind of like a limited number of people because it's hard, right? If you don't, if you don't have a social media presence like I do, it's hard to collect people, like, if you were just to go out on the street and be like, Hey, who's had surgery, this surgery? Not a lot of people are gonna say, but because I have a lot of people in my audience who might have, then it's easier for me to collect this evidence. And who knows, you know, maybe no one will, maybe no one will respond to this survey, because people are like, I'm bored of it that I want to share my story. Or maybe you do.

And minimum, I'll maybe make another episode like part three. Or I was thinking maybe I can make it into like a big blog post or a book or something. It needs to be where we can get people the stories, right, because we've already got a few hours of stories. And, you know, because the more information out there, that is not pro bariatric surgery, I think it's going to balance it out a little bit. It'd be like a drop in the ocean, but you never know. It might be a good resource to share.

Yes. Okay. Sure. Sure. So the link for that is in my show notes, pHYs valley.com, forward slash, one, two silver, go for the out. If you've had surgery, somebody knows how to surgery and you've got something to say about it. As in my, someone had it and they died or whatever.

Or if you're thinking about it, because I think that'd be useful to be useful to.

Yeah, okay. So I've been thinking about this recently, ways, I used to just dry and disguise my fat nurse I had, I've spoken about it before, like 100 episodes ago, briefly. And it's been, I've been thinking about it recently. And it's kind of, you know, with love and compassion towards my previous video, you would do these things and some of the things that were really funny and, and the reason but you know, I'm like laughing about it. But obviously, the reasons behind why I would try to disguise my fatness in the past was because of the heartbreaking reality of living in a fat body in this society. I just had a swig of my tea. Don't you hate it when you have made a beautiful cup of tea, and you're like, Oh, I'm gonna fucking drink this shit out of it. And then you forget about it when you go and sip it and it's cold, I suppose just happened to me. Although I knew that this this was cold because I made it like two hours ago.

Anyway. So being young and super insecure and being fat, I used to think that I could disguise the fact that I was fat with visual illusions, trickery of the eyes and magic techniques. But I wasn't fooling anyone. I don't think maybe I don't know, maybe, maybe people saw me do the things that I was going to tell you that I did. And, and they were like, Whoa, what happened to them? They used to be so fat. Now. They're really high, maybe you maybe did a little bit and maybe it felt me to help me help help me feel better, which, you know, if it helped me feel better than good for good for me for coming up with a solution so that I could live life and sometimes, you know, this is kind of like when you're younger, some of the things that you think are just just silly, right? Like I was reading this meme of someone saying, what's the silliest thing that you used to believe as a child? And they said, I used to believe that anytime I turned the radio on, whoever was singing the song was singing it live in the radio studio. And it's like, you have one of those things. Yeah. And I think this kind of falls into my bit younger self

Not quite, you know, buying into beliefs that weren't I don't know, based in reality and it's kind of like have you ever seen if you're if you're not British you might not know this reference but Darren brown brown on Channel Four who was uh, I don't know if you call him or if he calls himself like an illusionist or he doesn't call himself a magician. He says like, this is like I'm, I'm, you know, this is like, I'm tricking you in some way. I'm influencing you in some way.

He must be around still wonder if he's done any good shows recently. British people are probably like, oh, it turned out that he was an abuser or something because he you know, some of these he's called a mentalist and illusionist, painter and author.

He started with his television debut, Darren brown mind control in 2000. Yeah, he was good. Doesn't look like he's turned out to be a creep. But he probably is. Who knows? Anyway.

He would like trick people and, you know, get things like oh, influence people to do things that they would never normally do. Like, there was one episode where it was like, he convinced people to rob a truck that had money. And he did like loads of stuff to kind of get them. They didn't know that they were going to do it. They were just walking down the street, a truck stopped in front of them. And they just robbed it. And then afterwards, he was like, Why did you do that? And they were like, I don't know.

Yeah, so a mentalist? an illusionist is what I was, what I was aiming for, by doing this stuff. So first thing that I used to do was, and I wonder how much of this stuff is you've done as well, some of this stuff is a bit weird. So I doubt that anyone else did it. But some of them stuff is pretty I think other people might have. And the first thing I would do is I would buy clothes, in sizes that were too small, even though they were like really, really tight on me, just in case, the label was to stick out of the back, you know, and someone would see it and see the label that says medium. And be like, oh my god Vinnies. So teeny, tiny, a medium, I thought that they were fat as fog. Turns out, they're wearing a medium. And you know, it'd be like a medium that I would have stretched to

I would sit in whatever top that I had bought that I bought deliberately too small, and sit for hours with two pillows, stuffed up the top to try and stretch it. So that it would not be cutting my body in half by how tight it was. But for hours walking around with to pillows in in for the off chance that someone might see the label. And do you remember, I don't know you might you still even might even be there of the label being such a powerful thing of What if someone sees my label and sees the size and I haven't thought about a label apart from today, in so long. And the only reason I thought about a label because I'm my underwear is quite small today. And there was a label for my trousers scratching my skin and I thought about the label. But I haven't thought about people seeing the size label on my clothes in a long time. But that used to be a big part of my life was clothing labels. And I'm so glad that you know because then if I did buy clothes that fit then you've bet your fucking now so I'm going to cut that label out because I don't want the anyone seeing I'm wearing you know, a 3x or whatever, when when I was younger. I'd be cutting that out and like burning it. No evidence of the fact that I'm fat.

But you know people have eyeballs and they could they could tell but yeah, that would be very, very kind of, yeah, get that get that label out. And now I'm so pleased. I don't know why because sometimes you wear something and you're like oh this is great. I really like it. And you look at the label and you're like oh where was it from? What size was it I don't know what size I am at this store because I cut the label out. Now I never have that. There it is right there label just hanging around. And I don't care if it sticks out.

So I used to always when I was a teenager

I thought that having big feet would balance my body out in some ways and I already have big feet. So I have UK size eight US size 10 And they're very wide. So rollerskating I'm going

rollerskating tonight I wear a size 12. So 10 Men's. That's how wide my feet are. And so I was like, whew, glad that I've got big feet, it's going to balance out my fatness. And so I would then go to I remember buying a pair of Reebok classics, two sizes too big. And proudly wearing them around school lower flopping around like clown shoes, thinking that people would be like, Oh my God, look at this illusion. Oh my god, they used to be so fat. Now look at the size of their shoes. They are a double zero.

Who knows? Maybe that did happen? I think more likely is that people will probably like what the fuck are you wearing your brother's trainers.

But that was only when I was a teenager because when I got a little bit older, so maybe like 20 years old, I decided that big feet were not actually a good idea.

Because big feet meant that I had a big body. So I wanted to have small feet. So I would do the opposite. I would be buying shoes that was smaller, to try and you know, cram my feet in. So that when men looked at my feet, they'd be like, oh, so petite and dainty. Look at you. If your feet are small, you can't possibly fat be fat. Wow.

Wow, look at them. My My Lord, the amount of times my feet have been in pain. I mean, how would they know? What you know what it is, is because you know, if you go into someone's house and you take your shoes off at the door, sometimes a shoe size is in the bottom thing. Some if someone saw that it was a size eight in the UK size 10 In the US, I would have been like, oh god mortified. And it's like all of these things on the off chance i Who's inspecting shoe sizes of their guests who have taking their shoes off at the door.

I know in my world in my world when I was young, I would you know just on the off chance. I will then be in terrible pain wearing the smaller shoes. Very logical. I would eat with a teaspoon instead of a normal sized spoon so that the food that I was eating would look smaller. And it would look like I was not eating a lot because I was taking teeny tiny bites because I'm so delicate and I'm not fat at all and I don't eat food. So everything would be small spoon. Everything. God's spaghetti bolognese, teaspoon.

Okay, no soup teaspoon. My goodness. Now, now I eat with a fucking ladle. The serving spoon. Oh, oh, that'd be good idea. I don't I just eat with a normal sized spoon. But that would be pretty good, wouldn't it? It would be like,

have you seen that meme where it's someone's in the gym. And they've they've taken they've got a Hershey's chocolate sauce bottle that they put water in and they're drinking out of it and it looks really funny. Like that go into like a restaurant and bringing out your own like ladle or something especially if it was like an all you can eat place. That would be pretty funny, wouldn't it?

And of course, I would do all the normal visual trickery, like not wearing stripes or wearing stuff that would cover my bum or you know, wearing black and all that type of stuff. Because you know, that's just you know, the standard obviously, it's just so funny. Like, I just think about it, you know, these rules that we have of don't wear horizontal stripes because then it's going to make you look a bigger

Unknown Speaker 19:14

unlike really really is it really really, really how I really read I don't look at people wearing I don't you doesn't even register in my mind. Maybe it doesn't other people's I don't know of like, oh, there's a person wearing horizontal stripes. Oh God now they look for at like, or, oh, there's someone who's not wearing black and they're fat. Oh God. Now I recognize that they're fat I was before if they were black clothes. I would have thought that they were thin. Like

Unknown Speaker 19:50

I don't know and and of course it's about like not drawing attention to yourself and all that type of stuff. But I don't these stupid rules, these silly rules that you know

Unknown Speaker 20:00

I guess some stylist made up in the 70s or whatever, you know, like don't wear tweed with with with this material and don't do that and wear your cufflinks like that. And all you know, it's just it feels very arbitrary, right? Because it's just made up. I don't think it's true. I don't think it's true. Is it true? I don't think it's true.

Unknown Speaker 20:23

And of course, I would squeeze my body into Spanx and Bice banks that were not the wrong size. Do you do have you done this? Do you do this? Don't buy Spanx that would fit and not kill you. Although it's probably still very squeezing but I would buy Spanx it was so

Unknown Speaker 20:42

ah, so small I can I literally have memories of how tight they would be on my ribcage until I pulled them up over and so that they sat under my boobs and then and then that was it. Like, that's, that's your that's your breathing done for the day, when you ain't gonna be breathing anymore. Never mind moving or eating or drinking. Because they were so tight. They had become basically sucked into your stomach wall lining. That's how small they were.

Unknown Speaker 21:17

And

Unknown Speaker 21:20

yeah, I just I, I think about this, you know? Why is it? Why is it when we look out fat bodies who have Spanx on or whatever, controlling underwear. And their fat is,

Unknown Speaker 21:34

is still there. But it's, it's, it's moved and sculpted. In a certain way. Why is that? Better than just

Unknown Speaker 21:47

no Spanx and just the body just being there? You know, it's like what why would people like what just is it just looks better? But God does it? Does it? I don't know. I think that that's that's another kind of made up thing social construct. Why is it that the big tits like you wouldn't think generally speaking, and this isn't for everyone with tits. But generally speaking, you wouldn't be like, I need to smooth out my tits to make them look less round and tit like, would you generally speaking obviously, there's lots of people who would be like, Yes, I do need to, you know, for various different reasons. But, you know, society doesn't say that. That's what I'm saying. Society doesn't say, Oh, God, you know, you haven't shaped that those unsightly round tits. And then why some why, you know, because

Unknown Speaker 22:47

patriarchy has said tits. Yeah, that sexy. We've decided the sexy move. Four inches around to your back, back rolls blue. No, gross. Oh, how can you go out with backroads?

Unknown Speaker 23:04

Shall we should cleavage? Yes. Please wear a backless dress. Oh, gross.

Unknown Speaker 23:11

And it's like, a few inches away. And it's still the human body. Like it doesn't. It doesn't make make it make sense. It doesn't make sense. It's just so made up. So why is it like, you know, a roll would look better if it was transformed into more of a sausage shape versus a croissant? undulating shape? Why is it that we want to see like I think about in nature, like a concrete slab versus a beautiful hill, or a rolling wave versus the sand and like, you know, the sand is beautiful. And the rolling wave is beautiful. And and why are we saying flat sand is is where it's at. And a rolling wave is ugly. Because it's Miller. We wouldn't think about that a lot about nature when we would just be like it's different. It's cool. We like it all, you know. So yeah, that's what I think about when I think about

Unknown Speaker 24:15

Spanx. Like

Unknown Speaker 24:18

I 1,000% get it and if it helps you feel okay to go out and fucking wear that shit. If that's okay with you do do it. Do what you want. And there's also reasons when people might be wearing shape

Unknown Speaker 24:30

underwear or whatever, whatever do you do? I'm just, it's just pure Rory also to my mind.

Unknown Speaker 24:41

of why, why?

Unknown Speaker 24:43

Why, why?

Unknown Speaker 24:46

What what you know, we know why fatphobia right.

Unknown Speaker 24:51

But it just seems so arbitrary, doesn't it? Now when you think about it, isn't it arbitrary? It's silly.

Unknown Speaker 25:00

You know, like I saw this surgery, you know, um, you know, I love watching this fucking dirty shit on on YouTube, you know, like ingrown toenails and corn removal and, you know, extracting dead spiders out of ear canals, all that type of stuff. Anyway, I saw this one where it was kind of like, surgery on someone's foot. Oh, interesting. Want to see. And I was like, Okay, what's his surgery? It was surgery to make this guy's toes.

Unknown Speaker 25:30

slightly shorter, one of one or two of them. Because apparently, they were too long. And it made them unsightly. They were not too long. I looked at his toes. And I looked at my toes. And I was like, Well, shit, my toes are the same. The same fucking thing. Hang on a minute. This is a new beauty ideal where we have to have toes that are these ones be short, these will be longer. And it has nothing to do with it when I was like in there must be a medical reason, right? Because who the fuck would have foot surgery where they are removing the length of his toe. Just for fun. He was doing it just for fun. Just because he wanted to have his toes. And it was millimeters. It wasn't like, oh, well now laksa sexy toe. It was just his toe. Like three millimeters shorter. Bizarre, like what what is going on? What is going on in the world? And so yeah, like we think about that like well, you know, you can say that silly why would why would he put himself in pain and probably cost money right? Obviously you're not going to just get that on the on the NHS you know, toe

Unknown Speaker 26:50

unless you've got them at wrong your toes anyway. And so it's just really it's just arbitrary. But then again if we lived in a world where everyone was like oh look at these sexy new toes and oh my god you know when you're talking about the dream guy that you want to day in New like tall dark and and short toes aren't really does it for me? Oh, it's fucking stubby toes. Oh, look at them toes. Oh, how big is toes girl? Oh, those shorten love it. Like if we lived in a society like that, then I would get it so you know, all this stuff. Don't feel bad. If you're doing any of this stuff. I doubt people are eating the small spoons, but you know, or wearing clown shoes. Whatever, even if you are don't feel bad for doing this stuff.

Unknown Speaker 27:36

So a big part of this stuff too was obviously about being hyper feminine. Hyper feminine. So the kind of like, if I'm feminine, that makes up for my fatness, you know, like the whole, dainty and you know fatness isn't dainty, therefore, femininity is dainty, therefore, aligned with femininity,

Unknown Speaker 28:01

and you'll appear less fat.

Unknown Speaker 28:06

And I want you to maintain his feminine image at time at all times. To Great detriment to myself a lot of times.

Unknown Speaker 28:16

Like, you know, wearing high heels

Unknown Speaker 28:21

Have you ever worn high heels? They fucking suck. Who has ever worn high heels and said this is a great experience. I mean, who are those people? What What have they done to the what is happening like because I don't think anyone has has worn high heels and being like, this is my preferred, comfortable shoe. You know, no one's walking up my mountains wearing fucking Malone Malone Malone no Blahnik below No, Manolo Manolo Manolo Blahnik or a Lubert home are they? No, because they were uncomfortable, comfortable.

Unknown Speaker 29:02

But that didn't matter to me, because, of course, I had a job and it meant that I had to wear high heels in my brain that I don't think there was any rules about wearing high heels but in my brain, you know, have to wear high heels look sexiest possible.

Unknown Speaker 29:20

And I just remember

Unknown Speaker 29:22

many times being miserable because of the pencil suit splits pencil skirt suit that I was wearing made for a tween had no stretch. My high heels, my, you know my hair that was done and I can't get it wet. And when I first came to Vancouver, I was working for a recruitment agency. I'd be going out and visiting clients all the time around the Vancouver area. I didn't have a car. I was getting on the bus. And I'd be bringing client gifts and like boxes of donuts and things like that all on the bus and a lot of these clients were in industrial parks.

Unknown Speaker 30:00

where I had to get to even three buses to get to them. And all while teetering on high heels with my pencil skirt suit, which actually did look really nice. It was really nice had like this like, frilly thing on the bottom, that flouncy thing anyway, whatever.

Unknown Speaker 30:20

And

Unknown Speaker 30:22

it would then be like if it was raining, walking in high heels, skirt, Sue

Unknown Speaker 30:29

boxer doughnuts, handbag,

Unknown Speaker 30:34

literature on the company, and an umbrella walking through industrial estates. I don't know if you've been in a lot of illustrious days, most of them don't have sidewalks because every motherfucker drives to them because who's gonna get the bus?

Unknown Speaker 30:49

Because they're so far away. Some people do. And I was one of the one of those people and they're arriving to the clients just be like,

Unknown Speaker 30:57

you know, and being drenched and freezing and soaking. And one time I remember having to like walk through mud, and get into the clients and being like, you're wet. And he's like, Oh, you must have like, got wet walking from your car. And I was like, yeah, yeah, walking from my car, not walking 15 minutes from the bus stop after getting 17 buses after carrying all of these things. And this one time having like two different client meetings and having to get lots of buses and then just being miserable it feet soaked blisters. And getting to I had to get had to get two buses to get home. And getting getting off the first the first bus to get to the second bus and the second bus was just there. And it was parked lights off. But would open the doors when people would come.

Unknown Speaker 31:47

presumed it was gonna be waiting there. So I casually strolled up to it. Maybe took 12 seconds. And the guy saw me coming, turned on the lights turned on the engine and just drove off. While I was like, Don't go, I just burst out into tears because I was just so done with it. Because then it meant I had to walk home because it's because the buses were not frequent from that area. So I had to walk, walk home. All of this shit like fucking now was awful. It was awful. Anyway, so it's like that was like a great detriment to me. I could have just put on a pair of trainers while if I didn't I don't know. I guess I couldn't have them in my hide them in my, in my handbag.

Unknown Speaker 32:31

Yeah, so

Unknown Speaker 32:34

it's like such a traumatizing story. I just remember it so clearly.

Unknown Speaker 32:39

Yeah, and I think like, you know, wanting to pay a pair small and feminine. Like I remember kissing a guy who was a couple of inches shorter than me. I don't know if you've ever done this, contorting my body to try and make me look shorter. So when he was kissing me, I'd be like

Unknown Speaker 32:55

contorting my waist so that my body would go into a shoe you know, I'd be a shorter height by three centimeters or whatever. So he'd be like, Oh my God, they're so sure therefore they're feminine. Therefore, they're not fat.

Unknown Speaker 33:10

Yes, I would also behave in ways to try and make up for my fatness. So things like

Unknown Speaker 33:17

eagerly sucking men's smelly Dix which they hadn't washed in 14 days to prove that even though I was fat, I was willing and eager. Don't mind this magma I'm gonna gobble it up Oh.

Unknown Speaker 33:35

Grows

Unknown Speaker 33:38

am of course never, ever respect expecting anything back from them. No, of course not. Don't be silly.

Unknown Speaker 33:47

And do things like not speaking up for myself or putting up with any ship friends and, and relationships and

Unknown Speaker 33:54

shit bosses? Oh, my goodness.

Unknown Speaker 33:59

And looking back now like some of those things are pretty hilarious. But at the time, I was doing my best, right? Poor Vinny.

Unknown Speaker 34:09

And the reason of course, I was engaging in that magical thinking of if I do this, and this will happen is, you know, and trying to be the next David Copperfield. hiding my fat noses because being fat was is

Unknown Speaker 34:23

very difficult and painful in this world. So if I could get a little bit of

Unknown Speaker 34:30

relief by eating with a teaspoon, and never drinking from a pint glass, because a pint glass was

Unknown Speaker 34:43

too masculine for a dainty dainty little thing like me, I'd have a cocktail or a glass of wine, even though I hate wine.

Unknown Speaker 34:52

Yeah, so

Unknown Speaker 34:55

it makes sense. It makes

Unknown Speaker 34:58

sense that we

Unknown Speaker 35:00

would do this because the world

Unknown Speaker 35:08

but the reality the reality, the reality is, of course it's okay to be fat. In fact, I think it's super cool. I think being fat is like we're in this club of really cool. counterculture people. And

Unknown Speaker 35:27

it's unique and fun and Yeah. And there's lots of fat joy and, and we don't see this right, like, obviously when we're young, we see fatness as this thing that's going to destroy our lives, it means that we're not going to never gonna have sex with anyone or be loved or, or be romanced or be happy or or any of that. Basically, we have, we've got no life ahead of us because of the fat of because of fatness. And that's because that's a message that society present it to us. But what if we had been presented with fat joy? And of course, there were probably moments where we saw fat joy, and we saw fatness as a either neutral thing or a positive thing. But you know, that was probably one out of the every every 10,000 messages that we've got that fatness was this life ending condition that we need to to

Unknown Speaker 36:31

get convinced others of our humanity.

Unknown Speaker 36:36

Yeah, so.

Unknown Speaker 36:39

So maybe now we know No, I'm 37 I, you know, I can be fat joy for other people to see younger people to see and be like, Oh, that's more fat Joy looks like maybe if I am fat, maybe I don't. I can have a life. You know, maybe I can be happy and be loved and accepted and, and, and also the world has shipped but you know, it's not because of my fatness that I'm bad, but you know, the world is the world's perception of my fatness.

Unknown Speaker 37:18

Oh, silly, silly, silly little Vinny. Another thing I used to do is do you remember when do you remember when it was like I was like a rocker when I was a kid. And I wanted you know, when it was really fashionable to have a long belt baggy jeans and a long belt. The longer the belt that's hanging out from your hoodie, the better. I couldn't find any belt to fit me nevermind a belt that had extra length. And so I would take a belt and just put it through like two loops not do it up. And so the belt was just literally hanging off a couple of loops. And then it'd be like this long belt that's just hanging down. The belt was not doing any belt duties. It was just hanging there. So people so people would think that my waist was so tiny. The longer the dangly bit of the bell, the tiny of the waist. So people would be like, Oh, tiny waist. Look at the tiny waist and how long my belt is it's touching the floor. They must be too tiny.

Unknown Speaker 38:21

Yeah. Also, because because I was poor, I made myself a belt out of a washing line. Yes, so washing line. And I put some beads on it. And it was very, very proud of it, went to the clubs, or went to the club busy with human adults and showed off my belt that I had made out of a washing line. And washing line like the line The line that you use to hang clothes.

Unknown Speaker 38:55

I remember even and I was genuinely proud of it. I remember even and it wasn't that. Oh, you know, it actually looked really good. But people were being classist. No It looked fucking like a washing line. I remember going up to some like guy that I wanted to get where the mainland 30 Like my bell and him like inspecting it being like, a washing line. And me being like, yeah, spray collars.

Unknown Speaker 39:21

And then him saying no. Beeping like what? And I doubted myself then I doubted myself and was like, oh, maybe it's not cool. And I just you know I'm changing my mind. It was cool. You were you were rocking it. You looked so amazing, Vinnie.

Unknown Speaker 39:39

God, I also had a gap hoodie, which was it was so expensive. I remember even at the time it was like 46 pound or something. My right. Like it's so expensive. I kept the price tag because I was like, I made 30 pound a week.

Unknown Speaker 40:00

Working in a bakery part time and it was a week and a half's wages to buy this gap hoodie because everyone was wearing gap hoodies and I obviously it was something that would fit me because I'm the common man sizes right and I would wear this gap hoodie and I had stickers over the gap and the stickers red greasy and proud.

Unknown Speaker 40:24

Greasy and proud. What the fuck was I thinking and this was my method to try and pull boys I like young man is just not my fucking you know statement about being greedy oh

Unknown Speaker 40:46

my goodness

Unknown Speaker 40:52

Genovese awesome teenager now with

Unknown Speaker 40:55

the gap hoodie with stickers over the gap saying greasy and you'd be like What the fuck is

Unknown Speaker 41:03

What do you mean greasy and proud and it wasn't like I was greasy? I wasn't a greasy but it wasn't that wasn't a trait of mine being greasy. But apparently I wanted to people why why I want people to think that I was greasy and proud about it. I don't know

Unknown Speaker 41:23

if you are Gracie go for it but I just white

Unknown Speaker 41:31

and change my Instagram bio to greasy

Unknown Speaker 41:37

what a ding dong

Unknown Speaker 41:41

made me greasy and proud. The washing line bell and then clown Reebok classics down at the club. Desperate to pull any boy

Unknown Speaker 41:55

every like shit pickup lines. Oh my goodness, I would I had a pair of like Toy handcuffs. And I would hang cough I remember handcuffing a boy that I made out with and was like

Unknown Speaker 42:09

to stay with me all night now.

Unknown Speaker 42:14

Like what? We're talking about creepy. Um, anyway, sending love to teenage Vinny sending love to your teenage self. Whatever you did. If you did anything silly, I'd love to hear tell me to send me an email Tell me about it.

Unknown Speaker 42:35

Give me a give me a laugh. Give me a lof and yeah, thanks for hanging out today.

Unknown Speaker 42:43

If you want to fill out the survey about the if you've had stomach surgery, go to the link in the bio one to seven fatty.com forward slash one to seven or four slash podcast and and if you're feeling like it and you enjoy the show, if you want to make a review on iTunes, not iTunes i Tunes then I will be very happy. It will make me so happy

Unknown Speaker 43:16

and it will help other people find the show.

Unknown Speaker 43:19

So that more than my mum listens to it, even though she doesn't listen to it rude.

Unknown Speaker 43:27

So see you next week in a while. Alligator stay fierce fatty. Goodbye

Unknown Speaker 43:38

thanks for listening to the episode and if you feel ready to get serious about this work and want to know when the doors open to fears fatti Academy which is my signature program, where I teach all about how to overcome your fat phobic believes and learn to love your fat body. Then go to first fatty.com forward slash waitlist again that is first fatty.com forward slash waitlist to get your name on the waitlist. For when first party Academy my signature program opens.

EP126 Transcript

You're listening to The Fierce Fatty Podcast episode 126, Stories from Weight Loss Surgery Survivors Part 2. I'm your host, Vinny Welsby. Let's do it

I'm Vinny Welsby, TEDx speaker, best-selling author, and fat activist. I have transformed my life from hating my body with desperately low self-esteem to being a courageous and confident fierce fatty who loves every inch of this jelly. Society teaches us living with a fat body is bad. But what if we spent less time, money, and energy on the pursuit of thinness and instead focused on the things that actually matter? Like if pineapple on pizza should be outlawed? Or if the mullet was the greatest haircut of the 20th century? So how do you stop negative beliefs about your fat body controlling your life? It's the Fierce Fatty Podcast. Let's begin.

Hello, and welcome to this podcast episode. Welcome to new listeners. Old listeners. Medium listeners. Are you doing how's life? I'm feeling fair to middlin Fair to middling today. Because Because Because Because Because because I had four fillings yesterday. Oh, boys dead for feelings. But feelings are normally All right. All right, but that I had one in my not the two front teeth. The one to the side is that the canine another one in front of the canine. I had a feeling though when I was like 15. And so it's been 22 years in there. And so they replaced it and they have to put the injection kind of up, up. Not Pinos. But it kind of feels like that. And I traumatize me when I was a kid, that was my first ever feeling. I'd had plenty of like injections before because I'd had like loads of teeth out for braces. But that was the first time anything at the front. And it was it's painful. It's like that's not what that's not fun. Although like the pain only lasts for 10 seconds. So I wish I could have just told myself like, because I remembered as being a kid and having this and single solitary tear rolling down my cheek from the pain of it. And exactly the same thing happened to single solitary tear around down my cheek from the pain of it, but it wasn't as bad because it's now Manado and I was doing like breathing techniques and whatnot. Anyways, so this is your reminder to go to the dentist that was from me not going to the dentist for two years when I was in Ireland. Because I was like Ah, okay, you know, I'm in Ireland, I'm going to be leaving soon any day now then a pandemic pandemic happened and so I didn't go to the dentist materials. And for fillings district show for it. Thank you very much teeth, but also genetics. You know, some people have harder teeth. I'm using the word harder. That's not a word that dentists use, but some people just don't get feelings right. Or decay or whatever. You're lucky motherfuckers but I'm one of the people that do about you know, whatever. So I don't know if I told you about me reading this book the tragedy tragedy tragedy. Tragic tragedy, tragedy. Tragedy of heterosexuality by Jane Ward, author of not gay, and I just finished reading it a couple of days ago and it's fucking good. Oh my glob, the tragedy of heterosexuality talks about well let me go to the contents page let's call it what it is a tragedy had had her sexuality sexuality. He's just not that into you. The misogyny paradox? Pickup Artists inside the inside the seduction industry. A sick and boring life queer people diagnosed the tragedy, deep heterosexuality towards a future in which straight men like women so much that they actually like women.

So we're talking about like, the heterosexual repair industry talks about how in the past we're all very much more gayer in society, obviously Before white people came along and said it was bad, white people are the worst. And so, women were with women a lot more men were men a lot more. And so when we decided this was a bad thing, and people said, Listen, you need to be with the opposite sex. men weren't really into it. And so neither were women. And, and so they kind of had to be coached into dealing with each other. You know? Yeah. And how, you know, like, with straight people, there's a lot of kind of, when I get married, all the old ball and chain all my life's over now and people say, you know, I hate my husband and always say that he's the worst, He's so annoying. And, and that's not a lot of what happens in queer relationships. And a lot of times women are be treated like a being being abused and treated terribly. And, and being told that they need to adhere to certain rules. Like, if we think about, they talk about men are from Mars, Women are from Venus. Fuck, and I loved that book when I was when I was like, 15. I, that was the first book I ever bought, with my pocket money. I could catch me a man was men are from Mars, Women are from Venus. And I was like, I'm sure I've got the Bible now. Now, and I had to talk to men. And I have to let them be in their cave and lalalalalala. And it's all total bullshit, right? And yeah, pickup artist stuff. I'm so interested by Pickup Artists stuff. Because it's in the book, Jane talks about how how a lot of them are just are just kind of lonely guys, and they are struggling to talk to women. And really, what they need is confidence boosting and the new modern way of pickup artists stuff is a lot of the more modern pickup artists talk about boosting men's confidence so that they can talk to women. And then previously, it was a lot more shady kind of like how to neg women and how to trick them into having sex with you, basically. But yeah, but there was still lots of creepy guys at these conferences who are like, I'm just here to get some high quality policy. Oh, lovely. Yeah, and then ending with like deep, deep heterosexuality is where if you really do love women, men, if men really do love women, then they will love everything about them. And they will seek out womanhood in all its forms, like they'll seek seek out women, women authors and women, content creators and listen to women and all that type of stuff. So that's kind of like deep heterosexuality, where, you know, they actually like the look of women, as women versus women as these shaved and slimmed down and died. And, you know, all of these versions of women that we've been told, is the standard of beauty. So yeah, really interesting book. Really interesting. And one thing about it was, though, like, like, she talks about fat stuff, she mentioned fat people, not in depth, but because it's a book about, about straightness, but she does talk about how fat folks are marginalized.

And she talks about how in the queer community, different types of bodies, old bodies, fat bodies, disabled bodies, are often not always, obviously, there's tons of fat phobia and all sorts of bigotry in all communities. But a lot of times the way that we look at the way that the queer community lesbians by folk pansexual people will look at women is more kind of accepting and valuing those traits, which are just natural to human bodies. And there's a snippet here from written. She's taken it the author's taken it from Audrey Lords book zombie. It's just like just a little clip here. I just want to share with you, which was nice about the It was a way that she Audrey Lord viewed her fat lover and her fat body. So, Audrey Lord examI reverently describes ginger, her first lover as gorgeously fat with an open knowledge about her body's movement that was delicate and precise. She had pads of fat firm fat above her thighs and round dimpled knees loving ginger that night was like coming home to a joy I was meant for and I really loved that because it reminds me of the need I might do I might do an episode on this the need to hear fatness in that way, because we talk a lot about how fatness is an attractive and people don't like fat bodies, but there are millions of people out there who are thirsty for fat bodies. And and we need to hear those stories and not the creepy people, people who can see that fat person as a whole person. But it was it was really nice. It was really nice. There here's another little quote here about an old old woman, Sherry mulgara. Two desires a woman with age accomplishment of Elena, the woman she lusts for Moraga states, I am ready for you now. I want age, knowledge, your body that still after years withholds and surrenders keeps me there waiting, wishing, willing, willing to feel this time what disrupts in me, girl, woman, child boy, willing to embody what I will in the space of her arms. And the author continues lesbian feminist desire in these accounts is defined not purely by to women's sexual attraction to each other. But by a quality of desiring women in which the objects of one's lust are women's complexities and accomplishments, both corporeal and otherwise, the best women lovers have the scars to hunger, the weight, the teeth, and the political and sexual experience that allows them to know and harness their erotic will through Lord desiring gays, Audrey Lorde physical features that are often cast as de erotica sizing. imperfections in the straight world are remade into sites of pleasure. Yeah, so I just love that I thought that was beautiful. And something that we don't talk about a lot about how we a lot of the times we view fatness through the male gaze, right? And actually the world shouldn't evolve around what sis hat men want and desire. But, and that as fact. And even if we do look at what purses hit men desire, what is going on? And like, where is that coming from? How were they influenced? Do we want to buy into those? Those very limited definition of desire. I mean, to me, it's just very boring, isn't it? Whereas queerness in all its forms. It just feels so free. In in contradiction to that. So anyway, now this episode, we are going to kind of continue on where we left off in episode one to two you don't have to have listened to one to two, which was stories from weight loss survivors eight year years post surgery if you want to go quick link to get there. It's just base fatty.com forward slash 122 To listen to that episode. You don't need to but in that episode I talk talk about more complexities in regards to maybe Why people do have the surgery and why they're not to blame? People who choose to do it, there's it's a very complex thing and all that type of stuff.

So if you want more of that kind of context, then go back to that you don't have to. But there is that an a giant trigger warning here, because we're going to be talking about death, bad health outcomes, and general or full fat hate. And so if you're not feeling that today, then skip the episode because I'm going to be reading the comments on my Instagram post. So I made an Instagram post about the episode. And I shared a couple more stories. And it came like they're 70 comments just on that. And then there's comments on the other posts I made around this too. And people just felt like it just an outpouring of this, here's my story, and I've not had anywhere to share it, and no one's listening to me. And they were so effecting to me and written like reading them, there's so many of them. It's like holy shit. And I think it was nice for folks who have experienced that to know that they're not alone, that their body isn't bad or wrong or hurt, or they've done something wrong to deserve these outcomes. Even though it is very, very painful to hear it and see it and all that type of stuff. So yeah, so take care of yourself. If you just left, it doesn't feel like a good time to listen to this. And even if you do stick around at any point, if this feels like too much, then feel free to pause the episode. And afterwards, perhaps give yourself a little bit of TLC because, you know, I'm not going to be reading 70 comments I'm going to be reading maybe, I don't know, 20 fives, maybe a little bit more. Yeah, so yeah, so let's, let's read these. Now, in the post that I made. I'll link to in the show notes. The show notes for this is facebook.com forward slash 126, if you want to share, but I added in a couple more stories from from people on Instagram, because I was talking about this in my stories. And Becky from Becky Barnes blog, messaged me and said, yeah, oh my god, like, this is my experience. And I thought, you know, this is another important story that needs to be shared. And so I summarized it in in a in this post here. And this is what Becky says, My GP didn't really understand the procedure. And when I fell pregnant 13 years ago, there were no support, there was no support whatsoever. I had to rely on common threads from America, where there were a little more where there was a little more shared knowledge and experience. I was incredibly ill during pregnancy. And it's only now that I realized that my baby was taking the nutrients they needed to survive, leaving me on empty. The whole thing is a mess. I'm astounded, it's still deemed a positive process procedure. The damage and stress it has caused me will stay with me for the rest of my life. I was 27 when I had it. I'm chronically vitamin deficient. I have IBD, which the gastro team confirmed is greatly aggravated by the gastric bypass. I'm constantly in pain, tired, and generally a bit of a miserable bastard. To be honest. I tried to crack on with life, but it's had such a huge impact on my daily life. So that's Becky from the UK. Caitlin on underlay at reframe your story. Talks about both both people talk about this on their accounts. This is what Caden says. There was no part of me that made the decision to have weight loss surgery from a place of self love. It came from a came from deep self hatred and longing to be accepted. I told myself it didn't have to do with weight loss. It was about my health. I thought I was a ticking time bomb. And that if I stayed in this body, it would be it would inevitably lead me to health issues. I thought it was only a matter of time. When the majority of society views your body as part of an epidemic and a strain on society, it makes sense that a person would want to change that. So people make the decision to have stomachs banded, amputated, and rerouted, they are encouraged by doctors and other professionals to put a permanent physical restriction on themselves.

The most sick part of this is that I knew and wanted there to be pain if I ate one bite too many, so I had to face the consequences of living in my body. The true consequences of all this and, and a lifetime of being told my body was wrong, was falling deeper into my eating disorder behaviors. And for that I was praised. So that's Caitlin on delay at reframe your story. Now I'm going to read comments on the post, some of them Okay, so, for years, every single one of my doctors suggested that I have weight loss surgery. I have started the process twice and something never sat well with me about it. I watched friends grow through the pre surgical requirement of losing a bit of weight prior having surgery getting ill or differently. As a result, losing weight, gaining weight, mentally struggling with feelings of failure, and deep shame. I refused multiple times. When I was 37. I learned that I learned that I have a fat disorder, lipo edema, late stage three that causes non metabolic fibrotic fat lobules to fill my arms and legs. These cannot be dieted or exercised away. Many undiagnosed and diagnose lipo edema patients have weight loss surgery, lipo edema remains, the legs will remain large sometimes and their midsections get very small. If they also have it on the arms like I do, then their arms will be a bit larger to one in 11 women and people assigned female at birth were born with lipid edema. Even more important is that a good number of those people who also have hyper mobile, Ehlers Danlos Syndrome, often a comorbidity of like edema, and other connective tissue disorder, eds can present with digestive issues. What cannot be determined with any accuracy is how much of a person's body consists of metabolic fat and lipid Dima, when weight loss surgery is suggested to someone who doesn't know they have lipo edema, it can be physically mentally and emotionally devastating. Yes. And this comment made me think of pale ginger pear, who's someone that I follow on Instagram pale ginger, pear, and she too had gone through the experience of being told to that she needed to obviously lose weight. And she has like edema and a doctor I think I'd know I don't know but there's a medical team that's that's doing surgeries for because it it needs to be removed. Right the because it's it's not something that is you know, it's a genetic thing right and it people really struggle with it. And obviously don't want to say it needs to be removed depending on on how much it affects someone. It can be removed and that taken away and pale ginger pear shares that journey on her Instagram. Now trigger warning for that is that there may be some feelings that come up of she looks quote better now that she has a smaller body due to these surgeries. So if that's not feeling good for you, then you know maybe skip that but if you think that you might have lymphedema and you want to learn more, or if you do then that's a page for you. Okay, so next next comment. So after listening to this, I would say this made me feel very anxious the idea of making people purge on purpose felt very violent.

And yes, me being from Finland, the Nordic countries are so deeply fat phobic. This is pushed for free and celebrated in our national news media. I can't seem to shake the feeling of horror and violence from these stories. This very literally hurts. Yeah. Next comment, my dad just died due to bariatric surgery that went wrong. I'm on a plane to go help plan his funeral. People need to know how dangerous As it is, and that's a big side that we don't hear is the family of those who have died due to their surgery. Because they know they're probably not in the same communities, they probably don't know where to go to talk about this often or you know. And people will probably say to them, wow, they were they were gonna die from being fat anyway, or something like that. And so having a place to talk about this stuff, where it's free from judgment is is really important and resource for family members who, who are suffering through the loss of a loved one due to this barbaric thing. Next comment, I definitely developed an eating disorder from my VSG. So VSG is a type of bariatric surgery. I don't regret it necessarily. But I wish I knew what I know. Now before I did it.

Yeah, so not everyone regrets getting surgery that those cases are kind of few and far between.

Next comment, these stories are very familiar and so sad. I had my bypass in 2013. And I was died, I was denied fertility treatment until my BMI was below X. I went from BMI of x to x within a year and the fertility treatment didn't work. So she went from this person went from a BMI that was higher than what they asked for, to lower than underneath the cut off point. Well underneath a cutoff point, and the treatment didn't work. I'm now in early menopause and have gone back to a BMI of the amount that before the cutoff. There's no research about men about menopause after weight loss surgery, none. My doctors didn't know what to do. And my surgeon told me to get over it. It's fucked up. Yeah, so you know, getting pregnant. If someone is struggling with getting pregnant, and are seeking fertility treatments, it's sad. To me, it seems counterintuitive, intuitive that they would make that person go through weight loss, whether on their own or this surgery, which just you're putting your body in a crisis mode of like, your body's like, What the fuck, like, give me some food. We're in crisis, we don't know what's going on. And so it's not setting you up to be able to get pregnant, like your body is not in this this best place. If you want to learn more about this and the whole kind of bullshit around fertility, and that stuff, go check out Nicola salmon, fat positive fertility, on Instagram Nicola salmon, fat positive fertility, on Instagram, she's got a book, you can go read that. And she's great. You like everything that you've heard about, you know, like you can't be can't be fat and pregnant. And if you're fat and pregnant, then you're you know, you're putting your baby at risk and all that type of stuff. She breaks down that stuff. And it's like, oh, surprise, surprise. It's It's not based it you know, it's not it's not it's not what we've been led to believe. You know? Okay, next comment. I had it. August a few years ago. First, you have to do a liquid only diet, in my case, one week before surgery, and one week post op, followed by one week soft food only, and that, in my opinion, messed with my already fractured relationship with food. I initially lost X amount of pounds, and then proceeded to gain it all back and more. I struggled to struggle to ever feel mentally satisfied with food, where I could feel that easier before. I can only eat a little at a time compared to before, but it hasn't magically made me thin just dissatisfied with meals and easily over fooled to the point of throwing up and often. I had zero so called comorbidity morbidities I did my best to convince myself it was better for my health, even though I was already healthy. What I personally really wanted was to be accepted or loved by society and myself. I wanted to quote look better All my doctors knew I had no comorbidities but they wanted me smaller and I did too. They ripped out over half my healthy stomach in the name of health. Now my disordered eating is worse. I throw it regularly and I have chronic heartburn for what? Huh? I just really I feel a really feel the anger in that and the frustration and the for what? Yeah, for what? Yeah. Okay. Next, my sister had the guy who got the gastric bypass about 13 years ago. Last year she needed a liver transplant because of it. She does not drink alcohol. We found out after her liver failed that studies have shown people who have GB gastric bypass have a higher correlation to liver failure not caused by alcohol. Yep. And and and and studies show that there's a higher rate the higher likelihood that someone who's going to be struggle with with alcohol.

And as we saw in previous stories, because some people say like it's just easier to drink alcohol than it is to eat food. And then you get into that pattern. Next story, I got told today by my doctor that she recommends this surgery for me, other than a high BMI I have no medical issues, blood pressure, blood sugars, everything is normal. I feel very surprised and overwhelmed. I didn't go to my appointment to talk about weight and I left in tears. Yeah. I wonder you know, like they I wonder how often doctors get kind of, yeah, they get more money they do and not in all countries, but just to write a note saying counseled on weight. And if they get a kickback if they refer to the surgeries or not. I know with my my doctor, it's so annoying, like in England with repeat prescriptions. You have these prescriptions and you just call the doctor and say can you fill my prescription call the reception and they'll say yet done and you don't have to see the doctor because it's like prescriptions that you've been having for years. Like I've had prescriptions since I was a child and yet every time I need to refill and they only give me three months of the drugs I have to make an appointment with a doctor so that then she can get the I guess the the consult fee and that's just the way it is it's just such a waste of my time their time it's just ridiculous. It was like what do you need this There we go. And they take it Chica check a box. Right. And I wonder they do obviously as well get in some countries. If you check a box saying counseled on wait, so why wouldn't they? I mean, unless they want to be ethical and be kind to patients. Why wouldn't they? And and you know every country is different but looking at you, America, United States. Okay, next, I had my gastric sleeve done Jan 2021. As a last ditch attempt to save my liver. I have a rare reaction to birth control pill and ended up in acute liver failure. While I'm glad the surgery saved me it caused me a great deal of distress and complications. I now have good get dizzy easily. I shoot myself on occasion feel tired and weak a lot of the time and will have to take a mountain of pills every day until I die. I experienced hunger so intense that it would wake me up at night due to the pain. Yeah, being able to wear standard size tops and dresses make my life more convenient and I feel less judged in public but the bariatric community I've been in has been extremely toxic or toxic and the whole experience will likely take years to fully process. I strongly believe that bariatric surgery is overprescribed and that patients are rarely prepared for how these procedures will wholly affect them moving forward.

I wonder how. What was the connection between having liver failure and having the surgery? I'm curious about that. Yeah. I had the sleeve six months ago and admittedly no complicated. shouldn't but I wish I'd had it years ago, I feel a million times better. It is sad to see how different I've been treated though, compared to when I was heavier.

Yeah, so and that's, that's one of the sad realities, right? Of being in a marginalized group and then moving into a group, who is who are privileged being straight sized. That's really sad to see how it was just body size that's, that saw people treating you differently. And this person is six months out, and hopefully, they're there. They have community around them and support because, as we know, in the last episode, as we know, that two years to five years, same with diets is when things start going tits up, that's when people start putting weight on through no fault of their own. And, yeah, and that's where study stop. You know, we don't have studies long term studies. So, yeah. This one comment says, I had it at 13 Thank you for this 13 Can you imagine like it because your body your you know, your body is growing? What at that severe lack of of nutrients is doing to a growing body? And ah, can you my eyes just can't even imagine. Next comment is interesting reading this, I'm in the US and the surgeries are more are very common here. People are shocked when I say I'm scared of doing the surgeries and all the complications problems after they have no idea that there are so many, even people who have had the surgery act surprised and they're like, I don't have issues. I answer, really, you don't have malabsorption issues. You don't struggle with your weight. And there'll be like, Well, yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah. Yeah, it's almost kind of like, wow, I guess for to be thin. Some folks will be like, well, you know, if you had asked me in the past, what would you give to be thin? I would give a lot. And so maybe to some people, these issues are worth it. Because they are now in a privileged group that is so valuable to them. And I mean, that not saying that's right or wrong? Because being in a marginalized group is difficult. Very difficult. So, I mean, for some people, it's worth it. You know, and obviously, we don't know what's going to happen to each person individually. When they have surgery, you could be one of the people that that you'll say, oh, yeah, I'm fine. I can deal with the Malibu malabsorption absorption and I can deal with this and I can deal with shit and myself. And that's not a big deal for me. Or you could be one of the people who dies. Next story. My dad had essentially a gastric bypass as treatment for stomach cancer. He had no other treatment, just that it was horrendous. He lost about half of his body weight. His quality of life suffered immensely, and so did mine and my mum's. Of course, we were just happy his cancer was gone. But if it had been something he had just decided to do, because because he was fat, I would have a massive amount of resentment, resentment towards him now. That's tough. Next, I had gastric bypass and it's such a big deal and people don't realize that likely not able to eat certain foods for life. Gallbladder problems, kidney stones. Now I'm having to navigate insurance changes with bariatric surgeons who I'm still required to see. It's so heavy and so hard. Yeah, I had my gallbladder out and so I can tell you a gold stuck gallstones. That is no fun. No fun at all.

Getting a gallstone attack is awful. Next, love this being voiced. This is something I'm hoping to study in my own country, as I have had this experience of walking into the doctor's office with a lump in my armpit and having been offered to surgery instead, nobody ever bothered with with said lump. Now this idea and treatment messed me up, the doctor was super excited about getting to enroll me in this. They had new funding and everything feels like the Nordic countries are particularly grim in their systemic fat hate. I hope this surgery gets banned eventually, it is violence in my book. And at the end of today's episode, we're actually going to hear from a bariatric surgeon to see what they think. Hint, it's bullshit. Yeah, next, I want the surgery because the impact of impact my weight has on my disability and because my disability causes me to gain weight easily, I'm losing my independence. But I'm so scared of messing up my already on the edge of body sad face. Yeah, this is I think this is really important to voice here. Because seeing kind of like the lose lose situation that some people are struggling with, have. They've been told here is a solution to your current pain. Yes, it's not going to be easy, but it here is a solution for you. Why would you not want to do that? And with this pay person, the impact my weight has on my disability? And so from from my point of view, I would be curious about like, what is the impact your weight has on your on your disability? What what are your goals? What do you want to do? Do you want to increase your mobility? Do you want to increase your strength? Do you want to learn how to feel at home in your body? These are all things that that we can work towards, without having to cut out an organ but how rare is it that that people would get that message? You know, not It's not often is it next got the gastric band in 2012. Because of the brainwashing The doctors did on my parents. I was 19 years old. When it didn't work. They suggested I do the gastric sleeve surgery on the 15th of April 2013. They made me do the surgery and a month later I got diagnosed with multiple sclerosis. Ms has major links to vitamin D deficiencies. Cut to today and the ramifications of that shit show us of a surgery still remain. One is constantly combating poor absorption, low energy levels, circulation issues, and massive deficiencies. Oh my goodness. Yeah. And we think about and we're thinking about people who are outside of the surgery, don't have other big things going on in regards to health. And I mean, Ms. That's, that's, that's life changing. And having to deal with a diagnosis like that alongside being disabled by this surgery makes dealing with something like Ms. So much more difficult. Versus if if this person didn't have surgery, what might might the outcomes be? How might she be able to manage her MS better. Okay, next, the decision was made by my mom on the pretext of health because thin equals healthy. I'm at I'm at worse I am worse off because of the lack of nutrients and I ever was when I was fat. Next, Wow, I feel all these stories. I connect with them deeply. I know exactly how it feels. Thanks for sharing, I feel seen

Next, another example of weight loss horror over here. Weight loss surgery horror over here and nowhere to tell my story either no one is remotely interested in it. I didn't even get short term follow up let alone long term. And the long term effects on my body are that I am now disabled and unable to work. Another fat person life life's ruined. Biggest irony is that not is that I need to other surgeries that are not happening because they will not operate on me. When I'm at my current weight. Guess what wait I was when they performed the gastric band surgery butchery and it's higher than her current weight. So yeah, surprise, surprise I were able to perform surgery on her when she was high await when it's gastric surgery. Next story. I had a friend die in her 20s He's after bariatric surgery. Every time it's suggested I tell people that and they try it still try to spin it. Oh, that doesn't happen normally. I have been anti doesn't say what but anti weight loss surgery, I guess for decades now. And these slides are just more proof. Yeah, then it's like kind of like, what wouldn't be me and I, you know, how are a lot of the times we all think I'll be fine. You know, won't happen to me. Okay, next, thank you for telling the stories and shining light on this butchery. I have no lived experience of surgery. But I do live in a body that is bigger than what so called medical science says it should be. And I know why my body is this way. And I know why people resort to taking a step like permanent surgical procedures. They are at the mercy of diet, culture and doctors. I feel so angry about the revered doctors in our society. What are the wise ones who respectfully guide where where are the wise ones who respectively guide and empower empower you to finding yourself? They are not doctors. I feel endless grief for the people who have allowed the surgeries to be done to them in good faith, trusting their so called caregivers in their infinite wisdom and then discovering it was all just guesswork and sleight of hand. Nature finds a way trust in that trust yourself, inform yourself, put yourself on a pedestal instead of medical experts. Read everything be informed trust your intuition, I wish endless strength and resilience of those who are struggling to come to terms with who they are. Knowing that surgery surgery will never make everything. Okay. Next story. I relate to all of this. I'm eight years post our NY are and why is another type of gastric surgery. I don't recommend it to anyone. Next story. I wish I hadn't thought I was a ticking time bomb. I wouldn't have done it. And now left with even stronger depression reflux, chronic diarrhea, low blood pressure that causes seizures dot dot dot. Yeah, I think that ticking time bomb thing is, is really powerful. Because it doesn't matter if you are healthy. Because is it's a moot point to people, right? Because they will always say, Well, you might be okay now. But we all know that fat people lalalalala. And I think even if you were 7080 90, you'd still have that, well, we'll wait, it doesn't matter that you're okay now. And so there's no end to ticking time bomb. Because we're all gonna die. And so and there's nothing there's nothing to prove wrong about, you know, in regards to you can't say I'm never gonna die. So you're wrong, because you, you know, you will die and, and we can't say what our health outcomes are going to be. And so the ticking time bomb is such a, quote, great way for fat haters to get into the minds of a fat folks. Because what are you going to say to that? And what we say to it, you know, like it's kind of like a rhetorical question. But what you know, what we say to it is, is let's look at the evidence. Let's look at what we do know about fat people, let's look at what we do know about what affects the health of fat people. And what perhaps the effects are felt healthier, fat people is shame, oppression, which is what's happening when someone's saying you're a ticking time bomb. Poor health care due to either not going to the doctor because you know, you're just gonna be told to lose weight or going to the doctor and just being told to lose weight, which is so many fat people's experience. And so poor health care, and weight cycling and weight cycling is dieting, losing weight, weight coming back on through no fault of your own losing weight when it comes back on. And then if we also look at, you know, how long do fat people live, I'm looking at studies that show that actually fat people live longer than people who are, quote unquote, average weight, normal weight in big quotes.

And that having weight on your body, especially as an older person, is is really helpful and you know, like so. But the time bomb thing is just so it's like a zinger, right it's is so powerful that it's something that everyone is worried about, you know, like when am I going to die? Oh, am I doing something that is there something that I'm doing that will cause my death early? Can I do something about it? So yeah, watch out for that one watch out for that one. All right, next story I had the gastric band put in in 2009. Last week I had it removed due to the complex due to complications and just having had enough of having pain while eating. The surgeon who took it out offered to do a bypass and like quickly and firmly said no thanks. He offered because I'm not at a weight society deems acceptable. I had also just told him I'm trying to heal my eating disorder can you imagine going back to the surgeon and being like take this out and just being so mad at you know me for projecting my own feelings of being some I get this fucking thing out of me. And they're like, Do you want another job? Do you want a different one hug cut your head off this time? How about that? Oh, yeah, no. Yeah, next, thank you for voicing this weight loss surgery is the most violent, violent form of fat stigma, and is worse than the most horrid violent interventions we have done in history to quote help people in things like mental health. This needs to be get get banned world wide. I'm so glad I came across this. I'm actually on the schedule for weight loss surgery and I'm having serious doubts about going through it. It's so hard to live in a fat body and this is science in this society. Yes. Oh my goodness, hearing stories of people who are saying I'm looking more into into this now that I've heard you. And I've heard these stories is just I'm so pleased that they're getting more information. So finally, we've got a bariatric surgeon who very proudly messaged me sent me a DM. Jess underscore Platts p l a Zed J E S S underscore P L. A Zed, who said to me came into my DMs and said, as a bariatric surgeon, I can say that the number of number of successful patients is far greater than few and far between. And I don't know why. But I responded to her. Because I was like, I was mad. Okay, I was mad. Alright, so this is what I said. How can you say that when there are no long term studies? Literally, how can you say that? How many years after surgery? Do you talk to your patients? Yes, you may see people up to a couple of years post surgery. And the fact that you're a thin person means that when they report to you, it may be inaccurate due to your own fat phobia. You are literally killing fat people and proper profiting off of it. She responds so you know more about being fat because you're fat. So she uses the words so you know more about being Oh word because you are Oh word then use a study and practice. Got it? I feel so angry now. Just reliving it. I responded Get the fuck out of my inbox with your disgusting views. And the thing is, yes. Was Yeah, I've been a fat person. What am I 37 years now? Did you do 37 years of study? No. She responds. So no medical research on your part. I respond. This is so not like me responding. Because I just, I just normally block, block and get on with my day. So interesting how this is my response. So interesting how you didn't answer my question about your own follow up with your own patients. How many years after Do you speak to your patients? Listen to fat people, when we are telling you that you are harming us. She responds, disgusting views. You know nothing about me or my views. You're you're saying that bariatric surgery is unsafe and barbaric?

And I say it is barbaric. Still didn't answer my question you want but you want. I say I'm making spelling mistakes here. So I'm like, oh my God even read my own message because I was I was so so mad but you go home smug thinking about thinking you're helping the out of Control fatties. And so she responded. So a patient came in today saying I saved their life. One year ago, she was lying. And I respond one year ago. And she says, There is no point in arguing this you are not a medical expert no matter how much you think you are just because your own word. And I respond, we all know that up to five years is a honeymoon period. So unless you have data, then you can go away and stop being a giant piece of shit so, and she keeps saying that she's she's got a medical, she's got a medical practice. And and I say, hiding behind a medical degree is peak white supremacy. Also funny how you still didn't answer my questions. And I blocked her. So I mean, she could have very easily said, yeah, actually, you know what we've got, we've done a study with my own patients and seven, eight years post surgery.

This is what we see. She can't say that though, because she's got a one anecdotal, someone came in to see me and someone said after a year that I'd saved her life. Uh, yeah, one person and you're a bariatric surgeon. Listen, I wanted to share that just this has made me look great because I was like, fuck off basically. But I'm so I was so mad that this person would come into my DMs and say this shit and and afterwards, I was like, listen, Vinnie, you could have gone about that better. You could have tried to educate her, and done better to get her on site. Because tomorrow, this week, next week, she's going to get be in contact with a fat patient, and she's going to harm that fat patient. Is she more likely to harm them? If she knows that there's someone out there who is angry about her existence and thinks what she does is immoral? I think that's probably would cause more harm to that fat patient. Or maybe not maybe because the fat patient is happy to be there. And she might think, Oh, here's a good fatty versus Oh, that one was a bad fatty. So anyway, I'm you know, I'm thinking about it and thinking, Oh, my should have done better there. And I should have just either just not responded, or whatever. But also, it felt good to tell her that she is an immoral piece of shit. So, and she's probably never had that she's probably Jess Platts has probably had people being like, Oh, you were so good saving the fatties and her thinking that like, I'm so good like these out of control factories, I go in, I saved them from their greedy nurse. And she thinks she's, you know, so. So it's probably strange for her to have someone say that. That she has got she's not doing the Lord's work is what she probably thinks she is, right. But also, I don't know, I'm gonna have some, okay, I'm gonna turn this around, I'm gonna have some compassion for myself because I left this conversation and I blocked her and I was just like, so angry and so upset me upset me. And so because I'm a human with the human brain, sometimes I'm going to tell people to fuck off. And that's okay. And next time, I'm just going to go by what I always go by because my VA is the one who goes through my inbox. But this just popped up after reading all of these messages from people saying, it's ruined my life and then you have this smug bariatric surgeon who's like, oh, you know, yeah, so Anyway, anyway, I'm gonna go back to and not reading my DMs because this is sometimes what happens most of the time I get nice messages. So the ones that I see anyway, because my VA very kindly goes through them for me. Thank you, Mari, you were the best. Okay, so I'm going to leave it there today. Thank you for hanging out and go do some self care for yourself because this stuff is fun. And feel free to send this episode to anyone who's thinking about So, bariatric surgery, maybe send to the part one. And then then there's another one that I did previously to that episode 50 which is a good kind of look at all of the stats of does weight loss surgery to make you thin and healthy and basically, the answer is probably not a surprise, surprise. We don't have information and also they stop they stop tracking people at like three to five years and that's when shit starts hitting the fan. So yeah. Alright, thanks for hanging out and we'll see you in the next episode.

Stay fierce fatty and I'll see you in a while alligator thanks for listening to the episode and if you feel ready to get serious about this work and want to know when the doors open to fierce fatty Academy, which is my signature program, where I teach all about how to overcome your fat phobic believes and learn to love your fat body, then go to first party.com forward slash waitlist again that is first party.com forward slash waitlist to get your name on the waitlist. For when first party Academy my signature program opens.

EP125 Transcript

You're listening to the first fatty podcast episode 125, Food, Faith, MLMs, and Cults. I'm your host Vinny Welsby. Let's do it

I'm Vinny Welsby, TEDx speaker, Best-Selling Author, and fat activist. I have transformed my life from hating my body with desperately low self esteem to being a courageous and confident fierce fatty who loves every inch of this jelly. Society teaches us living with a fat body is bad. But what if we spent less time, money, and energy on the pursuit of thinness and instead focused on the things that actually matter? Like if pineapple on pizza should be outlawed? Or if the mullet was the greatest haircut of the 20th century? So how do you stop negative beliefs about your fat body controlling your life? It's the Fierce Fatty Podcast. Let's begin.

Am I sweating? I have older friends. How are you? How's life? You feeling? Good? I'm feeling good. Looking for my glasses. Don't need him. Don't need them. Now that you know that I'm looking at my glasses. We've got a wild ride for you today. I don't know about you. But I just love. Love learning about scams. And in fact, less my favorite genre is a scammer is a scammer. And anyway, and so true crime and anything kind of comes off of that. And I spotted an article from Jezebel, which is what started this whole thing. And I realized that I want to do an up to date version of this episode. Not that I've done this episode specifically, but I've done kind of, I've talked about cults and diet culture and how it's related. I don't think I've ever spoken about MLMs. Specifically, I've said that they're dogshit. But yeah, and also these wacky religious groups that wouldn't necessarily be classed as a cult. But they've got some pretty interesting beliefs. And this one article really kind of put me into the rabbit hole, and it's called from Nexium to the way down. Cults really love a dangerous diet culture. That should read really love a dangerous diet. Maybe. Did I write it down though? That's what the that's what the title is. Yeah. That's what the title is. Anyway, yeah. So don't worry if you don't know what I'm saying. When I say Nexium, or the way down, I'm gonna, I'm gonna give you all of the details. And so we're talking about who, okay, so the way down is a documentary series. Well, where is it on? Where's it on? Was it on Amazon? Amazon, I think is on Amazon. And that came out a few weeks ago, a few months ago, maybe all about GWEN SHAMBLIN GWEN SHAMBLIN created a program called the way down, which is so she is was a leader of a religious group who taught that people should be thin to be to get into heaven. Okay, so we're talking about GWEN SHAMBLIN we're talking about Nexium so Nexium is a MLM that turned into a cult that then had Oh sorts of of stuff. And Keith Ranieri, the leader was sentenced to I think, 120 years in prison. So spoiler spoiler alert, like spoiler alert, if you haven't seen the way down and you want to see it and you don't want to know what happens. If you want to learn about Nexium and watch the documentaries and it's on your list and you don't want to you don't want any spoilers. Then probably skip this episode because it's just it's filled with it, or go on watch the go and watch the things and then come back and be like, Oh yeah, yeah. Yeah, so we're talking about Gwen Shamblin, Nexium, LuLaRoe LuLaRoe, the MLM login company breatharians. And talking about Stephen hasanz Bite model in regards to describing cults, Minnesota starvation experiment talking about what dieting does to our brains, and wrapping it all up in Why do some cults MLMs and religious groups, coerce them members to die and become thin. So here's the, here's the thread with all of this is these groups really kind of leading the way in, you better be fair, and you better diet, you better not eat food, because then you are going to get salvation, then you're going to get promotions, then you're going to get all the riches in the world, then you're going to be re your consciousness is going to be raised to a higher plane.

And just like a, an FYI, we're not saying that all religious groups do this. Or that, you know, for example, Lent in the Catholic faith, or Ramadan, where there is a expectation of eating less, or changing the way you eat, or fasting is necessarily evil or bad, or, you know, that those religions are awful. I mean, I was brought up Catholic and so still, you know, it's not a sweeping statement of all faith is, is bad. And, you know, well, the thing is worth, you know, like, growing up Catholic, if you didn't do the things for Len in my family anyway, then no one would say anything, cuz no one did it anyways, it wasn't a big deal. And, and so I guess it's about the coercion and the control and the messages in regards to if you don't do it, then you're a bad person, and you're gonna see terrible consequences in your life. And so I want to just make that differentiation there before we get into it. And a huge giant trigger warning today because we're going to be talking about a lot of shit, which includes starvation, abuse, coercion, child abuse, and death, eating disorders, and mention of specific foods. General shitty human behavior, and power dynamics. Just a lot of stuff. A lot of stuff with mental health stuff. In regards to the effects of, of being on a diet, yeah, so because it's, this is so filled with so much stuff, I won't be able to give specific trigger warnings before each instant because it's, it's just everywhere. And so if that's not feeling good for you today, then I'll see you in the next episode, but if it is, let's go into it. And there's no by the way, there's no gratuitous mentions of any of these things.

As in we don't go into detail, but if you kind of not feeling good, then I'd say just skip it. Just skip it just all right. Okay, let's start with Gwen Shamblin. And so what I'm going to be doing is I've I've done a ton of research, GSO research, all of the stuff that I've talked about today, I've like watched the documentaries and the different versions of the documentaries. I haven't seen the new episodes of, there's a the GWEN SHAMBLIN one is the way down. I haven't seen the new I think there's two or three episodes have just been released. I haven't seen that yet. But I will be but I've seen everything else. Yeah, so and read read the things. And I want to give you excerpts from different articles and what not and the basis like I mentioned for this episode is from Nexium to the way down cults really love a dangerous diet culture from Jezebel links, whatever thing in the shownotes as always fist fatty.com forward slash one to five. Okay, so I'm gonna give you kind of a little overview of this stuff by reading from this article. Okay. GWEN SHAMBLIN by the way, you should do some Googling to see what these people look like. GWEN SHAMBLIN is very interesting book when Shamblin is big innovation. Besides that signature, towering hairdo was a new kind of divine dieting to her. The Bible was littered with evidence that God doesn't just care about the state of our souls. He's also worried about our love handles the fatted calf in the story of the prodigal son, an indication that the Lord is a fan of filet mignon. Shamblin reading of Exodus revealed, however, that God frowns upon the greasy Tupperware containers, containers in most of our fridges. Someone who sets aside leftovers apparently lacks faith that God will provide their next meal. Above all, human body fat is a physical embodiment of sin, an indicator of insufficient piety and a departure from God's grace, by the way, also another kind of trigger warning of some of these links, not this one, but some of the links I'm sharing might have diet culture type statements in there. So just a heads up there. Alright, continuing the way down the HBO Max documentary series about Shamblin Remnant Fellowship Church, so it's not Amazon. It's HBO returns on Thursday with two new episodes. And though the story of the church is filled with its own unique peculiarities, oh my God, there's so much scandal and so the diet thing is just one thing. There's so much choosy shit uses yet to watch. Because I'm picky. materialities a weight loss theme echoes other entries in the cult media boom, particularly the vowel, which reported on the starvation diets that Nexium urged on some of its female members. So why do these groups which purport to be concerned with FAR loftier matters, like God, eternity, self actualization and spiritual and emotional fulfillment often see more concerned with how much their members weigh and what they're eating? Food says University of Pennsylvania lecture or travel, who teaches a course on cults and new religious movements is a very rudimentary basic way to control.

The new episodes also feature interviews with women who left Shambles church and describe just what it was like to be part of a community that placed explicit moral judgments on food and dieting, and reportedly punished those who did not meet the leadership's weight loss demands. When were describing told that they were too fat to be admitted to heaven, and warned that if they left the group, they would face divine retribution in form of a regained pounds. A featured quote expert accurately points out that the vast majority of people who lose large amounts of weight gain it all back within five years. Those who left or were kicked out of the church however, were taught to believe that their almost inevitable weight gain was the result of their fall from grace. Notice how how that really echoes the the big things that diets diet companies, diet culture says that they like deny the reality they gaslight you and say, Oh no, no, it's not. It's not our diet and dieting in general. That's failed. It's you. And so GWEN SHAMBLIN ins group of besties are like, Oh, yes, you and you know, we told you so God is mad at you, girl. So you better stick with the group because when you put on weight, because we know you will, because diets don't work. That's God mad at you. One former member describes being told to eat only 10 bites of food a day to achieve the weight loss goal, the leadership set for her and to partake in extreme fasting regimens. The starvation she experienced left her with holes in her kidneys. I mean, shit, wouldn't you like if you believe in God or whatever? I don't, in case that wasn't obvious. And you thought that there was this place heaven were eternal. Whatever happens in heaven parties or whatever happen And then if you're not in there, then you're missing out on the the really cool party and then you're gonna go to hell or whatever if that's what you believe in or not just die. But anyway, one time say the stakes seem really high. I don't know, wouldn't you if you knew that it was kind of a matter of internal damn eternal damnation or not follow the starvation diets. I mean, shit if that's not motivation because, you know, normal diets, normal diets, it's kind of like, well, you're gonna die if you don't become thin. And then with the religious stuff on top, you're gonna die. And you return all life. You're gonna fuck with that. Because if you're a fatty, you ain't gonna get into heaven. Because God doesn't like fat chicks. And hey, even though in the Bible, it says, I think it must, I think it says we love everyone doesn't matter in the Bible.

I mean, I did study theology, what a waste of an education there, studied, studied religious education for up until 750 16, and then from 16, to 18, studied theology at higher level level of education, a levels of fucking water, waste of my time and brain space. And then the, the teacher who was an ex priest was like, oh, yeah, the Bible is made up, right? We all know, but we have faith and I was like, Bitch, what do you mean the Bible's May, but we have faith. I don't know how faith I thought it was real. Anyway, side note. So if you do believe in that stuff, then if it means that you're gonna have to talk partaking eating only 10 bytes of food a day, you probably do it right. Because eternal damnation or not getting into heaven or whatever. Doesn't sound fun, even though it kind of goes against what's in the Bible. You know? And, you know, you know, I'm talking shit about religion, but I think anyone can read the Bible and pick out anything that they like, right? And so, this GWEN SHAMBLIN is like, Oh, God says he doesn't like he, whereas someone else could read the Bible and say, Actually, God says, that is amazing, you know? So I think you can literally just read it in any way that you want it and to make it into what you want it to say. And I you know, the people who say, Oh, God loves a fight, I'm down with that. Okay. Yeah, if God loves a fat Yeah, that's cool. Love it. This, this whole kind of you need to be doing certain things to get into heaven. And so certain things are like, don't be a dick. Hmm, probably not that helpful to lead a happy life. So. GWEN SHAMBLIN she's all like, divorce is the worst. Don't ever get divorced. If you divorce, then you know, you're, you're obviously going to hell. What does she do? Golf Course. She divorces her her husband, and she gets with a handsome former. Was he like, I can't remember what he was in like, not be watch, but something kind of cheesy 80s Maybe some nameless thing. But anyway, so she gets with this guy. And his name was Joe Lara. That's it. Yeah. Joe, Laura. And there's like scandal around that as well. I think he was younger than her as well, I think by a lot or something.

There was some type of discrepancy there where it was kind of like, oh, this is a bit scandalous, obviously, and then she's getting married to some guy that you know, she said getting divorced is bad. And she gets divorced. And then and then in the, in the documentary they show they're like, engagement video when it's like hilarious, like, almost looks like satire. It's so cheesy. Yeah. And so anyway, long story short, he and other congregation members get in a plane, he was flying, and the plane crashed and they all died. And that happened a few years ago. But Gwen Shamblin is still her legacy lives on. Her daughter is now running the church or the programs you know, the way down programs are way down workshops. And so here's a here's a bustle wrote to this, which is GWEN SHAMBLIN is way down workshops are unfortunately still active. And so quote from that article Brentwood, Tennessee seems to Have a church on every corner but one church in particular looms larger than most Remnant Fellowship, a religious sect that serves as a subject of HBO Max's new Docu series a way down. remnant was founded in 1999 by Gwen Shamblin Laura, who created a controversial diet program called the work called the way down and way by the way is spelled W E IG H Ombria Solu bit of a pun in their power and all the way down in 1986, intended to quote teach people how to stop bowing down to the refrigerator, and how to bounce back down to God. Laura, because her name was then GWEN SHAMBLIN Laura after she married this this fellow, Laura died in May 2021. Okay, it's only like a year ago in a plane crash that also killed her husband Joe Lara and five other remnant leaders, but the way down programs remain popular. As detailed in the way down, Shamblin was raised in the church of Christ, and used her religious knowledge and training as a dietitian to devise the way down. The program consists of seminars and guided videos and audio tapes created by Shamblin who believe that being thin is a reflection of purity. According to her teachings, those who are able to lose weight and keep a lose, lose and keep off weight quickly are holier, and closer to God. Though experts express concern that the way down died, eliminated exercise and did not include guidance about food selection. People were intrigued by the fact that it did not require calorie counting or restricting foods instead. By the way, don't don't get interested in this diet, it's bullshit. Instead, Shamblin encouraged her followers to eat only when they feel hunger pains, and preached to quote run to God every time you want to go to food. The program was introduced in the midst of the 80s diet culture. It's of 80s diet culture and quickly took off according to the way down it at one point spread to more than 250,000 people in over 1400 congregations and 70 countries. The target for the workshops were women that felt they had great needs in life that weren't being spoken to by the traditional church that they were in. Reverend Raphael Martinez a cult interventionist explains in the way down, quote, therefore the workshop becomes an outlet for these women. In 1999, Shamblin decided to break from the Church of Christ and found Remnant Fellowship under her leadership with the way down diet as its focus. She believed that the Christian church had been corrupted and that it was her duty to create a place of worship for quote, true believers. However, former members claim in the Docu series that remnant was really a way for Shamblin to accumulate wealth, and power for herself and foster complete obedience to her. As a former member, Autumn Williams explains in the show, The workshops are all about selling chandeliers, brand, journals, DVDs, workbooks, and tote bags were among the goods required to take the classes. Former Member Rachel Phillips also says that the members have to be enrolled in way down class at all times, and that they paid for the classes themselves. Furthermore, many former members detail abusive practices within the church, including women's complete obedience to their husbands and violence against children.

Yeah, so the violence against children. In the documentary you can see there is a recording where congregation members they're like, oh, they talk about how should we deal with discipline children, and they were like, you know, you should hit them. And they were talking about, you know, his congregation members saying, We've been hitting our kid and like Gwen, and someone else or Awesome. Yeah, is like, cool, that's great. And then then these people who were hitting their kids hit the kid and the child died. So continuing, after Shamblin is death, her daughter Elizabeth Sharon, Hannah assumed the primary leadership role in the church. The way down workshops are still available, including classes about basic weight loss, and others that delve deeper into the meaning between hunger and loving God. Though the website boasts hours of free content content, a subscription to Weigh Down TV is 9099 a month, while a single class is 6999. Quote, God did not put chocolate or lasagna or real blue cheese dressing on Earth to torture us but rather for our enjoyment that were at work. sight reads, however, he wants us to learn how to rise above the magnetic pole of the refrigerator so that food does not consume our lives. Which sounds kind of reasonable, right and unloving, a lot of people would would, would not be ahead when they read that saying, We don't want food to consume our lives. And you know, even the work that I do is we don't want food to consume our lives. But this program will not do the opposite for will consume your life. If you're not eating it, if you are turning to God, every time that you feel hunger, pain, not as hungry, but you have to get so hungry that you're in pain and then turn to God instead, instead of, quote, bowing down to the refrigerator. Yeah, so you know, it's kind of like that bait and switch of a lot of cults, a lot of dodgy religious communities, they really prey on people who are struggling, who are looking for something. And these people are are intelligent that people who go into into cults and religious sects are not stupid. Reading that sentence, God did not put such chocolate or lasagna on Earth to torture us, but rather for our enjoyment, you'd say yes. However, we want to rise above the magnetic pole. Yes, you know, if I had read that, however, many years ago, 10 years ago, I'd be like, yes. Sign me up. And if you're like, if you're searching for something, you know, and if you're religious, and you're searching for kind of, to be thin, and, and that really strong desire, and I don't know what the desire is to be pious to be in God's good graces, I don't know what that feeling is. But I can imagine it might be something similar might involve a lot of guilt, maybe. And something that's powerful and something that's kind of maybe filled with dread if you think, oh, maybe I'm not getting into the heaven party. We're all the thin we're all the thin bitches are, you know? So, I mean, shit. That's good marketing. If I was religious, if I was religious, and read that when I was in diet culture, I'll be like, Fuck, yeah, take my money. 1990 and 1990 99 a month to get into heaven. And be thin, double whammy. Take my money. But then what you're getting is, oh, your husband's in charge. And you are a greedy motherfucker. And you need to be in pain before you consider eating and instead of eating, you need to do a prayer or whatever. And yeah, and would give you just a shit ton of disordered eating and how much shame would you feel if you left? Because you're turning your back on? God. Right? Wow. That must be hard. What are you going to do?

Alright, let's move on to Nexium Nexium is spelt. And XIV M Nov. X ray, indigo, Victor, Mike. And next year, um, oh, you know what I feel? I feel like I feel like an affinity for next year. I'm not like I want to join. But I can imagine like, how many years ago I was. I was I probably knew people, you know, friends of friends who were in Nexium because it was in Vancouver as well as other places. But they had a an office in Vancouver. And it was all about kind of women's empowerment and becoming the best version of yourself and executive leadership and attractive people who are thin and and there was some celebrities in it. And so when I worked, I worked for an organic food company. I tell you what that was, I feels like That was so close to all of this shit. And I feel like I could have easily been in that coal. Like easily, probably not actually because I was poor. So it is. It's so expensive. Nexium is also an MLM. So if you don't know what MLM is, it's a bit of a tongue twister. Isn't it? MLM MLM MLM It's not a multi level marketing, multi level marketing is a great way to take money from poor people who hope that they can have an independent working arrangement. They have been cleared of not not being a pyramid scheme. By the I don't know, if it's FDA, some governing body in the US looked into, what's that one big one, that's football players. And it's green Nutri neutral cents or something like that anyway, big lawsuit because basically, the idea behind an MLM, if you're, if you're not familiar with them, is that you Well, there's a product, right. And this is what gets let's install legally can carry on is that there's a there's a product, that's, that's like a thing, if there's no product, then it's very clearly a pyramid scheme, even though it's a pyramid scheme, there's a product and you will start selling the product. And you'll make a little bit of money. But where your big money comes in, is recruiting your mates, to also sell the product. And when you recruit someone, you get, like a bonus sometimes, but you also get a cut of their commission. And that commission is from setting a little bit of product, but not really, most of the commission comes from recruiting new people, and so on and so forth. And so you're if you're first in on a new MLM, you might be at the top of the tree. And be making tons of money, because you'll have like your downline, which is, however many people long and so if you've got 10 people reporting directly to you, and they both have, they, those 10 people will have three people reporting to them, then that's like 30 people under them, and then 10 people there. So then you've got you've got 40, people's commission coming in. And if those three people each all recruit two people, etc, etc. But I'm not turning you on to MLMs. Don't do it, don't do it. Don't start one there another girl.

The stats around MLMs is something like 9099 plus people, percent of people who join in MLM, lose money. And it's like, point 1% of people make more than 50k. And they marketed as, oh, join this MLM. And you're going to be buying a fancy car or going on vacations, and dah dah, dah, dah, dah. And that is true for a tiny percentage. Is this sounding familiar? Is it sounding like diets? Yes. And so you're kind of looking at that look into those people who are making a lot of money. And saying all the people who have lost weight, which are the unicorns and saying, Well, if they can do it, I can do it too, all I need to do is hustle, all I need to do is get my head down and lose weight, just do it, it's a matter of mind, mind over matter. And I'm the only one responsible for my success or failure. The truth is, if you're in an MLM you are 99% chance that you're going to fail and lose money. Because it's just designed like that. And because there is a little bit of product selling and so maybe you know a small percentage of what you're selling. And anyway, even if you got 100% of 100% of your revenue came from selling stuff, you get a tiny, tiny percent of like, selling you know, say if you're selling a legging and the legging is let's be generous 50 bucks, and you get let's be generous. Let's say you get 25 bucks for selling a legging. I mean to make a living wage, you are going to be have to have to be selling a ton of them. And once you've gone through your personal network, unless you're an influencer at once you've asked your friends and your mum and you know your your long lost, you know, people that you went to school with, which is we're all very familiar with those emails that we get, you know from your high school bully. He's like, Will you buy my Tupperware and you're like, fuck off Michelle, Michelle Smith, she was such a bitch. And yeah, once you've done that, then it's kind of like, well, you know, people buy stuff out Gil and then that's it. And then it's kind of like, oh, well, the only way I'm really gonna make money is if I recruit other people to sell this shit. And really the only way they're gonna make money is if they recruit people to sell their shit. And often the products are subpar and overpriced. Just it's just, I feel terrible for the people who are involved. Here. Whew. It's like all of this stuff, they're sold a faulty bill of goods, right? They see influences online, and they see them being like, Oh my God, this isn't my day, I wake up and I go to the pool, and I'm in Mexico and look at my fancy car. And, you know, and it's not real. And, and even in the, they tell them, show your like, show your fancy lifestyle, show them how great it is to be a part of this program, blah, blah, blah. And so they're making shit up and, like, buying so that they can't afford to promote this lifestyle so that other people can then sign up under them, so that they can make money. And it's like a desperate situation for everyone. And it's so like sunk cost fallacy of, you have to have a certain amount of inventory for some of these MLMs. And, and so you're in for and then when you sign up, you have to pay a signup fee. And it could be, you know, a small fee, it could be a huge fee. And you need to have a certain amount of different types of products on hand. And, and so you've already spent, let's say, 10 grand to get enrolled in this business, and you're a quote, business owner now. And so, are you going to give up? No, you're going to keep going and you're going to keep doing and hustling. And eventually, after, you've kind of realized that there's, there's no way to make this sustainable. Then people start you know, leaving and and feeling very sad about it and very embarrassed and feeling like if only they worked harder, but that's not true. It doesn't matter how hard they work. They are setup to fail. And yeah, anyway, so next em was an lm n LM LM LM L M. N. M, started by Keith Ranieri, the creepiest motherfucker piece of shit. Just Google watching him, I hate him so much. He's just he's awful in every way that human can be awful. And including everything you can imagine that an awful person could do.

Allegedly, he so what Nexium turned into was kind of like self development that you take the first course and then you take the next course and then you know, get other people in and blah, blah, blah. Okay, so there's quoting from the same Jezebel article that started all of this is, quote, Nexium, by contrast, wasn't a religious group, but a self help multi level marketing scheme. Still, like the Remnant Fellowship, weight loss, see weight loss. Often, weight loss seems often to have been placed at the forefront of members minds. Women who left the group have described being put on diets that restricted them to just 800 calories per day, less than half of blah, blah, blah. In this group, women's body fat wasn't an affront to God, but a personal affront to the cults founder, Keith Ranieri, who has been accused of sexual abuse, he's been accused and convicted of it. Extreme dietary restrictions pop up again and again in stories of cults, high control groups, Jim Jones, wired people's temple members mouth shut when he deemed them fat. And Michelle Pfeiffer wants describe falling in with a controlling group of breatharians people who believe they can survive purely on light without eating food or water. And surprisingly, the ideology has been linked to several deaths. So here's a quote from a different article which is by insider who says ex members of Nexium say leader Keith Ranieri brainwash women into starving themselves. Quote during ordinaries lifetime prison sentence hearing on October 27 Former members talked about about renewing these request for diet restriction among multiple women members including those in Nexium secret sorority das das stands for I want to go to Dominus a secret to them some something dos Nexium in xv I am meaning. So there was this like subgroup that he siloed women that he wanted to have sex with in in an EN so it was kind of basically he felt he founded a group but it was like a Oh we founded it the women but you didn't because I called it DOS and it was basically dos means master over slave something like that. Let me see. Come on Google put it right in front of me so I don't have to search and click things. Dos. Here we go. Let's click on to dos. Oh, no, it just goes to Keith Ranieri annoying. Anyway, watch the documentaries that I'm going to mention and you'll see is is like Greek or something Dominus syncretism, blah, blah, blah. DOS, bear with me color. Okay, so stands for Dominus oats, ob SIG cuius cerium, which according to one member means master over slave women. And so that's what he was doing is he was like, the puppet master and Allison Mack who is an actor from small Ville, I think from the top of my head. She was the like, quote, leader, but really, it was Keith behind the scenes. And it was all about, like, fucked up, but all of it swept up. But this is like extra fucked up of basically coercion coercion, getting them to eventually have sex with Keith, and getting them into a really kind of submissive state and really controlled state because they had to eat a tiny amount of food, they had to constantly be in contact with their, quote, Master. And so for some people, it was Allison Mac, and then other people then have people reporting to them. And and so Allison Mac would be like, show me an image of what you're eating.

And if you've eaten too much, then you're you're you have to you have to be punished for that. And also, they would have these things called readiness drills where where someone where Allison Mack or whoever is your your, your master would send a text anytime of the day and night and within an X amount of minutes, you have to respond. And so she would send a text saying ready and then you'd have to respond ready with an X amount of minutes. And if you didn't, and so these people were sleep deprived, they were starved, and then they were branded and they were branded with this was this what they thought was something to represent like the earth and the sea or whatever. But actually it was key through an Aries initials. And also, maybe Allison Max initials into this like symbol, which when he turned it around, and he had them branded close to the evolvers. And yeah, so lots of fun. Let me continue. According to India, Oxenberg, India was in Davos, who executive produced the Docu series seduced about her seven years in the cult, and two years as a das sex slave, renewing framed diet restriction as the ultimate show of self improvement, and convinced some followers to believe that in reality renewably restricted women's diets to make them look more childlike Oxenberg said during her victim impact statement at the sentencing and that is something as well he's been accused of raping underage women raping children. And yeah, so it lines up and as well, I'm thinking about this about, you know, men's obsession with women looking like children and, and how fucking creepy that is. And in regards to size, too, and, and the idea that, you know, sometimes you can look back and be like, Oh, when I was in the prom, I was only this size. And now I'm 30 and I'm this size, and I've put on so much weight and I was so much better looking then and it's like you were a child. Like why? Why do we want to look like children? And the reason is, is because a lot of you know patriarchy and sexism and all that type of stuff teaches us that teachers men, that is what is attractive, and teachers, everyone else if they want to attract men that they better look like children basically. Let's continue during an appearance on Dr. Oz that airs October 29. Former Member Tammy Chapman said renewably falsely told her diet restriction was a useful tool for self improvement. I was originally food restricted because because Keith had everyone convinced that the fastest way to work on your issues will still work on your relationship with food. She said she often wondered how eating fewer calories would lead to her business success, but continue to eat between 509 100 calories daily as renewably requested, renew Erie 60 was sentenced to 120 years in prison after being found guilty of child sex trafficking and conspiracy to commit forced labor. Yes, and I really, I really this person who's saying this to me, Chapman, she was confused how eating calories would lead her business success, eating fewer calories would lead to a business's success. I can really see that thinking, because I would think that really, I mean, and the reality is, if you do have a smaller body, you probably will have more success in business, as we know that people are hired less and paid less. And so there is truth to it. But these people, all of them were thin to start with. They were not letting in fact, ease into this inner circle dos. I don't know if they let that ease into even the just a basic Nexium groups. So these are people who are already thin. Right? So and really, so he's, he's like, I can see that, like, I can see myself falling for that being like, yeah, if I if I fix my relationship with food, because clearly I have a fucked up relationship with food because I'm fat. And the reality was, I had a fucked up relationship with food, because I had restricted so much in my life. And yeah, not because I was I was fat. But being fat obviously mean that I'm like, well, that's why I need to restrict because I need to show to the world that I've got my shit together. And a big part of before I started getting into

wanting to be and wanted to, you know, be a career coach, because I was in recruitment for a number of years is a big hesitation of mine was like, Well, how can I be a career coach, if I am fat, because clearly, I don't know shit about shit, because I'm fat. So I can totally understand how people could get sucked up into that sort out your relationship with food become thin, and then you're going to be a millionaire. I mean, there is some truth in that. But Keith was using it as I not necessarily he wants them to have success. He probably did. Because they they all were free labor for him. He didn't pay anyone. And everyone gave him tons of donations. And so he used it, I think, you know, a little bit for that, but also these to get them looking in a certain way that was more pleasing to his sensibilities, which were fogged up. And also because they became so pliable. We're going to talk about later exactly what happens when you don't eat enough food. And so, if these women were like, starving, sleep deprived, and then they had the chance to win their leaders, affections by having sex with him? I mean, they would, I mean, you know, it's easier for him to, it's easier for him to get that type of person who has been groomed into having sex with him, versus just some random person off the street, you know, if the if if he just grabbed some random person who had had enough sleep who had had not had been eating who had not been brainwashed for all of these years, and it was like, Hey, have sex with me, they'd be like, fuck off. And I want it to, you know, but these these people were so because of the state that he put them in because of what he had done to them. More likely to do anything that he wants, which also included because he would, he would he would draft in people who were rich, giving him millions of dollars. Yeah, so if you want to learn more about Nexium go and watch, there's two there might even be three documentaries. The two that I know of is the vow and seduced and I listened to a podcast from CBC called uncover. That was where I first learned about this stuff. And then the two documentaries came out close to each other. Allison Mack, I don't know if she was sentenced yet but she I think she was found guilty. Allison Mack. And I mean, it's just wild and I may think she's she's a big victim of that although she did perpetrate a lot of thanks to Max sentencing let's see sin tense Okay, sentenced to three years in prison for sex slavery. Okay, so hopefully she can go she can continue with her life. So I don't I don't think Allison Mack was like she's wasn't Keith Ranieri? You know, she did some fucked up things, but hopefully she's able to do heal from all that stuff and everyone else who were who were who's in it able to heal. Okay, so let's move to LuLaRoe LuLaRoe is another m l m, not as extreme as Nexium. But LuLaRoe I think they've shut down now because of all the scandal LuLaRoe is it still going? LuLaRoe let's have a look. Do so they sell leggings, right? I am still going still going. Don't get into it. Don't get please don't get into an MLM. Milan. Bah, bah, bah, bah, bah moleben them because you will lose your money and even buying stuff from the thing. A lot of times the stuff is really low quality. I mean, not always. Who knows. Maybe there are other places that have nice stuff, but yeah, okay. So Luna RO, founder.

This is a an article written by our friend Regan Chasteen LuLaRoe founder profits from sending consultants to Mexico for weight loss surgery of course sheet. Okay, article from Robert Schlee links in the bio facebook.com forward slash when we add one to five. If you always forget the episode number you can always go to facebook.com forward slash podcast for the latest and greatest. Okay, so Luna rohu. This is from the article. So Reagan talks about you know what they do for business and blah, blah, blah. But it turns out that the business owner and her sister were quietly developing a another stream of income, aside from scamming people into selling their leggings and recruiting people, for consultants interviewed by Bloomberg reported that they were pressured by founder Deanne Brady or her sister Renee to go to Tijuana Mexico to have so cold weight loss surgery. Sam Schultz The Sisters nephew explained Lenay charges $5,000 But it costs $4,000 You pay her through PayPal, she gets a cut then takes you to Mexico. Consultant Courtney says the sisters refer to themselves as the Tijuana skinnies. Stacy Stacy Christina, a LuLaRoe consultant told Bloomberg I was told by Deanne herself that she likes her leaders to be a size small or medium. Let's be clear about what's going on here. Not happy enough with cheating fat consultants out of their money through her pyramid scheme. Lulu rose leader was making $1,000 a pop for sending fat independent consultants to Mexico to have a surgery that may leave them thin or maimed or dead. The quote skinny sisters work with a clinic called I'm not even kidding you. Obesity not for me the number four. If the name alone doesn't convince you that this place is totally legit. Try these quotes from their website. In bypass surgery the patient may have have small diarrhea when they eat too much or they eat food that contains too much fat when they what they are talking about is called dumping syndrome. And as the name may have already implied there's nothing small about it and cause nausea vomiting diarrhea rapid or irregular heartbeat hyperglycemia glycaemia And it can require surgical intervention. They claim that quote the complications of these procedures are similar to any other abdominal surgery. I mean, if you listen to that our surgery episode a few episodes or episodes ago you know how fucking false that is. Regan says that massive that's massively misleading since other abdominal surgeries seek to cure disease for health and this one seeks to take healthy organs and create a disease state in them for weight loss. People are allowed to do whatever they want with their bodies, including amputating this their stomachs. The point here is that the founder of Lulu row is not just encouraging but profiting from pushing her workforce to go to a questionable clinic clinic that is not honest about the potential dangers of the surgery. While the leadership seems to Have a quote no fat chicks policy when it comes to upper level consultants, they're willing to take fat people's money. LuLaRoe sizing can be complicated, but they do claim to have sizes up to 3x. So they seem to be comfortable taking fat people's money while engaging in active fat phobia when it comes to their workforce. It's true that fat people get hired less and paid less and thin people. Sadly, companies like Lula row are often touted as a way to escape this discrimination by creating one's own business. The actual solution would be to end fat phobia, but that's a subject for another article. So it's extra disappointing that a company that is built around the idea of empowering women is in fact, leveraging the damage to income potential created by fat phobia as a way to profit from that same fat phobia. All the while putting fat people at risk. Yes, very good. Slam Dunk. Can you imagine? I mean, your workplace and your manager says, Oh, we're going to go and going down to Mexico to get our stomachs amputated. Come on, borrow your fat and ugly and go borrow?

Yeah, okay, here's another article 1000s of women say Lulu Lulu rose legging Empire is a scam. This is from Bloomberg. This is the article that Reagan was quoting. But another little quote in here is it wasn't the first time. First time things that LuLaRoe had gotten word for her. In November 2016, Harwood had traveled with Deanne to a handful of conventions to talk about her success at the company. At a dinner in Detroit one evening, Deanna asked if she could get any if she had any interest in getting gastric surgery. She's like, Courtney. Oh my God, you have got to go get it. I'll have my sister call you next week. Howard says for people I spoke to with for their stories say that they been approached by either Deanne or her sister, Lynn a nap who offered to take them to do on a fun fan firm. And we're not even talking about this. I mean, this is a fucking legging company. It's not a fitness company. You know? We're not even talking about all of the absolute dogshit MLMs that are. There's one what's it called? It works and Beachbody Beachbody my gold. And so imagine that if you a word for one of those MLMs Oh, Nellie. I mean, I was gonna say would they even let you join? Fuck yeah, they're gonna let you join. They're going to take fat people's money. Are they? Imagine the amount of bullshit that you're gonna be hearing? Oh, I don't even want to think about it. Oh God and all the lies and all the scams. I've been to a few like anti MLM accounts and seeing all of the the scams that these motherfuckers Paul like, stealing people's photos, there was this one person who was stealing photos of someone who had had a tummy tuck and saying, This is the results if you eat my whatever it is, if you drink my juices, or if you follow my program, and it's like, they had fucking surgery. And people are like calling them out. And they're like, oh, no, no, not me. I'm not telling lies. I mean, they've got they've got to if they're going to have to try and have a business because they're not going to have people's pictures to show of the results. Because as we know, does that work? Well, they work temporarily right? Let's move on to the breath areas. So you know, you've got vegetarian and you've got pescatarian and we've got breath Aryans. Which is is what you think it is? People who think that they can survive just by breathing and not by eating or drinking water. If you're curious if that's a thing and it works and no people die, people die. And the people who are leaders in this in this arena, allying basically they eat food, you know, because if they didn't, maybe dad and yeah, so Okay, so here's an article quote from an article from G q. And this is it's called the people who think air is food. They call themselves breath areas and new ish kind of spirit spirituality that is dubiously believed that dubiously believes that the human body can and should sustain itself Not all food, but on air and quote, universal energy. Are these people really not eating Brina? Curry spent seven days at a breatharian retreat in North Carolina to find out. Yeah, so it's a it's a long article. Go read. It's interesting.

So it starts do you need to eat to live? Most people would say yes. But as a small group of people self proclaimed prilocaine breatharians who might say? No, not necessarily. By the way, big disclaimer, you need to eat food to live. Okay? There's no kind of way around this. There's no There's no, they've not found out some system or trick or whatever. Please eat food. Okay, don't what I'm reading here is a ton of bullshit. And is very dangerous. Okay, eat food. All right, we need food and can't survive by breathing. I mean, you need to breathe but you need to breathe and eat food. Okay, so through the fringe philosophy, though, though the fringe philosophy has existed in its modern modern incarnation since at least the 1970s and is modeled after religious aesthetics of old. I hadn't heard of breatharians until a New York Post article that went viral in early June. The title like most tabloid headlines is a complete sentence that reads like a fact for vetted discovery. breatharians couple survives breatharian couple survives on the universe's energy instead of food. That couple a life coaching duo name. A car he Ricardo and Camilla Castillo belong to a community of people who believe you don't need food to live that surviving on non food substance like sunlight. And prana allows people to live more evolved healthily spiritual lives. I wonder as well, like how much of this is, is people stealing from other cultures and their ideas kind of like how people are taking from the Bible and it's like, the Bible says that you have to do this and it's not true and and these presumably white people, I bet you they're white. Let me google it. Camilla Castillo Yeah, taking things like concepts like prana and then being like, oh, okay, yeah, she's white. Maybe there's just lots of good there's different Camilla Castillo. Anyway, whatever. No matter who they are.

No matter who they are the teaching bullshit, right? That's how I look. Okay, here's the New York Post thing. Okay, so who knows? Who knows? Anyway? Moving on. Moving on. Moving on. Yeah, so they're taking concepts probably that aren't theirs to take and, and just making it into a ton of bullshit. Okay, so all the retreat goers intend to complete the suggested fast no food or water for three days, and only juice for another fall. game without water is something that most doctors consider dangerous. But for breath Aryans, a, an initiation fast is essential for being beginning a life where food is optional. There will be no doctors present at the retreat, then the only thing remotely resembling medical oversight will be a white box called a bio Well, that is supposedly measures the human energy field and chakra alignment. And that ends up having broken in transit on its way to the retreat. Yeah, so no, no medical oversight, not sure that this this box would have done anything anyway. Later, I asked Ricardo Why do this? Why give up a central part of human life go against medical advice when there are so many spiritual practices out there that don't require you to give up food? His answers surprises me. When I started this, I felt cleaner. I felt sharper. He tells me pausing I felt fearless. Yeah, that word cleaner. Sharper. What does that? What does that sharper? Angular? Not fat, cleaner. Clean, makes you think of food is dirty fatness is dirty. Driving back to the breatharian house two days later, I feel a mounting sense of dread. It's been two and a half days since the participants had food or water and I can't stop thinking about Verity Lynn, the woman who died emaciated alone on a remote shore in the Scottish Highlands in 1999. Among her belongings was a diary that current chronicled her food and water free spiritual cleanse and a copy of the book living on light written by preeminent breatharian Ellen jazz mu Hien grieve so this person very Ritalin died seven days into a 21 day fast. And she was following this, this person who was obviously a scammer who wrote a book living on lights. And she claimed she didn't eat anything, didn't drink anything. And there was a documentary, which I was able to find a snippet of. And it's an old documentary, right? So this person died in 1999. And the documentary I think, was made near there were 60 minutes, which is an Australian show, met with jazz mu heen, which is the person who wrote living online and confronted her. And then she did, they said, Well, what if we locked you up and said, you know, you can't eat or drink for 21 days? You would die? And she was like, No, I'd happily do it. It'd be a vacation for me. And so they said, Okay, let's do it. And so they, they did it and we've got this kind of snippet from the program of, you know, within within a day, she is not doing well. And they have to end the experiment because they were worried that she was going to die, but she was like, I'm fine. Don't worry about me, even though she was slurring her words and was so dangerously dehydrated that the medical professional was like, you know, this is really unethical to continue because she's gonna die. But okay, continuing with this article. breatharian leaders have often been undressed in public. Jazz Maheen was humiliated by a 60 minutes episode in which she started to fail and slurred during a monitor dry fast. An early breath Aryan leader Wiley Brooks, who claims that all foods and liquids are poisonous so many of his followers dispatch in 1983 after he was spotted grabbing takeout including allegedly a chicken pot pie and biscuits at a hotel and groceries from 711. I just love it. Like a chicken foot by because obviously they can't be alive if they don't eat and I think that's what it's like with these breath. Aryans, that is the worst is when they're just like, I literally don't eat and then you have people who and this person Verity Lin who died. She's not the only one. Lots of people have died because of it, because they believe what these people are saying. And they follow them and they die and the leaders are like, Yeah, but like lol secretly I'm going to 711 and I mean, no chicken potpie and which they should because they're human and they need to eat. Yeah, if you want to see that snippet from the documentary, it's not very good quality, but it's in the show notes as well.

But I have to wonder this is continuing the article is all this in a piece just a symptom of starvation because you know, all these people on the retreat and like I feel amazing. And so the the the documentarian, the reporter is saying, is that inner peace or is that starvation? Dr. Perry G fine. A preset professor of anesthesiology at the University of Utah has worked with terminally ill patients who decide to stop eating as a way of peacefully ending their lives. Patients often quote from him, patients have oftentimes described themselves as entering a transient, transcendental blissful or euphoric state. After they stop eating. He tells me though, painkilling drugs exaggerate the phenomenon in some, but that doesn't mean it's a positive thing. If the brain is being starved of nutrition and hydration, you may have a sense of well being, but you might be doing harm to yourself, he says, might be doing harm to yourself. He says, I think definitely you're doing harm to yourself. And let's look at the well known Minnesota starvation studies. To know what dieting not eating or eating, eating less food than we need. And even not even that less does to our minds. And we I have a whole episode on the psychology of hunger, which is episode 94. And it's called the psychology of hunger where we go into the Minnesota starvation experiment, and also the Warsaw the Chava. Study which Jewish people when they were in the ghettos, they studied what starvation did to their fellow fellow inmates or fellow people in the ghetto, which is pretty incredible that they were thinking about science when they were literally being murdered. So let's look at this. The Minnesota starvation study quickly is we're looking at a study that was conducted in around second world War 1944. And so keys wanted to study the effects of starvation to help with the war effort, because there was a ton of starvation going on. They got 36, white men aged 22 to 33. And they were conscientious objectors. And so they really wanted to help with a war effort without violence. And so they were they were very eager participation participants. And they were assessed to make sure that they were physically and psychologically well, they had to be able to get along with the other people and be very resilient. And so these were very kind of robust. Men who were doing this. And so they did six months of semi starvation at 15 170 calories a day. Let me just repeat that, in this starvation experiment, the men were given 15 170 calories a day. How many diets do we know of that the amount of calories that are prescribed are less than that?

NuMe 1200 calories. A, I mean, many of them, right. And so this is this is their starvation diet of 1570 calories. And the foods that they were given were foods that are common common foods, potatoes, rutabagas, turnips, bread, macaroni, cabbage, and meat and dairy products. So there's a photo I saw of a really thin man licking his plate at the dinner table, which was apparently common alongside other behaviors. So quote, they diluted potatoes with water held bytes in their mouths for a long time without swallowing, or labored over combining the food on the plate, making weird and seemingly distasteful concoctions. So at 15 170 calories for six months, they were becoming obsessed with their food, quote, standing in line at the diet kitchen before being served with a source of explosive conduct. At the table, they often turned on one another annoyed by each other's voices and the increasingly strange habits that other that many men developed. They would cuddle the food like a baby or handle it and look over it as if they would, if they would some gold they played with it like, like kids making mud pies. Food became the sole source of fascination and motivation. Many men became obsessively collecting recipes stayed up until 5am. Last night studying cookbooks wrote one they found themselves distracted by constant daydreams of food some sublimated their cravings by purchasing or stealing food. One man began stealing cups from coffee shops that guzzled water seeking fullness. Some took up smoking to stave off hunger and others chewed up to 30 packs of gum a day until the bar oratory banned it. Meanwhile, all other elements of life seem to fade into mere background noise. Over and over again the researchers reported indifference and boredom when it came to personal development, and basic socializing, social socializing, budding romance is collapsed and sexual desire evaporated at parties or subjects found conversation both difficult and pointless. They all preferred a solitary trip to the movies, adding that while they could recognize comedy they felt they never felt compelled to laugh anymore. In a store when shopping they were easily pushed around by the crowd. The research team reported their usual reaction was resignation sometimes his permeate permeating donors gave way to moments of inexplicable inexplicable euphoria followed by an emotional crash. One subject was eventually eliminated from the project for sneaking unauthorized food in town. After doing so he found himself so high that he stopped at 17 Soda shops on the walk home. He kidded with the fountain girls thought the lights were more beautiful and then then ever felt that the world was a very happy place. The researchers reported this degenerated into a period of extreme pessimism and remorse. He felt he had nothing to live for. And the he had failed miserably to keep his commitment of staying on reduced rations.

And during the rehabilitation period, and so rehabilitation, they were increased their calories to I think 2000 or something. So a surprising finding was that even though they weren't now allowed food, their mental health continued to decline. The results of this is that there were significant increases in depression hysteria, hypo Condrey SS as measures using the Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory. Most of the subjects experienced periods of severe emotional distress and depression, as well as significant decreases in their strength and stamina, body temperature, heart rate and sex drive and a gaunt appearance. The cycle logical effects are significant as well hunger made the men obsessed with food they would dream and fantasize about food, read and talk about food and savor the two meals a day. They were given they reported fatigue irritability, depression, apathy. Interestingly, the man also reported decreases in mental ability, signs of social withdrawal and isolation or declining concentration, comprehension and judgment, judgment capabilities. Some of the X subjects exhibited edema in extremities, presumably due to increased levels of plasma proteins giving that the body's ability to construct key proteins like an album is based on available energy sources. During the rehab phase, which was said to be the most difficult phase one man Sam leg chopped off three of his fingers with an axe. Let me repeat that, during the rehab phase, which is said to be the most difficult this is when they've had about 2000 calories, I think, or more, Sam leg chopped off three of his fingers with an axe. Sam said he didn't know if he did it deliberately or not. I meant to I admit to being crazy mixed up at the time leg later explained, I am not ready to say I did it on purpose, I am not ready to say I didn't, quote, deprivation itself drove these men to the threshold of insanity. Even after the study ended, there were reports of men still being incredibly fixated on food. One man even had to go to hospital for seven days after having his stomach pumped. Others said that they ate constantly. So that is six months of 15 170 calories. And these were people who were allegedly seemingly robust, physically and psychologically. And they were very, very motivated because they were conscientious objectors, they there was a lot of shame around that, that these people were not in the war, they were not fighting for their country. And so they had the opportunity to redeem themselves by being good participants in this study. And so there was a lot of pressure that they'd put on themselves, maybe society as well. And this was important work to see how starvation affected people and how the refeeding stage might go. And so that's what that is what it does. I mean, ethically now, I'm not sure how, if they could repeat this study, especially now with what we know, I mean, could you repeat a study where you know, a man cut off his fingers? And I would love to know what happened to these men afterwards, long term. And, you know, all of this stuff is extreme. But it's, it's at a, quote, normal amount of calorie restriction that we'd see for an average diet. Not even a fad diet, you know, when the fad is, you know, I'm big quotations around fat, because all diets are fat diets. But, you know, the diets where it's kind of like, extra extreme. I mean, it's not even an extra extreme diet, and that is what it's doing to the participants. Okay, so I have another episode, which is episode 41 is diet culture, a cult and I just want to talk about the model that Steven Hassan developed called the bite model, which describes the specific methods that cults use to recruit and maintain control over people and bite stands for behavior information, thought and emotional control. Now the episode goes deep into this stuff and I'm just going to pick out certain things from the bite model just to to illustrate them for you.

So you can be like Ah ha, okay, and so if you're thinking is something a cult, where you would use the bite model to say okay, well it has this this this this and yeah, so let's have a look so behavior control. So these are the warning signs right like this is it says a co regulate Diet, Food, drink hunger and or fasting Well, thinking. So we'll be talking about today. Major time spent with group indoctrination and rituals and all self indoctrination including the internet, rewards and punishes punishments used to modify behavior, both positive and negative. Well, you know, rewards like getting into heaven. rewards like getting a promotion with LuLaRoe. Impose rigid rules and regulations instill dependency and obedience. So that's behavior. It obviously is a lot more but I'm just picking out things. Information control. So there's deception. So deliberately withhold information distort information to make it more accessible. Okay, withholding information like with the whole thing about even dieting that it is not something that is you know, losing weight it's not achievable. That's the being thing is gonna get you into heaven. Heaven. That with lm n LM LM M's LM Eminem m&ms, just call them m&ms With m&ms, that you're going to make tons of money and become rich and you're going to be successful if you get stomach amputation surgery because you're going to be taken into a leadership role. compartmentalize information into outside of us insider doctrine. So you see this a lot with m&ms. That they'll be like, Oh, the haters say that you can't make money from an lmm but they are just they're just haters, they don't know anything. They they say that we're a pyramid scheme. But we're not any company is a pyramid scheme because there's a CEO on top. And there's employees on the bottom there the real pyramid scheme. And also, you know, like with Nexium and stuff, it's kind of like very kind of suspicious of outsiders. extensive use of cult generated information and propaganda including newsletters, magazines, videos, YouTube, misquoting statements or using them out of context from non cult sources. Okay, so let's move to tea in the baits model thought control, require members to internalize the group's doctrine as truth. Adopting the group's map of reality, instead of black and white thinking decide between good and evil, organize people into us versus them insiders versus outsiders. Teaching thought stopping techniques which shut down reality testing by stopping negative thoughts and allowing only positive thoughts including denying reality of hunger and misery being on a diet and as well if we think about with m&ms, the idea of your you feel like you're doing bad because you're you're letting negativity into positive vibes only. Like just hustle, hustle, hustle and you'll you'll see success. Rejection of rational analysis Critical Thinking constructive criticism Yeah, so you know, you see a lot of people. If anyone criticizes the leader of anyone could criticize his organization they are ostracized they are told that you can't do that. Forbid critical questions about leader doctrine or policy allowed labeling alternative belief systems as illegitimate evil or not useful? instill a new map of reality if you become thin, then XYZ magical thinking will happen. And finally emotional control. So manipulative manipulated, narrow, the range of feelings, some emotions, and our needs are seemed as deemed as evil wrong or selfish. Yeah, so feeling hungry, needing food is wrong. Fear that the diet doesn't work. That's wrong. Yeah, making the person feel that the problem is always their own fault. Nevertheless, leader or the group's fault, it's not that the diet failed, you failed. Promote feelings of guilt or unworthiness. instill fear. Yeah, so it's not safe as food as unhealthy. We don't know how many calories certain things contain the hope that you will be good if you're thin. Extremes have emotional highs and lows. Yeah. So when you lose weight, how good do you feel if you put on weight? How bad do you feel? And the praise you get from the group if you lose weight, and then how bad you feel if you've put on weight?

What they're thinking about, you know, when I was a Weight Watchers, I used to weigh people on Weight Watchers. And I would be judging people so bad when they put on weight and they'd like I don't know how this happened. I didn't eat anything all week. And I'd be thinking and I'm sure you didn't. Okay, so no happiness offer for milk filament possible outside of the group, and terrible consequences if you leave. So especially with the getting into heaven if you're thin, death, and lovable, not able to play with your kids. If you leave the diet partner thinks your ugly family will redirect you reject you if you're fat. Yeah, yeah. Yeah. So that's the bite model. So wrapping it all up. Why do some cults, m&ms and religious groups coerce their members to die and become thing? Well let's let's wrap up with reading a little bit more from this Jezebel article. Who this is I think this is going to turn into the longest episode ever. So from Jezebel article, this sort of dangerous dieting dieting can serve paradoxical purposes. Making followers feel that they have power over their lives and bodies. While they're actually relinquishing their autonomy. It gives a believer a sense of control over their own destiny. I'm only going to eat these types of food I'm only I'm going to abstain from that type of food since Tuffle. But it also allows a group to control the individual. The Remnant fellowships may represent a dangerous extreme but religious and spiritual movements have always constructed dietary mandates. Food is a powerful determiner of group identities and rules surrounding it are deployed across cultures and faiths faiths it's like clothes that says Teva, which, what why is a certain type of clothes or hairstyle is such an integral part of religious identity? Because it's very, it's a very easy marker to demarcate and ingroup and differentiate them selves from outsiders. However, keeping kosher fasting for Ramadan, or opting for vegetarian dinner on Fridays are all compatible with meeting nutritional needs. And in most mainstream religious communities, believers can pick and choose which dietary restrictions to follow without fear of being ostracized. People can live perfectly healthy lives never eating a piece of pork says Gillespie. But when it's like don't eat the things that you want to eat or that your body is telling you you should eat. That's when it starts to get more risky in terms of developing disorders. The preferred diets of religious groups also have a history of working their way into secular culture. Early Seventh Day Adventist Adventists event Seventh Day Adventists helped create the wellness industry and advocated for vegetarianism and abstaining from sex and alcohol in pursuit of physical health and spiritual purity. Leaders of the church so table really popularized the idea of this pure, almost vegan diet that was supposed to detox your you spiritually and physically. Sylvester Graham motherfucker who helped the that's me adding that, who helped popularize vegetarianism in the US was a Presbyterian minister, who issued dietary guidelines that he believed would stave off moral decay. Eating the graham cracker he invented he promised would help prevent kids from masturbating. That's right. Campfire smalls were initially supposed to stop you from heading back to the tent and jerking it. That's why I hate this guy so much. Sylvester Graham is a piece of shit because he was basically like, everything that you do as a human as bad. And he really popularized circles circumcision. And that circumcision means that you can't wank is his thoughts. And so, if you really believed in God, you would circumcise your children, says that they cannot masturbate, therefore, they're more likely to get into heaven. And circumcision is all kinds of fucked up and an awful act that happily is falling out of fashion, in a lot of cultures. And as a British person, like circumcision is, you know, a very small percentage of babies are circumcised. I think in Canada, it's around about the 30% Nowadays, which is obviously still too much.

So the contemporary American health food industry has roots in 60s counterculture embrace of new religious movements. As devotees started brands and shops selling their preferred varieties of grew up. This historical melding of food and faith can be seen in the moralizing way we still talk about nutrition with foods labeled as good or bad, natural, unnatural or clean. Also, this is me talking now, also, we don't talk about in this article, like where did selvedge Sylvester Graham get his ideas from? And if we think about the racist origins of all of this stuff, and the ideas that that black folks were only interested in food and fornication, which also links that you know, Sylvester Graham, wanting people to eat his graham crackers and not masturbate and getting the four skins amputated in order so that they can't masturbate aligns up with those racist ideas that to be white is to be not interested in food and sex because that is a quote black trait, which is obviously wrong. And obviously fucked up. So In summary, why do some cults MLMs and religious groups, coerce them coerce their members to diet and become thin? Well, I think you know, it's three reasons. First is, is fat phobia. That's the, that's the, the underlying belief that phobia the belief that a fat body or a body that isn't thin, is bad, immoral, a sign of sin, a bad representation for the group. The second thing is sacrifice and piety, to show that you're really dedicated to the cause, there is an expectation that you will modify your behavior. And having a body that is thin is a walking billboard, of your devotion to the cause to the company. And finally, control. So weight loss can have devastating effects on our bodies and our minds, making us pliable, exhausted, confused, obsessed with food, weak, unstable, and desperate for salvation. Through our efforts, perhaps the leader will notice us and we will be anointed as redeemable and good. So how much of this ties into what diet culture does to us? I mean, I think a lot a basis of fat phobia, the idea that you're good if you diet and being controlled by a force that you are seeking approval from, and that approval will probably never come. In this case, society and oppressive systems that are designed to to keep you distracted. So I've made a Venn diagram, which I'm still working on, but the Venn diagram has diet, culture, MLMs, and cults. All overlapping, overlapping. So it's three circles all overlapping. And in that I've got you know how diet culture is related to MLMs. How MLMs are related to cults and how cults are related to diet culture. And the thing that ties them all together is fat phobia. And, and so I'm going to have that on my my Instagram. By the time this episode comes out, and so if you want to share these ideas about how they're all interconnected, and now in the core of all of it is fat phobia and the belief that fatness is bad and thinness will get you to heaven. Thinness will mean that you're, you're a better person, that you're more devoted, that you're more more presentable and someone that the company or the cult wants to have in their community. So okay, so we're at 90 minutes, you know, what is fuckin 2pm My time now and I'm, I'm fucking starving. After listening to all of this while I was talking about it, but also it's past my lunchtime. I mean, oh, my goodness, how much this is I'm feeling this right now. I am hungry. And I am my skin is hot. And I feel like electric feelings over my skin. This is what hunger feels like for me. My tummy is rumbling. Luckily, I have food ready to go. So I won't, I won't. I won't, I won't die.

So all right, this has been a kind of intense episode. So go and go and have a deep breath and do some relaxing. And if you're like me, you're probably gonna go and watch everything and read everything that's related to this stuff because I find it super interesting. Again, you can go to the show notes. First of all.com forward slash one to five if you liked this episode, and if you liked the podcast in general, go to Apple podcasts and leave a review I will be eternally grateful it would make me so happy and it means that other people can find the podcast so yeah. All right. Well, I find you on the next episode stay face fatty See you in a while like a to goodbye

thanks for listening to the episode and if you feel ready to get serious about this work and wants to know when the doors open to fears fatti Academy which is my signature program, where I teach all about how to overcome your fat phobic beliefs and learn to love your fat body. Then go to first party.com forward slash waitlist again that is fierce fatty.com forward slash waitlist to get your name on the way Wait List for when first party Academy my signature program opens.

EP124 Transcript

You're listening to The Fierce Fatty Podcast. I'm your host, Vinny Welsby. And this is episode 124, 10 hidden ways fatphobia looks in people's lives. Let's do it.

I'm Vinny Welsby, TEDx speaker, Best- Selling Author, and fat activist. I have transformed my life from hating my body with desperately low self esteem to being a courageous and confident fierce fatty who loves every inch of this jelly. Society teaches us living with a fat body is bad. But what if we spent less time, money, and energy on the pursuit of thinness and instead focused on the things that actually matter? Like if pineapple on pizza should be outlawed? Or if the mullet was the greatest haircut of the 20th century? So how do you stop negative beliefs about your fat body controlling your life? It's the Fierce Fatty Podcast. Let's begin.

Hello, hey, welcome. Welcome to this podcast episode. Welcome back. If you're returning listener, and hello, and come join us if you're a new listener. I'm feeling pretty good today. Because last episode or the episode before I said, Hey, can you make a review online for me on for Apple podcasts? And you did. Oh my God. Because I was like, Oh, my old reviews mentioned my name Victoria. And obviously I've since come out as non binary and have a new name, which is Vinny. And so you all have put my name in their hair. Thank you. So first review is from a florist who says Listen, five stars. I love listening to Vinnie. Yes, there. Thank you. Frank unapologetic attitude is perfectly balanced with thoughtful well researched analysis and plenty of humor. Thank you, Vinnie, for creating this podcast and for all you do. Exclamation mark. Thank you. A flast. Next one, Vinnie rocks five stars from Alex who says, Vinny is a voice of compassion. They are also intelligent, insightful and hilarious. Do yourself a favor and listen. Thank you. Thank you, Alex. Alex T S, I won't read your last name just in case I didn't know. I didn't know something would happen. But anyway. Next one, life altering five stars. Vinny is the mutts nuts. Oh, love it. They are hilarious, intelligent, empathetic, or round badass human being I truly wish the rest of the world could understand and be like them, it would be a much more pleasant and welcoming existence. Please keep this go wing exclamation hot, hot, hot, hot. And that's when we lose hate not wait. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Honestly, it makes me so you'll say nice things about my oh my goodness. Really? And when I when you read that, you know what you know, like when you say? I mean hilarious. I was thinking about this because I read these reviews earlier and I was like, because obviously I'm in a room on my own and I don't know if I do say funny things. I just I feel like I just talk about stupid shit like assholes and stuff. And so I'm like, all people being like, oh, for fuck sake, shut up talking about assholes all the time. But I don't know what I don't know if that's what it what is hilarious or something else is I don't know what it is. But yeah, I really appreciate it. And it just makes me curious about what it is. It's what it what it is that I say which is enjoyable or whatever or bla bla bla Yeah, maybe I need to stop talking about assholes so much. I was at the dog park the other day. And there was a new person because you know, there are dogs, but we've got a great little community here where I live. And so you kind of spot some new people and I was like, oh my god, they look rad. It was like a fat person. I was like, I'm gonna go talk to them. And yeah, and so I went and had a chat and, and one of the first things I said was like, Oh, look your dogs playing with my other dog. Doesn't that dog have a giant asshole? The dog's asshole was the same with it as its tail. It's a little dog and it was very quite peculiar and she enjoyed it.

She enjoyed the observation. She said, You know what? That dog does have a giant asshole Yeah, so I maybe I should just keep going on with my talking about assholes because Jessica liked it from the dog park. Either that or she was being very polite. I don't? I don't know. So thank you to Jessica, thank you to all of you who left me a review. And if you want to leave me a review, then you have to do it on Apple podcasts, I think I think I think that's where you can only do it, Apple podcasts. And two reasons. One, it is good for other people discovering more podcasts and more reviews, the better and the annoying thing about Apple is that they don't show the reviews from the world. And so if you're in like, Canada, we'll say 10 reviews. And if you're in the States, you might say 50 reviews and if you're in Ireland, it'll say two reviews. And so the more reviews from all around the world, the better because they don't show all the reviews and so someone new to the show might see, oh, Ireland only has two reviews. Vinny is a decade so I'm not going to listen to the podcast. So it's good for that. And also it just makes me happy. It makes me happy to read when people write nice shit about me versus the normal stuff that I read I'm joking it's not I don't I don't read that stuff anymore. My my wonderful assistant reads my inbox now so yeah, I don't have to read the bad stuff. So yeah, I like reading the good stuff. So today I want to share two couple of couple of things because today I always say this and this almost never happens that I think today's gonna be a shorter episode you wake up this motherfucker is gonna be like one hour 45 minutes long. No, no, I'm my guess is today's episodes can be 45 minutes long. But yeah, so I didn't actually tell you two things brought me happiness into my life recently. Two things which are accessible if you so choose to to want to get them. The first thing is have you ever heard of diamond painting? Diamond painting if you are on Tik Tok, you will probably have seen tic TOCs made about diamond painting what it is, it's kind of like paint by numbers. And so you get you can get it so I first got one from the pound land or dollar dollar store the dollar store there was a picture of a cat. I told you about this before when I made this picture of a cat is a little square thing and the board is sticky. And then you have a lot of little diamonds not diamonds a little pieces of plastic that look like do your mom teas, I guess. And you pick them up with a special pen that has this tacky stuff on and then you put it on the board and like sometimes if you get it right there might be like a clicking sound as you put it in because it Yeah, anyway, so satisfying. And I ordered a so I did that little cat one and I ordered from she in you know the clothing store. That's unethical. And so I wanted from she in like a kit, which has all like the different pens and gadgets or whatever, for like nine bucks and then ordered a picture which is kind of double the size of a4. So double the size of a laptop, I guess or 1/3 Slight size of a laptop, and a three size whatever. And it was like five bucks or whatever. Obsessed been sat there watching 90 Day fiance. Before the 90 days someone told me about it on on the on the Instagrams and so I've been I've been watching that season five, oh, so scandalous love it. No, no fatphobia that I've seen in it. So there was nothing in there where that was eyeroll in regards to fat phobia. So season five of beyond before the 90 days, 90 day fiance safe. Vinnie approved, it's safe. Obviously it's very, very trashy, I guess, you know, but sometimes you just got to watch this stuff and I haven't been I've been enjoying watching that doing my diamond painting or living my best life. The other thing that I've enjoyed getting is something called you know, polymers that do cocoa butter stuff. So Palmer's is called is face oil basically skin therapy oil, face visualage That's French for face. And it help kind of helps you helps because I've been putting on moisturizer at nighttime as well because my skin is kind of dry.

And then this is for kind of a Lots of different things, but it kind of helps even out your skin tone, because I get lots of red blotches on my face. I don't know why, but it's like, It annoys me. And sometimes they get, like, get hot. And anyway, so I started using this stuff for the last week or so. And they've they've, they've they're starting to go away. Could be coincidence. Could be placebo. Could be anything else. But yeah, it was like eight bucks or something from, you know, the local, the local drugstore. So yeah, there's two things. It's called Palmer's cocoa butter, skin therapy oil for your face. It smells nice. But don't rub it into your eyeballs because it's kind of a little bit stinky. Yours. Okay, so 10 hidden ways fatphobia lurks in people's lives, I want you to write out a list here a list a call of different things. So just so we're aware, all the different ways that fatphobia can sneak in. And, you know, sometimes you don't realize, oh, yeah, that is a little bit fat phobic. And when you think is weird, like with fat phobic beliefs we all have them is the most annoying is when you don't realize and most difficult is when you don't realize that something is fat phobic, because then you can't change it. Right? And so sometimes you need someone to point out oh, by the way, actually, that's something you know, maybe we can think about this in a different way, then you can start kind of pulling the thread of that belief and untangling it. And then next thing you know, you're feeling real fat positive. But yeah, sometimes you need to have someone who points out some of these, you might be like, Well, yeah, of course, this is fat phobia. And some of them maybe not so much. Or maybe all of them, who knows. But here we go, we're gonna go through the 10 of them. And the first one is actually two separate people have have clients, I've said this to me. And I was like, oh, yeah, yeah, that they have had people complain about how unattractive. So a friend, a friend. So let's say friend, person A, Person A says, I'm so fat and ugly. And they're saying it to person B, who happens to be bigger than Person A. And this happens quite a lot. And I might this is one rude as fuck, like, hello. You know, you've got this person who's in front of you, who's bigger, and you're like, I'm so fat. I'm so fat. And because I'm fat, I'm ugly. It's like, what does it mean about the person that you are saying that to what you think about their body like? And even though you know, they will probably like, oh, no, no, you look great. You look great, but just me me. I don't look great. Yeah, so that is the first way is they complain about how unattractive they are at their current weight to the bigger friend. And also can spring off from this leading leading on for this from this is treating fat people as the therapist. That is a big thing that we see happening is, is treating fat people like they're desexualized either they're either hyper sexualized or de sexualized. And if they're de sexualized, then they are the you know, the soft bosoms therapists type four straight sides people to complain to or smaller fat people to complain to. Because they must have oodles of compassion and endless energy to council people. Whereas you whereas people can be more respectful of straight size people and not turn them into like mother hen or within the black community. black activists talk about magnifying the magnification.

And, and so, yeah. So, yeah, they complain about how unattractive they are at the current weight to their bigger friend, which is also fat person being see seen as a therapist. I'm just typing this a little bit out as well, because I'm gonna make this into an Instagram post. Okay, so um, Someone might make fun, make fun of how fat, greedy, lazy or unhealthy they are. Okay, so if someone's doing that, to me, it's cringe, it's really cringe in regards to I'm like, oh, oh, you don't need to be doing that. And you're doing that because you think it's funny because it's true. You know. I've been guilty of this. I've been guilty of this, man, Big time, big time. And it just, again, any of these things don't doesn't mean that if you're doing them, or if you have done them that you're a giant piece of shit, and that you need to go away and you know, you're dead to me or anything. It's just it. Of course, we do these things, right. Of course, I used to make fun of being fat or being unattractive, or whatever. Because if I made fun of myself, then people couldn't hurt me by doing it themselves. And it would be like, quote, pointing out the obvious. The obvious is that my body is bad. So I'm gonna make fun of it and tell you, I'm not a threat. I'm not a threat to you. Because I know, my body is bad and unattractive. And I want you to know that I know. I'm not out here being fat and being unapologetic. I'm very apologetic. Gonna turn my phone on. So hopefully you can't hear. Can you hear that? I don't know. We just have to, you just have to, you'll have to put up with it. Cuz I'm wearing a hoodie. I'm not going anything underneath it. So I can't take it off. Well, I could I could get up and go to my bedroom. And but I'm not gonna, I'm gonna put the phone on. Yeah, so number two is make fun of how fat greedy lazy or unhealthy they are. And also that's tying in with health ism, with ableism, with colonial settler, settler capitalism, all that all that great stuff. And it makes sense why people won't do it. But it's kind of like, that's fatphobia that's locking. And people might do it to be safe. Okay, number three. They think so, Kay, for other people to be fat, but not me. I don't look good. Being fat, I look better when I'm smaller. Other people can be any size they want. I don't care. But for me, I just feel better when I have a smaller body. I know I'm healthier. When I have a smaller body. Yes. I know, I'm healthier. And these beliefs. These are really persistent beliefs that come up, come up of well, I know that when I was 25, and I was x pounds smaller, I would run triathlons. And I would I just felt so good in my body. And, and I was so healthy. And I know this is someone who is now currently 65 A and is like what's going on there? And obviously, you know you're on you know, that's hyperbole is an extreme example, but a lot of times people look back at two with rose tinted glasses two times where their bodies were smaller. And they say I just feel I feel I felt better. I know, I was healthier. I know, blah, blah, blah. And I'm going to continue on with this vein of thought and another one another number example. But kind of saying it's okay for others, but not for me. And, and it's wonderful that they can extend compassion to others. And I think this is really, really common. A lot of people feel like this, like, I know that fat people deserve equal rights and access and to be treated as human and all that type of stuff.

But for me, I know that I'm healthier and happier and feel more comfortable in a smaller body, which is underneath all of those that those things are a return of unhelpful, problematic, potentially bigoted beliefs. And so if we're having those beliefs, you need to be like, okay, okay, let's have a little thinking on gorgeous noggins of what is going on here. Is that true? Is Is it true and is it possible for me to be smaller and younger? Is it possible to, for me to now run in triathlons now that I'm 65? And I'm not fully. I mean, I'm, I'm disabled in some way or, you know, whatever, like, Is this is this, you know, can I keep the weight? Can I keep my weight off when, before when I was that way, I was engaging in disordered behavior, disordered eating, over exercising. And actually, I felt like a piece of shit, I didn't feel attractive, I just happened to look smaller, which was easier for me because I wasn't exposed to weight bias. And I was in a privileged size group, you know, so it's kind of like, what is going on here? Let's pull the thread a little bit, and try and look at it outside of it. It being okay for others, but not for me. And why that is? Why that why why is that? And I guess, you know, because theoretically, it's easier. It was not theoretically, it is easier to see someone on Instagram be like, yeah, you go girl, you go and show that you're, you're not seeing we're not seeing everything they've done to get there. And also, we're not seeing the hardships of what that might look like, you know, like, say, if someone is a super fat person, and they're on Instagram, having a bit of a dance, we're not seeing the all of the hate messages that they're getting in their inbox, we're not seeing their family members telling them that they need to lose weight and all that type of stuff. Whereas if if we are having to do that for ourselves, no matter you know, depending how privileged we are, we might see those same quote, consequences for living without shame. And it's too much. Also, we might have different expectations on perfectionism, which is white supremacy, culture, and, and compassion, were able to offer compassion to others. And were able to see them as unique individuals with a complex life and give them grace and be like, listen, they've probably struggled for a long time to get to that place. And Hell yeah, they should be, you know, celebrating their body and doing whatever. But for me, no, I just got to stop being so greedy and horrible, and bla bla bla, and I'll be thin and trying to expand it. Extend that compassion to yourself, which is really hard, right? Oh, my God, the same compassion that you might have for I know, a dog or something. Give it to yourself. You know, like, there's a meme that I loved it it was came out years ago and I just think about it. of you know, when you see an animal with a big tummy or what a you know, a big tummy and you know, stupid little fat thing and look at them little legs that they go look at those silly floppy ears, and you're just like, yes, such I'm just want to eat you because you're so cute. You know? And why is it we can, you know, do think about an animal who's got like a big belly or whatever, or, or, you know, in the the cats just given birth, and he's got like, these teats hanging down wobbling all over the place, and you're just like, Oh, look at those little things. We wouldn't think like that to ourselves. We wouldn't be like, tapped me. Then we should and we should, like Oh, yeah. It's nice when you do like that, you know, to be able to look at yourself, like, Oh, look at this silly little belly button. Or whatever it is, you know, it's cute. Ah, yeah.

Okay, so look. So number three was I think it's okay for other people to be fat, but not Moo. Number four wouldn't consider dating a fat person. So this might be difficult if you are in a relationship to consider this. And theoretically, you might say, of course, I would date a fat person. But when it comes down to it, I wonder if we would and I wonder at what size would we stop? You know, you might say I date a fat person, but you know, they have to be fat in the right way. If I'm looking at dating a sis hitman, he has to be you know, I could do fat with their husky. But what if they are very fat? Whoo. Maybe not. Okay, so why does that why does it stop there? What's going on? Why? Why might that be a cause for pause? It might not be for you. But I noticed Is because obviously I'm on I'm on the apps and I'm just so curious about the people that I swipe yes to in the sleep of people I select no to. And recognizing my, my, my bigotry, which is just simmering at the surface where I'm like making these sometimes unconscious decisions of yes, no, yes, no, yes, no, whatever. And what is going on? Why is it? You know, maybe, you know, why is it maybe I'm saying yes to more white people, or why is it that I'm saying? Yes to people who are more conventionally attractive? Or why is it you know, and just, that's, you know, that's why this shit takes a long time for me? Because I'm like, No, okay. All right. So on a niche initial pictures is, you know, it's a picture of him holding a fish. And you know, there's a picture of him with you, no, no, a baseball hat on and it looks like it might have an American flag or not, okay, I'm gonna give him the benefit of the doubt and presume he's not a Trump supporter or something. And obviously, I'm in Canada, that's nude is not going to happen. I'm going to presume that and I'm not I'm not a racist, and I'm going to read the bio to give him the benefit of the doubt. And the bio is like, I don't want no drama, from no bitches. And I'm like, Okay. And now I've gone into the details. I can, you know, safely swipe No. And so, you know, it takes time. But anyway, we all have these biases and asking this questions of, but why, why? Why wouldn't you date this person or not that person? I mean, I'm asking myself as well, you know, what is going on? What? What is attraction? What is What am I looking for? And, uh, no, annoyingly for me, a lot of times I'm attracted to people once I get to know the personality. So yeah, so for me, it's not necessarily as long as they're not forgetting, you know, profile pictures with you know, facial, you know, Trump flags or with a deck out or whatever. If they've got a some type of bio that's interesting, then I'm probably going to say yes. Yeah, so number four wouldn't consider dating of apples and this by the way, this is not what so when fat haters read this concept of your fat phobic if you won't date a fat person, what they hear is you must date and fuck fat people and if you don't, you are a bad person. That's not what this is. This is saying I know that there is not a single person on the in the whole world. On planet Earth there is not a single fat person that I deem worthy enough for me today or for me to fuck on that sole characteristic of fatness. Like I don't think that that's realistic. I think there there are plenty of you know even if you're uncomfortable with fatness there are probably plenty of fat is out there that you'd be like, oh, yeah, you know. And anyway, fat people don't want a charity fuck. Faculty. We're not on the corner being like, come on, please, please have sex with us. No, listen, if you don't want to have sex with perfect person, if you don't want to go on a date with a fat person don't. You don't have to, you know, fat people are not gonna be chasing you down saying Come on, you know, suck on my tits or something?

Oh, no, just let's think about it. This considerate. Let's see, let's let's be open. And also question why is it? Why is it I'm feeling like that? Why Wayne? Alright, number five. Think that if they are sick, or unable to move their body like they could before then it's 100% The fall of their size. So this is another thing I see quite a lot of think I've spoken about it on a couple of other episodes to have splash, especially post Panini, where someone you know, three years ago before the Panini was going to yoga a couple of times a week and was socializing with people in person and was not living in a global pandemic. And they, they were happier. And since the pandemic they've put on weight. They've not been able to go to yoga, they stopped doing it. The mental health isn't That's good. And therefore, you know, they're not able to do yoga, handstands or whatever it is that you do in yoga. And so they then see the fact that they've put on weight and be like, Uh huh, well, 1am one equals three, I cannot do these things. Because because I have a bigger body. And I'm sad, because I have a bigger body. And I have depression. And it's probably because I have a bigger body. And that is it, you know, it's and so therefore, if I lose weight, then I'll be good at yoga, again, I'll be happy again, I'll be, I'll be healthy in all these different ways. And, you know, the reason why we think like that is because that's what society has told us is lose weight and run through the streets, through the code for the cornfields into the arms of your handsome lover, and everything will be alright in the world. And unfortunately, it's a lot more complicated than that. And so, again, it's kind of like the shades of gray thinking, which is, you know, this is an extension of, it's okay for other people to be fat, but not me. And it's this black and white thinking of, if I am sick, it's because I, because of my body and my size, if you've if you've if you are fat, or if you've put on weight, or even you can be straight size and be like, Okay, well, I need to lose weight to get healthy in whatever way. And we need to start being a little bit more like detectives, and get out those magnifying glasses and being like, okay, let's dissect it and see what's going on with life. Versus, Oh, absolutely, this is absolutely the fault of my, my body size. So that's number five. Number six, they talk about food as something that they can't control themselves around moralizing it, or feeling superior for eating, quote, good food. So this is quite, I think, quite a common one.

As in, you know, we all know this is not great, but I think we sometimes have language that is so second nature, we need to stop and think before, saying these types of things of, Oh, you must get this thing out of my house. Because I can't I can't live if there's a piece of chocolate in the cupboard somewhere because I'll just eat it, I'll eat it, it'll eat it and eat it and it'll like die. And there's no chocolate left in the world. And, oh, it's just I've been so bad recently. And all we're being naughty by eating this thing. And, and that group talk of that. And, and even if you're not saying those things, if you're engaged in in a group, and I know this can be very complicated, there's lots of different things at play. But if you're surrounded by people, and you're, and they're constantly talking like that, and you have the capacity in regards to privilege, and the personality type and power dynamics to say, hey, that ain't cool, then it's like fatphobia is just there sitting, festering, like some dirty shit, that's just been put in the conversation. And we need to just not have that happen. And again, it's complicated, right? If you're, if you're a fat person, you've got a group of friends who are thin, and you're at work, and they're all talking about how they like, you know, all they want to do in their lives is lick lettuce leaves and, and how being thin is the best thing ever, and all that type of stuff and your boss is saying it, the the dynamics there probably don't lead for it to be a great idea for you to be like, shut the fuck up with it about this stuff. Because there's so many different things at play, right? But there could be opportunities in our lives where we do have the ability to say something, and it still might be a risk. And I think it's important to take those risks because it's not cool to let fatphobia hang around like a dirty turd. You know? No one likes a dirty turd in a hat. fatphobia thinks so nasty one. No amount of popery is going to PooPourri you know that stuff that you spray in the toilet? That's good stuff that is no amount of poop or is going to clean up that smelly turd, or fat phobia. Oh yeah. So seven, they zoom in and examine photos of themselves with a critical lens, or don't even want to be in the photo in the first place. Okay, so a lot of people will be like, Yeah, that's me, again, doesn't mean you're a bad person. But what is going on here? Why is that? Why are you comparing the size of your arm to the person next to you? And oh, maybe your arm is a little bit thinner. Okay, that makes me good. No, no, and maybe it's a little bit bigger or look at my size. I'm a dummy. Look at my face. Oh, the camera is a low angle, and therefore I looked bad. And oh, God, take another picture or don't even take my picture. Oh, it's just a big thing for a lot of people. And why? Why? What is going on? What beliefs are coming up? What is wrong with the visual representation of you? And it mean, I don't know the answer. In regards to for you, girl. You might be like, Vinnie, I fucking love a photo. And that's Glasgow was great. And if you don't, it doesn't mean that you're a bad person again, it? It's, it's Is this a manifestation of fat phobia? Is this fat phobia ruling your life? What is going on here? What's going on? And it's just a nice clue. I say, I like it when we are able to recognize things that we're not able to do because of how we think about ourselves, or how we think about fat bodies. Because it's giving us the clues. You know, it's like we're in an escape room. And finally, there's another clue. And you can like, oh, yeah, if I can, yeah, I'm gonna open the door. And so it's a clue that there's something there for you to work on. And there's some beliefs there that probably aren't helpful for you? And is it fair for you to be erased from your own personal history and have no photos for you to look back on? You know, is it fair for you to be so cruel about yourself when you're looking at those photos? No, is the answer. Because you're like, yes, it is. Yes. It is. It is fair for me to be me. No, no, it's not. It's not. So what's going on there? What beliefs do you have? Let's see if we can untangle them.

Okay, so that was seven, zoom in and examine photos with a really critical lens, or don't even want to be in the photo in the first place. Number eight, feel relief? at the thought of at least I'm not as big as her and her being person who is bigger than them. So it could be her, him? them, whatever. At least I'm not as big as her. And that sense of relief of, oh, well, you know, well, I'm not that size. So I'm not that bad. And, and it's self soothing, right? That is self soothing. It's self soothing. And, and it makes sense why we do that. And also, to what end? How is that helping us? Is that? Does that align with our values? And it might be temporarily relief, of how we're feeling. But, you know, to what end, and I, I catch myself doing not that but things like things to make myself feel better. Like I was talking to Lauren from feelgood dietitian about this, we did a live together and I was like, Oh, my God, go into people who are like you, like, colleagues of mine in the industry, who maybe I don't know, personally, and go into their Instagram pages and being like, Oh, well, look at them. They've got like, they've got more following followers than me. And people like them better than me. And what is it? They probably hate me, they probably think that I'm really unintelligent, they probably think that I'm a piece of shit. Well, well, well. Well, I think they're, they must be mean, they must be a bad person. Look, there, their opinions are trash, and I'm more intelligent than them. And even though I've got less followers, I get more likes in my last photo than they got and, and then I'm like, really? What are you doing? What are you doing? And yeah, that, you know, the other side of my brain is like, and I stopped doing this, but then there's another part of my brain is like, I need to soothe in some way and okay, you know, I'm gonna go look at some other things that make me feel better and, and so it's normal. And it's normal for us to compare ourselves to other people, but it doesn't feel good. I know for me, it fucking doesn't. It doesn't. So let's just not do it. And this one obviously this is definitely you know, your this is fat phobic, right? Because you're saying at least I'm not as awful as that person because that person will fool for that their life must be shit because of the size of them. Oh my god, you know, it's very judgmental versus versus coming from a place of oh, I acknowledge my privilege. And, you know, I might be having a hard time in life, but I don't have to deal with the extra bullshit that comes from living in a bigger body. You know, it's not that that's not what that statement is about, is it? That statement is like, well, I might be ugly, but I'm not as ugly as you. That's like, oh my god, I hate this. I hate this. But I used to think it was such a good comeback of if someone says you're fat. And the comeback being, well, at least I can lose weight, you can't fix your ugly face. And I think that's such a good comeback. Because it was like, yeah, man, I could get thin and beautiful worries, you're stuck being fucking ugly. And it's just, it's not good. If you're making if you're, if that was one of your comm. bucks. I think we should just use this. Let's put that one in the bin. Let's put that one in the bin. Because well, I mean, it's not even true. Is it? You know, we can't we can temporarily make ourselves thin. But yeah, it's like appearance based. Insults is, is always not a good look. Always not a good look. And where as well, where are those coming from? Anytime I make an anytime I have in the past because I don't do it now. Make appearance based insults, it's really coming from a deep place of shame, deep place of shame. And that's the only power I can get back is by insulting someone's appearance. Fun times fun times. Fun times. Okay, so number nine.

Thinking that an alpha only looks good or better. If shapewear is worn underneath, and believes it's a way fat folks must control their body. So shape wear, again, is complicated. Some people will wear shapewear for lots of different reasons. And it's not to do with what it looks like. It could be Century century stuff, sensory stuff, it could be it just it. It I don't know, whatever. It could be something which is not fat phobic. And even if it is, I think that I look better when I'm wearing shapewear. If that's how you need to do things. That's how you need to do things. I saying this on the podcast a couple of episodes ago, like shit, if that's how your your affiliate feel comfortable right now, then that's it, that's fine. If you need to do that right now then that's, you know, that's just where you're at. But I think what it is, is the idea that I've seen on a lot of accounts of, you need to be wearing shapewear. You need to be smoothing this out. And so this is kind of like you need to do this. Versus I'm doing this for me, and this feels good. And I know it's probably not the best and I probably want to get away from it. Versus the Whoo, that dress does not look good. Because I can see every wrinkle and bump and cellulite. You should really put on some Spanx. You're ugly, you know, you know. And so the difference being to conform as a fatty people are people, you know, having the belief that you need to and others, others need to. Others need to too, because if they're not they're letting the side down because they don't look as good. Because the real deep belief that fat bodies look better refer squeezed and you know, squashed into shapewear. Which is some people could say I mean it's true. It's a it's objectively true that fat bodies look better in Spanx. And I would challenge that like, is it? Why is it why do we believe that? Where's that? Where has that come from? Is that is that a belief or is it a fact? Are their bodies that are fat and not controlled in that way that are also beautiful. I mean, you think so. And finally, number 10 They view fat people as angry can planers unreasonable or excessively large slash scary especially black men. So I want to give a trigger warning because I'm going to be talking about police brutality here. I would say just skip to the end of the episode because I yeah yeah for the rest of the episode that we're gonna be talking about so viewing fat people as angry and complainers and unapproachable and scary and and we know we've seen this post lindo bacon stuff that's going on of fat people are just unreasonable and and we've seen this with police brutality and I took I took this week was it this way last week. So now we're now gonna positivity pride, which is an account on Instagram, hosted fat positive di CrashCourse dei diversity, equity and inclusion. So fat positive dei crash course you can go and check it out yourself. But so something there that they were talking about, and I'm just going to give you a little snippet and if you want to learn more, you should go to now go now gonna positivity pride, check out the show notes for a link to it to take this course is it's cheap, right? It's like,

I think I paid like 75 bucks is like a sliding scale. And it's an obviously it's really important because these are the who's teaching it is to women of color. Anyway, so just a little kind of overview about that is one slide. They're all talking about how on. So Mike Brown, in 2014, was murdered by a police officer in Ferguson, and he was 18. And what the police officer said about this murder, because he was a fat black man. The police officer descriptor also officer described Mike Brown as quote, Hulk Hogan claimed that he shot Brown. As he shot Brown, he quote, bulked up to run through the shots. And he called him a demon and claimed that Brown was looking through him. And so I think that's that's that's really important stuff that NPP are talking about and I'll go into positivity, pride, pride in this presentation, which is fat positive dei Crash Course, which is a two to over two days. And it's talking about as well like this stuff and also fatness in the media and all that type of stuff and really interesting, really interesting stuff. And so thinking about how how we view fat bodies and how, you know, at the beginning, I was saying about how we see you know, the fat person has a Saraf bit therapist and mummified and either hyper sexualized, you know, like, BB W big, beautiful woman, and let's not treat them as humans and fetishize them and consensually or totally. De sexualized, and, and then as well, we see with a police brutality, fat black men being seen as an human, like, you know, because they're big, seen as needing, I think it was like 12 bullets that Mike Brown was shot. The officer, the guy that murdered him. And, you know, why was such force needed? And obviously, this is just one example. There's many, many, many, obviously, as we all know. And so how are we viewing people what is going on when we're seeing when we're seeing fat people on the internet and the fat person is angry? And what else is going on? And so if they're fat, and they're also black, and if they're fat, and they're also neurodivergent and black and if they're fat and have other other intersectionality going on? What is good? What is coming up for us? And asking that question. Is this my ableism? Is this my fat phobia? Is this my racism and white supremacy that is telling me that I don't like this person. I don't like the way that they are talking. I don't like the way they're going about things. What is going on here? And again, like questioning ourselves, what is what is happening with this stuff? So, yeah, let me round up all 10 of those. So 10 hidden ways fatphobia looks in people's lives. Number one, they complain about how unattractive they are at their current weight to their bigger friend, which is obviously problematic because they're complaining about their size when their friend is fatter. So what do they think about their fat friend, and also, it's putting that fat friend into that role of therapist and person who listens to the problems of others, which is a trope. Number two, making fun of how fat really lazy or unhealthy they are. Number three, number three, they think it's okay for other people to be fat, but not me, I just know that I'm healthier, better looking and feel more comfortable when I have a smaller body. Number four, wouldn't ever consider dating a fat person or has a weight limit on how fat they might date or have sex with.

Now, number five, think that if they are sick or unable to move their body like they could before if they had a smaller body, then it is 100% the fault of their body and how it's changed. Number six, they talk about food is something that they can't control themselves around moralizing it, or feeling superior for eating, quote, good food. Number seven, they zoom in and examine photos of themselves with a critical lens or don't even want to be in the photo in the first place. Number eight feel relief at the thought of at least I'm not as big as her and her being the person who is bigger than them. When it could be anyone at least I'm not as big as them. Number nine, they think that an outfit only looks good on themselves or other people, especially fat people if they are wearing shapewear. And believing that fat people need to control their body and squeeze their body into shape where to be seen as acceptable. And number 10 They view fat people as angry complainers, unreasonable, or excessively large and scary. And that is that last point, especially for fat black men. And now a reminder that if you are doing any of these things, it makes sense we live in a violently fat phobic society. And there's lots of things that we do to try and conform. And so if you're doing any of these things and feel guilty or bad, I don't want you to at all, but sometimes we need to have someone point out how these things are contributing towards fat phobia. So we can start to unpick them, untangle them and remove them from our lives. If it's if it's something that is accessible to us. Sometimes, it's easier to engage in these types of things because we it's not safe for us to not wear shape where it's not safe for us to not eat healthy quotes, or good food because we don't want to be seen as a bad, fatty. And so all of this with a lot of nuance, and a lot of compassion for yourself and others who might be struggling with this with these things. And also, let's work to try and change this stuff because it's not the great No, it's not the greatest. Okay, okay. Okay. Okay, so yet again, it's 54 minute episode. I guess 44 But no 45 But no. No like to chat. I like to have a chinwag. So I have a chinwag. Alright, thanks for hanging out with me today. So I hope you over have fun hanging out with me being my friends. Will you be my friends? And I'll see you in the next episode. Have a wonderful rest of your day. See you in a while. Alligator stay fierce Fadi.

Thanks for listening to the episode and if you feel ready to get serious about this work and want to know when the doors open to fears fatti Academy which is my signature program, where I teach all about how to overcome your fat phobic beliefs and learn to love your fat body, then go to fifth fatty.com forward slash waitlist again that is phase fatty.com. Forward slash waitlist to get your name on the waitlist. For when first fatty Academy my signature program opens

EP123 Transcript

Welcome to the Fierce Fatty Podcast. I'm your host, Victoria Welsby and this is episode 123. Today, we're talking about “Fat and Trans Identities Intersecting”.

I'm Victoria Welsby TEDx speaker, Best Selling Author, and fat activist. I have transformed my life from hating my body with desperately low self esteem to being a courageous and confident fierce fatty who loves every inch of this jelly. Society teaches us living in a fat body is bad. But what if we spent less time, money, and energy on the pursuit of thinness and instead focused on the things that actually matter? Like if pineapple on pizza should be outlawed? Or if the mullet was the greatest haircut of the 20th century? So how do you stop negative beliefs about your fat body controlling your life? It's the Fierce Fatty Podcast Let's begin.

Hello, and welcome to this episode my sweaty nipples 60. Man. How you doing? How's life? Good. Good. Hi, welcome to this episode, we're talking about trans shit today.

And just want to give you a trigger warning at the top of the show here. I'll also give you more when we're up close to the time but we're gonna be talking about gender dysphoria. Also transphobia in the medical system, but fat phobic beliefs and sis het men nonsense. So if that's not feeling good for you today, then skip this episode. But if you're like, Ah, I'm not sure. We'll see when we get there all. I'll tell you when I'm going to read say certain things on on QA, all QA. All right, so we're hate 123 and welcome to the episode.

First thing I just wanted to share with you is that if you are a social worker, or in the mental health field, or are interested in that type of stuff, or are fat or human, you might be interested to, to know that the International Journal of social work values and ethics, volume 19 has a piece in there, which is called weight stigma as a violation of the NASW Code of Ethics a call to action NASW I'm guessing its National Association of Social Workers. Question mark. I'm sure it's something like that. Anyway. So Nancy Ellis Ordway and a Virginia, Ramsay, winter, have written this piece I'm going to give you a little excerpt here is going to be about a minute.

So this is something that's come out in 2022, which says weight stigma is a violation of the Social Work Code of Ethics, given that weight loss attempts have been shown to be harmful and ineffective, and that they increase weight stigma the National Association of Social Workers. Yeah, that's that's what I said, Isn't it National Association of Social Workers urgently needs to revise its response to weight loss endorsement. social determinants of health. A robust robust indicator of population wellbeing, are ignored when interventions focus on decreasing the body size of individuals when considering intervention. Individuals full stop when considering interventions, the field of social work has responsibility to consider the evidence of what helps as well as what harms as social workers, we need to examine our own attitudes for the biases that may harm the very people we are directed to help. The Code of Ethics gives us clear direction when applied to the topic of weight stigma.

Kill so if you are being told by a social worker, or if you're a social worker, and you're being told by your boss or other social workers, that you need to tell people to lose weight, you can say it is a violation of the National Association of Social Workers code of ethics. And then putting them to this document which has lots of different things in it, but it's on blabbermouth. It's going to the right to the top. Why is this so slow? I'll link to this in the show notes. It is on page 6565.

So we'll link to that in the show notes show notes. As always, first party.com forward slash podcast for the actual actual episode. Always the same fist of it.com forward slash 123. It's not always the same as in it's always the same format is the episode number. Lord Jesus.

Yeah, so facebook.com forward slash 123. So you can get your little paws on that. But today, I wanted to talk about trans stuff trans stuff, specifically because one, I read this piece that I enjoyed and to this trans non binary incredible human begging me, Yeah, boy, is going on a date. I've been thinking about this, you know, you know, when you say your girl is doing that, and I'm like, what feels right, because it's not your girl. Your boy feels more but not really. So what what would be a non gendered version of, say, gender? Yeah, human, your friend, your friend is going on a date tonight is my second date with this one guy. And shit is coming up in my brain. And it has been.

It has been since I realized that I was non binary like this stuff has just been percolating. And if anyone else is out there dealing with gender stuff, I just want you to tell you what my brain is saying. No, I'm not the expert on this stuff, because I'm still learning and figuring it out. And Holy fucking shit is so complicated and difficult and blah, blah, blah.

But even if you're not thinking about, you know, gender stuff, this intersects with fat stuff, too. So it's its own frost on so there is a, so there's a group of psychotherapists, and it's called affirmative couch.com. And they write pieces. There's a different group of different therapists there. One of them is called M Addison Tucker, they them pronouns. And they wrote a piece at the intersection of fat and trans. And so, the first half of it is talking about like, what is fatness and blah, blah, blah. And then next, we go into the intersection of fat and trans. And I wanted to read out this.

Read out some of this stuff, just an FYI about Addison Tucker's identity. Addison says I'm a fat, queer, able bodied, neurotypical, white and cisgender femme person. They say they're cisgender in this piece, but then when I went on to their bio, it says that now that they're a non binary femme, so that would then now currently make them not cisgender. Unless I don't know which one is the more up to date, I'm going to presume them being non binary is the more up to date thing.

So So So sir, again, I'm going to link to this in the show notes. And what Addison is saying is that they, their clients, they have a lot of gender diverse clients, and that they help them with immunotherapy stuff. And so this is what they've seen as a they're a small fat person. They're white, non binary neurodivergent able bodied, what they have seen, with their years of specializing in gender diverse people, and that intersection of fat and trans now, I only have my very short lived experience of non binary pneus. And, you know, coming you know, it was maybe a year old of me realizing that I'm non binary maybe a little bit longer because I was, you know, talking about it with my therapist for a long time. And and so, I've only got my experience to go on in regards to just a year and obviously the privileges that I hold as someone who when people perceive me they just perceive a woman right. And so my experience of trans non binary nurse is is very different from other people in regards to I can walk down the street and not have to fear for

My life as a non binary person potentially as someone considering the a woman and you know violence against women but that's that's like the privilege that I hold and on dating sites. Men just view me sis hat man just view me as a woman, even though even though in my bio, which they don't read they I say I'm not and then I get you know the first message. Oh my god, you were such a beautiful woman. You're my dream lady. Oh, you're such a womanly figure and Lola Loyle this fucking stuff. And then I'm like, Oh, by the way, thank you, by the way, I'm not a woman. And then like, what? Some people are like, oh, yeah, that's whatever, that's fine. And other people. One guy the other day was like, what's that? And I said, Google it and then I never heard from it again.

Good, whatever. Who knows why, but you know, I'm just like, I'm done educating these these ding dongs?

Yes, so let me just read this. This is not too long. But here I'm gonna go in if this doesn't feel good, and then we reading examples of transphobia intersecting with fatphobia and then I'm gonna then give you another trigger warning when I read a specific article about something that happened I'm going to tell you what that is when I get there. So if this is not feeling good, skip ahead. 20 minutes

Unknown Speaker 11:24

now I'll see you on the other side for some hilarious

Unknown Speaker 11:29

sarcasm. Is that sarcasm me saying hilarious is some of these hilarious and also very sad experiences that I've had with with men and people's people's theories about that. So I skip ahead, maybe 20 minutes and you'll you'll hear that if not, let's go into this. Okay, so this is from the post. And so I'm skipping, skipping ahead about the fat stuff because we've we talked about the fat stuff all the time. So we're gonna pick up here here where it says, at the intersection of fat and trans, when we talk about the above concepts in relate relation to fatness they also hold true for other identities and so they're talking about

Unknown Speaker 12:08

fat phobia and weight stigma.

Unknown Speaker 12:11

They also hold true for other identities that experience oppression eg race, gender, ability, sexuality, T, G, and B. So that's trans gender non binary folks. I always thought it was transgender non binary, folks, but apparently, I'm gonna Google where because I T G and biodiesel is transgender. non binary, but apparently trans and gender non binary hang on bear with me color trans I'm gonna have to Google it

Unknown Speaker 12:41

and have to put in have to type in words. Yeah, this is in this is transgender, slash non binary. Okay, so whatever, we're just gonna, we're just gonna say it could be either or, but it's the same.

Unknown Speaker 12:57

What is it pulling hairs picking hairs? Whatever. pulling teeth? No, that's whatever splitting hairs there we go splitting hairs splitting hairs.

Unknown Speaker 13:06

On that, so anyway, T G Nb is transgender non binary true. So let us continue. TGFB folks experienced transphobia sis sexism, sis heteronormative expectation expectations.

Unknown Speaker 13:21

We'll be talking about that in a second. And pressures to fit into white binary understandings of gender. IE, what is suppose what it supposedly supposedly means to be a man or a woman. Because T, G and B people are often valued based on how well their bodies quote, fit into these expectations. It follows that they would also be held to standards of body size, shape and weight, adding weight stigma to the other pressures that a T, G and B person experiences along with their own struggles with their body is like a shaken soda bottle of oppression waiting to explode. Here are several ways that a TG MB person might experience the cumulative and harmful effects of size ism, and fatphobia in the context of their trans SNESs.

Unknown Speaker 14:13

So just a quick terminology thing, in case you're like, What the fuck is even going on here. Trans is someone who doesn't identify with the gender that was assigned to them at birth. Cisgender is someone who does identify with the with the identity. They were assigned at birth.

Unknown Speaker 14:33

Someone who is non binary doesn't necessarily have to identify as trans.

Unknown Speaker 14:40

Everyone identifies a different things, but that's kind of like a quick and dirty thing. You know, I would identify as trans non binary

Unknown Speaker 14:49

so that people don't just think I'm a woman. Like I want them to know. This is like, I don't know

Unknown Speaker 15:00

Hey, I'm not messing about

Unknown Speaker 15:03

a guy.

Unknown Speaker 15:04

Okay, so a trans masculine person eats. Okay, so we're gonna go into example. So. So if this doesn't feel good, skip ahead

Unknown Speaker 15:15

10 minutes, a trans masculine person eats as little as possible to shrink his body and appear more androgynous by reducing the width of his hips and size of his chest.

Unknown Speaker 15:29

Yes, so I was talking to a trans masculine person about then putting on weight and it causing a lot of feelings coming up. And

Unknown Speaker 15:45

you know, why? What is going on there? And it's kind of like with a, with a cisgender person, then we can more easily identify if, if the source of it is fat phobia. Whereas with a

Unknown Speaker 15:59

TG, NB person,

Unknown Speaker 16:03

it's harder because is it dysphoria? Exactly. Like this example example. If you have more fat on your body, is it the fact that you appear more, quote, feminine?

Unknown Speaker 16:21

Is it also fat phobia? Or is it only fat phobia? And literally, like,

Unknown Speaker 16:28

everyone, and is it also

Unknown Speaker 16:32

getting sexism and

Unknown Speaker 16:36

all sorts of different things going on, right?

Unknown Speaker 16:40

And so it's a lot more complicated. So to kind of be like, Okay, well, I

Unknown Speaker 16:46

would, as a trans person,

Unknown Speaker 16:50

trying to be thin,

Unknown Speaker 16:55

temporarily, because obviously, we can't be thin long term. Unless you're thin already.

Unknown Speaker 17:01

Code trying to lose weight is what I'm trying to say could trying to lose weight help with my feelings of gender dysphoria knowing that, and so I work on that temporarily, as I welcome those feelings of gender dysphoria, and see if I can come up with ways to to to cope or whatever or, you know, some other tactics or whatever, and, and then, maybe, when I put weight back on, because that's what's probably going to happen, then I'm maybe in a better place, maybe, or maybe not to deal with the stuff. And so it's complicated, right? So saying,

Unknown Speaker 17:36

don't lose weight. Even though we know it's a temporary thing might not be helpful for people if the feeling of dysphoria is so overwhelming, and it can be for a lot of people. Okay, so moving on, a non binary person hesitates to go to the gynecologist for worsening pelvic pain, because when they initially brought it up, the doctor said that the pain was weight related. You are a trans feminine person fears going out on a date because she can't blend enough with her large belly.

Unknown Speaker 18:09

An agender person has to search endlessly for affordable clothing that both fits their large body and also feels congruent with their gender. Here's something that I was thinking about the other day is, when I was on that documentary, we went to a a shopping center, a mall for North American people.

Unknown Speaker 18:33

And the crew wanted us to buy some clothes for a photoshoot. And we've all said, Are there any plus size stores? Because we all know that that even though we're in a big city, there's probably not gonna be a single place there that has clothes to fit us. And they were like, oh, yeah, yeah. Yeah, we checked this was one store and they carry plus. And we got there and that one store that carries plus, if you're curious, it was new look.

Unknown Speaker 19:03

They were like, oh, yeah, yeah, we carry plus online. And so you know, there was a scene that was cut from the episode where all stood outside being like, we've I can told you, we told you there is no way for any of us even,

Unknown Speaker 19:18

you know, the smaller medium fat people to go apart from the guys who went downstairs to this big apartment store, department store, John Lewis, which is what it's called. And two of them were able to find something that that fit two of them, or more, you know, three that the men who were bigger than the women, most women

Unknown Speaker 19:44

were able to find stuff.

Unknown Speaker 19:47

And but then it would be masculine clothes, right? And so,

Unknown Speaker 19:53

a

Unknown Speaker 19:55

trans you know, an agender person has to search endless.

Unknown Speaker 20:00

sleeve for affordable clothing that both fits their large body and also feels congruent with their gender. If they don't just want to wear men's clothes, quote, men's got, you know, masculine clothes, then that's going to be an issue. Like for me, I like wearing. I really like Adidas, or Adidas, as you'd say in North America.

Unknown Speaker 20:24

Like Adidas, I managed to find myself in Adidas tracksuit. It's a men's one

Unknown Speaker 20:31

that fits, I couldn't fit into the women's ones.

Unknown Speaker 20:35

But for me, that was okay for me because I didn't care because I would rather be if it was the other way around. If I was non binary, and I was assigned male at birth, I think that would be triggering for having to buy a man's size if I identified more as a woman do you see what I'm saying?

Unknown Speaker 20:59

But because I'm I'm more leaning towards

Unknown Speaker 21:03

neutrality.

Unknown Speaker 21:05

And masculinity is also feels fine for me. It wasn't an issue. But if I wanted to find more Addy das stuff, and I was really didn't want any masculine stuff. I'd be SOL, right? Because there isn't, you know, unless you're a medium fat person you knew by like, Ivy Park by Beyonce, which goes up to and again, you'd have to be buying the gender neutral stuff, which goes to a 5x and the women's range goes to a 3x.

Unknown Speaker 21:41

So yeah.

Unknown Speaker 21:44

Again, it's it's it's difficult. It's difficult. Anyone knows anyone who works at Ivy Park and they want to send me clothes?

Unknown Speaker 21:55

Can you please do that? I would literally shit out shit in a box with excitement. Because I love it so much, but it's just too expensive for me to spend.

Unknown Speaker 22:09

I love it so much.

Unknown Speaker 22:11

But then I'm thinking will it fit though? I don't know. Anyway, okay, let's move on. Now moving on. Moving on. A gender queer person wants to fly without drawing attention to themselves, but they face ridicule when going through the security body scanners. And then I looked at with disgust while walking down the airplane aisle due to their body size. You know those scanners?

Unknown Speaker 22:32

Oh, it's so invasive. It's so invasive. A trans woman's doctor does not refer her to get treatment for her anorexia because he reasons that restriction might help her lose weight.

Unknown Speaker 22:45

Yeah, and I wonder I wonder being a trans woman

Unknown Speaker 22:50

versus being a trans man.

Unknown Speaker 22:54

A trans woman the doctor might be like, well,

Unknown Speaker 22:58

they want to be feminine. Therefore they need to be thinner to be feminine.

Unknown Speaker 23:03

Maybe just haven't I guess.

Unknown Speaker 23:09

Either way, this happens to all genders.

Unknown Speaker 23:11

How many fat people have gone to the doctors and they've been like I've lost weight because I have an eating disorder. The doctors congratulations fat at your final finally worthy because you lost some weight. Keep going. Oh, but I'm dying doesn't matter.

Unknown Speaker 23:26

Yeah, fun. Okay, a trans adolescent is extremely uncomfortable in their body due to the compounded effects of going through puberty. Puberty as a fat person. Yes.

Unknown Speaker 23:39

Yeah.

Unknown Speaker 23:42

Yeah, puberty is a puberty as a fat person.

Unknown Speaker 23:47

Yeah.

Unknown Speaker 23:51

I'm just thinking, I'm just thinking, I'm just thinking, I'm just thinking about how I fell as a fat as a fat person. Totally. D.

Unknown Speaker 24:04

D, sexualized. Like, one of the guys. I think that as well had to a little bit to do with my personality too. Because I was like the jokester, you know, because I was like, Well, no guy is ever going to fancy me. So I might as well be the class clown, you know.

Unknown Speaker 24:23

And so it felt like, it didn't matter that I was going through puberty, because it wouldn't have an effect on who would find me attractive.

Unknown Speaker 24:38

But then imagine if, if you Yeah, if you're going through puberty, if you're thinking about gender stuff, exactly hear uncomfortable in their body due to the compounded effects of going through puberty as a fat person? Yeah, you're okay. A pregnant trans man gets mistaken for being fat and doesn't get the

Unknown Speaker 25:00

Emergency emergency medical care he needs. Note, an article was recently published about this exact situation. Okay, so here I'm going to talk about

Unknown Speaker 25:11

I'm going to read an article from USA Today about this experience of a trans man getting mistaken for fat. So if you don't want to hear about trans man, pregnancy and him losing that pregnancy, skip ahead four minutes. Okay. So the story that

Unknown Speaker 25:32

we're talking about here,

Unknown Speaker 25:35

come on my tab. Okay, so, Nurse mistakes pregnant transplant transgender man as fat I'm going to change to words, then man births are stillborn baby. When the man arrived at the hospital with severe abdominal pains and nurse didn't consider it an emergency, noticing that he was fat, and had stopped taking blood pressure medicines. In reality he was pregnant, a transgender man in labor that was about to end in a stillbirth. The tragic case described in Wednesday's New England, New England Journal of Medicine points to two larger medical issues about assigning labels or making assumptions in a society increasingly confronted, confronting gender variations in sports, entertainment and government. In medicine, there is a similar danger of missing diseases such as sickle cell and cystic fibrosis, the larger effect specific racial groups the author's right, the point is not what happened to this particular individual. But this is an example of what happens to transgender people interacting with the healthcare system, said the lead author Dr. Daphne strew, Musa of the University of Muskegon, Michigan, Ann Arbor, he was rightly classified as a man in the medical records and appears masculine, strong, strict strict Stroom sir said but the classic classification threw us off from considering his actual

Unknown Speaker 27:02

medical needs.

Unknown Speaker 27:05

Stream sir would not say where or when the case occurred and the patient was not identified.

Unknown Speaker 27:17

That's a heartbreaking example of that anti trans and isn't anti fatness intersecting, leading to the death of the baby. Continuing, a trans person arrived for their consultation appointment for gender affirming surgery. But the armchairs in the waiting room are too small for them to fit the exam room table cannot hold their weight, and they soon find out that the surgeon has a maximum BMI requirements.

Unknown Speaker 27:45

So we see Yeah, we see we see that a lot in regards to examples of

Unknown Speaker 27:51

anti fatness and anti trans SNESs of ridiculous barriers, for no reason, no reason whatsoever.

Unknown Speaker 28:01

A trans college student gets the courage to go to the gym and build muscle for his upcoming top surgery, but then his fat shamed by other students at the fitness center. So that's the end of the the examples but and so, the author goes on to talk about how the intersections of transit and fatness

Unknown Speaker 28:22

can affect TGN V people. So here are some ways that TGN PV Pio put people are impacted by these pressures compared to cisgender people

Unknown Speaker 28:32

increased body dissatisfaction and frequent body checking risk of dishsoap dissociation from or hatred of certain parts of their bodies increased in increase in disordered eating or weight and shape control behaviors including binge eating, fasting,

Unknown Speaker 28:48

vomiting and laxative use weight loss to suppress secondary sex characteristics and or for trans feminine people to achieve the thin ideal for trans masculine people to slow or stop the menstrual cycle for TGFB people with a high BMI even greater rates of body dissatisfaction and disordered eating for trans feminine people increased experiences of sexual objective objectification

Unknown Speaker 29:14

greater risk of mental health struggles due to the stigma of being trans and or fat. Example desire for weight change increases reported history of suicide attempts and self injury.

Unknown Speaker 29:28

Desire example desire for weight changes increases the reported history of suicide attempts and self industry injury, risk of negative social consequences stigma and safety concerns when physical features are not in line with societal expectations for their gender.

Unknown Speaker 29:47

And then for all of those stats, they've linked the sources there.

Unknown Speaker 29:55

Yes,

Unknown Speaker 30:00

And then they go on to say, here are some ways I believe we can work to support our fat TGN be friends and fellow humans. Don't comment on someone's body practice empathy, practice self compassion. Don't assume that a T G and B person wants their body to be in line with a binary constructions of femininity and masculinity.

Unknown Speaker 30:20

Yes, dig into fat positive movements. I'm summarizing, by the way they go, they go deeper on these things. Be critical of the way that mass media portrays TGN be people this is important.

Unknown Speaker 30:34

Be critical of the way that mass media portrays TGFB people,

Unknown Speaker 30:39

fat people and TGFB fat people then.

Unknown Speaker 30:44

Yeah, so if you look at a lot of pages, four

Unknown Speaker 30:50

pages about non binary people or about trans people, notice how very often all of the people that they portray are thin, they conform to

Unknown Speaker 31:07

ideas of what a masculine or feminine person or what a man or a woman looks like. And so I'm thinking of, there's a page called they that I like, I'm just going into it now to see if they've made any changes, but they

Unknown Speaker 31:22

often

Unknown Speaker 31:25

portray very kind of normative trans bodies.

Unknown Speaker 31:33

I know it's called them, it's them. It's not they there is a there is a band. Then there we go.

Unknown Speaker 31:39

them. Okay. Yes, so thin, thin, thin, thin, thin, thin, thin, thin, thin, thin, thin, slightly, chubby, thin, thin, thin, thin, thin, thin, thin, thin. These people look cool. They're awesome, by the way, but there's a lot of like fineness then then then then thin, thin, thin, thin, thin, thin. Yep. So and really like a lot of a lot of Wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, why wait, we'll let you know. Yeah, so So that's fun.

Unknown Speaker 32:16

Okay, check that check your privilege of caring the world sick, sick of mental, medical or mental health providers who are fat positive, blah, blah, blah. Okay, so I think that's really important to talk about. And yeah, it's been on my mind because because like I mentioned I've gone on a date tonight. And it's a struggle in my mind thinking about sis hat men's perception of my fatness and his potential the guy I'm gonna deal with tonight his potential fat phobic thoughts and

Unknown Speaker 32:53

and then my own gender dysphoria and my own gender dysphoria bringing up I don't know if they're my fat phobic beliefs their beliefs that I know that some sis hat men will have and some other you know fat phobic people will have

Unknown Speaker 33:14

and

Unknown Speaker 33:16

and also not trusting says hit men. You know when says that men say? Oh, yeah, you know, because I always say always say so. what's your what's your opinion? On fatness? You know, how do you feel about dating a fat person?

Unknown Speaker 33:33

I asked that of someone a couple of days ago. And they they blocked me.

Unknown Speaker 33:41

And I was like, oh, that's your answer. They ain't interested. But anyway, even when I do say like what's your and they always

Unknown Speaker 33:51

they

Unknown Speaker 33:53

always come back with

Unknown Speaker 33:56

Oh, yeah, it's fine. You know, whatever. And

Unknown Speaker 34:00

and you know that they haven't got any they haven't had any critical thought behind that. Because apart from this is this hitman.

Unknown Speaker 34:10

Trans men,

Unknown Speaker 34:12

by men, queer men that I talked to. They've got something else to say which is

Unknown Speaker 34:21

that they're educated on the topic that they say yeah. Oh my god, fat phobia is fucked up. And I'm so sorry that that's something that you've had to deal with. Or, or Yeah, actually, you know, they've got something to say versus Oh, yeah, no, I think everyone is equal or something, you know, which kind of says that they haven't really thought about it, but they're open to it. But then my brain is like, am I the first fat person you've ever gone on a date with? Are you just experimenting with me? To see if you can stomach having sex with a fat person? You know, they're not clear

Unknown Speaker 35:00

really fat positive, but they're not clearly fat phobic either, you know?

Unknown Speaker 35:09

Yeah, and, and I've seen this way, you know, I always check, I always say hey, what do you think of fatness? And, and, and then? And then they say, Oh yeah, no, I like it's great blah blah, blah. And then I'll be like, you know, say this is I'm just thinking about this one guy. Oh yeah, I love it. Great. And so I'm like, oh, okay, good, good, good. And then, like a few weeks later, I say, also, is it normally only fat people that you day? And he's like, Oh, actually, I've never dated a fat person. And I'm like, oh, so well. Is that true that you love that? Doesn't you just saying that?

Unknown Speaker 35:46

I'm gonna just take your word that in that it is true.

Unknown Speaker 35:50

But no, it's just, it's

Unknown Speaker 35:56

yeah, you have to take people's word for what they say. And and I mean, but there's always this hesitation, right? As a fat person. What are their motives? Are they just, they're just looking for easy sex? What is going on? Are they? Are they actually very comfortable and happy and excited to date a fat person? Or are they like, oh, fuck it. I've never dated a fat he was might as well tried their hair talking to me. So what the heck are they?

Unknown Speaker 36:23

You know, seriously unhappy about having to talk to a fatty but they're desperate to get the Nope, they're not sucked. And so they'll just do it anyway, you know, these are the questions that are going through my mind and I'm sure a lot of other fact people's minds. Yeah. And so with that, that intersection of of gender dysphoria that I'm thinking about? I think to myself, Okay, well, I should dress feminine. So because he's gonna think this is this is, by the way, this guy has never said anything like, that makes me leet leads me to think that he is transphobic he's had relationships. I've not actually asked if he has relationships with

Unknown Speaker 37:07

fat people, but from my I kind of got the impression that you had.

Unknown Speaker 37:12

But he his last relationship with was with with was with a trans woman. And so

Unknown Speaker 37:19

I get that kind of more, I feel more safe with him. Anyway, so I think to myself, Okay, what if he thinks, oh, well, Vinnie is fat, but at least they ain't masculine. At least, Vinny isn't coming up here looking like a masculine non binary person. So that's what I'm thinking.

Unknown Speaker 37:43

Him any any sis man is thinking

Unknown Speaker 37:49

that, at least that they could do is make up for their fatness by being feminine, because if they are fat, and non binary, masculine or androgynous, then that's too much for me to handle. As if those things are negative. They're not by the way. They're just ways of humans to be to be.

Unknown Speaker 38:12

And then my other side of my brain is like, fuck that. Dress for yourself, dress how you want to if that happens to be feminine, then do that. And if it's not, don't do it. And so I'm like, Yeah, fuck that. Fuck that. And I feel empowered. And I think about this like cool pair of combat boots I've got, I got on sale from eliquid. And then the my leather jacket and how badass it looks together. And then like with a like, a rolled up gene, a little cuff on the bottom, and, you know, and I'm like, Yeah, that looks badass. And then another thought comes up of,

Unknown Speaker 38:49

but then he is going to be worried about your version of non binary. Perhaps he only wants to go on a date with you.

Unknown Speaker 38:59

Because you've appeared so far to be feminine to him.

Unknown Speaker 39:05

And if you show up on a day to night, this is a second date.

Unknown Speaker 39:09

Looking more androgynous that he's gonna be like, No.

Unknown Speaker 39:15

And then I'm like, Okay, well, I'm gonna god yeah, I need to keep the feminine up. Because if I then you know, all of a sudden change and switch to something more androgynous he's gonna be like, What the fuck? This isn't what I signed up for. Even though it's only like one day and pictures on my dating profile. So then I'm like, Okay, well

Unknown Speaker 39:38

you know, next time I'm online shopping, I'm gonna buy a frilly dress. Even though it makes me feel blue when I see it.

Unknown Speaker 39:46

When I see it when I see myself wearing it,

Unknown Speaker 39:50

and then I'm like, fuck. No, I'm not doing that. No, no, I'm no, I'm gonna do what makes me feel good.

Unknown Speaker 40:00

Then I think about how I don't wear many things that show my cleavage, and that men like cleavage on the whole, and then

Unknown Speaker 40:11

well, I think what if I'm gonna be fat and non binary? I may as well flop my fat hits.

Unknown Speaker 40:20

So I think about

Unknown Speaker 40:23

what do I own that is low cut?

Unknown Speaker 40:26

Not really anything

Unknown Speaker 40:29

unless I unbutton a shirt.

Unknown Speaker 40:32

So maybe I should buy something that shows off my tips to confuse men into thinking that I am a woman and a sexy woman. And I'm not like one of these bad fatties, who is

Unknown Speaker 40:45

you know, androgynous.

Unknown Speaker 40:48

And then I'm like, No, fuck that. What the fuck Be yourself. If you want to show off your TED show, if he texts if you don't tone.

Unknown Speaker 41:00

And so then I'll see your super cool non binary person on Instagram. I'm like, Yes, that's who I am.

Unknown Speaker 41:07

And I feel buoyed again and resolute again to not

Unknown Speaker 41:11

give in to these transphobic fat phobic thoughts.

Unknown Speaker 41:20

So it's a it's a merry go round in my head due to dysphoria and misogyny and fat phobia. And it's frustrating and I'm not used to feeling like this. And

Unknown Speaker 41:32

I think you know, the SIS hat male gaze is really fucking with me. I feel like if I was on a desert island, and I didn't have to deal with sis hat male gaze.

Unknown Speaker 41:42

I wouldn't have I wouldn't be having these feelings at all. I mean, if we all lived in a desert island, we probably wouldn't be having fat phobic feelings, probably. You know, because it's society that makes it so difficult, right?

Unknown Speaker 41:59

And before I realized that I was non binary, I didn't give a fuck about what men thought about my body in regards to fatness. Obviously, I did previously previously previously, but you know, in the most recent history,

Unknown Speaker 42:12

and I still don't as a standalone issue, if a guy says, I'm not attracted to you, because you're fat. I'm like, well, your fucking eyeballs are wrong, because I'm gorgeous. You know, your loss.

Unknown Speaker 42:25

But then when you combine it with

Unknown Speaker 42:30

how I'm working to working out to be my third authentic non binary self, then all sorts of chips come comes up. And that same defiant, confident levels of I don't care what they think, because if they don't like me, then it's a them problem. And I'm still in these kind of, like, Baby Giraffe legs of being like, oh, but maybe I should, maybe I should wear a nice dress and, and then a little bit, and maybe I should you know, when it's kind of it feels like before when it was kind of like, well, maybe I should wear something black. And something, maybe I should wear shape wear. And maybe I should wear high heels to make myself look as feminine and as thin as possible. And the performance or femininity that I would I would put on in order to quote make up for the art for my fatness

Unknown Speaker 43:31

was,

Unknown Speaker 43:34

was the thing that I dealt with. And then I obviously learned a lot of that stuff. And in that unlearning was examining my performance or femininity, not the stuff which just naturally feels good because, you know, there's a lot of stuff that would be like that I like doing this classes feminine, like wearing lipstick, or

Unknown Speaker 43:57

earrings or whatever. And that's for me, because I genuinely enjoy it. I don't think about how men are being like, Oh my God, look at their earrings. I really want to fuck them because of their earrings. Like,

Unknown Speaker 44:10

I don't think like that. Whereas before it would be

Unknown Speaker 44:15

certain things doing certain things to to attract men, which didn't necessarily feel authentic to me or doing it to

Unknown Speaker 44:28

make up for my perceived floor or fatness. And so I guess what it is, is it's my own transphobia. Right. It's my own

Unknown Speaker 44:40

belief that that being non binary is

Unknown Speaker 44:45

less worthy, less desirable, less attractive than being a sis woman and that my expression of my gender has to align with that.

Unknown Speaker 45:00

very rigid ideas of femininity or being a good non binary person as in non binary in name only not saying that that was what a good one, you know, good as in good or bad, fatty these are social constructs and, and, and tropes, right? That a guy, me thinking, me thinking about their biases, and trying to minimize myself so that I don't trigger their biases. And when I think about it in regards to just fatness, I'm like we they're fucking lucky that my body might trigger biases, because then I'm giving them a free fucking education. If they are having, feeling a certain way about my body and its fatness, and, and being like, Oh, I don't like this, then, you know, you're welcome. No, you're welcome. And see you later. Because if you don't do the work to sort that shit out, then it's got nothing to do with me because I'm feeling fucking good in my body as a fat person. And so I'm not there yet, with my non binary identity, which is just gets on my fucking tits. Because I don't like it. I don't like this feeling of being unsure of second guessing myself, because I haven't felt like that in so long. And it's not a good feeling, right? But also doing this stuff like talking about it and, and pointing it out. And, you know, talking about this dialogue that my brain is having, of, of, you know, the worst, darkest thoughts of buy a frilly dress and put on a wig. I was literally, I was literally pulling out this wig that I have this pink wig that I have and being like, oh, would they be more attracted to me if I wore this and I'm just like, for fucks sake.

Unknown Speaker 46:58

It was like there's two different videos on my shoulder the the transphobic unsure

Unknown Speaker 47:05

people pleasing version of Vinnie on one shoulder and then like the badass, you know, fat positive,

Unknown Speaker 47:13

cool, confident person on the other side being like, What the fuck are you thinking? Like, get out of here. And I don't think

Unknown Speaker 47:21

you know, maybe that other side, they kind of like what the fuck is maybe not as helpful, maybe being compassionate for myself, versus being angry and annoyed with myself that I'm having risen to this higher level of not thinking about this shit. When I have been

Unknown Speaker 47:39

out as non binary for like 12 minutes. I mean, come on. And if I think about like when someone comes to fat, positive positivity, and they feel frustrated that they're not there certain place within and I'm like,

Unknown Speaker 47:55

How long have you been doing this? And how many years have you

Unknown Speaker 48:00

been in this fat phobic world that tells you that you're a piece of shit and you believe it? Oh, you've been in that world for 40 years. And now you think after 14 minutes, you're gonna be you know, what's the phrase taking names and flipping tables? I mean, yeah, there will be moments when you are you flipping tables and being like, fuck you. I'm fat and fabulous. But there's gonna be lots of times where you're still struggling with oh, what are people thinking? And,

Unknown Speaker 48:27

and I'm there with, with me being non binary, right?

Unknown Speaker 48:33

of older people thinking. And when I think about it in the fat stuff, I'm just like, well, who fucking cares what they're thinking what they're thinking is really none of your business and you can't control what they're thinking. So do you want to try and minimize yourself to, to make sure that that person is comfortable seeing you and your presence doesn't trigger any biases in their brain? Or, and that's not great for you because you haven't to like, be a fake version of yourself. Oh, do you just want to live what how you want and then fuck what other people think. I like the second option. I just gave myself a pep talk. have gone to that date many and just crush it. Yeah. Okay, so yeah, yeah.

Unknown Speaker 49:18

So I want to talk about

Unknown Speaker 49:21

there's this phenomenon, this phenomenon mono mono, that I have noticed and notice that other people have noticed this phenomenon, too, with messaging people online. And it really is really fucking annoying. And I thought okay, so Okay, so the phenomenon is says Hitman not

Unknown Speaker 49:46

asking questions in a conversation. Okay, so this is this is this is what I mean. This isn't this is a made up example. Hey, this is me. Hey, how you doing? Nice teeth.

Unknown Speaker 50:00

I probably wouldn't say that but

Unknown Speaker 50:04

a sexy looking teeth. Hey, thanks.

Unknown Speaker 50:09

How are you? I'm great. I just made some chili con carne and I'm about to take my dog to the dog park. Cool.

Unknown Speaker 50:20

Yeah, so. So tell me more about yourself. are you originally from Vancouver? What do you do for work? Yeah, I'm from

Unknown Speaker 50:31

Alberta and I

Unknown Speaker 50:36

made a professional cheesy to

Unknown Speaker 50:39

oh my god cool professional cheesy to Oh my God, that sounds amazing. So

Unknown Speaker 50:45

what's your favorite type of cheese? Brie.

Unknown Speaker 50:49

You know, it's like, and it's like, like, it's like that. And it's like,

Unknown Speaker 50:54

even when they've messaged you first.

Unknown Speaker 50:58

And

Unknown Speaker 51:02

it just makes no sense.

Unknown Speaker 51:04

It's nice Sans.

Unknown Speaker 51:07

And so in that interaction to me, I'd be like, Well, clearly, they're not interested. They're just responding to be polite. But, you know, because that so that wasn't a good example. But these are people who are keep messaging, right? They reach out first. They keep messaging, but they never ask you a question, John. I'm literally going to read out some chats,

Unknown Speaker 51:30

some chats and chats and chats. Okay, so this guy messaged me, and we're having a back and forth.

Unknown Speaker 51:37

And so I'd have it. And so I've been calling them out. And so let me read this, me calling him out. Chat. So I message this guy. And I said, Okay, so where are you from, originally? From about Alberta, originally. And so in Vancouver, there's, it's very rare to meet someone who's actually from Vancouver, like, say, if you meet 100 guys online, maybe

Unknown Speaker 52:00

10 of them would be actually from Vancouver. And so, you know, a common question is like, Where you from originally? Because, you know, so? And I'd be like, I'd be like, Oh, are you from Vancouver? Originally? I'm not. I'm from UK, Ireland. And so instead of him saying, oh, UK, Ireland, cool. I've want to go to visit London or whatever. He just says, I'm from Alberta originally. And so no questions for me. So I just respond. Cool. Because I'm at this point, I'm like,

Unknown Speaker 52:33

Are you going to ever ask me a question about me? And he responds, I guess LOL, because I didn't think it was cool. I was just like, oh, for fuck sake.

Unknown Speaker 52:42

And so then I said, said to this guy. So maybe you can answer me this. I've been trying to work something out. Why is it that men often during messaging on apps don't ask questions about the person they're talking to. This guy responds, well, as for myself, I suck at Tech messaging, slash texting, hahahahaha shoulder shrug. We'd rather chat face to face. So then I respond. Okay, gotcha. But then if you don't ask questions, it makes the conversation end so you'll never get to meet face to face. And then he said, Guess we just got a meet in person then. laughing, winking. And then I respond. You know what, whenever I have met people who don't ask questions over message is the same thing in person. Just me asking all the questions and then them not returning the curiosity. He didn't respond to that message.

Unknown Speaker 53:41

US we rely on for floods like.

Unknown Speaker 53:45

Okay, so here's another guy on the exam day, different app.

Unknown Speaker 53:50

Same thing.

Unknown Speaker 53:52

So maybe you can answer me this. I've been trying to work out blah, blah, blah. Why don't Why don't men ask questions? He says, Well, I guess they figure it out gradually by observing the actions rather than speak. And he's got kind of chin scratching, chin scratching emoji. And then I said, but then it makes the conversation very one sided. One person asking all the questions, and the other just answering and not reciprocating.

Unknown Speaker 54:20

And he says, nope. Sometimes the questions you ask rise a question in my mind as well. Lol. Don't know why, why that's funny. But

Unknown Speaker 54:31

and then I say, but it hasn't though. Right? Only question you asked was when I asked you to ask a question. Because previously in the chat, I said, is do you want to know anything about me? And he said, Yeah.

Unknown Speaker 54:45

I'd said, we'll ask me a question then. And then he said, You asked me something, something, whatever. And then he went back into not asking questions and so so I say you know, the only time you've

Unknown Speaker 55:00

asked me a question is when I told you to ask me a question. And then he says, I'll ask questions

Unknown Speaker 55:06

as all ask questions as well, lol, gradually, lol. And then I say, but then it makes the other person think that you don't care slash aren't interested. And therefore the conversation will just end. And you'll never know that it was just that you didn't ask questions.

Unknown Speaker 55:24

And he says, fair enough exclamation point. thumbs up emoji. So tell me about your hobbies. And so

Unknown Speaker 55:33

tell me about your hobbies. For me, that was like, fine. For fuck sake, I'll ask you a fucking question. Now while you're Shut up. That's how I write it. And so I told him a really cool thing. I was like, oh, so I, I'm actually starting the roller skating club in a couple of weeks. And I also like singing, and I go to a singing class, once a week, and also really into watching cheesy reality shows on Netflix. Lots of content there, right? And so it's not like I'm My hobbies are like, Oh, my hobbies are breathing, you know, and nothing for him to say in return. And he was just like, oh, and then because then I said,

Unknown Speaker 56:20

what about you? And he was just like, oh, I watch Netflix or whatever. And then I was like, oh, anything that you really enjoy, and at the moment, and then he just kept just going on about him just talking, talking, talking about him, what he likes. He sent four message messages. I didn't respond, all talking about himself, and then finally sent a question, which was, what are you doing, which I didn't respond to?

Unknown Speaker 56:45

So I took this to I took this to the Instagrams and I said, Do you notice this that sis hat men suck at conversations on the apps on the dating apps? Never asking question, and you are having to do all the legwork. And so I did a poll and the answers were oh my god, yes. Sometimes not at all. And 78% of people said, Oh, my God, yes. 18 said sometimes and 3% said Not at all.

Unknown Speaker 57:16

By the way I looked at who said Not at all.

Unknown Speaker 57:20

To have the people look like they're women.

Unknown Speaker 57:25

But of course, I could be talking to this man. But I just thought that was funny. Because mostly, almost everyone that follows me is is is not is not a sis hitman, man. Okay, and so then I put a question box saying, Why do you think that sis men often won't? Don't ask questions on the dating apps? And this is what people said. And I wanted to read out that what they said, because I think it's really interesting.

Unknown Speaker 57:51

Honestly, I think that it's they they just don't care enough to put in the effort. They literally just expect to word vomit on them like they do. We they literally just expect you to word vomit on them like they do. They don't actually want to get to know you. They're just buying time to meet face to face. Because they're awful. They're used to it being all about them. And if they find you attractive, that's enough. That's at first. They don't want to actually put in any effort, they will meet up for sex, not conversation. Because they're not interested in dating only sex in my experience. It's a little hint. They give to show you that they that you'll have to do all the legwork in the relationship to

Unknown Speaker 58:38

ya, selfishness. They aren't actually interested in getting to know the person they just want an ego boost their self centered. They think showing interest makes them vulnerable. And toxic masculinity says no to that. They only ask when they're already invested emotionally, not to find out if you're compatible. I found it just to be social laziness on their part.

Unknown Speaker 59:02

Someone says sis women can be just as bad.

Unknown Speaker 59:05

Not really interested in meeting people, not good textures expect others to do the work. I don't know. But I've decided I'm not going to carry the Convo by myself.

Unknown Speaker 59:15

Don't care what your answers would be self absorbed. The good ones ask questions too. Yes, lack of social skills and not having to stay attuned to the other person's reality to survive all the time. A lot of marginalized folks are very good at attuning to others as a survival skill.

Unknown Speaker 59:33

I don't know but this is my number one complaint with the apps. I don't know but I hope you find out so annoying. Because the emotional labor is always forced on the SIS female. And again, people are mentioning sis female, but obviously I am a non trans non binary so I think it's sis hat men, whoever they're dating. They just expect you know the labor to be on them.

Unknown Speaker 1:00:00

because they think the universe revolves around them.

Unknown Speaker 1:00:04

That's usually how I screen them out the ones who don't talk. Trying to play it cool.

Unknown Speaker 1:00:11

They're just self centered and nobody that nobody told them it wasn't cool.

Unknown Speaker 1:00:15

No one taught them how to connect with or care for someone but that but that others would do it for them.

Unknown Speaker 1:00:24

Hashtag mana trash overall. And so all the apps because sis men are completely self centered and essentially babies

Unknown Speaker 1:00:37

Yeah, I've been watching Off. I've been watching 90 Day fiance

Unknown Speaker 1:00:43

franchise or MMA girl.

Unknown Speaker 1:00:47

A lot of men on that show, especially the ones who are American adjust, set, they are babies, they're just like, oh, I can't wash a dish. I'm getting my wife over to come over here to wash my dishes and do my laundry and, and I just feel so it's so I'm so embarrassed for them with a woman coming over from coming over suffering from a foreign country to come and do the fucking laundry of this guy that probably doesn't wipe his own ass.

Unknown Speaker 1:01:18

And everyone being like they're here for a green card. Really? Because America is the greatest country in the world. I don't fucking think so. Is the other way around. Americans trying to get green cards to other countries to get the hell out of that place. Yeah, only the people on the show being like, oh, everyone wants to be here. I'm like, really?

Unknown Speaker 1:01:38

Oh my god, it's just so there's so much racism or anyway whatever. Continuing with the responses.

Unknown Speaker 1:01:44

pure laziness being constantly on is exhausting on apps. Women are more picky so have to be interesting to a number of men. Men play the numbers game and half ours it for a lot of women. They're looking for partners who will do all the work, weaponized incompetence.

Unknown Speaker 1:02:00

They have enough options that they don't need to put out put in a lot of effort. So common, they're self centered, poor communicators who haven't had to try. I've noticed that most of my boyfriend's exes never ask questions in person either.

Unknown Speaker 1:02:15

I've had the same issue. I think lack of self awareness. They don't even ask themselves questions. Yeah, they don't even ask themselves questions. A lot of men don't want to do the inner work questions, raise potential problems.

Unknown Speaker 1:02:29

Lack of emotional intelligence, lazy, expect women to do all the work, they lie a lot. So they expect you to do it. Also, they observe actions and decide if you're suitable. I think they're used to not having to do the labor honestly, they think they need to figure out the things they want to know it doesn't occur to care to them to ask in my opinion, they genuinely don't care. Women are not just on bedposts not people, because they don't give a fuck, as long as they as you look a certain way, they don't care what you have to say. Because they're lazy and expect women to do all the work. They've never been asked to do better, they just float on by with their privilege.

Unknown Speaker 1:03:12

Because straight men suck, and the bar is so low for them. And finally, talk to women instead.

Unknown Speaker 1:03:21

Oh my goodness. And so it's fun. It's funny because I just finished reading reading my last book. I was I was reading a book and now I'm on to my next book. And my next book is The tragedy of heterosexual ality that my therapist recommended for me and I'm just like

Unknown Speaker 1:03:41

yes, so my good news. And I'm only like 15 pages in and I'm like fucking I need to get the highlighter out and just highlight everything because it's so 100% on point like

Unknown Speaker 1:03:57

basically

Unknown Speaker 1:04:00

the bar for sis hat man is literally on the floor. And

Unknown Speaker 1:04:09

men don't actually like women that much this is all kind of not every man obviously. There's lots of great men out there who are who are kind and empathetic and emotionally intelligent and cool and blah blah blah. No any send them my way. But and and really what we're critiquing is

Unknown Speaker 1:04:32

the patriarchy and what happens because of that, and it's like it's it's a whole a whole load of shit basically, and men lose out because of it. Women lose out because of it. And gender non conforming people lose out because of it.

Unknown Speaker 1:04:52

So yeah, I'm, I'm,

Unknown Speaker 1:04:55

I'm just starting this and you know, the whole hetero

Unknown Speaker 1:05:00

Are they all the streets? Okay, that are the streets okay? It's so fucking funny like, go and look on like different Instagram accounts like all the streets okay? Like stuff that straight folks do which so cringe like, you know, like

Unknown Speaker 1:05:16

baby showers where the guy it turns out it's a girl and the guy throws a tantrum is like Oh for fuck sake because it's a girl because of what he thinks about women obviously or, or

Unknown Speaker 1:05:29

you know, saying saying, oh, gay people don't force your sexuality on us and then having things like, oh my god, there was this one.

Unknown Speaker 1:05:38

Someone announcing their pregnancy by saying like, we made a cake. One cup of money mummy, three squirts of daddy.

Unknown Speaker 1:05:49

So

Unknown Speaker 1:05:52

can you imagine a queer couple doing that? Like?

Unknown Speaker 1:05:59

No, because they don't like, Okay, I'm gonna find some more examples and we'll see who are because I started follow them last night.

Unknown Speaker 1:06:08

My people who aren't following me is not in order of when I followed them. Road

Unknown Speaker 1:06:16

what's the name of it? Anyway? Just Just look for the hashtag hashtag of the streets, okay, for hilarious examples of you know, just straight people like forcing sexuality onto others doing cringy things. And actually, you know, that whole like, oh, ball and chain. Oh, you know, and women actually not liking

Unknown Speaker 1:06:36

men's bodies and thinking penises are gross. By the way. I fuckin love a penis me.

Unknown Speaker 1:06:42

But, you know, a lot of a lot of people would really probably do better just not being with a man or woman, you know, just

Unknown Speaker 1:06:52

because they don't actually like them that much.

Unknown Speaker 1:06:56

It seems like And anyway, I want you to eliminate like 17 pages into this book. But it's so really, it's so really interesting. And so anyway, so that's the end of the episode I've been rambling on for about 50 years.

Unknown Speaker 1:07:09

Have you enjoyed it and just

Unknown Speaker 1:07:12

hashtag not all men? Because I know there's gonna

Unknown Speaker 1:07:16

there's gonna be some people be like you hate man. But you hate straight people. Probably not because you everyone listens to the podcast is really cool. But just in case anyone's like, thinks that. I hate men.

Unknown Speaker 1:07:29

I don't

Unknown Speaker 1:07:31

love men. That's why I want to have sex with them and be with them. Just most men are giant balans because they haven't done any work to get up to the level of, of what what we've all been doing. The rest of us have been trying to not be the same balance that we were 10 years ago. Men are still there from 10 years ago, you know, when you see a post on Facebook or memory, a memory of you from like, 2008 And you're like,

Unknown Speaker 1:08:04

you read it and you just it is just so embarrassing. I'm not the most shameful thing that you've said. No. And you're just like, if I knew that person, I would I would unfriend them. Yeah, so a lot of men are still there in 2008 version of themselves and they've not moved on. Whereas the rest of us have moved on and are like, Oh, I was a bit of a bellend but now I've read some books and done some therapy and trying to be better still probably lots of Belen qualities about me, but I'm trying

Unknown Speaker 1:08:40

whereas Yeah, a lot of people are just

Unknown Speaker 1:08:43

like in

Unknown Speaker 1:08:45

2008 Me was fucking cool.

Unknown Speaker 1:08:49

Yeah. Okay, well, have you had fun today, links to everything that I've spoken about in the show notes basically.com forward slash 123. If you work in a company and you want me to come in and talk about fatphobia and all of this type of stuff, then just send me an email. Or if you're a dietitian or a nutritionist, a therapist, you want me to train your staff then reach out to me if you want me to help you with making sure that your shit is not fat phobic. Reach out to me. You want to tell me that you that I'm the love of your life and

Unknown Speaker 1:09:29

that you have someone for me today in Vancouver then reach out to me.

Unknown Speaker 1:09:35

And I hope you all have a amazing rest of your day. And I'll see you in the next episode. Okay, goodbye. See later fatties and fattier lies and am I

EP122 Transcript

Welcome to the Fierce Fatty Podcast. I'm your host, Victoria Welsby, and this is episode 122. Today, we're talking about “Stories From Weight Loss Surgery Patients 8 Years Post Op”.

I'm Victoria Welsby, TEDx speaker, best-selling author, and fat activist. I have transformed my life from hating my body with desperately low self-esteem to being a courageous and confident fierce fatty who loves every inch of this jelly. Society teaches us living in a fat body is bad. But what if we spent less time, money, and energy on the pursuit of thinness and instead focused on the things that actually matter? Like if pineapple on pizza should be outlawed? Or if the mullet was the greatest haircut of the 20th century? So how do you stop negative beliefs about your fat body controlling your life? It's the Fierce Fatty Podcast. Let's begin.

Hello, welcome to this episode off the podcast. How are ya? How's life you feeling? Good? I'm feeling good. So today, I'm not going to be regaling you with stories of dates and pimple popping. up today, I feel like oh, God, what are they going to be talking about today? No, none of that stuff. Because I haven't been on any date. So very sad, very sad. Reminder to write a review for the podcast on Apple podcasts, I think is the only place that you can do it. Write a review for for the podcast, and I will be eternally grateful. And the reason why I'm asking you to do this, if you want to don't have to, if you don't want to, is because the more reviews are more likely. Other people will see the show. Because other people are saying hey, it's gone. It's gone God, or whatever it is that you think about the show, hopefully that you think it's good. Anyway, so if you can do that on Apple podcasts, that'd be great. I just be so happy if someone reached out to me and said, How do you do review and I was like, well, Firefox, like I didn't tell you how to do it. Last episode, I was just like, write a review. And so people might have been like, Where the fuck are you talking about Vinny? And that is where you do it. Other podcast platforms, I don't think have the option to write a review but Apple podcast does. So alrighty. The inspiration I for today's episode is from. I'm in a Facebook group called fat studies. And Deb God, who I've mentioned on the show before, incredible fan activist. She posted a link to an article. This is a comment that she posted with it. Here's a tiny bit of testimony, seven people in Norway eight years out for the surgeons and researchers who are unaware of the long term realities of starvation and lack of solutions after the honeymoon period of weight loss surgery. The people here also speak to the self blame for the lack of loose solutions. Showing that even when one's body fits in better training as a fat person to blame your self for the neglect and abuse of the medical system remains untouched. It's so cool that these people imagine that because they gave quote informed consent. They then they must have brought their miseries on themselves when informed consent without data is impossible. Love that informed consent without data is impossible. And so Deb is linking to an article called untold stories of living with a bariatric body, long term experiences of weight loss surgery, written by Anita Berg who is faculty of Nursing and Health Sciences, not University, Norway and this was released released September 2019. I wanted to make this episode sharing more stories about, quote, weight loss and quote surgery because I put in quotes because more often than not people don't lose weight from weight loss surgery. So I wanted to have this as a companion piece to it. Episode 50 which is called What about weight loss surgery and you can find that easily by going to face batty.com forward slash 050 for that episode, so, can't believe that like seven episodes ago was when I first started collecting this stuff on weight loss surgery. And so that's a really good episode if I do is eyes. Oh, Mazel Tov, with tons of research around the surgeries the stomach amputation and skirt stomach squeezing surgeries and and this is the bio the synopsis for that episode. Does weight loss surgery make you thin? What percentage of people? Is it successful for other side effects worth it? And what are they exactly. And so this episode, that episode is going to be talking about this surgery, including mention of suicide attempt, and no mention of calories or pounds or anything, I guess we're talking about the reality of living with a body that's gone through this surgery and so that can be kind of difficult to hear about.

Because other times it's not fun. And now just an FYI, I'm sharing these experiences, which are talking about the negative experiences. And I just want to point out that there will be people who've had surgery to amputate or squeezer stomach who come out, they lose those away, they have no side effects. And they're like, this was the best decision of my life. My life is great now that okay, so that does happen. But what doesn't happen is people don't get this information when they are looking to if this surgery is good, right? Because all of the because of the you know, the massive injury industry behind it. If you Google like side effects of weight loss surgery, or weight loss or weight loss or weight loss surgery stories, you're not going to get this information, you're going to get sanitize, sterilized, hyper positive evidence and stories of people who are likely to change my life. So it's important to have this information out there to show the other side of weight loss surgery. And the other side being that heads nod, it's not a, it's not a great thing to do if you have the choice, if you have the choice, because I know some people don't have the choice to not have surgery because healthcare has been denied to them, unless they do it. Also, sometimes the chance of living in a smaller body. And all of the awful side effects out ways doesn't outweigh the let me say that, again. The living in a living in a fat body in this society is violent, right. And so sometimes people will pursue weight loss at great cost, because it is so difficult to live in this society as someone who is very fat. And on top of that, also for people who have different marginalized identities on top of having a bigger body. And so I I don't want to say anyone who's had or is thinking about or is planning to have this surgery is is not intelligent, is not you know, they haven't thought about it a lot and is not is doing something bad and wrong, because the reality is actually complex. You know, it's really complex. But we also want to get out stories of the realities of weight loss surgery, because like I said, you Google it, you'll see you know, happy thin people running through fields having puppies, saying that weight loss surgery was the best thing ever and they've never had any terrible side effects and blah, blah blah, which is true for some people. I do that. Because who knows? And the reality for others is death and the reality for most.

So let me read this, this posed to you changes that I made after my previous episode about weight loss surgery, weights talks about weight loss surgery facts. Okay, so weight loss surgery facts. So what are the outcomes? Will it extend your life 4.6% of people who have weight loss surgery die within a year, and that's 7.5% for men 6.4 will die by four years, and 15.8 by eight years. Three out of 1000 people die within 30 days of the surgery. There's an increased mortality risk of time seven in year one, and 250% to 363% by year four. Would it make you thin and healthy. Two years after the surgery 46% have regained weight. And by four years 63% of people have gained weight. We don't have good data. Past that, because people stopped measurement measuring sound familiar, something that weight loss companies do year five afterwards is a little time when weight comes back on. There are no randomized, controlled, controlled clinical trials that have shown any long term improvements to actual health or that lives are saved or extended. The complications 20 to 25% of gastric bypass patients develop life threatening complications. 89% of patients have had at least one adverse event 1/3 of them severe 56 of 56% of bariatric patients have had 62 Different gastro gastro intestinal complications and abnormalities. There's a double the risk of substance abuse issues. And four times increase in death by suicide, the cost of the surgery, most insurance companies won't pay for the procedure, which costs 15 to $25,000, which is one of the most lucrative specialities for doctors. Of course, there are some countries in the world that will pay for it. And so we're talking about North America here. So will weight loss surgery make you thin make you healthy? Is it worth the risks? I don't know. I I'm not able to answer that answer that for people. But looking at looking at that information is not something that I personally would choose for myself. But also I want to recognize my privilege here as a white person. As someone who is able bodied as someone who is a medium fat person, my experience of fatness is laden with privilege. And so that's a decision that I have made, because the pain that I'm feeling in regards to living in a fat body doesn't outweigh the risks of death and adverse health, side effects for surgery. That probably won't make me smaller, long term temporarily it probably will. Okay, so let's look at this in this article. And what I'm going to do is I'm going to be reading new people's exploring answers that's collected by an eater Berg and the article explores long term experiences after going undergoing bariatric surgery, which is shortened to BS, which allow girls bariatric surgery is this with individual interviews now, there are different types of bariatric surgery, and it needs it doesn't say what, what Norway has done in regards to their bariatric surgery. The way that Anita talks about it, it's like there there is one standardized surgery and so if it's just one standardize where it's stomach amputation, that is that sounds like what it is because she's saying it's irreversible, which amputation is whereas a bypass or squeezing, that could be reversible, great risk, you know, but still, and so that's something to keep in mind is we don't know exactly what type of bariatric surgery also we have.

So the participants were four men and three women between the ages of 35 to 61. When at the time of the interview, and all of them self reported to have lost weight and kept that weight off. So at the time of the surgery, they said, are you okay with us talking, you know, people contacting you to talk about your experience. And then again, in follow up interviews, as they confirmed they were and they had a number of follow up interviews with a Anita who tried her best to be impartial, and just kind of probe and ask questions about their experiences. Of course, it's impossible to be impartial. Because we all have biases, and agendas and all that type of stuff. So, here as well, we've got seven experiences, and it's sis people. We don't know anything about any other of their identities apart from there's a no on, you know, they were married, and they have kids and things like that. But we don't know. You know, are these are white people? Are these these these bipoc people? Are they trans people? You know, presumably not because she says men and women. So I mean, white supremacy is is, is all around in this type of stuff. And so I'm transphobia. And notice how often those stories are not shared. Also, on the other hand, it's hard to get people to talk about this stuff. Especially long, long time out. People, what we see is we've got a lot of studies from people who are a year out of their surgery, 18 months out two years, three years, those people more often other people who were spoken to, or, and or are the ones who want to talk about their experiences, because presumably they're at that point where they've lost weight. People who are longer term, they either have put the weight back on and or they are also seeing the negative side effects really manifest in their life. And as we can see in in the stuff that we're going to be talking about here, you'll see that the stories, a lot of times they're blaming themselves for those outcomes, versus being like, well, the surgery, the surgery was something that's, you know, unethical, not well researched, forced upon me as the only options of that person. And therefore, and I wasn't told about all of the consequences, and therefore the consequences are not my fault. And they're not my fault anyway, even if I did consensually go into the surgery. Yeah, so it's complicated, right? And there's lots of different variables at play. And, yeah, so what I need to start with is talking about all that type of, she doesn't mention the stuff that I just mentioned, but talking about like, who the people are, and how she interviewed them using certain techniques and, and she continues, this is quote from her the experiences of living with a bariatric body fell into three main themes. One, the bariatric body in daily life, to being a dignified patient and three, shame and unknown problems. So the first thing that that we go into here is dumping syndrome and in here, we'll explain what that is. So this is this is I'm going to be doing reading from the article Okay, so are you comfortable, I will begin they'll put participants relate related the non and by the way, the Oh words, I'm going to change them, so you don't have to hear them. So I'm just going to change the words to fat. The participants related their nonfat life to the presence of the bariatric body, and specifically to dumping syndrome DS, thus, eight years after their surgery, all the participants still have problems identifying what they could tolerate. Lin who succeeded very well, in her sustained weight loss pinpointed this continuous challenge on a daily life. One day I can eat eggs, and the next day I react on eggs and eater asks, Are you still trying to figure it out? Yes, I have to every day. I have to figure it out.

The effort of sorting out what to eat is experienced as energy consuming and uncertain science, says Lynn these are pseudonyms by the way. So DS dumping syndrome is an is an intended effect of surgery. Let me repeat that again. dumping syndrome is an intended effect of surgery and kicks in as an instant bodily reaction when the wrong kind of food or an Send too much food or in the wrong combination is eaten and is valued positively as a barrier to overconsumption. This bodily reflex reflex causes rapid gastric gastric emptying by vomiting, and sometimes diarrhea, and is often accompanied by sweating, dizziness and irregular heartbeats. The consequences of eating the wrong food in the wrong quantity and timing is causing an urgent need for a timeout in the bathroom and puts them out of action for several hours. So it's I find it very interesting. It's that DSX is an intended effect, right that that is there to punish the bad fat people for eating too much food, eating food at the wrong time, or eating food that they will react with. And as we saw from Lynn story, that one day she can eat eggs and next day she can't eat an egg. And so people are struggling to know how to eat because their body is just all over the place. Okay, continuing DS was a well known and expected effect that was essentially viewed positively. problems occurred when participants were unconscious, or when other circumstances such as activity, stress or illness interfered with this issues not understood prior to surgery. Roger explains his three safe cars to avoid DS coffee at work, sushi at restaurants, and beer instead of dinner. This is a quote from Roger. It is challenging to find the middle way, no days are the same and then it becomes difficult. Or I often refrain from the whole meal. I have to cut the nine o'clock meal at work so I won't be sick. But then it becomes wrong because they say you should eat every third hour. I take comfort in drinking or comfort is not the right word. I replace food with alcohol because then I'm in control. So after I become single, I gave up dinner and took a beer instead. I know how much I can drink before getting ill. But I can be sick from one meatball and a spoon of gravy. I was tired of gambling with eating a couple of beers work well and stop the hunger. And then the ball just started to roll cries silently. I needed alcohol more than food. Food was too complicated. So summarize, this is a neater speaking so summarized food is still a big issue in your life after BS. Bariatric Surgery. Yes, because food plays a major role in everyday life. Coming home after work trying to participate in social settings is difficult. I have withdrawn socially Yeah. It goes in kaput goes in coffee at work. And in the weekends with no plans. It is easy to resort to the beer but so that echoes the double the risk of substance abuse issues. I read recently that substance abuse is is not the right way to say that. But they didn't say what was the what is the right way. So just wanted to point that out. There might be a better way to say that instead of substance abuse. Okay, so let's move on. The next section is and so there's more stories, but I'm not going to be reading all of them. Next section is crumbling bodies.

Okay, so here's a quote. Initially, it gets better. You get rid of the many problems you had before surgery, but after a while, I realized that you receive too little information in advance. Bariatric Surgery was quite new in Norway, then I see it now afterwards, I would not have done the operation again. I'd rather be locked up in a prison cell with locked Jaws because you're very plagued afterwards. I need to asks What problems have led you to such a conclusion. One of the things easy to pinpoint is the lacking absorption of vitamins and minerals and the hormones freaking out all the ways. You eat nutrition supplements for hundreds of pounds each month, but you cannot compensate. Nine days ago I was at my GP and I think it really he sums up how the doctor sees it. And then he read from a letter that he'd received from her from his doctor received reading to me from a letter he received the previous day, quote, blood samples taking it for for show very low levels of vitamin D, maybe you should increase the dose of a telfa. That's what its doctor is saying. So when the doctor does not know what to do, yes, because he asks you if you can double the dose, yes, because I'm on the highest dose he can prescribe and bone density measurements. They say that in three to five years I have I have osteoporosis, osteoporosis, if it does not turn, no. And vitamin D is important for taking calcium. I've never had any dental problems, but now my teeth are breaking like crackers. So when it eventually gets empty in the calcium, calcium reservoirs are as it was reservoirs. I do not do not know what to do. So we need to relate experiencing crumbling bodies and rapid dropping capacity to cope with everyday life made participants draw parallels to aged bodies. As Roger summarized as similar experience. My body is breaking down faster than I am aging. The decomposition of the body begins before you die. In some, the Yes, led to smaller and more capable bodies, but also disrupted bodies undesirably interfering with daily life. Okay, so the next part is called being a dignified patient. Dude, he's asleep next to me, and he's doing little. Let's see if you can hear him. Nice stop now. Maybe you woke up because he heard me say his name. Okay, so being a dignified patient. The feeling of responsibility is prominent in participants stories about undergoing surgery intertwined with their stories of compliance and making their new body's function as intended in daily life. Quote, I think that you have to know what you're getting yourself into. Of course, you're not guaranteed that it will be 100% Fine. But at least I think that I have to do my best to make it as good as possible. Because I hope and I suppose they've done this, then it's up to me, you cannot go back. So you will accept quite a lot. You have to take it up on your own self. And it's hard to say anything. It's a bit embarrassing to tell because it actually means I haven't done my job or paid enough attention to the preoperative training. So talking about how this person is talking about how they have to be a good patient now post op, and if they have complications, and it's their fault because they weren't a good patient. And he just says the participants have an underlying feeling of responsibility entangled with blaming themselves for their need for and choice to undergo the surgery as well as for problems experienced after BS. Okay, shame and unknown problems. And he just says, even eight years after undergoing BS, all the participants exercise caution in talking about their surgery if they are not 100% comfortable with the interlock, you interlocutors, interlocutors interlocutors This is from the dictionary, a person who takes part in a dialogue or conversation.

So why did the wonder of use long word of God interlocutors, okay, so if they're not 100% comfortable with it interlocutors, and they still have not taught people they interact with daily about it, due to the feeling that surgery is a defeat and an abnormal way of losing weight, quote, imagine losing a pound a day. It's not your achievement. I'm not proud. It was no hard effort to get on the operating table either. And I laid myself there voluntarily. And I know very well that I was too fond of chocolate. Therefore, it was self inflicted to get there because I failed. I was unable to do anything about my weight problem myself. So I'm not announcing Hi, my name is Hannah, and I have bariatric surgery. Laughing. If I'm asked, I will tell but I feel ashamed. On the web, for example, if anyone asks for some experiences, it is not certain. I'm the first to help out. Because then in a way, I'm revealing myself. Nothing. I'm a bit embarrassed by the fact that I was so big that it was irrelevant. I think it's more notable to lose weight by yourself. And now, I just want to really like this quote from Hannah. How much shame and blame is in there? And fat phobic beliefs? Right? Okay, so I'm not proud. And she isn't she's saying I'm not proud because I didn't do anything difficult when actually, she did do something incredibly difficult. And she says I was just lying on the operating table. It has no, there was no hard efforts. But actually, I imagine for Hannah to be at that point where she chose to have surgery, there was a lot of struggle that she went through, you know, and I mean, Jesus, having a tooth out, or getting a felon is difficult. I've got four fillings in the next next Friday. Oh, looks good. And so it's really diminishing, she's really diminishing the hardships that it took and saying I was no efforts, you know? That, you know, it's it's hyperbole, it's, she's really Yeah, docking herself. And then she says, I like myself there voluntarily and I know very well that I was too fond of chocolate. This is what you'll see often is people say, you know, I blame myself I know it's my problem because I ate too much food. And it's, that's a fat phobic assumption, right? There's a fat phobic belief coming to the forefront, which is this very black and white thinking of I eat chocolate, therefore, I am fat. And I am to blame for my body size. Now, do we know what causes fatness? Yes, yes and no. Yes. And it's in the hundreds, hundreds of different reasons. And do we know why people may eat more chocolate than they think is okay. So someone says I just eat chocolate day and night. From the moment I wake up to the moment I go to bed. Wally is chocolate because I am greedy. What that tells me is they are probably responding to a ton of restriction that they probably are going in waves of being like, I should be good. Okay, tomorrow, I'm going to be good. Tomorrow. Just eats you know, diet food or doesn't eat enough food or, and then you know, continues that for as long as they can, as long as they can before their body is like flogging something. And then they will go to the thing that is nice that they enjoy chocolate that they've denied themselves. And it you know, puts chocolate or whatever it is on a pedestal is this sinful thing that I can't stop thinking about? Because there's something wrong with me? Versus okay. I'm wondering why I'm having these big feelings around chocolate. I wonder why I tend to go towards it. And I wonder why I feel out of control?

What is going on here? What is the reality? is Am I being influenced by diet culture by fat phobia? Is it that I'm just an inherently bad person and I when I want to as soon as I was born, or you know, my first words was chocolate, because I am an inherently addicted person to chocolate and I am bad and out of control. Is that the reality? No. I mean, are we pretty cool. Someone's was word was chocolate. But I mean it's it's, you know, this is not created in a vacuum and if someone does eat a lot of chocolate, is that does that mean that they're bad? Does that mean that they're unhealthy? You know, and and then we go into okay, well what is health? Who knows what Hannah was experiencing because it she didn't talk about it here. But she says I got so big that it was relevant is what her words are to have bariatric surgery but But it seems very simplified to say it's Hannah's fault that she was, I don't know, if she still is fat, because she ate too much chocolate. And it, it probably feels good in some ways to be able to pinpoint it and blame it on yourself. Right? It probably does feel like it's it. I know, I know, I caused this to myself because I did this thing. That probably feels better than actually, I don't know why I'm fat. Actually, health is really complicated. Actually, maybe I don't have control. Maybe if I stopped eating chocolate, I would still be fat. And that doesn't feel good for a lot of people. Because it's nicer to think, Okay, I just need to stop this behavior. And then I'll get the result that I want. Yeah, so So anyway, I'm just, you know, reading Hannah's thing. It's just she says, I feel ashamed. And I don't think I mean, I personally, I don't think people should feel ashamed for having bariatric surgery because, I mean, same way I don't think that people should feel ashamed for for, for having fat phobic beliefs, unless they are, you know, actively, like being a fat fo you know, but I don't think people should be ashamed for being a product of society. I don't think people should feel ashamed for doing things to try and fit in, try and live a longer life, because that's what they've been told. So I don't think people need to feel shame. And I don't think that losing weight quote, naturally on a diet or losing weight with surgery. One is morally superior. One is harder or less hard. I mean, it's you know, different circumstances right. But to me surgery sounds really fucking hard. Even if it's laparoscopic, you know, keyhole surgery. I had my gallbladder out. That fucking hurt. Like fuck, because they have to, like blow your stomach and not blow it up, you know, inflate it with air, so they got the space to do things. That motherfucker you wouldn't have been air in your abdomen cavity would be so painful. And that's just my experience. Other people might be like, What are you talking about? But yeah. Okay, so continuing, dismissed and personalized problems. As described above, above, several of the interview interviewees experienced unknown problems and crumbling bodies experiencing issues in different degrees and combinations such as poor short term memory, emotional intimate stability, cold intolerance, low energy and bad teeth. All of these issues were not experienced before surgery, for example, bury a former angler now living on a disability pension due to previous heart problems, still likes to go fishing but he has problems with his fingers. They get stiff, and he loses feeling in the feeling in them in cold weather. These problems were restricting his activities as a leisure fisherman in Norway. So he went to his GP. This is a quote from from Barry Barry boughs. I froze so much, so I thought the doctor might be able to investigate a little. And he says, Did the GP think it had to do with the operation? Now? Did she think you were just whining then? Hell, I don't know. My blood pressure was too low.

Once I was told it was because I was too calm and balanced. That's what she told me once. Continuing in numerating, these problems participants often referred to the mandatory pre operative program, and the fact that they were encouraged to get in touch if problems occurred. John described his only call to them. Quote, at the hospital, we were told that side effects were hardly any to speak of, and we would receive good follow up for 10 years, and they had specialists. They followed us at 910 11 months, something like that. And then we're gonna pan on our shoulder when we left. The responsibility was given to the GPS because because they had so much to do, operating on new patients. I tried to call them once to ask if they knew of others with dental problems. There was no one who was bothered with teeth after these operations. Never heard of it. End of discussion. If other issues came up as when Roger was referred for acute psychiatric treatment following a suicide attempt, participants were reminded of their unconventional treatment and their responsibility for their own destiny. Quote, I was at the hospital a while ago, I have had several suicidal suicide attempts. They did not know what gastric bypass was, what is it? What is it? Once they had to use Google? Then I thought, What the hell have I done I've been so far down that I've wanted to kill myself. In reflecting upon the responsibility of undergoing BS discussed by all the participants, Roger is the only one to pinpoint the surgeries effect on the body as a system when reflecting on his or her experience. Quote, bariatric surgery is like playing with nature, the body is, is as it is for a reason it is created in a certain way. Doesn't have to be God, but it's not meant to be redesigned, the body should be kept the way it is, don't mess with it, you're gonna get into trouble. I know all about it. And in my situation now, alcoholic was several suicide attempts behind him. I have nothing to hold back. I just want people to know what they're doing. Choosing surgery, do not mess with your body. They claim the body to be the world's finest machinery. And then the doctors cut out half of the cogwheels it has to break down morphing. Okay, so wrapping this up discussion section here, and he says bariatric surgery expands beyond the boundaries of the body and into daily life. In a short time surgery alters the physical body and functions as intended enabling weight loss and normal weight normal equipment I'm getting I'm putting quotation no more weight. In the long term. Surgical alterations also affect the body beyond the digestive system by irreversible processes that we can enter body structures, an empty its reservoirs, establishing a vulnerability to unforeseen, unknown unacknowledged and not yet curable health problems. The resulting vulnerability requires continuous attention to avoid problems and cope in everyday life. Living individuals individual lives in different contexts bariatric bodies may for some replace fat related problems due to regained health and avoiding fat stigma, while for others it may not. Responsibility for health was a fundamental theme in the narratives from choosing surgery, striving to comply with treatment and coping with problems after surgery. Still, eight years later, the participants were cautious about discussing discussing their form of fatness, Bs and post BS problems, fearing stigma and worsening of their situation. Talking about it will reveal their spoiled identity as a morally weak and irresponsible confirming them as morally weak and irresponsible confirming them as abnormal because they have undergone elective surgery for a condition understood to be self inflicted. Their internalized shame and self stigma, stigma stigma, stigma ties ation results in efforts to non disclose a non help seeking in retrospect by wanting and consenting to be us. The participants experienced unforeseen effects of treatment, some common and some individual, but all unexplainable and addressable. When the consent was informed, it's difficult to determine in hindsight with the knowledge available, whether the consent was informed is difficult to determine in hindsight, with the knowledge available in 2008.

Undergoing irreversible elective surgery makes it difficult to speak out when informed consent was given, especially when doing so is disapproved by bariatric clinics, the participants of this trying to solve the problems they experience on their own. The long term follow up program was cut due to costs and reprioritization ins. Okay, so here is the conclusion. Another little bit of rereading conclusion. There's stuff above it but then here we go living with Bs in the long run bariatric surgery by the way, in case you've forgotten, maybe experience is demanding both due to the continual consciousness of the object of body and the strong feeling of responsibility to comply with the new body to avoid problems after surgery. Bariatric bodies constitute a vulnerability both physiologically and psychologically and not least to prejudices towards fatness and be us. speaking out about problems after surgery is difficult when experiencing unknown On unacknowledged problems, the study highlights the need for in depth studies on patients experiences of living with bariatric bodies in everyday life to broaden the understanding of the effects of BS. Providing individual outcomes BS may be perceived as an experimental treatment. Individual and contextual parameters of success guides were the BS functions as a positive biographical disruption, or just another event in the biographical flow reinforcing an already difficult life. The patient's success parameters is adjusted by time and life context, depending on daily experiences of living with a body interfering with life, reinforcing both the positive and negative effects of BS. This study confirms a widespread illusion of the body as a controllable unit separable from the lot from life in contemporary society. In addition to documenting the experiences of BS this study reminds us of two potential pitfalls in medical sociology. First, the risk of presenting patients experiences as universal as potentially legitimate legitimizing medical intervention with insecure effects and the patient's responsibility for treatment outcomes. Second, the need for in depth longitudinal quality qualitative studies in order to understand the long term experiences of treatment, finally, sociological knowledge should not be not forget to include the body as a social phenomenon in the analysis, and not merely study narratives of the body as a biomedical phenomenon. So we don't have a lot of information about patients experiences in regards to them speaking, you know, we don't we don't have a lot of of studies to show actual data. Long term. There's another piece, and that's a problem, right? That is a problem. And we need to, we need to look at stuff like data, like, Okay, let's look at, you know, hundreds 1000s of patients, and let's look at the data and let's look at when they died, let's look at what diseases they appeared after, after surgery. Let's, I mean, this is impossible, right? It's impossible. Not that stuff. But it's impossible to separate, then why why why did they die? Why? What effect did oppression have on them? What effect did not being able to go to the doctor because of shame because of lack of access? What effect did that have on health? What affects do poor medical interventions? When people do go to the doctors? What affects the lack of nutrients for year over year over year? Yeah, you know, so we to pull that all apart? If we can have that data? I mean, that's why we we don't we don't, you know, we don't have that data.

We have this piece which is called patient experiences of outcomes of bariatric surgery, a systematic review, and qualitative qualitative qualitative synthesis from Karen Kuhlman, Fiona kitchen, Jane Blaise Lee and Amanda Owen Smith, which is an overview of all of the research that we have at this stage, and I'm just going to pull out some quotes very quickly. And this is. So again, looking at this, and so this is a review of what we've got so far, in regards to experiences. Now, something to think about what this stuff is. When was the one with the paid people interviewed? Who were they interviewed by? Because like, so if they're interviewed, and we've got this information in the study, right, we've got this information, okay. And most of the people are being interviewed eight months, one to five years, 18 months, 12 months, two to five years, five to six years, two to nine years. So the longest hair we have is 10 years and so there was a study here which was psychosocial social experiences following gastric bypass and it was C six months to 10 years out, and that was of 33 people, how many of those were 10? years out? Was it just one people? Was it all 33? People? You know, we we don't we don't have that right there, we could look into each study to find out. But you know, just like an overview, most of the people in this is looking at the all of the studies that this paper is looking at, are people who are short term. Also, who is doing the interviews, what methods are they using, because because of everything that we just spoke about the shame of, of the realities of living after surgery, if it's people from the team that did the procedure, I guess it would be more likely that they say, yeah, no, everything's great. Yeah, it's good, because good, versus a non, someone who's not biased in that way. So that's something to think about as well. The the quotes from this article, there's two things that two things that I've noticed is I've got medical issues now and it sucks. And the other one is, I'm thin now. And therefore, I'm in a privileged group. And life is easier because of that. So there's a lot of people who are not a lot this like, you know, don't want like 10 different quotes of people who say, I'm happy now, because people will talk to me, because I can get a day because people were not stigmatizing me because of my size. Which is, is that I mean, and that's great for that. That's great, right? We don't want anyone to have to experience those things. Is the solution to living in a fat phobic world to have surgery? Or is it to tackle the problem at the root of the problem? But here's the other thing. When is that going to happen? You know, you know, what is like changing people's belief systems and society and all the different ways that manufactured fatphobia manifests in the world that's going to take there's going to be beyond our lifetimes, right? And so are we saying to people, the best way to go about it is to change society not to go and have surgery. And some people are like, I, I can't wait for that to happen, because my life is shit right now. And I'm going to do anything I can to not to make it not shit. And that's valid. You know, what? I mean? Would you want to be waiting around your whole life for society to change, and, you know, society is going to change in our lifetimes. But you know, all the systemic things of, of, you know, when we look at things like, oh, women are going to be paid equally within the next 100 years. It's just those things. systemic things take a longer time. But the way that, you know, we think about, you know, sexism, even the way that we think about and we talk about women and gender roles, and patriarchy in the last 10 years is night and day, right. And so, there will be a lot of changes, then we have seen a lot of changes already in attitudes, and it will also take a long time to change a lot of things too.

So, so that's the big things I noticed with these quotes is the that my life is better because I'm thinner. But again, remember, these people are a lot, most of them are not long term. And so we have data up until year five, if I remember or three or something, year, three, good data to show weight loss. And you know, 63% of people have put weight back on by year three. And so this stuff is kind of anecdotal, right? When they say I'm thin now and it's kind of like, oh, no, how long are you going to be thin for maybe forever, you know, and Okay, so we've got the, it's great to not be in a in a marginalized group. Because people treat me better, which is good for them and also that's That's fucked up for that is true. Yeah, it is true. And the health outcomes really fucking suck. And so let me give you some, some of the quotes of the health outcomes really fucking suck things. And these are short ones. Okay, so quote, you just have to find out how much you actually can eat and what you can tolerate. It has been some challenge navigating such as a labyrinth, female Denmark, quote, I must admit that I'm quite scared and often think what if my weight increases again? It's the worst case like a nightmare. I've spoken to others who've told me that they've put on weight after two years, I get really anxious when they tell me this participant, Norway. It's funny how I know was was it? No, it was Norway. Yeah, it was normally I'm gonna say hang on why we got all these Nordic countries. That just happens to be anyway, whatever. I must admit that I'm an and I don't know if I mentioned previously, in the paper that we were just reading. In Norway, Norway were given away at an if they still are free bariatric surgery. And so they were pushing a lot of people through to get that done. I don't know if they still are. And so that might be why we have more people from Norway, maybe from Nordic countries. I don't know if their neighbors are doing similar things. Anyway, continuing on my side notes. I must say, we didn't get one. Right after surgery, there is a part of you that thinks I'm cured, I'm automatically going to lose weight. But the surgery alone only works by itself for the first several months, maybe a year. But then you have to take over, you have to establish your new habits and your new patterns. And that can be rough because you're confronting a lot of issues that you've never confronted before. Female USA quote, It feels like I have a rock in the machinery which makes me disabled in my daily life. Life. I'm struggling with low blood pressure. Occasionally I See Stars and nearly faint when I work. Female Norway. The women emphasized how their blood values and vitamin levels have changed dramatically after surgery. They constantly struggled with iron deficiency, low hemoglobin percentage and B 12. Deficiency. While these levels were previously regarded as normal in terms of medical standards, they were far below the acceptable level accepted level after the surgery. author's words. So the authors from one of the papers. So there you have it, there you have it. And yeah, people's experiences and you know, I've not had surgery like this. So I know, I have nothing to say in regards to my experience, because I have no experience. Yeah, and again, I want to point out, just to make it really clear, that if you have had are thinking of having or no, you definitely are going to have bariatric surgery, it doesn't mean that you are a bad person, it doesn't mean that you are not intelligent, it doesn't mean the I think that you're an idiot or something, you know, I think it's complicated. And there's many reasons why someone would choose to do it.

And I also hope that we can continue sharing more information, as more information has been collected, and gathered to show the long term effects and to show the reality is and, you know, one of these quotes here saying, you know, it only works for the first year or so and then you have to take over and you have to change your lifestyle and, and that kind of like gave me the chills of the shudders of the, you know, when you go on a diet and what really made me it's like, really made me say what the fuck was when I was on Weight Watchers and I lost a lot of weight and I was just like, I can keep this up, I can keep this up. And then when I've lost weight, then I can go back to eating food. And when I lost weight I said to the leader, you know, can I start eating food now? And she was like, No, you have to eat like this for the rest of your life. And that was a holy shit. Of now I know you have to decide had to be engaged in disordered eating or an eating disorder for the rest of your life to in the hopes of maintaining thinness, not even a guarantee of it in the hopes of maintaining thinness. And, and it's the same with this, like, you're choosing to have a disordered relationship with food for the rest of your life, sometimes irreversibly. Knowing that you, you know, like that one guy was saying he can't eat a meatball and a spoon of gravy without throwing up. And so you just have to have beer. That's what he's what that's what he's doing. So yeah, and I think some people are able to recover in regards to get back to eating in a way that feels more quote, normal, you know, like, not disordered. You know, I do know, people who've had surgery who are able to become intuitive eaters afterwards. And I do you know, people who've had surgery who haven't had bad side effects. And even so regret it. And I know people who have had surgery and don't regret it. Yeah, so I think the thing in here is, is the more experiences we hear the better because one person's outcome is going to be you know, totally unique to them. And we can never guarantee okay, this is what's going to happen. And if we know that, okay, in the hopes of become thin, I'm risking dying. I'm risking shitting my pants every single day. One of the one of the things that I didn't read out was a guy who was saying, Well, I go between having diarrhea and having constipation. And on the days when I when I when I when I know it's a diarrhea day, I can't leave the Hay House. And when it's a constipation day, I also can't leave the house because the pain is too immense. And if I do go out I have to take with me like emergency food in case I faint because of lack of sugar. You know, like this other person saying that they were fainting. And so it's like living life in it being very difficult, very difficult. And as someone who lives with with IBS, I mean, they fucking sucks. Just the IBS stuff, it's sucks and so I can't imagine also then having a meatball and some gravy and immediately throwing up and not being able to eat being like, Okay, well I can't have breakfast like that one guy was saying can't have breakfast because then I'm going to be sick at work. Okay, so I'll just not have breakfast and then but I need to eat food and yeah, it must be really difficult to to keep up with that and to get enough food into you and then spend so much on that guy. One of the one of the guys were saying that he couldn't afford to the vitamins. He couldn't get the vitamins in in Denmark because they stopped being produced the vitamins that this the surgeons told him to use. And so we had to have them imported from the UK and that's why they met he mentioned that pounds cost hundreds of pounds, hundreds of pounds is a lot. So in us it's like let's see hundreds as a 300 Hundreds 100 pound to us. Okay, so you know that's 400 $400 a month on on vitamins and minerals.

Okay, well if you want to know more about this, you want to look at the stats and hear all of the all of that type of stuff, go back to the other episode, which is episode 50 If you want to get to get links to all of the things that I share today, this is episode 122. So you go to fears fatty.com forward slash 122. And you'll get all the links for everything that I've mentioned today and a link to the old episode or to the Instagram post and these two studies. Yeah, okay, well, I hope you have a nice psycho. Nice rest of your day and I'll see you in the next episode. Okay, bye. See you later crocodiles. This work and want to know when the doors open to fears fatty Academy, which is my signature program, where I teach all about how to overcome your fat phobic beliefs and learn to love your fat body, then go to fit Use fatty.com forward slash waitlist again that is fierce fatty.com forward slash waitlist to get your name on the waitlist for when first fatty Academy my signature program opens.

EP121 Transcript

Welcome to the Fierce Fatty Podcast. I'm your host, Victoria Welsby, and this is episode 121. Today, we're talking about “Seeing people after gaining weight”.

I'm Victoria Welsby, TEDx speaker, best-selling author, and fat activist. I have transformed my life from hating my body with desperately low self-esteem to being a courageous and confident fierce fatty who loves every inch of this jelly. Society teaches us living in a fat body is bad. But what if we spent less time, money, and energy on the pursuit of thinness and instead focused on the things that actually matter? Like if pineapple on pizza should be outlawed? Or if the mullet was the greatest haircut of the 20th century? So how do you stop negative beliefs about your fat body controlling your life? It's the Fierce Fatty Podcast. Let's begin.

it's our last show together. Oh, my globe. I know for now, I guess like we didn't really talk about it when we went out for dinner the other week. Went out for your birthday. Happy birthday. Thank you.

Oh, now you turn 43 Haven't been haven't been dead yet? No, I know.

You got into 40. And just like don't even know like, you literally have to like do the math in your head because you can't remember.

I'm 37. I'm still I think from the age of 35. I've always rounded up my age. And then when I did when I get to my birthday, and then I calculate how old I actually am. I'm like, a year younger than what I thought this is great. So it's a good like problem to have in my brain because I keep thinking I'm 38 Then I remember the seven and I'm like, oh page Columbo another year. You know, it's pretty good. Yeah. Yeah, that's a good way to do it.

Today, our last episode, what are we talking about? So we are talking about, we really just want to put the nail in the coffin as it relates to dieting. And so we are answering the question, what if you need to lose weight? I said it like that, because you capitalize the need. Yeah.

Well, you want to lose weight to lose weight. Yeah, and I think we both got a lot of feedback from our audiences around this. So yeah, good.

We'll just do a brief intro of the show for anyone who's listening. This is death to diets where we talk about diet culture, ridiculousness of diet, culture, stuff that's happening that's more topical, as well as stuff that you know, we've heard from you feedback from you on things that you want us to discuss, and we don't shame people for dieting, we really just talk about the cultural issue of dieting in general and how it hurts individuals and what we can do better. Yes, yes, yes, yes. And who are you anyway? Summer? Who the hell are ya?

Summer Antonin. I'm a professionally trained coach that specializes in body image confidence and self worth. And I've been doing this work for about eight years, I help people all from all over the world. And I host a podcast called Eat the rules. Yeah, are you who are you? Who am I? Who am I'm still trying to work out some I don't know. But here is a 3d print of my teeth. So you come from you said, Do you want this? And I said, Fuck yeah, I want this 3d printing of my teeth. So I can put it on my desk. I mean, come on.

Do you think Google will come and see if it will scare me, but he didn't realize that it was my teeth. You know, I kind of like for those who can't see the I'm smashing them together in a bite thing. But he just was cool. Yeah, so you know. So yeah. Anyway, that's a closeup of my 3d printing of my teeth. I teach people how to unlearn a fat phobia. So that's all people fat people, thin dieticians, tall people, short people, you know, everyone around everyone around the place.

And I have a podcast face fatty which is where this has been hosted. If you know me, then that's it.

And yeah, here's my non binary crown. Yeah, hobby Trans Day of visibility is trying to save his military. This is the crown that I wore on my gender celebration ceremony on New Year's Eve. And it's got the color the non binary colors, which are purple, gray, white, and yellow. But I don't really like wearing it because it makes me feel a bit too feminine. So I'm like, like it because I want people to worship me, but also don't like it because I'm like, it's a little bit too feminine. I need to I need to mask it up a bit. Maybe put on some spikes or the Damascus? Yes. Yeah, it's like Game of Thrones, like the spikes out of the chair type of thing. Yeah. Yeah. Or it could be like, I don't know, with decks or something. I'm just thinking like, what can I find in the local area with your 3d teeth on it? I feel right? Because the idea was fucking rubbish. Nice try. but no cigar. No, it's not working. person better ideas. Jesus. Yeah.

So so so so so so. So summer? We hear this all the time, right about, but I need what I've know if you do, I do, presume you do.

With lots of use, but I need to lose weight. So I need to go on a diet, because dot dot dot dot dot. And so you're going to take the first big one, and I'll take the other one. And so what is the first reason that people say but I need to lose weight? for health, for health being I think one of the bigger bigger ones. So obviously, you know, most people believe that.

In order to be healthy, you have to be in a in a smaller sized bought like in a straight sized body or in a lower body weight than you're currently at.

We know that that is not true. We know that a lot of health conditions are more. It's more about like there's some correlation there not necessarily causation.

I mean, actually, I was just curious, like when someone comes to you and says that, how do you answer that mutually? Yeah, so what I would say is okay,

first off, I'm not a doctor, I'm not giving out. Yeah, health, blah, blah, blah, whatever. It's called diagnosis, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, I'm not blah, blah, blah, and blah, blah, blah. But I would ask the questions of like, you know, is normally the big kind of things that we associate with fatness? And so it's normally things like, type two diabetes, it's normally things like sore knees, it's, you know, like, so again, Sleep Apnea is Yeah, so it's normally the things that we associate, you know, the things that are going to kill all the fatties, and so I will present with them with information. And so my favorite resource do you know about this resource? Is the Hayes health sheets.com. Do you know about that one? Yeah. My loved ones that Reagan Chastain came up with. Yeah. And so I talked about it, like pretty much every every podcast episode. Basically, everything I ever talked about is just listening. And so all of them are all on there. So heart disease, high blood pressure, high cholesterol, joint pain, joint replacement, non alcoholic fatty liver disease. She had sleep apnea, PCOS, type two diabetes and osteo. Arthritis. And we look at them every single one, what causes this? And none of them are because you are too fat, because you need to lose weight. And the the biggest ones type two diabetes, non alcoholic fatty liver,

heart, Hi, Claire straw, things like that. Most of it is genetic. And yes, fat people are at a higher risk. We don't know why. But what we do know is that fat people have worse health outcomes, because one, because of the stigma that we face, the the raging fatphobia that we live in to because of dieting. Dieting is really not great for our health, and three because of the subpar health care that we get. And so, you know, are those things, any of those things, the fault of fat people? No.

So the big thing is, it's not your fault. And let's actually look into what we can do to support health using this information created by Raven Chastain, Tiana Dodson, and the last person it's skipping.

It's gone out on my head, but it's a medical doctor. he's come up with these recommendations. Yeah. So that's what I would say. So what would you say? Yeah, I always like to ask people, What does health mean to them? I always like to understand, you know, what, what, you know, what's your kind of personal definition of health? Because I think that that's, that, really, it can be different. And I think that sometimes when we ask ourselves that question, we might start to identify things that actually don't have anything to do with weight, like we might think we might say, you know, it's, it's to have energy, or it's to, you know, be able to keep up with my kids, or it's to be able to, you know, sleep well, or, you know, like, just different components of, of health. And when we actually can look at those things, or we can create a personal definition. And I failed to mention, like mental health, I think a lot of people when they don't even think of that. But if you say, Well, what about mental health?

And they might think, oh, yeah, like, you know, stress reduction, or some of these other things, we start to see that none of those things really have to do with the size of your body, that, you know, we can work towards better energy or stress reduction, or better sleep or better mobility, via things that don't require dieting or or weight loss, because we know that the outcome of dieting is actually going to be more harmful to your health overall, we know that dieting is a stressor, and we know that weight cycling is not not good for for your health overall. And so I think if we can create our own personal definition of what health is and look at what we want more of for ourselves, that that's really important. And I also think that just some education around the fact that we don't have so much control over our health as we've been led to believe, I think that diet culture, wellness culture, has us believe that like, we can control everything about our health, like if we only find the right supplements, the right nutrients, if we only eat more of the certain foods, that we can, you know, that we can control our health outcomes. And like, that's such, that's such bullshit, like, we we can't, it's so much it, like you said, so much of it is, is genetic. And I think that a much smaller percentage is really related to things like food and movement, I would say stress is probably a bigger component in that one that we tend to neglect because we just want to like, we just feel that like, well, I need to just add more kale to my life or something like that. And that's not actually going to do anything that you would have everlasting life. superfood, right. That's what that means is.

Yeah, super cute. Oh, I thought I was gonna live forever, because I had a cow sandwich one time.

Yeah, really good point this summer is something that I talk about a lot is the determinants of health. And I'm actually reshare the graphic on my Instagrams of what I used to think what I eat and how I move is pretty much 90% of what made up my health status. The reality is my health status is made up of many different things. Things like the fact that I have white skin, that I am university educated that I live in Canada, that I have access to go into therapy, that I go to visit a doctor who doesn't shame me constantly because of my weight. Only sometimes that I'm not exposed to guns that I have safer sex that I

Unknown Speaker 13:54

wear so long, huh? You don't smoke either, which is, yeah, and so and so it's actually really, really, really complicated. And there is like health, like, what does that mean? You know, what, what is it? You know, it's such this amorphous concept of, we can never arrive at being healthy. It's not a place not a destination, we can get to where we like, right? That's it, I'm done for life, I've ticked the health box, and I can just live forever. It's just it's constantly changing. There's so many different parts of what is healthy, and most of it we can't control and just a kind of quick, you know, quick and dirty overview of the determinants of health, massive study done, individual behavior, it makes up 36% of health, determinants of health on the individual over level, and individual behavior isn't just food and movement. It's psychological. It's mood disorders. It's a risk related behavior, like driving a car and the risks

Unknown Speaker 15:00

associated with getting into accidents, it's your sleep patterns, and physical activity and diet. And so physical activity and diet are just two points within 36%. And I think that's something like, I don't know, 6% or something. So and So, really what society tells us physical health is is like 99%. How much kale do you eat? In reality? You know, and even in that diet, and diet and moving, that doesn't necessarily mean that you just eat kale, and work out 75 hours a day, is actually way more complicated than that, and more nuanced, and is different for everyone. Yeah, yeah. It's so individual. And like, I'm just, you know, privileged, like you said, plays such a huge role with, with all of this stuff. And I think that, like, we also need to be asking ourselves, you know, if we want to make changes in the name of health, like if we want to, you know, focus on whether that's blood sugar management, or, you know, better stress reduction, or sleep or whatever, to always look at what you can add versus what you need to take away. Because I think that we've, we've learned that like, oh, we must take a restrictive approach, we must look at what I should eliminate from my life or my diet. And I'm a big fan of looking at like, well, what, what can we add more of

Unknown Speaker 16:31

it and making changes that are really, really small, that feel ridiculously doable? Because I think that there's also this mentality of like, well, I'm going to make all these sweeping changes, and I'm going to starting Monday, I'm gonna, you know, do, I'm going to go to the gym, and I'm going to eat this. And, you know, we know that we know that ends up, end up kind of in like this kind of the same sort of restrict binge cycle. So really looking at two things. One is like, what can you add and what feels ridiculously doable for you? And, you know, how are you going to feel if your body doesn't change? Like, what how are you going to sort of assess whether something is working for you? Like, what can what intentions can you set for yourself? Whether that's, well, no, it's working for me if I just you know, if my digestion is better, or if I'm sleeping better, or if I just feel better overall, and bring it back to, you know, listening to our bodies to kind of see what, what feels best. For us knowing that like, that doesn't mean you're less of an individual, if there's something wrong with you, if you have a health condition, or if you have if you have diabetes, like it's not your fault. So much of that is is like you said just outside of our control? Mm hmm. Yeah, and the kind of the health ism and ableism that's in there as well. Exactly. Like you say, someone who is not healthy or not able bodied, is exactly equally as worthy and important as someone who is quote unquote, healthy whenever healthy. Yeah. And if you choose to engage in like health behaviors, that doesn't make you a better person, like then someone else who if you have that choice as well, like I think that that's

Unknown Speaker 18:16

another thing that we have to divest from is this idea that like I'm a better person because I do these things you're not on and I some I definitely felt like I was a better person when I was like running 10 k's and stuff and posting about it on social media being like I did in the rain, what's your use?

Unknown Speaker 18:37

As a better person. Did you do that? Did you realize oh, my God, this memory popped up of me and my then boyfriend running in the fucking snow and ice. And I said, we are so dedicated to health that we do it even when and I was and now I'm like, what?

Unknown Speaker 18:53

Snow and Ice worm because it's dangerous. And two, why are you being such a self righteous decayed by posting it on Facebook? And you know, people I'm so so bad. I need to, I need to find it again. So that I can share it and be like, Look, what a balance. I mean, I I definitely have some shit like that to it. I think like you it might have made you feel like a better version. But that was because you were so insecure. Like you don't I mean, like you didn't actually, like wholeheartedly feel like a better person. It was like that hit of validation that you're getting made you feel like about her first. Yeah, exactly.

Unknown Speaker 19:31

Yeah, you're right, because I was actually just being like, Oh, look, I'm such a good fatty because I'm going out for a run.

Unknown Speaker 19:37

You tell me that I'm okay. You know, I understand Paul. You know, we need you know, I understand I get them that there were there were sausage and they were addicted. You know both of those things at the same time. Yeah.

Unknown Speaker 19:52

Okay, so then anything else you want to say on that or should we move over to the other reason? Let's go on to the other thing, which is

Unknown Speaker 20:00

The other big thing is mobility, which is the other thing is people say, I am so unfit. Now now that I've put on weight a lot of people since the global Panini that we are in, they put on weight. And now they can't do the things that they used to be able to do before the Panini, or perhaps when they were younger. Or they say, you know, now I go upstairs, and I'm out of breath. And it's because I've put on a little bit of weight. So what do you think might be going on there? Summer? Yeah, I mean, like, here's the thing.

Unknown Speaker 20:40

There's a couple things one, fat phobia, like just the this sort of belief that like, well, it must be because of my body size, because that's what we've learned.

Unknown Speaker 20:51

As well, like, sometimes when our bodies change, there's an adaptation period that happens that it takes a while for your body to like, you know, feel the same way that it did before.

Unknown Speaker 21:06

And so sometimes, you know, like, for example, if your belly sticks out further than it did before, then doing particular things like whether it's tying your shoes or doing a particular pose in yoga, like that is going to get in the way, and it is, is going to feel different. And I think that that doesn't mean that there's something wrong with you, or that you're, you know, like that. You need to make a change to your body. I think it's just like, how can we work with the body that we have in this moment? And how can we take the focus off of weight being the problem and focus on like, what we really want more of if, for example, we want to be able to, you know, pick up more things or be more mobile? Mm hmm, yeah, I always find it, I find it so interesting that it's kind of like A plus B equals C, you know, one plus one equals 10. Because we've got a bigger body, then, of course, it's because we have a bigger body that we can no longer do the things that we used to do. And a lot of times I say, I say get my detective glasses out my molecule or whatever it is, you know, the thing that was it called the magnifying glass. And so okay, what's going on your life and like, when the last two years we've been in a global pandemic, I've given birth to a baby, I've had postpartum depression. I have suffered suffered an accident when I fell down the stairs and hurt my back, I stopped being able to go to my weekly Pilates class. I haven't gone out and done any type of movement recently.

Unknown Speaker 22:34

Yes. And it's like,

Unknown Speaker 22:39

I'm good. Any of those things together mean that you don't have the same abilities that you did?

Unknown Speaker 22:47

You made? And so if you do want to get back to whatever, you know, physical ability or mobility that you had, what can you do exactly what you said some? Or what can you do to support yourself towards those goals? Because if we try and lose weight, it's, it's not gonna, you know, we just know it's probably not going to happen.

Unknown Speaker 23:09

And so yeah, and the big thing as well is what you touched on of people saying, I feel uncomfortable in my body. And I like to think about it. When I was a kid, my mom said to me, do you want to get a hair cut, we have this this hairdresser that would come around our house, like super cheap. And she says, You're gonna Can you can get hair cut called the bomb. And I was like the bomb I wanted. She was saying a bob, but I missed.

Unknown Speaker 23:35

And I was like, Oh, the fucking bomb. Yes, please. And so I had long, thick hair, the hairdresser cut it short, didn't do any layering, because it was just like a quick and dirty thing. And the next morning, I remember waking up and seeing myself in the mirror, with this triangle of hair on my head, and being like.

Unknown Speaker 23:56

And it was really alarming. And when I shaved my head, going from long hair to having a shaved head, it's just weird and different. And so it's more noticeable. And that's hair. Having a bigger body is a lot. There's a lot, you know, there's fatphobia behind that. And so, of course, it's distressing. And of course, you feel physically uncomfortable, especially if you're wearing the same size clothes, especially if you're noticing changes in your body. And those changes in your mind mean that you're a bad person or you're or you're unhealthy, or whatever it is. And so you will get used to those new sensations of having a different body, you know, the same ways you get used to a shit haircut like I got when I was a kid. Yeah, I always use the example.

Unknown Speaker 24:42

I always use the example of like a new pair of shoes. It's like, you got to kind of break it in, right? Like it's like the body that if it's different, it it it's going to take a little while for your, your your mind to sort of catch up and and normalize it and I think that one of the things that often

Unknown Speaker 25:00

We do is like we completely,

Unknown Speaker 25:03

like, try to not look at it, we try to, like, avoid it, like we're just walking around with our heads cut off. And I think that that actually exasperates the issue, like, even just, you know, some physical touch, like put your hand on your belly or look down at your legs, like, take a minute to take them in, and whatever feelings come up are valid. But making your body less familiar, or I should say making your body more familiar is going to be beneficial to to that process as well. Because I think that we are, if we sort of just are like avoiding mirrors or avoiding pictures, we never see ourselves in our bodies of change. And then we're going to do something we haven't done, then it's going to bring up a lot of sort of feelings and and beliefs that we have. And so trying to work through that as well to become a little bit more embodied, I think is beneficial in that process. Mm hmm. Absolutely. And the other thing that I want to talk about in regards to mobility is

Unknown Speaker 26:03

wanting to unpack the ideas around health ism and ableism on this topic, too. And the idea that as we age, and because of life, because we you know, we don't know what's going to happen in life, you will lose my ability, as you get older, you're not going to have the ability to do the things that you did when you were 20. And you never know what's going to happen, you might lose your mobility for a reason. And so if you're tying your self esteem and your worth so closely to how mobile you are, and, and your health status, then you know I've got to break it to yet you're going to die one day, you know, you're going to get hopefully you're going to get old if we have the pleasure of of being able to age, and so things will change. And so if we can untangle our self esteem and our worth, from what our body does, I think that's really crucial. Because if we can't, then we're just going to be miserable for the rest of our lives. Yeah, yeah, absolutely. Totally. Yeah, it's kind of the same thing with like, your appearance, like I we're all aging out of this out of beauty standards. You know,

Unknown Speaker 27:15

if you're if you're if the way that you view yourself as a whole is hinged on that, then you're gonna it's gonna really hurt as you continue to see wrinkles and things hanging towards the floor. Yep, yep, yep, yep, yep. Unless, unless you're like me and you have saggy tits from the moment that you have tits, then, you know, you know, I had to deal with that since I was like 12 or whatever. Anyway, so I don't have to I don't I don't have tickets. So I can't really

Unknown Speaker 27:48

I don't like the zoo because like my

Unknown Speaker 27:56

my little prunes my little prunes. Oh.

Unknown Speaker 28:01

So

Unknown Speaker 28:07

now I want to talk about the reason that you might actually need to lose weight for health reasons, because, and people might say WHAT THE FUCK Hang on, you were both just talking about how you don't need to lose weight for health reason. But there could be a reason that you need to for health reasons. And that is if you are being denied life saving surgery until you meet an arbitrary BMI number. So, some people will say, like for gender confirmation surgery, we are not going to offer you gender confirmation surgery, unless you have your stomach amputated first, unless you lose weight first. And so you may choose because, you know, it's a life or death situation, you may choose to undergo surgery or to participate in a diet knowing that it's harmful to you knowing it's you know, not going to be resulting in long term weight loss in order to get life saving surgery or access to care or so many different things that fat people cannot get access to because of these ridiculous BMI standards.

Unknown Speaker 29:27

Yeah, and fertility I think is another one although, you know, it's not necessarily like life or death, but for a lot of people that's like, Yeah, they really that's what they want, like that's their life is is to be able to you know, have a family and, and there's a lot of, you know, fertility clinics or IVF that there's, there's a BMI limit and low is low, low low that BMI limit is basically you have to be straight size. Like it's fucking that really is so low. It's fucking gets on life.

Unknown Speaker 30:00

laps. And I am I made this whole post on Instagram medical fatphobia how public health promotes the eugenics of fat people and it goes into every single thing. Not every single thing because it would be like 50 billion things along, but a lots of different things that we don't even realize that how fat people are denied things. One that is very distressing to think about is

Unknown Speaker 30:30

transplants. So if you're on a transplant list, if you are fat, you are seen as your classic as higher risk, and so you're less likely to get a transplant. And so imagine if you're, you're so sick, that you need an organ transplant, and then having to either undergo stomach amputation or squeezing surgery or a diet in order to get life saved it life saving transplant is just so violent.

Unknown Speaker 30:59

It just makes me it makes me and you know, and the list goes on and on and on of different ways that, you know, things are denied to fat people. And so you may as a person make that decision to say, You know what, I know this is bullshit, but I'm going to die if I don't adhere to their,

Unknown Speaker 31:20

their guidelines. And so I'm gonna, I'm just gonna do it. Because this thing is so important for me. And the other thing to think about is

Unknown Speaker 31:31

when people are living with multiple marginalized identities, then perhaps dieting is the only way to be safe, or is a great way for them to be safe if they live in a fat body. Because society is kinder to fat people who are trying not to be fat versus fat people who are

Unknown Speaker 31:51

proudly fat. And so sometimes it is easier just to engage in dieting to prove your humanity to society. And so that's really important to recognize as well. Yeah. And I think he was sort of see that with celebrities, because they're under so much scrutiny and constant criticism. And even though they have wealth privilege,

Unknown Speaker 32:15

you still see how they will sometimes go down that route road. And it's all like, I think that it's it's also connected to that feeling of like, well, I want this, like the safety of not having that constant like barrage of criticism. Yeah, I can't even imagine like, I've done episodes on there. So you know what happens when your favorite fat celebrity loses weight, and I just think, fucking hell, like, if I was a celebrity, I wonder if I might be succumb to the pressure of the absolute scrutiny of my body, every single centimeter of it being pulled apart. My not being able to get roles being being casters, like the funny fat word, or this type of things. You know, I wonder if I would succumb to that. And this is coming from someone who is a fat activist. And so

Unknown Speaker 33:09

we're also putting these these people on a pedestal as if to say, they should have their shit together. They're representing the fat community or whatever. And it's kind of like,

Unknown Speaker 33:20

Yeah, but there are a few men, you know, when did they say, We don't know their history with dieting, and if they, they had a history of disordered eating, and all that type of stuff, and they're in fucking Hollywood, like, every single one of their Hollywood friend is probably like, oh my god, I'm just gonna rub some dust into my eyeballs. And I'm gonna lose like, you know, and so it's probably exhausting. Yeah, yeah. Yeah, I imagine. Yeah, no, I think you gotta like, have empathy for people. Because, yeah, it's just the culture we live in is, is violent, as you said. So yeah, yeah. So yeah, especially those who are, who are like super fat people, or, you know, fat people who are also people of color, or also are disabled or also are trans, you know, etc, etc. Yeah. Yeah. And I think that's the crux of, of death, the diets. I think we we don't want to say exactly like we say at the beginning of every episode, that you're, you're a fucking idiot, if you die if you're dieting, we're saying diets don't support us in the way that we've been told that they do. And in fact, they're really harmful. But we understand if people want to engage in diet culture for many different reasons. And it doesn't mean that you're a bad person or you're not smart or, or whatever. It just means that our society is not built to support people, fat people, you know, and other models identities. Exactly, exactly. Should we talk about what the audience said? Yes, please, you go ahead and we asked the audience, do you know how to deal with health issues without dieting or attempting weight loss? I was sort of surprised by this. So

Unknown Speaker 35:00

My audience said 37% said yes. And 63% said no, just pretty close to yours. Yeah, mine was 31% said yes. 69 said no. Why are you surprised? No, I felt like more people would say, I know how to deal with health issues without attempting weight loss.

Unknown Speaker 35:19

Yeah. Yeah. Follow. Like, they're they follow. They follow us. Like, I'm like, they listen to the podcast and stuff. And so that's not to say there's anything wrong with people who said no, but it just it shows how pervasive fucking messaging is. Yeah. I think maybe what it is, is I think some people think, oh, other people can be healthy and fat, but not me. Yeah. And one of the bad ones, you know, I, you know, because I'm trying to think about Yeah. And maybe they haven't listened to our podcasts. Maybe they haven't been following us for a long time. Maybe they're new people. And the ones who said yes, you know, I do know how to support my health without attempting weight loss. And the people who've been around for a little bit. Yeah. Oh, maybe I need to talk about this even more. Yeah, I know. No, actually, it was like a real. I was like, Oh, wow, like, Okay, I'm so glad we're doing this episode. And there needs to be more. Like I did, I did like a deep dive on diabetes with goddess oyster and Rebecca scritch field. And I'm like, I have that because I feel like that's, there's just so many health conditions that there's these misconceptions about so yes, like, oh, we just need to do more, you know, more education around this.

Unknown Speaker 36:32

Then we asked, What reasons do you feel you need to lose weight.

Unknown Speaker 36:37

And so my audience said,

Unknown Speaker 36:40

just feeling uncomfortable sleep apnea health, fitting into airplane seats, restaurant booths, things that associate that are associated with, you know, weight discrimination and things like that pressure off joints, to get hip surgery, feeling more confident, to be taken more serious, seriously, professionally.

Unknown Speaker 37:00

What about you? Yeah, that's there's some really good responses because, you know, like to get hits hip surgery, that's an a prime example of someone whose will probably unless they can find a doctor who will operate on them have to do something which is not conducive with health to get surgery. And the reality is, the world is kinda too fat, or too thin people.

Unknown Speaker 37:25

And that's what my first might what people are saying to be attractive. And so to be attractive. That's obviously subjective, the world tells us that fat bodies are not attractive. I personally don't think it's true. I think that people are fucking amazing. But the world in general tells you, you need to be smaller to be attractive. But anyway, so to be attractive world is kind of two smaller bodies. So I look like the girls that the boys want. The boys fancy, worried I have diabetes. And then someone sent a longer message, which is I'm really struggling to access any health care as a mid fat person. And I don't see that changing in my lifetime, the bigger societal fatphobia to I feel simultaneous Lee emboldened to change the world and take down the system and live radically and life has been incredibly hard due to fatphobia. But I won't pursue intentional weight loss for for one thing, I'm in recovery from anorexia, and my whole life is talking about this. But yeah, I guess those are the reasons I feel that sometimes feel that sometimes, but don't act on it. It's kind of like holding these two realities of, yes, if I was sinner, my life would be better in lots of ways, because,

Unknown Speaker 38:39

but I probably can't get there. And that sucks, you know? Yeah, that's really tough. Yeah. So next question was, if you think that there are health issues that will will mean you need to lose weight. What are they? So what are the health issues that you think that you need to lose weight? What did your people say? Arthritis, bad knee high blood pressure, diabetes, acid reflux, fertility, and I think

Unknown Speaker 39:07

you I'm seeing yours, they seem to echo that those health notes I feel are so important, as it relates to a lot of those.

Unknown Speaker 39:17

But that's where again, that like the IVF and the fertility, that one's so tough, because

Unknown Speaker 39:23

I mean, fertility, the fertility is different. If you're if you're trying on your own, there's ways but if you need IVs, then yeah, you may be denied that which is one of those really hard situations. Yeah, acid reflux. I've never heard that one before. Oh, I mean, like, you know, I mean, doctors will just say it's your weight. Everything you ever saw you my eye. I was literally just gonna say an ingrown hair and my eyebrows.

Unknown Speaker 39:55

Wake like

Unknown Speaker 39:58

oh my goodness. Yeah.

Unknown Speaker 40:00

Yeah, yeah. And and as well like we've been so mindset, you know, diabetes infertility, bad back and hips, arthritis to get pregnant and have a healthy pregnancy. And so a lot of these are, you know to get pregnant and have a healthy pregnancy. So for people who are on the pregnancy thing, Nicola salmon fat positive fertility is excellent and we'll break down

Unknown Speaker 40:22

what's going on there and the realities of it and so, so doctors will say like, Oh, you have if you're fat, you have a 50% increased chance of getting gestational diabetes. And then we look at the numbers it goes, it's something like a straight size person has a nought point 5% chance of getting gestational diabetes, and the fat person has a nought point seven 5% chance, you know, and so, you have these scary things said to you, and you're like, oh my god, I'm gonna, I'm gonna hurt my baby. Because I'm fat. And it's my fault. And the reality is that gestational diabetes is not your fault to begin with. But the risk around these types of things are way overblown, very often, and you can get pregnant if you're fat. And actually trying to lose weight to get pregnant is putting your body in a state that makes it harder to get pregnant. Yeah, Nicholas salmon talks a lot about that stuff. Yeah, and so taught questioning these things like oh, arthritis, you know, arthritis, and someone saying, Oh, I'm could get arthritis. And I'm sure they said I'm 40 my sister had arthritis from the age of like, 20. It's a you know, she heredity it was her, she got it from my mom. So you know, and she straight size and do strange sights, people also have bad back and hips. Is it true that being fat is the cause of these things? You know, no, our joints are massively supportive. And all the times overusing them by running and doing things like that doing over exercising, or having injuries

Unknown Speaker 42:11

can cause complications. But again, go to the Hayes health sheets for more information, and how to treat this stuff. From a doctor. I want to give a shout out to Nicola salmons book fat and fertile.

Unknown Speaker 42:28

It's so good. Even if you are not fat. I think it's like an amazing book on pregnancy and like trying to become pregnant.

Unknown Speaker 42:37

And if you are obviously it's, it's even better because that's who it's geared towards. But it blows up so much stuff. And she was also on my podcast, too. So there's that interview there. I can't remember the episode number. But if you Google it, then she'll come up. So

Unknown Speaker 42:51

I'm always I'm always dropping her name because her work is so good. And she's such a nice person. She is she and she has this many British person like me. So you know.

Unknown Speaker 43:04

Yeah, but I think I think the other thing too, I wanted to mention the high blood pressure is interesting, too, because you and you've spoken to this or you shared this I know is that like if the cuff isn't the right size, because if your arm is so this happened to my husband recently because he's bigger.

Unknown Speaker 43:20

And like, for some r

EP120 Transcript

Welcome to the Fierce Fatty Podcast. I'm your host, Victoria Welsby and this is episode 120. Today, we're talking about “What about if you NEED to lose weight?”.

I'm Victoria Welsby TEDx speaker, Best Selling Author, and fat activist. I have transformed my life from hating my body with desperately low self esteem to being a courageous and confident fierce fatty who loves every inch of this jelly. Society teaches us living in a fat body is bad. But what if we spent less time, money, and energy on the pursuit of thinness and instead focused on the things that actually matter? Like if pineapple on pizza should be outlawed? Or if the mullet was the greatest haircut of the 20th century? So how do you stop negative beliefs about your fat body controlling your life? It's the Fierce Fatty Podcast Let's begin.

It's our last show together. Oh, my globe. I know for now, I guess like we didn't really talk about it when we went out for dinner the other week.

Went out for your birthday. Happy birthday. Thank you. Oh, now you turn 43 Haven't been haven't been dead yet? No, I know.

You got into 40. And just like don't even know like, you literally have to like do the math in your head because you can't remember.

I'm 37. I'm still I think from the age of 35. I've always rounded up my age. And then when I did when I get to my birthday, and then I calculate how old I actually am. I'm like, a year younger than what I thought this is great. So it's a good like problem to have in my brain because I keep thinking I'm 38 Then I remember the seven and I'm like, oh page Columbo another year. You know, it's pretty good. Yeah. Yeah, that's a good way to do it.

Today, our last episode, what are we talking about? So we are talking about, we really just want to put the nail in the coffin as it relates to dieting. And so we are answering the question, what if you need to lose weight? I said it like that, because you capitalize the need. Yeah.

Well, you want to lose weight to lose weight. Yeah, and I think we both got a lot of feedback from our audiences around this. So yeah, good.

We'll just do a brief intro of the show for anyone who's listening. This is death to diets where we talk about diet culture, ridiculousness of diet, culture, stuff that's happening that's more topical, as well as stuff that you know, we've heard from you feedback from you on things that you want us to discuss, and we don't shame people for dieting, we really just talk about the cultural issue of dieting in general and how it hurts individuals and what we can do better. Yes, yes, yes, yes. And who are you anyway? Summer? Who the hell are ya?

Summer Antonin. I'm a professionally trained coach that specializes in body image confidence and self worth. And I've been doing this work for about eight years, I help people all from all over the world. And I host a podcast called Eat the rules. Yeah, are you who are you? Who am I? Who am I'm still trying to work out some I don't know. But here is a 3d print of my teeth. So you come from you said, Do you want this? And I said, Fuck yeah, I want this 3d printing of my teeth. So I can put it on my desk. I mean, come on.

Do you think Google will come and see if it will scare me, but he didn't realize that it was my teeth. You know, I kind of like for those who can't see the I'm smashing them together in a bite thing. But he just was cool. Yeah, so you know. So yeah. Anyway, that's a closeup of my 3d printing of my teeth. I teach people how to unlearn a fat phobia. So that's all people fat people, thin dieticians, tall people, short people, you know, everyone around everyone around the place. And I have a podcast face fatty which is where this has been hosted. If you know me, then that's it. And yeah, here's my non binary crown. Yeah, hobby Trans Day of visibility is trying to save his military

This is the crown that I wore on my gender celebration ceremony on New Year's Eve. And it's got the color the non binary colors, which are purple, gray, white, and yellow. But I don't really like wearing it because it makes me feel a bit too feminine. So I'm like, like it because I want people to worship me, but also don't like it because I'm like, it's a little bit too feminine. I need to I need to mask it up a bit. Maybe put on some spikes or the Damascus? Yes. Yeah, it's like Game of Thrones, like the spikes out of the chair type of thing. Yeah. Yeah. Or it could be like, I don't know, with decks or something. I'm just thinking like, what can I find in the local area with your 3d teeth on it? I feel right? Because the idea was fucking rubbish. Nice try. but no cigar. No, it's not working. person better ideas. Jesus. Yeah.

So so so so so so. So summer? We hear this all the time, right about, but I need what I've know if you do, I do, presume you do. With lots of use, but I need to lose weight. So I need to go on a diet, because dot dot dot dot dot. And so you're going to take the first big one, and I'll take the other one. And so what is the first reason that people say but I need to lose weight? for health, for health being I think one of the bigger bigger ones. So obviously, you know, most people believe that.

In order to be healthy, you have to be in a in a smaller sized bought like in a straight sized body or in a lower body weight than you're currently at.

We know that that is not true. We know that a lot of health conditions are more. It's more about like there's some correlation there not necessarily causation.

I mean, actually, I was just curious, like when someone comes to you and says that, how do you answer that mutually? Yeah, so what I would say is okay,

first off, I'm not a doctor, I'm not giving out. Yeah, health, blah, blah, blah, whatever. It's called diagnosis, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, I'm not blah, blah, blah, and blah, blah, blah. But I would ask the questions of like, you know, is normally the big kind of things that we associate with fatness? And so it's normally things like, type two diabetes, it's normally things like sore knees, it's, you know, like, so again, Sleep Apnea is Yeah, so it's normally the things that we associate, you know, the things that are going to kill all the fatties, and so I will present with them with information. And so my favorite resource do you know about this resource? Is the Hayes health sheets.com. Do you know about that one? Yeah. My loved ones that Reagan Chastain came up with. Yeah. And so I talked about it, like pretty much every every podcast episode. Basically, everything I ever talked about is just listening. And so all of them are all on there. So heart disease, high blood pressure, high cholesterol, joint pain, joint replacement, non alcoholic fatty liver disease. She had sleep apnea, PCOS, type two diabetes and osteo. Arthritis. And we look at them every single one, what causes this? And none of them are because you are too fat, because you need to lose weight. And the the biggest ones type two diabetes, non alcoholic fatty liver, heart, Hi, Claire straw, things like that. Most of it is genetic. And yes, fat people are at a higher risk. We don't know why. But what we do know is that fat people have worse health outcomes, because one, because of the stigma that we face, the the raging fatphobia that we live in to because of dieting. Dieting is really not great for our health, and three because of the subpar health care that we get. And so, you know, are those things, any of those things, the fault of fat people? No.

So the big thing is, it's not your fault. And let's actually look into what we can do to support health using this information created by Raven Chastain, Tiana Dodson, and the last person it's skipping.

It's gone out on my head, but it's a medical doctor. He's come up with these recommendations. Yeah. So that's what I would say. So what would you say? Yeah, I always like to ask people, What does health mean to them? I always like to understand, you know, what, what, you know, what's your kind of personal definition of health? Because I think that that's, that, really, it can be different. And I think that sometimes when we ask ourselves that question, we might start to identify things that actually don't have anything to do with weight, like we might think we might say, you know, it's, it's to have energy, or it's to, you know, be able to keep up with my kids, or it's to be able to, you know, sleep well, or, you know, like, just different components of, of health. And when we actually can look at those things, or we can create a personal definition. And I failed to mention, like mental health, I think a lot of people when they don't even think of that. But if you say, Well, what about mental health? And they might think, oh, yeah, like, you know, stress reduction, or some of these other things, we start to see that none of those things really have to do with the size of your body, that, you know, we can work towards better energy or stress reduction, or better sleep or better mobility, via things that don't require dieting or or weight loss, because we know that the outcome of dieting is actually going to be more harmful to your health overall, we know that dieting is a stressor, and we know that weight cycling is not not good for for your health overall. And so I think if we can create our own personal definition of what health is and look at what we want more of for ourselves, that that's really important. And I also think that just some education around the fact that we don't have so much control over our health as we've been led to believe, I think that diet culture, wellness culture, has us believe that like, we can control everything about our health, like if we only find the right supplements, the right nutrients, if we only eat more of the certain foods, that we can, you know, that we can control our health outcomes. And like, that's such, that's such bullshit, like, we we can't, it's so much it, like you said, so much of it is, is genetic. And I think that a much smaller percentage is really related to things like food and movement, I would say stress is probably a bigger component in that one that we tend to neglect because we just want to like, we just feel that like, well, I need to just add more kale to my life or something like that. And that's not actually going to do anything that you would have everlasting life. Superfood, right. That's what that means is.

Yeah, super cute. Oh, I thought I was gonna live forever, because I had a cow sandwich one time. /Yeah, really good point this summer is something that I talk about a lot is the determinants of health. And I'm actually reshare the graphic on my Instagrams of what I used to think what I eat and how I move is pretty much 90% of what made up my health status. The reality is my health status is made up of many different things. Things like the fact that I have white skin, that I am university educated that I live in Canada, that I have access to go into therapy, that I go to visit a doctor who doesn't shame me constantly because of my weight. Only sometimes that I'm not exposed to guns that I have safer sex that I wear so long, huh? You don't smoke either, which is, yeah, and so and so it's actually really, really, really complicated. And there is like health, like, what does that mean? You know, what, what is it? You know, it's such this amorphous concept of, we can never arrive at being healthy. It's not a place not a destination, we can get to where we like, right? That's it, I'm done for life, I've ticked the health box, and I can just live forever. It's just it's constantly changing. There's so many different parts of what is healthy, and most of it we can't control and just a kind of quick, you know, quick and dirty overview of the determinants of health, massive study done, individual behavior, it makes up 36% of health, determinants of health on the individual over level, and individual behavior isn't just food and movement. It's psychological. It's mood disorders. It's a risk related behavior, like driving a car and the risks associated with getting into accidents, it's your sleep patterns, and physical activity and diet. And so physical activity and diet are just two points within 36%. And I think that's something like, I don't know, 6% or something. So and So, really what society tells us physical health is is like 99%. How much kale do you eat? In reality? You know, and even in that diet, and diet and moving, that doesn't necessarily mean that you just eat kale, and work out 75 hours a day, is actually way more complicated than that, and more nuanced, and is different for everyone. Yeah, yeah. It's so individual. And like, I'm just, you know, privileged, like you said, plays such a huge role with, with all of this stuff. And I think that, like, we also need to be asking ourselves, you know, if we want to make changes in the name of health, like if we want to, you know, focus on whether that's blood sugar management, or, you know, better stress reduction, or sleep or whatever, to always look at what you can add versus what you need to take away.

Because I think that we've, we've learned that like, oh, we must take a restrictive approach, we must look at what I should eliminate from my life or my diet. And I'm a big fan of looking at like, well, what, what can we add more of it and making changes that are really, really small, that feel ridiculously doable? Because I think that there's also this mentality of like, well, I'm going to make all these sweeping changes, and I'm going to starting Monday, I'm gonna, you know, do, I'm going to go to the gym, and I'm going to eat this. And, you know, we know that we know that ends up, end up kind of in like this kind of the same sort of restrict binge cycle. So really looking at two things. One is like, what can you add and what feels ridiculously doable for you? And, you know, how are you going to feel if your body doesn't change? Like, what how are you going to sort of assess whether something is working for you? Like, what can what intentions can you set for yourself? Whether that's, well, no, it's working for me if I just you know, if my digestion is better, or if I'm sleeping better, or if I just feel better overall, and bring it back to, you know, listening to our bodies to kind of see what, what feels best. For us knowing that like, that doesn't mean you're less of an individual, if there's something wrong with you, if you have a health condition, or if you have if you have diabetes, like it's not your fault. So much of that is is like you said just outside of our control? Mm hmm. Yeah, and the kind of the health ism and ableism that's in there as well. Exactly. Like you say, someone who is not healthy or not able bodied, is exactly equally as worthy and important as someone who is quote unquote, healthy whenever healthy. Yeah. And if you choose to engage in like health behaviors, that doesn't make you a better person, like then someone else who if you have that choice as well, like I think that that's another thing that we have to divest from is this idea that like I'm a better person because I do these things you're not on and I some I definitely felt like I was a better person when I was like running 10 k's and stuff and posting about it on social media being like I did in the rain, what's your use?

As a better person. Did you do that? Did you realize oh, my God, this memory popped up of me and my then boyfriend running in the fucking snow and ice. And I said, we are so dedicated to health that we do it even when and I was and now I'm like, what?

Snow and Ice worm because it's dangerous. And two, why are you being such a self righteous decayed by posting it on Facebook? And you know, people I'm so so bad. I need to, I need to find it again. So that I can share it and be like, Look, what a balance. I mean, I I definitely have some shit like that to it. I think like you it might have made you feel like a better version. But that was because you were so insecure. Like you don't I mean, like you didn't actually, like wholeheartedly feel like a better person. It was like that hit of validation that you're getting made you feel like about her first. Yeah, exactly.

Yeah, you're right, because I was actually just being like, Oh, look, I'm such a good fatty because I'm going out for a run.

You tell me that I'm okay. You know, I understand Paul. You know, we need you know, I understand I get them that there were there were sausage and they were addicted. You know both of those things at the same time. Yeah.

Okay, so then anything else you want to say on that or should we move over to the other reason? Let's go on to the other thing, which is

The other big thing is mobility, which is the other thing is people say, I am so unfit. Now now that I've put on weight a lot of people since the global Panini that we are in, they put on weight. And now they can't do the things that they used to be able to do before the Panini, or perhaps when they were younger. Or they say, you know, now I go upstairs, and I'm out of breath. And it's because I've put on a little bit of weight. So what do you think might be going on there? Summer? Yeah, I mean, like, here's the thing.

Unknown Speaker 20:40

There's a couple things one, fat phobia, like just the this sort of belief that like, well, it must be because of my body size, because that's what we've learned.

Unknown Speaker 20:51

As well, like, sometimes when our bodies change, there's an adaptation period that happens that it takes a while for your body to like, you know, feel the same way that it did before.

Unknown Speaker 21:06

And so sometimes, you know, like, for example, if your belly sticks out further than it did before, then doing particular things like whether it's tying your shoes or doing a particular pose in yoga, like that is going to get in the way, and it is, is going to feel different. And I think that that doesn't mean that there's something wrong with you, or that you're, you know, like that. You need to make a change to your body. I think it's just like, how can we work with the body that we have in this moment? And how can we take the focus off of weight being the problem and focus on like, what we really want more of if, for example, we want to be able to, you know, pick up more things or be more mobile? Mm hmm, yeah, I always find it, I find it so interesting that it's kind of like A plus B equals C, you know, one plus one equals 10. Because we've got a bigger body, then, of course, it's because we have a bigger body that we can no longer do the things that we used to do. And a lot of times I say, I say get my detective glasses out my molecule or whatever it is, you know, the thing that was it called the magnifying glass. And so okay, what's going on your life and like, when the last two years we've been in a global pandemic, I've given birth to a baby, I've had postpartum depression. I have suffered suffered an accident when I fell down the stairs and hurt my back, I stopped being able to go to my weekly Pilates class. I haven't gone out and done any type of movement recently.

Unknown Speaker 22:34

Yes. And it's like,

Unknown Speaker 22:39

I'm good. Any of those things together mean that you don't have the same abilities that you did?

Unknown Speaker 22:47

You made? And so if you do want to get back to whatever, you know, physical ability or mobility that you had, what can you do exactly what you said some? Or what can you do to support yourself towards those goals? Because if we try and lose weight, it's, it's not gonna, you know, we just know it's probably not going to happen.

Unknown Speaker 23:09

And so yeah, and the big thing as well is what you touched on of people saying, I feel uncomfortable in my body. And I like to think about it. When I was a kid, my mom said to me, do you want to get a hair cut, we have this this hairdresser that would come around our house, like super cheap. And she says, You're gonna Can you can get hair cut called the bomb. And I was like the bomb I wanted. She was saying a bob, but I missed.

Unknown Speaker 23:35

And I was like, Oh, the fucking bomb. Yes, please. And so I had long, thick hair, the hairdresser cut it short, didn't do any layering, because it was just like a quick and dirty thing. And the next morning, I remember waking up and seeing myself in the mirror, with this triangle of hair on my head, and being like.

Unknown Speaker 23:56

And it was really alarming. And when I shaved my head, going from long hair to having a shaved head, it's just weird and different. And so it's more noticeable. And that's hair. Having a bigger body is a lot. There's a lot, you know, there's fatphobia behind that. And so, of course, it's distressing. And of course, you feel physically uncomfortable, especially if you're wearing the same size clothes, especially if you're noticing changes in your body. And those changes in your mind mean that you're a bad person or you're or you're unhealthy, or whatever it is. And so you will get used to those new sensations of having a different body, you know, the same ways you get used to a shit haircut like I got when I was a kid. Yeah, I always use the example.

Unknown Speaker 24:42

I always use the example of like a new pair of shoes. It's like, you got to kind of break it in, right? Like it's like the body that if it's different, it it it's going to take a little while for your, your your mind to sort of catch up and and normalize it and I think that one of the things that often

Unknown Speaker 25:00

We do is like we completely,

Unknown Speaker 25:03

like, try to not look at it, we try to, like, avoid it, like we're just walking around with our heads cut off. And I think that that actually exasperates the issue, like, even just, you know, some physical touch, like put your hand on your belly or look down at your legs, like, take a minute to take them in, and whatever feelings come up are valid. But making your body less familiar, or I should say making your body more familiar is going to be beneficial to to that process as well. Because I think that we are, if we sort of just are like avoiding mirrors or avoiding pictures, we never see ourselves in our bodies of change. And then we're going to do something we haven't done, then it's going to bring up a lot of sort of feelings and and beliefs that we have. And so trying to work through that as well to become a little bit more embodied, I think is beneficial in that process. Mm hmm. Absolutely. And the other thing that I want to talk about in regards to mobility is

Unknown Speaker 26:03

wanting to unpack the ideas around health ism and ableism on this topic, too. And the idea that as we age, and because of life, because we you know, we don't know what's going to happen in life, you will lose my ability, as you get older, you're not going to have the ability to do the things that you did when you were 20. And you never know what's going to happen, you might lose your mobility for a reason. And so if you're tying your self esteem and your worth so closely to how mobile you are, and, and your health status, then you know I've got to break it to yet you're going to die one day, you know, you're going to get hopefully you're going to get old if we have the pleasure of of being able to age, and so things will change. And so if we can untangle our self esteem and our worth, from what our body does, I think that's really crucial. Because if we can't, then we're just going to be miserable for the rest of our lives. Yeah, yeah, absolutely. Totally. Yeah, it's kind of the same thing with like, your appearance, like I we're all aging out of this out of beauty standards. You know,

Unknown Speaker 27:15

if you're if you're if the way that you view yourself as a whole is hinged on that, then you're gonna it's gonna really hurt as you continue to see wrinkles and things hanging towards the floor. Yep, yep, yep, yep, yep. Unless, unless you're like me and you have saggy tits from the moment that you have tits, then, you know, you know, I had to deal with that since I was like 12 or whatever. Anyway, so I don't have to I don't I don't have tickets. So I can't really

Unknown Speaker 27:48

I don't like the zoo because like my

Unknown Speaker 27:56

my little prunes my little prunes. Oh.

Unknown Speaker 28:01

So

Unknown Speaker 28:07

now I want to talk about the reason that you might actually need to lose weight for health reasons, because, and people might say WHAT THE FUCK Hang on, you were both just talking about how you don't need to lose weight for health reason. But there could be a reason that you need to for health reasons. And that is if you are being denied life saving surgery until you meet an arbitrary BMI number. So, some people will say, like for gender confirmation surgery, we are not going to offer you gender confirmation surgery, unless you have your stomach amputated first, unless you lose weight first. And so you may choose because, you know, it's a life or death situation, you may choose to undergo surgery or to participate in a diet knowing that it's harmful to you knowing it's you know, not going to be resulting in long term weight loss in order to get life saving surgery or access to care or so many different things that fat people cannot get access to because of these ridiculous BMI standards.

Unknown Speaker 29:27

Yeah, and fertility I think is another one although, you know, it's not necessarily like life or death, but for a lot of people that's like, Yeah, they really that's what they want, like that's their life is is to be able to you know, have a family and, and there's a lot of, you know, fertility clinics or IVF that there's, there's a BMI limit and low is low, low low that BMI limit is basically you have to be straight size. Like it's fucking that really is so low. It's fucking gets on life.

Unknown Speaker 30:00

laps. And I am I made this whole post on Instagram medical fatphobia how public health promotes the eugenics of fat people and it goes into every single thing. Not every single thing because it would be like 50 billion things along, but a lots of different things that we don't even realize that how fat people are denied things. One that is very distressing to think about is

Unknown Speaker 30:30

transplants. So if you're on a transplant list, if you are fat, you are seen as your classic as higher risk, and so you're less likely to get a transplant. And so imagine if you're, you're so sick, that you need an organ transplant, and then having to either undergo stomach amputation or squeezing surgery or a diet in order to get life saved it life saving transplant is just so violent.

Unknown Speaker 30:59

It just makes me it makes me and you know, and the list goes on and on and on of different ways that, you know, things are denied to fat people. And so you may as a person make that decision to say, You know what, I know this is bullshit, but I'm going to die if I don't adhere to their,

Unknown Speaker 31:20

their guidelines. And so I'm gonna, I'm just gonna do it. Because this thing is so important for me. And the other thing to think about is

Unknown Speaker 31:31

when people are living with multiple marginalized identities, then perhaps dieting is the only way to be safe, or is a great way for them to be safe if they live in a fat body. Because society is kinder to fat people who are trying not to be fat versus fat people who are

Unknown Speaker 31:51

proudly fat. And so sometimes it is easier just to engage in dieting to prove your humanity to society. And so that's really important to recognize as well. Yeah. And I think he was sort of see that with celebrities, because they're under so much scrutiny and constant criticism. And even though they have wealth privilege,

Unknown Speaker 32:15

you still see how they will sometimes go down that route road. And it's all like, I think that it's it's also connected to that feeling of like, well, I want this, like the safety of not having that constant like barrage of criticism. Yeah, I can't even imagine like, I've done episodes on there. So you know what happens when your favorite fat celebrity loses weight, and I just think, fucking hell, like, if I was a celebrity, I wonder if I might be succumb to the pressure of the absolute scrutiny of my body, every single centimeter of it being pulled apart. My not being able to get roles being being casters, like the funny fat word, or this type of things. You know, I wonder if I would succumb to that. And this is coming from someone who is a fat activist. And so

Unknown Speaker 33:09

we're also putting these these people on a pedestal as if to say, they should have their shit together. They're representing the fat community or whatever. And it's kind of like,

Unknown Speaker 33:20

Yeah, but there are a few men, you know, when did they say, We don't know their history with dieting, and if they, they had a history of disordered eating, and all that type of stuff, and they're in fucking Hollywood, like, every single one of their Hollywood friend is probably like, oh my god, I'm just gonna rub some dust into my eyeballs. And I'm gonna lose like, you know, and so it's probably exhausting. Yeah, yeah. Yeah, I imagine. Yeah, no, I think you gotta like, have empathy for people. Because, yeah, it's just the culture we live in is, is violent, as you said. So yeah, yeah. So yeah, especially those who are, who are like super fat people, or, you know, fat people who are also people of color, or also are disabled or also are trans, you know, etc, etc. Yeah. Yeah. And I think that's the crux of, of death, the diets. I think we we don't want to say exactly like we say at the beginning of every episode, that you're, you're a fucking idiot, if you die if you're dieting, we're saying diets don't support us in the way that we've been told that they do. And in fact, they're really harmful. But we understand if people want to engage in diet culture for many different reasons. And it doesn't mean that you're a bad person or you're not smart or, or whatever. It just means that our society is not built to support people, fat people, you know, and other models identities. Exactly, exactly. Should we talk about what the audience said? Yes, please, you go ahead and we asked the audience, do you know how to deal with health issues without dieting or attempting weight loss? I was sort of surprised by this. So

Unknown Speaker 35:00

My audience said 37% said yes. And 63% said no, just pretty close to yours. Yeah, mine was 31% said yes. 69 said no. Why are you surprised? No, I felt like more people would say, I know how to deal with health issues without attempting weight loss.

Unknown Speaker 35:19

Yeah. Yeah. Follow. Like, they're they follow. They follow us. Like, I'm like, they listen to the podcast and stuff. And so that's not to say there's anything wrong with people who said no, but it just it shows how pervasive fucking messaging is. Yeah. I think maybe what it is, is I think some people think, oh, other people can be healthy and fat, but not me. Yeah. And one of the bad ones, you know, I, you know, because I'm trying to think about Yeah. And maybe they haven't listened to our podcasts. Maybe they haven't been following us for a long time. Maybe they're new people. And the ones who said yes, you know, I do know how to support my health without attempting weight loss. And the people who've been around for a little bit. Yeah. Oh, maybe I need to talk about this even more. Yeah, I know. No, actually, it was like a real. I was like, Oh, wow, like, Okay, I'm so glad we're doing this episode. And there needs to be more. Like I did, I did like a deep dive on diabetes with goddess oyster and Rebecca scritch field. And I'm like, I have that because I feel like that's, there's just so many health conditions that there's these misconceptions about so yes, like, oh, we just need to do more, you know, more education around this.

Unknown Speaker 36:32

Then we asked, What reasons do you feel you need to lose weight.

Unknown Speaker 36:37

And so my audience said,

Unknown Speaker 36:40

just feeling uncomfortable sleep apnea health, fitting into airplane seats, restaurant booths, things that associate that are associated with, you know, weight discrimination and things like that pressure off joints, to get hip surgery, feeling more confident, to be taken more serious, seriously, professionally.

Unknown Speaker 37:00

What about you? Yeah, that's there's some really good responses because, you know, like to get hits hip surgery, that's an a prime example of someone whose will probably unless they can find a doctor who will operate on them have to do something which is not conducive with health to get surgery. And the reality is, the world is kinda too fat, or too thin people.

Unknown Speaker 37:25

And that's what my first might what people are saying to be attractive. And so to be attractive. That's obviously subjective, the world tells us that fat bodies are not attractive. I personally don't think it's true. I think that people are fucking amazing. But the world in general tells you, you need to be smaller to be attractive. But anyway, so to be attractive world is kind of two smaller bodies. So I look like the girls that the boys want. The boys fancy, worried I have diabetes. And then someone sent a longer message, which is I'm really struggling to access any health care as a mid fat person. And I don't see that changing in my lifetime, the bigger societal fatphobia to I feel simultaneous Lee emboldened to change the world and take down the system and live radically and life has been incredibly hard due to fatphobia. But I won't pursue intentional weight loss for for one thing, I'm in recovery from anorexia, and my whole life is talking about this. But yeah, I guess those are the reasons I feel that sometimes feel that sometimes, but don't act on it. It's kind of like holding these two realities of, yes, if I was sinner, my life would be better in lots of ways, because,

Unknown Speaker 38:39

but I probably can't get there. And that sucks, you know? Yeah, that's really tough. Yeah. So next question was, if you think that there are health issues that will will mean you need to lose weight. What are they? So what are the health issues that you think that you need to lose weight? What did your people say? Arthritis, bad knee high blood pressure, diabetes, acid reflux, fertility, and I think

Unknown Speaker 39:07

you I'm seeing yours, they seem to echo that those health notes I feel are so important, as it relates to a lot of those.

Unknown Speaker 39:17

But that's where again, that like the IVF and the fertility, that one's so tough, because

Unknown Speaker 39:23

I mean, fertility, the fertility is different. If you're if you're trying on your own, there's ways but if you need IVs, then yeah, you may be denied that which is one of those really hard situations. Yeah, acid reflux. I've never heard that one before. Oh, I mean, like, you know, I mean, doctors will just say it's your weight. Everything you ever saw you my eye. I was literally just gonna say an ingrown hair and my eyebrows.

Unknown Speaker 39:55

Wake like

Unknown Speaker 39:58

oh my goodness. Yeah.

Unknown Speaker 40:00

Yeah, yeah. And and as well like we've been so mindset, you know, diabetes infertility, bad back and hips, arthritis to get pregnant and have a healthy pregnancy. And so a lot of these are, you know to get pregnant and have a healthy pregnancy. So for people who are on the pregnancy thing, Nicola salmon fat positive fertility is excellent and we'll break down

Unknown Speaker 40:22

what's going on there and the realities of it and so, so doctors will say like, Oh, you have if you're fat, you have a 50% increased chance of getting gestational diabetes. And then we look at the numbers it goes, it's something like a straight size person has a nought point 5% chance of getting gestational diabetes, and the fat person has a nought point seven 5% chance, you know, and so, you have these scary things said to you, and you're like, oh my god, I'm gonna, I'm gonna hurt my baby. Because I'm fat. And it's my fault. And the reality is that gestational diabetes is not your fault to begin with. But the risk around these types of things are way overblown, very often, and you can get pregnant if you're fat. And actually trying to lose weight to get pregnant is putting your body in a state that makes it harder to get pregnant. Yeah, Nicholas salmon talks a lot about that stuff. Yeah, and so taught questioning these things like oh, arthritis, you know, arthritis, and someone saying, Oh, I'm could get arthritis. And I'm sure they said I'm 40 my sister had arthritis from the age of like, 20. It's a you know, she heredity it was her, she got it from my mom. So you know, and she straight size and do strange sights, people also have bad back and hips. Is it true that being fat is the cause of these things? You know, no, our joints are massively supportive. And all the times overusing them by running and doing things like that doing over exercising, or having injuries

Unknown Speaker 42:11

can cause complications. But again, go to the Hayes health sheets for more information, and how to treat this stuff. From a doctor. I want to give a shout out to Nicola salmons book fat and fertile.

Unknown Speaker 42:28

It's so good. Even if you are not fat. I think it's like an amazing book on pregnancy and like trying to become pregnant.

Unknown Speaker 42:37

And if you are obviously it's, it's even better because that's who it's geared towards. But it blows up so much stuff. And she was also on my podcast, too. So there's that interview there. I can't remember the episode number. But if you Google it, then she'll come up. So

Unknown Speaker 42:51

I'm always I'm always dropping her name because her work is so good. And she's such a nice person. She is she and she has this many British person like me. So you know.

Unknown Speaker 43:04

Yeah, but I think I think the other thing too, I wanted to mention the high blood pressure is interesting, too, because you and you've spoken to this or you shared this I know is that like if the cuff isn't the right size, because if your arm is so this happened to my husband recently because he's bigger.

Unknown Speaker 43:20

And like, for some reason is the dental assistant takes his blood pressure and it came back high. And I was like, I was like to think maybe they use the wrong cuff size because like he's he's big and his arms massive. And so

Unknown Speaker 43:35

that can also like give false reading, right? If you if you have a too small cough, it will give up false high reading. Yeah. So how often does a doctor or a dentist have any more than one size? cuff? Yeah. Oh, this was a dental assistant to like, no offense, your dental system. I was like, why do they take your blood pressure the oddest thing I've ever heard?

Unknown Speaker 44:00

You're gonna go run off and if you're fabulous last summer. Yeah, I gotta go pick myself up. But these have been so fun. I've loved doing these. I feel like we've gotten some really good feedback from them. So who knows what will happen in the future? Yeah, who knows? Whether we'll just keep having conversations at dinner or whether we choose to.

Unknown Speaker 44:21

Yeah, right. Yeah, that's it. All right. Wow. Thanks, everyone, for hanging out with us. And I guess we'll see ya on the Instagrams. Which is where you can find us where can people find you summer? Yeah, they can find me.

Unknown Speaker 44:37

At the body image coach calm my podcast is called Eat the rules. And I'm summer intern in on all the social platforms. What about you? I am first fatty everywhere. Easy peasy lemon and lime. So come follow me. Let's have some fun.

Unknown Speaker 44:56

Okay, well, we're saying goodbye. Thanks, everyone.

Unknown Speaker 45:00

See you later in a while Cocteau. bye

Unknown Speaker 45:08

Thanks for listening to the episode and if you feel ready to get serious about this work and want to know when the doors open to phase fatty Academy which is my signature program, where I teach all about how to overcome your fat phobic beliefs and learn to love your fat body, then go to phase fatty.com forward slash waitlist again that is phase fatty.com. Forward slash waitlist to get your name on the waitlist. For when first party Academy my signature program opens

EP119 Transcript

Welcome to the Fierce Fatty Podcast. I'm your host, Victoria Welsby, and this is episode 119. Today, we're talking about “Cancel Culture” and Thinness in Fat Spaces.

I'm Victoria Welsby, TEDx speaker, best-selling author, and fat activist. I have transformed my life from hating my body with desperately low self-esteem to being a courageous and confident fierce fatty who loves every inch of this jelly. Society teaches us living in a fat body is bad. But what if we spent less time, money, and energy on the pursuit of thinness and instead focused on the things that actually matter? Like if pineapple on pizza should be outlawed? Or if the mullet was the greatest haircut of the 20th century? So how do you stop negative beliefs about your fat body controlling your life? It's the Fierce Fatty Podcast. Let's begin.

Hey, Fatties So welcome to the podcast today. Tell you what I do for big ol fucking brain nap after this during the research for today, or even, you know, just delving in and collating everything to talk about what I want to talk about today. Big old brain nap I need. So I'm going to talk about briefly the situation with Lindo Bacon. I don't know I just said briefly that it's not going to be brief at all.

But why I said briefly, is because I'm going to talk about Linda Bacon. And what's happened with Mikey Mercedes. And the reason why I said briefly is that you should go to Mikey Mercedes page Patreon. And read her words about this. And so, you know, I'm not talking about exact exactly everything that's, you know, blow by blow that has happened because my key has done an incredible job of talking about this. And yeah, so you know, it's not my place to talk about this in regards to the Mikey and Lindow situation, but I wanted to talk about fineness and canceled culture because I see a lot of people being confused maybe about what's happening and how to respond and what to do and is then they're being canceled and, and what is canceling? And is canceled culture real or is it not real and, and there's, there's lots of different things going by, and sometimes it's kind of hard to know, right?

What's the best thing to do? So I want to give the information in regards to council culture in quotation marks and thinness in fat spaces as how I see it. And the opinions that I've formed over the last year, year or so. So for those who don't know even anything about what I'm talking about week ago, now Mikey Mercedes, and you've, you've heard me speak about Mikey on the podcast, probably maybe like 10 times now and I've said that I'm subscribed to Mikey's Patreon because, like, you talked about great stuff anyway, so I got an email a week ago, and it's a Patreon post that Mikey wrote, and anyone can read it. I'm going to link absolutely absolutely everything in the show notes today. It's podcast.

First party.com forward slash 119 for Episode 19 facebook.com, forward slash 119. Or if you forget the number it's just Ford slash podcast facebook.com forward slash podcast.

So yeah, Mikey released a post on her Patreon that everyone can read and in it it details an interaction with Linda Bacon lindo is non binary and uses they them pronouns just as an FYI. So Linda wrote a book called Health every size.

And, by the way, lindo didn't create Health, every size movement, they just wrote a book called Health every size.

So Linda wants to rewrite the book and approached Mikey to be a co author. So this is a very basic overview of what's in what's inside this post that Mike, you wrote. Very, very basic overview, okay, there's lots in there, go and read it yourself if you haven't already. And so Mikey wanted to change the problematic things in the book in Hayes in health every size. I don't know if you've read how that every size, I read it. Years ago, when I first came into this work, and at the time, I remember there was a chapter that I needed to skip over, because there was a chapter where I was like, eat this and don't eat that. And I was like, Oh, I don't like that, even at the time. And so that's one big thing that needs to change. But also, there's other aspects like, focusing so, so much on health and the good fatty thing, and a real lack of fat people talking about this stuff. You know, there's no fat voices in the book, who's a thin, white person.

And yeah, so there's and, and the idea on body love and stuff like that. And so anyway, Mikey was like, Yeah, we should change the problematic things and Lindos like, yeah, gray. Okay. Yeah, but no, and so wasn't down with it and then said, you know, this club is not going to work out because my key didn't want to put her name against the book, which was full of things that could harm someone. So Mikey pointed out that Linda was being Mike Mikey pointed out being thin and white and centering themselves, in a movement created by and for fat, marginalized voices wasn't great. And maybe after, I don't know, 20 years of being the V person in a fat movement as a thin person, maybe they might consider passing the torch to people who movements made for fat people and family with other marginalized Asians. And then de was like, Yeah, LOL nap. Now, I don't want to do that. You know? No, no, thanks. Yeah. So Mikey, very patiently tried to explain saying was harmful, they did not listen. And so my key was, was, you know, you can tell Mike was being so patient and be like, Listen, you know, I don't normally, you know, when people are harming me, I don't normally go to the effort of, of helping them understand why this might be inappropriate. And I've done a really kind of basic job of explaining the interaction there go in, and you'll see so many different things I've not even mentioned. So anyway, the call ended and emails to try and get her to engage further. And in one even said, even said that, if we let marginalized people talk, then we're basically this is what she's basically said, If we let marginalized people have the stage, then we're going to be discriminate against white people.

This is a quote, I'm thinking. So this is an email that sent to Mike, after I'm thinking particularly about your belief that white people need to step back for black people to move forward. While I didn't use this language, in our call, I'm concerned, that concept is a continuation of supremacy, just with different people in power.

I mean, can you imagine? It's, I mean, it's not unbelievable, because, you know, white people are going to white, and we're going to want to uphold white supremacy, and say shit like, well, if we let other people take the sage, then they're just going to that is just a continuation of supremacy, which is what Linda was saying. That's one thing that really stuck out to me like the blatant racism sent another email and was trying to get Mikey to engage in a public debate about this. Basically, fat ally then being a fat ally versus fat per ship person. And the debate being fat person saying, hey, I can speak for myself please.

Let me and fat ally saying no, that's not a good idea, as you'll take take too much power from white people. What? That's not a debate that is not a debate. That is not a debate that anyone wants to hear. You know, and then it kind of rubs salt in the room too. When I think about this other quote, I have listened to marginalize people. And people have given me given me the right to kind of speak on some of these issues, like a lot of fat people.

Like, it's a lot of fat people that really adore my work and appreciate it.

That really rubs me the wrong way. Because it's kind of like fat people like me, so I can talk on their behalf. Lynne and Mikey was pointing out, we're fat people are held hostage, and we can't speak.

Because what thin people are in this space, which is meant to be for fat people. And then if they decide they want to share the stage, literally, metaphorically, then the you know, we have to be so gracious and, and thank you. And really, they don't want to share this stage. And that's really sad, because if we do then apparently black people are going to take over and that's not good. So yeah, I'm not gonna talk about that whole, that whole piece. Please go and read it. If you haven't, there's so much more that I'm not even, you know, I'm totally missing. So much more analysis there. So, I mean, it just just speaks for itself really go and read it.

So that came out. Then shortly after Lindley Ashley Ashley ASHLine. Ashley, I'm going to ask her how you say her last name.

It Lindley from body liberation photos.com. Or you can find her own links are in the show notes. You find her on Instagram anyway, wrote a piece sharing how she too had had a shit experience. So this is what Lindley says, quote, last week I connected with Mikey and she told me an abbreviated version of her experience. I basically spent the whole time clutching my face in horror I a white woman had gotten less paternalism and condensation. condescension. Mikey, a black woman got the whole shebang. my conversation with Mikey is an example of how whisper networks in communities and the purposes they serve. When we have missing stairs, I'll tell you about that in a second, especially missing stairs, you hold immense power and respect. Back channels are often the only way we can protect ourselves. So missing stairs, the links to a Wikipedia page just to describe what we explain what missing stairs is. This is what Wikipedia says. The Missing stair is a metaphor for a person within a social group, who many people know is untrustworthy, or otherwise has to be managed, but who the group chooses to work around by trying to quietly warn others of their behavior rather than deal with them and their behavior openly. The Missing stare in the metaphor refers to a dangerous structural faults such as a missing step in a staircase, a fault that people may become used to and quietly accepting of is not openly signposted or fixed. And that newcomers to a social group are warned about discreetly.

So within these experiences is what then Lisa's published a lengthy essay titled critiquing social justice dogma, to astor's private listserv. And so this it's so long I've only got through so because someone sent it to meet you anonymously. Because you can't read it unless at that point, someone else's. Someone has shared it now publicly. It was in like a private on as does website as D H.

And so you couldn't read it, as does stands for Association for Size, diversity and health. And so they hold the trademark for health every size. I think I mentioned that in last week's episode.

I feel like I've mentioned that before. Imagine this being a thin person and using the audience of fat people to publish your thoughts to about how and so the what, what Lindos their, their article was, was saying we should not want to hold people accountable because it's bad.

And it was filled with with racism and fatphobia and basically positioned

Fat people as these angry people who are unreasonable, who are saying, Stop being mean to us and, and thin white people as these innocent people just go in about their business and fat people come and like, cancel them and ruin their careers. That was what it was about.

And actually, the fat Dr. ASHA has written a piece on their Patreon, which is free for everyone to read, which is Linda Bacon privilege and the impact on the fat community which dissects it

and actually says they can't dissect the whole thing because it's 7000 words but you know, they've gone through as much as they can.

Unknown Speaker 15:48

Talking about this, this post made

Unknown Speaker 15:54

Yeah, and so just going skimming over ashes.

Unknown Speaker 16:01

piece is basically positioning there was a victim.

Unknown Speaker 16:08

When people start to fear accountability, you know that they're guilty of something and we'll talk about that more in a moment.

Unknown Speaker 16:16

Whom we choose to prioritize says a lot about us.

Unknown Speaker 16:21

And it paints a disturbing picture. It's minimizing the damage caused by abuse.

Unknown Speaker 16:28

Lindos warped understanding of accountability is self serving at best and sociopathic at worst.

Unknown Speaker 16:40

It lindows complete disregard for the fact experiences telling.

Unknown Speaker 16:46

And Lindos rubbish solution.

Unknown Speaker 16:52

Yeah, so. I mean,

Unknown Speaker 16:57

again, link to this in the show notes.

Unknown Speaker 17:01

There's a lot. There's a lot. There's a lot there.

Unknown Speaker 17:08

Yes. Okay. So let's get let's get back to it. Let's get back to this. All right. Okay. So, Lindley, emailed and said, Hey, I read your piece. It was certainly interesting.

Unknown Speaker 17:21

It kind of echoes the same sentiments that we hear time and time again, that fat spaces are not safe for fat people. And fat people are accused of being like, you know, the angry fat mob sort of thing. And so

Unknown Speaker 17:37

Linda respond, responds, and Lindo, this is what they said.

Unknown Speaker 17:43

This is what Lindley said he's got a hard with a lip Lin li N Dooney. Lin. Okay, so I was informed that I didn't get it because I hadn't studied enough. I didn't get it because I hadn't read their book yet. So they had a new book coming out at the time called Radical belonging, I think from the top of my head, they had a hard time, quote, offering up grace to me. So if you read Lindsay's post, you can hear another there's another thing called FUPA gate, which is where a thin white provider

Unknown Speaker 18:15

harmed

Unknown Speaker 18:18

fat people. And then there was another instance where they harmed black people. And they were asked by people in their local community to join in a accountability process, and they refuse to engage. And so Linda was talking about Maria

Unknown Speaker 18:35

and the fact that she refused to engage and was saying how it's a bad thing that people asked Maria to try to fix the harm that she had caused. Okay, continuing what Lindsey saying we're all scared to speak up because we fear rejection as opposed to the very real fears are further oppression and marginalization that fat and black people hold.

Unknown Speaker 19:00

So

Unknown Speaker 19:03

yes, so then so so that came out so Linnaeus piece came out

Unknown Speaker 19:09

again go read it there's so much more stuff in there that I'm not going to be covering.

Unknown Speaker 19:14

So then after after he holds a trademark for health every size came out as well with their experience and basically

Unknown Speaker 19:23

their experience was told them that they wanted to read they wanted to rewrite the book let they as in wanted to rewrite the book health every size, bear in mind that health every size is owned by Asda and so

Unknown Speaker 19:37

as to said hey, we think it's time that

Unknown Speaker 19:42

the person that centered in you know, in the movement should be people with the most marginalized identities should be super fat people it should be black fat people, it should be trans fat people that should be disabled fat people, not a thin white person.

Unknown Speaker 19:58

And, and so forth.

Unknown Speaker 20:00

Veronica, from Mazda

Unknown Speaker 20:03

sent this really good email, I got that email. I'd be like, Oh, okay, okay. And I'm sure I would have been like, oh, fuck, you know, this is my book, I want to write it, but I would have sat with it and being like, yeah, yeah, I'm glad my first book was meaningful for you. The rest of your email did not land well, I'm going to take a pass on responding to your questions, or engaging, kept emailing about other stuff, saying, hey, you know, give me this and whatever. And, you know, it was sent like, it felt like I've 5 billion emails, even though they said, I'm not gonna, I'm not going to engage on this topic of me taking up space in a community that I should not be taking up space it.

Unknown Speaker 20:48

So, again, go read that in the show notes.

Unknown Speaker 20:52

And since then, more and more people have come forward, because it took a poor, disabled, black person, woman, Mikey, to do that first step, where everyone else just kept quiet. For various reasons, you know, some of them absolutely legitimate because you don't want to ruin your career by the being the person who speaks up against the person who has the most power inside a movement.

Unknown Speaker 21:26

And for some, some people, especially if someone who is, is fat, and has other marginalized identities, if they're getting paid.

Unknown Speaker 21:34

They don't want to risk losing money, rightfully so.

Unknown Speaker 21:41

And so,

Unknown Speaker 21:43

Mikey did it, which is just amazing. And incredible. And so, a lot of thin white dieticians have supported Mike in Italy, and as and everyone else.

Unknown Speaker 21:57

And of course, you know, that that people as well. But really who we want to hear from is the thin white dietitians to say oh, yeah, this is fucked up. Like yeah, why is it

Unknown Speaker 22:10

movements? Like, health every size? Like intuitive eating like

Unknown Speaker 22:19

body positivity? Why is it that these movements that should be centering the most marginalized bodies, and majority Lee made more? The majority of these movements are created by fat people? Why the fuck? Is it a sea of thin white faces? Why is it that everyone who's got a book deal? Not everyone, but you know, all the big book deals have gone to thin white women.

Unknown Speaker 22:49

Why is that? What I mean? Strange, isn't it? And so

Unknown Speaker 22:58

the thin white dieticians, you know that a lot of them say, Yeah, I mean, that is a bit strange. And hey, listen, we should be we should be stepping back and, and giving space for people with more marginalized identities to come to the front. It's going to make it better for everyone.

Unknown Speaker 23:17

However,

Unknown Speaker 23:20

there have been a few people crying, council culture, council culture.

Unknown Speaker 23:28

And so

Unknown Speaker 23:30

if you're a kind person who cares about people, and also wants to advocate for people with marginalized identities, and you're not familiar with the

Unknown Speaker 23:45

the politics behind canceled culture, it can be very easy to say, Yeah, shit, yeah, maybe we shouldn't say

Unknown Speaker 24:00

Say, say things about lindo. Because it could hurt their mental health and it could make them sad. And can we not just do this in another way? You know, so.

Unknown Speaker 24:12

I know, I've certainly had in the past about Council culture being like, you know, what, I don't like people

Unknown Speaker 24:21

being dickheads you know, and is that what Kancil culture is? I don't like it when people are dickheads.

Unknown Speaker 24:30

And then I read the book

Unknown Speaker 24:33

by Jon Ronson, so you've been canceled.

Unknown Speaker 24:38

And I was like, kind of looking for

Unknown Speaker 24:43

some really good analysis on it.

Unknown Speaker 24:46

And didn't get it. I just got kind of,

Unknown Speaker 24:50

oh, here's someone who,

Unknown Speaker 24:53

who made a faux par. And was it really that big a deal should they have have lost their job because

Unknown Speaker 25:00

This faux pas and helping them kind of get their life together, you know, quotations

Unknown Speaker 25:08

afterwards. And I was like, well hang on, where's the where's the rest of it? You know, like, where's the other side of the story?

Unknown Speaker 25:16

They kind of left me kind of like nah. Anyway so I was just I'm just curious about that. I'm just curious. I'm just curious positive.

Unknown Speaker 25:25

And in my, you know, just wanting to learn more about

Unknown Speaker 25:32

the concept of Cancel Cancel culture and, and all that type of stuff anyway, so I want you to read a post to you that I made yesterday, just with some thoughts in like a basic primer, we're going to get in a little bit a little bit deeper. Okay, so my post is I start with a quote from from Mikey, the quote is to put it simply eating in matters of fat. The thinnest and widest people, often under the guise of owlish. Allyship have benefited the most socially personally and professionally.

Unknown Speaker 26:07

And then the next slide I say, so is lindo bacon being canceled?

Unknown Speaker 26:13

And I wrote some thoughts. lindo did not create health every size, they wrote a book with that title. lindo is not the only person who has slash is doing research and writing around Hays concepts. Yet they are the person who is seen as the quote, leader in a movement that should center fat, black and other marginalized voices. Linda was thin and white, yet they take up an enormous amount of space in this movement. lindo didn't just make a one time error. There are multiple accounts of folks very generously calling in Lindo, only for their rightful concerns to be dismissed, met with defensiveness and refusal to engage in discussion. This has happened over years, you may have seen some mostly thin and white people claim it is unfair that lindo is being called to repair the harm they have done, citing Kancil culture Kancil culture as a concept is used by people with the most privilege and power in society as a way to protect themselves from the consequences of their harmful behavior.

Unknown Speaker 27:29

Calling out people and asking them not to hurt those with less power is a way people who are marginalized can exercise agency and ask for accountability, normally at great risk to themselves. People who are leaders in the anti cancel culture movement say that lindo shouldn't see consequences because their behavior wasn't, quote, physical violence or abuse. And here we've got a quote from anti diet fatty who says, This isn't a disagreement between two people that makes it sound so distorted so by your own different definition. Here's why this isn't cancer culture. Oppression is abuse. So I continue oppression is violence and is abuse spaces that should be centering the most marginalized fat people are led by and filled with those with the most privilege. That's simply not okay. Why is it some people are more concerned about whether it is canceled than the pain that has been caused by them for decades? Thin White feelings are not more important than the humanity and safety of people with marginalized identities. No was not being canceled. Aster has asked to engage with them in a community accountability process has not yet appeared to be willing to engage. Okay, so that's that's my post and I'm a bum bum bum

Unknown Speaker 29:14

so basically, as the has said, Your fucked up. People have said you fucked up you fucked up with us. Let's fix it. Okay.

Unknown Speaker 29:24

We are willing to engage with you in fixing this and and hire consultants that you can pay for. And we'll get together and we'll work this out

Unknown Speaker 29:40

we'll try to see if we can work it out.

Unknown Speaker 29:43

Now,

Unknown Speaker 29:45

does that sound like

Unknown Speaker 29:49

like this awful thing?

Unknown Speaker 29:53

Hey, you fucked up. Can we try and fix it? I mean, that sounds pretty good.

Unknown Speaker 30:00

generous, considering how would you feel if someone had fucked up against you and hurt you? And, and being, you know, racist or fat phobic or whatever it is?

Unknown Speaker 30:13

Could you extend that generous offer?

Unknown Speaker 30:18

I would be inclined to be like, they can fuck off, you know. But as they're saying, let's fix this. And Mikey is saying, here's how we can fix this. And Mike has come out with his steps that I would like us to like and the community to take. And they're not outrageous things. They're really fucking basic things like, Hey, don't be racist. Hey, Toby, fat phobic.

Unknown Speaker 30:43

Hey, listen to us, you know.

Unknown Speaker 30:46

So I just want to point that out. Think about how you would react.

Unknown Speaker 30:53

Even if you didn't understand, okay? Someone who who has a marginalized identity that you don't have comes to you and says,

Unknown Speaker 31:01

Hey, I've been really hurt by something you did.

Unknown Speaker 31:06

And I'd love for us to see if we can work it out and kind of talk about it.

Unknown Speaker 31:14

Do you think that that's that's possible?

Unknown Speaker 31:18

Would you be like,

Unknown Speaker 31:20

I think there's a remarries. Did you Did any I don't want to listen. And not only that, you know, the last like, what, you know, one time thing, but this has been happening on the DL quietly. For years. I mean, I have heard shit about I've never mentioned it right? I mentioned it with those whisper networks. A friend of mine, who's in the industry said about an experience that they had when I was like, Ooh, that's pretty shit.

Unknown Speaker 31:48

And so many times where someone says, oh, well, that's not so great. And has has

Unknown Speaker 31:56

not done anything about it. I just keep wanting to go back to like, what would you do? What would you do? And of course, you know, they, they probably have normal reactions, which is you'd probably be defensive and, and be a bit sad and all that type of stuff. But you would want to work to do better, right?

Unknown Speaker 32:16

Yeah. So little wing, Linda from little winged potatoes. On the Instagrams. I mentioned, Linda before, as well is

Unknown Speaker 32:26

talks a talks about has written a post last year, actually, and I read it then called the illusion, illusion of a cancellation.

Unknown Speaker 32:38

So

Unknown Speaker 32:41

actually, Lindos, Linda,

Unknown Speaker 32:47

Linda, Jesus, there's so many li n people in it today, Linda, from little wind potatoes. Her blog is called fluffy kitten party. I know it's getting so confusing. The title of it is pay no attention to the mob behind the curtain on cancel culture. But so this is, but then this is a quote that I wanted to read. But

Unknown Speaker 33:14

the illusion of a cancellation because, quote, cancel culture offers us such a clear binary view of these situations, it's easy to zoom out and see all the cancellations is predictable, following the script similar to similar to one another. But when you look at individual cancellations in quotation marks, they're all remarkably different.

Unknown Speaker 33:39

So

Unknown Speaker 33:43

I want to talk about that a little bit more about you know, if we actually look at what's happening, and so this is the reason why people say

Unknown Speaker 33:53

if you believe in Kancil culture, then that's a problem. Or people saying, you know, Cancel Cancel culture, and people saying cancel, culture doesn't exist, can get kind of confusing, right. counterculture doesn't exist, because in the reality is, this is how people who say anti anti cancel culture, this is how they see a cancellation. A person is just going about their life, and they make a teeny tiny faux pas, or maybe they say, an off color joke that that didn't mean anything by it. But you know, they just said it. And next thing you know,

Unknown Speaker 34:34

a mob has come to their place of work and has has or is in their inbox and they lose their job and they

Unknown Speaker 34:46

their partner leaves them and they lose their kids. And they are left destitute with nothing. And then they die. And all they did was say well, all they did was say a little blue joke you know them doing

Unknown Speaker 35:00

anything so that's what that's what, how Cancel Cancel culture people view a cancellation, right? This extreme thing.

Unknown Speaker 35:10

The result is death. And

Unknown Speaker 35:15

and it's for some minor infraction, right? Like, you can't even say anything nowadays and people are going to counsel you.

Unknown Speaker 35:22

The reality is that those who hold power are doing fucked up things for years on end, they are perpetrating violence, they are being racist. They are being every type of as you can imagine, they are being pieces of shit.

Unknown Speaker 35:42

And then, eventually, after, after years of doing this stuff, someone will come up and say, hey, you know, that time that, you know, this person has got a history of being not so great. And they might lose someone follow up, they might get some unfollows on Instagram, they might get some

Unknown Speaker 36:04

people saying, hey, you need to try and fix this. And they might get some people saying awful things. People saying awful things isn't good, right?

Unknown Speaker 36:15

They might have the chance to engage in a accountability process.

Unknown Speaker 36:23

And so then they can they can apologize and move forward. And so if we look at the people who've been, quote, canceled,

Unknown Speaker 36:32

what has actually happened to them?

Unknown Speaker 36:36

Nothing much, really, in fact, a lot of people who've been, quote unquote, canceled, it's actually boosted their career. You know, it's helped them gain more followers, because now they're in the public eye.

Unknown Speaker 36:51

Have they? Have they had to stop doing what they're doing with their lives has? Who was the guy that makes the trans jokes? Kevin Hart? Yeah, I think it's Kevin Hart. Has he been? Has he been banned from being comedian? No, not only him. Netflix has even taken his show off off Netflix.

Unknown Speaker 37:13

That

Unknown Speaker 37:18

loser guy from House of Cards, Kevin Spacey, Kevin Spacey, he went away for a year or two. Now he's back making films. So just has, how has he, you know, been really canceled? Yes, he might have had a bit of a shadow ship time, because he's had to look inwards and be like, oh, yeah, Chile. I did commit lots of crimes.

Unknown Speaker 37:45

And that was fucked up. And now people don't like me. Not everyone, you know. Now.

Unknown Speaker 37:51

Some people don't like me. And that makes me feel sad. What about the people that he abused? How are they feeling? Are they able to continue to act? Oh, actually, they didn't have an acting career. Most of them because they were marginalized people. They were in they there was a power imbalance. So they're, you know, still trying to get on with their life. And there's this man who was, you know, presumably a multimillionaire, just continuing with his life.

Unknown Speaker 38:25

Yeah, okay. So I'll read this post from Elliott Gen SD,

Unknown Speaker 38:33

which is really interesting about Kancil culture.

Unknown Speaker 38:42

So, again, link in the profile for fragility defensiveness, right to comfort and fear of losing power, how the anti cancel culture movement or raises the labor and progress of black indigenous people of color, abolitionists and upholds white supremacy,

Unknown Speaker 39:03

the origins of quote Kancil culture, the origins, let's just presume that you're hearing we say, quote, Kancil culture because in quotation marks for the rest of the podcast, and I won't say it again. Okay. So the origins of what is now being over generalized as canceled culture is that it came from the black queer community, more specifically black abolitionist survivors, as a way to break the silence when those with more power and privilege evaded accountability for harm they have caused, being that it is extremely easy for those with more power and privilege to hide behind their social capital in order to evade accountability, a tactic that began to be known as call outs was created within these black queer communities to push back on those power dynamics and gather community support to bring what about accountability by bringing it into the public sphere. Being that a main competitor

Unknown Speaker 40:00

of white supremacy and patriarchy, our silence and dismissal around harm and interpersonal violence. This is then a legitimate tool to push back on that conditioning. This tactic then gained usage by other marginalized communities for the same purpose to call out harm caused by those with more power and privilege when the hope of bringing with the hope of bringing about accountability.

Unknown Speaker 40:26

Next transformative justice. The definition of transformative justice, as written in the book fumbling towards repair by Maryam Kaba and Shira Hassan as adapted from fi from generation five, transformative justice TJ seeks to provide people who experience violence with immediate safety and long term healing and reparations while holding people who commit violence accountable within and by their communities. transformative justice is centered around the following main goals one survivor safety, healing an agency to accountability and transformation of those who abuse or cause harm, three, community response and accountability for transformation of the community and social conditions that create and perpetuate violence, systems of oppression, exploitation, domination and state violence. transformative justice does not rely on the state, the criminal justice system are the legal system,

Unknown Speaker 41:34

accountability and consequences. accountability on the personal community and collective level looks like the ability to self reflect and acknowledge harm caused, it then looks like accepting the consequences of one's behavior and taking concrete actions to create repair. This can look like a lot of different things, but being that transformative justice is centered around the needs of the person or community that was harmed. That is who needs to drive the decision making process on what repair should look like. It is important to remember here that consequences being faced by someone who has caused harm is not punishment, some example of consequences, one financial reparations to losing a platform three, giving up a leadership role.

Unknown Speaker 42:29

Where we are now and why it needs to change. It is important to first note that TJ transformative justice will was created as an abolitionist tool by black abolitionist survivors, what happened and what we are what we are now seeing several things. One, a white influencer, who is evading accountability for harm they have caused named by named Clementine Morgan is building a brand by CO opting the language of TJ, turning it on its head and framing the seeking of accountability as quote, policing. I'm asking you to think how deeply problematic this is for a white person to be doing this. They are even going so far as to encourage people to not respond when someone tries to inform others of something having caused harm, which also erases the, quote, whisper networks that other that marginalized communities use to warn each other of danger. In my personal opinion, their content is largely responsible for the growing anti cancel culture movement, and it is causing harm to other people with power and privilege privilege are jumping on this bandwagon. And pushing back on call outs and labeling anything that looks like it may cause them to lose power as canceled culture, as well as demonizing marginalized people and communities seeking accountability as being abusive, bullying and harassment. None of this takes into consideration the power dynamics at play that brought about the call out in the first place. But more importantly, it is Davo on a massive scale. Davo is a defensive gaslighting tactic that people use, wherein they make themselves out to be the victim when they are actually the one who caused harm. It stands for one deny two attack three reverse victim offender. So deny attack reverse victim offender.

Unknown Speaker 44:34

This needs to change because we are never going to be able to dismantle white supremacy if we allow this to continue. This is a derailment. When we should be talking about racism, white supremacy ableism transphobia. The conversation is now about canceled culture. A lot of black folks will tell you canceled culture is not real. It has now become just another tactic to evade accountability. What we need to be focusing on

Unknown Speaker 45:00

In my opinion is building the skills to be accountable to create repair and to be able to accept the consequences when we cause harm when compared to to harm course, especially if it is severe, losing a social media platform is not actually that big of a deal, and why people need to be working on being able to give up their power in order to dismantle white supremacy anyways, we need to get back on track to centering black voices. And that includes deferring to black abolitionists when it comes to transformative justice.

Unknown Speaker 45:34

And we've got a quote here from

Unknown Speaker 45:37

Estelle, who says, it still at abolish underscore time is actually not possible to say you oppose cancel culture without canceling survivors. preventing abuse from being abuse from becoming public puts the burden of ending abuse solely on survivors abusers isolate and silenced survivors to help ensure that abuse continues without interruption

Unknown Speaker 46:06

Yeah, so there's another couple of a couple of other slides and so

Unknown Speaker 46:11

go and check that out really great post love it.

Unknown Speaker 46:16

No, I didn't I didn't know that Kancil culture came from black abolitionists

Unknown Speaker 46:23

so that's really interesting.

Unknown Speaker 46:26

And and we think about like, what what's the alternative here?

Unknown Speaker 46:31

No one you know silence and with with someone like that's what's happened his silence over the years and then it is just you know, escalated where it's caused more harm, more, more, more, more more harm. And now

Unknown Speaker 46:44

ending with

Unknown Speaker 46:47

Mikey

Unknown Speaker 46:50

as

Unknown Speaker 46:52

someone who holds these marginalized identities, ended entities is a woman who is who's stepping up a great cost to herself.

Unknown Speaker 47:03

Yeah.

Unknown Speaker 47:04

So anti diet fatty has got a couple of really good posts. The first one that I want to talk about is called is everyone canceling Vega now, accountability versus canceled culture? So

Unknown Speaker 47:17

I'm going to skip ahead a few slides here. And antedated it says when a powerful public figure in a community has harmed other people refused to even attempt a resolution and then demanded it all be kept secret. That's the other thing as Linda says, Can we keep the secret? What do you propose people do? What do you recommend people do to prevent other people from experiencing the same harm pattern of harm they have experienced? If you are concerned about the mental health impact this public discussion has had? I would ask, Did you consider the mental health impact for Mikey Lindley, the ASTER leadership and other who share similar stories? Did you think about the vast number of comments DMS and gaslighting that these folks have endured by sharing? Have you thought about the emotional and mental toll that they have had to shoulder alone for months before they decided to share publicly? Why isn't Mikey Lindley and as mental health just as deserving of your consideration and regard? Oh, slam dunk, slam dunk,

Unknown Speaker 48:21

and there's more slides here.

Unknown Speaker 48:25

And so as well,

Unknown Speaker 48:30

we've got here and guess what anti diet fatties name is Lauren. Why if we get another l name in this, then I'm given up. We're gonna have another l name.

Unknown Speaker 48:42

Okay, so, Lauren anti diet fatty has also shared excerpts from

Unknown Speaker 48:48

an article from Forbes. Some quotes from that cancel culture is relatively new term developed to insulate the powerful from being held accountable for hateful language. It is mere, a mere propaganda tool that has proliferated in our mainstream discourse. Kancil culture is either unfair or justified based on the recipient and the alleged alleged transgression. Actions have consequences and some infractions are indeed Council worthy. When it comes to issues of equity and inclusion, many advocates consider zero tolerance policies on as public policies. zero tolerance policy is an important part of rooting out racism, bias and broader discrimination. Freedom of speech or freedom to act doesn't imply freedom from consequences insist anti racism educator and consultant Denise branch consequence culture is needed to build safer, more inclusive, equitable and accountable workplaces. Perhaps the truth is that black and brown people have historically been granted very little if any margin of error, much less second, third and fourth chapter chances and then in the middle of the country's countries racial reckoning

Unknown Speaker 50:00

high profile mostly white celebrities, executives and other leaders are now being treated more like everyone else. Maybe it's yet another example of saying when those with privilege privilege are faced with equality to them, it often feels like oppression. Let me read that last line again. I loved it. When those with privilege are faced with equality to them, it often feels like oppression.

Unknown Speaker 50:24

Okay.

Unknown Speaker 50:26

So

Unknown Speaker 50:28

I want to as well share something from Nick McDermid.

Unknown Speaker 50:33

That is her handle on on

Unknown Speaker 50:35

Instagram. He says therapists who cry Kancil culture are modeling to their clients an unwillingness to believe survivors to prioritize marginalized experiences, and are blatantly giving permission for abuse and coercion to continue. So saying this, so Mikey has collected all of the white fuckery that she has experienced after coming out here.

Unknown Speaker 51:02

And

Unknown Speaker 51:04

I want to I'm going to talk about that in a second. But before I do, I want to share another post from Lauren anti diet fatty and it's actually I'm going to share another post a post from Project he'll project he'll has said in a post it's quite short here. If you are not fat you should not be or believe you are the sole authority on issues affecting predominantly fat people act as a gatekeeper to financial and professional opportunities to speak on fat issues. ignore your privilege and say yes to opportunities which elevate you as the authority on fat issues. I love that from Project he'll.

Unknown Speaker 51:51

And I'm going to read one more from anti diet fatty which I liked, which was

Unknown Speaker 51:59

fat folks know a thing or two about enduring stress under a continuous stream and then read it again. Fat folks know a thing or two about enduring under a continuous stream of stress. I would imagine receiving volumes of tags, comments, emails and tweets would be difficult under the best of circumstances. The mental strain that brings is a difficult experience. Every fat creator I know especially fat, brown, black indigenous people of color creators can relate the barrage of trolls tweets, tags, IRL encounters and everyday vitriol is an emotional and mental burden that we carry around every day. We don't have the privilege to leave, opt out or escape. We can't declare ourselves quote, fixed and move on to other pursuits. The world won't let us our fat bodies require that we gather up every shred of Audacity that we possess. And can you continue to take up space in a world that is Turman to keep us small? Only in tiny pockets of people can we steal a breath and exhale in relief? Because for a moment we know that we are safe. Do I wish that experience on anyone else? Absolutely not. People living in a small in small body sometimes get bombarded with criticism because of something they said. Fat people constantly get the body with animosity for simply living.

Unknown Speaker 53:28

Yes.

Unknown Speaker 53:30

Slam Dunk. Yes. And it's like Don't be mean to me because of my shitty behavior. That's not fair.

Unknown Speaker 53:43

It's like um, maybe just don't be sure.

Unknown Speaker 53:48

Okay, so something that Mikey has pointed out is that

Unknown Speaker 53:57

this is tiring stuff you

Unknown Speaker 53:59

owe

Unknown Speaker 54:01

that there are a few

Unknown Speaker 54:05

people in the in the industry, the fat, the haze the intuitive eating whatever anti diet industry

Unknown Speaker 54:14

who are just being really shit.

Unknown Speaker 54:21

And in in Mikey's most recent post, it's called a week into the pocalypse she's naming names and she's been Mike has been no names already. And it's given me the courage as well to name names and I have in the put on the podcast recently.

Unknown Speaker 54:44

In the last six months, do you remember Do you remember?

Unknown Speaker 54:51

I said, listen up here everybody. I want you to be careful about where where you know who you're investing in, like who's

Unknown Speaker 55:00

whose books you're buying and stuff. Just keep your Spidey eyes spidey senses whatever opened and here's a little clue. Go and check out your favorite thin

Unknown Speaker 55:11

anti diet people and go and see who they're following for some clues about who you might want to keep an eyeball on.

Unknown Speaker 55:23

And yeah, I was talking about our Caroline Duna. And it's not just who she is following but the absolute awful shit that she has been sharing in the last year.

Unknown Speaker 55:37

Now Chiron Jr. and I have had a kind of want to say relationship like we know of each other. I've been on our podcast a couple of times.

Unknown Speaker 55:45

This is hard, right?

Unknown Speaker 55:48

Because I'm like, Just don't say anything. My thing is, I just don't say anything. Anyway, so we've known each other we've been connected. And I started noticing some of the things that Caroline was sharing and I was like, hang on a minute. It's not just a bad take. I so she says she's having an off day. Well, I definitely by she's having another off day. And then it was like wow, what the fuck is this shit. So

Unknown Speaker 56:16

this is what

Unknown Speaker 56:18

this is what Mikey has said in that about Article I just mentioned

Unknown Speaker 56:27

it's a running theme among Ling lindows supporters who have been mostly spouse in public but surely congregate in large numbers in private, who have been horrible at remembering Linda's pronouns as well as not dead naming them to depict a hypothetical image of a broken Lindo, a Linda who is being counseled for refusing to link relinquish their life's work over to her a bunch of ungrateful fat you servers. Despite how Lindos fund us for ghostwriters challenges this this questionable challenges this persecuted juniors fantasy, or how they engage with young collaborators of color and extremely questionable ways to put this lightly or how their treaty on social justice dogma from last year published to the as the lesser in support of Maria paradas paints the picture of Lindo, who is more calculated than maligned a weird anti diet anti culture anti cancer culture brigade, comprised of people like Clementine Morgan and Caroline doona has emerged to defend lindo however, as others have already done a good job of unpacking that ridiculous ridiculousness I will not okay so links to Caroline Luna and what she said about this whole situation and what she said it's fucking horrible.

Unknown Speaker 57:45

Let me read it out to you. I'm sure you want to know what she said.

Unknown Speaker 57:53

Someone tag Caroline Jr. and said

Unknown Speaker 57:57

as the largest and most popular Health at Every Size writer, influencer, your silence is deafening. And Karen, you know, responded, what are you even talking about? Have I not been crystal clear that I do not agree with or participate in online mob campaigns? Have I not been crystal clear that I don't even identify as liberal anymore because of this kind of coercive culty fervor? Have I not criticized throwing around the word harm so much that it loses meaning? The people demanding that I weigh in have also been calling me quote, harmful, dangerous, anti Vaxxer, racist, anti semitic conspiracy theory conspiracy theorists for over six months. Now. Now you want me to speak up and do the same thing for someone else? Or you guys hi, funniest part. I don't even condone Lindos actions, but I despise this coercive mob shit even more. At this point. I'm not even close to being a being a part of the haze community. And I have unfollowed every single person who I've seen engaging as mob justice, I stand by every single thing in the Fuckit diet. But but in sharing my story, healing from an eating disorder, I never signed up to be part of this cult. I'm done.

Unknown Speaker 59:12

Mikey's commentary is this whole thing is a dumpster fire or Goldmine if you're like me, and you like to make fun of people like this, but I wanted to point folks attention to the part where the fuck diet says The funniest part is I don't even condone Lindos actions, but I despise this coercive mob shit even more. I think this is an important statement. Duna doesn't condone lindows actions, but is so against accountability, and so committed to perpetrating historical inequity, as well as her anti cancel culture grift that she's still against a public calling that was only necessitated by lindows long string of failures over over a decade's long career to take any of the private feedback that numerous fat

Unknown Speaker 1:00:00

People have given them about their conduct or in short, whites are gonna white. Yes, exactly. Whites are going to white. So

Unknown Speaker 1:00:16

so

Unknown Speaker 1:00:18

so my my so so let's talk about this.

Unknown Speaker 1:00:23

So I got a DM from Caroline a couple of weeks ago.

Unknown Speaker 1:00:27

And I was like

Unknown Speaker 1:00:30

okay, what is this?

Unknown Speaker 1:00:34

So Caroline so so one month ago

Unknown Speaker 1:00:40

I saw a post on

Unknown Speaker 1:00:44

Caroline's Facebook page, the post was

Unknown Speaker 1:00:50

a picture of the blonde girl from euphoria screaming. And it says I have never ever been happier. And clearly she's sad and crying and so she is being sarcastic. And so the text created by Caroline says, telling my friends how much I love being an author in the age of canceled culture and censorship. So basically saying it's really hard to be an author when you're going to get cancelled.

Unknown Speaker 1:01:18

So I thought, Oh,

Unknown Speaker 1:01:20

this isn't good.

Unknown Speaker 1:01:24

Because really, she's a thin white woman. Who's

Unknown Speaker 1:01:29

this summer shit. I want to tell you, but I'm not gonna tell you.

Unknown Speaker 1:01:33

She's got privilege. Okay, she has got fucking privilege coming out of her eyeballs. Okay, so she's a thin white woman saying, Oh my God. I'm being censored. Who is sense who is who is censoring her? Is because people tell her Hey, when you've been when she's been a decade, people say hey, can you not be a dickhead? And so that is for her is terrible censorship. Anyway. And so Marin Wan, God lover, Marin, one incredible fan activist, has said a beautiful comment. Here's a saying that has helped in response to the post. Here's saying that has helped me put these issues in perspective. Why do people care more about being called racist than about ending racism? being asked to refrain from creating hateful and oppressive content, or being held accountable when we do is not oppression. Imagine being an author who faces racism, homophobia, ableism, sexism, classism, classism, or, or some combination of these oppressions.

Unknown Speaker 1:02:34

And beautiful, right? Yeah, doesn't

Unknown Speaker 1:02:40

really, I think that really explains it. And someone said to Marilyn, oh, I wouldn't be following this person because she's a she's anti Vax and something blah, blah, blah. And then and someone else said, also, she said, let me find it. I've got a I'm looking at these posts.

Unknown Speaker 1:03:02

Been, by the way, this post is still up. So if you want to go to the fucker diet page, and you can go and have a look, government screaming picture of a white one.

Unknown Speaker 1:03:20

So so let me let me see tell you what Caroline's responses. American. Well, I absolutely loved your book fatso. And 10 years ago, it was a catalyst for my own Hayes journey of healing, and my own writing about my relationship with food and weight.

Unknown Speaker 1:03:35

Her saying that? Why the fuck? Have you not been centering Maryland's work then? Why the fuck has she not been on your podcast? If she is the catalyst for your journey? Why are you not sharing in the profits from your two

Unknown Speaker 1:03:52

enormous books? What the fuck? This is the first time Marilyn has been getting any any flowers for this? Would the catalyst and she gets a shitty fucking Facebook comment? Anyway, let me continue it just mad about it. I'm mad.

Unknown Speaker 1:04:09

So, okay, so 10 years ago, it was a capitalist blah, blah, blah. I even mentioned in your book. I'm even mentioned your book in my new book that came out. Sorry, you think the worst of me now. To me. This is actually a great example of how cancer culture and accountability culture works. Assuming the worst without actually knowing but getting swept up in the mob rhetoric and piling on any way.

Unknown Speaker 1:04:37

Twisting things and turning them into capital haitch harm, blah, blah, blah. Other bullshit. Marilyn said a lovely beautiful comment, didn't she? So other people said oh hey Marilyn.

Unknown Speaker 1:04:51

She's done other fucking shitty things too.

Unknown Speaker 1:04:55

And

Unknown Speaker 1:04:58

someone said

Unknown Speaker 1:05:00

She made a

Unknown Speaker 1:05:04

so someone said, Oh, she made a joke of expensive fat people. And I was just like reading all this stuff like,

Unknown Speaker 1:05:11

what's going on? So I said to someone's comment, what was the joke? That's it.

Unknown Speaker 1:05:17

Didn't say anything else. That's it. And so this was a month ago, so a few days ago, or last week or whatever it was, I got a message from Caroline Duna since an iPhone followed her maybe a month a month ago when I saw all this shit.

Unknown Speaker 1:05:32

And so she says, Hey, Vinnie saw on Facebook you asking what my quote terrible April Fool's joke was, I just all I said was, What's the joke, which was turning was turning, which is about turning into a fitness account. With April April falls. In the first line in the caption, this was toasted into Caroline won't apologize, which is way violence with no context. And people furious with me thinking I did something racist. curious what your thoughts are on things like this because I noticed you unfollowed me which prompted me to unfollow you. Which is I just thought what? Caroline dooner If you followed her is all about if you don't like me, unfollow me, I don't care. I don't care. I unfollow her. And then she's up in my inbox saying, Why did you unfollow me?

Unknown Speaker 1:06:22

What?

Unknown Speaker 1:06:24

So I responded, hey, Caroline. It was a post that made that you made with anti semitism, anti mass mandates, vaccines victim blaming, sexual assault survivors, etc. Karolina kept all of these posts their stories, go and check her stories, stay safe stories, you will see them don't don't take my word for it. Don't take my word for and your jaw is probably going to hit the floor. Talk about Nazis talking about all sorts of shit. Like

Unknown Speaker 1:06:55

I was like white. So that's when I unfollowed anyway, okay. Also seeing you follow a lot of right wing racist pseudoscience accounts. We all fuck up. It's part of what being human is. But doubling down when we cause harm means you're not safe for me to follow. Being a thin white woman in a fat positive space and you die it means the default should be to listen to those with more marginalized identities and learn from them. Always. It doesn't mean I think that you're a bad person, or politics just no longer align. And she responded saying yes, we def don't agree. Best of luck. Then she's made a post. Then she blocked me. So I logged into my other account to check out what she what she was saying on the thing. Bearing in mind. I've never spoken about this, okay. I've never I just said he, I just said to you, I said hey, listen, I didn't name names. I just said go and check to see who people are following. Okay. Just just to be aware, you know.

Unknown Speaker 1:07:56

So, Caroline, her her story then that day, fun fact. Some of the people who have turned on me slash engaging in cancellation bullshit against me in the past two years, were people I'd had on my podcast. That's me. And so I deleted their episodes. And I might delete some more now that I look through.

Unknown Speaker 1:08:18

And she went on saying loads of other stuff that I was just like,

Unknown Speaker 1:08:23

and I shared it with some friends and they were like, what Duff

Unknown Speaker 1:08:26

is going on here.

Unknown Speaker 1:08:33

Yeah, anyway, so this thing you know about the April Fool's joke, someone had captured the screenshot of her.

Unknown Speaker 1:08:41

Someone had sent in a, you know, this is this is how she's been called out. This is the mob that she talks about.

Unknown Speaker 1:08:49

Someone has said, it's a very sensitive topic. Why don't you just just apologize it would be not much nicer if what you said offended anyone just apologized and do better next time? I think it was a really bad joke. I found your book so helpful. I love your account. But that April Fool's post left a really bad taste in my mouth. You are not like

Unknown Speaker 1:09:12

me with 100 followers. You're a public figure who has written a book on the very sensitive topic topic again, just apologize and then move on and do better. And then Caroline said, apologize for what exactly were three question marks. And now she's saying in it. Like, there's also a group demanding a public apology from my April Fool's post, where I said I was turning into a healthy recipe account for the quote, harm I caused and the trust I broke and I just fucking refuse. And that's the thing is

Unknown Speaker 1:09:49

there were a few refusal to say

Unknown Speaker 1:09:53

a marginalized community that you are a spokesperson of now will give you that

Unknown Speaker 1:10:00

job, you took it. And you say I'm not in the haze, I'm not in haze, you fucking are because your book is healthy.

Unknown Speaker 1:10:10

And

Unknown Speaker 1:10:12

you're benefiting from concepts that people created, while not not lifting them up or doing anything. And in fact, when you heard that people you just like, for what like, why the fuck would I apologize, go fuck yourself and blocked them. And you know, blocked me and, you know, my message to her was like, Listen, I don't agree with you being racist, and being anti semitic. I don't think you're a bad person, our politics don't align, and she blocked me, you know, and then putting post up like, Oh, I'm going to delete people and blah, blah, blah.

Unknown Speaker 1:10:46

And someone had said, messaged her saying isn't deleting someone from your past podcast doing the same canceling that you're against? And she says, Guys, deleting someone from your podcast feed after they publicly attacked and slandered you is not the same as publicly going after someone. So here's the thing I'm thinking who, who was one of this big campaign of of canceling Caroline Duna. Like

Unknown Speaker 1:11:13

I don't see it. The only thing is there has been a very smaller account a very, very small account with

Unknown Speaker 1:11:22

let's see how many followers I have.

Unknown Speaker 1:11:28

I'll tell you in a second, but what I'm looking at, who made a very indirect post, just just like a fat whisper network thing being like, Hey, guys.

Unknown Speaker 1:11:36

I don't like saying that word, guys. But so a small account with 3000 followers saying, hey, and by the way, I believe in vaccination, and this account is spreading, anti Vax, anti mandate messages, just a heads up

Unknown Speaker 1:11:53

a 3000 follower account saying something like that, then recently, and then she then she's she's saying all that type of stuff. Then recently.

Unknown Speaker 1:12:03

Joshua, what's his name? Dr. Dr. Joshua, whatever his name is. Joshua.

Unknown Speaker 1:12:12

Woolridge. Someone said, said to him, Oh, hey, what do you think about

Unknown Speaker 1:12:17

her talking about anti mask stuff? And he says, It's not science based. And it's in it's dangerous. And so

Unknown Speaker 1:12:28

she's in that she's not talking about that when she talks about this mob that's trying to get her. So I was curious. I was curious to see how much this dam there how much damage this mob of people unfollowing her has actually done. And so let's do this with so I on socialblade.com Social Blade will tell you things like how many followers people have, how many followers they've lost, what grade their content is, how many likes they get all that type of stuff kind of gives you the behind the scenes information. You don't have to pay for it to get basic stuff, but you have to sign up. Anyway. Okay, so if we look at Linda Bacon, Linda Bacon, in the last 30 days has lost 1320 followers.

Unknown Speaker 1:13:11

And so,

Unknown Speaker 1:13:13

at the beginning of the 30 days, she had I'm sorry, they had

Unknown Speaker 1:13:19

an eye. I'm very cognizant of

Unknown Speaker 1:13:23

me. misgendering and I probably have done it, done it in the podcast already. And I just want to point out those absolutely not okay. And, of course, me being non binary. It's something that I should absolutely do better at so

Unknown Speaker 1:13:39

yeah, so just pointing out Lindos pronouns are they them, and if I have misgendered them, then that's not okay. Okay, so they started with 21,870 followers. So it is ago

Unknown Speaker 1:13:55

they lost

Unknown Speaker 1:13:57

1560 So what percentage so that is 7.13% After this alleged huge cancellation, awful, their career is over.

Unknown Speaker 1:14:12

has lost has maintained 93% of their followers 93% of their followers and so this week, presumably would be the biggest kind of hit to the followers because people are sharing and then in a couple of weeks time it's going to die down.

Unknown Speaker 1:14:29

So let's look at Caroline dooner Let's go a little little it but boots go to the top. Let's have a look. Let's look at diet. Okay, so in the last 30 days, and by the way after

Unknown Speaker 1:14:43

Caroline shared like fuck all you I don't give a shit about accountability thing.

Unknown Speaker 1:14:52

She then the next day rejoiced in being unfollowed by everyone. Okay, so

Unknown Speaker 1:15:00

Caroline Duna

Unknown Speaker 1:15:03

to let's just make it easy and just say we'll just use the, we'll just use the followers that she has now. So it's not it's actually the percentage is going to be skewed a little bit because she's lost followers. And so she's got 20 236,000 followers

Unknown Speaker 1:15:20

but the bottom 236,000 Let's just do those 236 photo and how she lost in the last 30 days she has lost

Unknown Speaker 1:15:32

3900 Okay

Unknown Speaker 1:15:37

3900 So this huge mass and following cancellations she's experiencing she's lost a whopping 1.6% of her following 1.6% When she had such a huge unfollowing the other day the huge unfollowing she had the other day was 190 people. So yeah.

Unknown Speaker 1:16:01

Wow, she's really being cancelled by who? Or what?

Unknown Speaker 1:16:08

So do you see how these people in power with these privileges are saying you know, counterculture is bad because

Unknown Speaker 1:16:20

they're protecting themselves. And the fit the crux behind it. The big crux a lot of people are saying is that people die if they're canceled people

Unknown Speaker 1:16:30

die by suicide. So longtime listeners of the show know that I was on a BBC documentary, watched by

Unknown Speaker 1:16:38

that 2.5 million people probably a lot more by now because it's been out on on the iPlayer. So millions of people have watched me on the show. After the response that I that I got, I was trolled hardcore. I was trolled. And I was really, really bitterly disappointed at one my portrayal in the show when to the dashed hopes of what good things could come from me being on the show. Because of that, I became suicidal.

Unknown Speaker 1:17:08

Haha, proof, canceled culture kills people.

Unknown Speaker 1:17:13

Well, I wasn't cancelled. I was trolled.

Unknown Speaker 1:17:17

I was trolled by people who hated me and wanted me to die. I didn't fuck up.

Unknown Speaker 1:17:27

I didn't have the opportunity to make amends. Because there wasn't, it was just my existence as a fat person. That made them mad as a fat person who didn't hate themselves that made them mad. And so it's not like so they came. And it's like the game of the show came out and people were like, oh, Vinnie, you already fucked up, pull out one. And I could go and be like, Hey, everyone, listen, I really fucked up. And

Unknown Speaker 1:17:48

here's how I'm going to make amends. And here's how I'm committed to making amends. I couldn't do that, because I didn't fuck up. I just existed. And so, you know, I got messages, I just got messages from people saying, you know, I should be dead and things like that. So that's trolling. That's bullying. And that is not what accountability is. That is not the process that's being has been encouraged to engage in.

Unknown Speaker 1:18:14

They have the opportunity to say, Hey, everyone, I fucked up.

Unknown Speaker 1:18:20

And saying, like, oh, we shouldn't be doing that. It's like, imagine if, for example, you lived in a family. And there was one awful person in the family. There say it's the dad, you know, because you know what, in my family, my dad was very close, it was not great. And so imagine if I was like, or you were like, Hey, that person is awful. And instead of hearing you, your family said, hey, hey, don't say that about your father. It'll hurt his feelings. If you say that he is a decade. And so in that moment, you're being taught that abusers feelings are more important than yours. And what what cost does that have for your mental health?

Unknown Speaker 1:19:00

You know, I've not seen anyone, anyone anywhere saying, hey, a piece of shit, you need to die. We hate you. And I'm not saying that hasn't received messages like that. Of course, there's people who were who were unkind and that's not appropriate. There's people who are trolls. And that is not appropriate. What is happening is people are saying, Hey, we should support a young, Fat Black Woman by giving donations to them and sharing their content. And some people saying Why don't you join in the accountability process? Why don't you want to engage and not being thrown out of the community, they're invited to repair the harm that they've caused?

Unknown Speaker 1:19:40

And again, I want you to think about what you would do in the same situation. Yeah, you'd probably be sad. And we you know, if you've got a message saying, You fucked up, you'd be like, awful, you know, you probably call your friends and whatever and be like, Oh, my God, I feel terrible. I feel like a terrible person. I fucked up and, and then, you know, you'd be like, Oh, this is what they want me to do. Okay, I'll do it. I'll fix it. You know?

Unknown Speaker 1:20:01

And if you're worried about being canceled, why

Unknown Speaker 1:20:06

do you cause repeated harm? Are people constantly coming to you saying, hey, you've hurt me? And then you're saying no fingers in your ears, I don't give a shit. Oh, you don't do that? Well, then you, you're probably gonna be fine. And you might be like, Well, I don't want to cause harm this son. That's a That's why supremacy culture is perfectionism, you're going to cause harm. If you're a human being, I'm going to cause harm. I'm going to fuck up. You know, even in this podcast, I've probably fucked up. You know, before mentioned I've maybe I've misgendered i when that's not okay.

Unknown Speaker 1:20:41

So what am I, you know, what are you going to do just not be alive? Because you might accidentally fuck up.

Unknown Speaker 1:20:48

And then what will how you will react? And it's not like fat people. And black people are trolling the streets, and other people with marginalized identities, you know, outs, you know, with a hairpin temper and someone says, Hello, how's your day to day? And then, you know, a fat person is like, how do you, you had said, that day you speak to me like that you're canceled, I'm going to ruin your career and then going to, you know, Instagram or, like, get this motherfucker. They asked me how my day was, how dare they speak to me? You know, and poor, unsuspecting, thin, white people are like, oh, all I said was Hello, how's your day, and now I'm dead, because of these angry fat people paroling trolling the streets being awful.

Unknown Speaker 1:21:36

And if that's what you think,

Unknown Speaker 1:21:40

is gonna happen, then that means you need to examine

Unknown Speaker 1:21:46

what's going on, because that's a manifestation of racism and fatphobia. And, you know, whatever it is, you know, that's going on with whatever marginalized group that you think, are so unreasonable, so angry. I mean, it's just such a boring old trope. You know, it's just such a boring old trope.

Unknown Speaker 1:22:06

Because the reality of all of this is, the amount of harm that someone has to cause before someone who has a shit ton less power, before they speak up.

Unknown Speaker 1:22:20

Is is huge, and the risk associated is huge. I'm here now thinking, Well, that's it, I fucked up because I've spoken about Carolyn Duna. I fucked up. Now. She's gonna come after me. And I'm not saying anything like, Oh, hey, everybody, you need to go and do this. I mean, I'm just saying like, this is what's happened. Maybe she isn't the fat positive guru that everyone positions her as maybe some of her views are harmful to people with marginalized identities. Maybe she should be using her power for good. You know.

Unknown Speaker 1:22:56

And again, I want to distinguish between saying, hey, let's engage in an accountability process. And the power, the privilege that's at play, because sometimes, some people, that's all they've got is to, is to say, Can we try and engage in accountability process?

Unknown Speaker 1:23:17

And most the time, those with privilege are just like, Oh, my God, you're hurting my feelings. I can't believe that. You're asking me that Kancil culture.

Unknown Speaker 1:23:28

And then you have people who are just felons who are trolls? Who send messages saying you're a piece of shit and you need to die. That's not that's being trolled. You know, when we talk about being trolled all the time, and if you're if you someone on the internet, and, you know, look, I've spoken about it on the show many times how the things that I've had to do to protect my mental health from the trolls out there, and I get that just from existing as a fat person, whereas it sounds like someone like Caroline dooner has had just people being like, you're amazing. Oh my god, you're great. And then she started being shitty. And now fat people are like, Oh, hey, maybe that's not great take and she's like, Oh, my God, council culture. And

Unknown Speaker 1:24:15

it just smacks of you know, white thinness doesn't it doesn't work.

Unknown Speaker 1:24:23

I'm sure I've not mentioned so many things here that I should have mentioned and so many points that I want to make, but we're at fucking 90 minutes now. I knew this was gonna be a big one. And it's way past the time that I normally work.

Unknown Speaker 1:24:39

Oh my goodness.

Unknown Speaker 1:24:42

So anyway, go and donate to Mikey go donate to Lindley go and join and go and join Nafa go and read some books and on my on my post. I've got a reading list of different books too. So go to my Instagram for that and

Unknown Speaker 1:24:59

if you're still going

Unknown Speaker 1:25:00

views listen just drop me a DM and we're like yeah you're actually you know I'm still not sure how how this is set in or whatever and I'm not just I'm just whatever

Unknown Speaker 1:25:10

you use just just reach out and say hey, I'm confused like what why is this not canceled culture? What is canceled culture what's going on? And of course I'm not an expert in this you know, I'm fumbling along like, like everyone else.

Unknown Speaker 1:25:25

Anyway, my voice is going so I'm going to stop talking it's almost like I want to keep talking because I don't want to forget something and then afterwards be like, Do you know what that's fucking that's just that's white supremacy culture where the be trying to be perfect. Okay, so I'm gonna stop right now.

Unknown Speaker 1:25:41

Links for everything in the show notes again, it is facebook.com forward slash a 119. Do I sound like a radio host or what? And I will see you all you first families in the next episode. Stay fears fatty and in a while. Alligator Good boy.

Unknown Speaker 1:26:01

Thanks for listening to the episode. And if you feel ready to get serious about this work and want to know when the doors open to fears fattier Academy which is my signature program, where I teach all about how to overcome your fat phobic beliefs and learn to love your fat body, then go to first fatty.com forward slash waitlist again, that is phase fatty.com. Forward slash waitlist to get your name on the waitlist. For when first Matty Academy my signature program opens.

EP118 Transcript

Welcome to the Fierce Fatty Podcast. I'm your host, Victoria Welsby, and this is episode 118. Today, we're talking about The Limitations of “Body Love”

I'm Victoria Welsby, TEDx speaker, best-selling author, and fat activist. I have transformed my life from hating my body with desperately low self-esteem to being a courageous and confident fierce fatty who loves every inch of this jelly. Society teaches us living in a fat body is bad. But what if we spent less time, money, and energy on the pursuit of thinness and instead focused on the things that actually matter? Like if pineapple on pizza should be outlawed? Or if the mullet was the greatest haircut of the 20th century? So how do you stop negative beliefs about your fat body controlling your life? It's the Fierce Fatty Podcast. Let's begin.

Hello, fatties and honorary fatties. Welcome to the show. So pleased to have you. I'm so excited today because I'm using an incredible invention. You've probably heard of this invention, but it had escaped my mind that these things existed. And I'm, yeah, so I record the podcast facing the window, right to get light. If I do it facing anywhere else, I don't get enough light. But I've got these lines, you know, like shutter blinds in little crevices, little things of light. And if anyone watches the show on YouTube, they'll watch like little bits of light, sometimes going across my face as the sun goes across the sky, and it's really fucking annoying. And I've been racking my brain thinking about what can I do to make it so that there aren't any line lines? Can I get another set of blinds that go over these blinds in the areas that the there are cracks because my window is so huge, it's like three separate blinds. And last week, I put up a towel over them. And it suddenly dawned on me, I've lived in this place for a year, it suddenly dawned on me that there is something called curtains that I could buy. Why Why? Why is no one told me about this magical thing called curtains, which I already have in my apartment in my bedroom, obviously. And it solved the problem. So I went to IKEA got some curtains. And now I don't have like shit in my brain annoying me making me sad. So yay. So if anyone out there thank Yes, you're welcome. For my incredible invention that I've I'm telling the world about spreading the news about curtains. Great device for stopping light getting into your apartment when you're recording a podcast. Yeah, dreams do come true. Anyway, so today's podcast, we're talking about the limitations of body love. And a lot of what about I want to talk I talk a lot about fat politics, right? And also body love. And I realize there's a big gap in regards to the words I'm using. And maybe sometimes what I'm meaning, and I think, longtime, longtime listeners of the show, no, but I think I really need to be explicit about what I'm saying when I use a word like body love, body acceptance, all that type of stuff. What I actually mean and also the limitations on the concept of body love. So let's talk about that. Now. First, I want to give you a kind of an overview of my morning as someone who doesn't hate their body. Or someone who loves their body or someone who's neutral their body. That's me, right? However you want to say it, someone who doesn't hate their body. So you can see what it's like. And is it is it this basically, me spending the first five hours of my day just stare in the mirror being like oh my god noise so good. Which is obviously what I do every single day. Not on Fridays because I'm busy being fabulous on Fridays, but is it like that or is it something else? So I thought I just give you kind of a little overview of my morning just waking up been walking doodle. So you can see the kind of thoughts that might go through my head not might have gone through my head. And so I have many, many hundreds of thoughts. I know, it's weird to think like that, that I have thoughts going through this gorgeous head of mine. But I do so just FYI, you know,

in between these sorts I'm having there's also thoughts about oh, you know, isn't it nice to have a pool or oh, what's on Netflix tonight, and oh, you know, whatever. So it's not a kind of stream of consciousness of me being like, only think about my body or not thinking about my body. Okay, so I woke up, my first thought was all that I had in my sleep. And I felt rested. I went to sleep at nine o'clock last night, which is not like me, I normally go to bed at midnight. So once I had my sleep, I had a shower. And notice my body. In regards to I noticed that my allergic reaction, I'm having an allergic reaction to something over the last few months. And we don't know what it is. But here takes a medicine to reduce the symptoms. So I'm having an allergic reaction to something, and it causes hives on my bodies. And so I had a thought of I felt frustrated about this, I don't care what the hives look like on my skin, but more so that they are itchy. I guess I care, I care moderate amount, right. So that's the thought that I had in my mouth about Molly had a shower. And then when I got out of the shower, I looked at my naked body in the bathroom mirror as I tried myself. And the only thing that I noticed was where the water was on my body and where I needed to put the towel to dry my body. I literally I didn't have any thoughts about my appearance or what my body looked like just oh, there's water on my shoulders, I should put the towel around my shoulders, that type of thing. Next, I picked up my clothes according to my mood, and I felt like I wanted to feel comfortable and also kind of grungy or rocky or you know, so I chose a low support tank tops tight bra. And a rock t shirt isn't a rock t shirt. It's got a picture of a growling cheater on it. Anyway. Yes. And then I noticed that my breasts were lower than normal. Because I'm not you know, I'm wearing like a bra that's basically not not a bra. I just noticed that and then I thought Fuck it, I want comfort today versus putting on a higher support bra. Next, I saw my hair that was all over the place. And I felt a sense of gender dysphoria. And that was around kind of keeping my hair short and deciding to grow it out and I feel like I want to grow out my hair but then But then gender dysphoria stuff is coming up. So I put in some dry shampoo took about 20 seconds to use up my hair and then I felt better about my hair. I put on some new glasses that I got even though I'm sure I'm not sure if I like them yet because they're a different shape to normal. But I thought to myself no wear them because you need to get used to the different shape and maybe that's why you're not sure if you'd like them or not. Then so Yes, yesterday I got a delivery from Elqui I haven't ordered from eliquid for like three or four years because in Canada you have to pay you have to pay $20 shipping. Last week I'd spoke about shipping problems today. It would have been 20 us shipping so that's like 25 Plus Canadian but then they had this sale where like because I've been looking for some boots and they had some sell where they had these black boots on like for cheaper than I could have gotten them in Canada and I got some other sale things anyway. So I had an order from aliqua which contained like a co boots, jeans top. Anyway so I put on put my new jeans but on my new boots and I thought I didn't like the way the jeans looked on my stomach because they kind of like rolled down when I bent over to do the the my boots and so I adjusted my jeans felt good. I was like yeah, they look good. But on the new eliquid coat and looked in the mirror and I thought Oh you look so cool and put together that was my thought. So we went walking Dougie and I and my boots are rubbing on the back of my heel and I had a quick thought of your feet are too big. So I have size 10 feet, which often is the highest shoe size in women's shoes. I started seeing a lot more size elevens but anyway, I've always had like in my head or your feet are too big. If you had smaller feet. Men will find you more attractive. These are my like deep, dark, deep dark thoughts that you know that I rarely notice, but then I kind of will, will talk to myself about and be like, you know, what's going on here? Yeah, so my, my, my, my boots were rubbing my heel and and my first thought was your feet are too big and then I changed it to the shoes of the issue not me.

Continuing walking when I saw people looking at me, my thoughts were neutral. So when people looked at me, they're just observing another human, they're not thinking anything. They're probably thinking, you know, what's my day look like? Blah, blah, whatever. Oh, I thought that they were thinking that I look good. So whenever I saw people looking at me, I just thought, whatever. And also, thank you. Yeah, I did look good. Although they didn't say anything to me, right? I'm just interpreting that thoughts of neutral or I look good. And then the last thought that I thought about before going in with Dougie to give him his breakfast was thinking about the guy who asked me on a date last night. So there was a guy on from OKCupid, who asked me on a day, he was like, it would be my honor to take you on a date. And I was like, yes, it would be, Your Honor. So as think about thinking about that guy, he's three centimeters taller than me. So he's, I'm five, seven, so he's probably five, eight. And I was predicting that he will be surprised by my size, about how big I am. And think I'm too big. And I felt like, I think that that is going to be his reaction, but not thinking of that making is a bad thing for me. Just thinking about his experiences and thinking, Oh, well, if he is the type of guy that I think he is, because he seems very forward thinking and kind, then he'll just notice my body. And then think whatever. You know, and I did have that. Yeah, he'll think it's too big. But, you know, and so that was kind of a negative, like a well, I guess, a fear, a fear. Because often if if someone I find out someone is significantly taller, I don't tend to have that fear. And I, yeah, see, you know, the stuff coming up that I don't even, you know, you start to dig into your thoughts. And you're like, oh, and because most of these things are kind of very fleeting things. And so for me, it's not a big deal. It's not like, I'm not going to go on the date, because I'm scared that he's going to think that I'm too fat. And if he does think I'm too fat for his liking, then whatever, you know, I think, Oh, that's a shame for him that he gets to, he's losing out on the chance to, to see me and be with me, because I'm a hugger. Boom. Yeah, so basically, that was me racking my brain for the thoughts that I had. And most of it, you know, when something negative came up, it was kind of quickly squashed by my brain. And it's not like I'm here having a conversation like this, this this, it's almost like my brain is kind of going into kind of an automatic, giving myself compassion type of thing. Which is, which is nice. Whereas before, I would probably, you know, got out the shower, looked on my body and being like, Oh, my God, and picked out clothes according to how to hide my body and thought that people looking at me, were thinking that I was frightful. And, you know, we're really, really nervous about the date with this guy, blah, blah, blah. So it's, it's, it's pretty much you know, not thinking about your body. Really say if, before I think about my body, like 100 out of 100. Now, I probably think think about my body like 10. And most of that is kind of just observational. Yeah, so just like her kind of like an overview there. You know, there wasn't any, like flying unicorns or amazing things that happened, because I don't hate my body. But life is easier. Right? Life is easier. So let's move on to talking about the limitations of the concept of loving your body and I am guilty in this regard of using the phrase loving your body as kind of like a shorthand of the concept that I'm trying to get across. And the concept I'm going to try and get across is literally just what I was talking about in you know, the morning of me, which is feeling piece with your body or just not thinking about it much or just not having a big amount of tension. You know? Like, if you could say, you know, what

are the tensions in your lives? What are the things that are bothering you? My, what I think about my body would be like, not on the list. Right? So when I say, loving your body, really what I mean is just not thinking about your body that much, though, maybe I should I should stop using that phrase, because I don't want people to get confused about I don't want exactly what we're going to talk about the limitations to this is I don't want I don't want, yeah, I don't want there's literally no, this is the I don't want I want people to you know, I want to be able to communicate effectively, is what I stumbled across to that I want to be able to communicate effectively. Okay, so I don't think it's realistic to expect that you can go from go from decades of hating your body to waking up seeing yourself in the mirror and making out all your reflection. Like, I see people getting frustrated, because it's because they say oh, you know, I've read like three books, and I've listened to like podcast episodes. And, and I don't, I don't I don't love myself yet. And you know, what the heck, you know, I've done everything and, and I'm like, How long have you not like yourself? And they'll be like, you know, four decades, five decades, three decades, seven decades, you know, whatever. And so I'm like, Well, how can seven minutes of you know listening to a podcast, suddenly make you be like, Oh, my God, I'm so amazing. You know, it's not realistic. And I think you know, it's a natural thing. We're humans, we want this instant sound of satisfaction of, of having a big change. But it's more kind of like a slowly, slowly thing. And it's not going to be I've never made out of myself in the mirror. You know, I know it's shocking, but I have never made out with myself in the mirror because I don't hate myself. And the reality is kind of just a little bit more quiet. You know, I do think it's realistic for you to begin to lose that tension. That tension to not be there of constantly having to think about your body that I think that is realistic. Here's the big issue though. accepting your body does not mean that the world will not still be fat phobic. Doesn't matter what you think about your body, the world is still going to be fat phobic. And you will not experience less marginalization because you think that your body's Okay. In fact, I feel like it can expose you to more bullshit because now you're more educated on what weight stigma is, you begin to notice it everywhere. And I feel like I've been more exposed since learning about this stuff. And sometimes I think I wish I could go back to the, quote, good days where I didn't pick up on this stuff. I think I mean, it's an inevitable as we all learn and grow right there, we'll start to see things that we couldn't see before. And so in some ways, especially as a fat activist, especially as someone who's doing this for their job, I am exposed more to to marginalization. And if you're doing this work in your life, then you are probably going to be exposed to more marginalization, because you're probably going to start talking to your friends and family about it. And you're gonna come up come up a grant against them saying all sorts of bullshit probably. And wherever that'd be, you know, friends or family or people on the internet, or old high school friends, or whatever it is. Whereas before it's, like, safer to just be a fat person who's dieting, you know, a fat person who is who knows, quotes, you know, knows they're a bad fat person and they need to lose weight. Sometimes that's just a lot safer. So coming out as a fat person saying, I'm fat, and, you know, this is me, that can be really scary. Very, very difficult and not possible for a lot of people. So the difference is, though, that the difference now that I'm not hating myself is that I tend to not internalize fat phobia. Versus before I would think, yeah, you're right. You know, when, when the doctor was like, you need to lose weight because you've got an ear infection or you know, whatever. And I would be like, yes, and I'd soak all of that in whereas now

I feel like I have a mirror in the middle of my chest. And that shame that the world is trying to direct towards me, is reflected back at them where it belongs. Because they're, you know, that shame, you know that shame and hatred of fatphobia it's been directed to fat people. And before I would just, you know, soak it in like a sunbeam and be like, yes, you're absolutely right, I am a piece of shit because I'm fat. Now, not so much. And of course, some of it slips by not, not all of it is hitting that mirror on my chest. Some of it is soaking into my skin. And I'm, you know, I'm still absorbing that stuff. But there is that mirror protection where I say, you know, I'm like, I don't deserve this. I don't because I'm worthy, no matter my body size. So, I do think it's incredibly important to try and shift the way that you view yourself. If it's something that's important for you, if it's something that's very distressing for you in your life, if you think about it a lot. And I do think it's possible to make those changes to the way that you view fatness in regards to education around what fatness means, but I don't think that doing that is going to change the experience of existing in a fat phobic world, or that much, but it will make it a little easier. You know? In some ways, some ways, in some ways, because then exactly like what I just said, you start noticing it everywhere. And then you'll be like for fuck sake, why? I want to go back to where I didn't know is that every motherfucker, every boundary is that Vivek and indict culture and all that type of bullshit. Yeah, so fun times, fun times, fun times. But here's an example. Here's an example. Okay, so let's let's think of an example is you are a bridesmaid or a non gendered. What would that be? So we've got bridesmaid, we've got groomsmen wedding party, you're part of the wedding party, at your sister's wedding, for example. So you'll go shopping, and go to a dress shop to find, you know, dress, dress, dress clothes for all of the wedding party, and the shop doesn't carry your size. So if you agree with your art with the idea that your body is wrong, and that fatness is bad, then in that situation, you're probably going to feel a total shame, embarrassment. I personally would want to move into secrecy and be like, oh, yeah, no, it's, yeah, the dress is fitting, I just, I just don't want to come out and show you and then I do, you know, maybe go and find someone that could alter it to make it bigger, or, you know, that's what I would probably do is I'd like secrecy and shame for this terrible thing that I had done by having this bad body, it would be a huge blow, right? It would be it'll be kind of like a core memory, potentially. So if you've been working on adopting more self compassion, then you would probably still feel frustrated and disappointed and sad. Perhaps some of those other emotions I mentioned before, but maybe not to the same degree, you would be able to see the injustice of the situation and feel angry that the store doesn't carry clothes for more human beings. Versus being like, Oh, I'm, I'm to blame. It's my fault. You'll be able to hold that mirror up and direct the shame where it should be, which is the fat phobic world. Right. So, you know, it can it can help a lot. But then you get in, you know, in that situation to be like, fuckin angry and like, Why did my sister not know that this store doesn't carry my size and learned it? But you know, I think I'd rather I would rather be angry and frustrated at these situations versus having shame eat me up from the inside. That's my, my personal preference. Yeah, because shame isn't my favorite is not my favorite, you know?

Okay, so working on self acceptance and self compassion doesn't shop stop shit situations from happening, but it can make it easier to navigate. Also, I think you're more likely to engage in fat activism, which will help change the world if you truly believe that your body is worthy and deserving of respect and that type of stuff. The more fat people who don't agree with the assessment that they should disappear, the better the world is, you know? So I think it's not that we need the world to be filled with people who were like, oh my god, I'm the swaggins sex machine. Oh, Everybody look at me, which is not what body love really is. I think body love is more quiet and it's more accepting. And it's more tender. It's more. Yeah, loving and that type of thing, which and I think if we had, if we all had more self compassion, I think lots of different things would be better in the world is my opinion. So I want to talk about another limitation, which is accepting a body that is disabled or chronically ill is complicated. And saying, just love yourself is not useful advice when your body is not doing the things that you want it to do. If your body is let you down, then telling someone to have a cheery disposition around their body is gaslighting them. And I actually go in depth on this, this talking about you know, disability and chronic illness, and having a fat body in Episode 93. To get to Episode 93. Quickly, you can go to first fatty.com Ford slash 093. And to listen to the episode if you if you want to know more about that. Yes, so the other issue with the concept of body love is toxic positivity or toxic body positivity. So Wikipedia says what toxic public positivity is, is a dysfunctional approach to emotional management that happens when people do not fully acknowledge negative emotions, particularly anger, and sadness. If we don't allow ourselves to feel mad and angry, and all the other incredible emotions that we can feel, then we are just expecting ourselves to not be human. And you're not a bad person, or failed fats liberationist If you don't like your body, you know. And it's important to explore that, you know, if your body is let you down, if your body has, if you're fed up, then it's important to explore that versus being you know, me, me this morning being like, ah, you know, these hives, they're itchy, and they're annoying, and I don't like it. And when instead of you know brushing brushing over with oh, look, you've got skin, you're lucky that you're alive. Yes, that's true. I'm lucky that I'm alive. And I've got skin in that editor. But also holding space for that sucks. That sucks. I shouldn't have to be dealing with this new health condition. On top of all the other ones that I have. It's fucking annoying, you know. And so exploring that is also important. And not having gratitude for your body, I think as well is important. If you're not feeling it, sometimes you do feel it right. But not forcing yourself to have gratitude for something that you don't have gratitude for. Right? Yeah, so the charm of just love yourself can come across as super problematic for many people. And the concept that that looks like thinking that your body is super, super attractive, still relies on what your body looks like and is not just thinking about yourself. So just love yourself can come across as your beautiful, embrace the idea that you're beautiful. Well, how about we embrace the idea that it doesn't matter if you are beautiful or not? You know, you still you still are a worthy human being. And so it's still focusing on looks of your you're wrong in the way that you perceive your beauty.

You know, what if what if you do just want to be like, You know what, I'm fucking ugly. I'm ugly as shit, but I still am worthy and deserve love and compassion, all of the good stuff that beautiful people get, you know. And often the concept of loving yourself comes from people who are conventionally attractive, so thin, young, able bodied, cisgender people. And they'll say things like, I've learned to love myself, so you can too and it's kind of like, of course you fucking did. Everyone agrees with the assessment that your body is beautiful. And this is something this is something that I'm sure juggling with I'm struggling with having a lack of patience for people who are clearly straight size and attractive, saying I'm ugly, I'm ugly. And I understand that I understand that something, you know, their, their perception of their body is, is it's not based on in reality, right. And at the moment, I'm kind of struggling with that, almost like I want it to be. I want it to them to have more self awareness to say, I'm struggling with the way my body looks, even though I know that I have a normative conventionally attractive body, you know, is that that's where I want people. That's where I want us to be because I don't think it's appropriate, especially for someone if they're saying it to a fat person, especially someone who's not paid to help them with with this. Then that's off how many fat people have got the story of a thin, conventionally attractive friend being like, I'm so fat and ugly, and the fat person having to comfort them and be like, No, you're not fat. No, you're beautiful. That's so fucking offensive to the fat people. Because, clearly, Hello, you are not your you, the world heralds your body. So having that self awareness of I'm struggling with seeing the reality of what I look like right now. I feel like I'm not attractive. But I know, theoretically, that I am because I'm thin. I'm white. I'm, I'm young. I'm able bodied. I'm, you know, conventionally attractive, according to all of these systems of oppression. I think that's what we where we need to be. That's where we need to be. Yeah. And I want to I want it to be taboo for conventionally attractive people to seek reassurance from fat and ugly people. And people who are not seen as having the body type that society worships, you know, like, oh, shit, you didn't just go and complain about being unattractive to someone who, whose body is told that they're unattractive like that? That ain't cool. I don't think that's cool. That's not cool anymore. Is it? It's not cool anymore. No. Sorry. If you can hear in the background, there is a truck right outside my window loading pallet loading pallets. I hoped that they might be done soon, but apparently there's about 15 million pallets that need to be thrown onto the back of his truck. So I'm sorry if that's really annoying to hear. And maybe you can't even hear it. Who knows? But yeah, no. Okay. So, toxic body positivity also negates to recognize the complex issues that each individual is faced with is way easier for me to accept myself because I'm white. I don't have to live in a world where I'm subjected to violence and murder, everything else that comes with racism, due to the lack of melanin I have, I don't have to be reminded every day that the world isn't accessible for me because I'm not in a wheelchair, I don't have to feel the pain of being rejected from job opportunities due to not due to looking to trans, etc, etc, etc. So it's easier for me and folks like me who have less marginalized identities to scream, love yourself from the top of you know, from rooftops? Well, because I have less instances in my life where the world is like, You're not welcome. We want you to die.

And it's kind of like, well, yeah, I'll love myself when when people stop trying to murder me. You know, if you have different marginalization, and invisible wasn't, marginalization is you know, like, me being you know, I'm trans non binary, but walking down the street, people perceive me as a woman, you know? And yeah, like, maybe when I had a shaved head, people might be like, Okay, maybe something's going on. But people who are more visibly trans are going to have different experiences than I would have as being trans non binary, right? So, it is easier for me to make that change. Because, you know, say if I walk out and people are like, You're fat, you're horrible. I don't have all these other things because I'm white, you know, and all of the other privileges that I hold, also using toxic positive As a stick to beat yourself with, like you're failing because you don't love yourself in a world that tells us our bodies are wrong 365 days a year, we have a constant battle to contend with. And a lot of times those other forces will win out. So it's not like you're failing because you're not, you know, you don't feel like Kim Kardashian when you wake up. I mean, Kim Kardashian probably doesn't even feel like Kim Kardashian, when she wakes up, you know, just surviving Holy shit, especially now, just surviving, is incredible. And anything else on top is just remarkable and beautiful, and all those types of things. And so I really don't want people to be, you know, using body love as a, oh, I failed at something else, you know? No, you know, nerdy nerdy cat. So let's wrap it up the limitations of body love. So it's super easy for thin white young body positive influence or to declare love your body, I did. But we are missing some really important nuance, with the idea of body love being the answer to happiness and easy for people to obtain. So we need to be clear that when we talk about body love, what many people mean, is just not thinking about their body, it's, it's more body neutrality. And the flippant use of body love can set up unrealistic standards. The concept of body love can also be used as a stick to beat yourself with the idea that you're failing because you're not spending 12 hours a day with love heart, eyes, staring at a mirror, looking at your reflection, because that's not realistic, right? Even people who don't hate their body, they're just not thinking about it. And if you're not at that place, and you are in a kind of struggling with really, really not liking your body or Hating Your Body, it doesn't mean you failed, it doesn't mean that you're bad fats liberationist It's just what it is. And it's to be expected. And if you do accept your body, that does not mean the world will suddenly stop treating you like shit. If you're fat, especially if you have other marginalized identities, it doesn't mean that it might be easier for you to navigate those situations because you can be able to direct that shame. outwards back to the perpetrator, or systems of oppression, versus agreeing with fat phobic beliefs and agitations. But not always, though, body acceptance doesn't mean that you're immune from shame, and stigma. The cry of just love yourself, also denies the very real lived realities of those who are disabled, or have chronic conditions, people of color, trans people, queer folks, etc, who are fat, who not only have to deal with the world telling them that their fat body is bad, but they also have to deal with the violence and murder due to other modernisations that they hold. So the idea of body love or the agitation to love your body can ring hollow, and be really problematic for many people because of that. So what are you thinking? What do you say? What are you thinking? What's your brain thinking? Hey, and thank you to anyone who donates to the podcast. I really appreciate it.

I'll get random Pay Pal notifications with a nice little messages from people. And that's written that really brightens my days because sometimes I think, oh, is anyone is anyone listening? My mom doesn't even listen now rude. And of course, people listen, right? I don't actually look at the stats, because my VA uploads things. So you know. But I know people listen, I know. I know people do. Listen, he imagined if I hadn't looked at the standard looked at the stats in a good few months. And I went and looked and it was like, oh, turns out no one's listening anymore. Oh. Imagine No, there's not it's not true. It's not true, because people will send me paid to have a bow. So someone's visiting. So thank you for thank you for those. If you ever have a question that you want me to answer on the show, please send me a message go to the podcast page facebook.com forward slash podcast or the episode number which is 118. And there'll be a button right there to submit a question. And I could answer on the show. Yeah, that's All right, well have a wonderful rest of your day. I hope you are having a fierce fatty day and we'll see you in the next episode. See you in a while alligator Good boy thanks for the listening to the episode and if you feel ready to get serious about this work and want to know when the doors open to fears fattier Academy which is my signature program, where I teach all about how to overcome your fat phobic beliefs and learn to love your fat body, then go to first party.com forward slash waitlist again that is phase fatty.com. Forward slash waitlist to get your name on the waitlist. For when first party Academy my signature program opens.

EP117 Transcript

Welcome to the Fierce Fatty Podcast. I'm your host, Victoria Welsby, and this is episode 117. Today, we're talking about: Why is the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics prescribing disordered eating for fat clients?

I'm Victoria Welsby, TEDx speaker, best-selling author, and fat activist. I have transformed my life from hating my body with desperately low self-esteem to being a courageous and confident fierce fatty who loves every inch of this jelly. Society teaches us living in a fat body is bad. But what if we spent less time, money, and energy on the pursuit of thinness and instead focused on the things that actually matter? Like if pineapple on pizza should be outlawed? Or if the mullet was the greatest haircut of the 20th century? So how do you stop negative beliefs about your fat body controlling your life? It's the Fierce Fatty podcast. Let's begin.

Hello, welcome to this episode of fierce fatty so glad that you're here to hang out with me. Oh, look at that rhyming. Rhyming. I'm so good. Today Oh my goodness. I'm so cute. If you're just listening in audio. I've got my hair too little bunches. Got some pink lipstick on and my gray round glasses. And my new jumper that says fat icon. Love it. Some of what me it is a present. Let me see fat icon. Where is it from? And I get dressed? Yeah. And I get dressed. So if you're in the States, you can get it. You can get it. Or you can get it in Canada too. I'm in Canada, obviously. But here's the thing. Here's the thing. It's in US dollars and then when it ships they put on a fucking handling fee not and I get dressed. But the the UPS fucking up. So the the jumper is 4990 or 50 bucks. And then best shipping handling, which I paid on the other end. So then so then shipping is 20 bucks. And then shipping that I had to pay not because of the company because of UPS UPS was 47 Seven, how much no 4178 4178? Rude. Rude. Rude. So yeah, you can order it if you're in Canada, but it's gonna cost you twice as much twice as much as it should, unfortunately. So if you're in the US enjoy it. Jealous. Well, I'm not jealous. I've done it, you know, but you know, I'm feeling for the other people in the rest of the world who don't want to spend gajillion dollars on handling to UPS fucking suck my tits. Yes, but anyway, the reason why I'm saying that is because I wanted to share that. When I woke up, I didn't feel good in my body. I thought you know what, my hair looks a bit shit. I need to I need to go to the hairdresser's. And I just wasn't. I was just like, Yeah, not a lot. But I love it when it comes up. I love it when it comes up. Because then I can tell you about it and then tell you about what I'm doing to make myself feel better. And so I put my hair in some these these bunches and put on some put on this new jumper. But some lippy, put on some eyeliner. And then I'm like, oh, turns out but I didn't suddenly become really ugly in a day. Just the perception that I have of my body has changed for whatever reason. And so then I'm like, Okay, what could have triggered me to not feel as great. It could be that my head is looking a little bit wonky. Or it could be that I had a date. I had a date, the last last night the night before? Not before night before I think we'll be fine. I'll give it like a five out of 10 Nothing bad. Nothing great. But I had said to the guy how do you feel about dating Someone who's fat. And he said, I've never dated anyone, all of my past partners have been, quote, normal size. And he said he put it in quotations normal size because he didn't know what the right word was. So, you know, that's fine. As I said, I told him I went straight size. But it made me feel unsafe to be with him. In regards to He wasn't like, oh, he just happens to be the I've ended up with people who are straight sighs and but of course, I see the beauty in all different types of bodies. That's why I'm here because you are a fucking smack show, obviously. Which is what my brain says, right? My brain is like, well, if you have, well, you know, if you're here, then you must find me attractive. But he was like, You know what? Yeah, I'm really you have really nice green eyes. And that's what attracted me to you. And it was like, Oh, the eye complement the eyes. Same as a smile.

You have such a beautiful face. And he wasn't outwardly saying, you know, despite your body, you've got nice eyes. You know, he, he wasn't saying that, but it kind of just made me feel unsafe, you know, and safe in regards to am I going to hook up with this guy? That was my plan. Motherfucker Robbie, I don't have I haven't had sex in two years. So I'm Come on. Give me some do. Yeah, so I just I just thought, you know, am I gonna give him the pleasure of seeing my gorgeous fat body? Because it would be his pleasure for him to not fully, you know, to educate him. When he's not like who? Yeah, I mean, you're repacking gray. Because I am really fucking great. You're not I mean, so. Yeah. It was a no from me. There we go, there we go. There we go. The next, you know, two days after the date, waking up not feeling as good about myself. So, you know, our brains are not walking around in a vacuum. We are influenced. And even someone like me who does this for a living, I too have a human brain that is influenced. And, you know, I want to be loved and worshiped and all that type of stuff. And so, when someone is not worshiping Me, they're wrong. They should be. They're not worshiping Me, then, you know, it's obviously triggered me, which is interesting. So, so it's just gonna be information and now I can just get myself some nice self care. And it's all good. And that whole process of me thinking about that took like, I don't know, 90 seconds. And it makes it kind of takes me out of the belief that yeah, I'm not I'm not good enough. Whatever we know, I was believing into Oh, there's a part of Vinnie that is feeling like they're not good enough. And it was triggered because you know, this guy said this or that or whatever. And so what can I adult self Vini do to support that part of me that is triggered so anyway, little story for you. But I wanted to do this episode. I wanted to do this episode. Last week. I had I had so much I had so much to talk about what would pause last week's episode. Oh, yeah, the fucking we go V drug bullshit. And then this bullshit happened as well the same week. And so I decided to do the the weego V thing first because I was steaming mad about it. And now I'm like, steaming mad about this. And so we're talking about the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics which is the if you're not familiar with who they are. Wikipedia tells us that it is a 501 C trade association in the United States. I don't know what that means. What a 501 C probably something like for profit or something who knows? Anyway, with over 112,000 members, the association claims to be the largest organization of food and nutrition professionals, comprising many registered dietitian nutritionists are the NS nutrition and dietetic technicians registered and the T RS and other dietetics professionals. So that's who they are. So they're kind of like a Yeah, association, a group you're like, oh, yeah, I'm a member of and so they release guidelines. These other bloggers have a release guidelines on how to deal with fatties. Okay, they did a they did a review of this The research and they released these guidelines which surprise fuckin surprise, something that's pulled out of 1993 and is really fat phobic. They release them during National Eating Disorder Awareness Week, and during Black History Month. I mean, how fucked up is that. And the reason why that's super fucked up, in case that's not really clear is that fatphobia weight stigma disproportionately affects people, black people, people of color, and people who are struggling with eating disorders, especially those who are fat. So, I mean, they just like go for the home run, combine was really stick it to them as that's, you know, increase the stigma that black fat people face.

And those with disordered eating or eating disorders, ready to give it to them girls come on, let's just increase the stigma is what they thought was a great idea. So we do have a little bit of power here to make some change, because they've opened the, their, their opinion piece to a survey that is available to submit until March 25. Links for everything I'm talking about is going to be in the show notes first it.com, forward slash 117. And so you can go on there, there's gonna be a link straight to the survey monkey thing, it's very easy. You can by the way, you can submit more than once. So you don't need to put your in your email or anything. And so it just says Are these are these things? Are these recommendations helpful? Blah, blah, blah. So there's like five, yes, no questions. And so the answers are? No, no, no, no. Yes. The final one is a yes. And then the rest of them of the nose. And then there's a little space box there to say, what do you think? And then you can tell them what you think? And then there's like, Who are you kind of thing? Like, are you a client, a member of the public blah, blah, anyway, and that's it. So it takes like, depending how much you put in the textbox, I will take probably about a minute. So if you want to if you feel compelled, the link is going to be in the show notes. First party.com, forward slash 117. And look for the survey monkey link, I'll make sure that it's the one of the first links up there. So let's go into what they recommended. And see if because they've done this review of evidence, right? See if what's going on here. Because you know, when when a body in association and authority comes out with recommendations, people listen. And so it's important that we understand exactly what they're saying what they're recommending, and if there is any holes in their arguments, to try and get us to be critical thinkers and and, and not be scared to say, Oh, well, yeah, this governing body or you know, and the you know, that's what, that's what they called the acronym and is recommending this. So maybe I'm maybe I'm silly for believing in health, every size, maybe I'm ridiculous for not being on a diet because this governing body has looked at the research research. And they're saying this. One thing to remember is that individuals, organizations are not free from weight bias themselves. Right? And so that's always going to be informing what, what's put out into the world. But let's let's get into it, let's get into it. The first thing I want to read is, as does response and so, Aster is the Association for Size diversity and health and Aster are the other folks that hold the register. Is it trademark, you know, the thing that isn't our you know, yeah, register your trademark of Health at Every Size. The reason why you we see it with a little r as a registered trademark is because as a s d h, have protected it so that it cannot be used nefariously because you know, motherfuckers are gonna be up here being like health, every size diet, how about every size, how to lose weight. And so because of that protection that as the hold as a group as a community, it's not one member that holds that it's basically the fat community that holds that, that trademark, they've protected health every size from that bullshitter II that intuitive eating has seen right? Intuitive Eating is not trademarked and as we see into to eating diets and to to Intuitive Eating lose 75 pounds in 12 minutes with intuitive eating all that type of non science anyway okay so as the has written a letter because the so a and a nd has said in the recommendations basically let me tell you what they've said trigger warning I'm going to be talking about calories, amount of calories that they recommend.

So if that doesn't feel good, skip ahead one minute. So they have recommended that fat clients need to be put on a 1200 to 1500 calorie diet a day and they need to not follow Health at Every Size or a non diet approach. Okay, so they're saying so not only are they saying eat nothing, but don't you be following health every size Don't be engaging in health promoting activities and behaviors because what they think health every size is because they did tons of research. They think Health at Every Size is a way to lose weight. So they say don't do health every size because you won't lose weight. What would you fucking yes oh my goodness. It's like saying don't use your car to drive across a lake in the water because the car will sink? Well Yeah, no shit. That's why you use a fucking bow. You know not that's not what car use a car a road. You know, it's just anyway, this is what this is what as the says recently and completed a review of health every size interventions as part of the adult weight management guideline that included many fat phobic and weight biased recommendation recommendations. One of the proposed recommendations is for adults who are Oh words. It is suggested that audience or international equivalent not use health every size, or non diet approach to improve BMI and other cardio metabolic outcomes or quality of life. We want to start by acknowledging the trauma caused by and being reactivated by Ann's actions, we see the frustration if not only the continued, of not only the continued violence of recommendations such as these against fat people, but the violence of attempting to discredit haze, which to many of us represents not only a safe path to health and healthcare, but a community where fat people are celebrated the action of and are not surprising dietetics the concept of health and the system of healthcare were built on and continue to thrive on fat phobic or racist ableist eugenicist and violent beliefs, it is doubly upsetting that their proposal comes during Black History Month, a time when the racist roots of fatphobia should be centered rather than further promoting ideas that most harm fat black people. White supremacy plays a key role in the development of guidelines such as these as well as in our response to the recommendations. We see it in the way we value the written word, especially when it includes copious citations and rubrics and people with an alphabet of credentials behind their names. So the first bit of that paragraph, it links up so white supremacy is underlined it links to a really nice, like five pages of five pages on it's like nine pages. Link of information on white supremacy culture. Really interesting. Again, I'm going to make sure it's in the show notes. But there there's this concept of white supremacy culture, we are so steeped in it, but there are certain things that we it's just built into our society that come from white supremacist idea ideas, and this goes into into that, but let me just read out like a few bullet points of I'll read out the top the what they are, it's just you know, it's like nine of them. So you know, so perfectionism, sense of urgency, defensiveness, quantity over quality, worship of the written word. Only one right way. paternalism either or Thinking, Power hoarding. Fear of open conflict, individualism. I'm the only one. Progress is bigger, more objectivity right together. Comfort. Okay, so underneath, all of those are bullet points and then antidotes to those things, just like a side note. And so if you're, if you're thinking like why are they talking about how the written word and how responding with a written word and how their guidelines with all of the links and blah, blah, blah, is is steeped in white supremacy. That's why.

Okay, so continuing, none of this makes their guideline, the truth, we see it in the binary thinking that one must be right and the other must be wrong, that for their adult weight management guidelines to remain correct, they must tear down any ideas that say otherwise. We see it in the urgency to respond immediately we see in the white martyr and white savior responses both at and and in our communities. We see it in the power hoarding, because because fat people were not at the table black. Indeed, indigenous and other people of color were underrepresented at the table, and the Asda and haze community was not at the table. This underscores a reality of our work. While we work to make health care less harmful in the now we ultimately cannot reform a system whose core and foundation is white supremacy. The review conducted by the end adult weight management team was limited in many ways, the first and most important of which was conducting an AMA Anana analysis on Hayes as an intervention for adult weight management. As many of you reading this will likely already know the Health at Every Size principles reflect the research that weight does not need to be quote managed, that pursuit of weight loss is not effective in making fat people thin nor is a minimal amount of weight loss, weight loss by most to attempt to do so sustainable over the long term, blah, blah, blah and more but that of the five outcomes they analyze that make up their recommendation, the three of them are anti antithetical to health, every size principles, lower BMI, percent weight loss and smaller waist circumference. For the other two outcomes, blood pressure and quality of life, only two articles each were included to draw their conclusions. Interestingly, only studies specifically using the term quality of life were included other studies which included similar measures, but use terms like psychological distress were not included in the team's analysis for quality of life. Yeah, because, you know, psychological distress is what a lot of people experience on a diet. So, yeah, that's important to look at. Another major limitation of their analysis was that Haze is a singular intervention, rather than an approach to health that reflects existing research, most of most of which does not explicitly explicitly name Health at Every Size. Any intervention that improves health markers, regardless of weight is part of the Hayes toolkit. So just a little thing in there just to make sure that we understand that is that not everyone? References health, every size in their research, not everyone is aware of it. But we will have research that says, hey, if you if you lower your stress, your health is improved. If you are no go fishing twice a week, your stress levels are improved, and therefore your health is improved. So those types of studies are not going to be linked to health every size. But it is part of the Health at Every Size paradigm, right? Because it's not saying you need to lose weight to be healthy. It's it's saying that health is a very complicated topic, and there's lots of different ways to be healthy. Okay. And, you know, outside of losing weight, people of all sizes have the same outcomes, right? So any intervention that improves health markers, regardless of weight is part of the Hayes toolkit, the search was limited to papers, naming haze or non die in the intervention, along with other inclusion criteria, such as only including programs overseen by dieticians, and only including studies that were limited to fat people, which is problematic, right? You know, we're only going to let this study count. If it's overseen by dieticians. Why, why, why is why why, why.

And only looking at Fat people well, you know, only looking at Fat people, we can't say, oh, yeah, let's let you know, we need to look at a wide variety of sizes of people to see how you know fat people do compared to to straight size people how this gender compares to that gender, how you know, all of these different variables and so they're saying no, only Fat people? Well, we can't see if that intervention worked for straight size people, and also worked equally well for fat people, you know. Okay, so the result of their search choices, including the mischaracterization of health, every size led to the identification of seven total studies included in their review. So what they did was they looked for Health at Every Size as a tool to help people lose weight, how much evidence are we going to find to say that how for every size is going to help people lose weight? No one says, Oh, my God. Okay, so despite lacking sufficient evidence to make claims about hey, they decided to write a recommendation that Hays interventions not be used, though none of the study showed harm, and none of the reported health outcomes measured worsened measures worsened during haze interventions. For example, one of the papers included was designed to measure heart rate recovery time, their results showed significant improvements in this measure in the haze group compared to the control group. This paper was only used in the analysis for BMI as an outcome by the team. Other studies showed improvements in dietary quality LDL cholesterol and binge eating, these outcomes were not evaluated. And these results were not considered in making the proposed guideline statements. Events like these remind us why the community elected to trademark Health at Every Size and haze. And why the community chose to have a community led organization hold the trademark, white supremacy and fatphobia will continue to rise up to discredit our work. haze was not created by any one individual and continues to evolve with our community.

Likewise, we collectively protect it against efforts like this by banding together by remembering that their attempts cannot take away what we have built as trauma inducing and violence as they are we as the proud that the organization has come so far to be able to respond quickly and thoughtfully to events such as these. And we're even more proud to return to our work of building a new world with liberation for all at the center. Yeah, so loved that loved that loved that. And others have gone in even deeper to the particular the particular recommendations and the evidence I looked at now, it's very interesting that if you want to see the evidence that they be looked at, so if you want links to what they looked at, you have to pay them for it. Of course, which again, hello, white supremacy, hello gatekeeping is just and it's not like, they didn't pay for these studies, right? They're just like, hey, here's a list of here's a list of the links that we here's a list of the studies that we looked at. Right? So it doesn't cost them anything to say, Yeah, we looked at study A B C, D is behind a paywall. Of course, of course, and somebody makes it harder, it makes it harder for the average person, the average dietitian who's not that familiar with this, if not, has not seen the backlash to to go in and be like, oh, I want to know, I want to go in and have a look and see, you know, getting it a little deeper. It's behind a paywall, they'll probably just lay out whatever, you know, I would I'd be like, Wow, whatever, you know, they know what they're talking about. They've done the research, therefore, I can just you know, I'll just don't just take it for face value. I know that Haze is bad. I know that the non diet approach is bad. Which Yeah, gets on my floppy terms. So let's have a look at going in a little bit deeper as the problems in here and turning it over to Reagan Chasteen and Reagan's newish I guess in the last few months, Regan has got a substack newsletter thing. So basically you subscribe, so I paid like 50 bucks for the year to get twice, three thrice weekly emails from Reagan, where Reagan is writing these fucking amazing pieces, I think yeah, so you can get them for free. Yeah, you can because I'm linking to this thing.

So I don't think you don't have to pay but if you want to, you can and you can pay like a monthly thing, which is probably just a few bucks, right? 50 bucks for the year. So consider doing that. I'll link to it in the show notes. But the what I'm going to pull quotes from I'm not gonna read the whole thing, which is a Reagan, the title is, is the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics choosing weight stigma over science question mark? Answer. Yes, that's me adding that, yes as the answer. But some key points here that we're going to look at. So headline of this paragraph is, so here's the issue. So here's the issues that Reagan is pointing out. So first is body size as pathology. So, quoting first they are adopting the concept that simply existing in a higher weight body, regardless of actual health status is a pathology to be solved by weight loss, including using first person language, which has been championed by those who sell dangerous and expensive weight loss myth, methodologies make me wonder if they are in some way aligned with those interests, by the way. So Reagan has I've spoken about this on the on the blog before and Reagan has spoken about this. The person first language, which originally came from the disability community, and is very controversial in that community. A lot of people say they like it, a lot of people say that they really don't like it. And it's it's super stigmatizing. And so person first language is saying someone with fatness versus saying a fat person. And the reason why the critiques on on that is that it's, it's again, making it seem like fatness is such a such horrible thing that we, we don't want to say they are fat, you know, like we don't have to say, person with brown hair. Because we're not offended, we're not worried about offending someone, because they have brown hair. Because we don't think that brown hair is a bad thing. Having a fat body isn't a bad thing. And so we don't need to be using first person first language or like it is and it's kind of like their same with euphemisms. And but even more so with the Oh words, which has even more layers of shit on top of it. So anyway, just a little sideline up like my commentary on these on these articles. They recommend that all higher weight people be given traditional weight loss interventions in order to quote improve BMI percent weight loss, waist circumference, blood pressure and quality of life. Note that three of their five goals focus on body size and not health.

One way to entrench yourself in the weight loss paradigm is to make body size manipulation rather than actual health, the goal of the intervention they've tripled down on this here. I don't believe that weight loss is shown to be ethical evidence based intervention to low to lower blood pressure. But we'll get into that in a moment. Suggesting body size manipulation is as a way to improve quality of life life suggests that people who experience weight stigma should just change themselves to suit their oppressors as a queer person who came out in the mid 90s. This has echoes to me of the ways that so called Conversion therapy, or suggested just solve homophobia for queer people by making a straight. Since weight loss fails the vast majority of the time, this pins their higher weight clients hopes of a better life on that intervention that almost never works, and an industry that blames his victims for the interventions, failures. And so she continues there. Another one of the titles is weight loss as an ethical evidence based intervention. And that's one of the problems we've spoken about this many times on the show how it's not an evidence, evidence based intervention. So I won't go into that. But the next point is very small amounts of weight loss, create, quote, health benefits. And so that's what they're saying. And it's saying that if you lose a little bit of weight, you are going to see health benefits. And this is what Reagan says. Their guidelines utilize a claim created not through clinical trials, but through attrition due to these abject failure of weight loss interventions, that three to 5% weight loss can result in cardio metabolic health improvements. So in the case of a 200 pound person, we are talking about only six to 10 pounds.

Continuing guidelines, specifically against weight neutral care, so let me just like wrap up that last one actually, do we really think that losing six to 10 pounds is going to result in quote, health benefits? I mean, where's the evidence? You know, you're gonna lose six pounds and then be like, yeah. No, you know, that's not gonna happen. And also like, just to recognize that some of the things that people do To lose weight, like maybe changing in the moving their body, diversifying what they and things like that could be helpful towards changing health outcomes. Marginally. But, you know, just a side note there. Okay, so guidelines specifically against weight neutral care. So that's one of the problems. The first thing to notice is that by creating outcome goals based on size slash BMI, rather than actual health, they are trying to discredit weight neutral interventions on the basis that they don't create weight change. This is a common trick of the weight loss industry and the research they fund. If you make weight loss, a target outcome, then you discredit weight neutral interventions from the start. If you make health improvements, the desired outcomes, then weight neutral interventions are shown to provide great benefits with less harm, it's helpful to recognize this trick that is used to continue to advance a weight loss paradigm by putting the focus on size instead of actual health. Also, by a new naming haze and anti diet, they have ignored the more general category of weight neutral interventions. That's exactly what as I was saying is that you know, we've got this kind of the official term, the term that they've they've trademarked but then there are weight neutral interventions, which fall under the umbrella of it, but they don't have that name, health every size.

So they're just ignoring anything, which is weight neutral, right? So Reagan ends with broader questions, given the fact that and is so blatantly not just ignoring research around the failure rate and potential harm of the proposed interventions. But in fact, actually attacking the evidence based weight neutral paradigm, I think we need to be asking some serious overall questions about these guidelines. And the and one, are the people creating these guidelines ignorant of the research? Or are they unable to understand it? Or do they know about it and understand it, but are going against it on purpose? If the former why are they in charge of writing proposed guidelines? If the latter, why two? Is this profit driven? Are the people driving these recommendations financially invested in the weight loss paradigm? Are their funders? Is this about their pharmaceutical ties are some critical mass of their members so invested in selling weight loss that they are pressuring the organization to create guidelines that go against the science? Three? Are these decisions political, the and does significant lobbying and has put out numerous papers supporting the weight loss paradigm, they are ignoring the evidence and doubling down in order to avoid having to say that they've been wrong? Are they ignoring the evidence and having to say that they've been wrong for is their goal to avoid competition with those dieticians who are working from an evidence based weight neutral perspective by threatening the work and careers of dietitians who won't swear fealty to the weight loss paradigm. So that is Regan Chasteen. And again, links to everything in the show notes. And I want to share one one last thing if you say an Instagram post from softening dot nutrition, which points out that the evidence Oh God, let me just read this. Okay, so this is from softening nutrition.

And it's a multi slide, Instagram post. The Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics evidence analysis library EAL practice guidelines for treating individuals in larger bodies are stigmatizing oppressive and harmful and indirect opposition to providing passionate inclusive equitable care for all folks. Okay, so AMD and then we've got another acronym here, here EA L. So the AMD have added this to the evidence analysis library. Okay, so EAL, that's what that is. Let me go to the next slide. The E L claims to be a quote synthesis of the best, most relevant nutritional research on important dietetic practice questions. Okay, and then there's some other words here and we go here to slide five. That's their recommendation on how much calories someone should be consuming is the same energy needs of a two to three year old toddler and will likely result in draught stick under feeding of any adult body. So not only is this unsustainable, but it's also wildly unethical as it prescribed restricted disordered eating patterns, defaults in already stigmatized bodies, putting them at even higher risk for developing an eating disorder. And here's the thing that I really want to share here. Okay. Statement 4.6 recommends that registered dieticians do not use health every size or non diet approach to quote improve BMI, blah, blah, blah. So it says full stop. Note, the grading of the recommendation listed here for this statement is to D, as outlined in the beginning of their guideline, two. So there's one and two, two equals weak strength of recommendation, and D. So you have ABCD, very low strength of evidence, basically, the least evidence based guideline grading possible. So they're saying we're making these recommendations, but the strength of the evidence we're providing is very weak. It's like, they've given themselves an F, in brackets, F. But you know, the average person looking at this is they're not gonna, they're gonna see that at the end of the sentence that says brackets 2d, you're gonna be like, Oh, okay, 2d is like that's the link to a reference. That's like, for some note at the bottom, you're not going to be like, okay, to D. What does that mean? I'm going to look it up, I'm going to go and have a look, oh, two means this D means that you just don't look at that stuff. Right? Yeah, so it's just it's kind of funny. It's kind of funny. It's not, you know, but it's a you know, it's like they tell on themselves, right? They tell on themselves. But sometimes you have to do a little bit of digging to, to get them to tell on themselves. You know, when you get these studies of like, oh, massive weight loss in participants of a study shows that anyone can lose weight, and then it's like, massive weight loss. And then you go and you look, and you say, you see the massive weight loss they're talking about is like three pounds. And then they're like the participants. Who were the participants? Oh, it was three mice in a lab. Oh, oh, really. And so you see this big like splashy kind of fat people are fucking horrible. And then you then you have to do a bit of digging. And a lot of times it means that you have to pay to get the information. And people don't do that, because it's sexier, just to be like, oh, yeah, fat people are horrible. Fat people need to lose weight, you know, you know. So anyway, so to summarize the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics, and released guidelines on how to treat fat patients. And this was during Eating Disorder Awareness Week, and during Black History Month, which is flabbergasting considering their recommendations are so harmful to black people and other people of color, and those who have a history of disordered eating or eating disorders. So perfect timing. Amazing. I love it. Their recommendations are to eat as many calories in a day that a toddler needs and so eat like a two to three year old. That's how many calories that you as an adult are allowed.

And then they say do not subscribe to Health at Every Size, or the non diet approach as these are not effective. These are not effective, and making fat people thin. Which they got right they are right, how they resize won't make fat people thin because that is not what it is designed to do. And it's not what it is about. So and Andy even share in their recommendations that the evidence that they have put forth to support their claims, is graded to D which means the quote weakest and lowest strength evidence. So they're telling on themselves that this evidence is pretty shit that they're putting forward. So if you think that ans recommendations are as fucked up as many people do, then you can go and tell them, their recommendations are open for public comment until March 25 2022. There's going to be a link around here somewhere for you to be able to do that. It's very quick and easy. He is going to take probably about a minute of your time. So go tell them if you think that it's pretty fucked up that they're recommending fat people. Only as much as a toddler to be healthy. So that is our episode today. Thank you for hanging out with me. I appreciate it. Don't have anything to tell, you know? Yeah. And I think I don't think I'm hungry. So I'm going to go and get some lunch, you poos algae, or do you know what? Oh my god, some of you are going to be like, No, duh, like. Okay, so, because of my dieting throughout my life, I had never eaten a kebap because I was like, No, I will never eat such a thing. I roll I roll. Anyway. And so and then, for the last however many years, multiple years I've been a vegetarian. And as you know, I've spoken on the episode if you don't know, recently, in the last couple of months, my body was like, I want some meat, please. And so I said, okay, buddy, here you go. Here's some meat. Anyway, there is a kebab place across from my my house and it has these like, I've gone in there and got like falafel before. Very nice. And the kebab thing that they've got looks really lovely. And anyway, so I went in there and I said all cannot go on. I'll have a try every chicken. I was waiting nervous, because, you know, I'm still kind of new to meat, right? It was so fucking Oh my God. Oh, like the meat was like kind of a little bit like because it'd been, it's, you know, they have it on that rolly thing. And then it's like gets, like browned was like kind of like a little bit like, not crunchy, but you know, kind of a little bit. Which was really nice. I went I've since I had that that was maybe like two weeks ago, I've gone back and I've had three I've had three and three kebabs in total as well because then as well with the kebab. You can get a and it'll give you a little cup of lentil soup. And the lentil soup of man so good. And I was just like shit. Fuck, I mean diet culture. And probably you know, like in me being like it's gonna be not good because it's you know, on a spit or something so probably racism as well has stopped me having this joy in my life of this I'm 37 and my whatever the things that I haven't eat because you know, I haven't you know, sometimes you haven't tried something because you've never had the chance so you've not been exposed to it but I've definitely had many chances to eat kebabs. And of course there are some might some kebabs are probably not as nice you know, the type of stuff that you know, you get get after a night out and but this is really nice. And all of the things like the joys that diet culture takes from us, right, man, I'm not. I'm not going to go get one for lunch now.

Am I? I'm thinking about that lentil soup that lentil soup was good. Yeah, I'm gonna go. I'm gonna get one for lunch. Yeah, it's across the street. It's across the street. I'm looking fabulous. This is gonna do it. There we go. Go. Thanks for lunch recommendation, everyone that great one good word. Okay, so thanks for hanging out with me and have a wonderful rest of your day. Stay fierce fatties. And I'll see you in a while. Alligator goodbye thanks for listening to the episode and if you feel ready to get serious about this work and want to know when the doors open to fears fattier Academy which is my signature program, where I teach all about how to overcome your fat phobic beliefs and learn to love your fat body. Then go to first party.com forward slash waitlist again that is phase fatty.com. Forward slash waitlist to get your name on the waitlist. For when first Mattie Academy my signature program opens.

EP116 Transcript

Welcome to the Fierce Fatty Podcast. I'm your host, Victoria Welsby, and this is episode 116. Today, we're talking about Is there a "game-changing" new weight loss drug.

I'm Victoria Welsby, TEDx speaker, best-selling author, and fat activist. I have transformed my life from hating my body with desperately low self-esteem to being a courageous and confident fifth party who loves every inch of this jelly. Society teaches us living in a fat body is bad. But what if we spent less time, money, and energy on the pursuit of thinness and instead focused on the things that actually matter? Like if pineapple on pizza should be outlawed? Or if the mullet was the greatest haircut of the 20th century? So how do you stop negative beliefs about your fat body controlling your life? It's the Fierce Fatty podcast. Let's begin.

Hello, hello, welcome to the episode. I'm your host, Vinnie Welsby. I do realize that I need to change many things where it's got my old name on it. But I can't be bothered bogged recording a new intro. So actually, it's not actually that difficult, but you're not I mean, you don't realize how your name is everywhere. So just Just hear me saying when I say Victoria, you hear me saying Vinny or cron just do that. Transport trans transpose in your head. I got a funny message from summer. In in in yesterday. And it is important that we include this last episode, silly yet last episode talking about TV shows and whatnot. And summer sent a frantic message.

Well, I don't know if she was frantic when she sent it. But let's pretend she was frantic. She messaged I realize we fail to talk about how the women on friends always wore thin shirts with their rock hard nipples showing. Do you remember that? It may be one of my life's biggest regrets that we forgot this key point and then crying laughing emoji. I responded lol No, I didn't remember that. Do you think they were wearing prosthetic nipples? Someone responded either that or they iced them between scenes. And I say maybe they had some boy whose job it was like a fluffer in porn films. In case you don't know that term. fluffer in porn productions, there might be someone who is not a an actress sock door, or gender neutral. Um, so gender neutral is probably actor. It's not their job to be on film, but their job to maybe like suck off someone to make sure that their deck is hard in between scenes. That's the fluffer anyway, so maybe they had floppers fluffing their nipples in between. And then someone sent me the Reddit there's a whole Reddit thing about it as a newbie to friends, what is it with all the nipples? And I said LOL LOL Oh my god.

And then this is even better. My Google autofill summers Google autofill was Why are Rachel's nipples always showing in friends? And here's the answer. She says. Did you know that friends his producers told Rachel and Monica to cut holes in their bras to show their nipples? You do know? Do you do know she made wardrobe cut holes in her bras so nips would show turns out that's a rumor. Jennifer Allison has said that that didn't happen. She just that's just what happened to her nips had just had nips, we're just there sometimes also somebody somewhere is a new show on HBO and so far has great representation leaders a fat female comic I'm only three episodes in but I love it. So there's a little tip for you. I said oh my god, I can't believe it. Maybe I should do that to my eyebrows but the holes would be pointing down so much point. I wonder why they didn't get fee me to do the same. Were her nips not good enough. So my response Good question. She was the kind of quirky quirky character versus sexy and I responded funny. Women don't have nipples. Don't you know? Someone says they can't possibly. And I said I think you should add this as an addendum to the podcast when you release it as the world needs to know This info someone says I will.

So now you know to about the friends his nipples. If that was on your mind and you're like, oh my god summer and Vinnie are definitely gonna be talking about the nipple situation in friends and we didn't and you were like, Oh, I'm so dizzy right around. There you go. You have it and if you didn't even know about the nipple situation like me, because obviously at the time, I just was like there's nipples and it gave me such nipple I remember at the time being like something wrong with my nipples while my nipple showing as like a 14 year old. Oh my goodness. And you remember at the time as well. A little bit later, in Sex in the City, there was an episode where Samantha put in prosthetic nipples to get a guy to have sex with her. And that was on one of the Reddit things I said oh yes. Remember? I think nipples were just really hot in the in the 90s.

Maybe they're making a comeback. Who knows? But either way, there you go. There you have it. There you have it. So this this fine day this fine call gets sunny day I was interviewed by Lucy Edwards who is a trainee journalist at the University of Sheffield. And Lucy has got an interest in in fat shit. Great interview where Lucy was asking about atypical anorexia and the connection with the new new I've I've spoken about it before, like forever 25 ish episodes ago that but it's kind of new in the UK, the new drug where weight loss in beer quotation marks drug. And, you know, the idea of prescribing atypical anorexia, anorexic people, a weight loss drug, and like the harm that it can cause atypical anorexia, if you're not sure what that is, it just means anorexia. infinte in fat people. So it's just anorexia. So a typical oh my god, fat people don't eat. How weird is that sarcasm by the way. So I am going to read you the a piece from The Guardian, which talks about this game changing new drug. And I'm going to it's not long, but I'm going to point out the problems here. Then you can listen to the interview with Lucy. And then I'm going to wrap it all up with all the juicy of what we've learned about this. Yeah, because there's been a lot of hubbub in the UK about this drug. It's called weego. V. And it's been approved by nice and nice is the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence. Not a lot of excellence going on with these recommendations and approving of this drug unfortunately.

But of course, the people that nice the people everywhere suffer from fatphobia. So of course, they're going to do everything they can to cure this illness, this lifelong condition that is fatness, even if it means killing fat people who cares about them dying, at least not on the planet. Okay, yeah, so trigger warning if you don't want to hear fat phobic fuckery. I'm going to I'm going to edit out the Oh words and just replace them with fat or fatness and so you're not going to hear the Oh words but you're going to hear the presumptions about fatness which I'm going to talk about so if that's not feeling good for you to do then skip just skip on skip on and just stay for the nipple talk and then leave and then you see in the next episode, but if it is okay, let me read this piece from The Guardian. Okay, so this was from eight the PIP 2022. Quote, game changing and quote, weight loss drug to be made available on NHS NHS National Health Service. Nice approves use of Semih glue tide opening door to new treatment for 1000s of adults with fatness. So semaglutide is the drug and then we go V is like the brand name. Okay, so 1000s of people with fatness in England will be able to get a new weight loss drug on the NHS after a watchdog approved its use patients The Weekly injections have seen their weight fall by an average of 12%. In one year, the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence nice set. Okay, so, first off weekly injections. Sounds fun. But hey, when I was when I was hating my fatness if someone said weekly, will you go and eat a dog shit in the hopes of being thin? Fuck yeah, I do it weekly. Would you inject human shit into your eyeballs? Yes, I would. So, you know, a weekly injection. That's fucked. But I can imagine it's not a huge barrier to people who are desperately wanting to be thin. And okay, so I've seen their weight four by an average of 12%. So what that means 12% is the study shows that's about 20 pounds 20 pounds. Game Changer. I mean, any, anyone could lose 20 pounds quite easily. Especially when we're starting out dieting, you know, lose 20 pounds in a couple of months to lose, I lose 20 pounds when I do a big fucking shit. So you know, 20 pounds. I don't think that 20 pounds is the game changer that fat people are looking for. Right? When they're looking at about game changing amounts of weight loss, they're thinking 50 100 more, right.

And so if we begin to scratch the surface, just a little bit, then it's like, oh, oh, that sounds good. Okay, continuing, it has issued draft guidance recommending some semaglutide also known as we go V for adults with at least one weight related condition, such as obstructive sleep apnea, or heart disease and a body mass index of APT at least. I won't say what the BMI is. Okay, big problems with that short paragraph there. Can you spot what they might be? health related conditions? Okay. Okay, Health Related. Related. Correlation is not causation. So fatness is not causing sleep apnea. Let's go and have a look at obstructive sleep apnea on the Hayes health sheets.com The Health sheep library. Okay. And let's see what causes sleep apnea? Is it that we are fat bastards. And if we lose weight, then all of a sudden we will not have obstructive sleep apnea. Okay, let's have a look what causes it according to his health sheets, there are several causes for obstructive sleep apnea, decrease in Apple, upper airway muscle function, structural upper airway factors. cranial facial structure was it which is often hereditary, soft tissue structure, including tongue size, pharyngeal walls, and soft tissue of neck often hereditary fluid in soft tissues of neck caused by medical conditions. Oh, hang on a minute. Just is it fatness? No. Okay. And so how do we treat? Obstructive sleep apnea? Is it weight loss? Weight loss? Oh, let's have a look. Overview. Breathing therapy, so CPAP Airway Pressure devices, oral appliances, so dentists stuff.

And in small number of cases, you might as a last resort, need a surgery. None of that is to do with weight loss. And so this this this from The Guardian is saying, Well, if you have sleep apnea, and you're fat, you're going to get this drug because only your one Sleep apnea is caused by fatness and being 20 pounds lighter is going to cure your sleep apnea. Okay, not evidence based. Let's let's look at heart disease. Let's have a look at heart disease. But but above. Top one on here, top one on here. Okay, so genetics and environmental Aflac factors can play a major role in the development of heart disease. Still, fat patients often have to deal with doctors blaming their body size for the same issues that also affect a thin people. That's counterproductive to good medical care.

Yeah, so there's lots of different there's four different types of heart disease. And none of them are caused by fat people being really horrible people. And nothing two thing to remember is that straight size people also get heart disease surprise over it. straight sides. People also have sleep apnea, surprise, surprise. So are straight sides people also going to qualify for this. This drug this weight loss drug? Hmm. Well, that's how you fix these problems, isn't it? Hmm. Strange. No, let's continue in exceptional cases, some people with a BMI of a lower BMI or more may also be able to access the drug which is self administered using a pen in Jack tall. More than one in four people in England have fatness which means having a BMI of x or above. fatness can be physically debilitating and lead to severe and potentially life limiting conditions. It costs the NHS and the wider economy billions of pounds a year. I mean, these that those two sentences are just fraught with inaccuracies, and presumptions, and is not helpful. So it costs this whole thing. It costs the NHS so much money. How, how, how, of course, fat people are gonna cost the NHS money. It's a large percentage of the population. It's like saying, men cost the NHS loads of money. Boy, Yeah, no shit. It's half of the population. You know, all people cost all the way. You know. Yeah. People with brown eyes cost the NHS billions of pounds. What? Well, yeah. It's competing a human. And, you know, in what ways in what ways and a lot of times you know what, so so often when a fat person dies, their cause of death, if they're fat, is I word the cause of death is fat. It doesn't matter, you know, what was going on? If especially if they have diseases that are linked to fatness than one 100% and the cause of death is fatness. Whereas if a thin person has this exact same disease that causes death won't be fineness, you know? And so it's like, oh, look at all these people dying of fatness? Are they? Oh, are they dying from things that everyone else does wrong? You know, and saying that fatness can be physically debilitating. It's just reeks of ableism and just just, it's just gross leads to severe bouts of and lead to severe and potentially life limiting conditions. I mean, it's it's a human condition, right? It's, it's just, it's the human condition to you know, eventually, maybe having a life limiting condition and then dying. You know, it's like, can we we can change this with live living can be physically debilitating and lead to severe and potentially life limiting conditions. Yeah, uh huh. You know.

Anyway, let's continue. The new drugs suppresses the appetite through mimicking the hormone glucagon clue glucagon like peptide, one GLP. One, which is released after eating painscience patients inject themselves with some semaglutide which makes them feel full, meaning they eat bless and lose weight. Now nice little appetite suppressant. Because we all know that fat people are fat. Every fat person is fat, because we cannot stop eating. We're out of control with food that's all we do day and night as he didn't he didn't. So much that we can't control ourselves so much. So very kind NHS has had to come up with a way to help us poor fatties with our constant eating. And thank God they've come up with this drug that is going to suppress our appetites because that's what's gonna make us thin. We can't do it ourselves. And so we need an intervention to help us stop being so fucking greedy. Um, that was all sarcasm by the way. If if you didn't get that bit.

Yeah, so there's two things there to two things that are presumed that fatness is a result of eating too much food. And fineness can be induced by not eating food. Not eating as much food as what apparently we eat all the time. Both are wrong. So here's a quote. We know that management of fatness and fatness is one of the biggest challenges of our health, our health service is facing with nearly two thirds of our adults either FAT or FAT. Said Helen Knight, the Program Director in the Center for Health Technology Evaluation at nice. Okay, so management of something that doesn't need to be managed management of a disease that isn't real. And it's not it's not the biggest challenges challenges our health services facing. There are so there are so many ma me the biggest challenge in the way that we think about fatness Yeah, yeah. I think the bigger challenges are things like lack of access, racism, discrimination, health care, mental mental health care. Right Wing thinking about how we treat people, they are the biggest challenges to healthcare, right?

Lack of funds, etc. Okay, continuing. It's a lifelong condition that needs medical intervention has a psychological has psychological and physical effects, and can affect quality of life. Yeah, the psychological effects of because you say it's a it's a lifelong condition that needs medical intervention. There are no it's not a condition because the only thing that fat people have in common with each other is that they are fat, we cannot say okay, this is what we classed as we know that there is a disease here because the only indicator is fatness, you know, we can't say okay, we know that this is disease because people have abc, and this is how we ignite we diagnose it because one fat person, one fat person's health is going to be different from another fat person's health. It's like saying, hey, oh, you know this disease of living with blonde hair? What's the common attribute? Blonde hair? Well, no, that's not that's not how it works. Okay, continuing. The nice document says access to current drug treatments for fatness is limited to specific to specific population who have pre diabetes and a risk factor for cardiac cardiovascular disease. Other drug treatment options available are poorly tolerated and rarely used.

So we've spoken about it before, even in recent episodes, the idea of pre diabetes that a teeny tiny percentage of people who have pre diabetes go on to develop diabetes, again, diabetes is a genetic condition. It's just shit on top of shit on top of shit. Yeah, it's the Committee concluded that there is a large unmet need for many people living with fatness and that cemetery semaglutide would be a welcome new treatment option. Nice said people from a South Asian Chinese or black African or Caribbean black background, would be able to access the drug at a lower BMI after advice from a medic, because, of course, we need to put in a bit of racism there. So let's hurt people who are marginalized, let's give them the, the the drug versus let's look at actually what's happening. You know, like how people with with marginalized identities people you know, with the merchant in here, South Asian, Chinese, black African Caribbean have can have worse health outcomes. We look at why, you know, like the stats about black parents who give birth Have you know higher mortality, you know, higher risks, all that type of stuff. Is it because of who they are? No. Is it because of bias racism and bigotry? Yes. So how is increasing the bias by forcing a drug But it's gonna hurt, hurt these populations and do the opposite of what it's trying to achieve.

How is that not increasing bias? How is that not hurting them? Even more. So yet again, people of color are getting the short end of the stick yet again, due to bias versus saying, why are people from a South Asian, Chinese black, African or Caribbean background? Having worse health outcomes? If they are, let's fix that. Versus always because it's because of the color of their skin. And so, you know, continuing patients will only be given semaglutide on prescription as part of a specialist weight management service involving input from several professionals, and for a maximum of two years.

And what do we know about what do we know about weight interventions that happen? Two years, two years? What happens? Two to five years? The way goes back on? So what are these people going to do these? Oh, my goodness, these people who are taking an ejection every single week, for two years, they lose 20 pounds? And do all the stuff that intentional weight loss does to a human body? Fuck up your metabolism? increase your risk for health conditions? fucks with your mental health lalalalala? Or what are they gonna do after the two years? See you later. You know, we're done with you. Now off you go. What's gonna happen is, are they gonna put weight back on because the treatment has stopped? And even during the treatment, our bodies are going to be like, Oh, I don't like this what's going on? an appetite suppressant every week. Imagine if someone said to you, oh, you know, I saw those. Those those those teas on Instagram, where it helps you shit your pants, I'm going to take that every single week for two years, you'd be like, Oh, please don't Oh, great for your health. This is what this is, right. And the thing is, the thing is the thing that guess how much data we have, guess how much research these motherfuckers did. 1.3 years, we have 1.3 years of research of what happens to people on this drug. Presumably because the information they're presenting shows that after 1.3 years, people start putting weight back on, even though they continue to take the drug. So it's not even as good as a bog standard, you know, diet, where we're like, kind of about to wish is 18 months to issues where the weight starts coming back up.

So and then the side effects from this the side effects, the one that kind of really made me shudder was suicide ideation alongside a whole host of other things. So, you know, can people tolerate taking this for two years? I mean, aside from the fact of having an injection every week, because like I mentioned, you know, I would do anything, I would do anything. Are they going to survive that two years though, without killing themselves? Like serious question here. And all for a 20 lb temporary weight loss. Okay, continuing clinical trial evidence show that people lose more weight with summer glue tied together with supervised weight loss coaching, than with support alone. I mean, supervised weight loss coaching. So you're going to be doing both at the same time, you're going to be taking this thing and you're going to be dieting, I mean, this thing is is you know, forcing a diet on you, but then presumably people are going to be not eating enough outside of what they are eating to make up for the fact that they're not eating you know. And then presumably, they're going to be you know, forcing themselves to over exercise and other things that you They hoped might induce extra weight loss makes me sick. Experts have previously described the drug as a quote game changer and suggested that for the first time people could achieve through drugs what was only previously possible both through weight loss surgery. Oh for fuck sake. And again, the saying is only possible through weight loss surgery. And as we know, weight loss surgery is Whoa, all kinds of fucked up often doesn't lead to long term weight loss. incredibly awful side effects so many stories of people saying that they regret it terribly. You know, a lot of time short term weight loss surgery, survivors are happy.

And even long term Some are happy. But many more often than not, they're not, you know, having their body mutilated in that way in the hopes of losing weight and it doesn't work like that. Continuing in 2020, Boris Johnson launched the government's anti fatness strategy, which includes plan for a ban on TV and online adverts for food before 9pm and ending deals as buy one get one free on food, which has salt, sugar and fat. Oh, great way to penalize poor people. Because we know that again, fatness is caused because poor people go and get a buy one get one free deal. And they eat too much. No, no, talk about increasing the shame and stigma. We can't show food on television because you know, people are just gonna like it and just go out and eat it even more. Because you know, fat people don't have control over themselves. And they're just so greedy. That's the end of the article there. I want to take a minute here just to like I'm just fucking fed up with this shit. Just have some breaths, and exhale the fat phobic bullshit from my body because it's getting online.

It's it's both just to like, get rid of that fat phobic bullshit. Let's go to the interview with Lucy I'll link to Lucy's Lucy's contact and work because Lucy has done other cool things. You can find Lucy on Twitter at ln e journaux, J OU and Jo, you are an O so lne journaux on Twitter and Instagram at Lucy spell el UCEA y. Okay. But I'll link to that in the show notes too. So you don't have to go looking. Let's go to this interview.

So tell me a little bit about fat activism then just in general, and about what place it has in your life? Yeah, so I would describe myself as a fat activist. And for me, it's just about getting equal rights for fat people. And a lot of a lot of people are like, well, fat people don't deserve equal rights because it's just don't be fat. There you go. Problem solved. And so educating the world on the idea that it's really hard to not be fats, you know, and the reasons why people are fat are in the hundreds. And fat people are not all of these stereotypes that we believe that they are. And so for me, that is what fat fat activism is, is educating people that fat people are just people and they deserve the same goodness that everyone else in the world gets.

Okay, so moving on to the topic of this new weight loss job, which I'm going to try and not chat too much about because I'm very passionate about the topic myself. So we might have a little bit of a proper chat as opposed to just an interview here. I don't know. So do you know much about the weight loss job? Like is it something that you've said about or Joby? To tell you a little bit about it? Yeah, no, no, I know about it. Yeah. So what is your general like thoughts on this weight loss job this suppose it gave game changing weight loss job?

Game Changing? I just feel so sad about it sad for all the fat people who have heard about it and they're like, Oh my God, saying fuck this is the answer to my prayers. And finally and all that hope that these fat people are feeling and All of the glee that the people who have manufactured this, they're like, yes, we've we're going to make so much fucking money. And then the pain that the those fat people are going to feel when they remain fat in the long term when their health is compromised. When this solution which has been touted as game changing, doesn't work and the amount of shame and sadness, they are going to feel afterwards, when they had such a high, so much hope that their, quote, problems could be solved. And it's just, it's just immensely cruel in many, many different ways. So it doesn't make me sad, it makes me sad.

And a big part of it that they seem to emphasize and all the articles are going around about it is this thing of it being like a BMI thing where over people over a BMI of have access to it. And then it goes to even say that on a case by case basis, this might come down to and then depending on someone's race, it can come down even further. So BMI is often criticized as being really wrong. Could you tell me a little bit about this and about how BMI can be wrong?

Yeah, because the BMI is 200 years old, created by a statistician astronomer, who said this is not meant to be measuring individuals is a population measurement. And it measured sis white European men, and other time just said, Oh, hey, this is what those bodies what they weigh, generally. And, and then the guidelines of what was, quote, normal or abnormal, were changed thanks to lobbying from diet companies so that the bans were even lower, it's absolutely arbitrary. The five, you know, the five points, literally, those numbers were picked out of the air because they were easy to remember, not because of science, not because it's what health is. And it is just really stigmatizing it. pathologize is fat bodies, it says that there is a way that human bodies should be. And it presumes even the words overweight and obese, obese means haven't eaten until gotten fat. And I mean, that's just fucked up. Because fat people are fat for many different reasons. And the main one being is just a normal way for human body to be. So all around, it's just unscientific, and racist. And just 100% Fucked up.

So with the headlines, Brandon, the jerk is most exciting. Games changing. It's hard to ignore how much value the media outlets seem to be putting on the idea of being thin and unfairness. Can you tell me a little bit about fatphobia? In general and fatphobia? In the media in particular?

Yeah. So it's, it's really, really surprising. It's really surprising to me, but then also kind of not when we see we kind of put an amount of trust in publications such as the guardian, to look at the research and and dig in and say, Is this true? Or is this a good headline. And I always presumed that if somewhere like the Guardian was reporting something like this, it was very factual, it was very well researched. But if we just scratched the surface a little bit, we can see that we have journalists who are under stress, who are just trying to pump out interesting pieces, and are just taking the science at face value versus doing a little bit of research to understand it. And I understand why because, you know, we live in a capitalist society where it's kind of like you need to bang out articles and pieces and work, you know, a ton.

And because we live in a fat phobic society, the people making writing these pieces, they have their own biases. And these, these new reports kind of feed into their biases. And so it's kind of like well, of course, this is game changing. Of course, this is a great thing to report on. Without getting critical about this the you know, the information because it just is a part of what they already believe. So yeah, I mean, we are all fat phobic. Even I am, you know, because we live in such an incredibly fat phobic society that it's very, very difficult to don't have bias around people's body size. And that is going to affect everything that we consume media that we consume. Because the people who are making it I've obit, there's a lot of misconceptions around sort of weight and health. So could you expand on this, obviously, with the case of like, assuming that a fat person is unhealthy, or a thin person is healthy, that kind of thing? Could you expand on that?

Yeah. So it's, it's really very well established in our society that, of course, a fat person is going to be unhealthy. What we now know about health, and what we know about weight science is that it's actually very, very complicated. And correlation does not equal causation. Yes, fat people are at a higher risk of developing certain conditions. But what we don't know is that it's having more fat on your body that makes it, you know, makes you get that higher risk, more adipose tissue. What we do know, what we do have good evidence to show is that engaging in intentional weight loss, so going on diets, is a really high risk factor for the the complications that fat people can sometimes encounter. So dieting, access to health care that is subpar. And so fat people go to the doctor, hey, I've got stubbed my toe, and the doctor says, Have you thought about losing weight. So subpar healthcare. And thirdly, shame and stigma, shame and stigma have a ton of impact on our physical and mental health. And so we do have great evidence to show that those three things intentional weight loss, subpar medical care, and the shame and stigma that fat people face has a tremendous impact on health. And so it's not we don't have the evidence to say it's fatness in and of itself that causes health outcomes.

Now, obviously, I want to point out that there are many fat people who are healthy, what is healthy, you know, health is such a complicated subject. And there are many thin people who are not healthy. So we can't tell anyone's health status by their body size. And the more that we understand that health is an incredibly complex topic. And so is weight science, the better and it's not a black and white, you know, you're fat. And the fact that you are the more unhealthy war is just, it's just lazy and out of date science.

And do you think when the media sort of cover topics like a weight loss injection, do you think it just adds to stigma and it just makes things a lot worse for fat people?

Yeah, because you know, the company who who are behind this drug, they've gone on this whole campaign to say, oh, fat fatness has a disease don't blame, the fact is that it's not their fault. They're fat. And trying to position it like, oh, you know, be nice to the fat ease. But in that whole process, they are doing the opposite. They're just doing the opposite. And the idea that this drug is basically an appetite suppressant. It just, it reinforces the idea that fat people have fat because they can't stop eating. And if we just help them stop eating, because they can't do it on their own, because they're so greedy and out of control. They need to have a drug because they're so they're so fucked up. And it will help them stop eating. That's what's gonna make them thin, because they can't control themselves. So would they need to take a drug? I mean, if that's not stigmatizing, then I don't know what is.

And another aspect that I'm sort of interested in, in talking about this is the fact that sort of eating disorders in particular, they come in all sorts of different shapes and sizes, there is not just one look of any disorder. So this kind of thing do you have do you have much of an understanding of sort of atypical anorexia or like a typical in the sense of it being with different weights? Yeah. So do you think that this kind of thing is even more out of touch and even more harmful to people who were experiencing eating disorders that don't have the stereotypical eating disorder? Look?

Yeah, I mean, oh, my goodness. Even even that word atypical anorexia, I think we need to get rid of the atypical because anorexia comes in all shapes of shapes and sizes. And as someone who I, I think that in my past, I have suffered from atypical anorexia or anorexia. But, if it's if someone is suffering from an eating disorder, they're they're in a bigger body. They're encouraged. They're just like, good for you for not eating anything and losing weight. But if they're in a smaller body, then all of a sudden it's a problem. And yeah, this presumes that this project so this this drug is presuming that someone has eaten too much food. If you have an eating disorder, you've had that assumption has been made, you're eating too much food, and you're you have anorexia, and you're going in and getting this appetite suppressant. Holy shit, I can't even think of the damage that that is going to cause mentally and physically to those who have an eating disorder. Yeah, especially if they have atypical anorexia. I mean, it's and all the side effects that the drug already already has. It just, it is so risky, it is so damaging, and I think it's gonna cause even more eating disorders in fat people.

And, as well, I just like to ask you about like a typical anorexia in general. So what's your sort of experiences with it? Like, what do you know about the topic of it, especially for people who are in larger bodies who have it?

Well, a lot of times, diets are basically the, the blueprint to help people fat people develop atypical anorexia, diets are prescribing an eating disorder. And if you're prone to, you know, if you're prone to soaking up fat phobic messages, which is, hey, if you've got a brain, and you know, you might have other things going on in your life, then it's just very, very easy to slip into something which is disordered. And you know, the idea between an eating disorder and disordered eating that line is very, very thing and a diet basically, is, is prescribing that disordered eating, and, and so it's kind of like you're very close into that, developing whatever it is, and I'm previously I had binge eating disorder. And, yeah, and atypical anorexia, and it's like, no shit, when I'm being told that it's a good thing, that I starve myself. It's a good thing that I deny myself food. No wonder, you know, people develop eating disorders. an atypical anorexia being one of them is obviously the case for people who have a typical anorexia as well as a lot of the time, it's really difficult for them to get treatment, because, you know, doctors are quite fat phobic, and a lot of them can be quite fat phobic, and they sort of if you do meet the requirement of being underway, or you won't get Yeah, exactly. You just encouraged. Yeah, well, I remember going back to my doctor, him weighing me, I'd lost so much weight, and he was like, congratulations, what did you do? Versus Are you okay? What's happening with you, you know, how's your mental health, I see that you've lost a lot of weight. And that's, that's, that's different. And I'm worried, you know, and it would have been very easily picked up if I was in a smaller body.

But in a bigger body, it was just praised. And there's no way if I went in and said, you know, what, I'm just, I'm not eating that much food. And I think about food all the time. And it just, you know, it feels very kind of disordered, then, you know, I can imagine the doctor would just be like, oh, you know, just don't get too crazy with it, you know, just don't go too far. But keep going because you're losing weight. And that is obviously a good thing. So, yeah, and even in eating disorder treatment, there's the the rampant fatphobia is kind of like if someone you know, don't put on weight, but don't put on too much weight. And if you're fat, you know, we manage that way. I mean, it's just even if you do get treatment, it will be fat phobic probably.

And is this something that sort of extends into all sorts of avenues of life? So aside from like, the therapy routes, and from doctors, like living with an eating disorder, without the stereotypical look, is it something that a lot like is there a lot of stigma that people have to deal with in just general life from other people like with diet talk and sort of gym talk and that kind of thing?

Yeah, I mean, oh my goodness. Being in recovery from an eating disorder living in a fat body is so fucking hard, because people will not think twice about talking about their new latest diet over lunch or how that has too many calories or, or how we need to burn off the weekend because I had a glass of wine or whatever. And so it makes it very, very difficult. Whereas if someone is in a smaller body and said, hey, you know what, I'm recovering from an eating disorder that I think people would be very mindful about talking about that type of stuff, but with a fat person, then it's kind of like, well, of course, the fat person wants to lose weight, and wants to hear about my new weight loss solution. Because they're fat, obviously, they don't want to be fat. So it's very, very difficult because it's not like you can step into a safe space, where people are not talking about this, this this stuff. Okay, so let me wrap up by just kind of giving an overview of everything that we we've spoken about. So we have it clear in our brains, for if you are in the UK, and I mean, this drug is is us as well, and who the fuck knows where else because it was a worldwide marketing campaign that this company has done to them, what they're doing is saying, Oh, we're all about taking away the stigma of being fat, and taking away the stigma of being it's not fat, people's fault that they're fat.

And then he's not taking away the stigma at all. Okay, so is there a game changing new weight loss drug? So there there's been hubbub in the UK because we go V has been approved for use by the NHS, it's also been approved in the US as well. And so people are a lot of fat people are excited that there is this new drug that's going to make them thinner. So what we know is that the issues with this one, it's based on the premise that fatness is a disease and a lifelong condition that needs treatment. And in reality, fatness is just a normal way for a human body to exist in the world, to it presumes that fat people are fat, because we are greedy, and eat too much food. And that if only we had this mere miracle cure to suppress our appetites, we would then be thin. Three in assumes that fitness equals health. And what we know about this drug drug is that the side effects are long and dangerous. And the longer term side effects have not been studied, because we only have just over a year's worth of data that's been examined, supplied by this company. So yeah, and what we know about long term weight loss drugs is that there are many side effects that include death. So this is going to kill fat people. For there is no evidence that it actually improves health. We don't have evidence improves health, five, it does nothing to address the actual things that hurt the health of fat people. And those things are things that hurt the health of fat people one intentional weight loss, which this is to subpar health care which this is, and three weight stigma. And so that's a shame that fat people face. And so this drug is actually increasing all of those things. So presumably, decreasing the health of fat people. Six, it doesn't actually help people lose much weight loss studies show that the weight loss is about 20 pounds, which for a fat person is certainly not game changing.

Seven all that in exchange for weekly injections, that when you stop taking the effects is going to are going to be reversed. Or even if you do continue to take for the rest of your life, which you won't be allowed to because the prescription length is only two years, your body is probably going to take over and force you to get back to a higher way because of this appetite suppressant that is going on. And finally, eight. It's a drug to drug that claims to fix a disease that doesn't exist. It doesn't have evidence that it works long time, and that it doesn't cause catastrophic harm, just like every other weight loss drug that we've ever seen on the market that's been approved. And even if it does work long term in the way that it does short term, it's only around 20 pounds that people will lose all in exchange for weekly injections and side effects like increased suicide ideation. This drug is going to kill fat people. And it is going to cause a ton of shame and heartbreak for the fat people who are desperately hoping that it's going to be their miracle cure, and what they're going to do afterwards, they've taken it for the two years and they are the same weight, a higher weight, their health hasn't improved, it's a waste of hope, when we could be seeking to increase our health with interventions that are actually evidence based, like Health at Every Size.

So I think we all need to go and have like, a little sit down I don't know a little kind of like, fuck you to something I don't know. I just have such empathy for the people who are so excited about this, you know, if I was not in this world, and I saw in this, you know, fat positive world, and I saw that, that there was going to be a drug, I would be just daydreaming about what my life was going to be like, when I was going after I would lose weight and how wonderful it's going to be and all sorts of things only for my hopes to be dashed in the next couple of years. Only for my mental health to really see tremendous tremendous pain going on. From from those hopes that are dashed, and the shame of like, what's wrong with me? Why can't Why can't I lose weight even when I have a fucking drug that an injection I'm taking every week? Why can't I lose weight What is wrong with me? I'm disgusting, you know, I can't you know, and the amount of eating disorders that are gonna go to it's gonna create imagine you know like because you know my my history with eating disorder is you know, basically the lack of access to food or physically mentally created binge eating in me naturally because that is what happens and imagine having an appetite appetite suppressant how that's going to add to that oh anyway, and let's just make next next episode better happier less raging juicing Shall we will is going to be another episode is going to be the last episode actually with with summer so I don't know what we're going to do it on. summers off summers off going to Ashley is not going to be with summer because summer is off on on on our holiday. So it's going to be a few weeks until we have summer on again. So I know let's make episode something next episode something funny or something? I'm gonna make a note. Trying remember? It's so fucking depressing.

Anyway, okay, well go and watch something go and watch some pictures of cats or something. I don't know. Some penguins, gay penguins making a baby or whatever to make you happy and yeah, we'll see you in the next episode. Stay fierce fatty goodbye crocodile thanks for listening to the episode and if you feel ready to get serious about this work and want to know when the doors open to fears fatti Academy which is my signature program, where I teach all about how to overcome your fat phobic beliefs and learn to love your fat body. Then go to first party.com forward slash waitlist again that is phase fatty.com. Forward slash waitlist to get your name on the waitlist. For when first party Academy my signature program opens

EP115 Transcript

Welcome to the Fierce Fatty Podcast. I'm your host, Victoria Welsby, and this is episode 115. Today, we're talking about TV shows and movies that messed with our body image.

I'm Victoria Welsby, TEDx speaker, Best-Selling Author and fat activist. I have transformed my life from hating my body with desperately low self-esteem to being a courageous and confident fifth party who loves every inch of this jelly. Society teaches us living in a fat body is bad. But what if we spent less time, money, and energy on the pursuit of thinness and instead focused on the things that actually matter? Like if pineapple on pizza should be outlawed? Or if the mullet was the greatest haircut of the 20th century? So how do you stop negative beliefs about your fat body controlling your life? It's the Fierce Fatty podcast. Let's begin.

Hello, welcome to this episode of fears are farty the Podcast. Today we've got another episode of death to diets with summer Internen my power my gal pow. And we're talking about the naught naughties. The 90s and noughties TV show bullshit that really fucked us up. And I know the list of shows is endless. Yeah, so we're also talking about if there are any shows are actually good. Count them on. Count them on the list of like one fingers, one hands. And hilason Lauren, who is a listener of the show, hi, Lauren. Really enjoyed my American accent from last week. And I told her actually I have a nother American accent that I am excellent at and so I thought I'd give it to show you my second American accent if that's okay. Apologies. Apologies. For ologies I'm going to read the synopsis of the show in my other American accent which is a family girl. So our oh my god, The Biggest Loser friends and Bridget Jones have a lot to answer for what this is no, Veronica. This is nobody go have a laptop as a fall when it comes to body it. Hang on. This is the same fucking accent I did last week. Oh my god.

Today Sommer and I are talking about shows and movies that did a number on our self esteem. Turning into the accent again. Have things got better? Oh my god, or is it the same old BS? And And were there any good shows from monopolies that help with body image? Oh my god. Okay, so that wasn't really Valley go. I tried. Do I have a career in voice acting? Do I I don't think that resembled any living Americans accent or dead Americans accent. But there you have it. There you have it. Now you know my many talents. And we can now get on with the show the good stuff, which is summer and ice. And let's get into it. I'm excited. For this one. We are talking about the TV shows and movies that messed up our body image as well as our audience's body image. Before we start death to diets is a show that we created where we look at the ridiculousness of diet culture and beauty standards and just kind of more topical things that have happened in the world of dieting or body image or any of the kind of work that we do. And yeah, we unpack it here. We ridicule it. We give people advice and we do not judge or blame anyone that engages in diets more we critique and reflect on the culture of dieting and The issues around that. Do you want to introduce yourself?

I am Vinny wells b V dub Alicia's super sexy person, and I am a fat activist, non binary, fat, amazing human being. And I teach about unlearning fatphobia.

I'm a professionally trained life coach. I specialize in body image, self worth and confidence. And I also host a podcast called Eat the rules. And yeah, we're buddies, right? We're, we're friends, we are friends.

I made the biggest mistake of my life before coming on here today as in trail mix. And now I've got trail mix in my mouth in me, one of the worst. So if you see me like this going, my fingers in my mouth and you know why?

You're not eating it while we're trying to record that, would you imagine?

So I love the fact that you said, Oh, it's topical. We do topical stuff. Because there's so many of these things on my island. I remember like, I need to talk to someone about Yeah, for sure. But I'm seeing there's a show I'm watching right now. Right now is we're streaming. I'm watching a show no, right now, in evening, and it's getting on my tits. And I was like, Oh, well, somebody can tell me I can talk to someone about it.

Yeah, so I got some of those to go go on set. Sorry. I'm interrupting you know, I interrupted you.

I was gonna say so one of the big things that the shows that shows on movies that foot your body image. Yeah. So you know, I was really reflecting on this. Because I saw that I this was like a couple months ago, and I saw a rerun of friends. And I was like, oh my god, like this show. Totally warped my body image. Did you watch Friends?

I loved friends. I remember. It'd be showing on Channel Four. No. So trying to follow Yeah, channel four 9pm Friday night watched it religiously?

Yeah, like I have I got the same tattoo that Rachel got. That's how obsessed with it. I was what is that? What is the tattoo? It's like a little heart on my lower back. Isn't what I read on it? Yeah. You superfan? Can I please disclose that I was 16 years old when I did that. So like, not very. My frontal lobe hadn't fully developed.

Why? How do you explain the that back tattoo you got a couple of weeks ago of Monaco space.

No. closeted fan? Um, yeah. So you watch the show. This was the time and this was some of the feedback we got from the audience, right, like that shows kind of in like the late 90s, like, early 2000s. That was when like, quote, unquote, you know, actresses were like competing to sort of be the fitness like, it was sort of this new ideal that came out, like we had gone from, you know, women having like, just like, they were still really thin, but to like, extreme stenness. And when I went back, when I saw this rerun, I was like, Oh, my God, like, they're so thin. And I'm not thin shaming at all. But I but it was more just a reflection of like, wow, this really, like I can see how this warped my own perception of my body. And then I think you're probably familiar with the character of fat Monica, you remember that character?

Yep. Like, horrible, horrible character that pretty much was, you know, the walking stereotype of everything that you would associate with, like, you know, like, with fatness in a very negative way, like what our culture has sort of made us believe. And then, you know, like the newer thin Monica being the one who like everybody likes and she's attractive and all this other stuff and just really feeding into this, you know, this belief that you have to be thinner in order to be you know, in order to be worthy. What were your thoughts? Like, what what what were your thoughts on that when you were in like, you must have been because you're younger than me, you would have been even younger sort of taking.

So I I remember that. She had a completely different personality. Yeah, like, I just remember her being like We can be like, oh, you know, I'm so disgusting and horrible. And you know, yeah, yes. A nerd and like Nabil is, you know, yeah. And a part of me was like, Okay, well I'm really shy. And so when I grow up and become thin, then I'll be kind of like Monica I'll be like confident and fabulous. And you know, date Chandler, Bing, and all that type of stuff. Because that's what happens when you lose weight is you get a new personality and you become confident, which obviously, yeah, don't. But yeah, and you know, that that hope that I you know, I was still young, like I was probably 1413 and being like, Okay, well, that was Monika when she was young. And so I've got a limited time until I better become thin. Because it was obviously a terrible thing that maybe you might be able to get away with if you're younger, but certainly not if you're an adult. Wow. Wow.

And like, Did you remember that? Like, was that something that kind of stuck with you? Or have you forgotten about that? No, I've totally remember

that. And, because that's the scene where she stabbed Chandler's foot. She dropped a knife on Shannon's foot and he lost a toe right? Like, I just remember it so badly. And and how shameful it was that she had this secret past of being fat, like fat was this like, like her past of being a serial killer? You know that she had to hide get away and don't talk about when I was fat? Mollica because it was so embarrassing. Yeah, such cheap humor to like, it's not even. Like it's so. Yeah, just low bruh whole and like, yeah, yeah, no, maybe it's not even humor really, but like, friends was, Oh, my goodness. I was. I felt like this about sex in the city. This so diverse because they have like a dark hair. One. They have a stupid word. The funny one. They've got all of the characters of humanity. They're like, yeah, it's all and no matter. Also, like with the fatphobia, but it was also problematic in a gajillion different ways. One thing that really stands out for me was transphobia. Chandler's dad was trans or maybe became maybe a drag queen. No, some sort of exploration of gender there. And it was like this hilarious punchline to make fun of the dead.

I don't remember that part of it. Wow. Yeah. I mean, yeah, I mean, and like who who can afford to live in New York in that size of an apartment in New York as well? Just as a side brachialis thing? Like millions and millions of dollars an apartment that size now in Vancouver would be like,

God so much bigger than my house. Yeah. Yeah. And then do you want to do one of your shows? Or do you want me to keep doing deals? Okay, so the other one that I wanted to talk about, which is interesting, because other people in the audience said this one too. Is America's Next Top Model. Did you watch that one?

13:19

Another one that I fucking love. Yeah, I was always working those smiles is you remember the smile. The smile? Yeah, the smile. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah, but I love that. Tell me tell me why that fuck with you?

13:36

Well, for one, I mean, like, you know, the again it's like, like extreme thinness like extreme sadness. But do you remember Do you remember what they always had a token plus size model? Do you remember what size the token plus size model was?

13:52

Oh shit. I don't even I don't even remember that being one like because I really like but they must have been Max a size 10 Size eight really fucking fat basically very small, very small.

14:12

So I remember thinking like in my own you know, distorted mind that like, oh my God being a size eight is plus size. Like, you know what I mean? Like, first of all, like that's, that's a terrible thought just anyways, and and so but in my in like, when I was when I was young and still buying into this notion that you know, like, thinner is better like I just, I remember that. And I remember thinking like, well, it can't be like a size. I think I was like I was a size eight at the time. But it's just like, I mean, it was just so distorted like that, that you know, like the obvious like lack of any sort of diversity that like the plus size models and size eight is just like the most ridiculous thing I've ever seen. And of course, if you're staring at like, stick than people for, you know, an hour or hour At the time, because you're watching all these shows, like back to back. Yeah, like it's gonna warp your perception of your own body and like what you associate like how you perceive yourself. And

15:11

yeah, oh my god. Yeah, I can't remember like the plus size models, it must have been, like, next seasons or whatever, maybe, maybe I didn't watch enough, but I'm so glad that didn't stick in my mind. Because size eight, I haven't been size eight since I was eight years old, probably like, so even if they're a plus size that size, I would have just like shit in my trousers. The only good thing I remember about Nick ATM was the height requirement was five, seven, and I'm five, seven. And I was like, Ah, I could be a model when I lose weight. So when I get older, you know, because I'm going to be clean when I'm older. At least I'm tall enough to be a model, because I'm definitely going to get on to ATM and Pa model. But the as well alongside the just stereotypical beauty ideals was the amount of inappropriate stuff that they did. Do you remember the episode where they put people in blackface?

16:15

No, oh my gosh, no.

16:19

Yeah, they did, like a culture swap quotes is what they, they they did it and they put white models in blackface, too, and then took pictures. And no one. No, no one said maybe we shouldn't. And there was another one where a girl had a family member had just died like the day before. And then the next shoot was in coffins in the ground. And the girl was like, I'm feeling really sensitive. Because you know, my mom just died and then like, it was not Miss J It was the other one you're the one with the silver hair was like Pete You better get in there if you don't want to fail being a model and she had to do it and she'd had to do the shoot sobbing and it was just like, and I remember being at the time Yeah, bitch get in that fucking coffin. If you you know, the moving world is harsh like this, you know, you just got to do it. And you know, I didn't battle if any of this stuff and yeah, I was there judging them. Their bodies. Like the judges were you know, I thought I was a Miss J being like, Oh, look at her walk. It's so terrible when you know, I couldn't I couldn't do a fucking what modern walk. Anyway, so true.

17:31

Yeah, it really taught you how to kind of critique like, critique other people to like, because it is all about kind of picking them apart and compartmentalizing them. And yeah, and I and you saying that now like really makes me realize, like, that was part of the entertainment value of it was like, you're part of like, the judgment of these other people. And like, it's, it's like, that's so messed up. Because it's, I mean, really, that's just like internalized misogyny at its finest, right? Like, kind of teaching you to just like objectify another individual and, and break them down and like, think like, oh, they're not good at like, oh, like, no, they don't look good in that picture. Or their arm looks funny or whatever. You know what I mean?

18:12

Yeah, yeah. And he's just so hyper focused on on looks. Yeah. Focused on books. And

18:19

I have a funny side story. When I was 12. I went to a modeling camp. Next up model tell me everything. They told me I was too fat. Oh, yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. You wanna talk about things that messed with? I remember that. Yeah, exactly. And I had this like, really, really fucking feisty, best friend at the time. Yeah. And she like we got into a lot of trouble together. She was the one that kind of led me down a bit of like, behavior that was probably not appropriate for my age. She She actually went to this place like without me knowing or anything like that. And she just walked in there and fucking wring them out. And wow, you people are like

19:13

Oh, my goodness. So hard. How fucked up that used to say to a 12 year old I mean,

19:19

I know. I know. They said they were like, look you up and down was like, too fat. Yeah, basically, like, you couldn't like you went to this camps. You paid money for this camp. And they taught you like how to walk and like how to do I forget makeup? Like, is really disturbing when I reflect on it. Please don't see this as like a fault against my mother. I have no idea. Like, maybe I asked to go there. I don't know. Um, but definitely like do not send your daughters to modeling. And then so you pay money to go to this.

And then they have like an audition. And so then I went to this audition and they told me I was And here's the thing, like, at the time, like I, like I was not what you would consider fat like I like I had, I have, like I pretty much had the exact same body that I have now like, really? Like, it's like, if you look at pictures of me then it's like pretty much not that different. And so like definitely, you know, some curves more mid size but not like like, and not that there's anything wrong with being fat, but to call me that. And it's Yeah, yeah, yeah, I mean, it's just like, like, and obviously they use it in a derogatory way and not in like a positive way. Like, you can't be part of this. But yeah, I just wanted to throw

20:43

that in remember that? I never knew that about you some. Well, next time we hang out. You're gonna teach me your model, obviously.

20:52

Oh, yeah, you just watch me. You just walk.

20:56

Like let's go get some lunch somewhere that I see you walking down the street. Who is she? Look at that wall. Just days. I'm sat in that walk

21:03

with like mud stains on my jacket and like my mom fanny pack.

21:10

Fabulous.

21:14

Okay, why don't we do some of your shows? Because? Yes, yes. Yes. What were some of the wasn't messed you up? Oh,

21:20

the biggest one, the biggest one, which is what a lot of our audience said is the biggest loser. Yeah, is just a whole heap of fucked up. Fucked up pneus to the extreme. Oh, my goodness. And I loved it. Did you used to watch that show? Oh, yes.

21:41

Yes. Yes. I mean, I love I pretty much watched every reality TV show in the early 2000s. But yeah, I mean, I loved it. It was I loved

21:49

it. It was not, you know, it just felt like these bad fat people had finally got their shit together, had got onto that TV show, and we're making their life good. And so I could imagine, you know, what my life was gonna be like, once I did that made the same sacrifices that they were making. And then the good the ugly when someone didn't lose weight. And then they were making excuses. And I say excuse me with the quotation marks of but you know, I did the workout I did the I did the I ate no food, and I still put on weight.

And then, you know, the voiceovers of the other contestants being like, well, the numbers don't add up and then and then me being like, the numbers don't add up. If you really worked hard, you would have lost weight and that kind of Glee and judgment and then they get booted off and just being like look at them they're so pathetic they they were so close to achieving this incredible thing, but they were just so greedy and and what they made the contestants do was was so I don't know if the show is dead on but so dehumanizing. absolutely appalling. not healthy, not safe. Extreme, just got degrading, awful, hate it worse, uptime. Loved it.

23:09

And I remember you know, I remember seeing I think this is one thing's kind of like, like, started to crumble for that show. Because I remember seeing the finale when there was some woman like, and they did the reveal in the finale. They hadn't seen her for a couple months. And she was like, like, really? Skeletal basically. Yes. And I remember like they the trainer's face actually, like their jaw just dropped and like you could see like them even being like, holy shit. Like, what just happened? Like, this is too much, right? But then they won the show, and they had to celebrate it. And I think that's when maybe things took a bit of a turn for that show. Because it was like, it brought a lot of attention on the fact that this was really harmful. But, but I I don't think they I don't think it's on anymore. But Jillian Michaels was is isn't was the worst. Like, just like still

24:05

still. She had she hasn't learned like you would think from that moment. Because I remember that because they you know, everyone comes out and has a reveal. Oh, look at them. They're thin now. And then all the trainers are like, oh, yeah, amazing. And then when there's this other contestant I remember. And they were kind of like, oh shit, we fucked up here. But they're still doing it. Right. They didn't learn Oh, you know, actually inducing eating disorders for entertainment and, you know, physically hurting fat people for entertainment. Ain't a good look. I mean, because Julia Michaels and the other guy Bob Harper, they're still doing that shit and you know, and Bob Harper having a heart attack, you remember in the last few years, and no no consideration there either to be like No actually, you know, I'm quote unquote healthy but I still had a heart attack. Should I maybe consider what is healthy like nothing like that? They haven't learned, you know?

25:04

No, no, I Yeah. And I was gonna say like, the whole the this idea that like, like fat people need to be saved by like these thin tree like, did you feel that way? Like I just Yeah, I feel like that fed into this idea where people like even now are kind of like concern trolls where they're like whoa, like, what about people's health and it's like, you know, it's not your business but I feel like that fed into this whole like idea that like we have to save these people.

25:40

Yeah because if it wasn't for those kind hearted trainers, then those poor fat people would just be sitting on the sofa eating quote unquote bad food and dying. But thank God that these kind hearted thin people came along to save the fatties and you know, the when when they would do like the the before and after footage of you know, at their home life and the before of them being a human and just going about life. But you know, the way that they framed it was just like, this sad sack piece of shit greedy person. And then when they would be talking to camera like, oh my god, this is the most incredible opportunity of my life and oh, whoa, did you ever read? I did the The Biggest Loser book, The Secret Expo from Oh, what was her name? Chi hai.

26:37

Okay. Ah, no, I didn't I remember. Like, knowing about it. And I. But I but yeah, and but I've seen I actually, you know, I had someone on the podcast recently who was talking about the study that they studied them, the people and the biggest loser and how their metabolisms like, never returned to what they were before. That extreme behavior. And yeah, like, yeah, you sort of wonder like, what's happened to all of these people? Who were like, really just like dehumanized for entertainment. Yeah.

27:14

Yeah, that was that's a great that was from Newton New York Times that wrote that piece about basically, as well. The feeling of the deep feeling of shame that the people who haven't unlearned fat phobia and diet culture of, I had this great opportunity and I had lost weight. And now look at me, I'm fat again, because of my greed versus because my body is doing wonderful things to keep me awake that I'm happiest that and my metabolism fucked. And so I just went, Ah, if anyone is has been on a weight loss show or anything like that all Well, anyone who's been on a diet, then, you know, feeling that shame. I totally give him a big hug and be like, it's not your fault. Your body is doing what it wants to do.

27:55

Yes, yes, yes, yes. Yes. Yeah. Cuz there's, there's a lot of feelings of failure and just like something's wrong with me. Why can't I figure this out? And it's not it's not it's not your fault. Gosh. Oh, the worst. What else? What other shows

28:12

when my favorite movie for a long time was shallow? How did you see that

28:17

one? No. Okay, so I was aware of it, but I never saw it.

28:21

I thought it was fucking amazing. I was just like, Oh, finally, a film about a fat person with power throw in a fat suit. Okay, yeah, that was awful. And so Jack Black, who Jack Black is is a raging fat phobe as well unfortunately, even though he's been positioned as someone who's fat positive. He's there's no evidence to really presume that but anyway, he's like, meant to be an unattractive person. But he has like, really high standards and only dates thin people or beautiful people. And then he has some sort of episode or comment when we met Meet Tony Robbins in an elevator and Tony Robbins puts like a spell on him to be able to see the inner beauty of people and then he suddenly all the fat people are really beautiful and all thin people are really ugly, which I mean that's fucking problematic. Anyway.

29:20

This is about oh my god.

29:22

I'm so he meets Gwyneth Paltrow who looks like Gwyneth Paltrow. But in reality, she's a super sized fat woman in a reality, no fat suit. And she's really shocked that someone like Jack Black would be interested in her. And his friend is like, Oh, she's so mean. She's so disgusting. How would you date her? And at the end, nothing. Nothing is learned. It's just Oh, how how does a fat person who has wear big underwear? I'm like I did and ever since it's always been in my mind, about a partner holding up the size of my underwear because there's a scene in the thing being like, oh my god, your underwear so big it scarred me. The other time I thought it was hilarious and great and innovative.

30:10

So you did like it like you. And you were all like, Okay. Testing.

30:15

Oh my god, check black. He just loves anyone no matter what their size, even though the whole premise was that he wouldn't have liked her if he knew that she was fat.

30:25

Master.

30:29

Oh my goodness. Yeah. That was fun. That was fun. That was fun. Um, so did you have any shows that have had a good impact on body image for you?

30:43

Uh, yeah. I mean, I don't think there's any, you know, prior to like, three or four years ago. I think I mean, I think the best one that we've seen recently which everyone sort of echoed when we asked them is shrill right that Yeah. And so that obviously like just is a great show because it's about at Brian just like obviously it's the story of Lindy West, but just living her life like it's not about her body size. Like there's some threads of that in the plot because of it mimics Lindy stir. I mean, have you seen it? Yeah. It's great. It's hilarious. Right? Right. Yeah,

31:23

I watched finished. I'm finished watching season three, just a week ago. I think that was out. And I was just I was just, I just, I just love this so much. Yeah, yeah. And just, you know, scenes of her having sex. I'm just like, Fuck, yeah. And it's just, it's just to normalize fat people being seen as sexy and attractive and successful and, and complicated and imperfect. And all of these different things. Because, you know, fat people are normally the funny fat one, or the loser fat one, or, you know, very 2d characters, but it's just really beautiful to see.

32:03

Yeah, yeah. Yeah, I think, you know, like, another show that I've liked recently is the sex lives of college girls,

32:10

did you watch that? scene that,

32:13

I mean, it doesn't like it doesn't have like, a ton of body diversity. But it just it has, like, you know, people who are more like, a little more normal, like it has more diversity, just in general in terms of in terms of, you know, abilities and races and, you know, and gender and things like that, and so, and a little bit with body size as well, but it's just more about their lives. Like it's not about like how they look and and it's it's a Mindy Kaling show it's really good. It's Yeah, honey.

32:50

The number six thing sex education. Have you seen that

32:53

one? I love that I was gonna say that one I love that show that shows so great. And I get flicked again, probably too many people but like, it's a great show.

33:01

Yeah, that's the thing is a lot of times when they have diverse bodies, like in Have you seen euphoria?

33:08

No,

33:09

I haven't watched it. Okay, so it's really good. I love it. They've got Barbie Ferreira. I think that's her last name is a plus size model in it and she seems like she plays a plus size because she really she's she's in real in real life. She's pretty mid size. I don't think she is fat she's probably a size 1416 That type of thing. She is absolute She's She's a model right? So she's a model and so she we have this representation of diversity and all that and and euphoria we've got an amazing trans actor in there as well and great diversity but all of these people are literally models and so you know where they have a fat person but it's a fat person in the right way and and in sex education we have a couple of fat people but you know, I want to see ugly you know, I want to see people who just look a bit weird or people who who are not models basically because it's

34:17

like the right kind of have like fat body like they still they still have Yeah, you know, like the more like our glass sort of shape I believe, like is that is that kind of Yeah, exactly. Yeah, yeah. And so like actually seeing like, you know, people who represent what normal people look like, I feel so great because I feel like it does actually have like, you know, really good

34:45

at Brian is still pretty modelesque right? She's pretty beautiful. But you know what I want to see, I want to see thin people with saggy tits. I want to say show you mine. You want I feel like I want to see, I mean, who is walking around with, like, you know, the type of tests that we see in shows, like 2% of the population, right? I want to see tests that fall into people's armpits on a young person, because I know that's what my tics did when I was young. And I didn't see any of that, right. I only saw like, Oh, if you're a young person, you take to the ceiling, and you know, and I want to see fat people with saggy tits. I want to see fat people with big hanging bellies, and flat bums and disabled fat people and trans fat people and all other like, I just want I'm just so greedy and want it all summer. Give it to me all that place. Now.

35:45

I know. It's pretty sad that we can only think of a handful of shows. I know isn't like I was thinking about that. And I'm like everybody said, shrill. I was like, I was hoping there might be some other ones. Oh, yeah.

35:57

Well, I had. I had a couple of ones from from the poll that I did. I had trill was my number one. And then I had Cagney and Lacey. Did you ever watch that? No, it's two. I have never seen it because two women cops fighting sexism as they were doing their detective work. And then we had Roseanne. Now, I was wrote down a little bit, but that representation of fatness always terrified me, because Roseanne was quite a, from what I remember strong character. Like she was a no bossy or something. And I remember being like, Oh, if I'm, if I'm older and fat, then I'll have to be like Roseanne and no man will ever want to be with with a strong woman, you know? So but someone said that that was good for them. Oprah

36:47

which, okay, yeah. Listen me.

36:52

I mean, didn't Oprah bring out the barrels of fat?

36:55

I mean, she was always talking about her diet. And I suppose if I suppose if you take away some of the content that she presented then like,

37:02

yeah, yeah. Yeah. And then we have shrill. Oh, yeah. I said. He said, sure. Yeah.

37:08

I've mentioned a lot. We

37:12

show on in the UK, and in Europe, it was called Euro trash. Did you ever see that?

37:18

Ah, no, but it totally sounds like something I would have watched.

37:21

It was just the weirdest fucking thing it'd be on at like midnight, and you'd be like on Friday night or something, and you'd secretly have it on quiet, and then quickly turn it off if your parents came in, because it was basically I don't know, some, I don't know where it was from Germany, or, or some, some East some Eastern European accented host, who was like a little bit creepy and a little bit suave. And they would have these really diverse kind of sex stories. And so they would, they'd have like, porn stars, and people making art out of their pubes and people shitting on each other, and like weird stuff, and also diverse stuff and normative stuff, too. But yeah, you'd watch that and be like, secretly turned on watching, you know, some stupid fucking story about you know, people going camping naked. But it kind of show real bodies. And so that was that was that was that was the only thing from when I was young. So

38:23

I honestly can't think of anything. And it was interesting, like when we asked people because I think we both found feedback that everyone was like, basically anything in the 90s and just awful. Yeah. And and then like a couple others that people mentioned that were that were problematic, but I totally remember, like Bridget Jones's Diary. Like I just, I remember like, Yeah, I mean, it was like a great movie. But then this focus on like, her weight and the fact that she, like, I remember she had a game. Wait for the role. Oh, hey, yeah, she had a game like 20 pounds or something for the role? Well, she's

39:00

she's used to that trick now. Because in her new movie, she's she's wearing Well, she's wearing a fat suit now and her new movie. Oh, okay. Okay. Okay. Yeah, I can't carry on. Oh,

39:12

but yeah, but it was like the like she wrote like her weight in her diary. Like, I don't know if you read the book, but I've no, I watched the films I Yeah. And so it was it was all about like, like, what the weight was and like, she hated it and then trying to lose, like, like, that was just like this kind of undercurrent of the entire plotline. Yes, it

39:31

was just so useless and fat. And really, she was very, very straight sized. Like,

39:38

yeah, yeah. Like I remember at the time, like, I think I was the same size as her and I was like, Oh, my God, like there's something wrong. Yeah. You know what I mean? Like, so just like, no wonder so many people of that generation of body dysmorphia? I think that's like, a real

39:57

good, yeah, just all of the media is just just you know from that time, but even saying that the thing that I was really watching recently that I wanted to mention was and you you meant you were thinking about this too. All the new dating shows that we have nowadays is all like fucking bikinis on the beach, like models on the beach trying to learn how to date too hot to handle and even even the most cutting edge One Love is blind. Have you seen Love is blind? No. The premise is, will you be able to fall in love with someone without even seeing them? And Will you still love them after seeing them because they could be unattractive? Of course, every single motherfucker on the show is a model.

And so you know, they fall in love the doors open? Oh, look at that, oh, two models, we can find each other attractive. You know, sometimes there might be a bit of conflict because it's like, oh, actually, his hair is a different shade of brown that I like I like more of a mousy Brown and his is a bit darker. So we have to call the wedding off. But they've done one season and now season two is out. And I think they have tried to include a little bit more oomph, more diversity. And so they had a couple of fat people who didn't make any airtime. No airtime at all. But two of the people that are really so no spoilers if you haven't seen it, by the way, to the people that are focused on two female characters. Both of them are former fatties. And so there's a fucking violent out being like, Oh, I used to be fat. And it's such a shame. Very fat Monica vibes. And so they're like, Oh, will you still love me? Because I used to be fat. And now I'm thin and a model. Will he still love me? Because of my dark past of being fat. And I was just like, burn fucking who you are so normatively attractive, and you used to weigh a little bit more not even like fat fat? Yeah, yeah. Midsize fat. Yeah, because one of them was describing our weight. And I was like, Bitch, I'm like, 30 pounds heavier than that probably like, and she's like, Oh, when I was so unattractive, you know, obviously, they don't use those words when I was so well, they pretty much do

42:16

it loaded.

42:18

And I'm just like, really get out of that tiny little fucking violin because you are a model bitch, shut up, get in some real love is blind, proper people, you know, like, people who are struggling with dating because everyone rejects them, you know, and actually make it good. And so the shallow people when the doors open and they see a fat person has to say, I don't actually want to marry you because you're fat. And then then that then that will be have a conversation to have. But right now he's just models dating each other doesn't stop me watching it, though, doesn't stop me changing it. Because I like it.

42:53

I know. I know. I know. I never watched those shows. But I actually I ended up watching Bachelor in Paradise, the Canadian. Because the it doesn't matter why I stumbled upon it. And then I was like, Oh, I'm not tuning out like this. I'm completely sucked in and invested in the rest of this series. But I hadn't watched it. I hadn't watched shows like that. And like, in quite a long time. And I and I and I was just like, wow, like they just really cast like these people that I think they are models, I think most of them are just models, and that's where that's where they're casting them from. But one thing I really noticed was that the majority of these people are kind of they're in their 20s they have Botox, and like, lip fillers, like you can tell it's really obvious. And I'm like, what, like, that wasn't a thing. Like when I was that age, like that wasn't, that was never a thing. And so now what I noticed was just how the bar is set even higher. Like when I was that age, it was like you had to have fake boobs. You know, it's kind of like the standard be really thin and have fake boobs, which like not neither of those I used to duct tape my boobs together to try to make them bigger, and then put in these like, chicken collars that were literally the size of chicken breasts.

And so, anyways, but now it's like, you know, there's like another level, it's like, okay, no, no, they have to have, you know, they have to have Botox and, and like, you know, pillars and, and and like, I'm not criticizing people who do that at all or judging but it just to me was more like a reflection of a culture where you like sometimes I like to hope that things are sort of starting to shift and we sort of see that with certain TV shows. But then you see shit like that and you're like God, like no like the bar just keeps getting higher you know, like it just keeps getting like more procedures more like manipulating your body like molding into something. It's not like that's, that's just more and more of the standard and it's really a shame to see.

44:58

That is so true. Yeah. Because I remember yeah, getting getting breast augmentation was the thing when we were younger and then having straight hair using GHDs Did you ever get GHDs and Canada?

45:11

Isn't that like a dry?

45:13

Oh GH video thinking oh

45:17

what's GHD is

45:19

good hair days what it stands for, but it was like these straighteners and they actually work they go winter really highly and for the first time people like me who had like really fit frizzy hair could straighten their hair and finally be attractive and it was like the attractive light with quotation marks. And it was like the, you know, the highlight of my life discovering GHDs and everyone had them everyone still does have them probably. But yeah, we didn't have things like lip fillers and Botox and therefore be around but it wasn't really part of the conversation then,

45:52

though. Yeah, definitely not. So yeah, but I know we have to wrap it up here we could go on and on. There's probably some shows that we could talk about.

46:01

So where can people find you somehow

46:05

people can find me at the body image coach comm that will redirect you to my website and I have a free 10 Day body confidence makeover on there as well. You can find my podcast eat the rules.

Amazing. And you can find me at first fatty.com My podcast his podcast is fierce bounty. And you can find lots of freebies and amazing shit like pictures of me on my website and come and hang out with me on Instagram at face dot fatty.

Amazing. Well hopefully everyone now understands why. Body image laugh about some of these things and let it go. But yeah, that was it. That was a good one. Thanks. Yeah, we'll see you next time. See you in a while alligator. Thanks for listening to the episode and if you feel ready to get serious about this work and want to know when the doors open to fears fattier Academy which is my signature program, where I teach all about how to overcome your fat phobic beliefs and learn to love your fat body, then go to first party.com forward slash waitlist again, that is phase fatty.com. Forward slash waitlist to get your name on the waitlist. For when first party Academy my signature program open

EP114 Transcript

Welcome to the Fierce Fatty Podcast. I'm your host, Victoria Welsby, and this is episode 114. Today, we're talking about the latest science on trauma and weight.

I'm Victoria Welsby, TEDx speaker, best-selling author, and fat activist. I have transformed my life from hating my body with desperately low self-esteem to being a courageous and confident fifth party who loves every inch of this jelly. Society teaches us living in a fat body is bad. But what if we spent less time, money, and energy on the pursuit of thinness and instead focused on the things that actually matter? Like if pineapple on pizza should be outlawed? Or if the mullet was the greatest haircut of the 20th century? So how do you stop negative beliefs about your fat body controlling your life? It's the Fierce Fatty podcast. Let's begin.

Hello, fatties, and fatty Ali's Ali's allies Welcome to this episode. Let's just say yeah, nice to talk to you. How are you your rights? How's life fair to middlin fair to middlin I made a post I made a post of a tweet that I saw on it. I thought it was so fucking cute. It's a tweet from like 2019 but it's talking about sled dogs, dogs, dogs, and let me only read it out to you. Okay, so the person who tweeted it originally is Blair Braverman on Twitter. And I'll put a link in the show notes of the post. So I made it into an Instagram posts for you. Because you get to the dogs you can get to the puppies. But this the post reads, y'all because they're American. Let's pretend they're American. I don't know.

Actually, I think they are. Y'all have a sled dogs has been so good for my body image. And now because motion is joy field, physical outdoor activity. Although that's true. It's actually something much slimmer and simpler than that. I want to stop doing my shitty accent and I apologize. Apologize. I don't think even even think this was American. Anyway, if that was an American accent, you're you're having sled dogs have been so good for my body image. And not because mushing is joyfilled. Motion is a joyfilled physical outdoor activity. Although that's true. It's actually something much simpler than that. And there's a picture of a yellow lab dog with an orange to to going along with that. Continuing, I grew up learning that all bodies are different. Okay, yeah, that's true, whatever. But what is it different? I get it.

And then I started caring for sled dogs. I feed and train and massage them, teach them as puppies and ease them into retirement. We get to know each dog so well. And once we started doing this, do you know what became extremely obvious? And I got a little picture of the puppies get this, or what is it different. But I don't mean this in some flip way. I mean in a bone deep, beautiful, complicated way. All the dogs his bodies are so different. Some of them eat 1000s of calories a day, and are still complete string beans. They eat literally three times as much food as everyone else. Some of them can eat like a tablespoon of kibble, and the next day they need a bigger harness that easy keepers. Their bodies make their bodies naturally want to be bigger, which is good, easy keepers make great sled dogs. Some of them can start training in September and are immediately ready for the long runs. Some of them need to ease into training slowly, but they need gentler workouts and more training sessions before they can keep up with the rest of the team. Some of them want to run 1000 miles. This is my favorite picture. If you go on the postgame. Look at that one. In dog dogs silly. So cute was either flight continuing, some of them feel their best during shorter, faster runs. And occasionally some of them aren't that into running at all. Some of them have disabilities. And so on that one they've got a little dog inside next to the fireplace chewing on something in with a blanket.

And then there's another dog there. It looks like maybe that dogs blind or has cataracts in their eyes. Anyway, some of them were born with bodies that makes it make everything harder for them. And they need extra care and understanding to really shine. The point is, their bodies are so different. But the differences aren't good or bad. They just are we don't love Tolec more or less because He's skinny, or Colbert, because he's a chunkster. The idea makes no sense. It's absurd. And like, my body is like that, too. It has its own it has its own set points its own levels, so does yours. The dogs bodies aren't up to them, just like ours aren't. There's no value judgment. They are what they are. And every single one of them is magnificent. The end and then the final picture is of a dog getting a scratch under under their chin and looking all smiley with their eyes closed with the tongue. The tongue in their mouth looking happy. I thought that was so cute. And lots of people put messages saying I love it. And I think I loved it too. Like to start with that. I think a lot of people say Oh, I can get it now. Now that it's about dogs. Of course. Of course.

Of course. I don't love my one dog more because it's it's this or that and versus another dog. Yeah. My little doggy. My daddy. He's just he's just doesn't love him. Right. Okay, well, okay, well, it looks like he's a silly little sausage. Yeah, so today I wanted to this is today is going to be like an audiobook. Almost, because I'm going to read an article to to you. It's not my article I didn't write. It's from Judith Matz, who is an incredible person in the fat positive community. He wrote a piece for psychotherapy, networker, and it just really stuck with me. My thinking about this and thinking about this, thinking about this. About I've done an episode on off people fat because of trauma. Before Judith has written a new piece on the latest science, and the idea that in mental health worlds and multiple mental health fields, there is still this pervasive belief that fatness is caused by trauma, and even in supposedly, supposedly progressive spaces. This is still a belief and people think, well, you know, what's the harm in that? Because they're not blaming the fat people. But, you know, it's yeah, let let me read. Let me read this article. Okay. It's probably going to take me 20 minutes to read it so you can just sit back, relax. I might give some commentary here and there, but I'm gonna I'm gonna link to it by the way in the show notes, show notes for today's podcast. Face facebook.com forward slash 114 for episode 114 If you forget, if you ever forget whatever number that you're looking for, then you can just go to forward slash podcast, not not just forward slash podcast facebook.com forward slash forward slash podcast for the latest podcast or car. Crime. You he said he settle. He settled in. Are you sitting comfortably? You feeling good? Ah, okay, let's read this read. Let's read this. Okay. And learning weight stigma, the latest science on trauma and weight base due to Matt's January February 2022.

A few years back when professional meetings were all still happening in person I found myself admits fellow therapists grabbing the last seat in a packed conference ballroom, we waited expectantly for the presenter, popular trauma expert, Gabriel Mati after a keynote speech earlier in the day in which he argued that much of our suffering isn't biological or he or individual failure, but one stemming from the traumatizing nature of the culture we live in. I realized that matter his viewpoint aligned with how I see diet, culture and the impact of weight stigma as a medical doctor offering compassionate addict addiction treatment in Vancouver, Matty's willingness to see beyond the addiction to the traumatized person it consumes has made him a sought after teacher in the larger world of trauma treatment. As someone who specializes in binge eating body image and weight stigma I resonated with his capacity to see the entirety of a person in the context of their environment. So when a workshop participant a few rows behind me stood up to ask him about the connection between, quote unquote, obesity and trauma, I listened with interest. He correctly pointed out that fat shaming is a problem. But then went on to say that the reason quote unquote, obese people don't lose weight is that they need to keep eating to sue. Pain. Almost reflectively reflects reflexive risk reflexively, reflexively, my arm shot, my arm shot up, and before I knew it, a microphone was shoved into my hand. I leaned into the mic, my heart pounding and said, some people may binge eat to soothe pain, but the assumption that everyone will lose weight if they stopped binging or that all higher weight people binge is wrong.

Matt a paused then asked me, Are you familiar with the work of Vinson Filati I immediately knew where he was going with this question. For let he was behind a study that imparts suggests that sexually abused women seek to protect themselves from further abuse by gaining weight and keeping it on in the Body Keeps the Score trauma specialist Bessel Vander Kolk describes how the observations of valetti and internist and chief of Preventative Medicine at Kaiser permanent permit permanente lead to the Adverse Childhood Experiences scale. So if you don't know the the a scale, it's it says basically.

Actually, I'll just continue because it says it just right here. For that is work identified not only the extent to which the general population experiences trauma during their youth, but also gave practitioners a simple ranking scale of traumatic experiences that could help identify who's more apt to engage in high risk behaviors, the outcomes of which include addiction, unintended pregnancies, sexual tension and sexually transmitted diseases, and, quote, obesity. For that his ideas about the whys of higher weights are now widely accepted, especially the idea that someone of higher weight maintains that weight because of trauma. In fact, more often than not, this is offered up less as a possibility and more as a full blown assumption on the part of too many professionals. You see evidence of it everywhere, particularly given the popularity of aces in the therapy and healthcare world. In her book, The deepest Well, California Surgeon General Nadine Burke Harris repeats the story of for lettuce discovery, saying saying it goes quite a long way toward explaining towards explaining why his most successful patients, the one, the ones who had peeled off that protective layer, were so desperate to put it back on and quote, for that is fun. It is headed for Letty headed up his quote a beat obesity clinic from the mid 80s to the late 90s, using what he called supplemented, absolute fasting to bring about dramatic weight loss. Patients ate no solid food, only liquids and supplemented by essential vitamins, amino acids and electrolytes. One of his female patients lost 276 pounds over the course of a year.

And when she regained weight, surprise the Bruins. For that he attributed her rapid weight gain solely to the distress caused by a male coworker beginning to express sexual interest in her 10 days after learning of this particular patient's history of sexual abuse. valetti came across another patient with a history of sexual trauma and rapid weight gain. According to Vander Kolk, this was quote, only the second case of incest for Lety had seen in his 23rd 23 year medical practice, and quote, but when half of the obese patients in the initial study later revealed they also be sexually abused. He settled on the idea that there must be a link between higher weight and the abuse and a correlation between weight gain and protection against further sexual trauma. He did this without researching rates of sexual abuse among thinner people. Hmm, well, well, for that he only having heard about two cases of incest in his career says more about his not knowing to ask his subjects about sexual trauma than it does about the frequency of abuse. As we now know, people of all sizes are survivors of incest and sexual assault, and only recently in the area of hashtag me to have many felt emboldened to share their experience. From a just from a statistical standpoint, there's nothing surprising about Pilates finding given that two thirds of Americans fall into a higher weight category. It's to be expected The majority of people who have experienced sexual abuse or higher weight, yet many practitioners today have come to interpret for letters work as proof positive, that sexual or other trauma underlies Most cases of quote, obesity and the inability to permanently lose weight. Psychologist Deb Bogaard a leader in the health every size movement puts it this way, quote, the majority of people who blink are higher weights. If sexual abuse and body size are totally unrelated, we'd see that the majority of people who have experienced sexual abuse being higher weight some one arguing that fat people are less likely to have experienced sexual abuse could be as true could just as truthfully say that the majority of people who have not experienced sexual abuse are higher weight and quote,

even more important that's potent than statistics is biology. To those of us who work in this area, it's clear that consistently attributing weight gain weight regain to trauma and fear of sexual attention is an outright denial of the science. It's no surprise that for let his patients rapidly gain back the weight following extreme fasts, research on this behavior dates, bait dates to World War Two when conscientious objectors who agreed to take part in a study on starvation lost a quarter of their body weight and became irritable, depressed, lethargic and obsessed with food. Once free to Once freed to eat what they wanted.

Again, the men benched for weeks, but stayed ravenous as their body sought to become re nourished. I did a whole episode on that that's the Minnesota starvation experiment. And I also cover in that episode, the the Chava, ghetto study, very interesting stuff. Which is basically making people lose weight is not good. And other things. Okay, continue. More recently, a study a study of former participants in the Biggest Loser television show demonstrated the physiological consequences of intentional weight loss. When the show began, they met metabolisms burned the typical number of calories for their body size, they had slower metabolism metabolisms at the end of the show, as would be true for just about anyone who suppresses their weight through intentional weight loss. The big surprise was that their resting metabolisms remain permanently lowered. Demonstrating that weight regulation is more than a matter of calories in and calories out. Binging after a diet is every body's natural, every body's natural way of trying to protect itself from perceived famine. A recent weight loss study of nearly 300,000 people found that within five years between 95 and 98% of people have gained back all of the lost weight out or more for letting was reported reportedly looking for a trigger event explain weight regain. It never occurred to him that the physiological response to dieting for weight loss might be it. Don't assume you know your clients history. There's no doubt that binging is a survival strategy for many trauma survivors, including sexual assault survivors, and then it can lead to weight gain, especially if they try to change their weight through dieting. But I reject the implication that all higher weight people who tries to lose try to lose weight and then gain it back should be assumed to do so to protect themselves from sexual attraction or trauma based shame. Why does this distinction matter so much? When those of us in therapy in the therapy world assume that highway individuals have a sexually or otherwise traumatic past, it adds another layer to the fat shaming and weight stigma they're already likely enduring.

And as Gabbo Marty emphasized in his presentations, exposure to stigma worsens physical health. In the book anti diet Intuitive Eating dietician Christy Harrison explains the impact of weight stigma on alates allostatic load or the cumulative effect of chronic stresses are multiple systems in the body, which can worsen like diabetes and heart disease. A large 10 year study found those impacted by weight stigma were twice as likely to have a high allostatic load making it a quote an independent risk factor for physiological stress.

Along these lines, therapists should be aware that within size acceptance communities the word fat has been reclaimed as a neutral, objective or positive identity and that as I expressed a matter The term obesity in is in itself a fat shaming world. I fucking love that this, this hat this interaction happened and I hope gave a Matty listened anyway continue in 2013 The American Medical Association declared against the recommendations of its own scientific advisory board obesity to be a disease. Higher white people with health markers that fall in a normal range are now considered diseased within the medical field, including, according to one study 54 million people incorrectly labeled as unhealthy when relying on the BMI. If you check in with your higher weight clients, you'll find the probability that they haven't been fat shamed by the medical community to be extremely low. What's more likely is that they've been given harmful medical interventions in the name of weight loss, while not receiving adequate medical care for actual health conditions. They certainly don't also need their therapist to be offering interventions based on stigma and stereotypes. Take my recent conversation with Grammy nominated singer Mary Lambert, a fat queer woman Woman best known for her collaboration with the Macklemore song, same love. So good song that is, over the course of my life. I've had several therapists tell me that I was fat, because I subconsciously wanted to be undesirable and desexualized after sexual trauma, she said, I didn't see it is a harmful thing at the time. But in retro strip retrospect, the fact that some therapists perpetuate the concept of pathetic pathologizing fatness is incredibly awful and damaging. women who've been sexually assaulted or experienced trauma deserve coping mechanisms that aren't harmful. What a blessing then, is food, not a drug or an addictive substance, just the comfort of fullness. I'm so thankful for those behaviors that soothe me at a painful time. But we also have to stop attributing the behaviors of emotional eating to every fat person and interrupted the belief that thin people don't emotionally eat separate to the behavior from the characteristic of being fat. They are two different things, and you have no idea what someone's habits are, and quote Lambert's hid Lambert's healed many of the wounds of her trauma and made peace with food and found a loving relationship, and she remains at a higher weight. If our anti fat bias leads us to conclude She must still be protecting herself from unwanted sexual attention must have a few food problem is physically unhealthy, or even that high white people can't be sexually desirable, then we're complicit in upholding weight stigma and promoting the interventions for weight loss that are so damaging. Yes, and that's a that's another thing that I want you to to mention, is that by saying even just by saying that people are fat to protect themselves from sexual advances, is making the presumption that being fat is so so an attractive that it would protect from sexual advances.

And when we talk about sexual assault, that it's the person who owns the body's fault for being sexually assaulted. When it's not, and it's not about being attracted to someone. It's about power, right? And so it's just so many false assumptions and harmful assumptions there. Okay, continuing fat shaming with a clinical brush. I hear this dread of fat assumptions, fat shaming and diet prescriptions by professionals. For many of my clients, you like very likely have clients who also feel this dread. Perhaps you feel it to hire white people often avoid going to doctors or therapists because the stigma they experience is untenable. We know that for example, fat women have higher rates of cervical cancer because they're likelier than thin people to avoid getting pap smears due to smears due to the wage discrimination and prejudice they experienced. at the doctor's office. fat shaming and weight discrimination can even prove deadly. Take the case of Ellen Maude Bennett, a high overweight woman repeatedly told by medical providers that weight loss was a solution to her ailments, but it turned out that she actually had cancer. Her obituary reads a final message Ellen wants to share was about the fat shaming. She injured from the medical profession. Over the past few years of feeling unwell she'd sought out medical intervention, but no one had offered offered any support or suggestions beyond weight loss. Ellen's dying wish was that women of size make her death matter by advocating strongly for their health and not accepting that fat is the only relevant health issue. The therapy community has long prided itself on being an tentative to the hurried and often insensitive medical establishment, but it continues to contribute to the problem. If we automatically paint our higher weight clients with a clinical brush labeled sexual trauma survivor will only further alienate clients already sensitive to our anti fat biases. Promote the a nuanced belief that fat is a mental health issue and expect weight loss to be evidence of healing. Among the revered work of existential therapists Yvan olam is his story fat lady, in which he describes his strong reaction to the body of his client Betty in an afterword after what in an afterword written, I think that should afterward written 25 years later that acknowledges the letters he received from higher white women about the stories offensiveness, he owns the detrimental impact on his bias and says therapists need to openly explore similar biases in supervision so they're not imposed on the client.

According to the Red Center, psychologists ascribe more pathology, more negative and severe symptoms and worse prognosis to fat patients compared to thinner patients presenting identical psychological profiles. And a recent review of Harvard, Harvard's implicit bias studies showed a decrease in all categories, except weight bias. Given that we have no evidence based means of achieving sustainable weight loss for the vast majority of people, we also need to ask ourselves, why do we continue to use weight loss as a measure for psychological healing? Aubrey Gordon, the author of what we don't talk about when we talk about fat, right? Whatever we want to think about ourselves, we've got to make the shift from thinking anti fat bias is something we decide to do out of animus to something that exists within us unless we unless and until we uproot it. Binge Eating is an issue that can benefit from treatment, and it does attach to trauma. But questions about the history of any trauma should be asked of all clients, not just those at higher weights. And when working with clients who want to explore issues related to food and or body size, it's important to ask the right questions such as, what can you tell me about your relationship with food? When was the first time someone said your body was a problem? What do you think would be different in your life if you lost weight? How have you been impacted by weight stigma and bias? It's important to remember that your higher weight clients often experienced weight related bullying and shaming in childhood by peers, family and health professionals. These messages become ingrained in the psyche, referred to as internalized weight stigma.

According to Amy Pershing, co author of binge eating disorder, the journey to recovery and beyond the pathologizing of body size and prescriptions to restrict food intake limit that opportunity to identify and honor physical cues of hunger and fullness, and many have significant diet and weight cycling histories as a result,

when there is trauma and binge eating, when binge eating is revealed to be a strategy for coping with emotional stress distress, therapists should be aware that developing body awareness and trust plays a critical role in lessening the impact of traumatic activation. But this is difficult when survivors of physical and sexual trauma experience connection with their bodies as a trigger for shame. Now in his late 30s, my client Tyler grew up in a physically abusive home with an alcoholic father. Once when he was in middle school and engrossed in a book his dad called him from court for him downstairs. When Tyler didn't respond immediately, his father stormed upstairs and broke down his door yelling, you lazy fat slob. For the rest of his childhood, Tyler had no bedroom door. There's no privacy admit, admit the chaos in his home. Food became his go to for soothing or numbing and binging followed him through his college years and beyond, eventually becoming woven into his psyche as a way to care for himself.

Now a manager at a lab called large corporation Tyler's embarrassed by his binge eating and higher weight body. This came to a head when his company offered employees a reduction in insurance rates determined by their weight. When Tyler first contacted me, he desperately wanted to lose weight so that he could save money and fit in better quote with coworkers. But no matter how many weight loss strategies he had tried, he couldn't get his weight quote, under control. We work with the concept of a tune Eating also known as intuitive eating, with full recognition that working his way out of diet mindset would take time. He managed to decrease the frequency of binging. But the pace of progress frustrated him, and he wanted to know when He would know when He would be, quote, cured. Though I couldn't tell him how long it would take to take to heal his relationship with food. I wanted him to develop compassion for his needs to turn it, turn to it during times of distress. Over time, Tyler came to appreciate how binging as a child helped him survive a chaotic, unpredictable, and sometimes dangerous household. He began to understand that when his past trauma became activated, food was still his best option at times for calming his nervous system. He felt both angry and helpless that his workplace was essentially punishing him for his weight, especially now that he understood how dieting for weight loss actually exasperate is that exacerbated his binge eating. As we focused on building new skills to meet his needs, in addition to turning to food, he began to notice that more time lapse between binges, and that when a binge did occur, he could end it sooner than in the past. He also focused on ways to care for his body that did not require the pursuit of weight loss, including seeking medical care for his health conditions from a weight neutral doctor. Anti fat bias inherently assumes a thin body to be healthier, more desirable, and even virtuous. There is a goodness about being thin. This moralization of CIBSE further reinforces the body shame narratives clinicians are trying to treat. So it's imperative that we recognize that we're at cross purposes if we're trying to help clients heal from body shame by focusing on changing their bodies. Even if weight gain is the result of a trauma driven eating disorder. The reality is that a client may or may not lose weight in the course of recovery. That's what it's meant means to be weight neutral. Ultimately, Gabor Ma Tei responded to my comments with openness and curiosity when I made a point at his workshop, and we continued our conversations throughout the conference. I've heard from many clients and colleagues that they find the find resources such as the Body Keeps the Score, and the deepest well extremely helpful in understanding their own clients trauma, but they're triggered by the Philately material that blames body size on trauma, promotes weight loss and exalt ignores the lived experience of higher weight people.

As mental health clinicians, we can do a better job of not contributing to this trigger to this triggering, we can use language that describes their actual behavior, which is binging and stop conflating, quote, obesity with trauma, we can understand the science of weight regulation and stop viewing higher weight bodies as pathological. I also urge those who treat trauma and especially those who are leaders in the field to familiarize themselves with the true nature of weight based trauma so as not to further traumatize or be it unintentionally, people, people who already experienced weight stigma end and it says due to Judith mats l CSW is a nationally recognized speaker and co author of the making peace with food car deck, the body positivity card deck beyond the shadow of a diet and the diet survivors handbook. She has a she has a private practice in the Chicago area. Contact Judas and Matt stock calm. Oh, can you imagine that? How lucky that patient Tyler that she was talking about got to meet her and not anyone else? Because how often is it that a patient gets to access care from a haze aligned provider? Like one in a gajillion chance now, you know that's that's overstated. But you know, it's you know, I just I'm so pleased that that person had that good experience and nice to hear that gavel Matty was open because he's from Vancouver, right which is where I am and it's all my phobic image based here so you know they call it Hollywood Hollywood North here because they do lots of filming but also you know, is pretty much is you know, Lululemon yoga and smoothies type place. Vancouver's great like, you know, that's a big part of the culture.

Anyway, so love that article. And some important so important so you know that the one quote that I really liked was about blinking Basically, where is it? The depth, the guard said that the majority of people who blink are higher weight. So if sexual abuse and body size are, if sexual abuse and body size are totally on right related, we'd see this in the majority of people who've experienced sexual abuse being higher weight. Yeah, so yeah, that idea of you know, more, you know, fat people are more likely to get this and that and Lola. And yeah, fat people are more likely to blink, you know, the majority of people who blink a higher weight, because there's just more, there's more fat people than there are things people. But, yeah, I like that. I like that. I like that. And I did a little reading for you that you should not be reading. I made a few mistakes, mistakes. But you know, I think that hopefully, I don't have a too annoying reading voice for you there. So a little article reading for you. If you go into work, or walk in the door, whatever you're doing, going to sleep doing the dishes. My favorite time to listen to relaxing podcasts is bedtime. But my favorite time for listening to funny podcasts is listening is walking Google. Because you know, you don't want to be laughing when you're falling asleep. You know, so I wonder when does I think when does my podcast go on in your life? I think my podcast is a doing something like doing the dishes. doing the laundry. That's what I think. Am I right? Are you doing the laundry right now? Are you doing are you having to walk right now? Yeah. So yeah, that's all I wanted to share today. Hope that you're doing well, and that you're alive and stuff. Everything is good for you. Oh, I forgot to mention. I've been on a couple of days with a human person. I had some smooches I met someone who was like so forward thinking and progressive everything that I talk about social justice wise, he's like, yes, and has tons of his terms of opinion. Even on fat stuff. And he's a straight size guy. I'm just like, oh my god, this is amazing. So listen, there's there's people out there there's people out there he's like saying to me Oh, you need to start a plus I store because there's only two places in Vancouver that I can show up and he's like, oh my god this is ridiculous. And he's like and plus I suppose is so expensive. I'm like Yes.

Great. This is great. Great. Great. So if you're dating you know not saying that this you know, I'm going to be with this guy forever anything I had a couple of dates with him but just saying there are progressive people out there who will be like oh my god, yes. I agree with you about ridiculousness of fatness. They exist and you don't have to settle for people who were like, yes, grace to be fat. Which is unfortunately the majority of humans in the world. Have that opinion.

Anyway, whatever. I'll stop getting annoying. I'll stop talking about people who are annoying. Not that I'm annoying. Anyway, thank you for tuning in. I appreciate it. I hope you have a wonderful rest of your day whatever you're doing if it's a laundry if it's walking the dog if it's having a PO have it's great for you. And we'll see you in the next episode of air Sramana by crocodile.

Thanks for listening to the episode and if you feel ready to get serious about this work and want to know when the doors open to fears fattier Academy which is my signature program, where I teach all about how to overcome your fat phobic beliefs and learn to love your fat body. Then go to phase fatty.com forward slash waitlist again that is phase fatty.com. Forward slash waitlist to get your name on the waitlist. For when first party Academy my signature program opens

EP113 Transcript

Welcome to the Fierce Fatty Podcast. I'm your host, Victoria Welsby, and this is episode 113. Today, we're talking about "toxic" food.

I'm Victoria Welsby, TEDx speaker, bestselling author and fat activist. I have transformed my life from hating my body with desperately low self-esteem to being a courageous and confident fifth party who loves every inch of this jelly. Society teaches us living in a fat body is bad. But what if we spent less time, money, and energy on the pursuit of thinness and instead focused on the things that actually matter? Like if pineapple on pizza should be outlawed? Or if the mullet was the greatest haircut of the 20th century? So how do you stop negative beliefs about your fat body controlling your life? It's the Fierce Fatty podcast. Let's begin.

Hello, and welcome to this episode we're talking about toxic food. Yeah. No, not that type of Britney Spears, toxic food but the normal dye wedges, dye culture bullshit. We've got another episode of death to diets today with my co host this summer in an urn. And yes, I've been watching the URL Netflix as I do. And super excited to see the new Jonathan Vanness TV show which is called getting curious with Jonathan Van Ness. Seen a lot of promo from trans folks because there's an episode on gender and really excited to check that out and first few episodes Love it. Love it. Great talking about bugs talking about hair talking about gender amazing. Episode in the middle of the of the series goes into why do I love snacks so much is the title of the episode?

And was this a delightful foray into the wonderful world of snacks? No, it was not. It was not a delightful foray into the wonderful world of snacks. It was it took a dark turn into a debunked science from 1996 fatphobia food shaming, basically a ton of bullshit. And it made me it made me sad. I was I was watching I was watching the show. And I watched I watched the the gender episode and I would like put on my stories. Oh my God talking Jvn I love this. I'm Maya Angelou. Oh finally you know a non binary

a non binary perspective and an episode and talking about you know, intersections with racism and all of that juicy stuff. And then the next episode comes on and then I'm like, I'm probably being like, do not watch it. avoid, avoid if you don't want to be triggered. And people were people were triggered, right? And I got a few messages from people saying, oh my god, right. I thought it was just me. I thought I was being sensitive and I know you're not being sensitive. You're not being sensitive. That was motherfucking bullshit and a few actually a non binary trans fats activists called Jamia now and so I thought when I have a little chinwag about it Yeah, so that's what today's episode about is about another you know, toxic food ideas which need to go into the bin because they in themselves are toxic.

As I said, I'm slipping under right so let's go to this episode. And enjoy it. Enjoy it. Okay have the best time with summer and I welcome to the show today which we're talking about toxic food and the show is death to die it's what is death to die it's so much in an in.

It is a series that we are doing together where we explore Our diet culture nonsense. And we are not here to shame people who diets rather we are here to look at the the culture of dieting, and the problematic elements of that. And its intersection with body image and lots of other things. And do you want to do a personal intro first?

Yeah, so my name is Vinny a Welsby. They them I am a fat non binary incredible human that teaches about fatphobia weight bias, health ism. And I'm friends with some Yeah, that's me.

I'm a summer in an in she her I am a professionally trained life coach, I specialize in helping people with body image, self worth and confidence, and I am friends with Vinny.

He will find out quote unquote, toxic food. And there's gonna be a big trigger warning for this episode, because we're gonna be, we're actually going to be talking about food, beliefs around food and beliefs around food addiction, sugar addiction, mentioning what someone eats in a day, we're going to be actually mentioning quantities, and what they eat. And that's going to be in the first section. And then in your section you're going to read, yeah, there's some, there's some sound bites from a particular article that was called toxic. That, that that may be, you know, like, just, you know, if you're feeling sensitive, or any, you know, we're going to be dissecting it. But when we talk about some of the quotes that are in the article that I would say that some of that stuff, we're just gonna put a content warning ahead, if you're sensitive to talk about, you know, like, the O word or stuff, you know, that implies that the amount of food you eat, it's going to make your body larger and things like that. So, but we're going to be smashing it all apart. So hopefully, you'll be fine. But just giving a content warning before that, too.

Excellent. And the reason why we decided to do this episode is quite timely, is that I very excitedly started watching Netflix as I do 27 hours a day of my life. I started watching Jvn Jonathan Van Ness, his new show called getting curious with Jonathan Van Ness Jvn. They are from query, which is another show and you've never seen it. So I can't believe it is but there's like, five seasons.

I watched queer I like back in the 90s or when it first came out, but I haven't like I like not in the last, like not since that first iteration of it. So Jvn. Like I although I know who they are, you know, you were showing me a picture. I'd be like, Okay, I recognize that face. Not familiar, like don't follow like, just, yeah.

So you're, you're lucky you didn't have to experience this today, which is empowering about it.

So So Jvn is a non binary, queer, hairdresser, fabulous human. excited for the new show, the new show. first started talking about books was the first episode the next episode was gender, and hair, and then gender.

And then and it was like so kind of deconstructing all of these different ideas and racism and all this stuff. And then the next episode was titled, Why do I love snacks so much? And I thought this would be like an ode to like, a love letter to snacks and why it's so wonderful. So I was like, Oh, great. We're gonna deconstruct the idea around snacks and why we love them and why they're great. And in the beginning of the episode, the first phrase that I picked my kind of red flag waving going off was the phrase, processed foods. Jvn said processed foods and I was like well keep watching. This is not sounding good so far. But then they went to a donut factory. And Jvn was like, oh my god, this is amazing. enjoying eating the donuts. It was cool and magical.

Then they actually saw someone else but then The big chunk of the program was Jvn meeting, a stony faced thin, white, quote, food addiction experts. As soon as I saw this person on the screen with that title, and she was just so miserable as well. Like, you know, I'm here to judge you come on the screen. I was like, Oh shit. Oh shit even not me that title Hey, summer food addiction expert. What that meant?

Well, that maybe she's hungry. She was why she came on kind of mean, I don't know, I haven't seen it. So I'm just throwing that out there.

I'm telling you, she is hungry as shit is what she like.

Thank God. So anyway, the first thing she says, Jonathan, share what you typically eat in a day. And so Jonathan pulls out from our bag, all of the things that they eat in a day. And so skip ahead a couple of minutes here cuz I'm gonna I'm gonna share what what Jvn is. So for breakfast, he has coffee is what he said. And then at lunchtime, he has a small salad. And then at dinner time, he has this small vegan pizza. And then he has some candy, some sweet things. So he says I have a pop tart. A Gusher. I don't know what that is an Oreo. So that is what Jvn says that they eat in a day now summer. If someone told you that's what they eat in a typical day, what would your reaction be?

Um, how are you feeling? Because that, to me sounds like what, like less food than my toddler eats? I would be absolutely starving. If I ate that. And I know that this person is a grown ass adult. So my guess would be that they're probably starving.

Yes. And actually, I forgot to mention jva did share that he has a chocolate covered pretzel and he offered one to Stonyface food addiction expert. And she looked like he had just offered her a steaming pile of shit. And she was like, No, I'm okay. I'm fine right now. You know, like put those disgusting. yogurt covered covered pretzels are way You beast? How dare you? I think though, secretly, she was probably like, oh, how am I gonna prep? Yeah, so my reaction to it was like, holy shit. JPN you must be fucking starving all of the work that you do, running around the world. Being Fabulous. Working so hard making these TV shows. And that's all you're eating? And then you're not are you having like coffee for breakfast? Which is I mean, and then and then you're confused as to why that you you might eat sweet things in the evening. I mean, to you and isomer it seems really clear that that Jonathan is not eating enough.

And because of that he because he says he struggles with with binge eating is that he is eating more during the evening, because he's not eating enough. And he's restricted so much throughout throughout the day. So to me, it seems really clear what what needs to happen here.

It's super Yeah, I mean, it's super obvious. I feel like any, any any nutrition expert, like even if they're kind of in meshed in, in diet culture, like, would still see that there's like an immense lack of, of caloric consumption happening for the majority of the day, and therefore, you know, that's problematic in and of itself. So, yeah, like I I mean, even when, in my dieting days, I would probably be like, That's not like you're not eating. I mean, it's extremely obvious to me now. But I mean, like, the fact that he's working with like, you know, a professional, and they're not identifying that, to me, just seems so hugely, hugely, hugely problematic.

And you think about all the people watching this show, and then thinking, Well, I must have a problem. You know, or like, I should be trying to eat coffee for breakfast only or, you know, all this other crap, like I know enough about Jvn to know that they're a pretty huge influence or like, have a pretty huge influence, right, like a massive following a lot of people look up to them and so to know that you You know, other people are going to see this and potentially then pathologize themselves as being, you know, binge eaters or addicted to food when, what what is just happening is like, a normal reaction to restriction like a normal reaction. Yeah,

yes, yes, yes. And so. So yeah, what happens is her what she says is very kind of try not to judge him too much for eating all of this quote unquote bad food, she says. So I think we can talk about some of the problems coming from this type of diet. And I, you know, I'm thinking, okay, come on, like, this is your last chance, this is your last year, this is your chance to say, you're not eating enough. Like, this totally makes sense. While you think you might be, you know, addicted to sugar or whatever. And she says, she goes on to say, because my concern is that eating a diet like this is going to catch up to you. I hate that whole fucking, it's gonna catch up to you. Like there's, you know, like, this disease is coming to get you if you eat an Oreo, you know, like, it's gonna stalk you down. You know, you might not feel it right now.

But in the future, you better watch out because if you eat an Oreo, now, you're gonna die, basically. So anyway, she says, it's going to catch up to you. I'm worried about what you might look like on the inside after eating like this. Oh, I just inside.

Whoa, wow. I think because like, Jvn is really thin, right? Like, are they really skinny? Like, no, no. They're not. Very straight size. They're just straight sized. Okay. Okay. But nonetheless, if, if, if they were fat. What do you think? What do you think this person's response would have been? Oh, just like, there's something wrong on the inside. Right? Yeah.

Yeah. Inside and outside, because you're fat clearly. Yeah. Yeah. So continuing, she said, what you just showed me is sending you down the path of having some serious health problems later on. A lot of this food is bringing you down. It's tough. A lot of people in this in this country are in an abusive relationship with sugar. We're finding this O word crisis in our country, where more than half of the country is struggling with being a word or Oh, word. And a lot of that is tied back to the things that we are seeing here. Sugar rich and processed food. You've developed a dependency on these foods

so wrong. Everything like little thing like half of people are struggling with being fat. Bitch, I am struggling with being fat. I'm fucking out here being fat and fabulous. Ain't no struggle here with me being fat, just like even basic things like that and saying, You have developed a dependency on these foods.

No, you you're you're hungry. And these foods provide quick energy. And so you naturally gravitate towards them when you're hungry. Like that's basic physiology.

And so Jonathan said, No, those words, I had to go to rehab before for those words, these feel like such big words. And so even Jvn is like, oh shit, this sounds serious. And then this woman is like, it is serious, and then compared him eating food and sugar to drugs and alcohol. And then Jvn confessed very shamefully that he thinks that he is a sugar addict. And i My heart was just breaking. And by the way, when I first watched this episode, I got to the bit where she started saying the O word. And I turned that shit off when I got straight on Instagram being like Oh my God. And so for for the audience. I went back and watched it again and watch the whole thing. I wrote down exactly what this motherfucking stupid food addicts expert wrote down so you're welcome. I'm traumatizing myself by by looking at that show.

Thank you for your service.

The nutrition is then said that the sugar industry is tripping Jvn because sugar masks the bitter taste from chemical additives and dyes and other things that are in processed food. And then Jvn did is this bit this kind of side segment on chemicals. How how how chemicals have long names. And some chemicals are used in other processes outside of food, and are also used in making food. And so if a chemical is used in one process, therefore, it can't be used in food making because that means it's toxic. And science tells us tells us if you can't spell or pronounce a word, it means that it's toxic. Isn't that true? Isn't it that backs? You know, I don't even think that they taught us that in nutrition school. Is that bullshit? You didn't learn it in nutrition school?

Yeah, I don't know. I'm trying to remember. But I feel like that's probably more of a literacy issue than like, she is just such it's just it's one of the things like, oh, this food, it's got so many names that I can't pronounce. Therefore, it's bad for you know, and saying it has built a DA chemicals. Well, yes. Because every fucking thing is a chemical you donkey. Like, come on? Like, oh, my goodness. So food shaming there. What?

And I think the issue is just that they they like laser and on on one tiny piece of like, this massive puzzle of health. And it's, it's like, if, if that focus was the issue, like, you know what I mean? Like, it's like, it's a red herring for everything. It's like, let's just blame like, the chemical in the in chemicals in our food versus like, really looking at the big picture. And, and what is what is really contributing to people's, you know, health, ultimately. Yeah, exactly. Yeah,

it is totally a red herring. Yeah. And then actually, someone said to me that this was really difficult when, and I mentioned it to you is that this, this food addict expert, brought out pictures of a brain and saying, like, this is what a brain looks like on sugar. And she said, quote, you're always chasing that high like a drug addict, end quote. And that if you eat too much sugar, you're going to have an abnormal brain. Then she shows a brain, which of someone who has used cocaine, and sugar next to each other. And she said that this eating sugar is a brain condition. And so because she brought out images of brains, that's so convincing, right, so convincing, well, oh, my God, look, it's clear as day someone has, has used cocaine, and it the dopamine is lighting up just the way it does when someone has eaten sugar.

But what they don't show is another slide, which shows the brain when you are hugging a kitten, the brain when you see someone that you love the brain when you have a really enjoyable shit. Because guess what it lights up to, it's our pleasure. It's, you know, what's what's causing us pleasure in lights up. And so they don't show all of the other stuff, they just show the Kokee to stigmatize people who might have addiction issues, and to stigmatize people who eat sugar, which is, you know, we need it to live, it's just up.

And, like, you know, I mean, you know, how I feel about this. And, you know, you know, we both know how that whole sugar addiction thing is, has been, you know, dismantled and broken down and is, you know, not really a thing. But what is your experience been with clients and personally around this? Because I can see you too.

Oh, my goodness, that is such a good question. Because I'm telling someone that sugar addiction doesn't exist, or food addiction doesn't exist. It doesn't matter because your experience my experience, your as in people in the world experience is that they are addicted, and I was 100% sure that I was addicted to food because I could not stop thinking about it. It's all I ever wanted. And I was really hyper focused on it. But why might that be summer?

What could it be that really restricting things? Or did you feel like those foods were bad or forbidden? Oh, I'm thinking exactly. Yeah, yes, exactly. What was going on? You see that with clients don't you a lot.

Yeah. And myself, I mean, over and over and over and over and over. Like I used to be the type of person that was like eating cake from the pan standing in my fridge. Like, why can I stop like I have no control like I am addicted to this. And then when I started feeding myself like a grown ass woman, I just don't like, sometimes I forget about food, like in the fridge, you know, cake is just cake. Like, I'll have some if I want it. And a lot of the time, I'm just like, I don't feel like it because I am fed. And I know that I can have it anytime I want. And I don't believe it's bad. And I have done enough, like unlearning on, like all this bullshit that we're supposed to look at food as if it's toxic and forbidden.

And it's just neutral, like food is just food, there's no, like, there's no morally, you know, superior foods. It's really more about, you know, having a healthy relationship with it. And all like all of this stuff is driven by, you know, our culture's obsession with, you know, being thinner, and like watching your weight, so to speak. And I mean, I just, I've never not seen this, I've never had a client come to me and still be like, I can't stop eating sugar every time it's like, once the foods become, you know, you once the food is no longer off limits, I think is what I'm trying to say. And they get to a point where it's just not a big deal. And they will forget about it or have one bite of it or or eat a lot of it, because they want it and enjoy it and maybe get a tummy ache sometimes. But like that's the extent of it.

Yeah, exactly. And the big way that we we can know that it's not an addiction is that when you increase your exposure to an actual addictive substance, your symptoms increase, whereas with food or sugar, if you increase your exposure, the symptoms decrease. And so what we need to be doing is the opposite is is allowing ourselves the sugar, the food, whatever it is that we are feeling like we are addicted to. And then lo and behold, turns out we weren't addicted, we were just obsessed, because we denied ourselves so much. Mm hmm.

Yeah, so a bunch of people called out, you know, gvn, just kind of just speaking to the problematic nature of the episode, especially as it like, really didn't fit with the rest of the sort of series that you're talking about. Right. And they responded and they

Yeah, and just to kind of wrap up what happened at the end of the episode is, is this illusion to this addiction that he has, is to eat only organic cookies, which has sugar in it Ah, yeah, because the sugar is in the form of a syrup, and not white sugar, which apparently is you know, not you know, gonna doesn't know the difference.

And, and also these these, these cookies are good, because good, quite good, because they don't have anything in there that you can't pronounce. So that's going to help with the sugar addiction, apparently. And this says nothing about you know, like, this is so fun. Like that's, that's, that's the thing to do is eat an organic cookie, which of course, are going to be like $75 per cookie board to eat organic cookies. So in a you have a quote unquote, food addiction, or sorry, you're fucked, you know. And then the episode ends with Jvn being at the fridge, opening it closing it debating about having something to eat or not, and then a cartoon mouse saying, Are you thirsty, perhaps instead of being hungry, hungry? And then the resolution is that Jvn decides to have half an Oreo cookie and gives the other half to the mouse.

And I thought that was pretty funny. Because half an Oreo cookie, when really, you know, they wanted to eat something more like that is fit for a mouse, you know, not a human being busy doing life, you know, like, you need to eat some more. Yeah, so Jvn actually responded to Moxie mind, because Moxie mind made a post saying this is fat phobia, and Jvn said, Hi loves, I'm sorry, as someone who is in recovery, I'm learning as I go. It's part of why I explored this in this series. I'm never done with learning on a subject. I'm always going to want to do more. As we discussed in this episode, we have to take the shame and stigma out of this conversation and emphasize it's not about it's not the individual's fault, but an industry wide system that needs so much healing.

So basically, he's saying it's not your fault that you might be a sugar addict. It's the system. There are so many ways to heal and learn I'm not perfect and I'm learning and sharing as I go I could always do better but as they say people are doing the best they can with what they know I've been struggling with binge eating my entire life. I don't want to have a conversation about it. And I'm certainly not done talking about it. I'm excited to keep learning and growing around this topic, heart, love and light. Yeah.

Yeah. Well, you know, like, at least they responded. And I mean, people will hear what they want to hear when they're ready. And I don't think that you can necessarily force that on people. But it's just unfortunate that a lot of other people probably were impacted as a result of that episode, because it just further reinforces this belief that, you know, there's something wrong with them, and they just need like a different meal plan to fix the fact that they're just fucking starving mentally and physically, you know?

Yeah. Yeah. And a lot of people weren't happy with with that response. And, you know, because, you know, Jvn is not saying, I fucked up, you're absolutely right, I'm going to learn from fat, fat non binary people. It sounds like they still believe that they are a food addict, or you need, you know, like, how do you I think they're gonna have their own awakening and whatever. Time is right for them? I don't think you can. I mean, you and I both know, you can't you can't convince someone, if they're, if they don't want to hear it. Yeah. And I think it's a hard thing. It's a, it's a hard thing to convince, when there's probably some level of, you know, fat phobia in, you know, inside about, like, you know, I can't like this must be an issue, right? Because the notion of just being able to eat what I want is probably too scary because of the public beliefs.

Yeah. So I sent Jvn a DM saying, Oh, hey, if you want me to be like, you know, a fat person on your show, then let me know, shoot my shop, nothing probably won't happen, obviously, because they probably don't check their gene at DMS. But you know, you never know,

you never know, they responded to the comments. So you just never know. But actually,

you know what some other people have have made posts about it. And Jvn has blocked everyone that's made posts about it. So oh, they only commented on that one. And then the conversation now is shut down. Oh,

well, they got to manage their mental health. I don't know. Yeah. Yeah. I feel bad. I don't know.

Right? Yeah, yeah. That's that. I mean, we've taken up half an hour talking about that matter the show, longer than what the show was really. around this idea of toxic food, somehow,

I found a Newsweek cover that said toxic food that came out, I think around, like around Christmas or beginning of January, obviously, like kind of coinciding with the whole diet season. And, you know, it really, it when you when you mentioned this episode to me, I was like, oh, like, we got it. I mean, it's exactly what was in this article, like, essentially, just reinforcing all the different things that that you've said. And, you know, like, when I when I saw it, and I read it, I was like Jesus Christ, like, is it like 1996 called they want their magazine covers back? Like, why are we still talking about the same thing? But like, clearly, like, clearly is not really like the issue, you know what I mean? Like, it's not the, it's not, again, it's like, it's the red herring. Right.

And so, the article really talks about how, you know, ultra processed foods, that's the sort of, you know, label that they've given them are things that, you know, big food, the system, which I used to work for. I don't remember ever being in a meeting room where people were scheming about like, we got to get people to eat more. Um, so you were there. You're like, yeah, like capitalism ramp it and of course, they care about profits. Of course, it's all about the shareholders. Of course, it's all about sales. But I think this idea that there's like these evil like, Masters behind it trying to, you know, I just, I'm not I'm a little skeptical of them. Yeah.

Yeah. Because they that if you think they're trying to kill people always that it's not a good idea to kill people because then who's gonna eat your food? You know?

It's an easy it's an easy scapegoat. Because I think I think again, like the problem is much bigger than just this one little piece of the puzzle. And I'm not saying that like, you know, the food industry is all great like that. There's absolutely issues with industry, but but they you know, they echo basically the same things that that you said that, you know, we that these ultra processed foods are designed to directly target the vulnerabilities of the human brain. And that they are, they deliver like a quick signal to the brain's reward system. So many people find them as addictive as opioids or nicotine. But then then they go on to just call them possibly addicted. Like, pick a lane. You know, and, and really just saying, you know, that this is the problem, people can't stop eating them. And the conclusion is that, you know, whatever these food chemists are doing to food is just is, is making people fatter. And obviously, they're talking about that, and in like, a very negative sense, because the article opens up with, please don't read this article, like, it's, it's very heavy on the O word, it's very heavy on the, you know, this is it's your individual problem, that you've gained weight and you're unhealthy. And like, it's it, there's so much bullshit in it, that it's, like I said, it's like 1996 calls, you know, it's like, it's like, so outdated, and in so many different ways. And a couple of things I just wanted to pull out was, you know, they mentioned that between 1980 and 2000. That's when like, obesity began to rock it upwards. Well, do you know what happened in that period of time?

Tell me what happened that period of time, zona.

They altered the BMI to lower it to say, Okay, now people over this amount are considered, you know, oh, and therefore, maybe that's why do you think maybe that's why it's skyrocketed.

Sounds very convenient, doesn't it? That means that people overnight, suddenly became to fats. Yeah, and you know, the skyrocketing a number of people when it's just a category has been changed. And arbitrarily like, the fact that the the BMI is, you know, 2025. Because it was easy numbers to remember. There's no reason it's just because it was an easy number to remember. It's the number five, so yeah, mm. Yeah. And also, like, who benefited from that change? You know, pharmaceutical companies peddling waves, weight loss drugs, and? Yeah, yeah, exactly. Exactly. And so, you know, the article is quite lengthy. And it really covers a lot of the same stuff that was unfortunately covered in that episode that you watched. And I think that, like ultimately, it's just, it, there seems to be this issue of like, people eating more, but it's like, they never factor in the influence of diet culture. They never influence they never take into account like any of the other variables that might drive that like whether some whether or not someone has a living wage, like what you know, what are their what, what other social detriment? I can never say this word profitably. detrimental. rentals, yes. Of Health, like what are you know what I mean? Like, yeah, what, what, what are these other factors that ultimately have, like a greater influence on someone's health? Like, what role is that playing in, in these increases in diseases? You know, what I mean?

Yeah, and the idea that, you know, really, what we need to be looking at is, shame, the amount of shame that people are experiencing, and the amount of oppression that they're experiencing, but it's so much easier to say, just an organic cookie than it is to say, um, maybe there's an disparity between how black people experienced health care between other populations, you know, because it's so easy to blame the individual and be like, eating organic cookie when What the fuck is that going to do?

Yeah, yeah, that's elitist health. Like, yeah. Through and through, you know, that's like the goop world, right? It's so good pay. Oh, my God.

Yeah. Are we just making that a verb now? Like, yeah.

Is that a would that be considered a verb or a noun? Or an adjective? Yeah, maybe?

Yeah, it's a word. It's a word. It's a word now that, you goopy, goopy. And you think it's like, a way you know, like with this episode, you see those slides of the brain and then you're like, Oh, my God, it must be real. And you'll see this article that's so long, but so chock a block full of linking through this study linking to this other thing and law or we all know that it becomes overwhelming and then you start to think Hang on. Is it true, and then then you start to really kind of feel that shame and your health is affected.

And the thing is, you know, you and I were able to dissect this and say, ha, you know, let's look at this study, and how many people did they study? And, and what are the factors are going on? And let's look at this, this evidence and see actually, it's a load of bullshit. But other people aren't. Because, you know, for many different reasons, because this is our job, right? And so to say, if you are seeing this type of stuff and feel like Oh, my God, but it might be true. That's, that's a normal reaction to have. And if you have the capacity just to look a little bit into it, or just reach out to someone who does it as a job to, you know, look at this stuff. And to get that reassurance of you're probably not going to die within 3.5 seconds. If you eat a Twinkie, you know?

Yeah, well, and I think like the, you know, a lot of the numbers that they throw out there, like you said, like, I know, at the beginning, they opened the article saying, I can't remember what percentage they say, but Americans are either diabetic or pre diabetic? Well, we talked about in one of the other episodes, how, like, the pre diabetic, is so large, but that doesn't such a tiny percentage of that actually, of those people actually end up getting diabetes.

And I think, like, one of the things that that also makes me really furious is that, like, they're putting the onus, I mean, they do put the onus back on, you know, like the the food industry to try to do something like they suggest doing what they've done with tobacco, which is to, you know, like, put a warning label on it, or change the way that these foods are marketed. But I'm like, that's not going to resolve any of the issue is like if people can't afford don't have time for, you know, like, fresh for like fruits and vegetables, so to speak, like, convenience foods, keep people fed, you know what I mean? Like, and I just think that there's like, a huge piece of this conversation that gets that gets missed. And people are allowed to eat whatever the fuck they want. Also, like, yeah, people have autonomy.

Oh, my goodness. Yeah. And, and then, you know, it's a lot of it is like a lot of well meaning white people who are like, Oh, my God, these, you know, these poor people, they've only got access to, you know, a quickie mart or whatever. Is that a thing? Is that a thing? Or is that just in the symptoms anyway, they don't have access to fruits and vegetables. And so what we're going to do is we're going to save them, we're going to save them, we're going to go into their community, and we're going to give them a farmers market. And, and it's just so it's so wide. It's just so white people, right, going in there into communities and deciding what we're going to do to fix their problem of disparities in health outcomes, is to give them some farmers markets, fruits and vegetables. It's just like, Oh, my goodness, how patronizing How about paying people? How about not being racist? How about doing access to health care?

Like? No, because we got a farmers market on Saturday. So we're doing good, you know, so we can feel good about, you know,

yes, yes, yes, yes. Yes. Yes, yes. 110%? Yeah, yeah. Yeah. I mean, like, and I don't think like, all things are bad, or all things are good. Like, I think there's, you know, probably nuance within any of these like, yeah, farmers markets. Great idea. And, like, we let's not ignore the bigger, you know, the bigger problems that are really playing a part here. And you know, specifically as it relates to living wage and access to health care, health care, yes. Like that.

Oh, you know, just giving them giving money to communities so that they decide what is best for them versus, you know, you know, so white British people like me deciding, you know, we know what's best for that community, because we don't so yes. Oh, my gosh, that's so so true. Right? Yeah, yeah. So to wrap up, we asked our audience about what do they think about the idea that you can be addicted to sugar and what do they think of when they hear the phrase processed food? So I had a few people thinking, processed food meant bad things. And actually, I got quite a quite a few of those responses. Yeah, yeah.

But then I had another people saying this one comment was, I hate it unless you are directly sucking a cow's Tex. All food is process.

Yeah, yeah. And then someone said, Oh, you need to talk about the Yeah, Jvn episode I said I am. And in regards to the sugar addiction, it's not evidence based. And it's a wellness culture lie. Yeah, yeah, I got some people saying they feel that way and it is real. And so it I mean, I got kind of across the spectrum so it wasn't all one or all the other there's and and and that's coming from like, you know our audiences where you were really pretty clear on like our messaging but I think that there's still there's still a lot of fear and misinformation and hopefully this episode helps people to want to learn more to want to, you know, debunk some of the stuff to be able to look at the big picture, huh,

you know who I love that you I don't know if you already follow them? Food Science baby. I don't follow them. But I know I've heard of their page. Yeah, yeah. Yeah.

She's still got a little bit of diet stuff to work. She's not at pro diet or anything. But there's a little bit of all but what she does is she debunked all of the you know, oh, don't eat gluten. Don't eat this dead end of that. So it's, it's really interesting, because she's a food scientist.

Mm hmm. Interesting. Interesting to check that out. Trying to limit how many people I follow because it's just feels overwhelming. Oh, really? Yeah. Like there's probably a million good pages that I just can't. I know. I'm annoying. Can't take it. Yeah, even though the algorithm probably only shows me the same four people over Yeah. Right. Totally. can people find you?

Yeah, so people can find me at the body image coach comm that'll take you to my website and you can find me all over social media. As summer in an inn and my podcast is eat the rules where can people find you Vinnie?

They can find me everywhere under face fatty. My podcast is called first party website, first party social media first party and go to my website to get some free stuff if you want not the boss have you do what you want?

Oh, yeah, same same. Yeah. All right. Well, thanks to everyone for being here today. Hope you enjoyed this rich discussion between two highly intelligent individuals who are also extremely good looking right. At my reflection, it turns me on it so. Thanks for listening to the episode and if you feel ready to get serious about this work and want to know when the doors open to phase fatty Academy which is my signature program, where I teach all about how to overcome your fat phobic beliefs and learn to love your fat body. Then go to first party.com forward slash waitlist again, that is phase fatty.com. Forward slash waitlist to get your name on the waitlist. For when first party Academy my signature program opens

EP112 Transcript

Welcome to the Fierce Fatty Podcast. I'm your host, Victoria Welsby, and this is episode 112. Today, we're talking about auto-immune disease nonsense.

I'm Victoria Welsby, TEDx speaker, Best-Selling Author and fat activist. I have transformed my life from hating my body with desperately low self-esteem to being a courageous and confident fifth party who loves every inch of this jelly. Society teaches us living in a fat body is bad. But what if we spent less time, money and energy on the pursuit of thinness and instead focused on the things that actually matter? Like if pineapple on pizza should be outlawed? Or if the mullet was the greatest haircut of the 20th century? So how do you stop negative beliefs about your fat body controlling your life? It's the Fierce Fatty podcast. Let's begin.

Hello, fatty knows how deep mobile is. I'm sick. I'm sick. I've got the sniffles. I've got a sore throat. So today is going to be a short episode because I probably can't make it through that long. Yesterday I had three calls, three hour long calls and by the end of the day, I was like, Oh my goodness.

And then the podcast a day so I'm going to hopefully it's not too annoying hearing my voice or maybe you're just like, Oh my god. Oh my god, Vinnie. That voice is super sexy, which obviously, obviously is super sexy. Yesterday, what do you want? When anytime I come sit at my desk and start recording diggy diggy the dog comes and sleeps next to me. He's such a good boy. Now he's doing a little stretch. Such a good boy. For those watching on video, you might notice a difference my hire, I went to a went to the barbers I went to the trans barbers place big big Bros. in Vancouver. If you're in Vancouver, close to Vancouver, and you are trans non binary gender fluid, gender queer person, then I definitely recommend going in. Oh, so nice to walk in and not have knowing that no one was presuming my agenda. And I sat down and I said oh yeah, it's my first time and and they said, Oh, why? Why? Why? Why are you here? And I was like, you know, I've just fed up with hairdressers just being like, yes, you're a brand new woman or ma'am, or you know, giving me a haircut that they think is feminine enough, I guess. I don't know. I don't know. And the hairdresser said, Yeah, you're the second today that said the exact same thing. And I was like, yeah, it was really cool was just really cool. Very, very queer very trends and very affordable. Like, normally I pay for a haircut in a Vancouver salon. So for a short, you know, quote unquote, man's haircut, quote, unquote, ManTech, or, you know, a short short haircut, that would be 80 bucks. Yeah, that'd be a black box. This one was it was a sliding scale, you could pay 2030 or 40. So I paid 40 plus a 25% tip. So you're paid 50. So pretty much half price of what I paid. And a gender affirming experience is great. I love it.

And then I came home and I bleached my hair twice. Because it was it was a natural color. And I bleached it twice and it's kind of gone. Yellow at the roots. And I put some lavender in and so it's like bluey at the end. And so anyway, it looks a bit shit but whatever. Oh, I have to go and actually get it. Probably bleached. Yeah, anyway and me way. In today's episode, I am answering a question that I got. And I thought you know what, this is a great question. Right little question. Erin, who were messaging me on Instagram and said that I was okay to answer this question on on the Pascal podcast asks, Aaron asks, Hi, Vinny. Congrats on coming out and feeling yourself. I have a couple of questions for you. No need to answer if it's weird or too much or something. One, do you think when the pan dough ends, you might do some speaking I might do a speaking tour or something. I totally I totally pay money to listen, I RL love it. No, let me just ask that question. No, no No, no, you know why speaking tours are really, they can be really expensive. And I mean, I would love if someone was to pay for me to do a speaking tour, and gave me money, so that I would make money doing it. Oh, totally, I would fucking love to do that.

But I think, you know, I think you need to be like a big comedian and whatever to make it worthwhile, you know, when you're filling out an auditorium or something, you know, whereas, you know, if you're traveling around, and there'll be, you know, my mom in the hallway, like, I'm proud of you. So it's a probably from you wouldn't work naturally for me and Aaron and Aaron would be wherever Aaron is saying, Hi. So yeah, I don't think like financially, I don't think it's, it's a good idea. You know, a lot of times, things like this, like, things that would be really cool and fun to do. It's just not financially viable. Like, I wanted to go on vacation and do like a fifth family vacation. And, and this is what I was thinking, like, years ago, and I know it's changed now. There's companies that will help will arrange everything for you. So I might be eating my words at one point, but things like that.

It's like, is it just something I want to do? Or is this a good business decision? And yeah, there's lots of different things I would love to do, but they're not good business decisions, like making merch is another one, like, making merch to be able to find someplace that I would, like, agree, ethically, politically with that would that carried sizes like, I wouldn't want to do merch if I couldn't have up to like 15x. And then like, how much you would make on selling one thing, and then having to price it to make any type of money means that it would be cost prohibitive, and you wouldn't want to price it that anyway. It's just so but then, you know, you'd like it'd be just fun to have merch. And so like, a part of me is like, oh, maybe I'll get some fears emerge. And then I'm like, No, you know, you know, it's probably not going to be the best decision, I think, Okay, fine. Thank you. business minded, Vinny. Rude. Hey, well, I'm actually I'm halfway through this question.

But it's on my mind, I was gonna I was gonna plan to talk tell you about it anyways, if anyone is planning on doing something, doing something similar to me, I as in like having a business or whatnot, I have thought it might be helpful if I shared my my expenses like how much it costs me to run a business my business is very lean in regards to I don't have lots of fancy outgoings like, you know, I don't have a personal drive I drive me around in a Porsche that is, is encrusted with diamonds like that.

Expenses like that might be his biggest expenses is his one software that I pay $270 a month for. But my total expenses for last year, I just did them a couple of weeks ago, my total expenses for last year was $29,000. So it's about a couple of grand plus a month to run my business to run my business. And you think, Well, what if surely isn't like, you know, having an email system, isn't it like 10 bucks and isn't having like this, and now five bucks, and, yeah, you know, a lot of other systems that we think, you know, like a social media messaging tool, you know, so like, when you can send out all your social media posts on one thing, that's like 30 bucks, and like a calendar management thing, that's like 10 bucks.

And then, you know, the software that I was saying that hosts my course and sends my emails, that's $270, etc, etc, and all adds up, right? And so, anyway, I just wanted to be transparent in regards to this type of stuff. Because you see, I've spoken about this before, a lot of online business people being like, am I going to go back and I'm a millionaire in like, 13 seconds, all you need to do is buy my course. And you'll be a millionaire so quick, and that's not the reality. The reality is that it costs it costs a lot of money. You won't make money for a long time. And and you have to be able to be in a situation that can support you like that. And so a lot of people if they've got a partner that might help them with finances, me to begin with, I had savings from my corporate job to get me up and going and a lot of like a year's worth of savings. So anyway, anyway, anyway, sidetrack, totally sidetrack and if someone is having a business if someone is listening in the habit, this They're like, Well, I'm rubbish at my business. I'm not making money and dah dah, dah, dah, dah. I bet you're not rubbish at your business. I bet that it's just just takes time on myth. And I've been doing this for many years now.

And it literally that is the secret ingredient is time is time is just keep doing it. Keep doing it, keep doing it, and keep doing it. And it's okay, if that's not what you want to do as well. Anyway, back to Aaron's question. So Aaron says, I'm not gonna go until I say 10 minutes later, no. Number two, when a person me has an autoimmune disease, and they're my numbers keep going up blood, glucose, liver enzymes, and the only thing their doctor says is to take metformin and lose weight. And then it puts them in a spiral of like, Shit, I need to only eat kale and beef and lemon juice or whatever, what the heck is a person to do? I'm just having a real mess in the head about it. Oh, you know, fear of disease and also hating on the body loathing and just eating disorder a restriction? It's a lot. Sorry, and thanks. Also, I undeleted Instagram to ask you deleted because too much before and after a shit Haha. Yeah, so I'm so so sorry that you're going through that air in that sucks my big swinging tits that you're having to experience that and, and just to start, you know, let's start on what an autoimmune disorder is. So Aaron doesn't share what auto immune disease disorder that that they have. So let me just go over a few.

So just in case you fall into any of these categories. And you know what we're talking about? I'm just going to go to this. The good WebMD tells me rheumatoid arthritis, lupus, inflammatory bowel, multiple sclerosis type one diabetes. Guillain Barre Syndrome or Julian Barre Syndrome depending how you might pronounce it. chronic inflammatory D My LeighAnn the knighting poly neuropathy, which is similar to golembo psoriasis Graves disease Hashimotos thyroiditis. My is the NIA Gravis Oh vasculitis Okay, so that's the list of ultimate immune disorders. So could be any of those one of those more of those.

So I have one I guess I have IBD fun fun. I wonder though as well or to immune diseases diseases things like asthma and with that be one an eczema would that be one because it's the body attacking itself right. So let me just read a little bit from this WebMD immune system disorders course abnormally low activity or over or over activity of the immune system. In cases of immune system over activity the body attacks and damages its own tissues, autoimmune diseases, immune deficiency diseases decrease the body's ability to invite invaders causing vulnerable vulnerability to infections in response to an unknown trigger the immune system may begin producing antibodies that instead of in fighting infections attack the body's own tissues treatment for autoimmune diseases generally focus on reducing immune system activity Hmm Okay, so no it's in there in somewhere where they could very happily easily crowbar is caused by people being fat they did turn because Yeah.

Whoo. Good science here.

Unknown trigger. We don't know right? We don't know. We don't know the body isn't Mr. Ricci know that we don't even know how paracetamol works. You know, like a headache tablet. We don't even know how it works. We know it works that people have. It's been around for like 50 years. We know that it stops somehow we think it stops pain receptors. No one actually knows. It's works. That's all you know, whatever. There's a lot of things that we don't know. Anyway. And so depending on what autoimmune disease you have, basically, none of these things are caused by you, your fault your actions. None of these things are because you ate too much. You ate the wrong things, etc. It's not your fault that your body is experiencing this. Okay? So I just want you to to really sit with that no matter what even if it's not an autoimmune disorder or disease. No matter what your body is doing, even if it's a traditionally kind of illness or disease, disease or disorder that's associated with fatness, even if it's type two diabetes, even if it's high blood pressure, you know, the things that, you know, people say you're going to get diabetes, if you don't stop being so fat. Even if you have those types of things, it's not your fault.

And when a doctor prescribes weight loss, they you're not giving you evidence based care. They are not giving you evidence based care, they are literally putting up their sleeves up to their elbow, or rumbling, rummaging around in their assholes and pulling out a piece of shit a piece of bullshit, because there is not one single study ever to show, any diet ever works. And there's not the information that shows that having a smaller body will mean that you are not going to have this illness or condition. And what we do know about intentional weight loss is it's not good for your health. So also doctors, you know, how much work how much training they get on on nutrition and food. Like hardly anything, Harvey anything in a huge, huge gash training that they do. I think they get like an hour class. So they are not a trained dietician, nutritionist. You know, they don't know stuff about food, what you know what to eat or not eat, if you want to manage certain conditions that might involve food. And we're not even saying that these conditions, these auto meat, autoimmune disorders are managed by food, you know.

So when I say that, I mean things like people who have celiac disease, who are confirmed gluten intolerant. And so a doctor in that case, would could confidently say, Listen, gluten is gonna make you feel sick, you know, then then then they'd have the education to talk about that. But they don't have the education to say this. Eating like this is going to help you lose weight, because that doesn't, it doesn't exist, it's a law and you doesn't exist, right. So the they're not a trained nutrition nutritionist or dietitian, they're not giving you evidence based care. And even if whatever or to Amin immune disorder can be helped with food, if there is a haze dietitian is more often than not, not going to be telling you, you need to lose weight, even if a condition can be helped with changing your diet, which is we're not even saying that that is what the case is, chances are a haze, dietitian or nutritionist is going to say, let's add in stuff, not takeaway stuff. Unless you know, you have something where you're deathly allergic to something, you know, you know, your celiac, you know, again, then they might say, Yeah, you know, removing gluten might feel good for you. But you still have that choice, if you want to go ahead and eat gluten and deal with the consequences, you still have that choice, right? So even if even this is a little bit a lots of hypothesis, even if your autoimmune disorder can be managed by the things that you eat, which is a big, a big, even if

And primarily, the way to manage is through drugs, like you mentioned. So it would still be a secondary thing right? Or even further down the list of things to help you with your health in regards to ring in regards to whatever it is that you've got going on. So I would be curious as to what treatment straight size folks get for the same thing that you have. Are you in a Facebook group? Can you go into a Facebook group is is there a group where it's Health at Every Size aligned and they talk about disorders and how people are treating Health at Every Size, hitting certain disorders or illnesses or whatever? With a Health at Every Size lens? There are resources I was looking at. Obviously I've speak about it all the all the time. Hayes health sheets, hate health sheets has like 10 Different things on there that could be a common quote, quote, fat things that get blamed on fatness and being told to lose weight. So even just checking out Hayes health sheets, so that's H A E. S. health sheets.com May enlighten you because you know what, you know, reading those, you know, what causes what causes this disease? What causes this condition? And it's like, Oh, it doesn't it's not caused because you are a big greedy loser. Oh, well, that's what society tells us, you know, even just reading it, even if it's not a related, related to what you're going through is really cathartic and enjoyable. So yeah, what does straight sides folks get? Do they get drugs? And no body shame, then yeah, we'll have some of those drugs, and then of that body shame. Thank you very much. Also, I want you to know that a lot of these conditions associated with fatness are not caused by having fat on your body. We don't have that evidence. We don't know. Right? We can actually link the issue causing someone to be a higher weight. So someone who has type two diabetes, whatever is happening in their body that could be causing them to be fat. And then they get the fat blamed on it causing the diabetes.

When it's, it's it that's not what is happening. It's like, it's like, it's like, let me let me symbolize simplify it. It's like you have a cold. And one of the cold. One of the symptoms of the cold like I've got one of my symptoms is sneezing. And the doctor said to me, imagine if the doctor said to me, because you started sneezing. You got a cold. And if you stop sneezing, then your cold will go away. We see you know, everyone who's got a cold, they sneeze, so sneezing, people are just more prone to getting colds. Well, no sees sneezing is a symptom of a cold. You know, fatness can be a symptom of certain illnesses, diseases.

And then and then we go in and say, Aha, I noticed that a lot of people who have this condition are fat, therefore, it must be the fatness that has caused this disease. Let's look at the evidence. Oh, there is no evidence to support that. Hmm, sounds fishy. Let's just say it is anyway. You know, that's like the the quote unquote, obesity paradox. Like, why is it when we we all know fat people are about to spontaneously combust? Because they're so greedy. But hang on, why are they living longer than straight sides before? Why did they survive certain diseases and conditions better than straight size people? It's a paradox. It just doesn't make any sense. Is it? Because fatness doesn't mean someone's unhealthy? Now I will just call it a paradox we'll just say is we're really weird. It's really weird. It's not actually. Yeah. So So Aaron, what to do what to do, I would say get advice from a Health at Every Size align dietitian to see if there are actually any dietary things that you need to add. Again, you you are not going to be told, unless you were really you know, something else is going on, that you're having a really bad reaction to a food you're not going to be told to take things away, or to stop being so greedy, or whatever it is.

Or the dietitian is going to say, just take the medicine because that's what helps this this illness. And then you'll realize that oh yeah, I've just been prescribed a shit ton of fatphobia. And as well, like, the doctor could be saying lose weight, but we might be needing to kind of decipher what the doctor mean. What do you mean when you mean lose weight? Like, what? What do you want me to actually do? And the doctor can say, well, I want you to do some exercise. Ah, okay, so it's not lose weight. It's you want me to do exercise? Okay, great. And at that point, the doctor will say how much do you exercise? No, they won't because they will just praise you that you never exercise if you have But bigger body

Yeah, so, so so so you know, what is really going on here when they say when you lose weight? If there is something going on around that what what do they mean? And also Aaron, give yourself some sense of empathy. And I can see why this would be triggering this is this is triggering for so many people. No, no, no, no, Matt No, no, you know, and that's without having an eating disorder, and recovering from an eating disorder. And then having a doctor saying, oh, loosen way, like, holy shit, this is a really, really, really big trigger for a lot of people because doctors are in a position of authority, right? It's scary to go to the doctor. I don't know about you.

But as you know, in Canada, it's a lot easier for me to go to a doctor because they, they like talk to you and ask a few questions. It's not the best. But in England growing up, you'd be in the doctor, you'd be like, it'd be like a some type of, you know, factory line type of thing, where it's kind of like, in out what you hear for, okay, get out his prescription, go need like, Okay, say as little words as possible, don't make eye contact, just get in and out. Don't Don't mess about with, with any useless information, you know, I've got a sore throat, oh, I've got that, you know, I've got I need to get this, I need to get it out. No probing questions, you know, appointments lasting less than one minute, you know, that type of thing. And so when I came to Canada, and the doctor would be kind of like writing out notes and typing things I was like, that's weird. But you know, it could be just a doctor's, I've been to here. And I know a lot of doctors everywhere are the same, right? Because they were under pressure to to get patients in and out. But anyway, a lot of us are trained. And a lot of us have that, you know, recognition of that part power dynamic, where we're just like, I'm gonna go on. So if a doctor says, lose weight, most people will just say, okay, yeah. Okay. And then afterwards have to kind of deal with the fallout. Which is, which is to be expected, right? You're not an inadequate person, if you can't, you know, when the doctor says, Have you thought about losing weight, you're not an inadequate person, if you don't, you know, flip the table and start a fistfight with them. Because most people aren't going to be able to do that. You know? So another thing is, is, can you come up with a plan to protect yourself the next time you go to the doctor's, because we don't want you to not go to the doctor's, that's, that's, that's why a lot of people fat people struggle with healthcare, because rightly, so. We don't want to go to doctors, because we know we're gonna get shamed.

And that means the doctors are winning. That means that we are suffering because we're not getting the health care that we deserve. And so what can you do to help yourself, advocate for yourself, it could be that you're sending a letter before you go sending an email saying, Hey, I'm recovering from an eating disorder. And any mention of my weight actively harms me, it could be that you bring in a little card that says I'm not up for be talking about weight. It could be that you bring in a patient advocate for you, whether it's like someone officially or it is a fat friend who, like if I lived in cities with people who were, you know, struggling with this stuff, I would come along and be like, listen, I tell the doctor where to go. Or it could be that you just learn, like, know that the doctor might say something bad. And so I'm going to give myself some self care afterwards. The doctor is gonna tell me to lose weight.

And so afterwards, I've got a bath bomb from lush, ready, and the new season of my favorite TV show ready to go on Netflix, you know? So, all righty, I'm going to leave it here. Maybe this is the shortest episode that I've ever had. 28 minutes ish. With one one pause for a single solitary cough. Yeah, so when I go mate with them none. And hope this has helped. And I will see you all next week when hopefully I'm going to be feeling better. Hopefully, hopefully, I'm going to have yours for the rest of the afternoon for the rest of the afternoon. It's 209 Now I'm gonna just have a fucking downtime. Yes, I'm not gonna do anything. So all right, boy. Thanks for listening to the episode and if you feel ready to get serious about this work and want to know when the doors open to fears fattie Academy which is my signature program, where I teach all about how to overcome your fat phobic beliefs and learn to love You're fat body, then go to phase fatty.com forward slash waitlist again that is phase fatty.com. Forward slash waitlist to get your name on the waitlist. For when first party Academy my signature program opens

EP111 Transcript

Welcome to the Fierce Fatty Podcast. I'm your host, Victoria Welsby, and this is episode 111. Today, we're talking about before and after photos.

I'm Victoria Welsby, TEDx speaker, Best-Selling Author and fat activist. I have transformed my life from hating my body with desperately low self-esteem to being a courageous and confident fifth party who loves every inch of this jelly. Society teaches us living in a fat body is bad. But what if we spent less time, money, and energy on the pursuit of thinness and instead focused on the things that actually matter? Like if pineapple on pizza should be outlawed? Or if the mullet was the greatest haircut of the 20th century? So how do you stop negative beliefs about your fat body controlling your life? It's the Fierce Fatty podcast. Let's begin.

Hey, Fassi you're so fine you So find your Brahma man hey patty. A fatty Hey patty. You're so fine You're so funny blow my mind. Hey Betty. Patti, you're so fine. A blur add another layer of budget that hey, the greatest lyrics I think of all time Bahar boys who let the dogs out let's go fluffy. Let's go scruffy. Let's go up infested Monroe.

Let's just a great great line and I think it's a great line to say to your friends when you're ready to go let's go fluffy let go scruffy let go you flea infested man growl someone just text me was still dosed. I was still streaming we did it we just did a stream we just did a stream on fireside and I hadn't ended the show so probably people could hear me having a little sing song with you but that's okay I just ended that I just ended the stream so we've got another episode with some today the person with loads of letters in her name and episode of death two diets where we were talking about before and after pictures and not only the standard before and afters but the you know where someone's loses weight and after they've been on a diet but also the quote unquote body positive before and afters where people have quit dieting and now they show a picture of them now that they look at me I'm so happy now that I don't die it but I'm also have a bigger body. Look how thin I used to be type of thing. We're talking today.

I like these episodes of settler because I I like having a chin. But I get a chinwag when I do an episode on my own, you will can't talk back to me. Yeah, it's so rude. Why don't you respond? Why don't you talk to me? Yeah, so I like having someone to talk to. But I don't want to do I'd still I still don't want to do have guests on the show. Because it's just too much of a ball like honestly, it's just too much of a ball like to to get people booked in and reach out to people and I'm sure if I started letting people on the show then I'd get loads of pitches and people who are like Oh, I like dieting and Lilly Lilly and it'd be annoying so anyway, it's just gonna be me from now on but you know, we still got another we've got six episodes in total of deaths and diets. And this is the flip third one so we've still got three more episodes with summer. I do like it I too like it you know, having a friend. So let's get into the episode today. I hope you enjoy it and I hope the Bihar boys is going to be stuck in your head or that other song that I said about fatties gets stuck in your head like Alma okay. Okay, this let's go into this episode.

Why did we come up with this topic? I don't know you came up with the story. I I was getting on an airplane and I was and I was like, I wanted a magazine that was at the airport and they had the People magazine and it had buddy white on the cover and it was so weird because it was like it was Like, the day it was like the day or two after Betty White had passed away. And but it was the cover celebrating her turning 100 because obviously they had like put this magazine together prior to her passing.

So anyways, I bought the magazine. And one of the one of the sections, which was, which was, interestingly enough, buried in the back was the section about like these people lost half their size. And I don't know, I don't know if you remember this. But that used to always be the cover story for People Magazine in January. Like I just I remember that that was always that was always on the cover. So it was interesting that it was it was buried in the back, there was no mention of it on the cover, at least I don't think so. And Betty White did have badass nose and was like, he was on leaving put me on the cover and put those other shit into the back.

Exactly, exactly, exactly. Yeah, so I read I read it for research. And it just got me, like, just super fired up about it. And I thought we can have a really cool discussion because we also see kind of like, in the reverse before and after in the body positive world. So people showing, you know, like, I used to be thin and now I've gained weight and I'm actually happier. And we wanted to have a discussion around both of those things. Because yeah, it's just sort of interesting, the impact that that these pictures on the the narrative, that the impact that it has on us.

Mm hmm. Yes, yes. Yes. And I actually, I have been exposed to this recently because I don't know if you know, some of but you can actually check out magazines from the library. And so I was like, Do you know what, I'm going to look at some really trashy magazines because I haven't looked at them in years. And you don't have to pay for them. So I was like, let's look at this one gay times. Yes, please. Fishing weekly. Ah, so I just skimming lots of different magazines. And yeah, that I did see that that stuff. And I used to log before and after pictures. That would be my favorite thing.

I was wondering Yeah, did you cuz I try to remember if I did, I'm not. Yes, cuz I used to be like, Oh my god, they used to be such a fat loser like me. And now look at them. Like they clearly they've changed their life around. If only I do what they did that I can be like them. So yeah, yeah.

Yeah. So you used to actually find that inspiring? Oh, yeah.

I loved it. Whenever I'd get the Weight Watchers magazine. I knew it was my goal to be in the Weight Watchers magazine. Because I was like, I am the even my, my What did I call it the leader? The leader was like, Oh, you could be in the magazine. And I was like, yes. And Thank fuck, it never happened because I quit didn't quit, you know, you know, diets diets. It just didn't happen. Anyway. Yeah. Well, you know, I, I worked as a nutritionist like 12 years ago, or 1010 12 years ago. And I used to take before and after pictures of my clients and like, do like, challenges where we would take before and after pictures. And so no, I feel really bad about it now, because I realized, like, how damaging and problematic it was, but I can't even imagine you doing that sound like it's just so foreign. About you. Yeah, but it's like, when you're like when that's your business like that. I mean, that's what a lot of people use to sell like nutrition services and things like that. And, and the kind of like, dirty behind the scenes of it is like, you know, you realize that clients don't actually stay that way that it's like it's a yo yo cycle. And so you know, thankfully I had my own like awakening with it that then allowed me to, you know, make amends hopefully and move away from that.

But definitely I was total I absolutely was, was was guilty of that because I just didn't I was so in my in it myself in terms of like, well, this is you know, I'm helping people get healthy and I'm helping them be confident and all that stuff. But the reality was like I would say the vast majority of them still struggled with food still hated themselves and ended up back like it was never permanent.

So when did you when you were taking those photos you mentioned Oh, you know it was temporary that weight loss. Did you know that the time are we now they started their life and they're gonna be amazing.

Yeah, no, I was like and they just need to keep doing it and like you know and so so i That's why I have like I do I empathize with people in this industry because I think if you don't know better, you don't know better, right? Which is why like, I don't like to kind of shame individuals like I you know, I prefer to just call it the overall issue because, like, I was in that frame of mind where I was like, oh, no, like and I was doing it from like the health perspective and Even like I pulled out some of the quotes from like the People magazine I read, where it's like, no, we're not using diets like my slogan was, like, it was like something around like, like no like it was it was a non dieting slogan like I can't remember exactly what it was I my my in laws had a postcard one of my old marketing postcards from when my my nutrition business. They had, like in there I found one in their basement. And I saw the slogan and I was like, oh my god, like I used to save. Like I shouldn't even remember. That's the same thing that was kind of being some of the stuff that was being echoed in this People magazine was that it was like, one of the most like I swapped fad diets for counting macronutrients and like, get rid of it.

I swapped fad diets for another fad diet, but I don't believe it the fad diet. Yeah, or like it was like you have to lose a diet mentality. This person was doing like, what's deemed like a very restrictive diet. I won't mention which one but yeah.

The mind trickery that we do. And you saying that you were saying, as a non diet thing you ahead of your time, some of because, you know, all the diets are doing it now. But if you were saying like I'm a non diet diet all those years ago, then I mean, how are you? Are you on the pulse? You were doing it?

Well, hopefully they'll find their way out like I did. I was an early adopter of garbage. But yeah, it was. Yeah, it's like, it's interesting to reflect back on it and, and just realize, like, I feel really bad. Like I, I hope I hope I've been able to, you know, yeah,

I mean, you've you've you've read like paid your parents, oh, my god, like 100 times over. interesting to think about the way that we were thinking back then. And I found a no, because I like keeping note, you know, in the Notes app, I like keeping notes. And I've got notes back for and like to like 2013 or something. And so I was I looked for I look for a search for a word I can't remember it was like health or something. Yeah. Because I was looking for health every size and my notes. And I had written this thing to myself about, you know, what negative thoughts and beliefs I have about myself and one of my negative thoughts or beliefs was, I will never be thin. And then I wrote myself like a pep talk of, Oh, my God, yes, you are going to be thin. I mean, come on you you're going to be so thin, and you're going to work out every single day.

And people are gonna say how do you do it? And you're gonna be like, it's so effortless. And I was like, talking about how healthy I was. And I was like, what, you know, every day like walking around with a six pack. Like, I couldn't even remember that I wrote that. And I was thinking like that. I was like, really trying to positive, you know, manifest being thin. Yeah. And it was only like, I don't know, seven years ago or something. But I was thinking like that. Wow. This to me. Yeah. Yeah. And I thought I was like, I probably thought it was body positive at the time. So anyway, yeah. Yeah, right. It's like, it gets all muddled. I mean, it gets co opted and muddled, and we convince ourselves of things just to convince ourselves.

We have to, we both asked our audiences, what do you think of weight loss before and after pictures? I've got my results here. And I said, Do you love them? Or do you hate them? And 13% said, Love, and 87% said, Hey, so what do you think of weight loss? before and after pictures? 13% said love. 87% said, Hey, and then a couple of people messaged me saying, oops, I said, Love. But I meant to say, hey, we can resume that numbers a little bit lower than 13%, let's say 10%. And I really get that kind of the love thing I've seen before and after pictures, it's feels so intoxicating. Especially if you're new to this stuff, because like I mentioned at the beginning, I just would feel so inspired by seeing these everyday people what I would see as them changing their lives, but the reality is probably very different. Isn't it summer?

Yeah, absolutely. It's it's kind of like it's it's one season of their life. And I think we all know that there's like they after and then like, what happens after that? You know, what happens like two years after that, what happens five years after that, and I think you and I both know that the majority of people blame it on themselves. They're like, well, you know, I just didn't try hard enough. Or, you know, I just I didn't have enough willpower. And the reality is that like, none of those things are true. Your body was just legitimately trying to keep you alive and that you weren't meant to be like on that diet, which is how I felt like which is how I feel when I see these images of these people in this magazine. And I'm like, they tell the story.

And the narrative is like, the words they use are like, I finally love myself. It's like Christmas morning, like, you know, like, you know, and it solves that idea. And I almost feel bad. Like, I don't want to pity people, but I kind of I'm kind of like, oh, like, what's that gonna look like, in two years or three years? You've been featured in this magazine, like you are a poster child for? Yes. It's like, how much more damaging is that to you? If your body can't sustain that, like if you know, which majority of our bodies can't, without maintaining, you know, disorder behaviors, which, for the most part, like our body's going to fight back against?

Yeah, that's such a good point about you know, they've been in a magazine and how much shame they probably feel after because, you know, the after, after the before and after the after, when when, you know, 95% plus of those people who are now bigger than their before picture, and, like, That must feel like shit. Yeah, camera just went off. That must feel really, really bad. And yeah, it makes me thankful that when I was doing all that dieting stuff, there wasn't, you know, I didn't have social media and all that type of stuff. But I was still a massive bellend about it and told everyone about the fact that I was losing weight. And I was such a good person. So you know, yeah, well, yeah. I mean, that's like what you're supposed to do, right? Like, yeah, with other people stay accountable.

Yeah. I wonder, like, when I see But now when I see before and afters instead of being like, oh my god, I love it. I'm just like, like you, I have such deep compassion for that person. Because I'm just I just think exactly what you said. What are they going to be feeling like in 2345 years? Because it's probably it's probably going to be a lot of shame. And you know, hopefully they found another way, but it seems kind of it's kind of like hoping for them that maybe this is the kind of final straw before they find fat positivity and anti diet and all that type of stuff. Yeah, you know, you never know Right? So yeah,

because for a lot of people it's a lifetime Sunday number more grim is just call it a life sentence but yeah, when you would do when you were taking the before and after pictures you know before and after pictures the before the person's like, oh, you know holes in like they're covered in shitstain but they haven't brushed my hair in three weeks. They've got bits of straw coming out of their hair and you know, they've got shit in their eyes and they're dribbling and stuff and then the after picture they've got you know, full makeup and all that type of stuff and probably posed and probably Photoshop Would you ever like in the first picture be like you know going sticking out a bit more or no, no, no, no, my work like that at all my were like my more like, you know, like, you look how you look? And then you look how you look like okay, I didn't I didn't like no I didn't I didn't I didn't curate those in any way. No, I guess it was more in my mind it was more for them to see the difference versus like something to use as like a you know, like a marketing a market a marketing thing. But you know, social media wasn't really around much fun. So thank goodness not not in the way that it is now. And so see if there was social media maybe you'd have like a sack in the back that you'd bring out and be like, go on this like ugly sack and like this, you know, you know like on The Biggest Loser and they would just make them were really get these are on.

I'm just gonna like use the spray tanner on you in the after to like make you like contour ABS on your body really toned. No. Yeah, no, I and I like for me personally, I'm trying to think like, if I found I must have found before and afters. Inspiring, but I also feel like, like, there was like, a few years of time where I was just perpetually frustrated because like, it didn't matter what I did, like, my body wouldn't change anymore. And and so I feel like there was a point in time around there, where I actually like they made me feel even more inadequate because it was just a reminder of like, see, you can't do it. Like there's something defective in you. So but, but now when I see them like I'm more just like, oh, like I know what that's like. Yeah, I know. I know what happens.

Yeah. I'm I'm, if any other than my social media, I'm immediately blocked I got, I don't want to see that shit because even even me who I do this work constantly, that's that type of stuff can still be triggering. And so I'm like getting that out of my brain. So I don't know, I just think for other people who are still on the journey and if they haven't curated their social media, and they've still got things like that, because it's kind of, you know, like, I kind of like looking at it, how much that's affecting people to still see before and after pictures. So my advice is, if you still have anything like that, because you know, you know, like, Oh, I know, it's like a guilty pleasure to see it. I just really like looking at it. Get rid of that shit. Probably not doing anything good for your brain. Yes.

And my survey was similar. It was like, actually was stronger. It was 96% dislike and 4% inspiring. And someone said that it triggers feelings of not being good enough, and it takes them right back to where they were when they were in that headspace. So yeah, I mean, obviously, our results are gonna be biased, because people that follow us have similar belief systems, but

yeah, I'm yet I was surprised like, 13% of mindset. Love. I was like, yeah, probably, they

might have read it wrong. Because you put love first. Like, when I saw the screen capture of yours, it was a little like, my mind would have thought the hate would be first. But I You probably did get a couple people who hit it incorrect. Yeah,

21:29

I was. Yeah. I think that's the most most accurate for our type of audience. But I think in the in the world in general, I think people probably be like, 5050, or even more that like him. Right?

21:44

I would think so. I would think so. Yeah. There's like a whole, like, good for that. Like, yeah, Tality. You know, like, it's still seen as like, an a call, you know, like an accomplishment, like, your body is an accomplishment. And, yeah, you know, so yeah, I unfortunately, I would agree that it is probably skews more heavily towards people finding them inspiring.

22:06

Mm hmm. Unfortunately, and I've just realized that I look at celebrity before and after pictures of you know, here's a picture of a celebrity when they were 20. And here's a picture of them now that they're 40. I've just realized that I look at those pictures.

22:25

Oh, what makes you do that?

22:30

Shit. I don't know. Like, I I think I see it more as Oh, isn't it interesting? How isn't it into what? I don't see those

22:42

links. I'm not I don't think I've ever let

22:46

my Instagram feed and say we're like, oh, celebrities when they were 20. And celebrities when they're now and it's like, oh, Helen Mirren is now at and look at her when she was 20. So it's kind of like, Oh, look at what celebrities look like when they were young. And so

22:59

yeah, yeah, that makes more sense. Yeah.

23:02

I was like, Oh my God, have I like, discovered some like, fucked up thing. No, I'm okay. I'm okay.

23:09

You're good. You're good. Should we talk about the opposite then, like, the pictures that we see that show? The, like the body positive before and afters where someone was like, I was unhappy when I was thinner. And now I've gained weight, and I'm happier and more confident. Like,

23:26

yeah,

23:27

so what do I What do you think of those?

23:30

Yeah, we know what to begin with. When I was new to body positivity. I used to be like, yes. Oh, my God, this is amazing. And now I'm like, a little bit more nuanced in my feelings about of, you know, what they're trying what they're saying is, what they're not they're saying, if we take it on a kind of surface level is, I'm happy and it doesn't matter what I look like, Yeah, but there is still that, that message that's, that's underneath there of, I used to have an asset, yet I wasn't happy. And now I don't have that asset, which is a thin body.

And I've learned to be happy, even though I'm missing an asset. So it's not breaking down the assumption that having a smaller body is inherently good. And so it needs to be I think, if people show them like before and after, when, you know, I used to be really thin. And now and I was miserable. There needs to be a more of a dissection of that's so interesting that I used to think that my body is an asset and, and well, I don't know if they even had the dissection or the or the deeper look into it. I don't think they'd be posting the picture anyway. Oh, I'm still presenting my body as a thing to be consumed in a way that's not maybe helpful. Yeah. Yeah.

24:58

So again, I did a couple of those in the beginning. Love it. And they would get, like so much engagement. And when I stopped doing those engagement went down, and I think it's like, so I get why people do them because they are more likely to like, go viral, get more followers, like, it sells the message. And, and so I get I get that as well. But what why I stopped doing them like several years ago was because it was like this idea of like, you know, body positivity needs to be about centering the most marginalized bodies and like, as a straight size person, like me, like highlighting that narrative around my body, like doesn't really do anything for the birther movement, right. So like my own personal like, awareness around that made me realize like, oh, shit, like, I don't want to do that anymore.

And it was still putting the value in my body, it was still putting, like, you know, the identity and my value in how in how I looked, and I didn't want that to be the thing that like I was known for I wanted it to be, you know, the the skills that I had, and the, you know, the perspectives that I had around around this topic. So I it was like, I think it was probably at least five years ago now that I like announced it on social media, like I will not be doing these pictures anymore. And here's what I've learned. And here's why. And

26:37

yeah, yeah. And I wonder as well, how many people who are new to the idea of body positivity? See in the before picture of the smaller bodied person? Oh, yeah, I'd like to look like that. And then they see the after of someone who has it who is a higher way? And they're like, Fuck no, if that means that if I need to learn to, you know, stop dieting and accept myself, it means I'm going to gain weight. Well, I'm not gonna do it. And that's not always the outcome of intuitive eating or body acceptance. It's, it's a million different outcomes. Right? And so yeah, and I think as well, it would probably reinforce the message that accepting your body means that you, you know, that's something that it means you have to give up, quote, quote, unquote, give up having your current body and that's not always a reality. Yeah, it's complicated, right? It is complicated.

27:37

And the actually one thing that I really appreciated, somebody commented, when I posted the survey, which the results of my survey were 71% of people disliked those and 29% found them inspiring. And so one person wrote, which I think, captured the essence of like what we're saying really well, I used to like how it displayed joy that someone experiences in a larger body, however, that I feel like now I feel now that that can just be conveyed through the after, like, just by showing like, yes, your body, like, you know, just having joy in your body instead of that narrative of like, associating it with like a particular size change or anything like that.

28:20

It's almost a language that we have learned to speak of, of body comparison. Even though we're out a diet culture, we still wanna do the body comparison shots, like we can't, we can't help it. No, because it's just such a language that we speak of. Yeah, consuming, consuming people's bodies. And my people said, when I said what do you think of body positive before and afters that show weight gain 36% said they love and 64% said that they hate and the comments were, either way they are conveying that there is a right or wrong way for a body to look.

And it just feels like the same narrative that your body size is the most important thing. And the cultural idea of the before and after is still harmful. Yeah, so all of this stuff that we're saying. Yeah, yeah, go ahead. I was gonna say I think there's a difference between someone who lived there before is they were living in a in a bigger body and thereafter is that living in a bigger bigger body versus someone who is straight sized showing us still another straight size slightly bigger, straight sized body I think that there's a difference in harm created there between Oh, look at me now. I'm so fat when they're still straight sized. Because then someone like me, and we'll see, you know, a fat person might see that straight size body and be like, oh, yeah, look at you accepting that hideous body really? I've never had a body like that, like really? What would you think of my body? If you think that you're accepting this, you're like a charity worker accepting that hideous body that you have, but clearly you have a normative, you know, societal socially acceptable body you know?

30:17

That's exactly what I was gonna say I feel like in a lot of cases are still some dysmorphia going on because it's like someone who's like a size two going to a size four or something and they're like, Yeah, you know, and and and that's not to judge them at all like that's not to judge people experiencing that because that you know, I get that like, you can experience those levels of shame and whatnot, but from taking like, yeah, the outsider's perspective or thinking about like, What would someone who is who is fat? Feel like how do they feel? You know, how would they feel? Seeing this, I think is really it's a it's a really important consideration because yeah, it's like, yeah, exactly. To your point.

31:01

Yeah. Yeah. It's like that that show I never really watched it. But this is us with Chrissy Metz. Did you? Did you ever watch that? I never watched it. No, it's a lot of there's a lot of fatphobia in it. So. But I watched it, I watched like, maybe the first season anyway, they go to a diet club, and it's lots of fat people. And then there's like one thin person who's like, Oh, my God, my, I'm so ugly. And everyone, you know, the fat people are having to comfort her and be like, No, you're pretty, but then it's just like, kind of feels like that. And, and that kind of segues into the thing that actually gets on my tips. I can, and like, where I'm like, Oh, I really wish that people wouldn't do this like, because it's it's very, very harmful. And that is when influencers it's it's almost it always influences twists them themselves into like pretzels, they bend themselves over 100 times to try and get a tiny little stomach roll, which is normally just their skin.

And they post that picture saying, oh my god, hashtag I'm so brave for going out with this. You know, I've learned to love and accept my body even though that I you know, look at that this this, this role, but that is here. And also the pictures where it's like, Oh, look how bloated, I was at 2pm. And then oh, look at 8pm I have no my stomach is so flat. Oh, it's only because I have a uterus. And so if you have if you're if you're if you're fat, don't worry. It's probably only because you have a uterus. You're not actually fat. Lol, you know? Just like, stop that now.

32:47

Yes, yes, yes. Yes. There's I don't see those pictures anymore. Thankfully, like, but I when I did, I did a bit of research for a podcast episode I did recently where I looked up the hashtags. Like I went and searched hashtags like body positivity and stuff like that. And yeah, I definitely still found like, like some a lot of some of the stuff. Yeah, they're actually yeah, no, it it made me really enraged. But I don't I don't like I yeah, I don't really follow that stuff anymore. Because, I mean, well, I've just i, i Yeah, it never really resonated with me much anyways, because I could see that you don't actually have a role if you have to treat it. Like if you have to bend over Are you have to like squeeze your side to create cellulite and say like, you should love your cellulite. It's like that's not but it keeps the focus on the body, which is my problem with the whole, like, mainstream body positivity thing anyways, but, but like, I mean, if you like that stuff, you like it? And it kind of this all sort of reminded me of like, do you remember the the body image movement, like the woman from the body image movement from us? Yeah.

And like, the reason why like she became so popular was because she had that viral photo of like, a before a reverse before and after, like one of them was from when her she was doing her, like weight competition like bodybuilding competition days, and then one after when she wasn't. And like, it was like, the like, it went viral. It was like news, like, viewed like millions and millions of times. And it's just so funny how I feel like maybe the times have changed since then. But it's just so funny how at that time, like because she was still straight sized. That it's like, Oh, my God, like straight size woman like accepts her body and it's like, in like, news outlets.

34:45

Yeah. Firing and yeah,

34:49

but it just speaks to how messed up the culture is because it's like, that is like so newsworthy. You know what I mean? Like, like, yeah,

34:57

she was fat. There's no way in hell anyone any news coverage because or if the news coverage was it'd be like look at this person who used to be so healthy and now look she was really let ourselves go and and so that would only work if you still had a thin body but a little bit chubby here and there in the right places, you know, because we have to have like an hourglass figure. Right? And yeah, and I yeah that I never that's so true. Yes. Her movie came to Vancouver, didn't it? Yeah. Yeah. No, I did. I did.

35:38

I saw that home. So I definitely didn't watch him. I think I was away or something. Because I remember I was gonna go with you and yah, yah.

35:47

Yah, yah. Yah. Yah. Yah. Yah, yah. Yah, but that is so true. And at that time, I didn't I didn't pick up on that. I didn't pick up on that. Yeah, I did.

35:58

Mm hmm. And I know someone I know someone out. Like, I know, there's another person that a similar thing, like, and they went viral. And it was like, got a book deal and like, all this stuff. And they were like, maybe a size six or something like maybe it's like a woman embraces her body. It's like, Yeah, but I say what? Like, not like, I'm judging the person. That's not what I mean. It's, it's like, like, it's like, come on, like, that's newsworthy, like police. Like, like, the tide needs to be shifted so much more.

36:32

Yeah. Like people wouldn't. That's all that society at the moment can take, right? Like, the straight size person who is not, you know, buff, excepting themselves. So that's like a good news story. But anything more that would be seen as dangerous, because we're encouraging people to be gluttons, and whatever else people think that fatness represents, so I can kind of get it you know, why the mere media does that?

37:02

Yeah. Well, if you think about the influencers, like with the most followers, they typically still really meet Eurocentric beauty standards. Like pretty faces, like why like a lot of blonde hair, you know, kind of skew like, a little bit younger. And then and just have, like, you know, like, still a straight size body, but more like not like the, you know, stick then or musculature like ideal that you would see that, like you'd kind of typically think of when you think of the thin ideal. So it's a Yeah, but it's interesting when you start critiquing that stuff, and you realize, like, like, are we really changing the culture here? Or are we just like, kind of upholding the same thing, but like, with 10 extra pounds, 20 extra pounds.

And I think that's like, you know, the more that you sort of get into this, and the more that you kind of build that like, you know, cultural awareness, the more that you start to see that, that it's just kind of the same old thing, but just packaged in a slightly different way. And again, it's like nothing against those people. I know, they make a big difference in people's lives and whatnot. But yeah, and I think it's like how you curate your own feed to like, I tend to follow people who are, like, have more of a social justice message as opposed to like, love your body.

38:20

Yeah. And it's, and I think about, you know, I'm always on the fence about this, because I always, you know, we need people who do the light and fluffy stuff, right, we need people who are doing the more, quote unquote, palatable stuff, because, I mean, if it wasn't for those types of people, I probably wouldn't be here. Because if I had seen people who had really made me have to think deeply about fat phobia, I would have been scared off and being like, Oh, I don't want to be like fat and horrible like them, you know, I would have run off and continue to dieting. And so I think we, we need those people, but then also the fact that we need them actively harms more marginalized fat people, because if we're centering smaller people, white people, able bodied people, etc, etc. It means that the spotlight is naturally not on the people who are in the greatest need of justice, and resources and all that type of stuff.

And so it's like, I'm always struggling with it or being like, we need it but it's really harmful. We don't you know, and so I think those types of people if they are able to recognize that and be like, Okay, right, you know, I just have this body and this is it, you know, whatever. Let's bring on you know, more diversity in my feed and let's let's use my platform and my influence for to help people with more marginalized identities and myself that would be that'd be amazing and make me happy.

39:58

Yes, yeah, I totally I understand see that? Yeah, like, you need the gateway. Like you need the gateway. body positivity because you're right. And I'm sure like, I'm trying to think back of my first kind of, you know, entry into that space. Like it probably was like someone like the body image movement woman who I can't remember, I think Terran Terran. rumfitt? Yeah. So, like it probably what because, you know, it was like, okay, like it was like, safe. And then, and then you start to kind of like, hopefully people sort of start to move along the spectrum and start to like, see the, you know, the real, like, social justice piece of it, and start to follow other people who are speaking more to the politic, political side of it. And yeah, how to actually, you know, advocate. Yeah, and make change culture,

40:53

even saying that it's like, but then also, the more fluffy stuff is making a change, because it's kind of slowly moving things along. But then again, exactly what I just said, it's also harming free will, I will? I don't know. It's not

41:09

it's there's not a clean answer. Right. Yeah. Some people will argue that, like, we shouldn't be showing bodies, but it's like, but I think we need that too. Because otherwise, otherwise, like the mainstream media controls the bodies that you see. So you need people who are also showing their body like yeah, it's not. It's nuanced. And I think it's like, it's not, there's no, no one knows of one like, right way to look at things, I think, and I think that people benefit from different things in their own journey. And yeah, find what works for you and hopefully, eventually get to one of us, you know.

41:47

And I really appreciate like the P the dieticians that I work with, or are exclusively thin people. And I appreciate so much when they bring me in as a fat person. It's because because it's kind of like with their body. They're vouching for me, right, because like that audience probably couldn't stomach a fat person, maybe where are their awesome, obviously lots of occurred, but some of them maybe wouldn't navigate or you know, towards me, but they're using their their body almost as a kind of vouching for me. And now I think that's an awesome, cool thing. I really appreciate it. And it's the right thing to do.

42:27

Yeah, yeah. No, there's definitely good, good people out there. So. All right, so, station. Anything else? I feel like we talked about everything we want to talk about.

42:39

No, you know what I really like talking to you. I really like having a little episodes. So where can people find you?

42:47

They can find me at the body image coach calm. And my podcast is called Eat the rolls. And I'm at Summer in an inn on Instagram and Facebook and Twitter. What about

42:59

snoop? Sorry, I don't I'm interrupting you. Like at the end of the sentence. I'm like, have you seen this new but I think you like it. Laziness. It does not exist. The book, Dr. Devin price Yeah,

43:13

I heard I have heard of it. I think Matt McCormick Gauri posted it. Like, go on. I remember bookmarking it. But I haven't read it. No.

43:21

Yeah, I'm reading it right now. And just you know, you know, it's solely to do with rules. And it's totally aligned with diet culture. And Dr. Devin price is fat positive and all that. Yeah. Anyways, it's really good.

43:35

Yeah, I've had a couple people told me that they really enjoyed it too, so I'll have to check it out. Yeah.

43:39

So where to find me is first fatty.com on Instagram first fatty podcast first fatty. Book first fatty? Yeah. So first, fatty. My new name Vinnie Welsby. Yeah, well, thank you for hanging out with us today. Yeah. Chat summer.

44:00

Yeah, let us know what you think. And we'll be back for another episode soon.

44:06

Yeah, and couple of weeks. All right. So Yolanda thanks for listening to the episode and if you feel ready to get serious about this work and want to know when the doors open to fears fattier Academy which is my signature program, where I teach all about how to overcome your fat phobic beliefs and learn to love your fat body, then go to phase fatty.com forward slash waitlist again, that is phase fatty.com. Forward slash waitlist to get your name on the waitlist. For when first party Academy my signature program opens.